Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Rep. Ro Khanna About this episode US Congressman Ro Khanna, who represents California's 17th district, joins Recode's Kara Swisher live onstage at Manny's in San Francisco to talk about the state of tech policy and the next elections.
In this episode:
Khanna's internet bill of rights; will we ever have a national privacy bill?; the problem with "break them up"; the FTC’s Facebook fine; President Trump's racist attacks on the “squad” and Democrats’ reactions; the current mood in Washington; is Silicon Valley "over?”; Trump’s continued popularity; working on the Bernie Sanders campaign; Khanna’s second choice, Elizabeth Warren; Medicare for All; Russian attacks on elections; ensuring the health of tech; the problems with facial recognition; and government regulation of speech online.
Follow us
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), host
Ro Khanna (@RepRoKhanna), guest
Erica Anderson (@EricaAmerica), executive producer
Eric Johnson (@HeyHeyESJ), producer
More to explore
If you haven't already, subscribe to Recode Decode
Subscribe to Recode's other podcasts: Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,358 words · 11 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. AMEX Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex slash AMEX Corporate. Terms apply.
0:24 Speaker 01 I'm Ina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Nathan Lane. We talk about his critically acclaimed run in Death of a Salesman, Taking His Dog to Therapy, and winning an Emmy for Only Murders in the Building. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.
1:00 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Tara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who probably should run against Ro Khanna, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Well, I'm not going to do that, but I actually did a great live interview with Congressman Ro Khanna, who represents California's 17th District, which includes the headquarters of Apple and Google. Congressman Khanna has been on the show before several times, most recently when he unveiled his proposal for an Internet Bill of Rights. We talked a bit about that here, but also about the state of tech regulation generally, the 2020 campaign, and the FTC's recent $5 billion fine on Facebook. This interview was recorded live at Manny's, which is a bar and event space in San Francisco's Mission District. Let's go there now to hear my interview
1:45 Speaker 02 with Congressman Ro Khanna.
1:55 Speaker 02 Yes, it's me again. Oh, woo, yeah. Roe and I know each other very well. We had a delightful lunch in the Senate dining—was that the Senate dining room?
2:04 Speaker 03 It was.
2:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, and we just gossiped about everybody there. Anyway, we know each other very well.
2:08 Speaker 03 Where all these senators started coming up to you. I actually felt important. I thought, maybe these senators are talking to me, and then I said, they just want to get to know Kara Swisher.
2:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was funny, because he was like, no one ever talks to me. It was really good.
2:21 Speaker 03 They don't talk to lonely House members in the Senate.
2:23 Speaker 02 And when we were exiting, the tech council of Nashville lost their minds.
2:28 Speaker 03 I know.
2:28 Speaker 02 Anyway, enough about me. Let's talk about Ro Khanna. So, we have a lot to talk about. I talked to Congresswoman—Congressperson Underwood.
2:36 Speaker 03 By the way, she is fantastic. How many folks saw her?
2:39 Speaker 02 She's amazing.
2:40 Speaker 03 She's one of the— I mean, the freshman class has so many stars. She's really one of them.
2:44 Speaker 02 She is, indeed. And she talked about a lot of things which we're going to get into, but I think it's really important to talk about tech with you. And you and I have talked a number of times. We've done a number of podcasts about things. We talked about the Internet Bill of Rights. Let's start with that, because I wrote a column in The Times about it, and we did a great podcast about it. Where are we on this Internet Bill of Rights? This is—explain what you did for Speaker Pelosi.
3:07 Speaker 03 So, Speaker Pelosi, after the whole Cambridge Analytica scandal, said, "We've got to actually have some principles of regulations, well-crafted regulations, that we can agree on, and that should have some accountability for tech." And so she asked me to work with a lot of the privacy groups, to work with some of the experts. She had in the back of her mind the technology illiteracy of a lot of Congress. I mean, I don't know if how many of you saw the hearing with Sundar Pichai at Google, where some person held up their iPhone and said, "If I move from here to there, will you be able to track me?" And Sundar Pichai said, "Well, Google doesn't make the iPhone, Apple does." At point— And you should watch this clip.
3:52 Speaker 03 At which point, the person starts yelling, saying, "I don't want to be misled. Tell me, can you track me?" And Sundar says, "Well, it depends what apps you're using." You have on your phone and the congressman says, I don't know what apps are. I don't care what apps are. Tell me what whether you can track me.
4:09 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, they can track you.
4:11 Speaker 03 This knowledge gap. And so she said, why don't you actually talk to people who know what they're doing? And see if you can come up with some principles. We came up with some very simple principles, but important principles. You should have the right to know what's happening with your data. You should have the right to consent before your data is collected or transferred. You should have the right to be able to delete your data and a number of other principles. You should have the right to be notified if your data is breached. And so we got fir consensus. It became part of the Democratic agenda. And now, like many things in Congress, it is caught up in the committee. But Jan Schakowsky is doing actually a very good job and she's going to be leading the bill in the Energy and Commerce Committee.
4:55 Speaker 03 So the next step is for some of these principles to come through that.
4:59 Speaker 02 Okay, so there were a lot of them and there were a lot of different laws that could come off all of them. There is not any legislation, though, in this Congress. It's exactly zero.
5:08 Speaker 03 Zero.
5:09 Speaker 02 Zero. Okay, nice work.
5:11 Speaker 03 You could say that, but a lot of furious.
5:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, I get that. But this was something that's been very important because of the issues around just today. I hope none of you have a Capital One card. What's in your wallet? Well, people in Seattle know and have been charging things. There's a huge breach of Capital One credit cards applications, which has pretty much everything. You know, this was followed, the Equifax one, which just paid their fines, the Facebook FTC settlement. What is preventing Congress from taking action? The national privacy bill or even the very low hanging fruit of so many do not track provisions?
5:45 Speaker 03 It's a very good question and it's been way too slow. I mean, in candor, we should have had this in the first six months of taking the majority. There are a lot of interest groups that have a stake, the Internet service providers, the companies themselves. And so it's balancing all of these different interests. But I believe that, well, California has a law, privacy law, that should be the floor. And it doesn't take rocket science to say, at least, let's start with that. But the jurisdiction is with the Energy and Commerce Committee. It's with Jan Schakowsky's committee. And we need to continue to push to get it through there.
6:30 Speaker 02 What are the likelihood of getting a national privacy anytime in this century? Right? No, really. I mean, when do you imagine it?
6:39 Speaker 03 Well, this is, I think, why tech leaders are not as concerned. You know, Tony Blair, actually, I thought, I don't agree with a lot of his things, but he had this really somewhat insightful comment. And he said, "The difference between American populism and British populism is you just have populist rhetoric, whereas we are committing suicide by actually changing our policy with Brexit." And the challenge has been that for all the rhetoric on antitrust and privacy, we haven't really actually advanced legislation. I mean, there's a lot of hearings, there's a lot of calls, but what are we actually doing? I think, you know, my view is we should do it by the next year.
7:23 Speaker 03 But would it surprise me if the entire term goes by and we still don't have something that the Senate would pass and that the president would sign? No, it wouldn't. And this is, I think, factored into a lot of the tech leaders' calculation.
7:38 Speaker 02 That it would be slow-moving. What do you think is necessary to pass right now? What of all the bills? And then I'd like to get to the FTC and other agencies that are supposed to monitor this for everybody.
7:48 Speaker 03 What part of the...
7:51 Speaker 02 What of the bills, if you could pass one, do you think is the most critical?
7:55 Speaker 03 I think having the right to at least know what's happening to your data, because I think that would give a lot of the nonprofit groups the ability to monitor and alert folks when things like Cambridge Analytica happened. I mean, many groups have 3,000, 4,000 people who are on these platforms, and if they could make requests to know what was happening, then they could have anticipated Cambridge Analytica and alerted folks about that. So I think having something as simple as that would go a long way. A right to consent in some form before your data is transferred or collected would go a long way. Having to be more simple about explaining privacy settings.
8:37 Speaker 03 I mean, I was talking to some real folk, someone who was really... Astute about technology and their daughter was on Instagram and was getting messages from a unsolicited messages for from a stranger and he tried to change the privacy settings and he said it literally took him 20 minutes to figure out how on Instagram he would be able to block someone from sending these unsolicited messages and if it's taking someone who is in the tech field 20 minutes imagine what it's taking people who don't have that level of technological proficiency and so just having simpler user friendly privacy settings so you don't have to go search for things but on the homepage they're
9:21 Speaker 03 right right there.
9:23 Speaker 02 So when you you represent Silicon Valley.
9:25 Speaker 03 I do.
9:25 Speaker 02 A stretch of it, not all of it, correct? You split it.
9:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, as I split it with Anna Hsu, I said all the company, a lot of the companies are in my district, all the executives live in hers.
9:35 Speaker 02 Okay. So you don't own them anything. So when you think about covering, do you think this tech clash has been too strong going back? I mean, they're your constituency.
9:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
9:46 Speaker 02 And Lauren Underwood was just talking about serving her constituents.
9:49 Speaker 03 Right.
9:50 Speaker 02 You have been not really a cheerleader and you're also not too much of an attractor. How do you talk about that?
9:56 Speaker 03 Well, look, I still think technology is going to create a positive impact on the nation and the world and I don't think the I think the biggest concern people have is that there are parts of the country where you don't have opportunity to participate in the technology economy and that's what we're not addressing, this gap of economic opportunity with a technology revolution. And so what I've said is, yes, we need to have stronger privacy regulations, but they have to be well crafted. We need stronger antitrust, but it can't just be reflexive, break up the companies and let the Chinese companies be dominant. Talk about what actually is going to prevent companies from privileging
10:37 Speaker 03 their own platform. Talk about having greater scrutiny in mergers, but be thoughtful about it. And what we need far more of is an investment in in in technologies, in artificial intelligence, in quantum computing. In photonics, in the areas that are going to allow America to continue to lead, and we need to disperse those economic opportunities in places around the country.
11:02 Speaker 02 So you brought up antitrust.
11:04 Speaker 03 Yes.
11:04 Speaker 02 I wrote a column today in The Times about this.
11:06 Speaker 03 Okay, I saw your earlier column, but I didn't see today's.
11:09 Speaker 02 This one, it was about antitrust. And one of the premises I was making, two of them, were, one, that Americans, or everybody, is a cheap date to the internet companies.
11:18 Speaker 03 Right.
11:18 Speaker 02 That they give us a free map.
11:20 Speaker 03 Sure.
11:21 Speaker 02 Maybe easy delivery.
11:22 Speaker 03 Yes.
11:22 Speaker 02 And we turn over all our data to them.
11:24 Speaker 03 Right.
11:25 Speaker 02 They get much better out of the trade than we do as a group. And there's all kinds of things. Should you be paid for your time? Should you be paid for your data?
11:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:34 Speaker 02 Should you be aware of it, at the very least? Should you have control of it? All kinds of things. And that, finally, these agencies are starting to investigate these issues, just like you said. Do you, Elizabeth Warren has said they should break them up.
11:47 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:47 Speaker 02 A lot of people have clombed on to that and thought that that was the correct thing. Part of me feels like, a lot of me feels like, that's a great idea, given how dominant. And I started the column by saying, here's a quiz. When was the last time we had a social media site started? 2011. That's a long time. In tech terms, that's an eon.
12:06 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:06 Speaker 02 Last time a social media, I mean, a search engine.
12:09 Speaker 03 Has that been that one?
12:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, Snapchat.
12:10 Speaker 03 Right.
12:11 Speaker 02 A significant one. I'm not talking about Yo or Oi or whatever the last one was.
12:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:15 Speaker 02 Or Peach. They're gone. They were here and gone. That was the Friday, the last whole Friday. The last search service was 2009, DuckDuckGo, and it has 1% of the market.
12:25 Speaker 03 Right.
12:26 Speaker 02 The last big commerce site, not in a long time. Amazon dominates. And it has a very, Wayfair has a very small percent of the market. The last, the biggest amount, the last time there was a online ad service, I can't even remember, a new one, it's Google and Facebook. And then each of these companies, Facebook, Google, and Amazon especially, dominate all these. What's the argument against breaking parts of them off?
12:53 Speaker 03 Well, the argument is, first of all, that there has to be a process, that the law
12:58 Speaker 02 Of course.
12:59 Speaker 03 in America is consumer welfare not protecting against competition. So you have to actually show harm to consumers.
13:07 Speaker 02 Unless you change that or show it, but go ahead.
13:10 Speaker 03 Sure, I mean, you could change it in Congress, but if Congress can't pass, like, we should have
13:14 Speaker 02 Right.
13:15 Speaker 03 know your data law.
13:16 Speaker 02 Right.
13:17 Speaker 03 The idea that they're going to overturn antitrust law is highly unlikely. They could, they could say, I don't think they should adopt, by the way, the European standard. I mean, Europe has had two tech companies in the last 30 years. They're almost irrelevant when it comes to technology. They've had SAP and Spotify. And so, I mean, China is far more relevant, but I would not listen to anyone about, in Europe, about anything about tech. I mean, that's a declining innovation culture. And so, I do think that there are thoughtful ways we should regulate. My view is Microsoft's case was a very good, well-decided case. You had the Justice Department come in, they said Microsoft shouldn't be allowed to tie
14:01 Speaker 03 Internet Explorer with Windows. Had they been able to do that, we may all be using Bing Search. You may not have had Netscape, you may not have had Google. The case went to the D.C. Circuit. The D.C. Circuit said you didn't need to break up Microsoft. I don't think there are many people today, maybe there are some, who say, we should have broken up Microsoft, but we should have regulated it to make sure they couldn't privilege their own platform.
14:24 Speaker 02 You could also look at AT&T. The reason you're holding your cellphone is because of that.
14:28 Speaker 03 Right.
14:29 Speaker 02 And there's networks, there's everything came out of that breakup. So, for the most part, breakups actually are beneficial for, for a lot of industries, if there's especially dominant industries. So, how do you assess how the FTC is doing the agreement they, that they agreed to with Facebook, the $5 billion parking ticket?
14:47 Speaker 03 I think it could have been more. I mean, I, I don't think, I think Facebook looks at it as a cost of doing business, and I don't think it really hurts their bottom line in a significant way. And I think that the, that there has to be, you know, I didn't, I wasn't involved in the enforcement, but it seems to me a slap on the wrist. I mean, I don't think it's going to lead to significant change in understanding the magnitude of, of the, of the problem.
15:16 Speaker 02 So, which had happened at the FTC? Because that's the agency. That has a lot of things to do, and that's one of them. We talked about a separate Internet agency.
15:24 Speaker 03 Right.
15:24 Speaker 02 A digital agency. Wall Street has the SEC.
15:27 Speaker 03 Right.
15:28 Speaker 02 Everybody has their agency. Why should there not be an agency?
15:32 Speaker 03 There should. I mean, I support that. Michael Doyle, who's on the Energy and Commerce Committee, has a bill actually saying we need to increase the FTC jurisdiction. We need to give them the ability to really enforce technology privacy issues. And I do think they have an enforcement challenge. I mean, they don't have enough people or enough expertise in technology. So I would support a stronger view on FTC enforcement.
16:00 Speaker 02 There's also a partisan situation, so it ping-pongs back and forth.
16:03 Speaker 03 Yes.
16:04 Speaker 02 The commissioners. But should there be a separate agency, the Internet Agency, or whatever you want to call it?
16:10 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, I'm open to that, but you could also create that within the FTC. So you're not creating a whole new bureaucracy. I mean, the FTC has been fairly effective in certain areas, and I think if you gave them the staff and if you gave them the jurisdiction over the Internet, you could have a strong sense of enforcement.
16:30 Speaker 02 So I want to finish up this part. So what would you want to see happen in that area?
16:37 Speaker 03 In FTC?
16:39 Speaker 02 In the FTC, in the enforcement. Is it the SEC? Is it the Justice Department? The Justice Department is now investigating these companies for antitrust.
16:46 Speaker 03 Right.
16:47 Speaker 02 Where is the appropriate place, from your point of view?
16:50 Speaker 03 I mean, I think that, I think both. I mean, I think you can have a robust antitrust division in the Justice Department that should look at misconduct in antitrust. And I think they've done well in cases like Microsoft. And then I think with the FTC, you can have a lot of the privacy issues, and they're, you know, right now, they basically split up based on companies. That seems a bit arbitrary to me. But, you know, I think you can have a strong, I guess you can have two strong regulatory enforcement agencies. Right now, the enforcement agencies aren't strong enough.
17:23 Speaker 02 Right. So let's talk about Congress right now. We just had Congresswoman Underwood here. She's in a swing district.
17:29 Speaker 03 Right.
17:29 Speaker 02 You are not in a swing district.
17:31 Speaker 03 Right.
17:31 Speaker 02 Right. So talk about what What it's like to be now, right now, in Congress? What's the mood? Besides, I want to hear about the fight, how you feel about the fighting within the caucus, if it's a real thing or just manufactured? Or, and how do you overcome that? Because it's certainly become a story and it's something that the Republicans and Donald Trump are using as a wedge.
17:52 Speaker 03 Well, I think Trump unified the caucus when he started to attack people in the caucus. There are genuine differences of opinion in the caucus. I mean, I would be lying if I said that everyone is on the same page on every issue. I mean, there are differences of opinion on boycotts and divestments. There's a difference of opinion on issues about the role of homeland security. There's a difference of opinion on the border bill, the border supplemental. There was a difference of opinion on how aggressively and how fast to go after Donald Trump. I mean, there, but when you have a diverse caucus from 235 districts and you don't believe in group think, that difference of opinion is healthy.
18:37 Speaker 03 The question then is, how do you disagree in a way that doesn't play into Donald Trump's hands? And I think when we ended this session before recess, we were probably more unified than ever before. I mean, you had the speaker meet with some of the four members of Congress, who, the freshmen, who I, you know, where I think that they had constructive meetings. And you had the caucus fairly unified in terms of the outrageousness of the president's attacks on other members of Congress. And so I think we are in a place, coming back, that we're going to be unified in the bigger
19:20 Speaker 03 vision of making sure that we win in 2020 and that we call out this president. But there are going to be disagreements within the caucus.
19:27 Speaker 02 So how do you, when you have that, how do you fight the use of the wedge issue? Because it seems very effective, doing these racist tweets, attacking this group of women, all of whom are women of color.
19:41 Speaker 03 Right.
19:42 Speaker 02 How do you stop that? Because it seems effective in some way, or maybe I'm misjudging it.
19:46 Speaker 03 Well, I'm not sure it's effective. I think the president has overplayed his hand. I mean, I think he's turning off a lot of people in suburban counties and places across this money country because it's un-American. I mean, I think it's just, it goes so much against the spirit of this country. Now, I think he thinks, or Steve Bannon thinks, that every time you're talking about race and immigration, the president's winning. That's their theory. That's how he won. But I think he has way overplayed his hand in trying to do that. Obviously, Democrats are going to speak out when the president does that. I mean, the idea that you can, some people say, "Well, why are you ignoring, why
20:29 Speaker 03 don't just ignore him and get your agenda done?" But we can't ignore it if their president's out there tweeting that some member of Congress should go back to a country which, you know, they weren't even born in. I mean, obviously, we have to speak out against that. And so the question is, how do we speak out? How do we speak out forcefully, call it for what it is, and then also be able to have a positive agenda?
20:51 Speaker 02 How do you assess the reaction that Speaker Pelosi has had to it? I mean, it seems like this is a constant thing, is he says something incredibly racist, says another things, and it ratchets up and then adds another one, and then the narrative continues. If you'd watched the show, this is how they did it on the show for years. I did watch the show for many years.
21:12 Speaker 03 On a premise?
21:13 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. I watched every episode. I totally understand this man. He's got all these moves. But this is what they did. They would ratchet, ratchet, ratchet. You know what I mean? Which was, it works. It works really well. To react and say, "This is awful", seems exhausting as a congressperson, because you don't get anything done. You don't do anything but react to someone saying a terrible thing to you.
21:37 Speaker 03 Well, I think that that's partly what you're reacting to. But you still have an agenda on how do we expand rural broadband? How do we get people a $15 minimum wage? How do we have infrastructure in this country? How do we lower the cost of prescription drugs? Notice the exchange with Congressman Cummings. The President attacked him very personally and attacked his district and his leadership. And Chairman Cummings didn't respond in kind. He didn't throw, he didn't even criticize the President. He said, "Mr. President, I'm disappointed. I met with you about prescription drugs and I'm ready to work with you anytime you want to work on prescription drugs." And he took the high road.
22:18 Speaker 03 And so the Congress, our focus is going to be on what we can get done. But you can't say that we just stay quiet in the face of the President's attacks, especially when they're attacks on the very fabric of what this country stands for.
22:36 Speaker 02 We're going to take a quick break now, but we'll be back after this in my live interview with Congressman Ro Khanna.
22:45 Speaker 04 What if we told you there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter? Interested?
22:51 Speaker 05 And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable?
22:59 Speaker 04 No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber, the least sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all.
23:05 Speaker 05 But what is fiber? How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is a powder you stir into some water going to do it for you?
23:13 Speaker 04 All that, plus the strange tale of the gorilla poop-obsessed father of cornflakes in the latest episode of Gastropod. Find Gastropod and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
23:26 Speaker 02 What does that feel like to be there now in Washington? What is the mood between Republicans and Democrats?
23:34 Speaker 03 It feels that we are letting the country down in that you look at what China is doing. And I disagree, obviously, with their worldview, but they are building all these new colleges. They are building, they have a rural broadband program that in the next three years they're going to spend 98% of China is going to be connected to the Internet. They are investing in winning the green energy race. They are investing $150 billion in artificial intelligence. They are creating exploitive relationships throughout Africa. And then the question is, and what is our Congress doing? We're tweeting back and forth with people?
24:18 Speaker 03 I mean, what are we doing to help this country win the 21st century? What are we doing to help create jobs and opportunities for so many people who have been left out? It seems a unserious time.
24:29 Speaker 02 Well, I'm very serious at the same time. It does help when you have an authoritarian regime of a homogeneous country that spies on its citizens almost constantly. You can get a lot done in that regard.
24:40 Speaker 03 Well, but some of it, look, obviously, I'm not defending in any way what China's political model is, and Hong Kong is a example of the revolt against authoritarian leadership. And Xi Jinping has been terrible in many ways. I mean, the way they've treated the Uighurs, the way they are dealing with dissent, the use of technology to perfect control over individuals, which is why I don't think we should allow Alibaba, Tencent, and Baidu to be the dominant tech companies, which would happen if we really went, had no regard for American tech companies.
25:22 Speaker 03 But I don't think that we can just excuse our inaction and inability to do things to saying, oh, we have a messy democracy. We have been capable of doing things in the past. We won the space race because America mobilized and had 3% of our GDP into massive investments after the Soviets. Launched the satellite and we wanted to really invest in those things and we have been capable in the past of transitioning to and thinking about how we're going to create economic opportunity in places left behind.
25:56 Speaker 02 So, talk a little bit about that economic opportunity, something you've worked on a lot. This is the 50th anniversary of NASA, the landing on the moon. What do you think is critical to be investing in? You've traveled, you did something in the Midwest, you did some rural areas and things like that. What do you think is the critical things that we need to invest in then?
26:16 Speaker 03 If you talk to people in these rural districts, they will tell you the first thing is rural broadband, that people want high-speed internet access in every community. I'll tell you, one of the ways I know that that's probably right is that Sprint and T-Mobile had this disingenuous ad in every church newspaper in Iowa saying, "Support the T-Mobile-Sprint merger. Extend the digital revolution to Iowa." And the reality is, a lot of these communities, they want to have access to high-speed internet and they want to make sure that they have some ability to get credentialing in something that's going to lead to a job
26:58 Speaker 03 in technology, or at least have that sense of possibility in their communities. It could be in ag tech, it could be in robotics process automation, it could be in any field, but they want to have some, at least, opportunity for those jobs. And so to have private industry working with community colleges, working with federal government and creating that opportunity. And then I would invest in programs and incentives to get people hired in these communities. I mean, Quebec has a program of tax incentives to be for people who are hired in technology in that area that led to a lot of tech companies and innovation coming there.
27:36 Speaker 02 You did visit, I think it was Silicon Hollow. They call everything Silicon something, like wherever they go, but this was Hollow, I guess it was.
27:43 Speaker 03 Hal Rogers' district, Paintsville, Kentucky.
27:46 Speaker 02 Right. Is this something that's doable, or are we creating this sort of elite at the coasts with... The center without these jobs. I mean, I've talked about this with Steve Case and Mark Cuban.
27:57 Speaker 03 Right.
27:57 Speaker 02 They were making a case, particularly Mark, saying Silicon Valley is over. Silicon Valley is finished. Well, I know. He was just saying it to be obnoxious.
28:05 Speaker 03 I mean, you can say stuff like that on Shark Tank, but I mean that's...
28:08 Speaker 02 Well, it wasn't Shark Tank. It was actually oddly enough, an Anthony Scaramucci event, which was... The whole thing was strange. I won't go into it.
28:15 Speaker 03 I mean, Apple and Google are at a trillion-dollar market caps. I mean, it's a little bit...
28:19 Speaker 02 I know. I got that.
28:20 Speaker 03 You can't both say that we ought to break them up. They're too powerful and they're over. I mean, it's gotta be one or the other.
28:26 Speaker 02 From an imagination, innovation point of view. But how do you get that to the... And they're trying to do things, Rise of the Rest, or even Shark Tank.
28:34 Speaker 03 Very supportive of that.
28:35 Speaker 02 So how do you get that to happen? Because it doesn't seem to happen. There's a lot of visits. There's a lot of, you know... At one point, everyone in Silicon Valley was going to these places, which seemed like a safari tour at some point. It got a little ridiculous. How do you get that to happen?
28:52 Speaker 03 Well, first, I think it requires local leadership. I don't think Silicon Valley or someone can plop into a place and say, "Okay, we're going to create a technology opportunity." You need the local school district, the local community college, local industry, local leadership to buy in. So Jefferson, Iowa, where it's been a success. You had Accenture, which acquired Pillar Technology, which was an Iowa company, say, "We're going to partner with Des Moines Community College and Central Iowa Community College. We're going to have Jefferson School District be completely remodeled into having a tech center, and we're going to have a 12th grade class for kids to get basic tech training, and then they're going to get a two-year program in combination with Des Moines and Accenture.
29:35 Speaker 03 And at the end of that, Accenture is going to agree to hire them at $65,000." Now, then they said, "Okay, let's partner with Silicon Valley." And we had the tech go out and do a training with a lot of the teachers on what a Silicon Valley curriculum would look like, Microsoft CTO, and others. Started funding scholarships. Ripple became interested in providing technology, but they were as partners to an effort...
30:03 Speaker 03 That was organic to a community. So I think a lot of it first requires significant local buy-in, and then we need the federal government that can fund and help scale some of the expansion.
30:16 Speaker 02 The numbers have declined really precipitously, investments like this, for the government at this point.
30:21 Speaker 03 Yes, I mean, the federal government can scale successful models to create these kind of hubs across the country. But I think what's important for technology, where tech can be successful is, and where I admire what Steve Case and to the extent Mark Cuban is doing that, is technology is still deeply fascinating to people. And most people, when you go, in my opinion, to Pennsylvania or Ohio, they don't talk to you about privacy, and they don't talk to you about antitrust. What was Trump's message? Trump's message was, "You built America. Your grandparents, your great-grandparents fought for this country, fought for this freedom. And now, all these people on the coasts are doing really well, and what happened to you? I'm going to bring back your pride. I'm going to bring back your
31:06 Speaker 03 sense of possibility." And I think when tech leaders go into these communities and say, "We believe in you. We believe your kids, your communities can be part of the technology future, and we're going to bring more jobs, more opportunity, more possibility," that's getting them to buy into the future. Trump doesn't sit there asking economists to go study whether we're actually going to get coal jobs back or manufacturing jobs back. He goes and he sells his vision. And, you know, when people often ask me, "Why is it that more people don't care about Trump's obstruction of justice and Trump's violating all these norms?" And I say, "Because he's fighting for their way of life. He's fighting
31:47 Speaker 03 for their dignity as they see it." And we have to speak not on a policy basis. We have to speak not with Rod Schetty's studies, who is a brilliant economist of moving places. We have to say, "We believe your community is going to have more choice, more possibility, more opportunity in the future, and we believe in your kids," and sell that.
32:08 Speaker 02 So, speaking of selling that, you work with Bernie Sanders, correct? What is your job? What is your... You have backed him, or what? I don't understand these political things that you all do.
32:18 Speaker 03 Well, I'm one of his co-chairs.
32:19 Speaker 02 That's right.
32:20 Speaker 03 I mean, my job is still to represent the district.
32:22 Speaker 02 Yes, I got that.
32:23 Speaker 03 But it's volunteer.
32:23 Speaker 02 Yeah. So what is that? Why did you pick Bernie Sanders?
32:26 Speaker 03 We worked on Yemen together. My passion on foreign policy comes from my grandfather. He had spent four years in jail with Gandhi in the 1940s in human rights. When I got to Congress, the Yemeni community came to me and talked about some of the famine that was one of the largest famine in the world. 14 million people may face that famine. The United States government was funding refueling Saudi planes bombing. And we passed together after two years of effort, the first War Powers Resolution to stop any refueling of Saudi planes. The president vetoed it, but the administration voluntarily suspended the refueling.
33:08 Speaker 03 And when I went to see which senator would introduce a War Powers Resolution, he was the only one who was willing to do so. So I would have supported him for whatever he wanted to do after that.
33:20 Speaker 02 All right. So how do you feel about the campaign? What is? How do you look at it as a Democrat right now? There's, what, 20 people left? 20. 20? No, there's 20.
33:28 Speaker 03 Is it?
33:29 Speaker 02 Tomorrow night and the next? How many? 24?
33:32 Speaker 03 24.
33:33 Speaker 02 Yeah. Something like that.
33:34 Speaker 03 Right.
33:35 Speaker 02 It's a lot.
33:35 Speaker 03 Yes.
33:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
33:36 Speaker 03 I mean, I think it's going to whittle down by the fall to six, seven serious candidates. But I think the fact that we have all of these candidates running now is a good thing. I mean, they're all getting their message out. They're all exciting different parts of the coalition. We've had, you know, when Jimmy Carter ran in 1976, I think there were 18 to 20 candidates. So just because you have a lot of candidates doesn't mean that the party won't be unified afterwards. I told Senator Sanders when I accepted the offer that I wouldn't criticize any of his opponents. I would make the case for him. And I think if we keep it largely positive, I mean, make the differences on issues. Obviously, if Senator Sanders wants to, or Vice President Biden wants to make a distinction
34:21 Speaker 03 about their healthcare or Medicare plans, they should feel free to criticize the plans. But as long as the conversation is about the issues and doesn't get personal and that we unify afterwards, I think it can be a strength.
34:34 Speaker 02 So of this field, if you had to not to pick a second person, who do you like?
34:39 Speaker 03 I like Elizabeth Warren. I mean, I'm a progressive Democrat. I think she's running an extraordinary campaign. And I say that having, you know, we don't agree 100% on tech. I mean, I think we need stronger antitrust enforcement, but I don't agree with her on everything, as I don't agree with Bernie Sanders on everything. But I think she has run a very, very detailed campaign. She has a clear vision of what she wants to do. I think she's doing an incredible job of telling her story in a way that connects with people across the country.
35:08 Speaker 02 In that, in connecting with people to get to the Trump base or people that he won over that had voted for Obama, obviously. What do you think the key elements are? Because some people are worried about her appeal to those people. Some people are worried about a lot of the Democrats' appeal.
35:24 Speaker 03 Well, first of all, and I say this as someone who, you know, backed Senator Sanders even the first time, I think Hillary Clinton was a better candidate than people give her credit for. And I think just piling on on candidates who lose is not the right thing. It's very, very hard to hold a presidency after eight years. Usually, the other party wins. And so a lot of, I think, what was going on was people were upset that wages had continued to be stagnant, that the technology revolution and globalization had left communities
36:05 Speaker 03 out, and they wanted to vote against the status quo. And now they've seen what Trump has done. They've seen that he really hasn't focused on forgotten Americans. He has focused on a large tax break to very wealthy individuals. These communities still don't see much progress on what he promised. And so I think that the argument that the Democrats have to now is easier, because we've seen Trump's true colors. And I personally think any of the top candidates will have a very, very good chance against him.
36:43 Speaker 02 And the key messages being what? Because it can't be running against him. It's got to be about running for something.
36:50 Speaker 03 I think the key message is there have been communities that have been left out of the economic prosperity of this country. And there have been people who have been left out about the economic prosperity of this country. And that we are going to actually empower them with more pay, better economic opportunity, revitalize these communities that have been left out, and that the president promised to fix and hasn't.
37:13 Speaker 02 And of the many areas, we just talked previously about healthcare. You are a Medicare for All person?
37:21 Speaker 03 I am.
37:22 Speaker 02 And what does that mean to you? Because it means something different to a lot of different people. What's your Medicare for All?
37:28 Speaker 03 Medicare for All means that every person gets Medicare. And Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan had 24 hearings on the Clinton plan in 1994. And at the end of it, he turned to Senate Staff Finance Director and he said, you know, I guess the only real thing that can work is just extending Medicare. I mean, I think that that is the simplest way of the solution. And that doesn't mean you can't have supplemental private insurance. Even Bernie Sanders' bill allows that. I mean, the current Medicare law is that if you are on Medicare, you can have private insurance that is duplicative of what Medicare provides.
38:12 Speaker 03 And so if you extend Medicare for everyone, obviously, you have to extend that law. And you can't have private insurance that would be duplicative of Medicare. But that doesn't, if you want to go after we provide you with Medicare, if you really want to have more, you can. And in Britain, for example, 4% of the population has private and supplemental insurance post having national healthcare. So I, I mean, that is the Bernie Sanders bill. I think it would lower the cost for many startups. It would make us more competitive, and it would make sure that people had healthcare from the day they were born.
38:47 Speaker 02 Right. Lastly, last week, in the hearings, one of the things that came out was Russian interference continues to be an issue.
38:55 Speaker 03 Yes.
38:56 Speaker 02 Or will continue to be an issue. The bills to fix this, of course, are mucked up into the Senate.
39:02 Speaker 03 Right.
39:03 Speaker 02 McConnell, I think his name is Moscow Mitch now.
39:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:06 Speaker 02 I'm sorry, I don't like those nicknames. That's a good one.
39:10 Speaker 02 How do you get that through? Because it's critically important in each of these states. It seems to, you know, I was just up at Microsoft looking at some of their new software, which is an encrypted vote along with a paper ballot, which gives you backup.
39:22 Speaker 03 Right.
39:23 Speaker 02 There's all kinds of ideas, innovations in this area that could be great. How worried are you?
39:28 Speaker 03 I'm concerned. I mean, I, you know, the bills that Mitch McConnell are holding up says, if you are a campaign and you are contacted by foreign agents, you should notify law enforcement. I mean, how controversial is this? And he doesn't want to move that because they view that any effort at talking about foreign interference is undermining Trump's reelection. What they haven't figured out is there could be Norwegian interference on behalf of Bernie Sanders. And they just are not anticipating the possibility of Norwegian interference. But I, I mean, you would think that...
40:09 Speaker 02 Now you've shown your hand.
40:10 Speaker 03 You know, you would think that you could have consensus that we shouldn't have foreign interference in elections. But we don't, and that's why this is going to be one of the ugliest campaigns in American history. And we should anticipate that this president will do any and everything possible to win. I mean, that should just, we should not go into it with any degree of complacency. And what it will take, as Speaker Pelosi, you know, she was quoted as saying, well, I don't think he will leave unless we win by a large margin. But I think what she really meant is, we're going to have to mobilize and win by 5%, 6%
40:55 Speaker 03 to account for all of the obstacles that are going to be thrown our way, which is the voter ID laws, voter suppression, the possible interference, the shenanigans on social media sites. And so... We have to mobilize and unify in a way that is unprecedented. And I think anyone who underestimates the president's chances would be making a mistake. We have to run like we're down. It's the only way to run a campaign.
41:33 Speaker 02 We're going to take another break now. We'll be back after this with Ro Khanna, who represents California's 17th district in the U.S. House of Representatives, where Apple and Google happen to be also.
41:44 Speaker 06 Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it all starts with a great deal from your local Toyota dealer. Make a smart buy on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or get a Corolla sedan, packed with the latest features, advanced tech, and head-turning style. Or take a test drive in two of Toyota's most popular SUVs, the spacious, family-friendly Grand Highlander and adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid and plug-in hybrid models available across the lineup, plus efficient all-electrics like the BZ, BZ Woodland, and all-wheel-drive CHR, you can drive your way and skip the pump. And long after you leave the lot, your Toyota keeps delivering. With legendary resale value, built on a reputation for quality and reliability, so when it's
42:29 Speaker 06 time for your next Toyota, you could trade in for more. From a great deal today to a great value tomorrow, a Toyota is right for you. Shop toyota.com for deals and details, or stop by your local Toyota dealer today. Toyota, let's go places.
42:45 Speaker 02 All right. Questions from the audience?
42:48 Speaker 07 Hi, Representative Khanna.
42:49 Speaker 03 Hi, how are you?
42:49 Speaker 07 I'm good. How are you? I'm working for a candidate in California's 14th district, a guy named Sean Frame. And it's one of the places where there hasn't been a ton of Democratic investment over the years. And I was just wondering if you could speak to spreading the Democratic brand, particularly to, you know, deeper-red districts like that, where we can, you know, still get more votes, pass more propositions, maybe flip a seat, that kind of thing.
43:11 Speaker 02 There was also a big shakeup today at the DCCC.
43:14 Speaker 03 Right.
43:14 Speaker 02 That looked crazy. I don't care.
43:17 Speaker 03 Right.
43:18 Speaker 02 It seemed crazy.
43:20 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, they wanted to make sure that the
43:23 Speaker 02 Yes.
43:23 Speaker 03 person there was responsive to all parts of the
43:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
43:27 Speaker 03 constituency.
43:27 Speaker 02 Which is everybody quit, but okay, go ahead.
43:29 Speaker 03 Right. But I don't think those things, that's inside baseball.
43:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
43:33 Speaker 03 And I don't think ultimately is going to matter for one seat. I mean, the Democrats are doing well in terms of the funding and recruiting candidates and the front line, so I think we'll be fine. But I do agree with you that we need to have a strategy that supports candidates in every district in this country. And I appreciate very much your getting involved in a campaign where the district is more red. But there were a lot of districts last time we won where people thought, oh, that's too red, we're not going to win. I mean, no one thought TJ Cox was going to win. No one thought that Harley Ruda necessarily in the beginning was going to win. So, you know, we should approach every district as one which is winnable. Now, at the end, if you're the DTC or the Speaker, you
44:17 Speaker 03 have to make certain choices and support places which are most likely to win. But I think there has to be a baseline investment in every district to fight for progressive values. And I appreciate what you're doing.
44:34 Speaker 02 Cool. Another question, right here.
44:37 Speaker 08 How do you balance the belief that Trump has sort of overplayed his hand in sort of the anti-diversity rhetoric with a need for us as progressives to reach into those communities and kind of share a different narrative for the direction the country should be heading?
44:53 Speaker 03 Into which communities?
44:54 Speaker 08 Communities that resonate with that story of kind of a narrower definition of what it means to be American and a rejection of the diversity that I think lots of us agree with as a strength.
45:06 Speaker 02 The ones that don't like the Squad.
45:07 Speaker 03 So I think we have to speak more aspirationally. Every person that the President's
45:17 Speaker 03 Tweet happened about send them back. We got like 15 media requests saying can Ro Khanna come on television and tell us a time where he was told that to go back to India. And so I went on, I said, okay, I'll accept one of these. And I said, you know, I grew up in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. I'm 42 years old. And yes, there are one or two times that I've been told that. But, you know, I grew up at a time where it was a 99% white community. And I had teachers who believed in me and Little League coaches who believed in me and neighbors who believed in me. And now I represent arguably the most economically
46:01 Speaker 03 powerful district in the nation or the world. And I choose to believe that that's much more the story of America than the story that Donald Trump is telling. I believe the way you win people is by inspiring them to have a sense of what America is. This is not a new question. Abraham Lincoln wrote about this and spoke about this in on July 10th in 1858. It was his July 4 speech. And the challenge back then was that the Germans and the French didn't feel that they were American because the test of what it meant to be an American is you had to be able to trace your ancestors back to the revolution. That if you couldn't trace your ancestors back to the revolution, how could you be
46:46 Speaker 03 American? And Lincoln in two pages that are more articulate than anything anyone has tweeted in the last year, basically tries to answer-
46:54 Speaker 02 He'd be a good tweeter.
46:55 Speaker 03 Huh?
46:55 Speaker 02 He'd be a good tweeter.
46:56 Speaker 03 He'd be a great tweeter. I mean, tweets would be insulting to Abraham Lincoln. I mean, but he would be probably good at it. But, but he, so he says that, he says, well-
47:09 Speaker 03 I believe that German Americans and French Americans are flesh of the flesh and blood of the blood of the founders if they believe in the principles of the Declaration of Independence because there's an electric cord that links all Americans to our founding if they believe in the fundamental principles of liberty and equality. That's Lincoln in 1858 having a more profound understanding of a multi-ethnic America than we do today. So my view is, don't let Donald Trump define patriotism. Don't let him define American history. Don't make arguments for diversity in the sense that it's something new.
47:53 Speaker 03 Great leaders, in my view, or thoughtful leaders, actually ground values in the context of the culture and history of the nation. I mean, certainly Dr. King did, Lincoln did, and I think what we do is we out-history, whatever that means, if the verb is wrong, Donald Trump, where that we show that we have an understanding of the true American historical context and that we ground our views in that and that we let people believe in the aspirational vision of America.
48:25 Speaker 02 Yep. Right there. I'm sorry, I know my glasses on, right there. And then we'll go over here.
48:31 Speaker 09 Hi. I just wanted to know your reasoning, why you voted in favor of the recent censure of the BDS movement. Yeah, and I won't color the question any further.
48:44 Speaker 03 I appreciate that. I was waiting for that question to come up. So, my view on the US-Israel relationship is one of a, that Israel is an ally, but we ought to be grounding it on a progressive values. And so, I have opposed any... Bill to criminalize or penalize any boycott. But I and I believe that the principles of the relationship with Israel should be no new settlements, a halt to demolitions, a lifting to the extent possible of the blockade
49:24 Speaker 03 on Gaza without compromising certain security provisions, which is a very progressive vision. I do not think that boycott and divestment of the entire country of Israel is justified or one that is going to get the parties to the peace table. And that's why I voted for the Schneider bill saying that, which boycott and global boycott and divestment, by the way, is not just talking about divestment in the settlements. It's talking about divestment against the whole country. And I just, I don't agree with that.
49:54 Speaker 02 Okay. Let's do one over here and then we'll do this one. And then I have one more question. I forgot.
50:02 Speaker 10 I was wondering if you could tell us a little bit about the two, you know, I don't think we've talked a lot about the future of tech. What are the two most pressing challenges that you see moving forward? And what are you doing tangibly right now to make sure that tech is healthy for all of us in the future and especially for those who are in your district?
50:23 Speaker 03 Well, let me talk about the challenges of tech in my district and then maybe the challenges of tech nationally. In my district, I think the biggest challenge is affordability of housing, of people being able to live there and and issues of being able to afford to live in the community without, if they don't work in one of these extraordinarily high-paying jobs. And so we need to do a lot more in terms of building affordable housing, in terms of building housing for teachers, in terms of building public transportation so people can get around the district. And the two biggest issues that come up time and again in where I live is affordable housing
51:06 Speaker 03 and and public transportation and and traffic. For the country, I think that the big challenge is what I have alluded to earlier is Access to the opportunity to be involved in the technology, in the new economy, in the technology economy. Every American has become a consumer of technology in some sense. I mean, every American is on Google or on Facebook at some point, or Twitter, or orders something on Amazon. But not every American has the opportunity to participate in the technology economy. So democratizing access to the technology economy, spreading the technology revolution to communities left behind, whether those are communities of color, or whether those
51:50 Speaker 03 are communities in rural America, to me seems to be the biggest challenge facing our country. I think the Clinton-Blair bet was that we were going to invest in innovation, that that was going to lead to a more liberal world, and that it was going to lead to a more powerful, innovative United States. And to some extent, you know, the fact that millions of people in China and India have been lifted out of poverty is a good thing. But what I think they totally missed was that there would be geographic concentration of economic opportunity, and that there would be whole communities that were left out. And I think we have to now address that.
52:25 Speaker 02 And also addiction, hate speech, disinformation. There's all kinds of stuff. What's a positive thing for tech, do you think? What's something cool?
52:34 Speaker 03 There are a lot of positive things. I was at a company this morning, that White Rabbit, that uses artificial intelligence to be able to monitor and assess breast cancer radiology. And so it turns out, as I didn't know before this meeting, that when you have one radiologist looking at a scan, you have about a 50% chance of an accurate diagnosis. If you have two people looking at it, it goes up to 75%. But a lot of times, we can't afford two people. So what this company does is, they say, "Look, we're still going to have a doctor, but we can have artificial intelligence conduct one part of the scan."
53:19 Speaker 03 So you're literally increasing the odds from 50% to 75% of an accurate diagnosis. The second thing they do is, which again, I didn't know before this meeting, is that apparently 10% of people who get a mammogram have a false positive. And of that, it's a very small percentage of the 10% who actually have breast cancer. But people have to wait almost a month or two months before they find out if they're in the 10%, whether they have cancer or not. Well, under this company that they have, because they use artificial intelligence, they can help someone get that diagnosis in 15 minutes. So that's an example of a technology that I think-
53:57 Speaker 02 The ladies know about the first part, you know.
53:59 Speaker 03 Yes, well, I'm sure they do.
54:00 Speaker 02 It's amazing how bad the diagnostics can be, especially around radiology. It's a really, it's an area that probably will not have doctors, it'll probably be AI that does a lot of those diagnostics. A lot of diagnosis in general going forward will be done by AI.
54:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, so that's, I think, one-
54:16 Speaker 02 Are you nervous about that at all, or facial recognition with all these things making determinations?
54:21 Speaker 03 I am, I am. And I do think we ought to have a moratorium, or strongly consider a moratorium on facial recognition, until that they can get away from the biases of race and profiling. I mean, when you have John Lewis showing up in artificial intelligence and facial recognition and being confused for someone who had a criminal background, you know that that technology can only-
54:45 Speaker 02 Did you get caught into that? Did they use your face? The ACLU did the test of Amazon's recognition-
54:51 Speaker 03 I don't think they did. I mean, but I think John Lewis speaks it. They don't mean me.
54:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
54:56 Speaker 03 They made their point with Lewis.
54:57 Speaker 02 There were a lot of members of Congress that didn't-
54:58 Speaker 03 But, but, you know, I think that they-
54:59 Speaker 02 For those who don't know, the ACLU did a test of Amazon's recognition, and many, many members of Congress were confused with convicted felons.
55:07 Speaker 03 Yes, and so, you know, we don't want technology exacerbating our worst instincts and biases. But I remain a technology optimist. I mean, I think that technology can create more economic opportunity and more possibility. The question is, it has to be guided by humanistic values.
55:26 Speaker 02 One question, one of the things that people think about of protecting Americans from tech companies is Section 230 of the Communications- What is your take on that? We just, you and I have discussed this at various times and Speaker Pelosi called it a gift to technology and maybe it was one that should be taken away. There's all kinds of people talking about that. I think tech is terrified that something like that's, you have Josh Hawley.
55:50 Speaker 03 Right.
55:51 Speaker 02 When he's not doing his crazy conspiracy stuff, a very serious bill about this. A lot of people are on both sides, Republicans, Democrats are talking about this.
56:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I haven't seen a proposal.
56:03 Speaker 02 This is, for those who don't know, it's a very, it's a very short thing. It's, it grants these platforms some form of immunity. It's not quite that.
56:11 Speaker 03 Right, I mean, it says that if you post something to Google or Facebook, that Google or Facebook won't be liable for the post of the people who are using their platforms. And, well, the one place where they didn't quite erode Section 230, but were getting close, was a bill that I did not support, which was FOSTA and SESTA, where what the law did was criminalize basic sex work. And if you talk to people in the sex work industry, they now fear exchanging information about safety online. It's forced that work back into the streets. I think it's had a terrible effect.
56:52 Speaker 03 I think a lot of those prosecutions of terrible sites could have been done under the existing law and you didn't need to criminalize it. So, my fear in removing Section 230 is that you would have greater government criminalization and interference of the Internet. And I tend to believe that while there needs to be more responsibility, ultimately, the Internet should be a site of largely free speech.
57:16 Speaker 02 Do you think your companies in your district have the ability to do that?
57:21 Speaker 03 To have more responsibility on?
57:23 Speaker 02 Do you think they have the ability and the will to do it? They haven't had the best record.
57:28 Speaker 03 Not, not yet. I mean, I think they need help. But I, but I will say this, and I, do I, well, I've criticized these tech companies for numbers of things, so I'm not an apologist. I mean, I've criticized the way Facebook can't hurt Cambridge Analytica. I've criticized during the election that they didn't do enough on the interference, that they had posts talking about suppressing African-American votes and that there was not enough monitoring. But, you know, one thing that we never talk about is, if you look at, Greco did a study at Stanford about what the biggest influence was of the polarization of the electorate in Donald Trump's election. And it actually wasn't social media companies. Anyone guess what it was? Cable news. Cable news. Fox. I mean, no one is talking about, and that's, a lot of the voters are actually getting
58:13 Speaker 03 their information from there. So, do I think that we ought to have a greater thought about what social media's companies' responsibility is to make sure that they are contributing to democracy and not undermining it? Absolutely. But do I think that they can be blamed for the cheapening of American discourse and all our problems? No. I mean, I think the truth is probably in between.
58:36 Speaker 02 All right, everybody. Ro Khanna. Thank you Congressman Khanna for coming back on the show. You can follow me on Twitter @KaraSwisher. My executive producer, Erica Anderson, is at EricaAmerica. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. If you liked this episode, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robby. And special thanks to Manny's for hosting us. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: Andreessen Horowitz's Scott Kupor Next Recode Decode: Index Ventures' Mike Volpi and Danny Rimer Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated