Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Lime president Joe Kraus About this episode Lime President Joe Kraus talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about how he came to Lime after a long career in both startups and venture capital, the company's pivot from bikes to scooters and the "unbundling of the car." Kraus also talks about the impact of scooters on cities and public transit, how Lime is trying to stand out in the crowded global scooter market, and the large valuations for scooter companies. Plus: Why Uber and Lyft's rocky IPOs haven't scared Lime away from going public someday.
Featuring:
Joe Kraus, President of Lime (@LimeBike)
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Pivot, Kara’s podcast with NYU Professor Scott Galloway that offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 13,808 words · 5 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Growing teams need a corporate card built for more, something that doesn't sacrifice speed for control. Introducing the American Express Corporate Cash Back Card. Get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, advanced spending controls, and real-time visibility, plus intelligent expense management. Get started at go.amex slash amexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Tic Tac. Lace up and get your game on because the Tic Tac lineup just got a new teammate. Dr. Pepper Tic Tac. This new double threat puts two of your favorite flavors into one box of mints. And when two iconic flavors come together, the result can only be iconic. Score big. Try Dr. Pepper Tic Tac today.
0:55 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who thinks if President Trump is really serious about climate change, he'd hereby order everyone onto a scooter. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Joe Kraus, the president of Lime. This is, of course, the company that used to be known as Lime Bike, but is now one of the key players in the scooter wars. Joe was previously Lime's first COO and was named president in May. He also is someone I have known for a very long time.
1:27 Speaker 03 Indeed.
1:28 Speaker 02 I think from the beginning. Disclosure, I was actually in his wedding a long time ago, 120 years.
1:34 Speaker 03 I think, yeah, I've had my 120th anniversary.
1:37 Speaker 02 120th anniversary. But he has a lot of interest. We're going to talk about that and more. And we're talking about Lime and where it's going. But first, talk a little about your background. You're not just any president of Lime. You've had a long history of an early internet person.
1:51 Speaker 03 That's how we met.
1:52 Speaker 02 That's right. So you ran. Explain who you are.
1:54 Speaker 03 All right, so I've been in the valley about 25 years. Graduated Stanford in 93.
1:59 Speaker 02 Typical.
2:00 Speaker 03 Typical.
2:00 Speaker 02 Right.
2:01 Speaker 03 Won really a birth lottery, truthfully, because... Internet was just getting commercialized with the web in 94. And friends of mine and I, coming out of Stanford, didn't want to work for anybody else. We started an early internet search engine that was called Excite.
2:14 Speaker 02 Yep.
2:15 Speaker 03 Took a public in 96. That's how we met.
2:16 Speaker 02 That's right. We met at a dinner with... There was one search engine with two guys, but that was later. Like, when was Excite? That was...
2:23 Speaker 03 93, we started. And that was basically Yahoo time.
2:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, Yahoo. There was Jerry Yang and Dave Filo.
2:29 Speaker 03 That's right.
2:30 Speaker 02 And ten of you guys, or whatever.
2:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, right, exactly. We just got a larger and larger band.
2:33 Speaker 02 And I had a dinner with ten dudes at a restaurant in Palo Alto. And you were the only person I found interested. You and Graham. I don't know who the rest of those people were, or what happened to them whatsoever. There was a big search engine wars, essentially.
2:45 Speaker 03 Yeah, for sure, back in those days. It was a fight for dominance.
2:47 Speaker 02 Right.
2:48 Speaker 03 Obviously, Google ultimately won.
2:49 Speaker 02 At first, it was Excite and Yahoo, right? And Yahoo was dominant.
2:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, Yahoo did the whole browsing thing. We were doing the search thing.
2:56 Speaker 02 Right.
2:56 Speaker 03 But that was back in the day when search was viewed as like a means to an end. You would gather traffic but couldn't monetize it directly.
3:01 Speaker 02 Right.
3:02 Speaker 03 Then there was the innovation about essentially including in search results ads. And then Google really took it, obviously, further with their bidding system and separating ads on the right-hand side.
3:09 Speaker 02 Right, right. But Google was a newcomer.
3:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, they were in 99, I believe, something like that.
3:14 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:14 Speaker 03 There was AltaVista in there, which had a big run for a while as well, so...
3:18 Speaker 02 Little run. A little run. Very short run.
3:21 Speaker 03 Having been in those, everything feels like a compressed period of time.
3:24 Speaker 02 But you would start this search engine. You had a really cool headquarters, which...
3:27 Speaker 03 With a slide?
3:28 Speaker 02 The slide. This is the famous slide that Joe tried to get me to go down. And I declined to ride the slide. And everybody... Everybody was like, "Oh, they had a slide."
3:35 Speaker 03 You know, the problem with that slide is it actually generated tremendous amount of static electricity. So as you went down, you were being constantly shocked.
3:40 Speaker 02 Well, that's not why I didn't go down it. I didn't go down it because it was inane for someone who's above 40 to go down a slide.
3:45 Speaker 03 Oh, you should really give it a try.
3:46 Speaker 02 No, I really... No, no. I just wanted to talk about your business. But, anyway, they ran Excite, and then it merged with At Home, which was a...
3:53 Speaker 03 Cable internet access company.
3:54 Speaker 02 Go rodeo, is what I was thinking.
3:56 Speaker 03 And so we took Excite public in 96, and then we sold it in 99 to At Home. And then I left in April of 2000 and took some time off, and...
4:07 Speaker 02 Were you involved in the Blue Mountain Arts buy?
4:09 Speaker 03 I was involved in the Blue Mountain Arts buy.
4:11 Speaker 02 Yeah, this was a card thing.
4:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, this was back in the day when eyeballs were the hottest thing to try to grab and there was a greeting cards company, an e-greeting cards company called Blue Mountain Arts, which we bought and that was certainly a mistake, although now, isn't he the governor?
4:25 Speaker 02 He's the governor of Colorado.
4:27 Speaker 03 Of Colorado?
4:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, he's the son, Jared.
4:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, great guy.
4:30 Speaker 02 He's a great guy. It was interesting because the husband and wife, his parents, who had started the company, were kind of hippies. Did you know they called me during that? Everyone's like, "How'd you get that scoop?" I'm like, "They called me to ask my advice." And I said, "Take the cash, don't take any of that stock, and run for the hills."
4:46 Speaker 03 Oh, so you're responsible for the poor deal structure that we ultimately did?
4:49 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly.
4:50 Speaker 03 Thank you very little.
4:51 Speaker 02 No problem. It was really funny. I was like, I said, "You know I'm a reporter, I'm gonna write about this now." She's like, "Yeah, but I just want the rest of you." I said, "Take the cash, run so far."
5:00 Speaker 03 Well, you were prescient in terms of...
5:01 Speaker 02 You got $600 million in cash, right?
5:02 Speaker 03 I don't remember what the price was, but it's on that order of magnitude, for sure. It was a lot.
5:07 Speaker 02 It was a lot. So then you took time off, then you were sort of...
5:09 Speaker 03 I took time off, I did some traveling, ultimately did some political work, joined the board of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and then started a second company in 2004, which is a small Wiki collaborative group editing company called JotSpot.
5:22 Speaker 02 Oh, JotSpot.
5:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, we sold that in 2006 to Google.
5:25 Speaker 02 Right.
5:26 Speaker 03 Which is how I ended up at Google, and then I was...
5:28 Speaker 02 Explain JotSpot, I like to keep this memorialized.
5:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, sure. This was right as Wikipedia was getting going, I think Wikipedia was probably '03, something like that. But the basic premise was, back in 2003, you know, I don't know, we were on Word or Microsoft Office 11. And so, one thought was, the whole Office suite was really around making an individual more productive. But at least Graham, my co-founder in both Excite and JotSpot, we were thinking, how much more productive can an individual get in Office 12 versus Office 11? But the Internet had been around for about a decade, email was clearly a way that people were communicating, and more and more groups were needing to work together over long distances.
6:16 Speaker 03 And so the idea was, well... Actually, it's about group productivity is what's going to be more important. And wikis were starting to come out as a group editing tool. And so we commercialized basically technology for allowing people to spin up wikis. It was a SaaS company, which was new at the time.
6:32 Speaker 02 Sure.
6:33 Speaker 03 And group editing was new, again, at the time. Obviously, Notes, Lotus Notes, back in, way back in the day, was something that had existed. Ultimately, Google looked at it as they were building out their Doc suite.
6:45 Speaker 02 Docs, it's a doc, it fits in Docs, and then Slack in a lot of ways.
6:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, it's amazing.
6:49 Speaker 02 There's pieces of it, yeah.
6:50 Speaker 03 It's amazing how the extension of that, if I look today at Lassie, a very successful company that has, obviously, things like Jira for bugs, but they had Confluence, which was a competitive product at the time. And what I think Slack really took to the next level was that same trend about working together and getting off of email. But I think they really figured out that it was about messaging.
7:12 Speaker 02 Right.
7:13 Speaker 03 Better than we ever did.
7:14 Speaker 02 Right, absolutely. So then you were at Google, and you moved into the investing space.
7:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, so I was, two guys had gotten Google Ventures off the ground, and then I, along with several others, joined as really kind of the founding general partners as Google moved from investing $100 million a year up to now about $1 billion a year. So I was there for a decade as a general partner focused on marketplaces, but also transportation. It turns out Lime was my second-to-last investment at Google Ventures, and I got so excited about what I saw in terms of the growth, the mega trends, that I just wanted to get back.
7:47 Speaker 02 I was surprised when you became a VC, because you'd been such an operator, you were such an entrepreneur versus moving inside of it. I mean, it seems like that's the disease everybody gets, they become a venture capitalist.
7:56 Speaker 03 You know, for me, I really thought about starting a third company. That's what I thought I would do. When I got to Google, I started a list, the first day I got to Google, of great product managers, engineers, designers, biz dev people that I was meeting. And once a quarter, I would stack rank the top five people, just thinking, this is a group of people that I'd want to recruit. The reality is, when I got to Google, I had one kid. And when I, my kind of earn-out was done at Google, I had three. And so I just felt like I wasn't cut out for operations at that time in my life.
8:25 Speaker 02 Right.
8:25 Speaker 03 So basically, took a decade and invested, and I loved it in terms of the intellectual variety, but what I missed was... The relationships you form with people when you struggle to do the impossible, that's just incredibly rewarding at a personal level.
8:41 Speaker 02 All right, so we'll get to Lime in a second, but so you, working at Google Ventures, Google has two venture arms now.
8:47 Speaker 03 They have kind of a venture group called Google Ventures and a private equity-style, later-stage, bigger checks called Capital G.
8:54 Speaker 02 Capital G, which does different things, competing things sometimes.
8:57 Speaker 03 Sometimes, we work together.
8:58 Speaker 02 Yeah. What was that experience like, being a VC? Because it got you to Lime. I mean, what were you, why did you suddenly focus on, you had been in content, really, forever.
9:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I'd say the first wave was around kind of consumer with search engine. JotSpot was really around small to mid-sized businesses and dealing with customer acquisition and business problems about long-term value versus cost of customer acquisition. I don't know, I found transportation really, really interesting in general because I think maybe one of the things that I yearn for is the ability to affect people's real li, like, non-digital lives. There's always an interesting business going on with some new digital thing, be it the rise of-
9:39 Speaker 02 What was some of the others you invested in there?
9:41 Speaker 03 In the transportation category?
9:42 Speaker 02 In general, in general there.
9:44 Speaker 03 Let's see, kind of looking back, Turo is one company, that's a peer-to-peer car rental company, obviously still going and doing quite well. In the trucking space, I invested in a company called Keep Truckin', which is basically in bringing technology to this huge segment of the American economy that not many people address. Was an investor in a company that's not related to transportation, but in the marketplace space, which is the other spot called StockX. It's a market that's kind of hidden in plain sight. It's a secondary market, like StubHub is to tickets. StockX is to these hard-to-get sneakers and T-shirts, and it's actually a much bigger business than people realize.
10:22 Speaker 02 Oh, I think it's bigger, I'm a teenage boy.
10:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, you know it exactly.
10:25 Speaker 02 I know all about it, I've been buying things-
10:26 Speaker 03 You know, like Supreme and collaborations-
10:28 Speaker 02 That's not cool, just so you know.
10:29 Speaker 03 Supreme is no longer cool. I understand that Bloom is off the road. If somebody like me is talking about Supreme, it is definitely not cool.
10:34 Speaker 02 Yeah.
10:35 Speaker 03 So that's another example of a company that was in the kind of sweet spot for me investing.
10:40 Speaker 02 But this one, Lime, what did you see when you were as an investor? They'd start as a bike company.
10:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, they had started in the bike sharing space, starting with pedal bikes, and they had just introduced e-bikes. And by the time I was looking at it, they had started introducing scooters, their own scooters. One of the things that I thought was interesting about them is they didn't use other people's scooters, like a nine-bot Segway, but they were instead using scooters that they had built themselves. So what did I see at that time? And that was back now in April of 2018.
11:09 Speaker 02 Back, way back when.
11:11 Speaker 03 Way back when.
11:12 Speaker 02 Year and a half ago. Less than a year and a half.
11:15 Speaker 03 The main thing I saw was just incredible growth. Any investor is really looking for, especially in an early to mid-stage investor, they're looking for evidence of product-market fit. And what was incredible is it was clear that scooters were something people loved, not just liked and used, but you would just watch, you would stand on a street corner and you'd see people try to figure out, what is this thing? How do I ride it? What do you mean it's for rent? Because this kind of sharing model, dockless sharing mobility, was something that was really novel in the United States. It was common in China, but it was novel in the United States back 18, 20 months ago. And so first, watching people figure out what this is.
11:59 Speaker 03 But then the second is literally the smile they would have on their face when they took off on one of these scooters. I argue that this is the closest thing humanity's devised to a magic carpet. People smile, and then they figured out how useful it was, how much time it saved them. And you saw that in the numbers. Basically, you saw incredible growth in terms of trips, revenue, users, and that was kind of the first signal. And then the question we had to ask ourselves was, is this a fad or a durable trend?
12:29 Speaker 02 Right.
12:30 Speaker 03 If it's a durable trend, can you make money from it?
12:32 Speaker 02 Right.
12:33 Speaker 03 And then how does the competitive landscape emerge? And so going through those questions was really the diligence process we did to say, should we invest in any company?
12:42 Speaker 02 Any of them, of which there were several.
12:43 Speaker 03 And there were several. And then the question was, why the one we're looking at? And ultimately, we came to the conclusion that Lime was the best company for that. Once we answered, yes, it's a durable trend, yes, you can make money, and yes, we think the competitive landscape will allow independent companies to exist. We picked Lime for several reasons. One, we love the executional prowess of the team. They were not first to market in scooters, but they were gaining share. They were still behind, in that case, Bird at that time, but they were gaining ground. Second is that they had built their own supply chain and we felt like hardware was going to be a critical component of the business. And the third is we thought that their approach to government relations was really just plain
13:26 Speaker 03 better in the way that they interacted and worked with cities. You know, the old model was this kind of Uber combative model, but our view at GV looking at the whole space was...
13:36 Speaker 02 Which was an investor in Uber, by the way.
13:38 Speaker 03 Which was an investor in Uber.
13:40 Speaker 02 Both of you? GV was and also...
13:43 Speaker 03 No, Capital G's and Lyft.
13:44 Speaker 02 Lyft, that's right. Okay, right, that's right.
13:46 Speaker 03 So Alphabet has plays in both.
13:48 Speaker 02 Right.
13:49 Speaker 03 You know, in the scooter business, Uber's hidden in plain sight. Like Uber X, you can't tell if that vehicle's an Uber or not. Scooters are on the street, visible, so you have to be a good partner with cities. You can't just kind of slip under the radar.
14:00 Speaker 02 We're going to get into that next when we talk about that, about safety and all kinds of issues, because it's a really challenging operational business. But they had been in bikes, which hadn't worked. When you were looking at these sectors, a lot of these companies had tried bikes. There's obviously been City Bikes and those companies, Lyft and the others have gotten into those. Talk a little bit about the shift, because it was called Lime Bike, and that was not disastrous, but felt semi-disastrous. There were too many, there were those pictures in China of bikes on top of bikes. That one photo was just fantastic.
14:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I would say if you look at the history of bike share in China, it is a story of unbridled competition to basically win market share with no spend efficiency. Like, they basically just dumped bikes everywhere.
14:46 Speaker 02 Right, right.
14:47 Speaker 03 Now, the good news is that for the US, Europe, Australia, New Zealand, basically any market but for China, and even China though today, nobody wants that.
14:57 Speaker 02 Right.
14:58 Speaker 03 And so cities are looking at how do we integrate micromobility, which they think is a good thing.
15:02 Speaker 02 Right.
15:03 Speaker 03 But make sure it's not this crazy, unbridled war on the streets where hardware gets dumped and basically...
15:11 Speaker 02 You know, the stories are easy, it's easy for the media to pick on, including scooters. We'll get into that, but it's less so with scooters than bikes. Bikes really... Didn't work as well, although they did when they were docked. Like, it's a really interesting.
15:23 Speaker 03 From the city's point of view, but not from the customer's point of view.
15:25 Speaker 02 Right, right, exactly, because you can pick them up anywhere.
15:27 Speaker 03 In my view, what's happening broadly speaking is that you're seeing this unbundling of the car. And the trend went, it first started with Uber. So Uber taught people that I don't need to own a car. I can have access to a car. And if that access is reliable enough.
15:41 Speaker 02 You know, that's my brand. You know, I've written about this a lot, like that you're not going to own one.
15:44 Speaker 03 Right, you have access over ownership.
15:46 Speaker 02 Right.
15:47 Speaker 03 And that itself was playing on the back of like the sharing economy that was coming up with Airbnb and others. But I think what Uber really showed is that it's sufficient liquidity, it's sufficient availability. It's a substitute for ownership.
16:00 Speaker 02 Right.
16:00 Speaker 03 And you can mediate that through your phone. You can summon a car on your phone. I think the next wave that's happening is to ask the question, why is the car the right vehicle for all trips? You know, since Henry Ford in 1908 with the introduction of the Model T, we've really had this notion of one car to rule them all. I take short and long trips with it, day trips and night trips with it, trips to the mountains, trips to the store. I do everything in my car. But if you look at an urban environment in particular.
16:30 Speaker 02 Where most people are moving.
16:30 Speaker 03 Where most, yeah, I mean, 55% of the world's population's in a city today. That's expected to be 68% in 2050, which is about 2.5 billion people moving to cities. Like, cities are, the trend towards cities is inexorable. It begs the question, cars aren't really the greatest vehicle for short trips. And so this unbundling of the car, which I think boils down to small vehicles for small trips. And the car's great for going long distances, where you want to go point to point. But inside a city under five miles, I strongly believe cars are not the right vehicle type.
17:03 Speaker 02 Right, and you know, people are talking about this. What's interesting about the bike thing, the first time I ever heard of the notion of this, of all things, I was walking with Sergey Brin and he said, I'm going to dump. A hundred thousand bicycles in New York, that's my new idea. This was a decade ago. It was weird. I was like, what? And he goes, yes, because they had them around Google, if you remember.
17:21 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah, for sure.
17:22 Speaker 02 The colored boot. And I always wanted to steal one, like, or drive into them or something.
17:26 Speaker 03 You wouldn't be the first.
17:26 Speaker 02 You know, not just steal them, but I was like, oh, they just annoyed me for some reason. But I also saw the genius.
17:31 Speaker 03 I think you're easily annoyed.
17:31 Speaker 02 I know, that's true. But they're, it's just they were multicolored and like, as if you're on a beach in the summer. I just was like, you people, wake up.
17:38 Speaker 03 Happy Googlers.
17:39 Speaker 02 Happy Googlers. So, but they had a lot of them. He said, I'm gonna drop a hundred thousand on New York. And I figured this many get stolen. He had an exact number that would get stolen and damaged. And then he said, then I'm gonna drop a hundred thousand more. Then I'm gonna drop a hundred thousand. And he had a point where you couldn't drop enough, like, that it became useful. That it would hit every section of the city. And he had the algorithm. He was, it was crazy at the time. And I thought, that was, that's brilliant in a weird way. Like, that you could do this. The idea of dropping micro mobility onto a city. Could you replicate what was happening on the Google campus? Which I thought was super interesting. But it was also, as usual, typically not thinking of life in the city. Like, dumping a hundred thousand bikes on a city, okay. You know, billionaire. That's good for you and your experimentation.
18:24 Speaker 02 So it was a really, it's a, it's a great idea that was initially, especially around bikes, executed totally wrongly. I remember being in Seattle and being overwhelmed by bikes there, which I don't think are there now. Or cities not being.
18:36 Speaker 03 No, we still have, I mean, Lime still has a bike operation there. The thing I would say, though, is this about bikes versus scooters. We offer both. Ninety-eight percent of our business is scooters.
18:45 Speaker 02 Now, yeah.
18:46 Speaker 03 And the reason is scooters are a better form factor for a mile and a half to two miles. They just are. And I think it's really a couple of reasons. The first is people know what a bike is. So, I'll say, I'll say this. An e-bike, if you haven't been on one, is no work at all. But when you look at it, it still looks like work. Because you've ridden a bike before and you think you have to pedal this and it's gonna be work and maybe you're gonna be a little sweaty. Also, the act of getting on a bike is meaningfully different than a slight step up to get on a scooter.
19:17 Speaker 02 Right, it is.
19:17 Speaker 03 And lastly, scooters are just more manageable as a vehicle. They're lighter, less cumbersome, smaller.
19:25 Speaker 03 And so for this subtle group of reasons, scooters took off in terms of utilization
19:30 Speaker 02 joy bikes.
19:31 Speaker 03 in a way that bikes have not.
19:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's some tinier. In Los Angeles, there's these teeny little bikes. I think you.
19:36 Speaker 03 There's a company called Wheels.
19:37 Speaker 02 Wheels.
19:37 Speaker 03 puts those out.
19:38 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:38 Speaker 03 And they're interesting. I do think, my own view, is that scooters are great for like a mile and a half to two miles and under. There's a vehicle type that I think has yet to be discovered between two and five miles. Some people are trying it with mopeds, like Revel in Brooklyn and Washington DC.
19:56 Speaker 02 Right, it just was on one the other day.
19:57 Speaker 03 Okay, yeah. That itself is a clone of a company called Gogoro in Taiwan. There's the Wheels form factor, which is a small bike.
20:06 Speaker 02 Teeny.
20:06 Speaker 03 Teeny, like a clown one.
20:08 Speaker 02 Yeah. Adults look ridiculous on them, but they're fun to ride.
20:11 Speaker 03 I'm gonna get a picture of you on one.
20:13 Speaker 02 Okay, good.
20:13 Speaker 03 I feel it.
20:13 Speaker 02 There is one existing. I'm not gonna show it to you.
20:15 Speaker 03 Okay. And then, I think, I think we have yet to discover what that ideal form factor is for the US market in particular in that two to five mile range. I think that, my own personal bias, I think Americans have always had an uncertain relationship with a moped. It's bigger, certainly bigger in East Asia. It's modestly sized in Europe. And mopeds have been around for a long time. So I'm not fully convinced that an electric moped, and I would point to Scoot's moped operation in San Francisco. Been around quite a while.
20:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, I haven't ridden one.
20:51 Speaker 03 And you probably haven't ridden one.
20:52 Speaker 02 I had a moped all through high school. We'll talk about this and more when we get back. We're here with Joe Kraus. He's the president of Lime, which used to be called Lime Bikes, but now is one of the leading scooter companies.
21:02 Speaker 04 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
21:04 Speaker 02 Price Line Negotiator.
21:06 Speaker 04 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities, like pools and spas and beachfronts. And, wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
21:34 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Tic Tac. Lace up and get your game on because the Tic Tac lineup just got a new teammate. Dr. Pepper Tic Tac. This new double threat puts two of your favorite flavors into one box of mince. And when two iconic flavors come together, the result can only be iconic. Score big. Try Dr. Pepper Tic Tac today.
21:57 Speaker 02 We're here with Joe Kraus. He's the president of Lime. We've been talking about various, uh, the micro mobility. Is that right? Is that micro mobility?
22:03 Speaker 03 That is the term.
22:04 Speaker 02 So I want to get, so you guys leaned really heavily into scooters, this idea. You're right, there's all kinds of different ways people get on. I was thinking vertical lift and takeoff things. Would I get in a drone? I probably would get in a drone, like those kinds of things, which I think are super interesting. I know Uber has some experiment. They've kept going for some unknown reason.
22:20 Speaker 03 Uber Elevate.
22:21 Speaker 02 Whatever. Sure. Okay. Maybe it'll happen, probably not for 30 years or something like that. And, you know, they'll drop like three or four people into the bay, you know? And then we'll see how that goes.
22:31 Speaker 03 Have you talked to Joby Aviation?
22:33 Speaker 02 No.
22:33 Speaker 03 They're like the most interesting company in eVTOL. I don't want to get over.
22:36 Speaker 02 That's what they do? Joby?
22:38 Speaker 03 Joby Aviation.
22:39 Speaker 02 Okay, all right. And then there's hoverboards, which are hovercraft, which is Larry Page's thing over there at Kitty Hawk and things like that. So I want to talk first about the bigger one, then about Lime, because what's happened with Lime is you are in a really competitive landscape, not unlike your experience in search. You know what I mean? Like here you are again with several different companies. But first I want to finish with micro mobility. So there's going to be lots of answers, you mean, in that you don't know what the answers are for the various problems?
23:08 Speaker 03 Yeah. Clearly scooters right now are what people love. Like we've done six, we operate today in 100 cities, 26 countries, five continents. We've done over 65 million rides. The business has grown tremendously and...
23:24 Speaker 03 I don't see any signs of that abating. Like 11%, to give you an example, like 11% of Parisians use a scooter.
23:31 Speaker 02 Well, we can talk about Paris because I just wrote a column about that, the idea of, okay, so 11% use the scooters that are available.
23:37 Speaker 03 That's right, which is amazing. They've been available in Paris for a year. The amount of people who have shifted their behaviors from cars to scooters is...
23:46 Speaker 02 So the shift is from cars. It's not from public transportation or walking or what?
23:51 Speaker 03 There's a few shifts. So about when we, when you look at data from, let's say, Portland's Department of Transportation, which I think has done the best study on this, that doesn't involve us, right? So I'll use their data. We have data that basically confirms this, but their independent data was, in Portland at least, about 40% of people were replacing a car trip. About half of that was replacing an independent car trip. About half of that was replacing an Uber or Lyft trip, a rideshare trip. The remainder was replacing walking primarily. They weren't replacing public transit. What was essentially happening was, our data shows about 40% of rides start or end at public transit. And so, let me, let me...
24:31 Speaker 02 So you're riding to public transit?
24:32 Speaker 03 Play the last mile.
24:33 Speaker 02 Right.
24:34 Speaker 03 So they might take the subway and then from the subway, they take the scooter to their work.
24:38 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
24:39 Speaker 03 So, our, our business in general, in our view, is that micromobility works much better in Europe than the United States. Those cities were made for, they're much denser, they're old, they were made for horses and humans, not cars. Cars were always a retrofit into those cities. They've invested...
24:56 Speaker 02 Cobblestones, thank you very much, in Paris.
24:58 Speaker 03 Cobblestones make it difficult. They make it difficult to, well, even worse is Prague. Prague's a really interesting market for us, and I'm shocked people ride scooters because it is so cobbleston-y there.
25:08 Speaker 02 Right.
25:09 Speaker 03 It's difficult. But regardless, so they're denser, older, cars were always a retrofit. They invested in public transportation earlier, so their networks are better, and that's actually better for micromobility because of this positive relationship between micromobility and public transit. And then lastly, they invested in bike lanes early. So the infrastructure, there's this great website called Copenhagen Eyes that looks at the biking infrastructure. Top 20 cities are not in the US, they're in Europe. And so that's why the micromobility business, scooters in particular, is a much better business in Europe than it is in the United States.
25:42 Speaker 02 Bike lanes are critical.
25:42 Speaker 03 They are absolutely critical for like, usage and safety, both.
25:46 Speaker 02 Right, we'll get into those in a minute, but let's first talk about the competition. So you came over from Google because you just wanted, this is the company you wanted to work for, or what?
25:56 Speaker 03 Because what I saw was, a company that was growing incredibly fast, was global in scale, and was riding two durable trends: urbanization and all the attendant problems. More urbanization is more traffic, more pollution, more congestion. Truthfully, I think at a, certainly in the United States, I think there's also this epidemic of loneliness with the decline in religious institutions, the decline in kind of civil organizations, Lions Clubs, Rotary Clubs. People are lonelier. And all of those trends, I think, have some interface with transit. So I don't think cars are the answer, as 2.5 billion more people go into cities. I felt very confident of that. That trend, coupled with the great execution of
26:41 Speaker 03 Lime, and the growth of Lime, and the global nature of the business, got me really attracted about jumping in, again. So that's why Lime, in particular, was, again, they made their own scooters from the very beginning, had a great government relations team to get into these cities. Competitively, what I think is interesting is that it was a much less clear picture a year and a half ago. Today, I think it's meaningfully clearer. We're pretty much 2X bigger than our nearest competitor. I would say, in the United States, we're 50/50, 55/45, depending on the metrics, one way or another, with Bird.
27:13 Speaker 02 Right.
27:14 Speaker 03 But if we look globally, we're 2 to 1, almost, bigger than anybody else.
27:18 Speaker 02 There's a ton of them in Paris. I wrote this column about Paris. This was, and it was, again, it's interesting, because it's the same story that Uber played out. Like, what? Like, it's the sort of what by government, which had allowed it to happen, and at the same time, then, was pulling back from it. I think there were at least 12 scooter companies.
27:35 Speaker 03 16.
27:35 Speaker 02 There were 16.
27:36 Speaker 03 Well, actually, maybe by the time you got on there, five had retired from the market.
27:39 Speaker 02 Whatever, there were a lot. And they were names I'd never heard of, for the most part. And then there was Lime and Bird. And some that are maybe owned by Lyft, that are getting rebranded Lyft. I don't recall seeing them in Paris. But I don't remember I see all of these things. But now, what I see is, Bird... You, a lot of you, Bird, whatever Lyft is switched from, are they, is that Uber or Scoot?
28:02 Speaker 03 Are you thinking about Jump in particular?
28:04 Speaker 02 Jump, Jump is Uber.
28:05 Speaker 03 Jump is Uber.
28:06 Speaker 02 And Lyft has changed whatever they bought to their name now.
28:09 Speaker 03 Lyft is, I don't believe, in Paris mainly because...
28:12 Speaker 02 Not in Paris, but in the US, I'm saying anywhere, yes.
28:14 Speaker 03 Oh, in the US, yes, they have Lyft scooters in the US.
28:15 Speaker 02 Yes, but they called, they were called something else powered by Lyft and then they became, they had a different name, they bought something or whatever. So those two have gotten into the market, those two mobility companies, Lyft and Uber.
28:27 Speaker 03 Yep.
28:28 Speaker 02 And then whatever local one pops up, it seems like, and I'm trying to think of who else has existed.
28:32 Speaker 03 In the European theater, they're essentially all one-syllable names, Tierr, Voy, Wind, Cirque.
28:39 Speaker 02 Right, right.
28:40 Speaker 03 They just, everybody seems to love one-syllable names in the space.
28:43 Speaker 02 Right, but the two ones that are dominating are independent companies with, with the Uber and Lyft versions pushing forward pretty heavily. In Washington, I ride a lot of Lyft ones because they're available in my neighborhood. I don't see a Scoot as much, but I've suddenly started to see them. Like, I take whatever is, I'm not brand loyal to you all. I like Lime ones, but I'm not. So talk about that competitive environment when you're like that, when there isn't a brand loyalty necessarily.
29:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, so what I would say is...
29:10 Speaker 02 As there is with Lyft and Uber, for sure.
29:11 Speaker 03 Really, it really, really depends on the market, truthfully, and we've got data all over the place on these topics. So if I look at, Germany is a really important market right now, mainly because it opened somewhat recently, middle of June, the whole country opened at once. As I already mentioned, Europe, the micromobility business there is meaningfully better. And in cities like Berlin, we have 47% of the total fleet in Berlin of all available scooters, but we have 62% of the rides. Or in Cologne, another German city, we have 56% of the fleet and 71% of the rides. So we think there is evidence of at least some portion of users expressing preference,
29:55 Speaker 03 but it's the biggest thing we're working to develop. And I think, truthfully, preference comes from a few things. One is, do people like your hardware?
30:02 Speaker 02 Right.
30:02 Speaker 03 Do they feel comfortable on it? Do they like the features in your app? So it's a product piece.
30:08 Speaker 02 Sure.
30:08 Speaker 03 Another piece is, are we deploying where people need them?
30:12 Speaker 02 That's what, deployment is really all I care about.
30:14 Speaker 03 Deployment matters a ton.
30:15 Speaker 02 What's near the coffee shop and I'll grab it.
30:17 Speaker 03 That's right. And then the last piece is a long-term investment. When I look at, how do you create preference in a world of abundance? I think the models to look at here are things like coffee and premium alcohols, where like you're willing to walk to get a Starbucks and not a...
30:33 Speaker 02 Nobody's willing to walk to get a Starbucks.
30:35 Speaker 03 You don't have to walk.
30:36 Speaker 02 That's why there's one on every corner.
30:37 Speaker 03 There's one on every corner.
30:38 Speaker 02 That's their strategy.
30:38 Speaker 03 You're certainly willing to pay.
30:39 Speaker 02 Shitty coffee, but it's right there.
30:41 Speaker 03 Conveniently placed.
30:42 Speaker 02 Yeah. I'm sorry, Howard, but it's true.
30:44 Speaker 03 Every time you buy a $3 cup of Starbucks coffee instead of a $0.50 piece of other, you know, somebody else's coffee, you're expressing preference in a world of abundance. Or when you ask for a Grey Goose and soda for a spirit that is supposed to taste like nothing, you are expressing preference in a world of abundance.
30:58 Speaker 02 Right. It's a brand.
30:59 Speaker 03 And so there is, the way these brands are built, in my opinion, is that they marry world-class product with elevating a sense of purpose. And I think one of the things that we need to continue to do is talk to our users about the sense of purpose. And our view, our mission, is that we believe a city life is a great life. And our mission is to making cities connected with other people, making them better for you to get around in, and fundamentally, over time, making them more human. I know that sounds like a big reach.
31:31 Speaker 02 Yes, yeah.
31:32 Speaker 03 I get it.
31:32 Speaker 02 You sound like WeWork right now.
31:33 Speaker 03 I know, I know. I'm sorry.
31:35 Speaker 02 They're just renting office space and not economically.
31:37 Speaker 03 I know. But if I just look at like, again, I...
31:40 Speaker 02 I like that you caught yourself, at least.
31:42 Speaker 03 I did. I caught you before you caught me, which is what I appreciate.
31:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, because I was like, oh, come on.
31:46 Speaker 03 You were about to blast me. I know that.
31:48 Speaker 02 Search is a way to connect people across the globe. Go ahead.
31:52 Speaker 03 I just think if you don't have that... If you don't try to raise the emotional stakes, it's very tough.
31:57 Speaker 02 So you want people to like Lime versus Bird versus?
32:00 Speaker 03 Of course. You know, I think that's an important part of the mission. But I think it starts with world-class product. Like, we have to make the best hardware. And then it starts with great placement. And then we have to continually raise the emotional stakes.
32:11 Speaker 02 Of those, I would imagine placement is probably the most important, right? If there's two there, if there's one there, they'll just take, people will just take one, like, whatever's available.
32:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think there's also something to habit. Like, if you look at first-.
32:23 Speaker 02 That's true. I do take Lime.
32:24 Speaker 03 First app open, it makes a difference for people.
32:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, if I have a bunch of them, I'll take a Lime or a Bird before. Because I'm like, screw you, Uber and Lyft. Essentially, I don't know why. It's just like, I don't want any of the big companies to win. Like, I like independent companies versus...
32:37 Speaker 03 Well, I appreciate the focus on the independence.
32:40 Speaker 02 Well, you're also ridiculously valued, but that's all right. I don't care. You're independent.
32:43 Speaker 03 That doesn't affect you as a writer.
32:44 Speaker 02 No. So how does this competition shake out? Because you've got, first of all, the city's putting pressure on there. Like, in San Francisco, there's just a few, right? Are you, you're here, right? Are you not here?
32:55 Speaker 03 Uh, we're not here today.
32:56 Speaker 02 And you're not here, right.
32:57 Speaker 03 San Francisco just concluded their RFP process in terms of submissions on Wednesday of last week. And I would anticipate that there's new scooter companies with more fleet here by mid-October.
33:07 Speaker 02 Okay, so possibly you all.
33:09 Speaker 03 Possibly.
33:10 Speaker 02 Possibly. Right now, they just have a few. They have, what do they have?
33:12 Speaker 03 Scoot and Skip. Scoot is now owned by Bird.
33:14 Speaker 02 And they're attached to, um...
33:16 Speaker 03 San Francisco's the only market that has what's called a lock-to requirement that requires you to have a lock.
33:20 Speaker 02 I like it.
33:21 Speaker 03 Why do you like it?
33:22 Speaker 02 Because people aren't as sloppy. People aren't as sloppy. They don't leave them.
33:25 Speaker 03 That is the theory. What I see is a lot of scooters that are locked to themselves and then parked anywhere they want.
33:30 Speaker 02 Okay, I don't see that as much. I see the people, most people behave. Most people feel like they're going to get fined. I don't know. I do, at least. And so it's interesting. I kind of like it. I like it better than just anywhere. But, okay, you might have the statistics on it. So, San Francisco's, talk about that market. That's a more stringent market. It had the experience with Uber, and it certainly has tried to control the scooter situation.
33:50 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, my general view is if you look at...
33:54 Speaker 03 Most technology businesses, there tend to be two outlier markets, be it Airbnb or Uber or Lime. Those outlier markets are New York City and San Francisco for different reasons. Yeah, San Francisco's RFP had a number of requirements that are definitely stretches relative to what other markets are thinking about. We'll see how it shakes out. I don't have any-
34:12 Speaker 02 And New York? You're not in New York.
34:14 Speaker 03 We're not in New York. There's a bill on the mayor's desk that legalizes scooters in New York, specifically in the outer boroughs-
34:20 Speaker 02 Right.
34:20 Speaker 03 But not in Manhattan.
34:21 Speaker 02 Right.
34:21 Speaker 03 We certainly hope he signs it. And that would allow us to at least bring operations to the outer boroughs.
34:26 Speaker 02 To Brooklyn.
34:27 Speaker 03 We've got a small operation in New Jersey right now. It does quite well, but-
34:32 Speaker 02 Do you have to be in those big cities, those two, or not?
34:35 Speaker 03 What I've, truthfully, what I've been surprised in in the economics of the business is if you had asked me 10 months ago when I joined, I would have thought, "It's only going to work in mid-sized cities and above." Truthfully, we have found that, and I've been, truthfully, it's a surprising outcome and a testament to the people that make these businesses happen on the ground in these markets. It's worked in small markets and mid-sized markets and large markets. Fleets as small as 500, up to, you know, 10,000, 15,000 vehicles fleets. It's just worked across the board and it's not easy. It's a tough business, but they've made it, they've made it work.
35:08 Speaker 02 Sue, I want to get into sort of the operational parts of it next, but when you have all this competition, how does that, you have been in that situation, not Google roiled over everybody essentially. How does that, how does it shake out here? Does there have to be competition or will there be two or one?
35:26 Speaker 03 At least what I see happening, and this is a prediction, and predictions are, you know, vulnerable because, what is it, the Yogi Bear quote, like, "It's hard to make predictions, especially about the future." So what I see today is I see Lime as by far the dominant global player. We're two to one bigger than anybody else approximately. In Europe, we're, we even have a stronger market position and the competition is more fragmented. So what I see in the Nordics is it's Lime leading Envoy as the second-place player. And in Germany, I see Lime leading Antier as the second-place player. And in France, I see Lime leading, and in that case, Bird's the second-place player. So I just see a fragmented competitive environment where I think Lime has an opportunity to be-
36:10 Speaker 03 Half the market in Europe.
36:12 Speaker 02 Is that important? You have to be half the market.
36:14 Speaker 03 No, I don't. I think what I see in the United States is actually quite a interesting competitive environment where I think it's really us and Bird fighting it out and providing great service to users and basically being kind of 50/50 in the United States.
36:28 Speaker 02 How do you look at Bird then?
36:30 Speaker 03 So I credit Bird. They started the scooter revolution and I thought that I have a lot of respect for Travis as an operator, know several members of that team and think they've done some great innovative work. I think they did, you know, they did personal scooter rentals, they sell scooters, they've got the new kind of bike format. And look, my job as their competitor is to serve users by being better. So I have a lot of respect for my competitors and yet every day I wake up and want to be better.
37:00 Speaker 02 All right. So then, and Uber's and Lyft's efforts?
37:03 Speaker 03 So Uber is an investor in Lime.
37:06 Speaker 02 Right.
37:07 Speaker 03 In addition, we have this deal in a number of geographies across the world where along with Jump, we're an exclusive provider.
37:14 Speaker 02 Jump is Uber's.
37:15 Speaker 03 Jump is Uber, sorry. We have Lime scooters integrated into the Uber app.
37:20 Speaker 02 Right.
37:21 Speaker 03 So you can see that in DC, for example.
37:23 Speaker 02 I do.
37:24 Speaker 03 And our general view is that Uber's trying to make a platform. And what they want to do is have users get from point A to point B.
37:32 Speaker 02 Like a subway or whatever, that you can pay for the subway that way or whatever.
37:35 Speaker 03 Exactly. Like you want to integrate public transit and ride sharing and maybe other modalities like van pooling over time. I don't have any access to Uber's product plans, but micromobility is a part of that. And I think truthfully, they have a part of their business in Jump, which we compete with, and a part of their business in the ride sharing marketplace, the Uber app, where we're a partner. And that's kind of normal for these early stages of markets where sometimes your partners are also competing with you and sometimes your competitors are also partnering with you. That's the state we're in with Uber.
38:07 Speaker 02 Does that mean you have to get bought by Uber?
38:09 Speaker 03 No.
38:10 Speaker 02 That has to be a...
38:11 Speaker 03 No, no, no. I actually think... I have a lot of respect for the Jump team and at the same time, I look at our global market share and I'm very happy vis a vis our competitive position.
38:22 Speaker 02 And what about the valuations, the enormous, how do you answer that? And people go, that's ridiculous, Joe Kraus.
38:28 Speaker 03 I think if you look at the total addressable market for how big micromobility is, if you rewind the clock a year ago, I think there were legitimate questions about can people make money? I think if you look at the scooter space, it went through the Gartner hype cycle relatively quickly. So, there was a period of time, I'd say a full 18 months ago, where the scooter business was viewed as the answer to cancer. It was literally, you put a scooter on the ground, it's an ATM, it starts throwing off cash, it's amazing. I would say nine months ago, let's call it November, December 2018 through January, February 2019, we were in the trough of despair in that Gartner hype cycle.
39:06 Speaker 02 Too many, all over the place.
39:07 Speaker 03 Not only that, it's nobody will ever make money in this business.
39:09 Speaker 02 Right, they break down, people throw them, yeah.
39:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, scooters last 30 days, nobody's ever gonna make money, this is just a fool's errand, and it's a great service while the VC money lasts.
39:20 Speaker 02 And there's a lot of those businesses.
39:22 Speaker 03 There's a lot of those businesses.
39:23 Speaker 02 Many people still think Uber is that.
39:24 Speaker 03 So, I understand why skepticism was there. I think we're in an entirely different position today. So, we have a large number of markets that are what we would call unit economic or contribution margin positive, meaning on a market basis, they're making money. That doesn't mean the whole company is making money, but those markets are making money and we've been able to demonstrate and prove that this is not just about building a world-changing service, we can build a world-changing business that allows a world-changing service to be durable. And that has come through grinding out the details on how you make this business work because it's complicated, right? We have a supply chain that starts in China, gets scooters into a local market.
40:04 Speaker 02 We'll get to China in a minute.
40:05 Speaker 03 A warehouse, people that operate, maintain, repair, deploy, prevent scooters from being stolen, collect them from the field, organize a group of people that can charge them every night. Like, it is a lot of moving parts.
40:18 Speaker 02 Yes, it's a logistical nightmare.
40:19 Speaker 03 A logistically difficult business, but the interesting part is that's also the moat. That's why, you know, truthfully, it's why at the surface, this looks like...
40:30 Speaker 03 People think it's very similar to Uber's business because we're matching
40:33 Speaker 02 Right.
40:33 Speaker 03 You know, riders and
40:35 Speaker 02 Oh, I think they have far less moats than you all do. You're an operational, I think your problem is you, it's so difficult.
40:41 Speaker 03 It's hard.
40:41 Speaker 02 It's such an executionally difficult.
40:42 Speaker 03 It is an executionally difficult business, which is, I think, the moat and the challenge.
40:46 Speaker 02 Well, one thing that's interesting is I find I am very price sensitive to Uber rides, but not to scooters. It's really interesting.
40:54 Speaker 03 You know, we see that in the data, too.
40:55 Speaker 02 It's fascinating because I was like, that's too much money today. But then a scooter was something that was more than I thought. And I'm like, oh, well, it was worth, you know what I mean? Because it's low enough, which is interesting.
41:04 Speaker 03 So your point is what we survey users constantly on this kind of topic. And what you just said is exactly what is said broadly.
41:10 Speaker 02 I just don't even know what the price is. And it's not, as long as it's not 20 bucks, I'm like, fine. We're here with Joe Kraus, the president of Lime. We're going to talk about safety and other challenges that the scooter companies face when we return.
41:22 Speaker 04 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
41:26 Speaker 04 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses. There's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. And wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
41:53 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Tic Tac. Lace up and get your game on because the Tic Tac lineup just got a new teammate. Dr. Pepper Tic Tac. This new double threat puts two of your favorite flavors into one box of mints. And when two iconic flavors come together, the result can only be iconic. Score big. Try Dr. Pepper Tic Tac today.
42:16 Speaker 02 We're here with Joe Kraus, the president of Lime. We've been talking about sort of the business, the difficulty of the competition. So you feel like it's going to shake out? Like it won't, like most things, there are usually winners in the end.
42:27 Speaker 03 If you force me to bet, I would say I think it'll be Lime as a dominant player in Europe with a fragmented competitive landscape of different regional players dominating different countries. And then I think in the U.S., I think it'll continue to be a market share battle between Lime and Burt.
42:44 Speaker 02 And Asia?
42:45 Speaker 03 You know, right now, we're primarily in Australia and New Zealand.
42:48 Speaker 02 Right.
42:49 Speaker 03 We think that there's...
42:49 Speaker 02 We saw you in Australia.
42:50 Speaker 03 We think that there's interesting markets in East Asia. We're much more bearish on Southeast Asia, both in terms of...
42:57 Speaker 02 Well, because you're banging up against...
42:59 Speaker 03 You're banging up against Grab, who's...
43:01 Speaker 02 Who's already been in this space.
43:02 Speaker 03 And a fundamentally uneconomic competitor.
43:05 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
43:05 Speaker 03 Kind of a scorched earth competitor, when we also think that willingness to pay in that market in terms of revenue per trip is more limited. We think that the use case in terms of traffic is very good, but we're more bearish on those markets.
43:19 Speaker 02 And then China?
43:21 Speaker 03 You know, actually, scooters aren't legal in China today.
43:23 Speaker 02 Right.
43:23 Speaker 03 They're classified as a vehicle.
43:25 Speaker 02 But they have all kinds of different low-microability efforts. There's lots of things going on there. So, and also, that market's difficult. But speaking of China, you guys get your stuff made in China.
43:33 Speaker 03 We have a team of 70 people in China that design the vehicle, that source all the components, that basically do all the engineering, and then we work with three assemblers that take that design and create it on an exclusive basis. And so, yeah, our supply chain is in China.
43:51 Speaker 02 So, what, there's a, apparently, there's a trade war going on.
43:54 Speaker 03 I've heard of rumor.
43:55 Speaker 02 Yes.
43:56 Speaker 03 I've heard tell of this trade war.
43:58 Speaker 02 I hereby order you to stop doing business with them.
44:00 Speaker 03 Uh, yes, note taken.
44:02 Speaker 02 No, ignored.
44:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, we pay more for our scooters coming into the United States as a result of the Trump tariff, 25% more, in fact.
44:10 Speaker 02 So, what do you do? What does the company, because that can really hit a startup hard.
44:14 Speaker 03 It can. Obviously, the business gets better if trade war is resolved.
44:20 Speaker 02 Trade peace, it's called.
44:21 Speaker 03 Trade peace is created. But our business is still economical in the United States. We still have many markets where we're making money, even with a 25% higher-priced scooter.
44:30 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. Is there anything to be done? Can you source them elsewhere?
44:33 Speaker 03 You know, I think...
44:35 Speaker 02 What about the United States?
44:36 Speaker 03 You certainly could. It's not clear to me that the total cost of the scooter would still be less than...
44:42 Speaker 02 It was a multimillion-dollar scooter.
44:44 Speaker 03 And the truth is that moving a factory is not an easy thing to do.
44:50 Speaker 02 No.
44:51 Speaker 03 And it's not a short-term commitment. So, I think we might look at other opportunities for assembling in different areas of the world. Probably the most egregious is Brazil. Brazil has a 111% import tariff. That makes that market harder.
45:04 Speaker 02 To bring anything in.
45:06 Speaker 03 To bring anything in.
45:07 Speaker 02 Right.
45:07 Speaker 03 At all. No matter where it comes from.
45:09 Speaker 02 How big are you in South America? You're not, right? You're not in...
45:12 Speaker 03 We have operations in, I would say, seven or eight cities. Bogota, Colombia, in Santiago, Chile, in Rio, in Sao Paulo, and several other markets. Actually, there are really good pockets of markets in there. But I would say it's a more concentrated play in the right cities and in the right places where there's either a lot of tourist traffic or a lot of congestion.
45:38 Speaker 02 Right. And also, these equipments, really important to have different kinds of... You're also making them hardier, right? So that they don't break quite as easily.
45:45 Speaker 03 Yeah. I think the thing that everybody focuses on in the business, rightly so, is how long do your scooters last?
45:50 Speaker 02 Right.
45:50 Speaker 03 Which is a combination of hardware, and it's a combination of how do you operate it? How do you maintain it? How do you collect it? How do you make sure it doesn't get stolen? How do you make sure you don't lose it? How do you make sure you have good mechanics? And that game of inches is basically what allows your... That hardware coupled with great operations is what allows your vehicles to last longer and longer and longer.
46:12 Speaker 02 How long do they last now?
46:13 Speaker 03 We're now in the seven and a half months range.
46:16 Speaker 02 And then what happens to them?
46:17 Speaker 03 They get anything from recycled to broken down into parts to fix other scooters.
46:22 Speaker 02 Right. And they're difficult to find the people who can fix them, right?
46:26 Speaker 03 What we've learned is how to train mechanics and how to spread that knowledge and generate standard operating procedures and get them standardized across now 100-plus markets around the world. So, I mean, as we've been talking about, this is literally a game of details, and that's one of the details that you've got to get right.
46:41 Speaker 02 What is the biggest problem around deployment and stealing and shrinkage, I guess, essentially?
46:47 Speaker 03 You can look on a city for hotspots about where do scooters go to die? And then you can kind of... Anything from contained service areas to making sure that high alert tickets get sent out for people to retrieve scooters that are in areas that are kind of danger zones in terms of being stolen, so...
47:06 Speaker 02 Where do they go when they're stolen?
47:08 Speaker 03 You got me.
47:10 Speaker 02 I'm assuming you have ways to tag them, right? Or to follow them.
47:14 Speaker 03 We certainly have ways to follow them. But at some point, a scooter could be, you know.
47:19 Speaker 02 Disassembled.
47:20 Speaker 03 Disassembled, destroyed, something. I, here's the thing. I think most people think it's a jungle out there. You put your scooters on the street. Everybody's trying to steal them. The reality of the business is far more subtle. There is some theft and vandalism. Don't get me wrong. You see enough Instagram videos of people driving scooters off, you know, off a cliff or doing something with them that is an unintended use. But the reality is that theft and vandalism is a small fraction of what makes the business difficult. What makes the business difficult is when you're managing a fleet of, I don't know, 120,000, 150,000, 200,000, 250,000 vehicles that are on the road simultaneously. Actually managing just that scale is itself the hard part.
48:05 Speaker 03 It's not really the bit that gets stolen, although that's a part of it. It's just the fact that you have so many vehicles.
48:11 Speaker 02 Right.
48:11 Speaker 03 That you're trying to.
48:13 Speaker 02 So many small vehicles.
48:13 Speaker 03 So many small vehicles that you're trying to find, maintain, address, update.
48:19 Speaker 02 That was interesting. I was thinking, what's interesting to me is that Hertz and those people haven't gotten involved in any of this stuff, which I find fascinating.
48:25 Speaker 03 You know what's interesting is I do think that the business.
48:27 Speaker 02 Because they do that.
48:28 Speaker 03 They do. They do fleet management. They are fleet management companies.
48:32 Speaker 02 Right.
48:32 Speaker 03 Fundamentally.
48:33 Speaker 02 Right.
48:34 Speaker 03 I don't know what the scale of the Hertz and Enterprise fleets are, but they've got to be really large.
48:38 Speaker 02 Huge, right, huge. It's the same business, really, in a lot of ways. I'm fascinated they haven't even touched.
48:42 Speaker 03 The big difference, I would say, is cars are.
48:45 Speaker 02 Harder to lose.
48:46 Speaker 03 Not only that, but the car has been around for over 100 years. And scooters are like three years old.
48:52 Speaker 02 Right. Well, they're not. People rode them for years, but just not in this fashion.
48:55 Speaker 03 That's true. That is true. There's like pictures of scooter races from 1900.
48:58 Speaker 02 So let's get into that issue, and then I want to talk about the company and its funding and stuff. To finish up, safety is probably your number one problem. That's the thing I worry about the most. And obviously, I've tried out your helmets, and you're designing helmets with Bern, you're doing all kinds of things. But the fact of the matter is, in all these devices, if you put a helmet, they put them on the scooter, you worry about people's heads. Like, do you want to.
49:19 Speaker 03 Depends on the market. They don't worry about that in Australia for some reason.
49:22 Speaker 02 Okay.
49:22 Speaker 03 But they do in the United States.
49:23 Speaker 02 People don't want to share helmets, people here. I was just with a micro mobility lawyer, and she was talking about these things that they blow up on your neck.
49:30 Speaker 03 I've seen that.
49:31 Speaker 02 They were, they were loving those. They were fascinated with those because essentially, it's like a car safety.
49:36 Speaker 03 It's like an airbag for your head.
49:37 Speaker 02 Airbag for your head. I was like, come on. And then I was like, and then I looked into it and it's actually quite fascinating all the time. There's all kinds of things, but getting people to wear helmets. And I got caught on a video. I wear helmets all the time on these things, except once, when my boss actually got a picture of me at South by Southwest.
49:52 Speaker 03 I think it was in Austin, Texas.
49:53 Speaker 02 Austin, Texas. And he thought I was on the highway. I was not on the highway riding.
49:55 Speaker 03 You were on an underpass, doing kind of a U-turn.
49:58 Speaker 02 Going under, yes. And I was going to dinner with him. And he somehow got behind me and took a video. And everyone gave me a hard time, justifiably. I shouldn't have done it. I just was late. And I like, I love scooters. As you know, I'm a big scooter fan. But I do worry about, you know, watching people drunk on them, watching people ride them, like, people ride them, like, double and triple. I was in, where was I? Somewhere I was, where there were three or four people on a scooter.
50:20 Speaker 03 Tandem riding.
50:21 Speaker 02 Tandem riding. And there was a guy with a kid riding at his feet, which I was like, I nearly, like, I couldn't stop him. Like, I was like, what are you doing? So it was interesting. The whole safety thing is, I think, one of your biggest liabilities. The second is insurance liability of people who hurt people on scooters and who get hurt on scooters. Because apparently, I just gave up my car insurance because I don't have a car anymore, because I'm using scooters, but I don't have insurance. So how do you deal with that? Like, I'm not, is it your homeowner's insurance? Is it your, it's a really interesting, I'm looking into it right now.
50:51 Speaker 03 Yeah. So, let's talk about safety. Safety, as you rightly point out, is something that we spend a lot of time thinking about, is really important. It's important to our riders, it's important to us as a business. I'll start with what's our objective? Our objective is to make this as safe as bicycles or safer. Like, we think that's a reasonable target.
51:09 Speaker 02 Right.
51:10 Speaker 03 Bicycles go about the same speed as a scooter. In fact, bicycles can go faster. People understand, basically, the risks associated with being on a bike.
51:17 Speaker 02 Yes. A lot of them.
51:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, a lot of them.
51:19 Speaker 02 Right.
51:20 Speaker 03 So we do several things as it relates to safety, but that's our objective. The first is, we try to teach people how to ride. Like, the Centers for Disease Control looked at, when do accidents happen on a scooter? Thirty percent of the accidents, about a third, happen on your first ride.
51:34 Speaker 02 Right.
51:35 Speaker 03 So we run these things called First Ride Academies, that basically teach people how to ride. I think it's strange that the industry can make an assumption that people just know how to ride these things. It's a brand-new vehicle.
51:45 Speaker 02 Right.
51:46 Speaker 03 A lot of people don't know how to ride it.
51:47 Speaker 02 Right, right.
51:48 Speaker 03 And so, teaching people how to ride and safe riding techniques, which is part of why we launched a feature called Group Ride. So, other than the United States, You can teach me how to ride a scooter. You can unlock my scooter for me on your account. You can unlock several scooters. And we can go on a group ride. And we believe that that increases safety because you're teaching me and reducing that risk on that first ride.
52:09 Speaker 02 Right.
52:10 Speaker 03 60% of rides, accidents happen in the first nine rides. Again, we think it's about people learning how to ride this vehicle. So we invest in these first ride academies. Yeah, exactly. The next is, how do we deal with drunk riding? In many markets, on Friday and Saturday nights, after I think it's nine or 10 o'clock, we have a challenge. That's basically an interstitial that makes you enter some information. As a challenge, if you can't complete it, maybe you shouldn't be riding a scooter.
52:38 Speaker 02 It won't unlock it.
52:39 Speaker 03 That's right. I can't remember precisely all the details, but yes, it's a challenge to say, do this and you can unlock the scooter. We've given away, I think it's on the order of a quarter million helmets as another piece of how to increase safety by giving people helmets because many, many, many people who want to ride scooters don't have helmets. And we think that the most effective way to do safety is bike lanes. The reality is that most, there's a series of injuries that can happen when you alone are on the scooter. Maybe you get a pothole.
53:10 Speaker 02 Yeah.
53:11 Speaker 03 But the amount of energy you have there is 15 miles an hour-ish.
53:15 Speaker 02 Some are governed, right? Some scooters, the scooters in Austin are much faster than the scooters in DC are like, blocking is faster in DC.
53:22 Speaker 03 Correct. Certain cities implement certain...
53:23 Speaker 02 But you have like seven miles in it. What is it?
53:25 Speaker 03 I don't know specifically anymore.
53:27 Speaker 02 It's real slow.
53:28 Speaker 03 It's real slow.
53:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
53:29 Speaker 03 It's probably 15 in one and 19 in another, something like that, or 13.
53:33 Speaker 02 Austin is like scary. I was like, slow down scooters. It was kind of funny.
53:36 Speaker 03 But the real long-term safety is you separate high-speed traffic, which is cars, from mid-speed traffic, which is bikes and scooters, from slow-speed traffic, which is pedestrians. And you see that in Europe. When they invest in that kind of infrastructure, and I would point to the Netherlands as the perfect example. The highest bike ridership on the planet and some of the lowest helmet-wearing on the planet and the least number of injuries because they have better infrastructure. I'm not advocating not wearing a helmet. We always advocate wearing a helmet, but I'm simply saying that the right long-term...
54:07 Speaker 02 The bike lanes are critical.
54:08 Speaker 03 Bike lanes are critical.
54:09 Speaker 02 I'm thrilled in San Francisco riding scooters because of bike lanes.
54:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's more and more and more of them.
54:13 Speaker 02 Right, it's really interesting.
54:15 Speaker 03 And I take a scooter every day from the Caltrain station. That Uber ride is 20 minutes to my office. My scooter ride is seven minutes. I'm saving like four days a year.
54:24 Speaker 02 So when you think about the idea of safety, you're not going to avoid some injury. But the idea of bike lanes, you also run into people who are riding bikes and there's a very strong constituency for that, that you're in these bike lanes with motorized vehicles.
54:38 Speaker 03 There's a lot of e-bikes in those lanes now too, to be honest. We actually think we're very much long-term aligned with the biking advocacy groups because we want the same thing. More bike lanes.
54:50 Speaker 02 No cars.
54:51 Speaker 03 We want fewer cars, more bike lanes, more pedestrian-friendly cities with less congestion and more alternatives.
54:57 Speaker 02 Do you imagine there being no cars in cities? There's all these...
54:59 Speaker 03 I mean, you see it in Oslo. There's no cars in the center of Oslo. Many of those European cities are far more serious about car-free zones, congestion pricing, and making their sustainability goals.
55:09 Speaker 02 New York has just pushed a congestion pricing in Midtown.
55:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, I know, I saw the congestion pricing.
55:12 Speaker 02 Which is really controversial. On the west side, they're making bike lanes, which the rich people on the west side or unsettled park west are pissed about. But it seems like it's inevitable that bike lanes are going to...
55:22 Speaker 03 I think it's a matter of when...
55:23 Speaker 02 I think cars take up 75% of the street space. They need to go down to 50, if not less.
55:28 Speaker 03 Look, I think the reality is cars are all around us, but we don't see them anymore. We're totally car-blind.
55:34 Speaker 02 Oh, I see.
55:35 Speaker 03 The amount of space we take for parking places, the amount of space we take for the roads, parking structures. I'm amazed but not surprised that somebody sees one scooter tipped over on the sidewalk and that's a five-alarm fire and they don't see...
55:48 Speaker 02 There's a lot of them, Joe, come on. And some, Paris was insane. I was walking over, it was like dead bodies, like someone shot a scooter family.
55:55 Speaker 03 There is a 100% we gotta train people on how to do good parking, which in Paris now, by the way, you can't park on the sidewalk anymore, you have to be on the street.
56:03 Speaker 02 Right.
56:04 Speaker 03 And so I think there's ways to integrate these, and that's a separate point from the fact that I think we're just car-blind because nobody, very few people that are alive today ever knew a world without cars from the moment you opened your eyes.
56:14 Speaker 02 So what about insurance? That's another thing.
56:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, we certainly offer insurance and it's an important part of the business. I think that one of the things to consider is the nature of... Well, so what specifically do you want to know about insurance?
56:29 Speaker 02 Well, so I don't have car insurance anymore. So if I hit someone on a scooter, I was like, who... How am I covered? I'll send you the law blog.
56:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, we have an insurance policy that covers riders as they ride.
56:39 Speaker 02 Right.
56:39 Speaker 03 And...
56:40 Speaker 02 How will people, when we get in a micro mobility world, think of insurance? Like, it's a really interesting question because you're often covered by car insurance for a lot of mobility.
56:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, in this case Lime has, again, an insurance policy that we cover. I think one of the parts about insurance that's interesting to consider here, relative to other modalities, is that the speeds are lower. And so the... For an insurance company, again, this is not speaking from the point of view of the rider, from an insurance company, you're carrying less energy, which means that the range of injuries is actually different.
57:14 Speaker 02 Got it. But there's one injury or even a death on a scooter. It's written about in the media and other places, just like with self-driving, just like with a lot of things.
57:21 Speaker 03 That's right.
57:22 Speaker 02 Because people are new to it.
57:23 Speaker 03 And again, thus far, all of those deaths have sadly involved contact with a car.
57:28 Speaker 02 Right, right, absolutely. All right, so let's talk a little bit about the company. How much funding have you guys... How much did you give?
57:33 Speaker 03 We have raised 777 million to date.
57:37 Speaker 02 That's a lot of money. That's a lot of simoleons.
57:38 Speaker 03 That is correct. There's a lot of simoleons.
57:39 Speaker 02 What... And the goal is to what? Go public?
57:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, this... I absolutely believe Lime is going to be a public company and a standalone company. We're... That is the path that we're on.
57:52 Speaker 02 And profitability, you know, we've had experience with Uber and Lyft, which, right now, they're down 20, 30% in... On Wall Street, which has finally sort of gone, no. This is a financially problematic situation for us.
58:05 Speaker 03 I actually think that the scooter companies and Lime, the foremost among them, will be much more capital efficient than the ride-sharing companies, despite the fact that we have to buy scooters. Primary reasons is that, several fold. One is... It costs a lot less
58:23 Speaker 02 No driver.
58:23 Speaker 03 To buy a scooter.
58:24 Speaker 02 As Travis like to say, the problem is the driver in the front seat. Remember Travis Kalanick?
58:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, I remember that statement.
58:31 Speaker 02 The problem is the driver in the front seat. When get rid of him, it's a great business. So you have gotten rid of the driver in the front seat.
58:38 Speaker 03 The driver, the rider is the driver.
58:40 Speaker 02 Right.
58:40 Speaker 03 In this case, we simply buy the scooter.
58:41 Speaker 02 Right.
58:41 Speaker 03 And I know the fixed price of the scooter in terms of pay for it. And I know how long it lasts as I get better at it. And I'm not having to constantly subsidize that side of the business. The second piece is Wall Street's pressure on Lyft and Uber for earnings has made for just a better environment in terms of how all the players are looking at the business.
59:06 Speaker 02 What they can do.
59:06 Speaker 03 And what they can do. Because we're tapping into those same capital markets. And I think that's really healthy.
59:13 Speaker 02 So going public is the thing, not being owned by a giant car company or a Google or that kind of thing. Because you could see Amazon getting into this. You could see all kinds of companies.
59:22 Speaker 03 Again, with the caveat that you can never predict the future, my view is we absolutely have both the growth potential, market size, and profit potential to be a standalone public company.
59:35 Speaker 02 And you came in, the CEO is now?
59:39 Speaker 03 Brad Baugh.
59:39 Speaker 02 Brad Baugh.
59:40 Speaker 03 Founder and CEO.
59:41 Speaker 02 Right, there were two co-founders.
59:42 Speaker 03 There were.
59:43 Speaker 02 And you were brought in, why? Many people are talking that you were brought in to take over from them.
59:47 Speaker 03 No.
59:48 Speaker 02 You know, adult in the room. It's happened. It happened in Facebook. It happens in lots of companies.
59:52 Speaker 03 I think my view is-
59:53 Speaker 02 It happened in yours, George Bell. Hello.
59:55 Speaker 03 That is true.
59:55 Speaker 02 What happened to him?
59:56 Speaker 03 That is true. I hired, we all hired George Bell to run Excite.
1:00:00 Speaker 02 George Bell.
1:00:00 Speaker 03 I love George Bell.
1:00:01 Speaker 02 How is George Bell?
1:00:02 Speaker 03 He's great.
1:00:03 Speaker 02 The only CEO is to call me to complain about every single article I wrote in the Wall Street Journal.
1:00:07 Speaker 03 You're welcome.
1:00:08 Speaker 02 No problem. Anyway, but there's been brought in. Have you been brought in for that?
1:00:12 Speaker 03 My view is all startups are like relay races, right? So you have one group of people that are- Really focused at the beginning on like market discovery. What is this thing and how do we build a supply chain? And what's the business? I was really brought in on the how do we scale up the precision in our operations as we move from a focus of just about growth to we got to make money out of this business. So my charter has really been about how do you scale global operations in a way that drives towards profit, not in a way that just is about getting incremental revenue.
1:00:48 Speaker 02 Okay.
1:00:49 Speaker 03 And that's what my focus has been.
1:00:50 Speaker 02 Where is that pressure coming from? Is it from the investors or is it just a different environment right now?
1:00:55 Speaker 03 I would say it's a different environment.
1:00:57 Speaker 02 Because there's money everywhere. There's enough ratholes to shove the money.
1:00:59 Speaker 03 The thing I say all the time to the companies, it's not about offering a world changing service. It's about how do you, the way to make a world changing service is to make a world changing business because if you can make a great business, then your service lasts forever and it's not about when the money runs out, the service is gone. So I would say if you want to make the maximum impact, you got to make a great business that's durable and sustainable.
1:01:24 Speaker 02 So you're not here to kick the founders out, that kind of environment?
1:01:27 Speaker 03 No, my general view here is, one, I'm a big believer in founder led companies because I think the data certainly suggests that founder led companies are better in terms of growth, motivation, mission. And then the second is Brad is really well qualified on being cross border. He was born in China, has all those relationships, has seen OFO and Moebike and the mistakes of those. As we look at so many of these trends actually start in China now and then get brought to the West in a different mode, having that cross border expertise is incredibly complimentary, at least to the skills that I bring. Like I don't have any of that.
1:02:06 Speaker 02 So what do you as a pair or as a group find then the most challenging thing? What are you most scared of? Like it's interesting, you just said China is where innovation starts. I was just arguing with someone, I was interviewing someone, they're like, you're too nice, China's coming. I'm like, China is where innovation is starting now, even if it's government controlled innovation. Where do you imagine your biggest, of all the different things we talked about or maybe one I didn't mention, what do you think, what are you worried most about?
1:02:31 Speaker 03 You know, I'm super focused on the operational details of the business. The main things that I think about are how do we continue to be good operators in cities all around the world? Scooters are clearly so useful to people who ride them, but most people aren't yet riding them, and it's easy to forget that 99% of the world never, or more, has never ridden one of these things. Being good actors in these cities, paying close attention to the way we handle parking and the way we handle people not riding on sidewalks, and educating users on good ridership is key to making this market big.
1:03:14 Speaker 03 And how do I get more and more people on these vehicles? Because my general experience has been, once you've ridden one-
1:03:20 Speaker 02 Yep, I would agree with you.
1:03:21 Speaker 03 You understand. And when you see it from afar, you're like, well, this is a bunch of tourists and kids making noise on a scooter.
1:03:29 Speaker 02 Like a Segway.
1:03:30 Speaker 03 Yeah. But you ride it and you realize, oh my God, I can make that coffee with a friend that I wouldn't have been able to make, I can get to work on commute twice as fast as I could via a car, and you kind of can make the leap viscerally to, cities can be better. Actually, there's a different way. And actually, in my opinion, the biggest barrier to Lime's success and the industry's success has nothing to do with regulation or supply chain. It's a lack of imagination, and this is just a human characteristic. It's a lack of imagination that the future can be any different than the past. And getting people onto a scooter for the first time tends to unlock that imagination.
1:04:09 Speaker 02 Well, you also have to get a range of people, not just millennials zipping around.
1:04:13 Speaker 03 100%.
1:04:14 Speaker 02 You know, I got a whole group of old guys on them. I shouldn't have done that, but I did. I was at a dinner in Austin. I was heading out of the, I think I talked about this, out of the hotel and- They were looking around for their Uber app and I'm like, I'm getting on this. There were a million scooters in Austin. There's so many available at any one time. And I got on when I'm taking a scooter and I had my helmet with me actually at this one and they didn't. They didn't. They should have, but they didn't. And they took them and I have to say it was the most enjoyable dinner with a pack of white guys. You know, they were like these old business types and they got on, they were like children. They were like teenagers. It was interesting. It was an interesting mood elevator in a weird way.
1:04:52 Speaker 03 And so...
1:04:53 Speaker 02 But I wouldn't let them on them afterwards because they drank and it was really interesting. I was like, you're not getting on a scooter.
1:04:58 Speaker 03 But that thing you're tapping into, like, one of the things that I love about the job is, how many products make people smile? Like, literally, there was a joy.
1:05:06 Speaker 02 Oreos.
1:05:07 Speaker 03 Okay, fair enough. How many tech products make people smile?
1:05:11 Speaker 02 Airpods.
1:05:11 Speaker 03 Okay.
1:05:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, you're right. Not very many. Not very many.
1:05:13 Speaker 03 And literally, there's a childlike element to it. And I know that sounds hokey, but you saw it with those folks.
1:05:18 Speaker 02 No, I get it. I get it. I just think that there's too many of them and it obscures what is a really interesting trend, which is micro mobility versus these crazy valuations and the safety issues and the execution issues. And then when they're piled all around, it's visually chaotic. I think that's really what happened.
1:05:34 Speaker 03 And I think those are the easy things to talk about, truthfully.
1:05:36 Speaker 02 Sure. But that's what you're gonna have to do. You still have to contend with them.
1:05:38 Speaker 03 But we gotta deal with it. Of course, we have to deal with them.
1:05:40 Speaker 02 You know what I mean? Like, it's just the same thing. Anyway, this is fascinating, Joe. I will have you back to talk more. I am a scooter fan. I'm sorry to say, but I am. I love them. And I do think that all these kind of micro mobility businesses are really interesting going forward. And to my listeners in the Midwest, you can still drive your friggin' car, just your truck, or whatever you want to drive, your SUV, go right ahead. But there is a significant trend in this area. I think we can, you can see it happening in real time.
1:06:06 Speaker 03 You can feel it.
1:06:07 Speaker 02 Anyway, thank you for coming on the show, Joe.
1:06:09 Speaker 03 Thanks, Kara.
1:06:09 Speaker 02 You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Eric Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. Joe, where can people find you online? At Lime?
1:06:20 Speaker 03 It's At Lime.
1:06:20 Speaker 02 Is it? At Lime. And then you, do you, you're not very online-ish. Where does, anyway, At Lime.
1:06:25 Speaker 03 I'm hiding.
1:06:26 Speaker 02 You're hiding.
1:06:26 Speaker 03 I'm a lurker.
1:06:27 Speaker 02 If, really, don't say that in today's environment.
1:06:29 Speaker 03 That's true.
1:06:30 Speaker 02 If you like this episode, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robey. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
1:06:56 Speaker 00 ...
Previous Recode Decode: Gro Intelligence CEO Sara Menker Next Recode Decode: Psychologist Jennifer Eberhardt Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated