Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: FEC Chair Ellen Weintraub About this episode Federal Election Commission Chair Ellen Weintraub talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about how the FEC works, how it tries to defend elections from foreign influence, and why the Commission is currently immobilized by a lack of "quorum" — in other words, it doesn't have enough members to launch or conclude any investigations. Weintraub talks about pending legislation to make advertising and campaign contributions more transparent, and explains how the FEC's current paralysis may undermine the cybersecurity of the 2020 presidential campaign. Plus: How she pushed back on President Trump's evidence-free claims about voter fraud in New Hampshire.
Featuring:
Ellen Weintraub (@EllenLWeintraub), chair of the Federal Election Commission
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Pivot, Kara’s podcast with NYU Professor Scott Galloway that offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
... But enough about us
We are conducting an audience survey to better serve you. It takes no more than five minutes, and it really helps out the show. Please take our survey here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 12,274 words · 9 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Growing teams need a corporate card built for more, something that doesn't sacrifice speed for control. Introducing the American Express Corporate Cash Back Card. Get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, advanced spending controls, and real-time visibility, plus intelligent expense management. Get started at go.amex slash amexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:31 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio, or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:48 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:54 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who's pining for simpler times, like when the number-one threat to our elections was confused people in Florida. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Ellen Weintraub, the chair of the Federal Election Commission. She's been a commissioner since 2002 and now is in her third year of chairing the group, which is an independent regulatory agency that enforces campaign finance law. Chair Weintraub, welcome to Recode Decode. Thank you, Kara. It's great to be here. So I met you because you were on, first of all, I noticed a lot of things you're saying, which, because they're sensible. And when I watch cable television, I try hard not to watch cable television. But you and I were on CNBC recently talking about some of the stuff
1:39 Speaker 02 that President Trump was tweeting about, about the elections. And so I want to get to that in a little bit. But I want to sort of get your, what the FEC does and what you think your role is and how you got there.
1:53 Speaker 03 Okay, so the FEC was set up to follow the money after Watergate. We take in all of the information from the candidates and the party committees and political groups.
2:04 Speaker 02 And these filings they have to make.
2:05 Speaker 03 Yes, yes, they are required to file with us, they're required to register, they're required to file regular reports with us so that everyone in America can see who is supporting which candidate and what they're spending their money on. And so we collect all of this information, we put it up on the web, and reporters and analysts, scholars all take a lot of look and do deep dives and do great analysis of it and get it out to the American people.
2:31 Speaker 02 And the format you have is to, they have to fill out the way you have it formatted, correct?
2:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's a form, they can fill it out, we have software, they can fill it out online, and then most forms are filed electronically and that makes it really easy for us to put it up on the web.
2:46 Speaker 02 So, explain to me, and you're funded by, what does independent mean?
2:50 Speaker 03 We're an independent agency, we're not part of the administration, we're not part of the legislature either, or the judiciary certainly, so we are our own thing, we get an appropriation from Congress and we use that money to do our job.
3:04 Speaker 02 And how much money do you get from Congress?
3:07 Speaker 03 Oh, that's a good question. It varies, obviously, and it depends on how much they're willing to give us, but I think the last budget was in the high 70s.
3:16 Speaker 02 70 million dollars.
3:17 Speaker 03 Yes.
3:18 Speaker 02 And so this funds the paperwork and the monitoring, and when you talk about monitoring, what do you mean that you do? You just make it available, you force them to file?
3:28 Speaker 03 Well, it's a little bit more than that. So, there are legal requirements that they file certain information with us, we have analysts who review the forms, and then we'll get back to committees if they think that there's something missing or something wrong. They send out what we call requests for additional information, that's all public, and then people will file amendments or correct the record however it needs to be corrected. We also have auditors who audit committees that seem to be not doing their job properly, so we need to take a deeper dive into those committees. And we have an enforcement function, anybody can file a complaint with the FEC and our lawyers will look at it and make a recommendation to the commission.
4:12 Speaker 03 And we will decide whether to open an investigation, whether there is sanction, warranted, whether somebody has violated the law, or they haven't.
4:19 Speaker 02 All right, I've been asking, for example, of something like that, what you've been forced on, but when they, then they do these, who has to file with you? Everyone who has an election in the United States, or what's the requirement?
4:28 Speaker 03 Federal candidates. This is all at the federal level. So candidates for the House, for the Senate, and for the presidency.
4:34 Speaker 02 Right.
4:35 Speaker 03 Have to register with the FEC and file regular reports with us. Also, the political party committees, also PACs.
4:42 Speaker 02 The state party committees.
4:43 Speaker 03 Yes, state, well, if they're doing federal activity, yes. State party committees and the national party committees. The congressional committee, the senate committee, the national committee.
4:51 Speaker 02 Right.
4:52 Speaker 03 Convention committees.
4:53 Speaker 02 And the PACs.
4:54 Speaker 03 And the PACs, including the super PACs.
4:57 Speaker 02 So many PACs.
4:57 Speaker 03 So many PACs.
4:58 Speaker 02 Yeah. How many PACs are there, another thing?
4:59 Speaker 03 Oh, thousands.
5:00 Speaker 02 Thousands of PACs, and they all have to, if they're involved in federal election, not local elections?
5:04 Speaker 03 Right. They have to file with us. And again, what they take in and what they spend, itemized down to $200 contributions.
5:13 Speaker 02 And who gives them the money, too?
5:15 Speaker 03 Yes. And who gives them? Who, the employers of those people, their occupations, there's the list of information.
5:22 Speaker 02 So the whole concept after Watergate was that we need transparency into the money, where the money's flowing, even though the Supreme Court allowed, Citizens United allowed so much more funding to happen, you all are trying to be there to say, here's what's actually happening.
5:37 Speaker 03 Yes. Well, the original law that was passed back in the 70s had both contribution limits and spending limits, in addition to these disclosure requirements. The Supreme Court, back in the 70s, in the Buckley decision, struck down the spending limits. They said that you can express your First Amendment right to show which candidate you're supporting with a limited contribution, but if you are going to limit spending, then you're limiting the amount of money that they can use to get their message out.
6:07 Speaker 02 Right.
6:07 Speaker 03 And that is ultimately a limit on free speech, according to the Supreme Court.
6:11 Speaker 02 Right. Transparency is what your goal is.
6:13 Speaker 03 That is our primary mission.
6:14 Speaker 02 Primary mission. And then, the enforcement part, give me an example of, I'm trying to educate people on what you all do, because people think that you're, you're supposed to catch the Russians, that's why.
6:22 Speaker 03 Well, um.
6:23 Speaker 02 Well, you, we'll get to that. We'll get to your catching the Russians, but then, your enforcement, for example.
6:27 Speaker 03 Okay, so I'll give you an example where we caught the Chinese instead of the Russians. One of the bigger cases that we've had in recent years, we resolved, I think, earlier this year.
6:39 Speaker 03 Involved a $1.3 million contribution that was funneled from a Chinese-owned subsidiary with the encouragement of the Chinese board members down to their US subsidiary to make a $1.3 million contribution to a super PAC that was supporting Jeb Bush in the, back in the 2016 primaries. And it's illegal to take money from foreign sources. So this was based, actually, on a very good bit of investigative reporting. So we had a lot of work done for us by reporters. And it was presented by a nonprofit organization here in DC, which filed a complaint based
7:24 Speaker 03 on the reporting. And the information was, was pretty compelling. So we did our own investigation after that and ultimately settled the case for close to $1 million in penalties.
7:35 Speaker 02 And the money had to go back?
7:38 Speaker 03 Well, the money was mostly spent.
7:40 Speaker 02 Spent, spent at that point. So they couldn't, but they find, cost them the amount of money. So the idea is trying to keep, sort of, keep one foreign influence. Talk about that idea of foreign influence within US elections. We are not supposed to collect anything from foreign countries seeking to create either discord or create a, create, move it to one way or the other?
8:00 Speaker 03 It is illegal to solicit, accept, or receive anything of value from a foreign national.
8:07 Speaker 02 Anything of value.
8:08 Speaker 03 Anything of value from a foreign national in connection with a US election. And that is one area where we have jurisdiction over state and local elections as well as federal elections.
8:17 Speaker 02 And, and meaning, and what are the enforcement for that? It's fines or?
8:23 Speaker 03 Yes. As I just described, it would be an investigation, fines, we don't send people to jail. If it's a knowing and willful violation, we can refer it to the Justice Department and they can send people to jail.
8:33 Speaker 02 Right, absolutely. And how many commish people work for you? Aren't people get a sense of how small a budget you have and also how few people you have working for you?
8:40 Speaker 03 There are about 315 people working for the agency right now. We have lawyers, analysts, auditors, we have IT people who keep our website up and running. The commissioners each have small staffs of their own, just a couple of people.
8:55 Speaker 02 And how many commissioners are there?
8:57 Speaker 03 Well, that's a good question. That's a good question. I'm trying to get, I'm getting into it. How many are there supposed to have? There are supposed to be six, no more than three of any one political party. Okay, so typically it's three and three. That's the way it's supposed to be, and that's the way it generally has been. Right. Uh, over time. Uh, once in a while, we'll get down to five, but usually it's not lower than five, except that recently, we had one commissioner who left a couple of years ago, and another one who left about a year and a half ago, and those slots were not filled. And then, at the end of August, one of my colleagues announced that he was resigning at the end of the week, and, um, that brought us down to three. There are four. The problem is... And then there were three. And then there were three.
9:41 Speaker 03 One D, one R, one I. Ah. At least that's fair, but go ahead. Maybe. Yeah, but you can't meet. But, well, we kind of can, but we can't do anything important if we do. So, four is a quorum, and it was designed to ensure that, uh, most decisions have to be made with four votes, so that any decision would be bipartisan by definition. If no more than three can be of one political party, and it takes four votes to get anything done, it's gotta be a bipartisan decision. And that, and that's a, that can be a good thing. It was put in as a protection to make sure that one side couldn't beat up the other with the campaign finance apparatus and find their political opponents. It had to be a bipartisan decision that the law had been violated.
10:24 Speaker 03 So, with three, we cannot make any decisions about enforcement, we can't issue advisory opinions, we can't write new regulations. We can continue doing the enforcement work that was pre-authorized. So, any investigation that had four votes behind it before we lost the quorum, those investigations are ongoing. But if new complaints are filed now, we cannot launch any new investigations and we not, we can't conclude any investigations.
10:54 Speaker 02 You can't conclude the ones that were existing before.
10:56 Speaker 03 Right, right.
10:57 Speaker 02 So.
10:57 Speaker 03 Our lawyers can finish what they're doing.
10:59 Speaker 02 Right.
10:59 Speaker 03 Write up a report, present it to the commission, but the commission can't vote on it.
11:03 Speaker 02 And can those be public? No, not until you vote on it.
11:05 Speaker 03 No, they won't be, they won't, they don't get to be public until the entire matter is concluded.
11:09 Speaker 02 All right.
11:10 Speaker 03 And it can't be concluded without four votes.
11:11 Speaker 02 All right, so I'm trying to do this in the most journalistic way I can, but we're coming into an election, the 2020 presidential, very key elections coming into it next November.
11:21 Speaker 03 Every election is key.
11:22 Speaker 02 I know that, I understand that, we're coming, a big one, it's a big president, all of them are at once. What the fuck? Ellen, why? Explain. That was, that was my, I went to Columbia Journalism School and they teach us how to ask questions like that. What? That's my question.
11:40 Speaker 03 Okay, so, this is not good.
11:42 Speaker 02 No, thank you.
11:44 Speaker 03 This is, it's all.
11:45 Speaker 02 Let's put an underline under that.
11:47 Speaker 03 Very not good.
11:48 Speaker 02 Okay.
11:49 Speaker 03 Also, completely out of my control, the way commissioners get nominated is the president has to nominate and the senate has to confirm. And traditionally, the president nominates, chooses the people of his or her own party and the senate leaders in the opposition party will recommend the folks they would like to have nominated on the president's side. And the president generally.
12:13 Speaker 02 Just sends them through.
12:14 Speaker 03 Yes, generally, although there have been instances where the president refused to take the suggestion and they had to come back with more names. So there's been one nominee pending for about two years now, a Republican nominee, and we are waiting to see what will happen next.
12:34 Speaker 02 So what will happen next? What do you, what's it pending for two years? What, what is that?
12:38 Speaker 03 Well, the nomination was made, the president nominated a Republican lawyer to fill one of the seats a couple of years ago, and there were never any hearings, and that person is still, I think he's living in Texas.
12:52 Speaker 02 Okay.
12:53 Speaker 03 Waiting. And there are rumors of a potential Democratic nominee, but that the nomination has not been made yet.
13:03 Speaker 02 So why?
13:05 Speaker 03 Oh, that is a question.
13:06 Speaker 02 Well, come on. You call people. I understand that. But don't you call people and get on your horns since you're not doing anything else and go, "Hey."
13:12 Speaker 03 Oh, I am very busy.
13:13 Speaker 02 No, I'm teasing you. But really, what can you do? You can't do anything? You call up Chuck Schumer and say, "Dude, what's up?"
13:20 Speaker 03 I have stated publicly and emphatically that I believe that we should have a full complement of six commissioners and that nominations should be made and that Senate should hold hearings and confirm nominees if appropriate.
13:33 Speaker 02 Has this ever happened before?
13:34 Speaker 03 Yes, actually it has.
13:36 Speaker 02 All right, tell me. Give me some historical context. I'm horrified.
13:39 Speaker 03 In 2007, this was back in the day when we had recess appointees. So, back in 2007, we had two commissioners who had been confirmed and three commissioners who were sitting in recess appointments, awaiting confirmation. Now, they're allowed to serve for a certain period of time, a limited period of time, while they are awaiting their confirmation. But one of those nominees, one of those three, was toxic and could not get confirmed. And usually, these things just kind of go through because there's at least one from one side and one from the other side. And everybody agrees to accept the other guy because they want their own guy.
14:16 Speaker 02 Right.
14:16 Speaker 03 Or woman. I mean, guy in the completely non-sexist sense. But that time, one of the nominees could not get confirmed.
14:24 Speaker 02 Right.
14:25 Speaker 03 And then each side was waiting for the other side to blink, thinking, "Well, okay, we're going to just hold on to our nominee and eventually you on the other side will have to accept that person and confirm them because you want your nominees to get confirmed." And the other side thought, "No, no. You're going to have to pull your guy because he's unacceptable to us." And so, they played this game of chicken and it went down to the wire. And then, December 31st rolled around and their recess appointments expired and they had to leave. And then, we were down to two commissioners.
14:55 Speaker 02 Wow.
14:56 Speaker 03 And that situation went on for about six months. And then that was in 2008. Mm-hmm. So it was an election year. Right. And John McCain at that point was, this was in the quaint old days when people still got public funding, at least some people still did. John McCain wanted to get some public funding and we couldn't authorize it because there were only two of us. Right. And our lawyers said, nope, takes four votes to authorize the funding to be released. So that created some real pressure. I see. Because now somebody wanted money and we couldn't give it to them. So no presidential candidate can get public funding until this is done? That is true, but unlikely to have much of an impact this time. Yeah.
15:40 Speaker 03 Since so few candidates are still taking public funding at this point. Right, right. Explain public funding. People can get, people who don't want to accept PAC money or whatever. There's a matching grant system for the primaries and a grant that can be made for the general election from the period between the convention and the election. Really since 2000, the system has been declining and at this point. Because they don't want, there's strictures on that. Yeah, the public funding system comes with spending limits. If you accept money from the public, you can, from the public funds, then you have to accept the spending limits and the Supreme Court has upheld that. It's the only way that spending limits have been upheld, only when they're tied to. A campaign.
16:24 Speaker 03 A goodie that you get from the federal government. They can put strings on it. But those spending limits haven't really kept pace with the way campaigns have been running and how much money people can raise and spend in this day and age. They aren't taking public funding. Right, so the candidates, serious candidates are not taking public funding. Taking public funding. Because they can raise so much more money if they don't take the public funding and then they've got more money to spend. And they can spend whatever they want. So really, pretty much, you, you can only collect this information. So the information and data part is intact? Yes. That's run pretty much at the staff level. Fortunately, we have a, as I said, we've got about 315 terrific staff people who continue to come to work every day.
17:08 Speaker 03 And yes, we do have the lights on and they're doing their jobs. And one of their jobs is to make sure that we get this information and we put it up on the web and it's available to the public. And that is really the core of our mission.
17:20 Speaker 02 Right.
17:20 Speaker 03 It's really important that people have access to that information.
17:23 Speaker 02 But the analysis of it. You can still do the analysis of it.
17:26 Speaker 03 Yes, we can do the analysis.
17:26 Speaker 02 But you can't take action if there's a problem.
17:29 Speaker 03 Right.
17:31 Speaker 02 So people could behave any way they want. And can you backdo that?
17:35 Speaker 03 Yes, yes. It's a five-year statute of limitations. So if somebody violates the law this year, and I would recommend that they not, somebody's going to file a complaint. We will, our lawyers will look at it. It will be sitting there waiting for commissioners. And sooner or later, they're going to appoint commissioners.
17:51 Speaker 02 Right.
17:51 Speaker 03 It's not, the five years.
17:52 Speaker 02 Are they?
17:53 Speaker 03 Yes.
17:53 Speaker 02 Are they, Alan?
17:53 Speaker 03 I believe they are.
17:54 Speaker 02 Why is that?
17:55 Speaker 03 Because I am a hopeful and optimistic person.
17:57 Speaker 02 All right. But so you can't do anything yourself except be chairman? Okay. So this is astonishing.
18:03 Speaker 03 I can ask, but I cannot require.
18:05 Speaker 02 Do you have any conclusions of what that says about what's happening in Washington? No, I think I have a conclusion that they just can't, this is an important function of democracy, to have transparency and money giving to campaigns.
18:17 Speaker 03 I, well, like I said, not a lot of campaigns are taking the public funds, but I do think the transparency function and the enforcement function are really important. There's another thing that we can't do, and that is write new regulations or give advice. We have, in the last year, gotten four advisory opinion requests around the issue of cybersecurity.
18:38 Speaker 02 Explain that.
18:40 Speaker 03 So there were four different, anybody can, who wants to know whether what they're...
18:43 Speaker 02 We're doing it right. Are we doing it right?
18:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, are we doing it right? Can we pursue this plan consistent with the law? And there are times when, particularly if it involves somebody providing something of value to a campaign, such as cybersecurity services, that they want to get sign-off from the Federal Election Commission because campaigns won't accept it otherwise. They'll be afraid to take it.
19:04 Speaker 02 Right, so they don't want to come back saying, oh, you took something you shouldn't have taken.
19:06 Speaker 03 Right. So we had...
19:09 Speaker 02 And they need cybersecurity protection.
19:11 Speaker 03 They do need cybersecurity. They need it. So we've had a couple of requests that involved... Ultimately, organizations that were providing those services in the ordinary course of business, they were giving it on the same terms as they had, were giving it to other clients. They were protecting their own business interests. Microsoft submitted a request saying, you know, "We're going to look really bad if somebody gets hacked because of some deficiency in our system. So we want to make sure, for our own business purposes, that we are providing the best suite of cybersecurity to our political clients."
19:44 Speaker 02 We can't upgrade.
19:45 Speaker 03 Right.
19:46 Speaker 02 They can't upgrade.
19:47 Speaker 03 And they were also making it available to similar nonprofit organizations. It wasn't just political committees. So the commission said, "Yes, you can do that." We also had a request from a group called Depending Digital Campaigns. I think that's right, because we thought of it as DDC. So I think I'm, I think I'm getting the initials right. Which was a group organized in Cambridge. It had one D, one R, and one national security specialist. Matt Rhodes from the Romney campaign and Robbie Mook from the Hillary Clinton campaign got together, working out of the Belfer Center at Harvard with some national security folks. And they said, "We want to, as a nonprofit organization, we, we want to provide cybersecurity
20:32 Speaker 03 services to campaigns. We're very worried about the potential of foreign hacking into our elections."
20:37 Speaker 02 Robbie Mook would know. He ran the Hillary Clinton campaign.
20:40 Speaker 03 Yes. And it was a tough decision for us, because there are limits and there are prohibitions on corporate contributions to campaigns. And this was being organized out of a nonprofit corporation, but still a corporation. So I was very concerned that we not write the opinion in a way that would open a big loophole in the corporate contribution ban.
21:00 Speaker 02 Right, so people create these, do it via these, these vehicles, correct?
21:04 Speaker 03 Right. But we were able to craft a response that was hinged to our responsibility to enforce the ban on foreign national spending and our obligation to protect our elections from foreign interference. And because of that special hook, we were able to tell them that it would be okay for people to accept these services. And as I said, if, if we didn't okay it, they were concerned that the campaigns would not be willing to accept it.
21:31 Speaker 02 But now you can't.
21:33 Speaker 03 Now, we so if somebody else, my point is that there were, we had four different requests that all had different ways of doing this. And we had, we were able to say yes to all four of them. But if somebody else comes up with an innovative idea tomorrow and says, hey, I've got a new great way of doing this, we won't be able to OK it for them, and therefore, the campaigns probably won't accept it. So I think that is a real weakness that we cannot respond.
22:00 Speaker 02 100%, especially around cybersecurity.
22:02 Speaker 03 Exactly.
22:03 Speaker 02 OK, we're here with Ellen Weintraub, hearing some terrible things, who chairs the Federal Election Commission. We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back after this.
22:10 Speaker 04 It's me, the We don't need the jingle twice. Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars. Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
22:41 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
22:42 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
22:44 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
22:45 Speaker 01 Caramel?
22:46 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
22:47 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
23:07 Speaker 02 We're here with Ellen Weintraub. She chairs the Federal Election Commission. She's talking about the fact that they can't really do their job right now because they do not have a quorum. Do you have any timeframe on this?
23:18 Speaker 03 Well, as I said, it's completely out of my hands. It's whenever the president nominates and the Senate confirms. It can happen pretty quickly.
23:25 Speaker 02 If they do that.
23:26 Speaker 03 Back in 2008, when they were suddenly motivated to fill the slots, the recently resigned vice chairman was nominated and then confirmed 12 days later.
23:35 Speaker 02 12 days later, so they can do it very quickly.
23:37 Speaker 03 They can do it quick if they're motivated.
23:38 Speaker 02 So what you've been doing now, one of the things that's, these are really important functions. Is it ever under threat that this wouldn't exist, that this, the Federal Election Commission, wouldn't exist? Like, a lot of people have their funding. Questions, because one of the things that you have to be doing more and more, I would assume, is related to data, online giving, and things like that. You guys need more money to get up to speed, presumably.
24:01 Speaker 03 That would be good. We would take it. We could come up with some good uses for it if they would give us more money.
24:07 Speaker 02 What are the things you're facing, from your perspective, going forward? You know, people filling out forms is one thing, but there's so much more need for, you know, especially as elections become more digital, as they become more involved with social networks and things like that.
24:20 Speaker 03 Well, there are constant innovations in how people are running their campaigns. And some of them are good, and some of them expose weaknesses in the system. So we need to be up and running so that we can stay on top of new developments.
24:33 Speaker 02 Talk about some of those things that you're thinking about, some innovations that are coming along in campaign finance.
24:38 Speaker 03 Well, of course, the campaigning is moving to the Internet.
24:41 Speaker 02 Right, moved.
24:42 Speaker 03 What used to be largely a broadcast advertising venue is now moving more and more to the Internet, and the laws haven't really caught up with that.
24:51 Speaker 02 Not at all.
24:52 Speaker 03 So the laws on disclosure, there are certain information that has to be disclosed when advertising takes place within 30 days of a primary.
25:02 Speaker 02 And that goes not to you. Does that go to you?
25:03 Speaker 03 Yes, it does.
25:04 Speaker 02 That goes to you, too.
25:05 Speaker 03 60 days of a general election, and the information comes to us, but only when those ads are run through broadcast media, not if they are run online. So the law needs to be updated so that we can get the information on this online advertising. We were in the process of trying to update our rules on the disclaimers that go along with online advertising. Political advertising has to say where it's coming from.
25:32 Speaker 02 Right.
25:33 Speaker 03 Right? And that's really important.
25:34 Speaker 02 That was at the crux of the Russia issues on Facebook.
25:36 Speaker 03 That was certainly one of the big issues there. And it's really important that people know where the information is coming from, because I don't think anybody wants to get their political information from a Russian troll farm.
25:45 Speaker 02 No, not at all.
25:46 Speaker 03 Right?
25:47 Speaker 02 Although some of it was the content. Like, a lot of it was, as we discussed yesterday, I was at an event at the FEC, a lot of it was the content itself, not paid for. But paid advertising is what you'd be concerned with, not the actual content.
25:59 Speaker 03 That is one of our focuses, is paid advertising. But when people are spending money to get their political message out, there is a potential there that they have to be disclosing that money to us, depending on what the message says and who's doing it. And as I said, for foreign nationals, they're not supposed to be putting money into our elections in any way, shape, or form. Right, but this is a sneaky way to do it. Yes, it could be a sneaky way to do it. So, one issue that is out there is the need to update our regulations to make sure that people are getting good information about where the information is coming from that they're seeing online. There's also chronic problems that are always morphing into new forms of people trying
26:43 Speaker 03 to hide where the money's coming from through various dark money vehicles. So they route the money through, from one organization to another organization through C4s or LLCs or other groups. And sometimes they will say, "Well, we're not a, we're not a political committee. We don't have to do disclosure because, in fact, we're just advocating on issues." Right. So, we had a case a few years ago involving a group called Carolina Rising, which said, "We're not a political committee. We don't have to disclose to you." But they were running ads, they were running ads about candidates in North Carolina about a particular senate race. They were really lovely ads. I mean, I wanted to vote for the guy after I saw those ads. They were so moving and compelling.
27:27 Speaker 03 They were terrific ads. And on, but they said, "It's all issue ads. It has nothing to do with the, we're not, we're not advocating for the election." Right. And on election night, the, the head of that organization was on film, a local reporter caught him on film in election headquarters for that candidate that, that his organization had been running ads for, wearing the campaign hat with the guy's name on it. And, and he was saying, "We did it. We spent $5 million and we did it." Right. You know, he said to us, "Oh, we weren't running campaign ads." But there he was at campaign headquarters saying, "These are, these were, were ads that were run to influence this election." Right. And- I argued that that made his group a political committee and we should have at
28:10 Speaker 03 least investigated whether their purpose was influencing an election and maybe they should have been disclosing their donors, but we didn't have the votes to go forward on that.
28:19 Speaker 02 Right.
28:19 Speaker 03 And that's just an example of a dark money group. We see groups like this all the time.
28:23 Speaker 02 And especially online, where they don't label things. TV has to, has, under much more stringent rules, correct?
28:29 Speaker 03 He would have to, if he was running a TV ad, he'd have to say paid for by Carolina Rising, but then the next question is, okay, so who's Carolina Rising?
28:37 Speaker 02 Right.
28:37 Speaker 03 Who's behind that organization?
28:38 Speaker 02 Right.
28:38 Speaker 03 And that information was not made available to the public.
28:41 Speaker 02 Not made available because it was online?
28:43 Speaker 03 No, because he claimed he was doing issue advertising.
28:46 Speaker 02 Right, I see, okay.
28:47 Speaker 03 So this is a whole different issue from the online issue. This is, because these are broadcast ads.
28:51 Speaker 02 What's the biggest issue online that you all face in this spending?
28:54 Speaker 03 Just tracking the money, because a lot of, now, there are positive attributes to the digital revolution, because it makes it really easy for small donors to participate.
29:07 Speaker 02 Right, sure.
29:07 Speaker 03 You know, back in the old days where everybody had to write a check, people might not bother, they might have think it was worth the trouble to write a check for $2.
29:13 Speaker 02 Sure, sure. And a lot of the candidates are collecting enormous amounts of money.
29:16 Speaker 03 Enormous amounts of money online, and, you know, people can arrange to donate on a regular basis and then...
29:21 Speaker 02 Which you monitor also.
29:22 Speaker 03 Yes, yes. All the, all the money that goes in and goes out to political committees and to candidates, we're on top of that. We don't get the details on contributions of less than $200.
29:35 Speaker 02 But you monitor, you monitor, the idea is that this is a good thing because small donors can get things in, although sometimes it can be obviously manipulated. Someone was saying that Republicans were trying to get several people on the debate stage, it doesn't really matter if it's a small amounts of money, correct? They were trying to get, they were trying to manipulate, you know, because a lot of the getting on the Democratic debate stage matters of how many donors you have and things like that. But in general, you think that's a good thing, that more people can use online services?
30:00 Speaker 03 I think it's, it's a good thing when more people are participating in the political process, whether they're doing it by donation or, and/or hopefully by voting.
30:09 Speaker 02 Right, right. And so that works. What are the things that are more challenging from your perspective?
30:14 Speaker 03 Well, as I said, you know, sometimes you have to trace it back through several levels to try and find out where the money's actually coming from. So that's a big problem. Making sure that some of these organizations are not hiding foreign money, that's a big problem that I'm worried about a great deal these days.
30:32 Speaker 02 And when this stuff happened, what is right now your relationship with? It's really just Google and Facebook. That's where the real action is presumably, or is it elsewhere?
30:40 Speaker 03 Well, Google, Facebook, Twitter.
30:42 Speaker 02 Twitter.
30:43 Speaker 03 And who knows what will come along tomorrow.
30:45 Speaker 02 Right, but those are the three you deal with. So what are the biggest? How are your relationship with them? How do you interface with them?
30:51 Speaker 03 Well, that's an interesting question. We have the potential to regulate them, but our regulations on the Internet are pretty mild. They're not nonexistent, but they're pretty mild.
31:00 Speaker 02 What are they?
31:01 Speaker 03 They were put into effect back in 2007, I believe. And obviously, there's been a great deal of change in the
31:09 Speaker 02 Yes, things change.
31:11 Speaker 03 Yes, in the landscape of the Internet, in the power of the Internet. I mean, back then, we had a really interesting rulemaking, and a lot of people came in and they said, "Oh, we've got this new thing, politics on the Internet, and we have to be very careful how we regulate this because it's like a little baby, and we have to let it grow."
31:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, they're big babies. They're giant babies that ate New York.
31:35 Speaker 03 And we don't want to regulate too strenuously because we don't want to throttle the baby in its crib. And now, of course, you know, here we are in 2019, and we haven't updated our regulations in a dozen years.
31:47 Speaker 02 What is the regulations for them right now?
31:48 Speaker 03 Right now, it just says that if there is paid advertising on another person's website on the Internet, it has to be disclosed. You have to carry the disclaimer information. But there's not a lot more to it than that.
32:02 Speaker 02 Is there things you'd like to see, or do you have things that you guys were working on?
32:07 Speaker 03 Well, as I said, we were working on even improving the, just making sure that that disclaimer information is appropriate and is being carried out properly. Because, you know, it's not clear that everybody acknowledges their obligation to put the information on their Internet advertising.
32:25 Speaker 02 Right, enforcement, yeah.
32:26 Speaker 03 Right. There's this whole new area of, well, it's not new anymore, but when we did our rulemaking, YouTube was in its infancy and the notion of a free platform where people wouldn't have to pay for advertising, but they could, in fact, spend a lot of money.
32:41 Speaker 02 Making.
32:42 Speaker 03 Getting something out there.
32:44 Speaker 02 Right.
32:44 Speaker 03 Promoting virality.
32:45 Speaker 02 Right.
32:46 Speaker 03 And getting a message out there that could have a huge impact on the election. A lot of money spent, and we wouldn't be capturing that right now.
32:54 Speaker 02 Right.
32:54 Speaker 03 And back then, it made sense to focus on paid advertising because we were working off of the old traditional broadcast model where you couldn't get your message out without paying somebody to run the ad.
33:05 Speaker 02 Sure, but now this content is free.
33:06 Speaker 03 Yes.
33:06 Speaker 02 And so therefore, you're still spending something to get an impact.
33:10 Speaker 03 Right, so I think we are long overdue for doing another rulemaking that might look at how is money actually being used on the Internet and are we capturing what we need to capture in order to make sure that the American people are informed about who is exercising influence.
33:27 Speaker 02 This is a massive thing, though. This is a massive platform now. So how would you, going to the companies that principally run things in this area, correct?
33:37 Speaker 03 It wouldn't be necessarily the companies themselves. Traditionally, what we look to are who's spending the money. So they're not actually spending the money.
33:45 Speaker 02 Right.
33:45 Speaker 03 They're receiving the money.
33:47 Speaker 02 Right.
33:48 Speaker 03 But we usually look to the folks who are placing the ads, who are spending the money, and those are the ones who usually have the disclosure obligations.
33:56 Speaker 02 Obligation, so where does that put the companies? Because they're the ones facilitating this. Because you know they're benign platforms, just so you know, Ellen.
34:03 Speaker 03 Good to know.
34:04 Speaker 02 Ellen's smiling at me.
34:05 Speaker 03 Good to know. I assume everyone is benign.
34:08 Speaker 02 They're not benign platforms.
34:10 Speaker 03 They're not?
34:11 Speaker 02 No, not at all. So how do you deal with this? It's massive.
34:15 Speaker 03 You're crushing my dreams here, Karen.
34:16 Speaker 02 I know, I'm sorry. I'm so sorry, Ellen. How do you deal with this? They're huge and they can't hardly run them themselves.
34:22 Speaker 03 Well, you know, it's interesting. I think the platforms have tried to take some positive steps forward. They have adopted some affirmative steps of their own, even in the absence of regulation. But what I have heard from them is that they actually would like some regulation because they're seeing that it's actually quite difficult to decide what is a political ad and what isn't a political ad. And where do you need that extra bit of information, that extra disclosure? And I think they would like some guidance from the government, if only to kind of get themselves off the hook from having to make those decisions.
34:56 Speaker 02 Right, absolutely. So here you are, when Cambridge Analytica happened and stuff like that, is that your purview? I mean, obviously, the FBI looked at it, all kinds of people looked at it, Facebook looked at it, there were whistleblowers. Where does that fit in with your?
35:11 Speaker 03 Well, let me just say that anyone who spends money to influence an election, if they do that in a way that violates the law, somebody can file a complaint. And I can't comment on anything that may come before the commission in the form of a complaint.
35:31 Speaker 02 Right. And so you wait for, but you see these complaints coming through, correct?
35:36 Speaker 03 Yes.
35:37 Speaker 02 Yeah. So when you looked at it in the whole, it sort of exposed what you're just talking about, is there's lots of ways to spend money and not the traditional way.
35:46 Speaker 03 Yes.
35:47 Speaker 02 And so, do you have enough technical tools that you're behind this commission to be able to handle it? Or is it just an overwhelming flow of information that is hard to handle?
35:59 Speaker 03 Well, as I said, I think the law needs to be strengthened, the Honest Ads Act, for example, which would-
36:06 Speaker 02 Explain that for people who don't know what it is.
36:07 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, the basic premise is you take the rules that apply to broadcast ads and you make sure that the same rules apply to online advertising.
36:13 Speaker 02 Yes, right.
36:14 Speaker 03 Which has a, you know, certain common sense value to it. And many of the platforms, in fact, have endorsed that. They seem to be on board with it. It's got bipartisan support, but it can't seem to get a vote-
36:27 Speaker 02 Right.
36:28 Speaker 03 -in the Senate.
36:29 Speaker 02 And why is that? You don't run the Senate.
36:31 Speaker 03 I don't run the Senate.
36:32 Speaker 02 You don't run the Senate.
36:33 Speaker 03 I definitely do not run the Senate.
36:34 Speaker 02 So, one of the things that was striking yesterday, because we also talked about cybersecurity, a lot of it about cybersecurity, and that I think someone mentioned there were, what, 30 bills, 40 bills in the Senate related to that, related to spending, related to all kinds of things.
36:48 Speaker 03 Well, yes, various forms of election protection, many of them, you know, some of them about disclosure, some of them about providing better cybersecurity, some of them involving making sure we have sanctions in place so that people would be deterred, particularly foreign spenders would be deterred from trying to interfere in our election because there would be huge consequences if they did.
37:06 Speaker 02 Sure.
37:07 Speaker 03 Providing more money to the states and localities in order to make sure that that's where the rubber hits the road in terms of election administration.
37:14 Speaker 02 Explain that.
37:15 Speaker 03 Our elections are pretty decentralized, so the folks who are actually administering the elections, running, manning the polling stations and collecting information for voter registration databases and making sure that people have the opportunity to vote, all of that is happening at the state and local level.
37:33 Speaker 02 Even if it has a federal impact?
37:34 Speaker 03 Yes.
37:35 Speaker 02 Yeah.
37:36 Speaker 03 So, there needs to be sufficient funding provided to every state and county to make sure that they can acquire the tools they need to ensure that they have the cybersecurity that they need in place, so the voter registration database can't get hacked.
37:52 Speaker 02 Right.
37:53 Speaker 03 And so that we have confidence on election day that all the votes are being tallied properly. So that there are bills to provide more money to the states and localities so that they can have the resources to protect themselves and protect all of us and make sure that we have a free and fair election in 2020. And even those funding bills are tied up in Congress right now.
38:14 Speaker 02 Right, all of them are. Is there one that's critically important that's tied up from your perspective, or all of them collectively have a difference?
38:20 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, from my, from my perspective, I'm very interested in both the Honest Ads Act and the Disclose Act, both of which would provide better disclosure mechanisms and ensure that we actually were getting disclosure of all the money that's being spent, particularly large amounts of money. I mean, I'm not so worried about the $25 contributions, I'm very worried about $25 million contributions, and there, there are such things. And Citizens United gave us the world of super PACs, there are, I think in the last election, there were 126 people who reported giving more than $1 million. There were a dozen who gave over $10 million, and there was one family that gave over $100 million.
39:04 Speaker 03 So there are huge amounts of money being raised and spent, and we want to make sure that we are adequately getting disclosure of all that, and, as I said, particularly at the top ends. So the Honest Ads Act and the Disclose Act would help with that, and from a disclosure perspective, which is my core mission, that's what I'm interested in. But also, I think the bills that would shore up our cybersecurity and impose sanctions on anyone, particularly foreign actors, who might seek to intervene in our elections, I think are really important and would give the American people a lot more confidence that our elections were secure.
39:43 Speaker 02 Were you surprised that after 2016 and all the inherent controversies around the interference, especially online, in the elections, primarily online, that nothing has passed?
39:53 Speaker 03 It's sad.
39:54 Speaker 02 Yeah.
39:55 Speaker 03 It makes me sad.
39:56 Speaker 02 Me too, Ellen. We just can't be sad. It's gotta happen. It's really amazing. I think it's an indictment on our Congress and the executive branch.
40:05 Speaker 03 Well, I think that there are many good bills out there. I encourage citizens to inform themselves, and if they see particular bills that they want to see passed, they should contact their members of Congress, particularly in the Senate, and try and exert pressure to get this done. Because really, I agree with you. It's kind of unacceptable.
40:25 Speaker 02 What is the resistance? Just resist?
40:27 Speaker 03 Again, you are asking the wrong person.
40:30 Speaker 02 Wrong person. Okay, Ellen. I would love to know what you think, we're going to talk in the next section, what you think the biggest danger to the free and fair elections are. And it could be Donald Trump's tweeting, which you got into. I was really admirable of how hard you pushed back on some of the statements he made. We're going to talk about that when we get back. We're going to take another break now. We'll be back with Ellen Weintraub, who chairs the Federal Election Commission, which is an independent body, that regulatory agency that enforces campaign finance law.
40:58 Speaker 04 It's me, the
41:03 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice.
41:06 Speaker 04 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
41:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
41:21 Speaker 04 Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop.
41:26 Speaker 04 Touche.
41:28 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
41:30 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
41:31 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
41:31 Speaker 01 Caramel?
41:32 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
41:33 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
41:45 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling.
41:50 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
41:55 Speaker 02 We're here with Ellen Weintraub, who chairs the Federal Election Commission, an independent regulatory agency that enforces campaign finance law, but it does a lot more than that. It also does regulation, it does transparency, it allows people to see where money's going. And money, of course, is at the heart of all campaigns now. Ellen, you got into a little tussle with the president, Mr. Tweeter, the tweeter in chief, troller in chief. Explain what happened. He had tweeted something about the integrity of elections.
42:20 Speaker 03 Well, I don't, I don't consider it a tussle. I, I have an obligation to make sure that everybody has the right information about the law. And I also worry a lot, I think, big picture, you know, I worry a lot about the state of our democracy. I worry about the fact that we don't get a lot of people to turn out and vote.
42:42 Speaker 02 Right.
42:42 Speaker 03 You know, in a, in a, in a boffo year, we'll get in the mid 60% of people turning out to vote. And people say, wow, isn't that great? In the last midterm, people were just over the moon at the turnout, and it was really only about 50% of folks who turned out and actually exercised their right to vote. Midterms matter. People tend to focus on the presidential, but midterms matter a lot.
43:05 Speaker 02 They all matter a lot. All elections do. I think it's a, it's a privilege to be able to vote. You know, my son, for the first time, will be voting in a presidential election this year, and I told him if he didn't vote, he's not allowed to eat. He's not allowed any food from my home if he doesn't, you know, he has to go to the polls, he must.
43:20 Speaker 03 Voting is really important. And you know who loves to vote? Old people love to vote.
43:24 Speaker 02 Yes, they do.
43:26 Speaker 03 I say this whenever I talk to younger potential voters, that you wouldn't let your grandparents choose your clothing, or your music, or who you went out with.
43:36 Speaker 02 Right, everybody should.
43:37 Speaker 03 So, you shouldn't let your grandparents choose your government.
43:40 Speaker 02 Right.
43:40 Speaker 03 Choose the people who are going to adopt the policies that are going to affect your life.
43:45 Speaker 02 Right.
43:45 Speaker 03 In so many ways, so...
43:47 Speaker 02 We don't mean to say, "Old people should vote," because I'm an old person.
43:50 Speaker 03 No, you are not an old person.
43:51 Speaker 02 I am an old person, but, you know, old people should vote, but young people should vote.
43:54 Speaker 03 Everyone should vote.
43:55 Speaker 02 Yes, but you're right, young people don't vote a lot.
43:58 Speaker 03 That is true. Young people tend not to vote as much as old people. And if they want a government that represents their values and their interests, then they have to show politicians that they're going to hold them accountable at the ballot box. That's what politicians pay attention to.
44:13 Speaker 02 So, you're pushing to get people to vote. And President Trump did what? I don't want to get it wrong. He tweeted that...
44:19 Speaker 03 There was an allegation that millions of people voted illegally, engaged in voter fraud in the last election. And in particular, there were people bused from other places to New Hampshire to vote, and therefore, the vote tallies were wrong, because people were... the tallies were right, but they represented illegal voters, and therefore, the results did not go the way they should have. And the notion of this canard of voter fraud has been around for a very long time.
44:52 Speaker 02 Yes.
44:52 Speaker 03 It seems to make intuitive sense to some people, that there must be people voting illegally out there.
44:57 Speaker 02 Three, and four, and five times, I think he keeps saying that.
44:59 Speaker 03 But, in fact, scholars have studied this. People have looked into this after the 2014 election. One scholar looked at every election between 2000 and 2014, over a billion votes, and found 31 instances of potential credible allegations of voter fraud. It just doesn't happen.
45:21 Speaker 02 Well, it's a persistent narrative, like, Chicago, they vote three, and the dead vote, and things like that.
45:24 Speaker 03 It is a persistent narrative, but it doesn't... there's no documentation for it.
45:28 Speaker 02 Voter suppression is the bigger problem.
45:29 Speaker 03 That is the problem, and that's what I worry about, that people who are worried about voter fraud will adopt really stringent restrictions, and that will end up impairing...
45:41 Speaker 03 Real legitimate American citizens who have the right to vote from exercising that franchise. They're just putting obstacles in the way and making it more difficult to vote, and we should make it easy to vote. Obviously, we only want American citizens to be voting in our election, but we want every American citizen to be voting in our election so that the government represents as many of the people as there are in the country.
46:04 Speaker 02 And so you pushed back on that. He was pushing the idea of voter fraud quite some.
46:10 Speaker 03 Well, the issue with voter fraud is I have not seen any evidence. And in fact, to the contrary, the studies that I have seen have shown that there really isn't any evidence. There was a case in Kansas, either earlier this year or last year, where the proponents of voter fraud trotted out all their favorite experts, and the judge found them totally lacking in credibility. They just couldn't come up with any real evidence to document this. And as I said, there are real ramifications. It is not a victimless process if you adopt a lot of really stringent restrictions to try and ensure that there is absolutely no possible way for this voter fraud, which
46:53 Speaker 03 doesn't seem to be really happening, to ever happen, if those restrictions are at the same time preventing thousands of people from exercising what should be their real right to vote.
47:04 Speaker 02 So what the president did was in a rally in New Hampshire this summer in New Hampshire, he said that he could have won New Hampshire in 2015, not for, quote, "thousands and thousands of people coming in from locations unknown." And so you sent a letter saying, "No, not so much." You wanted to substantiate the claims of voter fraud.
47:23 Speaker 03 Well, I asked if he had any evidence. And if he did have evidence, I said he should bring it forward to the appropriate law enforcement officials. Because if indeed this happened, if thousands of people were voting illegally, then that is a massive crime, and it should be pursued.
47:39 Speaker 02 Right.
47:40 Speaker 03 And by the way, it probably, it's hard for me to imagine any kind of a grand conspiracy involving thousands of people that wouldn't involve spending some money somewhere along the way.
47:49 Speaker 02 Right, which is where you come in.
47:50 Speaker 03 Which is, that's where we come in. Because that money was certainly not reported to us. So, you know, if there are buses rented to haul people into New Hampshire from some other place.
47:58 Speaker 02 You would like to know.
47:59 Speaker 03 I would like to know who paid for those buses.
48:01 Speaker 02 Right.
48:02 Speaker 03 So, what I said was, let's see the evidence. The evidence should be produced, but if there isn't evidence to be just raising these allegations, which, as I said, have been around for a really long time, this notion of voter fraud, it is a sticky one, as you've said, it kind of sticks in the imagination. If there really isn't evidence, and as I said, I haven't seen any, then it's harmful to the democracy to be promoting this view. I think there are also increasing numbers of people who are worried about what's going to happen in the next election, and will people accept the results?
48:36 Speaker 02 Right, which is a big question we discussed. Let me read from the letter. First of all, you tweeted, you go, "Sad," sad, which I like that, well done. "Last night, @RealDonaldTrump again made unfounded claims about massive voter fraud in New Hampshire in 2016. In the letter, asked him to back up his claims. In the terms, a former casino operator should understand, there comes a time when you need to lay your cards on the table or fold." Ellen, that's very cheeky of you.
49:05 Speaker 03 It was a little cheeky.
49:07 Speaker 02 It was cheeky. What did you think about using Twitter in this methodology, in this fashion?
49:11 Speaker 03 I hear that some people find Twitter to be quite a venue for political speech.
49:16 Speaker 02 Yes, I know, yeah.
49:18 Speaker 03 And it seems to be a good way to get certain messages out.
49:21 Speaker 02 Yes.
49:21 Speaker 03 And it seems to be a place that some people actually pay attention to.
49:25 Speaker 02 Right, they do, especially the media. But actually, let me read from the letter, because I think this is critically important. "What I wrote to you in March 2017 is just as true now. Our democracy depends on Americans' people's faith in our elections. Your voter fraud allegations run the risk of undermining that faith. Just as seriously, baseless allegations of fraud have been used to rationalize indefensible laws that deter certain US citizens from exercising their right to vote. Words matter, and facts matter."
49:51 Speaker 03 And facts are not partisan, by the way.
49:53 Speaker 02 Well, they are today, but tell me more.
49:55 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, that's really it in a nutshell. I am concerned about the state of our democracy. I want people to have faith in the system. There are so many good people out there who are trying to administer free and fair elections for the American people. And I don't want people to be needlessly scared and not to trust the results, but I also don't want measures to be adopted that are going to prevent people from voting who really do have the right to vote.
50:20 Speaker 02 Right.
50:21 Speaker 03 And, as I said, if this is going on, this is a massive crime and it needs to be addressed, but it needs to be addressed through the proper channels. Let's put the evidence before law enforcement and let them go after it.
50:34 Speaker 02 Right. Do you think proof is really the point here? It's to create doubt. It's actually just what the Russians do, without any proof, to create doubt. There is no attempt here to provide proof. You don't expect to get proof, correct?
50:47 Speaker 03 You'd be happy to get proof. Well, I wouldn't be happy to get proof because it would be sad if there actually was proof of massive voter fraud. But I would like there not to be massive voter fraud. I haven't seen any evidence that there is massive voter fraud. Nobody wants voter fraud, but it tends not to happen. The nonpartisan Brennan Center in New York has done some studies on this, and they said that you are more likely to be struck by lightning than to engage in in-person voter fraud. If you think about it, it doesn't make a lot of sense. You would have to persuade thousands of people, each one of them to risk going to jail in order to, you know, add one vote to the total.
51:28 Speaker 02 Right, exactly. It's quite an expensive way to do it. Do you worry? So when you did this, you got a lot of attention for doing this, but you're going to keep doing it, like, prove it. Like, we will investigate it if you can prove your allegation.
51:40 Speaker 03 Well, somebody should be investigating it. And we will investigate if there are allegations of somebody was...
51:44 Speaker 02 If only you had a quorum.
51:45 Speaker 03 Well, there's that. We can't launch any new investigations now, but if there was evidence that money was being spent to perpetrate a voter fraud... Then it should be reported and we could investigate that.
51:56 Speaker 02 Right.
51:56 Speaker 03 If somehow this was being done without any money being spent, but there was still voter fraud, then it would be a matter for the FBI or state or local officials.
52:03 Speaker 02 Right, but it's not just money spent, it's like any, any value, right? Anything of value.
52:07 Speaker 03 Anything of value, yeah.
52:08 Speaker 02 It's not insane money. Do you, when you look at this, do you, are you more worried about the corrosive effects of money on these elections? Because you have to now monitor this enormous gusher of cash coming through, which is already a difficult problem. Or sort of the more sneaky ways you can do it online? Like these, these social media sites, these, these online venues, the ability to use email and everything else to raise money. It probably raises your job the quantum level of, just quantumly, I guess, I don't know.
52:35 Speaker 03 Well, the amount of money that is being raised and spent is, you know, in the billions. You know, we don't know, but there are predictions that the cost of this election could reach $10 billion. I think the last one was in the $7 billion range. So the question is, what are people getting in return for that money?
52:55 Speaker 02 Right.
52:56 Speaker 03 That's, that's what you have to worry about. Are there, are there rich donors at the top end who are getting undue influence over the process so that, you know, ordinary, regular citizens don't really have that kind of a voice in their own government?
53:12 Speaker 02 Right.
53:13 Speaker 03 And aren't fully represented? If, if, if politicians are adopting laws at the behest of their donors rather than at the behest of their constituents, that's a problem for the system, I think. We want a government, I want a government that represents the views of everybody, not just the people at the top, not just the people who are able to make million dollar contributions.
53:35 Speaker 02 Right.
53:36 Speaker 03 So that's where you get into the corrosive influence of money in politics because it, it affects how policies get adopted and, or don't get adopted, how policies get stopped that maybe a lot of people want. I mean, you, you see this in Congress from time to time. Public opinion polls show that High percentages of people want this policy or that policy and somehow it can't get adopted.
53:57 Speaker 02 Right.
53:58 Speaker 03 What's stopping it? You know, maybe there are wealthy donors out there.
54:01 Speaker 02 Yeah.
54:02 Speaker 03 Who are having a say at the expense of everybody else. So I think that's a problem when you talk about the corrosive influence of money in politics. When it's coming in through dark money venues, then it's completely invisible and people can't, don't even have access to the information to be appropriately, to appropriately critique their government and hold it accountable. The risk of foreign money seeping in through any of these sources or for foreigners to be getting influence over our government.
54:30 Speaker 02 In other ways.
54:31 Speaker 03 Our elections through social media or in other ways is obviously deeply troubling. There's plenty to be worried about.
54:36 Speaker 02 So let me ask you, I'm going to give you more to worry about. When you're thinking about these things, you've now got to deal with not just the amount of money, but how it's coming in, how it's spent in more creative ways because online gives you, you know, a television station's pretty straightforward, buying ads on TV stations. This is not straightforward. These ads are not straightforward. And they're not even ads necessarily.
54:56 Speaker 03 Well, when you look at these targeted ad buys, so that, you know, what comes into my feed, what the ads that pop up in my feed are not the same as the ads that pop up in your feed because somebody is targeting us because of all the information that sometimes that the social media platforms themselves are collecting. Then it becomes much harder to monitor because the advertising is going out on an individual basis.
55:20 Speaker 02 Right.
55:21 Speaker 03 And our campaign finance laws never anticipated that.
55:23 Speaker 02 Right.
55:24 Speaker 03 They were set up in the 1970s for the most part, in a world of broadcast advertising. So they don't really have a mechanism for reaching that kind of individual advertising. And it's hard for people to respond to it. So if you're the, if you're a candidate and you're being attacked, but you can't see the ads that are attacking you, you don't know they're there because they're just going in different formats to different people's feeds in your constituency.
55:51 Speaker 02 Or emails or anywhere else, your texts or anywhere.
55:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, however you're receiving it.
55:54 Speaker 02 Right.
55:55 Speaker 03 And the more you get into these private networks, so there's, there's the... The problem of individualized advertising that nobody can see because it's
56:05 Speaker 02 But you.
56:06 Speaker 03 But you.
56:07 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
56:07 Speaker 03 And I think the platforms have made some commitments about trying to capture those ads and make some kind of an archive, but I don't know if they're actually capturing all of them.
56:16 Speaker 02 Oh, it's perfect.
56:17 Speaker 03 It's
56:17 Speaker 02 It's perfect for these people who are trying to spend this money.
56:20 Speaker 03 It's very hard to tell. Then there are people who are getting it through WhatsApp or from some other private messaging service where it's not even
56:29 Speaker 02 You're never gonna see it. It's encrypted.
56:30 Speaker 03 Yes, it's all encrypted. It's not on any kind of a, even semi-public platform. Who sees that? Who monitors that? Who knows that it's even there?
56:39 Speaker 02 And with Facebook wanting to become more encrypted, WhatsApp is largely used in foreign countries, which is, not as many people use it here, but Facebook wants more and more of the information to be encrypted, to be private. That's where they're moving.
56:51 Speaker 03 And, you know, encryption can be a good thing.
56:53 Speaker 02 Sure.
56:54 Speaker 03 You know, I want my information to be private and protected and
56:57 Speaker 02 But it's a perfect vehicle for targeted ads.
57:01 Speaker 03 But it does, I don't think anybody has done a lot of serious thought on how one would regulate that, how one would adapt the platforms, the legal platforms that we've established, that again, go back to the 1970s when none of this stuff existed.
57:17 Speaker 02 Right.
57:17 Speaker 03 Nobody even thought about it.
57:19 Speaker 02 Right.
57:20 Speaker 03 Um, the laws are just hopelessly out of date for this.
57:23 Speaker 02 A hundred percent, and so are the legislators, but that's, we won't get into that. I won't have you insult the Congress. I will do it all by myself. But the last thing I want to ask you, Bitcoin. Have you even thought of Bitcoin?
57:34 Speaker 03 We have. We've had a couple of AOs on Bitcoin.
57:37 Speaker 02 Okay.
57:37 Speaker 03 I think that we should treat Bitcoin like cash. There are very strong limits on cash contributions because of its, you know, there are limits on anonymous contributions.
57:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, you can take it anywhere in a suitcase.
57:48 Speaker 03 There are limits on cash contributions, and I think we should treat Bitcoin like cash. But I worry about it because, again, There's no way to trace it. You don't know where it's coming from.
57:59 Speaker 02 And what shall you do, Ellen, if you have to deal with it? What kind of regulation?
58:03 Speaker 03 Well, as I said, we've been
58:04 Speaker 02 It's treated like cash.
58:05 Speaker 03 We've been asked about it.
58:06 Speaker 02 How do you treat cash now? Because people don't do suitcase. This is not Because cash is harder, because the suitcase is full of money.
58:11 Speaker 03 You can't give more than $50.
58:13 Speaker 02 Right, exactly. So, but Bitcoin, you can.
58:16 Speaker 03 Well, that's what I'm saying, is we should subject it to the same limit as cash contributions.
58:20 Speaker 02 Do you think you can chase the Bitcoin? Because, boy, it's
58:22 Speaker 03 There aren't that many campaigns that are using it now. And again, this is one of these areas where
58:28 Speaker 02 Not Andrew Yang? There isn't
58:30 Speaker 03 I have no idea. I have no idea. We have had a couple of requests on this, and I think that some folks are probably going to be somewhat circumspect about accepting Bitcoin without some kind of
58:43 Speaker 02 Ruling.
58:44 Speaker 03 without some kind of ruling from the FEC that says, here's how you should go about dealing with this new form of digital currency.
58:52 Speaker 02 And until then, they can just, well, you could come back for them, but till then, there's no rule?
58:58 Speaker 03 No, I think the rule
59:00 Speaker 02 They won't use it. Legitimate campaign.
59:01 Speaker 03 I think the rule is you have to subject it to cash limits.
59:04 Speaker 02 Right.
59:04 Speaker 03 And not accept large amounts of money through Bitcoin. That's my view. But this is an area that the Commission, when it was presented with this, did not entirely agree. That was the part that we could agree on, that at least if we were
59:18 Speaker 02 What didn't you agree on?
59:19 Speaker 03 It would be okay on how to treat Bitcoin in amounts larger than the cash limit. I thought that we should just say, you can't take it if it's above the cash limit. Some of my colleagues disagreed with me. We didn't have consensus the last time it came up.
59:30 Speaker 02 Come up, but it's going to come up in the future, all kinds of stuff.
59:33 Speaker 03 No doubt.
59:33 Speaker 02 No doubt. All right, Ellen, how do you feel about the 2020 election? Last question. How are you looking at it? Here you are. You can't do anything for right now.
59:41 Speaker 03 Well, I'm really hoping that we're gonna, that situation is not going to last very long. I am hoping that the President's going to make nominations, and the Senate will confirm them. I'm hoping to get colleagues who are willing to enforce the law. I mean, because that's another whole problem that we haven't even talked about, is that for the last
1:00:00 Speaker 02 Please go ahead.
1:00:01 Speaker 03 Thank you. No problem. For the last 11 years, the polarization on the commission, not unlike polarization in Washington in general, but on the commission, when you've got a 3-3 split, it's become a lot worse. It's a lot harder to reach a result that will get four votes. And when I first started on the commission, there was a real commitment on the part of all commissioners to try and work together, to try and find four votes, to, you know, people would have to make some compromises on that. Which is always good. Nobody would think the answers were perfect. But if there was a place where four commissioners could land in order to give a clear answer, in order to write regulations, in order to issue advisory opinions, in order to enforce the law, that that was the way the commission was set up.
1:00:46 Speaker 03 It was set up to compromise. But starting about 11 years ago, we got a new group of commissioners who said, no, actually, if the three of us vote together all the time and we vote no, we can really restrict the activities of the election commission. We can really Hamper you. We can really hamper our, the commission's ability to enforce the law. We can hamper the commission's ability to give guidance and to make regulations. And since they were, had a very deregulatory libertarian philosophy, they thought that was a good result. Yeah. So we've had a lot less working together. Mucking up the gears is a very, is a very easy thing to do. It is. Governing is very hard. That is absolutely true.
1:01:29 Speaker 03 It is much harder to, but you know, that was the part I always liked the best. That's the fun part, is where's the deal? See, if you can find a place for four people to land, there's just a lot less interest in finding that place for the folks who would rather not see us enforce the law so much at all. Do you see any solution to that? In the short term, probably not. Yeah.
1:01:53 Speaker 02 Go and catch a falling star. Remember that poem? It's a really sad thing because the integrity of these elections are critical.
1:02:01 Speaker 03 Absolutely.
1:02:02 Speaker 02 And it's really important that we have people like you serving. I do hope you get the rest of your commissioners. I hope you get commissioners that you all can do deals with because it's really important in this partisan environment when the outsides are controlling the center. It's a really, it's a big problem in our society and hopefully it will be resolved at some point, but we'll see. But I appreciate it.
1:02:22 Speaker 03 Well, I hope that these things are cyclical and maybe we're at a high point in polarization and partisanship, but the wheel will turn.
1:02:30 Speaker 02 I don't know about that because I feel like it's at the bottom of bottomless well. That's what it feels like to me. But I really appreciate that you're on the job. You give me great hope and you're an excellent tweeter, by the way.
1:02:41 Speaker 03 Thank you.
1:02:42 Speaker 02 And you should keep doing it. It was very funny. It was really funny, but actually quite pointed in that we have to have free and fair elections without the influence of too much money or foreign influence.
1:02:52 Speaker 03 Absolutely.
1:02:53 Speaker 02 Critical. Anyway, thank you Chair Weintraub for coming on the show. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Erica Anderson, is at EricaAmerica. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. Chair Weintraub, where can people find you online?
1:03:06 Speaker 03 At Eleanor L. Weintraub on Twitter.
1:03:09 Speaker 02 And the FEC?
1:03:10 Speaker 03 The FEC is at FEC.gov. I've got a page on there that's got all of my statements and everything I talk about.
1:03:18 Speaker 02 And you can find all these campaign finance reports.
1:03:22 Speaker 03 Absolutely.
1:03:23 Speaker 02 If you're just a citizen and you should look at those things.
1:03:25 Speaker 03 Yes, you can look at it. And let me also recommend another great website is OpenSecrets.org, run by the Center for Responsive Politics. They do a great job of taking the data that we collect and crunching the numbers and doing great analysis and charts and...
1:03:39 Speaker 02 Can I ask you, will you be using AI in the future to do stuff like that, to see Pat? Are you starting to do that kind of stuff with the data?
1:03:46 Speaker 03 Not yet, but we'll see what the future brings.
1:03:48 Speaker 02 Okay. If you liked this episode, May, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robby. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
1:04:10 Speaker 06 In this life, you can't win.
1:04:12 Speaker 07 When the world gets you down.
1:04:13 Speaker 06 No!
1:04:13 Speaker 07 Escape to Pluto TV.
1:04:15 Speaker 06 This is objectively fantastic.
1:04:17 Speaker 07 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free.
1:04:21 Speaker 06 Schwing!
1:04:21 Speaker 07 Even our news is uplifting.
1:04:23 Speaker 04 You stay classy, San Diego.
1:04:25 Speaker 07 Watch School of Rock, Crazy Ex Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
1:04:30 Speaker 06 We're not worthy!
1:04:32 Speaker 07 The best things on TV really are free. You just have to know where to look. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
1:04:40 Speaker 08 Para los grandes, para los chicos, para los bajos y los altos, los pacifistas, los valientes. Para los optimistas y los pesimistas, los que valoran lo de adentro. Para los que están lejos, los que no vende lejos, y los que no vende cerca. Para los introvertidos y los extrovertidos. Para los que piensan y los que hacen. Para los que nos mostraron el camino. Coca-Cola. Para todos. Compra una Coca-Cola en una tienda cerca de usted.
Previous Recode Decode: Obama's cybersecurity chief Michael Daniel Next Recode Decode: Former HP CEO Carly Fiorina Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated