Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: DuckDuckGo CEO Gabe Weinberg About this episode DuckDuckGo CEO Gabe Weinberg talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher in this live conversation recorded at Made By We in New York City.
In this episode: What DuckDuckGo does; why Weinberg started the company; contextual advertising; Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act; are people actually mad about privacy violations?; Weinberg’s proposal for national privacy legislation; competing against Google and the “filter bubble”; data interoperability and what good policies would look like; what can consumers do to protect themselves?; security and facial recognition; the small number of people making decisions for the whole world; should Americans have the right to be forgotten?; and can there be a DuckDuckGo for YouTube?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,768 words · 11 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spend can be complicated. Managing it shouldn't be. Amex Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments all in one place. That's less time managing work and more time doing work that matters. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 You could try to find a perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:53 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, the editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as the champion of DuckDuckGoose and all other preschool games, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play a live interview I recently conducted in New York with Gabe Weinberg, the CEO of the privacy-focused search engine DuckDuckGo. This interview was recorded live at the Made by Wee space in New York City, which is an event space in the Flatiron District owned by WeWork. Let's go there now to hear my interview with Gabe Weinberg. We're going to very quickly bring up Gabe. Come on up, Gabe Weinberg. He's from DuckDuckGo. We're going to talk about the awfulness of Google now. Hello. This is Gabe.
1:37 Speaker 02 He's the founder and CEO of DuckDuckGo. This is another search engine. You do have a choice in this world, whether you know it or not. All right. So, Gabe, we were just talking about inequity in wealth and stuff like that. Let's talk about inequity of information, because that's really what's happened. We have given over control of our information to one company, really, in this world. And I'm going to tell one quick story before we start, so you get a sense of it. I was walking in the early days of Google with Larry or Sergey. I often can't tell them apart. And there was a room full of televisions, like a Circuit City. And I looked in, and it was recording. They were all on, all these dozens of televisions. And I said, "What are you doing?"
2:20 Speaker 02 And I think it was Larry, said, "We're recording all of television." And I was like, "Why?" And he said, "So we can figure out a way to search it." And I said, have you gotten the copyright from those people to do that? Have you actually reached out? And he said, why should we do that? Why do we need to do that? And I said, well, because if you have recorded, then you'll have it recorded, then you'll have the search for it, and then nobody else can do it, and then you'll dominate it. And he was like, uh huh. And I was like, that's wrong to do that. And he was like, okay. And we moved on. And it was a really interesting moment for me, that they really were super interested in owning every piece of information on the planet. It was really, it was a revelatory moment for me. Talk about what we have now.
3:05 Speaker 02 Talk a little bit about DuckDuckGo first, about what you're trying to do, because you have been a search engine for how long?
3:11 Speaker 03 Eleven years.
3:12 Speaker 02 Right. So talk about what you do precisely, and how it contrasts with Google.
3:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, so DuckDuckGo is a general internet privacy company at this point, and we help you essentially escape the creepiness and tracking on the internet. We've been running this non-tracking search engine alternative to Google for 11 years. We're doing about a billion searches a month. It's about 1% market share in the US now, fourth largest search engine. And then we also operate a mobile browser that, and browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox, that block trackers across the internet. So as you're expressing, Google and Facebook are the largest purveyors of these trackers, but we block hundreds, tracks from hundreds of companies. And then we also enable more encryption on the internet. So when you go to a website, you know, there's a HTTP, HTTPS version, sometimes sites have the unencrypted version and the encrypted version, but they send you to the unencrypted version.
4:02 Speaker 03 And so we force you to go to-
4:03 Speaker 02 That's in order to follow you.
4:04 Speaker 03 Yeah. And so we force you to go to the encrypted version, which helps your ISP is not from tracking you. So it's all one download that just helps you escape tracking on the internet.
4:12 Speaker 02 So why did you decide to do this? Because a while ago, everyone was welcoming this idea of convenience. I think Marguerite Besterg said that to me, is that we've traded convenience for something better. And she was talking about search engines she uses in Europe that are different. And Google's convenient, Google has mail, Google has maps, Google has this. And I'm using that because you're in the search business. Why did you decide to do this in the first place?
4:35 Speaker 03 Well, I have a tech policy background, so my graduate degrees in tech policy from IT. And I originally got into search, actually because I was interested in search. But immediately after launching it, I started getting privacy questions. This was well before Snowden, still 2008. And so I did my own investigation and found two really interesting things. One, searches are essentially the most private thing on the internet. You just type in all your deepest, darkest secrets.
5:00 Speaker 02 Right, absolutely.
5:02 Speaker 03 And the second thing is you don't need to actually track people to make money on search. So, Google still, to this day, and there's been congressional testimony, actually the hearing that I was at, the representative from Google said this, they still make most of their money off the same way Dr. Goo makes money, contextual advertising. Nothing to do with following you around. It's keywords on the search page. So you type in car, you get a car ad. And you could do that without tracking anybody. And so what I realized pretty quickly is that's a better user experience and just made the decision not to track people. At the beginning of that, that wasn't the main differentiator because we weren't as aware of all the privacy harms. But as time has gone on, it's become the main driver for people to adopt Dr. Goo.
5:42 Speaker 02 To adopt that. So, talk about contextual advertising, because this is just a basic business, is if you type whatever. And, you know, a lot of ways, if you think about a Google or what you are, search is like sort of a database of human intentions.
5:53 Speaker 03 Yes, this is a great history of advertising, and I think it helps to explain the current market. And so, it used to be the case, as you're saying, and the internet started, all the way up until the mid 2000s, this contextual advertising was basically all advertising. So, on search, it's just the context of the page. But it was also the case on publisher sites. I'm sure you remember, like, sites used to sell their own ads. They would put advertising based on the content of the article. And then the mid 2000s, it switched to behavioral advertising, which is creepy ads, the ones that kind of follow you around the internet. And two companies dominate that because they have all the data on people, you know, Google and Facebook. But, there's been no real proof that that is really better, and it's arguably way worse
6:35 Speaker 03 for the publishers who then have ceded all sorts of money to Google and Facebook and have decimated the business.
6:40 Speaker 02 So, talk about that shift to behavioral advertising, because when you did it, I mean, years ago at Google also, there used to be a ticker that used to run across when you entered Google about what people were searching for at that moment. And they stripped it of dirty stuff, which was quite a bit, apparently. But you would see things like, you know, horses...
6:58 Speaker 02 Jam French and you'd be like, what the fuck is that person searching for? Like, you know, I would sit there and I'm like, I don't even understand that query. Talk about how it shifted from that to the idea of behavioral. Why go there?
7:13 Speaker 03 What happened was is you had publishers selling the biggest inventory. So the top of the page banner advertising and then they still wanted to make some more money. So they had seeded the bottom of the page to ad networks they didn't want to sell. And Google's was the biggest. It was AdSense. It's not a company they actually acquired.
7:29 Speaker 02 Called DoubleClick.
7:30 Speaker 03 Before that.
7:31 Speaker 02 Before DoubleClick.
7:31 Speaker 03 The one before that. And then they acquired DoubleClick 2007. And so slowly publishers kind of seeded some of their page over to it. And then Google ended up having all this behavioral data. So if you search for something, you could then follow people around with that search. And those advertisements became more lucrative. And then slowly publishers seeded most of their page over to this behavioral advertising. However, my proposition is innovation and contextual advertising hasn't happened in the last 10 years. And it may be just as lucrative. So you can imagine videos, articles, similarly parsing out what the real content of it is and putting ads just based on that, not based on you. And there's been a little evidence of this after GDPR.
8:13 Speaker 03 New York Times, for example, got rid of all the behavioral advertising in Europe and saw an increase in revenue. Now, partly that's because they just got rid of the middleman. But partly that's because it actually is useful advertising. Like you write an article on airplanes and you have an airplane ad.
8:27 Speaker 02 Right. So what was this? Why the shift then to behavioral? Because they just decided to do it?
8:32 Speaker 03 Yeah. It's strategic for their companies. Because if you think about their position, they're the ones with the data monopolies. And so if they are going to run an ad network, they should run it based on behavioral. Because, you know, no one can compete with them on that. The real reason why that's enabled is because there's been no real regulation in tech that would have prevented it.
8:50 Speaker 02 No, there's zero regulation. Right.
8:52 Speaker 03 There's the one from, you know, 230, but that's it.
8:55 Speaker 02 Right. Talk about 230. Do people know what Section 230 is? Well, those who don't, it's the Communications Decency Act, which I wrote about for The Washington Post 109 years ago, was an act that they put through, most of which was stripped out. Most of the act was deemed, it was started by people who were worried about dirty stuff on the Internet, essentially. And within the Communications Decency Act was Section 230, which gave Internet companies broad immunity from anything that happened on their platform. And it was designed so that these companies would be able to grow and not be sued to death, essentially. And their businesses wouldn't, would be able to, they were small businesses at the time, and it continues to protect big companies like Google and Facebook, YouTube.
9:40 Speaker 02 And when you mention the idea of, now, there's been some eking away at 230 around sex trafficking and some other things, but essentially, if you mention the idea of removing 230 to Internet companies, they start immediately vomiting on their shoes, because it would mean they would be subject to legal attacks, which would be unprecedented, presumably, correct?
10:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, it's the, I think it's the specter of any regulation, right?
10:06 Speaker 02 Right.
10:07 Speaker 03 But the idea that there would be no regulation on digital forever is ridiculous. I mean, every other area of technology has regulation to pull back some of these externalities.
10:16 Speaker 02 Right.
10:17 Speaker 03 So I think it's inevitable, it's just a matter of what it looks like and when.
10:20 Speaker 02 All right, so they moved to behavioral advertising, I want to get to that legislation in a second, because you were proposing your own legislation, correct? They get this behavioral information, talk a little bit about what it does, because people sort of are very unclear about what happens when this occurs.
10:36 Speaker 03 I mean, essentially, these trackers exist across the web. So when you go to a website, like Recode even, there are trackers hiding behind it. So you think you're just interacting with the site you're on, but really, there are companies like Google and Facebook and many others, kind of slurping up your information, your browsing history. And so through these various mechanisms, they're getting purchase history, location history, browsing history, search history, and when you add all that together...
11:03 Speaker 02 And made more important by mobile.
11:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. It's harder to block stuff on mobile.
11:08 Speaker 02 Right.
11:09 Speaker 03 You get location much more granular. Some of these are sending like hundreds of data points a day. And so you get a really robust profile of you. And then when you go to now a website that has advertising for one of these networks, there's a real time bidding against you as a person. And there's an auction to sell you an ad based on all this creepy information you didn't even realize people captured. And I think that's what people are finally starting to realize. And they've been going on the idea that they were just interacting with this one's website. But once they find out that all these tracking is going on, they become incensed effectively.
11:46 Speaker 02 Do you think people are actually mad?
11:48 Speaker 03 I do, yeah.
11:49 Speaker 02 Explain that to me. Because a lot of the tech companies say they don't care about this. They don't care about privacy. I just interviewed Scott McNeely recently.
11:55 Speaker 03 He's the famous one.
11:56 Speaker 02 He's famous for saying-
11:57 Speaker 03 Privacy is dead.
11:58 Speaker 02 No.
11:59 Speaker 03 Get over it, privacy is dead.
12:00 Speaker 02 You have no privacy, get over it. You have, you, you, privacy is dead, get over it.
12:04 Speaker 03 I mean, so we track this, like do national surveys very closely. And it's increased again and again and again of people, once they understand what's going on, they want to take action. And so there is a setting, which is part of the legislation that, our legislation is based off, do not track. So in your browser, in most browsers, if you delve into the settings, into the privacy settings, there's something that says do not track. And our measurements, and it's not just us, because Gizmodo measured their sites, between 10 and 25%, depending on what you look at, people have enabled that setting. So they've actually kind of, people are like, no one ever goes into settings and looks at privacy. It's not true.
12:47 Speaker 03 Literally, tens of millions of Americans have gone into their browser settings and, and checked this thing. And so people do care, and that has just climbed up and up and up as the knowledge of the tracking is going on. Because before you knew about it, you were okay with it, because you didn't realize it was so invasive. But as like after came to Analytica and all the stories about the tracking, that number just keeps going up and up and up.
13:09 Speaker 02 So one of the things a lot of people do bring up with me still, though, is, well, I don't really care. I don't have much to hide. I don't know what's, doesn't matter. I get that all the time. Like, who cares if they know if I went to Best Buy and then bought up, like, whatever I bought. Talk to why that might be not the best way to think about it.
13:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's kind of two answers to that. One is philosophical in that, you know, privacy is a fundamental human right. And so you don't need to care or hide anything to exercise your rights. Like, you wouldn't say that for speech. Just because you have nothing to say doesn't mean you should have a right to free speech. So that's kind of on the philosophical side. On the harm side, there are some that people don't realize. So a lot of people really don't like the keep ads flying them around. Some people seem to be fine with that. At a more deeper level, there's this thing called the filter bubble, which is that, you know, recommendation algorithms and in particular, search results are tailored to you. And that means that you're not seeing what everyone else is seeing. And that actually distorts the democracy. And that's a real harm to individual people and society.
14:14 Speaker 03 And then there's just the general identity theft and data breaches, which is happening over and over again, which is one of the main drivers for adopting stuff like that.
14:23 Speaker 02 So you've submitted legislation, you've created legislation that you would like someone...
14:29 Speaker 03 Model legislation, yeah.
14:30 Speaker 02 That you would like someone to submit to Congress. Explain what you want to do.
14:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, so this is in the landscape of all the privacy legislation. And I would love to hear the nuance of it.
14:40 Speaker 02 Now, just to understand, we do not have a national privacy bill in this country at all. Other countries do, and much more stringent, like GDPR in Europe. But we don't have one. We have one in California that's about to come online, but the lobbyists are trying to defang it rather substantively. There are 10 others in states across the country. I don't know where they... There are certain states that are doing it. I think Louisiana has one. There's all kinds of states.
15:07 Speaker 03 Vermont has a data broker law.
15:08 Speaker 02 Let's hope Alabama doesn't have one, but go ahead. Sorry, but Jesus Christ. All right. But there's too much of a patchwork of them, correct, across the country? The idea, there's not a national bill.
15:21 Speaker 03 There's no national bill. We really should have a national bill, like GDPR. But one of the problems with GDPR is how it's operationalized is a lot of consent dialogues. And that's called notice and consent. And people just end up clicking the consent. And so we think a better mechanism is this thing that I was talking about earlier, this do not track setting in the browser that tens of millions of people have already put on. And the fact that consumers have already adopted it and it's in the browser, it's just an amazing legislative opportunity. Just give it teeth. And it's actually a better mechanism for privacy laws because once you have this setting and it works, you don't have to deal with all the pop-ups anymore. You just set it once and then sites can't track you.
16:02 Speaker 02 Should it be set from the beginning as do not track?
16:05 Speaker 03 This is a debate, whether it should be default on or default off. I would love it to be default, you know, have to opt out of it, but I'd be happy if it was opt-in as well because I think people will.
16:16 Speaker 02 Oh, people keep tripping here. This is the second trip.
16:21 Speaker 03 That's fine.
16:22 Speaker 02 Hello, sorry. Okay. Oh, it's the same guy. Okay, it's the same guy tripping. All right, now he's just bucking with me. All right, go ahead, sorry.
16:31 Speaker 03 No worries. I think people will opt in.
16:34 Speaker 02 Let's Google.
16:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:36 Speaker 02 Out there.
16:37 Speaker 03 I think people will opt in if they have the opportunity and they can opt out of this tracking. And so what we're hoping is, there's kind of two things. One, as you said, California is getting defanged, the California bill. As that happens, the pressure for a federal bill is going down this year because there's no, if it's all defanged, there's no pressure to, you know, pass something that preempts it. And so one thing that, but still, all the people in the country really want something passed. And so one option here is this would be a much simpler thing to pass. Just give a do not track mandate for no tracking for that setting, much easier than comprehensive legislation. The other thing is that any comprehensive legislation that gets passed, do not track can be the
17:21 Speaker 03 mechanism. So we're hoping that it gets added to any larger bill as the mechanism to help people opt out.
17:28 Speaker 02 So why do people have to opt out? You don't have to opt, why do they have to opt into it, I guess? Opt into it? Because you don't have to opt into clean water. You don't have to opt into, like, I think I'd like my water clean or dirty. Like, it's kind of crazy, the stuff that consumers have to do. In order to protect themselves compared to almost any other thing they use. You don't, again, opt in, I'd like the tires that don't fall off. Opt in, I'd like the, you know, I'd like the food that isn't tainted, please. Why is that mentality around?
18:02 Speaker 03 I think the mentality is around because of the lobbying that it would distort the advertising business model. And I would love it to be opt-in by default. But in a realistic way, I'm, I think if it was operationalized as a way to opt out, I think that would be effective because as you said before, the other argument is some people don't care and that gives people really the choice.
18:26 Speaker 02 That they just could leave it there?
18:27 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:27 Speaker 02 We're going to take a quick break now, but we'll be back after this with Gabe Weinberg, the CEO of DuckDuckGo.
18:34 Speaker 04 How about a latte?
18:35 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
18:36 Speaker 04 Vanilla?
18:37 Speaker 01 Caramel?
18:38 Speaker 04 Blueberry?
18:39 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pipe varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
19:01 Speaker 05 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
19:05 Speaker 05 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
19:31 Speaker 02 How is it operating against a site like Google or a big site where you're 1%? How do you do that?
19:39 Speaker 03 It's been interesting. We try to educate people about privacy and that they're alternative. So our main issue is just not everybody knows about us. There's 20% of people that we think would be interested in switching to DuckDuckGo, but it's hard to convey all these privacy concepts. I'll give you an example. We've been talking about the filter bubble for years. In 2012, we ran a study on Google that we think influenced the 2012 election. That's how long ago it was. But we had to speak for 10 minutes to explain what the filter bubble was back then. But after 2016, in the last two years, now we can talk about the filter bubble, just name it, and people know what it is generally. How many people know what the filter bubble is? Just curious.
20:22 Speaker 02 Explain the filter bubble.
20:25 Speaker 03 Well, first of all, that percentage is very high, so I like that. But it's the idea that, for search in particular, as an example, when you search, you expect to get the results, right? If you search for gun control or abortion, you expect, we search at the same time, right here, you would expect to get the same thing. But that's actually not what we found when we did a study on Google.
20:44 Speaker 02 Yes, they give you different search results.
20:45 Speaker 03 Yeah, and people don't realize that. And so, in addition, we found that it varies a lot by location. And so, if you take that to the extreme, let's say that voting districts are getting different results for candidates or issues, it can skew the polarization of that district very easily over time, because people who are undecided are actually searching for these topics. And people generally click on the first link, and if you're controlling that first link in that district, that's what people are going to learn about.
21:12 Speaker 02 So Anand was just talking about the idea of people that shouldn't have this kind of power having this kind of power. How do you look at it? Because it is a group of maybe 1,000 people making these decisions in Silicon Valley, pretty much, if that many. And recently, I did an interview with Tristan Harris, and he was talking about, he called it the climate change of culture, is what we're going. The only positive part about it is there are only 1,000 people whose minds you have to change on this. How do you look at that small amount of people making decisions for the entire world, really? And what can we do about that?
21:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, I look at it structurally and I think that on the consumer side that we've talked about, there needs to be a way to opt out which would lower the power, right? On the kind of structural business side, that the core of this problem, at least the one that we were talking about here, is data monopolies, right? It's the collection of data profiles and there are ways to split those up. So, some people are talking about extreme measures, which I'd be in favor of, the spinning off companies, but there are other ways to do it, such as not allowing data to be shared between, you know, different business units. So if you're on Instagram and you, you know, are browsing something, that data cannot be shared and used on Facebook or WhatsApp.
22:35 Speaker 02 Which was precisely the reason Facebook bought that company.
22:37 Speaker 03 Yeah. And that's why it should have been rejected in the first place. But at this point, one thing you can do is legislate, and it was part of our proposal, is that if you go to that site, you can't share data back to the other sites. And so that would effectively add more competition and less power in these decisions.
22:54 Speaker 02 Except they sit next to each other. They happen to on that same ridiculous campus they have. You know, they share the same kombucha stand, so it's hard to...
23:03 Speaker 03 That's why the argument for separating them more strictly is pretty solid.
23:08 Speaker 02 What about opening up their data that they have collected? Both companies, for example? Because essentially, we're talking about Facebook and Google, pretty much, and Amazon's just starting to get into that business, the advertising business. It's two companies right now, correct?
23:23 Speaker 03 Yeah. In the digital advertising market, absolutely. There's a... The debate's kind of out on interoperability, which is what that is. It may help in the social network space. It's less important in the search space, because as I was saying earlier, you know, you actually don't need these profiles to do good search results. They're really using search to do ads on YouTube and Gmail and all these other places. And so it could help in social networks to help someone start a social network and be able to switch all your friends a little quicker, but it probably wouldn't solve Google's problem.
23:57 Speaker 02 There hasn't been a major social network started since 2011.
24:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:01 Speaker 02 Which is amazing if you think about that. And there's a reason, because why do it? And for the rest of it, I think it's just Snapchat, correct? And he's the chief product officer for Facebook right now, as far as I can tell, because they steal all his ideas. So, how do you then...
24:19 Speaker 02 Shift that, how do you stop that? Just separating them, which are the ways you think should happen?
24:24 Speaker 03 I really think you have to get to the core of this data monopoly. That's the key. And I think part of the problem actually has been that market definition. It's like people think of it as search market, social network market. It's what you saw in Congress too. But it really is the digital advertising market. That's where the domination is.
24:41 Speaker 02 Right.
24:41 Speaker 03 And so you have to change the digital advertising market. You can do that by having, you know, putting more Chinese walls between companies. You can do that by doing something like Do Not Track, which would force companies to be more contextual. And so all of a sudden, you'd be steering the industry back to the contextual from behavioral. Because, you know, 25% of people now, you would advertise on contextual. Behavioral will be outlawed for them.
25:07 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
25:07 Speaker 03 And so that would just break up the competitive advantage, basically, of the data profiles.
25:13 Speaker 02 And when you have behavior, do you think, do you think that's even possible? Because the idea is adding more, with AI is adding more and more behavioral data in order to track you. And in company, in countries like China and other places, they're using that behavioral data very, they're using a lot of it, including facial recognition. The companies here, I think, are just dying to get into facial recognition and know the controversies around it. So it doesn't seem like backing away from behavioral is something, they seem to be doubling down in behavioral.
25:44 Speaker 03 That's why I believe you need government regulation in it. And to your point, you can look at China as an example. And so not only should you push things back to contextual, but you probably should have some lines, bright lines, that you can't cross in behavioral. Right? You saw San Francisco ban it the other day.
26:01 Speaker 02 This week, San Francisco banned facial, facial recognition
26:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:05 Speaker 02 ... software being used in the city. Is that correct?
26:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's right. For, for government.
26:10 Speaker 02 For government.
26:11 Speaker 03 Another good example, which isn't talked about that much, is political advertising on, you know, on Facebook. So, you know, there's
26:18 Speaker 02 Always talked about.
26:19 Speaker 03 Yeah. Well, not this part. There's this disclosure, but arguably, there should be a ban on behavioral advertising to some level of people. Just blanket for political advertising.
26:30 Speaker 02 To some level of people, what do you mean?
26:31 Speaker 03 So like a thousand people or 10,000, you can pick your cutoff and then say you cannot target ads at a population less than that amount. Because what's happening now is the behavioral advertising is just targeting you, right? Or a very small amount of people. And it's using, it's manipulative in two ways. You can manipulate the targeting, so I can select just the three or five people that I think would like totally be triggered by this. And you can also do A/B testing and change words and images to get like the perfect, you know, manipulation. Tristan Harris has a better words for this. I forget what he says, but the brainstem.
27:08 Speaker 02 Yes, it goes down the brainstem, yeah.
27:10 Speaker 03 Right? And that kind of stuff should be probably outlawed, especially for political advertising.
27:15 Speaker 02 To individualize people.
27:17 Speaker 03 Yeah. And but not just individual, probably at some threshold that's significantly high. Like they make the argument, oh, this is just like TV, our disclosures are going to be like TV. Well, you know, you can't target, or you might be able eventually, which also should be outlawed, but in TV, you weren't targeting down to the individual person.
27:34 Speaker 02 Right. You're targeting great groups of people.
27:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:37 Speaker 02 You also couldn't just put ads up the way they do on Facebook.
27:39 Speaker 03 Right. And do all this testing. You couldn't do, you can't test a thousand ads.
27:43 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. So do you think our regulators are up to this task? And you're ma, you're writing your own legislation, I'm assuming you're running your company at the same time, and you don't, you're not a legislator.
27:52 Speaker 03 That's true.
27:53 Speaker 02 So how do you look at our legislators? Is there more strength on elsewhere in the world or in this country? Let's talk just about this country, because I think most people saw the Facebook hearings.
28:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:06 Speaker 02 And Mark looked great in that hearing. And he's not the most articulate of people. It's largely because most legislators looked so bad and looked so ignorant. And so when you say Mark looks so good, it was because it was such a low, low bar that it was hard not to. I think they could have put a ham sandwich there and it would have looked pretty good. How do you, but that said, I do have talked to legislators who are quite smart. There's a lot of them in Washington.
28:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:32 Speaker 02 And especially in the regulatory agencies and elsewhere. What's the problem from a regulatory, is it the money these companies are throwing at lobbyists at them? Or is it just a lack of will? Or is it? Ignorance, how does that change?
28:47 Speaker 03 Right, so to answer your first question, I mean, there are very smart people there. And just like running a company, you know, they hire staff. And there's lots of senators who've hired really good tech staff, and there's a handful, maybe five to 10. And they're trying to write some of this legislation. So I don't think you need the whole Senate writing it, for example. And so I'm actually pretty encouraged on that regard, the level of thought that's been going into some of these proposals. I think that writing something like GDPR is complicated. It was, Europe was doing it for 20 years. I mean, it was an update of a 1995 law, and then they took, you know, five years to update it, basically.
29:31 Speaker 03 And so we're just getting started this year, so there is some amount of time that it will take. That's one reason we proposed this legislation, because you can do this right now. Like, this is an easy thing you could do. Like, solving a lot of it all at once is difficult. I'd prefer to do it a little bit in piecemeal, as opposed to just one thing and then be done. That's the other thing I don't really like about our government system, is we pass something and then we don't touch it for 20 years, which is what happened to, you know, the CDA. It would be better if we passed something every year or two and kind of tweaked it.
30:03 Speaker 02 So what do you imagine, of the many different things that are happening, like right now, FTC is considering fining Facebook $5 billion, which I call the parking ticket.
30:14 Speaker 03 Yes, I agree with you.
30:15 Speaker 02 Thank you. I'm correct.
30:17 Speaker 03 Need another zero.
30:20 Speaker 02 Two zeros, actually, I've decided.
30:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, that would do it.
30:23 Speaker 02 Two zeros, yes, that would do it. But the concept is fining them, taxing them is another way, regulatory guardrails is another way, and breakup, antitrust action for presumably breakup, and then not letting them buy anything.
30:40 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:41 Speaker 02 Of those things, what do you imagine is the most effective right now?
30:47 Speaker 03 I think not letting them buy things would be good.
30:51 Speaker 02 Right.
30:51 Speaker 03 Anything that gets at, if you're talking about Google and Facebook and the digital advertising market, anything that gets at the data monopoly would be good. Of those, you know, Breaking Up could do it, Chinese Wall could do it, John Trac could do it. All of those would do something.
31:09 Speaker 02 And why, how much time do you imagine it will take? There is a tech clash going on right now, and it's largely because of the 2016 election and the idea that the Russians were customers of these companies. Do you imagine that will continue, or do you think it's gonna peter out in the next thing? How dangerous is it for the next elections that these continue to be issues? Do you think these companies have finally sort of come to Jesus and said, oh dear, we've made some errors here?
31:39 Speaker 03 I think you're seeing that because all of their announcements have just been centered around privacy, right? So they're, they're feeling this is a real thing at this point. Maybe Scott McNeely is still saying that, but everybody else is, is now embracing at least the word privacy, whether they mean it or not.
31:54 Speaker 02 Right.
31:55 Speaker 03 I think you're gonna see the tech clash continue until, you know, people think there's some meaningful change. I worry about the breakup because that takes a really long time, you know, historically.
32:06 Speaker 02 Right.
32:07 Speaker 03 And some of these other things can be done much quicker. And so I'm hoping that something will get done quicker. I'm a little saddened by what's happened in California, because I think that's slowing things down.
32:18 Speaker 02 Right.
32:19 Speaker 03 But what I haven't heard anyone talk about, which is interesting, is that got started by a ballot measure, for people who don't know.
32:24 Speaker 02 Everything in California gets started by a ballot measure, just so you know.
32:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, one person did that.
32:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
32:29 Speaker 03 There's nothing to stop somebody from doing it again, if it gets watered down.
32:32 Speaker 02 That someone put on something else.
32:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, just, or put on the same thing again.
32:36 Speaker 02 Right.
32:36 Speaker 03 You know, if it gets totally watered down, just do the same thing.
32:39 Speaker 02 And yet, we don't have privacy in place. We're gonna take another break now. We'll be back after this with Gabe Weinberg, the CEO of DuckDuckGo.
32:49 Speaker 04 How about a latte?
32:50 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
32:51 Speaker 04 Vanilla?
32:52 Speaker 01 Caramel?
32:52 Speaker 04 Blueberry?
32:53 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
33:15 Speaker 05 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
33:19 Speaker 05 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
33:46 Speaker 02 Talk to, just very quick, we have just a few more minutes. What can people do right now besides using DuckDuckGo? What are some of the things they should be doing to protect themselves online and things that they don't realize they're being tracked? Besides, please, please don't buy one of their internet home devices.
34:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, that would be good.
34:03 Speaker 02 Yeah. My son goes around and unplugs them all in our house. Yeah, they don't work.
34:10 Speaker 03 So.
34:11 Speaker 02 They make lovely paperweights, but go ahead.
34:13 Speaker 03 Facebook is an interesting challenge. I mean, I haven't been to Facebook for a long time and there's plenty of studies that show that's a healthy choice.
34:22 Speaker 02 Yeah.
34:23 Speaker 03 But there aren't great alternatives to it. And so that one, I think you should leave. And a lot of people have.
34:30 Speaker 02 Just leave Facebook?
34:31 Speaker 03 Just leave it, yeah. For Google, there are actually alternatives in like every category. So, you know, we're in search, but you know, there's alternatives in emails, alternatives in
34:40 Speaker 02 Such as?
34:41 Speaker 03 Proton Mail is a big one. We use Fastmail at DuckDuckGo. And, you know, Docs, there's things like Zoho. They're not all super private like us, but they're often paid but cheap alternatives that put privacy first. And so I would leave the services because the idea that their alternatives don't exist is just nonsense.
35:04 Speaker 02 Well, although it's inconvenient because they all work together on your phones or whatever you have, they all seamlessly work together.
35:11 Speaker 03 You know, I've been out for a long time, but it's totally productive. I mean, you just click on a different app on your phone. They're on your home screen, you know, you go into a different one.
35:21 Speaker 02 Okay. What else should people do to protect themselves?
35:26 Speaker 03 So, in the devices themselves, there's a bunch of privacy settings that actually matter. And we have a blog at spreadprivacy.com with device tips that we just, education wrote it all up. And there are things like you can turn off the ad tracking on a lot of, on Apple, for instance. You can use encryption end to end. You can basically encrypt your, Apple's by default, but you can do your laptop. These are things that take like an hour, but you run through the checklist and then you're a lot more private.
35:58 Speaker 02 So encrypting your laptop?
36:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:01 Speaker 02 Encrypted your phone or having a phone?
36:03 Speaker 03 Encrypted everything, changing, like basically doing all the opt outs you can do, which we have like a list and you can run through the settings and then switching off of these services, kind of voting with your feet.
36:15 Speaker 02 What about mapping?
36:16 Speaker 03 So, we use Apple Maps for our search results.
36:21 Speaker 02 They're such bad maps.
36:22 Speaker 03 They are, they have gotten a lot better.
36:25 Speaker 02 Oh, sure.
36:26 Speaker 03 I would give them a try.
36:26 Speaker 02 All right, okay, because they're terrible maps. That's why, I mean, it's hard not to use a Google map because they're so good.
36:32 Speaker 03 I would give them a try.
36:34 Speaker 02 Okay. All right. Anything else? Any other things?
36:37 Speaker 03 Those are the top ones, because I don't want to scare people that it's difficult, you know? It really is, you spend a few minutes on this and you can be out. Like, I think people think it's such a gargantuan thing to leave these companies. I don't think that's actually true.
36:50 Speaker 02 And what about cameras and audio? Just so you know, when I was visiting Facebook, I know Mark had his camera covered.
36:59 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah.
36:59 Speaker 02 He had his audio covered. He had everything covered.
37:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. When you, you know, I... People conflate privacy and security a lot, but I totally agree. So on the security side, you should definitely have a webcam cover and use two-factor authentication. You know, that thing that texts you all the time.
37:15 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
37:16 Speaker 03 You should use that for all services. So, most services that you have, your email is the most important, but you can set up this two-factor authentication much better because most of the hacks that have happened, a lot of the identity theft, has all been from phishing on your email.
37:30 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
37:30 Speaker 03 And, you know, you click on something, type in your password, and two-factor authentication is just another layer that prevents that from happening.
37:37 Speaker 02 All right. And covering, and when you get into things like facial recognition and other issues, as people start to use VR and AR and things like that, what would you advise people?
37:47 Speaker 03 Facial recognition is hard. There are ways to actually change, like, wear things and change your face so you don't get captured by the cameras, but I think that...
37:56 Speaker 02 Wear things and change your face?
37:58 Speaker 03 Yeah. You can, like...
37:59 Speaker 02 Mask. It's called a mask, but go ahead.
38:02 Speaker 03 Yeah. More minor things. I forget what it was, but you can, like, put, like, aluminum foil or something that, like, freaks things out.
38:08 Speaker 02 Okay.
38:09 Speaker 03 But I'm not recommending that. You don't see anyone wearing it. I think the problem with facial is you're gonna need laws, you know, with some of this stuff. And so, San Francisco's great, you know, starting the trend there.
38:21 Speaker 02 Okay. To not to use facial, and companies not to use facial recognition.
38:25 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. You're gonna need, that one is gonna need to be solved at a more societal level.
38:29 Speaker 02 Do you think people realize how much facial recognition is used in this country?
38:33 Speaker 03 No, not at all. There was a, the Privacy Project, the New York Times, as you know, you're aware, there was a really interesting story like two weeks ago where they, they took, I don't know if you read that one, they took camera...
38:46 Speaker 02 It was part of the project.
38:47 Speaker 03 Yeah. Were part of that story?
38:49 Speaker 02 No, that's a project.
38:50 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah. So, they, they took webcam, live webcam footage that was just on a camera and just...
38:58 Speaker 03 Put it up on Amazon, their facial recognition, off the shelf stuff. And then we're able to like de-identify a bunch of different people.
39:04 Speaker 02 Yeah.
39:04 Speaker 03 And then called them up and was like, I saw you walking here.
39:06 Speaker 02 Right.
39:07 Speaker 03 And it took, it took a hundred dollars in like three hours.
39:10 Speaker 02 Right, well, exactly. And they also are using things much more seriously in workplaces to watch your face as you work and also to decide whether to hire you based on your facial expressions. And what they're trying to do right now, from what I understand, is track, some of the, some of the new software will track your face and expressions during an interview and then match it to their top performers who, whose faces they were also tracking and therefore don't hire you if you're not one of their top performers' facial expressions.
39:40 Speaker 03 It's crazy. And this is another area, just bias in algorithms in general. But this is to your earlier point is that, I guess the central point of regulation is there's been no regulation for 20 years, right? So there's a, there's just a dearth of regulation and you're not going to solve it in one shot. And so like this bias in algorithms probably needs to be a separate bill, right?
40:00 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
40:00 Speaker 03 AI in general, this area, facial recognition, we need to tackle these problems separately. But there, there are the biggest problems and so we should be doing it year after year. I worry that there's going to be a checkbox, like we pass something and then it's going to be done. We're just going to have to keep the pressure on.
40:15 Speaker 02 Do you ever imagine, and I'll get to questions from the audience, that will ever escape the enormous power of something like Google? Because what it's become is that it is the answer machine for everything, really. Even though you have 1%, that's, they have 90% everywhere.
40:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, I, I do. I think if we have these structural changes, I think you could see the market open up. We are a small company, right? And so we're only 65 people. And so you're like, well, how do you compete? And I mentioned earlier, we use Apple Maps, right? And we could debate how good they are. But in each of these verticals, there are actually really good answers. So Yelp for restaurants, which we use, you know, we use Wikipedia, just like Google does for-
41:03 Speaker 02 Yelp is getting crushed by Google.
41:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. And so, but it's not like their answers aren't good, right? And so if the market opened up a bit, these companies could thrive more. And we use them and put together good search results just based on all these other companies. And so I think that the idea that there, this magic- Kind of magic AI that no one can compete with, I think, is false. Because if you look around in all these categories, there actually are good alternatives.
41:27 Speaker 02 But given that the amount of money they have, the amount of money they make, and the fact that consumers like them, like using them. I think one of the issues around all these tech companies is, you know, Amazon's so great about delivery, even though they're ruining the lives of retailers across the country. I'm sorry about that. Or causing people to have jobs, or their contractors are treated badly within the stores. But, gosh, they delivered my, you know, they delivered my iced tea really quickly, and it's delicious.
41:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:57 Speaker 02 Like, or Google, it's, ah, they're a horrible monopoly, and yet, wow, they were fast on giving me that answer if so-and-so is alive anymore, or whatever they decide.
42:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, I mean, it's interesting.
42:08 Speaker 02 I always search people if they're dead or not.
42:11 Speaker 03 Facebook, trust in Facebook has precipitously dropped
42:15 Speaker 02 Right.
42:15 Speaker 03 in the past year. And so I don't think it's inevitable that trust is always at high levels, even if people kind of like.
42:24 Speaker 02 Right, trust in Facebook has dropped, usage has not.
42:27 Speaker 03 Yes, well, that's because there has not been a great alternative, right?
42:30 Speaker 02 Right.
42:30 Speaker 03 People don't necessarily believe or want to believe the healthy, you know, ness of quitting. But trust itself has eroded. And so I think trust could erode in these other companies as well.
42:42 Speaker 02 And last question, are you worried about who runs these companies at some point? Because one of my worries has always been, many years ago, I was in, I wrote a story about Google trying to take over Yahoo's search.
42:54 Speaker 03 Yep.
42:54 Speaker 02 I think I've talked about this before. And they, I, they were gonna try to, it was gonna get them 90% of the market at this point. Yahoo was still a substantively large search, did substantially large search business, and Microsoft was the third one. And I was very much, you know, I was struck by they can't have 90%. Why isn't our government stepping in to do something about that? That's a ridiculous amount of market share. And so I, a line I wrote was, at least Microsoft knew they were thugs. Google pretends they're all happy with their funny balls and their crazy eating habits and their weird clothes and stuff like that. But they're still, as adorable as they are, they're still just as evil as Microsoft was. And so I was making that point, and I think it was Eric Schmidt who called me up and said, that's really mean, like, that you say we're thugs.
43:38 Speaker 02 And I said, well, I think you're worse than thugs because you don't know you're thugs, and you are thugs, and therefore you're worse than thugs. And he was like, we're not thugs, we're really good people. Were really good people. And I said, I get that, but I can't imagine a world where you have a company of this much power over information. What if someone, you know, of course, it's like three clicks to Hitler, but that's what I said. It was like, what if Hitler ran Google? What if someone who wasn't so nice ran Google? And it was, and it was like, well, they don't. And I was like, what if they do? And they said, what if they don't? And so, are you worried about the concentration of power in the hands of, again, a very small amount of people?
44:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I worry that, you're basically saying, you know, they're, they intend good, right? And it's like, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. And I believe, like, we did this filter bubble study, that they did influence the 2012 election. Now, a lot of people on the left liked the outcome. And what we found, by the way, was, when you searched for stuff, we found this thing called magic keywords, where if you search for something, and you search for something subsequent, you would get extra results inserted based on the previous search. And so, Obama was a magic keyword. So if you search for Obama and then gun control, you get three gun control results in the
44:59 Speaker 03 results. Romney was not a magic keyword. And so, all these people-
45:02 Speaker 02 No, he was not a magic keyword.
45:04 Speaker 03 Yeah. And so, all these people searched for Romney and Obama, and there were tens of millions of extra Obama results inserted across the country for that entire amount of the election. And, you know, we don't know what that changed, but I presume it actually did change a lot. Because people were searching just, you know, random issues that they wanted to hear about, and they were just getting Obama's take on it, not Romney's take.
45:26 Speaker 02 And do you believe that was purposeful?
45:28 Speaker 03 No, I don't. I think it's totally unintentional. It was a result of the algorithm, you know, and, and they were questioned on it, and they were basically like, oops. And kind of the answer was, you know, when we created these magic keywords, Romney was less popular at the time, you know, it was a year before. And that just happened. But it was probably a tiny change that no one even knew about that had a big impact.
45:50 Speaker 02 Okay, questions from the audience? Lots of them. Okay, let's start here.
45:54 Speaker 06 A question about how this conversation could or should change once it moves from the digital world. So, a lot of times when we talk about privacy, especially tonight, we're talking about digital-first problems, or problems that are because of digital-first companies. But specifically, the advertising example. Now we're seeing addressable advertising on TV, where you can be just as targeted as you are online on your TV screen. And that can change, depends on who they think are in the room at that time.
46:23 Speaker 02 Streaming.
46:24 Speaker 06 Yeah.
46:24 Speaker 02 It's a bit of streaming, yeah.
46:25 Speaker 06 All of it. So how does that conversation change, now that it's not just digital? And it's really everywhere?
46:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, so, in a sense, it is digital, because the streaming, the conversion from analog to digital on TV is a digital conversion. It doesn't feel digital, because it doesn't look like you're browsing the internet. But a lot of it is still going over the internet. And so if you had something like Do Not Track, it could apply to all of these mechanisms, as long as it, you know, remains digital. And so I think it would apply to that situation, as well as the kind of billboards. You know, there's been talk about individualized billboards.
47:01 Speaker 02 Right. Well, you saw the Tom Cruise, maybe, Minority Report, right?
47:04 Speaker 03 Yes.
47:05 Speaker 02 They clicked his eyes, and then it says, "Hello, Mr. Nakamura. Would you like more fleece culottes, or whatever the heck you wanted last time?"
47:12 Speaker 06 Well, addressable ads on cable boxes, that comes through.
47:16 Speaker 02 Yeah.
47:17 Speaker 06 The data cable companies have. Doesn't necessarily, yes, if you probably have some digital information coming in, but it's wrong.
47:26 Speaker 02 Well, they want to get the same information Google gets. Cable companies and telcos now are able now to get the kind of... Because they're like, if they can get it, why can't we get it? And usually, telcos were prohibited from getting that kind of... But now they're... And the point is, you're right. If they get it, why don't we get it?
47:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I agree with your premise that they're trying to copy the tracking business model everywhere, right? To compete. And if it's outlawed some one place, it should be outlawed everywhere.
47:54 Speaker 02 Yep. Next question?
47:55 Speaker 07 I have a silly question.
47:56 Speaker 02 Okay.
47:58 Speaker 07 Why'd you name it Duck Duck Go?
47:59 Speaker 02 Ah, that's a good question. It's not a silly question.
48:02 Speaker 03 It is a good question.
48:03 Speaker 02 I didn't know the answer to that.
48:04 Speaker 03 And I wish I had a good answer, yeah. Which I don't.
48:07 Speaker 02 It's a really fun game.
48:08 Speaker 03 Yeah. Duck Duck Goose? Yeah.
48:13 Speaker 02 It is. Go ahead. Go ahead. You had no...
48:15 Speaker 03 That's a fact.
48:16 Speaker 02 Where were you? You were sitting there and going, "Oh, it's either gonna be like...
48:19 Speaker 03 So I was on a walk with my wife.
48:21 Speaker 02 Blue geese or duck, duck, girl?
48:22 Speaker 03 Walk with my wife.
48:23 Speaker 02 Okay.
48:23 Speaker 03 Pre even having a company. And I was gonna start something, and I was like, "That's a cool name." And didn't know what the company was.
48:31 Speaker 02 Who thought of the name?
48:32 Speaker 03 Me. Just popped in my head.
48:34 Speaker 02 Okay.
48:37 Speaker 02 All right. All right. There you have it. All right. Next. Right here.
48:40 Speaker 08 Do we have the right to be forgotten, and should we have the right to be forgotten?
48:45 Speaker 03 We currently don't in the United States. It's part of GDPR. And it's something we comply with. It's an interesting question of where to draw that line. And it hasn't been one taken up very much in the US yet.
48:59 Speaker 02 Because of the First Amendment?
49:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:01 Speaker 02 It's never gonna happen here.
49:02 Speaker 08 So then what, if you were to write an amendment, what would the amendment be? To make the right to be forgotten?
49:07 Speaker 03 You would probably need a constitutional amendment because of the First Amendment.
49:11 Speaker 02 Yeah. To change the First Amendment. That's not happening. But the idea is whether you want it or not, too. The idea, can people take bad inform... If a bad person can take bad... If there's good and bad information about a good person, a bad person can take down good information about them. And so it gets into really thorny issues. The same thing around editing tweets right now. That's their excuse. There's lots of ways they could do it, by the way.
49:33 Speaker 08 Well, it's also like, check the box. So if someone has a history, and they paid their debt to society, should they keep getting that time to time again and not be able to move past it?
49:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. Well, you know, they're not gonna change that. But the line from the movie about the social network is the internet's written in indelible ink. So that is, it's an excellent question. I just don't think, because of the First Amendment, that it will ever get any traction here. I think every single thing you do online, every drunken college picture is gonna stay there.
50:05 Speaker 03 I haven't heard anyone talking about that here.
50:08 Speaker 02 What? Drunken college pictures? I don't have any. I'm really old. Go ahead.
50:13 Speaker 09 What are you going to do, how are we going to help the advertisers who are getting progressively more and more addicted to data and have built these really robust data sets even without the Googles and the Facebooks of the world?
50:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, they have Axie and others.
50:32 Speaker 09 Yeah, you can work with Axie and you can get them with likes, you can deliver to them digitally or traditionally. And so the issue, I wonder, is also the advertisers, the P and Gs of the world, who are paying and they're going to be subsidizing and encouraging this by paying for the ads.
50:51 Speaker 03 Yeah, data's starting to come out about this and the data so far is that they're paying for a lot more for not much. Like behavioral advertising has not been that effective.
51:02 Speaker 09 But they don't necessarily believe that that's true.
51:05 Speaker 03 Right. I agree, we need empirical evidence a lot, but I think once they realize that they haven't been, you know, getting much for what they've been paying for, they're totally happy to embrace contextual advertising again.
51:19 Speaker 02 They've also given up their relationship with the consumer. Yeah, I had a really interesting conversation with the CTO of Ford and one, I said, "What's your biggest problem?" And he said, "Well, the internet companies want to suck every bit of data and chomp it back out and we have, we want a relationship with the consumer over time." They have a very different mentality towards their consumers because they buy things from them. And essentially, Google and Facebook are pass-throughs. They don't care about you. They just care, you know. So it would be interesting to see if they can regain power because you're right, it's not effective for P and G. It's not, they are start, they do start to realize this.
51:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, they don't have any agency right now.
51:57 Speaker 02 And the question is, will these big advertisers, the problem is the big advertisers are also getting disrupted by an Amazon. Like Amazon selling all their Amazon goods.
52:06 Speaker 09 Including advertising?
52:07 Speaker 02 Yes, everything. Yeah. Yeah, we didn't even talk about Amazon.
52:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, it's right now, they don't have a lot of choice because all the audience, if you want to reach billions of people, you got to go to Googles and Facebook. But if they're...
52:17 Speaker 02 And Amazon.
52:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, and Amazon. But if it's, if it's broken up a bit and contextual is back, there can be other ad networks that aren't Google and Facebook.
52:26 Speaker 02 Because they are the only road. Okay, any more questions? Last one right here.
52:30 Speaker 03 Can there be a DuckDuckGo for YouTube?
52:33 Speaker 02 There, can there be a DuckDuckGo for YouTube?
52:36 Speaker 03 It's a good question. It is one category which shouldn't hit on that doesn't have a great answer, honestly, right now. And there are great sites to put your video on. So Vimeo is a good example that I use for privately with my kids videos. But unfortunately, if you're a creator, all the eyeballs are on YouTube. It's another network effect. And so to break that network effect is very difficult.
53:03 Speaker 02 It's impossible. There's no other choice. And the expense of doing it is so high. So they can create monopolies without creating monopolies, which is really the question for our legislators.
53:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's another legislative question we didn't address. But that one's an argument for treating it as a utility at that point. If it's such a natural monopoly that nothing can really compete with it, you need to regulate it as a utility.
53:27 Speaker 02 Or change law, or change the way we do antitrust law. I think that's really, there's interesting people like Lena Kahn and others that are talking about how to change the idea of what a monopoly is, and it doesn't have to cause consumer harm. In fact, it could have consumer good. You all like all the freebies you get from all these companies. You really do. That's the problem here. It's not harmful to consumer script. It is. It's harmful to society, but it's not.
53:51 Speaker 03 There's an interesting argument. There was another New York Times article from Brian Chen, who left Facebook. And he saw, it's one anecdote, but it was interesting. He saw his purchases go down by 50% on his credit card. And so you can say, well, he wasn't seeing a lot more ads, right? Because he wasn't on Facebook seeing all the ads. And that's definitely part of it. But some part of it was also because the ads were probably manipulative, and they were kind of like manipulated him to buy stuff. And so that's arguably a direct consumer harm. It was money out of his pocket he wouldn't have spent otherwise from being manipulated.
54:23 Speaker 02 Addictiveness, which is something a lot of people are talking about. I mean, I don't use Instagram. I don't use any of these services, by the way. But I was on Instagram the other day, and I was like, I must buy that strange little object that there's. I don't know what it was. It was some bra that was better than other bras, and it was not. But it was weird. And I don't know what it was doing to my brain. I was fascinated.
54:41 Speaker 03 They probably ran a thousand ads on that thing to like get the exact emotional trigger.
54:45 Speaker 02 It was weird. I literally had to have it. I didn't buy it. But it's close.
54:48 Speaker 03 Close.
54:48 Speaker 02 Close, but not so close. Anyway, thank you so much, Gabe. This is Gabe Weinberg from DuckDuckGo. Thank you all for coming. We'll be doing a lot more of these around on lots of topics and I'm at Kara Swisher on Twitter. Please tweet at me with ideas of people we should interview. We try to get a range of people to talk to and so we really love suggestions. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thanks again to Gabe for coming on the show and thanks to you all for listening. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer Erica Anderson is at Erica America. My producer Eric Johnson is at HeyHeyESJ. If you liked this episode, we really appreciate it if you share it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media and Pivot.
55:33 Speaker 02 Search for them on your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor Joel Robbie. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
55:52 Speaker 10 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall, the most incredible survival thriller of the year. Help me! In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home! Josh Brodel. Survivor, survivor. Whale Fall, rated PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Facebook’s former security boss Alex Stamos and Twitter co-founder Ev Williams (Live) Next Recode Decode: Investors Mark Cuban and Steve Case and talent agent Scooter Braun (Live) Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated