Pod Insights Decoder Poshmark’s Tracy Sun on stitching e-commerce with social media About this episode Nilay Patel talks with Tracy Sun, the co-founder and SVP of new markets at Poshmark, a fashion resale company that just went public earlier this year while riding the huge wave of e-commerce growth during the pandemic.
Tracy has to manage regular e-commerce issues, like shipping logistics and customer service, as well as influencer economy problems, like burnout and the incessant need to grow follower counts — not to mention the universe of problems that comes with selling fashion, like dealing with fashion labels and brands. But if Poshmark can get it all right, Tracy thinks community is the future of retail.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,701 words · 8 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Companies shouldn't have to choose between speed and control. Amex Corporate connects cards with flexible spending controls and real-time visibility to help teams adapt faster. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:23 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great until the CFO sees them? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
0:33 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand." When leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:41 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:54 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge. And Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Tracy Sun, the co-founder and SVP of New Markets at Poshmark, a fashion resale company that just went public earlier this year, riding the huge wave of e-commerce growth during the pandemic. But Poshmark's app is kind of a different riff on e-commerce. It's part catalog, part social network, and part creator platform. It competes with similar apps like Depop and Etsy, but also things like Instagram and eBay. The user base skews young and it's growing. By the end of 2019, there was a sale on Poshmark every second in the United States. And as of September 2020,
1:37 Speaker 03 the site had 6.2 million active buyers, 4.2 million active sellers, and 201 million total items for sale. The company is also expanding. They just launched in Australia in addition to the United States.
1:52 Speaker 03 All this means Poshmark has a unique set of challenges. Tracy has to manage regular e-commerce issues like shipping logistics and customer service, as well as influencer economy problems like burnout and people trying to game follower accounts, not to mention the universe of problems that come with selling fashion, like dealing with fashion labels. But if Poshmark can get it all right, Tracy thinks community is the future of retail. I asked Tracy about all these problems, how she's thinking about solving them, and how she thinks Poshmark can grow as the overall creator economy grows and matures. And of course, I also asked for some post-pandemic fashion
2:33 Speaker 03 advice at the end. Okay, Tracy Sun, co-founder and SVP of New Markets at Poshmark. Here we go.
2:52 Speaker 03 Tracy Sun, you are the co-founder and SVP of New Markets at Poshmark. Welcome to Decoder.
2:58 Speaker 04 Thanks. I'm so happy to be here.
3:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm really excited to talk to you. Poshmark is really interesting. It's a shopping app with a really strong social element. It has basically a social network embedded into it. Explain what it is and how it works.
3:12 Speaker 04 Sure. So it is a bit of a different experience. Poshmark is a social marketplace, which combines the human connection of a physical shopping experience with the scale, reach, ease, and selection benefits of e-commerce. If you think about it, shopping has been around for a very long time. And if you think back to the markets, and more recently malls, and more recently, no more malls, people just like to connect, right? Like you go to the local farmer's market and you like to know who grows your lettuce, or you like to speak to the shopkeeper at a store to find out how to style things. And with the
3:55 Speaker 04 rise of e-commerce, what's happened is a lot of that human connection gets stripped out. And what you get is just, like I said, like ease, selection, all that stuff. But what Poshmark does is it brings back a lot of that really innate human connection that that happens around shopping and combines it with e-commerce.
4:14 Speaker 03 That human connection in your app is it's people, right? You you you sign up for Poshmark, you open the app, you follow some brands. That's the first prompt, but really you're following people who there's a there are strong echoes of Instagram in this entire experience, right? Is that is that the main focus for you is you're going to follow actual people on the app?
4:34 Speaker 04 You follow people as a means for discovery, as a means for connection. So what we see on Poshmark is people are on the app 27 minutes a day. And that is that's not an engagement stat that you typically see in commerce. It's a it's an engagement level you see when there's more things to see, more people to talk to, content's changing, there are conversations going on. That's what that level of engagement we really see today. And that's what's happening on Poshmark. People come, they look at their feed, they talk to people who are selling things, asking them questions like, where did you get that? How do I pair that skirt with a pair of shoes?
5:19 Speaker 04 How does this fit? There's a whole bunch of conversations going on.
5:24 Speaker 03 Is that 27 minutes? Is that the is that the mean or the median? Because it feels like you probably have some sellers who are on there eight to 10 hours a day. And then, you know, people like me that bang through all their social apps for 30 seconds before they go to bed.
5:37 Speaker 04 Sure. That 27 minutes is an average of everyone who's active on a daily basis.
5:42 Speaker 03 Okay. One of the interesting problems for all social apps I always think about is the flywheel of getting started. So you started Poshmark in 2011. Now you're a public company, you just IPO'd in January. How'd you get the flywheel started, right? I mean, you're asking people to sell products, to spend money, to put things in boxes and ship them. There's that's a lot more than a TikToker, a Clubhouse or an Instagram. Like, you're asking a lot of users, how'd you get the flywheel of engagement started?
6:10 Speaker 04 You know, that's such a good question. And I actually remember back in 2010, Manisha and I, so Manisha is a co-founder, we were, I sat there and I asked him, like, do we get buyers first? Do we get sellers first? Do we get inventory? Because, you know, in 2010, not only were there not social marketplaces, people did not embrace reselling on a mass scale yet. So in addition to Flywheel, we had to convince everyday people that you really do have items in your closet you can sell. So what we ended up doing is kind of inadvertently going after all three at once. We met people, so not buyers, not sellers, not people with inventory, but just
6:54 Speaker 04 people who we thought would want to connect over commerce. And these are everyday people. So people that, you know, you feel like you could walk down the street and see them on the street. We went and talked to some fashion bloggers who are not shy to take photos of themselves. Because again, Instagram had not really become big yet. So the idea of a selfie was not in our, not in our lexicon. So we really found just digitally savvy, fashion-loving people who loved to get together and talk about style. And we actually had physical events that brought them together. And during these physical events, we taught them how
7:33 Speaker 04 to use the app. And they really, really took off and started making it their own. And what, so what we found to answer your question about Flywheel is, these people became buyers, they became sellers, and they switch back and forth. And so what we focused on is really recruiting people. And the Flywheel took care of itself.
7:54 Speaker 03 It's interesting because you run, it's a commerce platform, but the dynamics you are describing are, they're the same dynamics as every social platform with creators. And I think that is, that's one of the more interesting tensions with every company that has creators on it. You have to service the creators, but you also have to make a great user experience. You have many more people who are just consumers. But if you don't have the creators, if you don't have the sellers, you know, you won't have the buyers. Who do you think of as the more important cohort of users? Who do you spend your time thinking about?
8:28 Speaker 04 We typically spend most of our time thinking about our sellers. Because they, as you call them, they are the creators. And we've focused our product strategy on helping these sellers become more and more successful. So we're always thinking about what are additional tools we can give them to further engage their buyers. So in a way, we do focus on buyers as well, but but through the lens of our of our sellers. An example of that is we recently launched a feature called Dropping Soon. And what that does is it enables sellers to notify interested parties and say,
9:09 Speaker 04 hey, I have this special product and it will drop tomorrow at 9 a.m. And and and our buyers love that. So they get notified and they they're so excited. They like the item in order to receive this notification. They wait for the drop to happen. The drop happens, we our seller can schedule it. It fans out to everyone who has signed up to be notified. And then buyers come in and and then they they purchase and have a great time. So, you know, this tool is, we build it for sellers, but the sellers are using it to engage with their buyers. And that's the approach we've taken for so much of the product strategy and Poshmark is, we enable people and the people that we're enabling are sellers, and then our sellers go and talk to our buyers through our tools.
9:54 Speaker 03 One of the things I think is really interesting about that approach is you're talking about your sellers, your creators on your platform, is like primary users of your platform, people who are, and they call they call themselves posher's, right? Which is really a great word. Other platforms like Depop, like I see a lot of TikTok stars who are just selling some stuff over on the side of Depop, and they're using that platform to monetize their main platform. How do you think about that relationship to Instagram and TikTok, all these places where there are other kinds of influencers who are looking for alternate revenue streams?
10:29 Speaker 04 I think everything is converging. The idea, the rise of creators and creator economy, Instagram, TikTok, what a lot of these, what we're entering into is an era where content is easily created and accessible. And you don't have to be what we used to call influencers, who have millions and millions of followings. You can, you can be a creator and be a star in your, in your own right. So I do think worlds are colliding. And it's a really interesting time where people are just creating a lot of content. And we're seeing that Poshmark where the idea of creating a closet and putting it up for sale, that was something, you know, 10 years ago,
11:14 Speaker 04 people only did if they wanted to make a career out of it. And what we're seeing now is it's, it's now very easy through Poshmark to come in and with a, you know, within a few minutes, you can have something up for sale, make 20 bucks, go on with your life and come back whenever you're ready.
11:30 Speaker 03 Are you actively out there recruiting influencers on other platforms, creators on other platforms to use Poshmark as a secondary revenue stream or even a primary revenue stream?
11:40 Speaker 04 A lot of our efforts around, we do have a lot of creators on Poshmark. And most of them are coming in through, through organic means. We're creating more and more tools to, to help people express themselves in this way. So for example, last year we launched our short form video called Posh Stories. And what it enables anyone to do on Poshmark is really tell a story behind something you're selling or your closet or your inspiration. And that was received really well by our community because as you know, video is just so much more vibrant and so much easier to, to, to create. And then just last week, we added to that product by launching listing videos.
12:23 Speaker 04 So now as a seller, you can add video product to every single item in your closet. But even more interesting as a consumer, you can just consume a stream of just what people are selling. They're styling it, they're telling you. How to wear it, what it looks like. So it's it's a really well received engagement mechanism that are being consumed by both sides.
12:49 Speaker 03 You know, you said everything is converging and as you're describing your new features, the app that converges the most things into itself is Instagram, right? Like any kind of interaction you can have in a social platform, Instagram either already has or is like rapidly copying. Is Instagram your biggest competition or is Depop your biggest competition?
13:09 Speaker 04 You know, wherever people are spending their time is where we focus on, right? Because for us, we really want to help our sellers be successful and really engage them. So we want to build as many of those engagement tools as possible so that they can stay on Poshmark and achieve as much of the social needs as well as commerce needs as they want. So we're just heads down, just focused on building out our social marketplace and making sure that we really serve our sellers.
13:42 Speaker 03 No, but let me push you in that. I mean, Instagram has shopping tools. They want people to spend money in there. They're gonna, every time I talk to Adam Mosseri, I ask him why he won't just take my credit card and turn it into a catalog. Is that the biggest threat? Or is it is it a more head up competitor like Depop?
13:58 Speaker 04 Well, let me tell you what our competitive advantage is. We built Poshmark grounds up with commerce in mind. So when we say social marketplace, they're not just, I don't think all social features are equal. This is something that we think about a lot in the early days of building Poshmark is you have to laser focus on innovation and you can't just take innovation elsewhere and plop it onto a new customer without really understanding your customer. So where we really focus is not just social, but how does social enable and unlock commerce? And so for us, nouns that we see elsewhere like video or like, follow,
14:39 Speaker 04 these are very standard social actions. On Poshmark, there's always commerce intent behind them. So you know, you're pushing me on competition, sure. You can shop on Instagram, you can shop on Amazon, you can shop at your at your physical boutiques on Main Street when they start to open. There's many places to shop and there's many places to spend your time. It used to be more TV, now it's more online and TikTok. So there's many places to shop and spend time online. There's very few places where you can socially engage and have it translate. Every engagement point you do translates into a better shopping experience
15:19 Speaker 04 for you. And that's where, yes, you know, if you decompose Poshmark into pieces, we're not inventing shopping, but what we're doing is where everything you do, it changes your experience on Poshmark. So it's like you have this virtual mall that's ever changing. And and and that's what we're focused on building.
15:40 Speaker 03 I think this brings me to the question that I ask almost every co-founder and executive that comes on the show. This is a 10-year journey, you're now a public company, you have this huge competition, you're talking about your focus. What is your decision-making framework as you think about ways to expand Poshmark? You're in charge of new markets. How has that decision-making changed?
16:01 Speaker 04 You know, it's it's been a really interesting journey for me to go from being a really, really small founding team to now be an executive at a at a public company. I've never gone through that career journey before, just seeing a company evolve. And I love this question because it's really true that that decision-making, I might have said it gets more complicated as you get bigger, but but now that I reflect on your question, I don't think it gets more complicated. I think that the inputs just change. So let me give you an example. In the early days, when there's a handful of people, you just assume that everybody has the same amount of information, the same amount of context.
16:42 Speaker 04 And because it's a startup and you're an entrepreneur and it's like, like, you know, find product market fit or die. Your North Star is so focused and it's, there's energy and adrenaline to getting there as a team together. The urgency is so clear. And so it, all of that context enables really fast decision making. Small number of people, everyone has the same amount of information. The urgency is extremely high, so you can't really sit and contemplate it for a very long time. And so innately, that small team makes decision making in a fast, urgent way.
17:22 Speaker 04 What I see now, when we've got many, many stakeholders, many more than the early days, is now you have to really intentionally ask yourself, when you're making a decision, who can help you based on the information they have? Do they have the context to help make the decision? What's the level of urgency? There are some decisions we're making that need a, that need an answer that minute. And then there are other questions we're asking that we've been asking for a year now and still contemplating, right? Some more of the strategic questions that, that aren't urgent, but super important. So that's, that's how decision making has changed. It's just, I, I guess what I would say is, I now have to be more intentional to think
18:02 Speaker 04 about all these factors and then incorporate that into what type of decision making am I gonna employ today? Versus the early days, it was usually kind of one type of decision.
18:14 Speaker 03 When you say what kind of decision making I have to employ today, what do you mean? What are, what are some types?
18:18 Speaker 04 So it's like I was saying before, there's, we make hundreds of decisions every day. Some of them are very tactical and they're small and they're between maybe three people. So anyone in that foursome, if they have the same amount of information and they understand the same amount of risk and urgency, any one of those people can make a decision. So someone raises their hand and goes and, and we move on. What's become newer at Poshmark and in my world is as we look at what's next? Where do we want to be in five years? Where do we want to be in 10 years? These are types of questions we're asking that everybody's coming in with a different context, different amount of information, different opinions.
19:03 Speaker 04 They're so important to the, to the future of the company, but not super, super urgent. They don't have to be answered today. And so this decision making involves a lot of people. We're soliciting input from different departments, different levels, inside the company, outside the company. And we're taking our time to process and synthesize this information. This is a type of decision making we didn't make in 2011, right? You didn't have the time. It's like contemplating your like, it's like existential, you know? So so more of this is coming. And what I'm learning is the to have some some peace and not rush things.
19:46 Speaker 04 I think I'm telling you an example at the extreme endpoints of of my Poshmark journey from day one versus today. But the truth is somewhere along the middle, like year five or so, is when things slowly started to shift and more important strategic decisions or questions started to come up. And I think, you know, as that transitioned, I would feel urgency to move quickly because I might not have processed that these questions are slightly different and require slightly different decision making frameworks.
20:20 Speaker 03 We're going to take a quick break. But when we come back, I'll ask Tracy about the experience of managing a company that goes public and also how Poshmark users make money and scale their businesses.
20:31 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them, that's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
20:40 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
20:48 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
21:01 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition, even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
21:33 Speaker 03 We're back with Tracy Sun of Poshmark, which just had its IPO at the beginning of this year. We talk about how that experience is going so far and whether it's influenced the way that she manages the company.
21:46 Speaker 03 You're three months into being a public company now, I think. One of the things I hear from people who work and who manage public companies is suddenly there's a score every minute of every day. There's a stock price that moves up and down. People want to see growth. Investors want to see growth. My friends who are anchors on CNBC will bring executives on and say, what are you going to do to move the stock price? Have you felt that influence yet? And just in this early moment of being in charge of a public company?
22:16 Speaker 04 Well, we certainly see the stock price. We certainly see people talking about the company in hourly, daily, quarterly mindset. So we see it. We saw this coming and I'd say that have been building a culture of long-term mindset within the company for multiple years now. So as we prepared for this process, we really had to take our own mindset and make sure that we stay focused, be really clear on what you want to achieve and what it takes to achieve it. And spent some time working with our executive team and our overall team to just say, look, we're making this change. We're going from a private company to a public company.
23:01 Speaker 04 Here, here's what's going to happen. And here are the changes we have to make to be good stewards of the company to all of our stakeholders. However, our mission and our strategy and the way we operate, which is the culture with which we operate, will remain the same. And so we've really focused, we put a lot of energy into providing stability in the team and with ourselves to go through this transition and not have it rock your world. It shouldn't rock your world, right? It's, we still operating as Poshmark. It's just now we have a new set of investors.
23:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, but they have a ticker. Walk me through, you had a meeting? It's like, did you have a series of meetings where like, this ticker is going to exist now? We, we want you to pay not so much attention to it?
23:46 Speaker 04 I wouldn't say we had a meeting specifically to that. It was more like we care a lot about our culture and our team. And we know the pressure of what happens when things go up and when things go down. It can be very confusing for for a company and for a team. And so because we care so much, we thought ahead of time, well before we listed, how might this impact our team? And what can we do to provide stability? And so we came out with consistent messaging well before we had to, that we made sure that people's North Star were clear to them. And you have to show by example, you know, things go up, things go down,
24:31 Speaker 04 but but our strategy remains the same. And we reinforce that messaging through our all hands and through individual conversations. So I wouldn't say it was like, everybody attend, you know. But it's it's part of it's weaved into everyday conversations. So, you know, when earnings call happens or when, you know, these things happens, they don't get internally. It's not like, oh, my gosh, crisis, everyone drop everything we're doing. It's like, no, this is one more thing we have to do as a company. But we have 50 other things we're doing. So let's keep going on the 50 things and and, you know, we'll have to do this 51st thing as well.
25:08 Speaker 03 Let me connect this to the people who use Poshmark or your sellers. I think a lot about hustle culture. I think a lot about creators, obviously. There is recently, I think in December, there's a Wired piece about people trying to make a living on Poshmark doing resale. Do you think now as you're getting bigger, is Poshmark a career for people? Or is it just a way to make extra money?
25:33 Speaker 04 It's both. So definitely, there is a large group of sellers on Poshmark who are here to do it part time or as a hobby. And the reasons they might do that is either make extra money, it's entertainment, it's sustainable. There's lots of different reasons why someone would want to casually sell on Poshmark. What we do see is a growing number of people who are either full-time professional or wanting to be full-time, right on that precipice where they want to make that plunge, but they're not sure how. And that's a growing constituency on Poshmark, and that's something that we've seen. And I think it's really exciting to be able to run a platform that could support people
26:18 Speaker 04 full-time. So, you know, when I think about what's ahead, there's many things we're focused on building and supporting high-volume sellers and giving them more and more tools so that those who want to take the leap find more comfort and find more support. And those who have taken the leap find that they have more and more tools to be successful with this decision is something we're really focused on. It's one of our key growth strategies going forward.
26:45 Speaker 03 The reason I wanted to connect it to your journey and, you know, the public company conversation is, you know, we've been talking about the path you've been on, how you make decisions. Over the course of the past 10 years, it's very clear that there have been periods of just exponential growth for you as a person, as a person who runs a company, as an executive. The company going public, that's an exponential growth moment in terms of, you know, investor dollars and in terms of the size and influence of the company. As you think about an individual seller on your platform over the course of 10 years, the dynamic between the people who use the platform is and the platforms that serve them, it feels like it can remain very fixed. Are you thinking that, okay, if you are on Poshmark and you dedicate yourself to it
27:30 Speaker 03 for 10 years, you will have opportunities to scale the business the same way that you had the opportunity to scale Poshmark itself?
27:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, I don't, I don't think that an individual seller on Poshmark, if they joined many years ago, their experience is fixed. There's a few major ways in which their experience has grown. The first is, what's been really personally a beautiful career experience for me with Poshmark is, everything we do, we're on the same side of the table as our sellers. So, we're constantly trying to make their world un-fixed. And we do it a few ways. One is, the community's grown. The number of users on Poshmark has grown astronomically over the years. And what that means for our sellers is, fresh eyeballs, fresh buyers, more people to connect with.
28:20 Speaker 04 And this is something, it's a service we provide that we don't often talk about. You're building a business on Poshmark, but you don't have to look for traffic. Not only do we bring traffic to you, we bring traffic to you every day. And as we increase our personalization tools, we're bringing qualified traffic to you. And so, that's a way in which there are more buyers to acquire for each of our sellers. And as they get buyers, there's more people that they can engage with and try to get as repeat buyers. So, that's the first. The second is, we have increased our categories. So, we used to be only a women's fashion site.
29:01 Speaker 04 And we have since, a few years back, launched our men's category, which actually, both genders are participating in buying and selling. We've launched a home category, which last year, during this crazy time we've been in, has skyrocketed as people are in their homes and finding more and more things to buy and sell. We launched beauty last year as well. And just recently, last month, we launched pets for the four-legged family member. So, as a seller, we have and will continue to increase the universe of the store that you can build. And therefore, the customers you can build. And then, the last thing I would say is, there's been a lot of innovation.
29:44 Speaker 04 So, there's video, there's drops, there's a whole bunch of new tools that we're inventing for people to play with and see if it works for them and their store. So, I would challenge your assertion that an individual seller, over the course of years, is fixed. I think that... We've made it our mission to grow the platform so they can grow. And I hope that they're using these tools as they see fit.
30:09 Speaker 03 Let me stay on the challenging side of this question for a minute.
30:11 Speaker 04 Sure.
30:12 Speaker 03 That is the path of all social platforms. They add new features, they, there's more buttons to push, there's more formats to develop. There's more categories to play in. In one sense, that's all just more work. You talked about traffic, one of the clearest sort of user seller criticisms of Poshmark that I have read is you have to spend a lot of time just sharing stuff, sharing other people's stuff to participate in the feed and draw traffic to your own store. And that's just a lot of time. And there are some Poshmark sellers that just hire another person to do that sharing work. So they can get on with the other stuff. As you add more things to do and find more ways to be competitive, are you thinking about, okay, how do we scale sustainable business growth? Or are you looking at the users are going to figure out how these tools all work?
30:57 Speaker 04 That's a good point. So there's two things that come to mind. So first of all, as you add more features and it gets more complex, particularly for a new user, it can get very daunting, right? A new seller comes to Poshmark today, for sure, they're seeing so many more features than someone who joined eight years back. So I do think putting extra attention to really guiding the seller today, if they're starting their journey today, to not get overwhelmed with all the advanced features and really just like laying it out for them. Here's how to be successful and let's not overwhelm you as a way of just supporting you and empowering you. So that's the first that I recognize as something we're putting energy into,
31:40 Speaker 04 but, uh, but we'll, we'll have to continue doing that with time. And then going to the other part, uh, for those that are not confused by features, but are just like, man, you know, it used to be two things I have to do, and now there's 15 things I can do. To me, that's, that is a good choice to have. I don't think that every tool we create is appropriate for every type of seller. The drops that I mentioned work really well for people with deep inventory. So boutiques that have 50 t-shirts, they used to have to create 50 listings. Now they create one listing and they can market it to everyone who's liked it and say,
32:21 Speaker 04 "I have 58 SKUs behind this and so I won't sell out in a second." And so for them, the drops is an efficiency tool and we can measure that over time. That's not going to work for an everyday, like I just want to flip some of my closet items that I'm not wearing anymore. That tool doesn't work. So we have different seller segments that require different types of tools and I don't think they'll work for all of them. And we do want to be mindful and go towards seller efficiency and make sure the ROI is there, but I'm not sure if the goal should be, "I want to do less work and make more money."
33:04 Speaker 03 Wait, that's everyone's goal?
33:05 Speaker 04 Okay, I don't think that that should be our goal, right? Like we are in the business of helping people be successful. We want that person who is making $20,000 on Poshmark, if they want to make more, we want to give them the tools to enable them to do that. Well, if I think about Poshmark, right, if we want to grow, we need to grow our team. We need to grow our infrastructure. We need to build. There's work to do to grow. And so we'll always focus on ROI and try to make the effort as efficient as possible. But I don't buy the, "I must hire someone, therefore I'm not successful."
33:48 Speaker 04 It's like, no, I think that's amazing. If you are hiring someone to run your store, we just have to make sure we make it worthwhile for you and we help direct your attention so that that person knows what to do and make it easier and easier for you, right?
34:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's the tension, right? You hire somebody because you think they're going to enable you to achieve an even higher profit margin than you could do yourself. But once you start going down the road of servicing that community, the initial community of people who just want to try it out, they're faced with doing the work of maybe three or four people. And that seems like the hard tension there for me.
34:24 Speaker 04 I think when you get to a place where you're running, I mean, there's such a difference on on Poshmark. We have some sellers who have 12 listings, right? And then we have some sellers who have 12,000 listings. And what's required to run these two stores is vastly different. And if we can segment our sellers and really look at each persona and say, okay, the person who has 12 listings, they need this. And let's keep going on that. But the person who has 12,000 listings, they have a completely separate suite of needs. And that 12,000 listing person, they would definitely fall under this high-volume seller that we've identified. And it is one of our focus areas right now, because that's where we think
35:09 Speaker 04 that we haven't done enough work. We were built for the 12-listing seller. We have a lot of tools to serve him or her. Though the one who is more high-volume, that's where I think we have some gaps in our platform that we're working to address.
35:23 Speaker 03 I would make the comparison here to a more traditional social platform, YouTube, for example. YouTube is always described to me as the gold standard of creator monetization. And really, all they do is serve ads for you and make it easy to do branded integrations in videos. People make a lot of money doing this. One of YouTube's big benefits, though, is that your videos continue to exist on YouTube's website. AdSense just keeps paying you for that long-tail archive of content. I think the best example of this is like kid video channels. I have a toddler. My toddler watches the same five videos all the time. They're just collecting that money. They don't have to make any work, right? They get software-style margins from that content. They've paid to make it once. They're
36:06 Speaker 03 selling it over and over and over again for effectively zero incremental cost. Poshmark sellers don't have that. They have to get the clothes, they have to take the photos, they have to sell their clothes, get more clothes. Can you think of a way to add that higher-margin revenue line for your creators?
36:22 Speaker 04 Well, in the world that we see today, it is possible for like a boutique seller who has a store to put up 50 listings and kind of let it run itself. I don't think that's great merchandising strategy, and I don't think anyone would do that in fashion who runs a store because freshness is what drives the shoppers in and talking to your customers is what converts them. So I don't think the analogy is exactly the same. But having said that, once you set up your store, for example, this boutique seller, she has her store going. Now it's about, I'd say, less about running the store and more about talking to people who come in and converting them.
37:05 Speaker 04 And then, and that's where the energy goes. If you have a past customer who comes in again, being able to say to them, hey, you bought this size last time. Do you want to buy the same thing in a different color? Or I think this necklace would go great with it. Those are the things that really, where the energy and attention makes sense. And that's just very much part of commerce. I think what's really great about that type of energy is typically for people who love, I mean, the people who, I think we tend to gravitate towards the things we enjoy, especially if you spend that much time doing it. So I have to imagine people who create content on YouTube love creating content, video content. And like you said, you're not one of them. I'm not one of them.
37:50 Speaker 04 But the people who run a store, they are merchants. They love running a store. And for most of the people I talk to who are in this world, the part they love is engaging with people. What they don't love is like ship, like dealing with logistics, shipping, like the grungy part of customer service, like catalog stuff. But they love creating their store and they love like, and so that's the merchandise in it, what the entire assortment means together. How a shopper feels when they come into their store. Those are all the the positive creative aspects of of running a store.
38:28 Speaker 04 So I think if we continue to give them room to innovate and create in those worlds and tackle as much of the stuff they don't want to do, like inventory management, you know, that kind of stuff, then we just enable people to really harness their love and and tie that into whether it's their job or their their hobby.
38:53 Speaker 03 That logistics stuff is is kind of the heart of the the Poshmark business. And it's probably important to talk about, although I could talk about creator stuff forever.
39:03 Speaker 03 How do you make money? You you charge creators a fee and then you you help them with shipping. You help them with customer service. Those are costs. But what is the fee structure like? How does, when someone starts to sell on Poshmark, how much are you taking? And what do you provide in return?
39:16 Speaker 04 We take 20% of each sale. And getting started on Poshmark is completely free. Opening up your store, engaging with people, building your following. So the key to Poshmark is as more and more people discover you and your store and they follow you, your reach gets bigger and bigger. So building that reach is is part of the Poshmark experience. And the only thing we we monetize right now, if you're successful, we take a cut. What's included in that? A whole host of things. So, starting from store setup, you set up your store, your catalog, all of that is managed and included.
39:58 Speaker 04 We maintain a growing community of shoppers. So, like I said, you don't, you don't need to to drive traffic to your store unless you want to. We have a whole bunch of sellers who organically drive traffic to their stores from other social networks. And and that's just good for them. They're they're practicing good customer acquisition strategies. However, we do have millions of buyers on Poshmark as well. We take care of shipping through a partnership with USPS. So that as a seller makes a sale, they just have to print out the label. And it's already been paid for and it's already been preaddressed. They just put it on and it's priority mail, so it gets there super fast to their buyer.
40:39 Speaker 04 We take care of all customer service disputes and we protect both the buyer and seller through our PoshProtect programs. There's just a whole bunch of, you know, the world of chargebacks, for example, is a very painful reality for a lot of sellers out there in the world. And our sellers do not really know what a chargeback is because we take care of it. We take care of all credit card processing. If there's a problem with an item and a buyer's not happy, we take care of that. So there's a lot of not so fun logistics things that our team has solved. And then how we do it honestly is we understand it,
41:22 Speaker 04 we put people on it. But then, because at the end of the day, we're a software company, we create software to help make it more efficient for us so we can scale.
41:32 Speaker 03 So you build your own internal software to scale things like shipping and customer service?
41:36 Speaker 04 That's right. So I'll give you an example of something that that we've had to deal with that no one else would have to deal with, right? So, early on, we would realize that people would, you know, oftentimes you come and you engage with with people and then you go away. But that engagement often leads to a sale. So you answer questions about how it fits, you we you do some price negotiation, whatever. So as what you find is that, especially for casual sellers, their sales can come together in one day, right? So what we would see is people would make like three or four or five sales in one day, and they might by accident swap the labels, right? So they would send the wrong thing to the wrong person, it would go across the country. And we would get our
42:19 Speaker 04 customer service team would get an email, be like, I didn't order this. And then simultaneously, someone on the other side of the country would be like, I didn't order this. And it's just such an honest mistake for a busy person who's trying to ship packages. So we it would create such havoc in the early days because we'd have to track down this package and track down that package. And now everything is automated. So we had actually have built it into the flow where the seller can say, oops, I swapped a package. And then automatically our system takes care of it. We auto generate emails to the respective buyers with an apology. And we in that email is a label that's prepaid, preaddressed, so that all that the buyer has to do is put it on.
43:03 Speaker 04 And in the cases of, in any case where there's any sort of like bad buyer experience or bad seller experience, because everything is centralized and managed by Poshmark, we can pay attention to our levels of service for various people. And so we know when someone's a seller who has a pristine track record, and then all of a sudden they make a human error, which happens, we can see their history and factor that into our decision-making and our systems do that as well.
43:34 Speaker 03 Paying attention to your sellers, they have a pristine track record. There's an element of this that, you know, Instagram creators don't have like star rankings. eBay merchants do. Where on the spectrum of that are you keeping track of your sellers?
43:49 Speaker 04 Well, I think when you're trying to build a community of sellers, we were very intentional to try to create a world where anyone can enter today to become a seller and really have a great selling experience. You can imagine over time, and this happens in other places, where over time, these sellers who are high-volume and do really well tend to dominate the entire platform because they have a million five-star reviews and they, you know, they filter to the top and all these things. And so we do want our high-volume sellers to succeed and we want to create a world where anyone can start selling today and be successful. So that's been something we've intentionally thought about from the beginning.
44:34 Speaker 04 An example of something we might, that we've done a little bit differently to help manage that tension is how we approach reviews. So like I mentioned, in a lot of other sites, you filter, or the sellers who have the most five-star ratings, they get preferential treatment. And as a buyer, why wouldn't you want to gravitate towards those sellers? It guarantees a certain level of they're going to ship, they're not going to like steal my money or whatever. At Poshmark, what we have is we collect ratings on every sale. So we know if a buyer has complained about slow shipment or product quality or something like that, but we don't expose it to the marketplace.
45:15 Speaker 04 What we expose is if you, if a buyer gives a seller a five-star review, And they leave a comment like, wow, I love this seller. She gave me like some freebies and she was super fast shipper. I'll buy from her again. What we do is we post that comment to the seller's page and we call it a love note. And so what happens is these are just positive comments that people are leaving. So you can go to any seller's page on Poshmark and just read all of their love notes that were given by people who shopped with them.
45:47 Speaker 03 But you're you're curating that. You have a team that's looking through everyone's love notes and saying, we're gonna post these ones?
45:52 Speaker 04 No, we post any comments as love notes that were published by buyers and gave a five star rating out of five. Right? Now, if someone's giving a one star rating and they post a comment, we don't, we don't expose it. So we don't penalize, we don't publicly penalize the seller. But internally, we use all that data to make sure that the buyers are having a positive experience. And so if we have a seller that's misbehaving or not providing the customer service that that we would like, we can take corrective action, but we do it behind the scenes.
46:29 Speaker 03 What does corrective action look like? So you, you have a seller, they've gotten a bunch of one star notes from people with bad experiences. Do you schedule a Zoom? How does that work?
46:42 Speaker 04 There's, there's infinite combination of things that sellers can do where they start to sometimes slowly, sometimes quickly, provide a terrible buyer experience. And we have a team of people that focus on that and created nuanced schedules of how we might deal with that. So an example is someone who ships slow has a different course of action versus someone who is violating our community guidelines. Right? Like we have, we think one is, is tolerable and can be rehabilitated. The other one is such a terrible experience for our community that we have less tolerance for it. So each of these instances have different courses of action.
47:26 Speaker 04 But generally, what can happen is, once we sense that it has hit some sort of threshold, we will reach out to the buyer or the seller. So whatever the situation might be, and let them know that, you know, this is a problem. You know, fill in the blank, and we expect something to be corrected. And if it's low urgency and the problems get resolved, it could end there. But there are instances where a team does get on the phone with a buyer or seller and really talk to them and try to understand, this is a repeated problem. It's now escalated. What's going on? So we do have a team that reaches out and talks to people because sometimes you can't tell in the data what's going on.
48:09 Speaker 04 And in an extreme case, we will cut a seller off or a buyer off if they're violating our guidelines.
48:17 Speaker 03 We're going to take one more break, but when we return, we have to talk about what we talk about with every social network executive. Content moderation.
48:28 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
48:38 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
48:46 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
48:59 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
49:31 Speaker 03 Okay, we're back with Decoder.
49:36 Speaker 03 Well, we've made it almost an hour and I have an executive from a platform company. And here we are at content moderation, which comes up on, I think, every episode of this show. You're describing a content moderation policy. You're saying there's some stuff that's against the rules. One of the important constituents that you have to deal with from sort of a moderation and policy perspective that most other platforms don't have to is big brands, high fashion brands, big consumer brands. Your users are buying and selling their goods, they're using their trademarks. Some of those brands are notoriously litigious. I know that Chanel and a competitor called The RealReal have just been in court forever. What is your relationship to the big brands like?
50:17 Speaker 04 Well, in the world of content moderation, if any, any brand, big or small, flags for us that we're in some way violating any of their trademark policies, we take that very seriously and work with them. So our relationship has been positive even from a content moderation standpoint, or like a trademark standpoint. On the, on the flip side, I think what we're, what we're seeing is a shift as we grow and as online is becoming more important and resale is becoming more important and our engaged community is thriving. We're actually seeing a whole bunch of inbound interest from brands on a positive note.
50:59 Speaker 04 Oftentimes, we're seeing that the brands community on Poshmark is one of their largest online communities ever. So we're getting a lot of inbound interest saying, hey, how do I, how do I be part of this solution? Whereas in the early days, it might have just been moderation. I think the future of, of working with brands is really bright in a way where we can combine forces and figure out how we can really help their customers connect with the brand more.
51:29 Speaker 03 You have an interesting intersection of problems. There's chargebacks and shipping fees and stuff that is very much in the physical world. And then you have the same set of digital problems as every platform, which is you have a content policy, people can post fake listings, you have things that are against the rules, like misrepresenting, I'm reading here, misrepresenting Native American or American Indian arts and crafts. How do you think about making a content policy for? Not a store, but a platform that enables stores.
52:02 Speaker 04 Sure. So when we think about content moderation or any other topic, we really start from a place where we're committed to ensuring that our marketplace reflects something, reflects our values and the values of the community we serve. And we start from that place. As we've scaled, our content moderation strategy is something we've put a lot of time and energy into, as you're alluding to. The first thing we do is we really harness the power of our community to help us. It's a growing problem, and as you grow, it grows. So what we do is we enable our community to flag any items that they think might violate our policies or our values.
52:46 Speaker 04 And then we have a team that monitors those flags and resolves them. So it's a three-pronged approach. It's community, we have a team, and the third, which is the place we're innovating in the most, is really seeing how technology can help us. So we're using machine learning and rules-based detection algorithms that help to go out into our marketplace and proactively identify anything that might be suspicious or in violation of our policies.
53:16 Speaker 03 I hear a lot about sort of machine learning and AI-driven moderation. Have you had good results?
53:22 Speaker 04 We have had good results in that they are helping.
53:27 Speaker 03 That was a very, very politic answer there.
53:29 Speaker 04 Well, it's true. We're finding things, right? We're finding things we might not have found before. And so it's enough of a positive result for us to say, we need to continue this work. And we need to invest. And what we're seeing is the smarter we get, the smarter other people get. And so you have to be committed to really fighting this battle in order to stand a chance. And so we have to. What we're seeing is that if we don't pay attention to this, it can, it can really, you know, like I said, it's a violation of our values. And that's the most important thing, is to create this like safe place where people can connect and transact.
54:11 Speaker 04 So, so yes, we're very focused on it. It's working, but we, it by no means, it means that, oh, it's working, we can stop investing. We have to continue to invest in this area for sure.
54:25 Speaker 03 Is this something you're building? Is there an ecosystem of vendors that are working on it? When I, when I hear about particularly computerized solutions to content moderation, it seems like every company trying to build their own is actually the wrong approach because the necessary rate of improvement is such that like a handful of specialized firms would get there a lot faster.
54:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, we do both, we do both.
54:49 Speaker 03 One of the more interesting debates that I've read about platforms like Poshmark and others is around the ethics of thrifting for resale. Most people have done it. Arbitrage is, you know, just part of the world economy forever. Platforms like Poshmark enable you to, you know, buy out all of the good stuff at a local thrift shop and then sell it for a profit at a massive scale. Do you, do you think that poses any issues?
55:13 Speaker 04 When I think about thrifting, to me, that's a very positive consumer behavior. I love how shoppers are embracing secondhand and that we are spending more time thinking about our sustainable choices. And the more we can do that, I think it's better to not waste what's out there and to continue to value what we have.
55:35 Speaker 03 But the, the sort of physicality of it is you've got a thrift store in a local community and then you're going to redistribute all the stuff out of that local thrift store in the United States, across the United States, across Australia. Do you see that sort of like digital scale applied to a local community as a net positive or a negative?
55:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think it's a net positive to be able to support a local thrift store and to go in and, and provide liquidity for something that is not currently being used. And so as things distribute from a physical store to online distribution, I think it would be really interesting to think through how we can evolve as a system to see that as a positive, to increase distribution and finding homes for items is a net positive end result. So the more we can innovate and help everyone thrive in that type of system, the better.
56:33 Speaker 03 Have you thought about working with thrift stores, Goodwills, things like that?
56:36 Speaker 04 We have. In fact, we worked with Goodwill last year and during the pandemic, we helped them distribute boxes from their physical store. They actually came to us and said, "How do I bring my stuff online to your sellers?" So we helped them distribute their product to the Poshmark community.
56:56 Speaker 03 I can't end without asking you some pandemic fashion trends, which is, I'm very curious, right? I mean, you run an ecommerce platform. We've obviously seen a huge surge in ecommerce during the pandemic. I'm hopeful that we're at the finish line. There seems to be a lot of light at the end of this tunnel. Have people been buying and selling more fashion during the pandemic? Is that something you've seen or are they just transacting more in general?
57:19 Speaker 04 I don't love the fact that we've gone through a pandemic, but I am a bit of a data junkie. And, you know, I started my career in data and in neuroscience, like, how does data show human behavior? And so this is such a fascinating topic because we did see shifts in our data based on what everyone was going through. And we're commerce, right? So we didn't, we didn't see, you know, really the data of everything that's going on, but we did see how, at least this pandemic, changed the way people are shopping. So some trends
57:57 Speaker 04 that we saw, we saw a decline in luxury shoes and handbags. We saw a decline in, everything makes sense, right? We saw a decline in dresses. We saw an astronomical increase in home goods and athleisure and oddly jewelry, right? And I attribute that to Zoom. It's like you want earrings.
58:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
58:20 Speaker 04 We also saw some strengthening of brands that are already popular but became more popular. So I'm talking about for women, Lululemon, Nike. For men, Nike and Adidas. So that was a lot of the pandemic stuff. I think what's really interesting is now we're getting into a phase where the data's changing again. And so, so what do I mean by that? We're seeing searches for bathing suits go up. Summer dresses, jean shorts. And, and to me, what this means is people are, that, that's not athleisure, right? That's not hunkering down type of consumer behavior. That's a bit more optimistic.
59:02 Speaker 04 That's like, oh, I, I, I might be able to go to a beach this summer. So I want bathing suits. I want dresses because I might be able to be much more social again. And so what I'm reading into the data is just a lot of optimism in our, in our shoppers.
59:20 Speaker 03 What do you think post quarantine fashion looks like? I have this dream that it will be like super futuristic. Everyone's going to be wearing spacesuits. But what do you, what do you, what does your data tell you? Post quarantine fashion looks like?
59:33 Speaker 04 Our data does not predict that. I, I can conjecture, not, not from data, that just like anything else in our daily life, post pandemic world is going to look nothing like the pre pandemic world. And it's going to look nothing like the pandemic world. There's going to be some sort of weird hybrid of both. It's such an interesting time for us to live through such a, a, a year plus of, I don't even know what to call it, like a complete upside down. Like everything got changed to the point where I don't think things are going to go back. Right? Like the, the, the shift to online that was already happening and exploded during
1:00:18 Speaker 04 the pandemic, it's not going to go back. Right? Some sort of hybrid is going to happen. And, and this is where, you know, innovation is really possible.
1:00:27 Speaker 03 Well, this has been great. Tracy Sun, you're the co-founder of Poshmark. Thanks so much for being on Decoder.
1:00:31 Speaker 04 Thanks for having me.
1:00:35 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Tracy Sun for chatting with me today. And thank you for tuning in. I really hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of the show. You can email us at [email protected] or hit me up directly. I'm at reckless on Twitter. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Sophie Erickson, Andrew Marino, and Ari Abbraci. Our music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
1:01:07 Speaker 06 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Offer valid through October 21st. U.S. and Amazon. See store online for details.
1:01:38 Speaker 07 I work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know, I've made things a little difficult in the past. Okay, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG. And finally, I understand. Now I'm making work work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, Pay, and Workforce Management.
Previous The robots are coming for your office, with NYT’s Kevin Roose Next Facebook's VP of Global Affairs doesn’t think the platform is polarizing Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated