Pod Insights Decoder I can't make products just for 41 year old tech founders," Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky on taking it back to the basics About this episode Brian Chesky, the co-founder and CEO of Airbnb, was previously on the show in 2021. Back then, Airbnb was betting big on long-term stays for remote work amid the pandemic, and Chesky had just restructured the company to a more functional organization, getting rid of the divisions it had before.
Now, the pandemic is ending, Airbnb has itself adopted a hybrid policy, Chesky’s back in the office several days a week, and they’re two years into that new structure. So that’s pure Decoder bait. I wanted to ask Chesky how that restructure is going. Has it really made the company more agile and cohesive like he hoped? Has the bet on working from anywhere paid off?
Links:
Brian Chesky's tweet announcing the summer 2023 launch
Microsoft thinks AI can beat Google at search — CEO Satya Nadella explains why
Samsung caught faking zoom photos of the Moon
Why the future of work is the future of travel, with Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott and it was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Sr Audio Director is Andrew Marino and our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 13,475 words · 8 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control, set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs, and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards, all backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
0:26 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great, till the CFO sees them, that's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:36 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:44 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com slash campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:58 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Brian Chesky, co-founder and CEO of Airbnb, one of my very favorite Decoder guests. He's on today because Airbnb just rolled out a big set of product and design updates, including a refresh of the shared rooms product it originally lodged with. We got into all of that, and we talked quite a bit about how the uncertain economy is changing the travel industry. But I also wanted to get an update on some things Brian and I talked about during his first appearance on Decoder back in 2021. It was the middle of the pandemic, and Airbnb was betting big on long-term stays for remote work. Brian had just restructured the company
1:41 Speaker 03 to a more functional organization, getting rid of the divisions that he'd had before. Here in 2023, the pandemic is ending. Airbnb itself has adopted a hybrid work policy. Brian's back in the office several days a week. And they're two years into that new functional structure. So that's pure Decoder bait. It's a show about work charts, after all. I wanted to ask Brian how that restructure is going. Has it actually made the company more agile and cohesive like he hoped? And has that bet on working from anywhere paid off? Just to refresh you, there are basically two main ways to structure a company. In a divisional structure, every product is like its own little company with its own internal design and product and marketing teams and so on.
2:23 Speaker 03 There's redundancy, but the promise is that those divisions will be able to move faster and more responsively to their markets. So the team that makes phones never talks to the team that makes laptops, but they both get to run real fast. Most every big company is divisional. Most startups are functional, which means they're organized into large teams that cut across their products. So there's just one marketing team, one engineering team, one sales team, and so on, responsible for everything. I use that phone and laptops example because Apple famously is structured functionally. Steve Jobs called it the world's largest startup. You'll hear Brian talk a lot about Apple in this one. Specifically, Johnny Ive's influence on him and Airbnb and why that influence pushed
3:05 Speaker 03 him to move to a more functional structure and to ship software on a cycle that looks more like a hardware cycle. Brian loves to talk about this stuff. He's like the perfect Decoder guest. Seriously, as you're listening to this, just note how excited he is. I love it. Okay. Brian Chesky, CEO of Airbnb. Here we go.
3:35 Speaker 03 Brian Chesky, you are the co-founder and CEO of Airbnb. Welcome back to Decoder.
3:40 Speaker 04 Well, thank you for having me, Leanne.
3:41 Speaker 03 The last time we spoke on the show, it was 2021. You had just restructured. I want to ask how that is going. And then you have a bunch of news today about new features for Airbnb. You tweeted. It's your most extensive set of improvements ever. So quite a lot to talk about. The headline here is that you're rebooting Airbnb rooms, which is renting single rooms as opposed to whole houses or apartments. Tell us what's going on with the new update.
4:06 Speaker 04 There's really two big updates. So I'll start with rooms, then I'll go to the 50 upgrades. As probably people know, Airbnb actually started as a way to stay in a room in someone's house. That was the original idea. And I remember we came up with the idea, people thought the idea was crazy. They said strangers will never stay with other strangers. But of course it worked. And from there, with rooms, we expanded to entire homes. And that's now what most people know us as. So if you stay in Airbnb, you're probably staying in an entire home. And for many years, I felt like we were starting to drift away from where we started. Because we started with people staying with each other. And the original tagline of Airbnb, and this is like back in 2009,
4:51 Speaker 04 was travel like a human. And that was kind of funny. The human part was like kind of more important than the travel part. It was about a community and you were meeting people and you saw people on the website. I think what happens a lot of companies is you kind of follow the market. You follow growth and most people weren't looking to stay with other people. They were looking to stay entire homes. And I think another thing happened over the years, Nele, and that is that a lot of founders, especially those that have a pretty successful, pretty big app, they kind of get a little bit bored of their core business. I think I see this a lot. And I think this happened to us. And we started focusing on like a lot of new offerings, not a lot of new exciting things because you want to expand.
5:33 Speaker 04 Something comes maybe somewhat easy to you and you think you can now do everything. And over the years, I just kind of felt like we were just, we really needed to get back to the roots of the company, back to our original founding ethos of sharing. And I really thought about this a number of years ago, like in 2019. But then, of course, the pandemic occurred. And the last thing somebody wanted to do is stay in a room with somebody else and have to put a mask on. So we really couldn't do it for a while. But Leaving the pandemic, exiting the pandemic, it became really clear that I think people really would want this idea more than ever. And there's really two reasons. The first is actually affordability. It's pretty obvious that if you stay in a room, you're not paying for the whole home. You get access to lots of the home.
6:16 Speaker 04 And the average price per night for a room on Airbnb is just $67 a night. We've been getting a lot of feedback from people and complaints about Airbnbs are expensive. And well, they're not all expensive, especially these. And if you're willing to stay with people. And the second is, I think that the pandemic has left a lot of people isolated. And I think there's a lot of people want to take a trip. They want to go to another city. And I think this is one of the best ways to experience a new city like a local. So let's say you're going to go to Mexico City or Tokyo. This is a great way because you get to like stay in someone's home. They can show you around. If there's any issue, they're on premise with you. And you get really a local insider's view of the city. So that's why I wanted to bring it back. But there was a problem. And the problem was, as we asked people like, why aren't you doing this?
6:59 Speaker 04 A lot of people said, well, I just kind of feel uncomfortable like. And we're like, why? Well, I don't want to stay with the person. I don't know who is this person? So we thought, well, what if we could help you virtually get to know the person before you book? I also noticed something over the years. Like when we started Airbnb, the people, the profile and the listing were like kind of equal importance. And over the years, the profile got smaller, the listing got bigger. And the profile kind of went down the page and pretty soon you could barely see it. And that they became just a site of listings. And the community, I think, started getting a little bit watered down. And I thought, we need to bring this back. So we created this thing called the host passport. It's basically just our version of a more updated profile on the internet. It helps you get to know the host before you book.
7:43 Speaker 04 So now we have a million listings. I'm, by the way, one of those listings. Last year, I decided to put, you know, I like to dog food the product. You know, I like lived on Airbnb. The first half of the year, I was hopping from home to home after I saw you. So second half of last year, I decided to host. I was going to put a second home on Airbnb, but I don't have a second home. I only have one home. And I thought, my God, and I'm not going to be traveling very much. So the only way to host is have it in my house with me. And so I kind of probably went through the experience that many hosts go through. Oh, my God, wait, I'm gonna have a host, a guest in my house. And then I'm like, OK, well, what kind of like verifications are we doing? And like, you start to really put yourself in the shoes of the customer.
8:24 Speaker 04 And suddenly, it's even like, like, it's not just what are people asking for. It's what do you want? And this really helped me realize that actually, this original idea could be a lot bigger. It doesn't have to be a niche, but we just have to invest in it. So we did, we launched in, basically, what we launched today is Airbnb Rooms. It's an all new take on the original Airbnb. There's a million rooms around the world, average price $67 a night. The practical idea is people just need to save money. This is a really cheap way to travel. The bigger idea is I really want Airbnb to become more of a travel community than just a way to book a home.
8:59 Speaker 03 You and I are talking on a day where the Fed's gonna raise rates again. And inflation is still out of control, especially in travel and dining and leisure. And it, when you talk about affordability, it, it, it seems like, boy, young people don't have as much money as they did before. And costs of travel are going up. Here's a much more affordable product. Is it, on some level, just that simple?
9:22 Speaker 04 It's pretty much that simple. I mean, there's really two ideas. The most important thing is just right now affordability. You know, we've been getting a lot of feedback over the year, over the last couple of years about affordability. Since I've been not last on your show, probably the number one complaint at Airbnb is affordability. Prices have gone up quite considerably on Airbnb in many sites in the last three years since the beginning of pandemic. Number two, if you look at it, like, cost of transportation is up massively. And people aren't making a lot more money. And so you can imagine they have less money to play with. Also, Neelie, I think one of the other challenges founders have is, it's like, when you build a product, you build it usually for yourself. You know, we were in Y Combinator, Paul Graham said, make something that people want, make something for yourself.
10:05 Speaker 04 And the problem is, once you get really successful, you stop becoming the customer. And I mean, I can't make products just for 41 or older tech founders. That's not a very big market. So I've got to make sure I remember the 26 year old me that didn't have a lot of money when I started the company. And the 26 year old me is not going to be booking one of these really large homes. The 26 year old me is going to be probably staying in a room in someone's house as cheap as possible. And by the way, I wouldn't be weirded out by that. And I might even like that because again, it's a really cool way to meet people and get a local view of the city. So that's, that's really what we're trying to do. And hopefully people realize these are now significantly more affordable than hotels.
10:44 Speaker 03 So you said you had a million rooms listed as of today, which is when the launch is. How much are you expecting that supply to go up? Are you going to initiate new people to come list rooms in their houses?
10:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, totally.
10:55 Speaker 03 Expecting people to shift from whole houses to rooms? How do you think that's going to go?
10:58 Speaker 04 I would love that. I mean, you know, obviously like in the near term, like the average daily rate is lower. So that would pull down our ADR and they are technically less profitable. But I think they're ultimately good for the world and they would actually bring a lot more young people to Airbnb, which is good long term. I think it's very strategic. Alongside this, we have like a pretty cool brand marketing campaign. We're one of the few tech companies that still seem to do brand marketing. And so we're going to basically-
11:20 Speaker 03 I absolutely want to talk to you about it.
11:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, let's do that. We have a cool new campaign around Airbnb rooms. See, we're like a two sided marketplace, right? So we have guests and we have hosts. And one challenge is you have only so much marketing dollars. Do you spend it getting demand or do you spend it getting supply? The best answer is if you can create one marketing message that speaks to both audiences, then of course your ROI is higher. So we're promoting rooms to stay in, but we're hoping people get the thought, oh yeah, well, I guess I have a room in my house. And we also did a little bit of a cool little marketing campaign called Airbnb. If you have a room, you have an Airbnb, basically saying you already have an Airbnb, just put it up. And so, yeah, we've been getting a lot of traction. I, I don't think that rooms will ever be the majority of our business.
12:04 Speaker 04 That's probably not right, but I would really hope that like this becomes like a major new growth driver for the company. And it's kind of cool. It's kind of like when Volkswagen reissued the Beetle in the like late 90s or Apple came out the iMac. They're like, you know, there's something about going back to the roots. I think it's important for us and, and kind of for our soul, you know, this is, this is the soul of the company.
12:24 Speaker 03 It seems like we're undergoing- A pretty big set of platform shifts on the internet at large. And I feel like your view on that is going to be really interesting. But I just want to stay on rooms.
12:32 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:32 Speaker 03 And sort of the core business for one more second here. The last time we spoke, it was just sort of like mid pandemic. You were very high in remote work and extended stays and work from home being forever. Here's the quote. We're going to have a generation of people that are going to be less tethered to the office, more nomadic. 20% of our business by Knight's book are stays over a month or longer. We're building, we're enriching communities by having people stay. So guests aren't just transient.
13:00 Speaker 04 Yes.
13:01 Speaker 03 This is the opposite of that, right? This is now 26 year olds with not a lot of money, bopping in and out of rooms and sort of forming communities by meeting their hosts.
13:09 Speaker 04 Yes.
13:09 Speaker 03 Is that still your focus? Do you still, I mean, work from home seems to be over in some ways. Lots of companies are bringing their people back to the office. The idea that, you know, people are going to be in a different house every time you see them on a Zoom call has somewhat faded. Is that, is that still part of the bet for Airbnb? Or are you shifting to this other model?
13:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, let me tell you how I think it's going to play out. And of course, we're just all like in the business predicting the future. And the problem is it doesn't always age well. But I think that like pure work from home or like pure remote is ending. I generally think the future is flexibility. Here's the calculation every CEO has to make. Are you more productive having people physically in an office together and then constraining who you hire to a 30 mile or 60 mile commuting radius to the office, or by allowing your team to be able to hire people from anywhere? And the truth is, it probably depends on the role. A lot of our software engineers, our accountants, certain types of lawyers, we probably don't need them physically in the office with everyone else. There's certain creative functions or people that are like really on certain teams that we probably do want together physically quite a lot. And then the
14:11 Speaker 04 question is, we need them together 50 weeks a year. And the answer for us is no. Like, we actually go in spurts. We do these product releases. So we kind of need people together months at a time. And they can choose to live here, but they want to go away for a couple of months. If people want to go away for the summer, that's possible. I think we're going to start to live in a much more nuanced world where the companies are not going to have all the people in the office. They're going to decide that some roles are most effective being on a small team in the office, but a giant sea of desks probably isn't the most effective thing. And many roles will be much more effective to allow flexibility so you can have a global talent pool. And I think there's going to be a post pandemic equilibrium that we haven't seen yet that's going to play out over the coming years.
14:54 Speaker 03 Just to focus on that for one second.
14:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
14:56 Speaker 03 Again, no one knew what was going to happen in 2021. And the predictions that we were all work from home forever were everywhere. It was easy to buy into. You were betting the business on that in some meaningful way. Right? You're like, well, people are going to be traveling. They're going to all be remote work.
15:11 Speaker 04 Well, it's still happening.
15:12 Speaker 03 It's still happening. Is it still a bet of that scale?
15:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:15 Speaker 03 Or have you changed that?
15:16 Speaker 04 No, no, it's still better that scale. I mean, we were, you know, and by the way, like when we, last April, we put out our policy and we said Airbnb employees can live work anywhere. But I said, I do not think the future is remote. I think the future is flexible. And I said, we want to combine the best of Zoom with the best of being together. That like, you know, we don't want to recreate this world of Huawei where everyone's just staring at screens all day and no one has any interaction in the physical world. And so we decided to design this in between state where we're going to gather people at least a week a quarter. Some teams are going to be together much more frequently. And that's kind of the way we did. Let me give you an example. So today, one of the other things we did is we announced 50 upgrades based on feedback from our community.
15:59 Speaker 04 So I've been getting a lot of feedback on Twitter and social media and millions of customer support calls. And I always wondered, like, imagine if a cable company CEO like actually like got in the details of their customer service or as a CEO of a public company, like just went down and just mobilized the entire company to go through the every single thing people are complaining about and try to knock them out one by one. We haven't fixed everything. We're honestly kind of just getting started, but we did 50 major improvements and fixes today. And the way we did it, and I'll get to monthly stays in a second, is we actually created a blueprint of the entire experience. So I think of our company as kind of like a design driven company in some ways. And we basically created a storyboard of the guest journeys and the host journey.
16:40 Speaker 04 Then we took all 150 product screens on our app and our website, all 72 user policies, some of which are as many as 100 pages long. Every interaction customer service, we actually blueprinted everything. Then we analyzed millions of phone calls, thousands of social media posts. We talked to guests and hosts around the world and we prioritized all the top complaints and we tried to work them down the list one by one. One of the things that became clear is a lot of people are still wanting. To be flexible when they travel. And Neelie, what I would also say is especially over summer. So even people that want to return to the office, I guarantee you, many of the CEOs are calling people back to the office in New York City. I gotta bet you a lot of them are going away to the Hamptons for the summer or going to Europe in August. So I still think that's happening. So you still have incremental flexibility.
17:25 Speaker 04 That's way more than the old world before Zoom. I mean, this interview would not have been Zoom before the pandemic. I never did Zoom interviews before the pandemic. And so I think that that is still the case. Still about a fifth of our business is monthly stays. It's still one of our fastest growing segments. I don't think we're going to be obviously pure remote. I think it's going to be much more of a flexible thing. Now that borders are reopening, a lot of young people are realizing I could like go to another country for a month at a time or a few weeks at a time. I never, when I was in my twenties, would imagine living in another country for a month. But now that's actually feasible. And so not everyone's going to be able to do that. But I actually do think you're going to have a generation of people that are going to be much more mobile, that are going to potentially choose different points of their life to live in different parts of the world.
18:10 Speaker 04 And I think that as long as we figure out the time zone matter, this is now feasible. Now, people may prefer them being in the office. But remember, this is the worst technology will ever be. Bandwidth will increase, screen resolution will increase, video conferencing technology will improve. And so this becomes more and more feasible. And so what we did is because we're seeing still so much growth of monthly stays, we basically made a bunch of improvements. We designed this like cool little monthly dial to like train people. It's like an iPod click wheel that you can stay from a month to a year. And then we were lowering fees. You can now pay by bank account on Airbnb rather than credit card processing, which saves you a bunch of money. So we're still betting on this, but I think it's a much more nuanced thing than like it's all remote or remote's bad. I think it's something much more nuanced than that.
18:57 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. When we come back, we'll get to the decoder questions.
19:07 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
19:17 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand." When leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
19:25 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit at a LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
19:39 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18 plus.
20:07 Speaker 03 We're back with Brian Chesky.
20:10 Speaker 03 You have a lot of decisions to make. You're obviously very thoughtful about how you make decisions and how you see the company going. How do you make decisions? What's your framework?
20:18 Speaker 04 Can I tell you? Can I answer that question with a story?
20:21 Speaker 03 So. Yeah.
20:22 Speaker 04 In 2011, I had my first crisis.
20:27 Speaker 04 We had a first crisis. A woman named EJ was a host in San Francisco. And one day, someone came and they trashed her apartment. And I wrote like a letter. I published it on TechCrunch. And I said, "We've resolved the issue." And then, of course, EJ said, "No, you didn't resolve the issue." And I was misinformed. And this crisis brewed. Basically, what happened was, within days, every time I tried to communicate something, I kind of seemed to keep making it worse. And then I hired these crisis communication professionals and I had these outside councils. And they were giving me what seemed like the good counsel. Like, basically like, "Well, be careful about admitting fault. Be careful about this. Don't say that. Do this, do that."
21:12 Speaker 04 And every time I got advice and every time I tried to manage to an outcome, I seemed to make the situation worse because I think what people really wanted was authenticity. They really wanted me to, you know, just like speak from the heart. And at some point, there was, this is in 2011, we were one of the first hashtags. There was a hashtag called hashtag ransackgate. And there was another hashtag called hashtag RIP Airbnb. I mean, people literally thought we weren't going to recover from this because they thought, wow, this is like, like you have no solution. And at this point, I came to a conclusion that the most important decision I'm going to make, I'm going to make based on principles, not on outcomes. In other words, I was going to make principle decisions, not business decisions. And a principle decision is if I can't figure out the outcome, how do I want to be remembered?
21:56 Speaker 04 And I said, well, I don't know how this is going to play out. Whatever I'm doing is probably going to make the situation worse. But what I really feel like is I'm just going to say wholeheartedly, I'm sorry. I'm going to tell the story and I'm going to do something crazy. I'm going to do more than is expected of me. What was expected was we make it right for customers. So we ended up with this $50,000 guarantee. It started as a $5,000 guarantee. Mark and Jason came in my office at midnight. He had just funded the company and he said, add a zero. And then suddenly we said, we will provide 50,000 dollars protection retroactively to everyone on the platform. And it actually was one of the biggest moments in the company. And ever since then, I came to the conclusion that I'm going to try to make principle decisions, not business decisions.
22:38 Speaker 04 And then this led to another development, which is first principle thinking, which of sure you're aware of. I think a lot of us think by analogy, but if you can understand the first principles of something, then you can really make a decision. So I'd been applying this ever since and it all came back to us during the pandemic because in January and February 2020, I noticed our business fell off a cliff. And within eight weeks, we lost 80% of our business. And in March 15th, the Ides of March, we called an emergency board meeting. It was a Sunday. I'll never forget it. And in this board meeting, I wrote out some series of principles about how to manage the crisis. And the first principle I said is we're going to act decisively. The second
23:23 Speaker 04 is we're going to preserve cash. The third is we're going to act with shareholders in mind. And the fourth is we're going to win the next travel season. And I even had like even more detailed principles. And I said to the to the to the board, I'm going to have to make like a thousand decisions a week like, and so I can't run every decision by you. So instead, let's agree on the principles and I'll use those principles to make these decisions. And I think a lot of people really struggle in a crisis or in times are moving quickly because they don't have data or the data is changing. But if you have a deep understanding of something, that's better. My issue with A B experimentation, for example, is that a lot of times when people choose A or B, they don't know why B worked. So let's say, oh, B works. Well, why did B work? Because if you don't know why B works,
24:06 Speaker 04 then you can never change it because you don't have actually any intellectual property developed around B. So experimentation is fine if you know why the experiment worked and if it reinforced your understanding. So I try to make decisions based on first principles. And those first principles are based on whatever we believe in. And what we believe in might be right, might be wrong in the eye of others, but that's how we do it. And, you know, it really comes down to like, listening to people. I try to have qualitative and quantitative information, art and science. I try to balance being in the lab with being in the field. And I try to be as close as I can to as decisions as possible. I try to get emotionally invested. A lot of people say if you do a layoff or
24:48 Speaker 04 fire people, don't get emotionally invested to secure decision making. I said, that's exactly what you want. You want to understand deeply all the costs. And then if then you can still make the decision, then you know you've made the right decision. So I generally say, be principled, be as close to decision making as possible, and get as emotionally invested as something as you can. And then explain your thinking. The exercise of having to explain your thinking clarifies your thinking. A lot of people like they feel something, but they can't explain it. Because they can't explain it, it's a good indication their thinking is still cloudy. So that's kind of how we do it. It's first principle oriented. It's clear. It's hopefully compassionate. It's the head and the heart.
25:27 Speaker 03 Last time you were on, we talked a lot about the structure of the company. You said that, you know, the pandemic had hit the business crater 80%. The quote is a good quote, I think about all time. You said-
25:37 Speaker 04 I had to stare into the abyss.
25:38 Speaker 03 And then you restructured the company.
25:40 Speaker 04 Yes.
25:42 Speaker 03 Been a functional startup structure, then you'd gone into a divisional structure. And you said, you know what, I'm pulling this back into a functional structure. We have one division. I'm going to run it all. I'm going to make sure I see everything. You're talking about going through customer service complaints now. Are you still in that structure? Has it worked?
25:57 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, we're still in that structure. We decided, let's go back to be a functional organization. And I actually drew inspiration from Apple around the same time that the pandemic hit is with the time we brought Johnny Ive on board, or I started talking to him. We brought him on board a little later. I also hired somebody who changed trajectory of the company named Hiroki Asai. He was a creative director at Apple and they really kind of brought me along on this methodology Steve Jobs had. Steve Jobs came back to Apple in 1997. They were like 90 days from bankruptcy or maybe even fewer. And he was divisionalized. I think he had like something like 80 products. And he did two things. He cut most of the products and he bent back to a functional organization. And that's what we did. We cut most of the products down, went to a functional organization.
26:40 Speaker 04 And the other thing we did, which seemed crazy at the time, and it's now totally intuitive, is we put the entire company on one roadmap. So most tech companies, every executive has their own swim lanes. We said, you have no swim lanes. Everyone works on everything together. Your only swim lane is your function. We're going to all collaborate. I said, I'm not going to push decision making down. I'm going to pull decision making in. I'm the chief editor. I'm like an orchestra conductor and I have to understand enough about each instrument to make sure it creates one sound. The other thing I said is we're going to connect product and marketing together. Product at a company are like chefs. Marketing are like waiters and they never allow the waiters in the kitchen. They get yelled at. And I thought, well, what if you actually have them collaborate on product?
27:21 Speaker 04 What if marketing, you know, challenges engineering and engineering inspires marketing? They could actually be connected. And I think you can tell the health of the organization by how connected engineering and marketing are. And so we did this. We then started doing release cycles, which meant instead of doing this agile bottoms up A B testing, shipping continuously every minute of every day. Now, we do some of that still. We said 70, 80% of our product release is going to be done like hardware. We're going to ship stuff twice a year. And the reason- We're going to do that is we're going to embrace constraints. When you ship stuff at the same time, everyone's on a deadline. Then I meet with every single team every week, every two weeks, every four weeks. I'm working and editing the work. I'm making sure all fits together.
28:04 Speaker 04 It ladders up to a cohesive product story. And then the product marketing team, which is, which our group, we have this function called product marketing. It's actually outbound marketing plus product management in one role. So you're not.
28:18 Speaker 03 This is very much like Apple, by the way. Apple's the other company.
28:20 Speaker 04 Yes, yes, and we took that from them.
28:21 Speaker 03 Has product marketing at scale.
28:22 Speaker 04 And we took that at them because they're really good at talking about the product. And we thought, again, we don't want to have senior product managers. There are no senior product managers at Airbnb. If you're a senior product manager, you also have to do outbound marketing. You're not allowed to decouple the roles. We have no pure product marketers who don't do product management. We don't allow that. And their job is to keep the entire company stitched together and make sure we understand what the story we're telling, who the customer is for, and make sure everything we deliver ships that product. So we've done this. We now do two releases a year. The reason we're talking is because we just did our summer release for May. And what we found is this. When I told people in the LA about this development process, the first thing everyone said is this is going to be horrible. No one's going to want to work together. It's going to stifle innovation. It's going to be too top down. You're not going to have as many ideas.
29:07 Speaker 04 It's going to be a bottleneck, et cetera, et cetera. I can tell you all the reasons this is a bad idea. What we found is we ship way faster. We have now shipped 340 upgrades. We shipped over 53 upgrades today. It creates a drumbeat for their organization, a rhythm. There is very little bureaucracy. Now, we do say no to more things. There are some downsides, like you can't do as many divergent things because everything is cohesive and integrated. But anything on the roadmap ships. Almost never do we greenlight something and it doesn't happen. So the answer to your question, we've been able to ship significantly faster. And the paradox is that people are actually happier. As I created more constraints, as the culture got a little more top down, I was more integrated.
29:50 Speaker 04 Everyone, if I asked them if they could, if they could have voted, 99% of people would have voted against this idea because it doesn't intuitively sound like something that sounds fun to work in. Now, maybe there's a bias of the people who. Who like it decided to stay and the people who don't like it decided to leave. There might be that too. I want to acknowledge that. But ultimately, I do think the company is much more productive and it actually bears out financially. When we were doing this bottoms up free for all approach, that's kind of my pejorative for it. We were basically losing $250 million in EBITDA a year. We were not profitable, growth was slowing, costs was rising. Last year, we did three and a half billion dollars in free cash flow. And we actually, I believe nearly like this might be now true.
30:33 Speaker 04 For every dollar we earn, I think we earn more free cash flow than Apple, Google, or Microsoft. More than 40% of revenue becomes free cash flow. Now, we're not nearly the size of them. That's not the point, but the point is it's extremely efficient. It helps to be a marketplace that's capital light, but it also helps to have one marketing department. It helps to not have a lot of waste. It helps to have one rhythm of the organization.
30:56 Speaker 03 So two things. One, you seem to have more conviction on this than ever. I went back and listened to our previous conversation. It's not that you ever have a lack of conviction. You're always very confident, but you were at the beginning of this process and you would allow in that conversation that you were going to tweak as you go. Now it seems like you have religion, like this is how you are going to run this company.
31:16 Speaker 04 Yes, that is 100% the case.
31:19 Speaker 03 And then two, one of the things that strikes me at this is you're saying, okay, we're not going to have bottoms up ideas, referring to that as pejorative. But as you are more remote, one thing that I have found is that ideas, the fragility of ideas is like more at risk than ever, right? It's like harder to have a new idea when you're not around each other all the time. And you're saying you're going to be hybrid and everything's going to flow up to you. And that does seem at odds with what you're saying about how fast you're able to innovate, right?
31:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
31:49 Speaker 03 How are you managing that tension?
31:51 Speaker 04 First of all, the organization, decision making and product generation is not bottom up. But this is a very important thing. The ideas don't all come from leadership. We do believe the best ideas come from anywhere and ideas do flow up the organization. But ideas travel up the organization, but decision making comes top down, not bottoms up. And I think that that is a very important nuance. But we're very, very integrated. Basically, either way, I think about the company is there's like 30 or 40 people. And the goal is to create one shared brain, one shared consciousness where 30 or 40 of us can be totally connected. If the top 30 or 40 people can be totally connected to one shared consciousness, then what happens is each concentric circle of seniority develops their own collaborative shared consciousness all the way down the organization. And this is really, really important.
32:36 Speaker 04 Now with regards to remote work, again, I just, just to clarify something, we're not pure remote. Like we have really nice offices and many people come to the office every day. We just don't mandate people come to the office every day, thousands of people. Again, also another thing, we are designing this really cool creative studio in our office in San Francisco at 88 Brandon Street. I have, you know, many of the, many of, many of my most important people come to that office multiple days a week, sometimes every single day a week. And so there is a core team. I go to the office, not every day of every week. I'm probably every other week I go in multiple days a week. And many of my team members are there.
33:17 Speaker 04 So again, it really depends by team, but like a lot of the product people, a lot of the creative generation, a lot of the core leadership of engineering, we are physically together, but we do not mandate downstream. The other thing is we travel together, like I'm here in New York and a couple dozen people came with me. We talk about the office is the laboratory and we, we talk about going into the field. So we try to travel together and a lot of teams travel together and we have these group experiences together, which I find very immersive. We also do this thing called a roadmap review. Twice a year, we gather all the top leaders in the company like, or many of the top people in the company and that are working on the roadmap, like 75, 80 people. We spend days together just going through every single thing. So, but the answer, maybe, maybe the final answer to your question is this.
34:02 Speaker 04 The more organized you are, the more flexible you can be with employees. So I always wondered, like, why do you need people in the office to know if they're working? If you have everyone on a roadmap and you track everything every single week, then you don't need people to be in an office to know they're getting worked on. The value of being in the office might be human connection. The value of the office might be that if we live our lives in front of a screen, we're going to be very lonely. The value might be that it's hard to trust people when you never have face-to-face interaction. And the other problem with Zoom is you can't have hallway conversations. You can't have one-on-one conversations. It's all a little bit too organized and ad hoc. So what I do, just to give you a little bit more color, and I run the company, we have a really robust program management function at Airbnb.
34:47 Speaker 04 Most companies don't. In fact, I think I saw a tweet from Paul Graham the other day where somebody said, "Describe what a product manager does." And he says, "They're the people who track everything that people are supposed to do." And I replied, "No, that's program management. That's not product management." But I realized that a lot of people conflate product manager, program management. Again, this is maybe something that's inspired by Apple. We have a very robust program management function that organizes everything. That's not the role of product management. The role of product management is to work with program management, but their job is to make sure we know what we're shipping, why we're shipping it, and that we actually deliver it. Program management is the people that keep the schedule, not product management. And because we have a robust program management, what ends up happening is I get a report every Sunday.
35:29 Speaker 04 Most people get metrics reports. I get product, um, program management reports. Every single project that I'm tracking in the company, a couple dozen projects, have a color code of green, yellow, red, orange, or lime green. It tells me a color code of like, who's on track, who's off track. Then I review the schedule. I have a schedule where I'll either review the work with the teams, with the key leadership every week, every two weeks, every month, every quarter. And this rhythm keeps us really, really on track. And then we can see all the dependencies. And everything moves towards these very public launch dates, so nothing can ship. That program management, I think, allows us to allow physical proximity. Because honestly, the thing that allows you to know what people are doing
36:13 Speaker 04 is the tracking of the work through program management. So that's how we've been able to solve it. And then people worry like, "Well, if you're remote, you're going to be complacent." I'm like, "If you want people to work faster..." There's two mechanisms to get people to work faster. One, you review the work on a cadence. Two, you have public deadlines. If you give a crazy deadline and then you review the work leading up to the deadline, that's your, that, that allows you to modulate the amount of intensity that people have. That's the best intensity, rather than saying stay in the office at 10:00 PM. It doesn't, that doesn't really do much for my mind.
36:46 Speaker 03 The thing that I, I find to be the most challenging is the conditions to take a small weird idea from just a thought to a product or a thing that is happening.
36:57 Speaker 04 Oh, that's a good point.
36:58 Speaker 03 You just need people around to, to just, to buffer it, to like support it.
37:03 Speaker 04 Totally.
37:03 Speaker 03 And I find that personally, very difficult to do when I'm remote and incredibly easy to do when I'm in person.
37:10 Speaker 04 I agree.
37:11 Speaker 03 And that to me seems like the reason that people are returning to offices, more than anything.
37:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
37:16 Speaker 03 It's the reason, for example, our team likes being around each other, is we can spiral each other into something bigger very quickly.
37:22 Speaker 04 I totally agree, and I don't think most people will find they need a hundred percent of their workforce together 50 weeks a year to do that. I think that in the big, you know, if you're a small team, maybe there's no difference. If you're like us, you're thousands of people, you're going to probably find that you need key people together at key moments. And so when we get into what I call production, I actually think we're much more productive remote. I think being in the office when your head's down in production, we're actually less productive. So right now, for example, Neel, we have a release coming next May, obviously. Today, we launched this release. We're working on stuff for next May. For the lead up to this today, we were more effective being remote or heads down. Just we're in production.
38:06 Speaker 04 But for next May, all that idea generation, it's much more constructive for us to be physically together.
38:17 Speaker 03 We have to take one more quick break. We'll be right back.
38:25 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
38:34 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
38:42 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
38:56 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration blog, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18 plus.
39:24 Speaker 03 We're back with Brian Chesky.
39:27 Speaker 03 I want to ask you just about the broader picture in tech. I think you're a pretty expansive thinker about these things. We are in a season of major change. The big tech companies are all doing layoffs. Interest rates are high. The startup ecosystem is Silicon Valley bank shaky. People are cutting products that haven't hit scale, even if they seem promising. Where are you landing in all of this right now? What do you see the broader tech ecosystem looking like?
39:52 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think this moment feels to me a little like when I came to Silicon Valley in 2007, 2008. In 2008, we were entering a recession. So a lot of tech companies were contracting. In 2008, we also had this supernova of a few tech trends converging. The internet was going international in 2008. So you could just ride the internet and a lot of countries were coming online. The iPhone had just launched. The App Store had come out, I think, in 2008. And so suddenly, like, mobile computing became a major platform shift. And then cloud computing meant that like, the cost to start a company went down and you could suddenly, like, you didn't need to build your own servers. I think AI is, to make an understatement,
40:36 Speaker 04 certainly as profound as that shift. Most important people I talked to by AI, and I'll just qualify this by saying like, I've had a pretty longstanding relationship with, say, Sam Altman. He's one of my close friends. I talk to him quite, kind of almost like every, like all the time. And I know James Meeke at Google and all those. Everyone says that this is at least as profound a shift as the internet. And some people say it's maybe as big as things like the industrial revolution. I think we can assume it's somewhere between the internet industrial revolution as a platform shift. Well, just imagine how big that is. It means that we're probably going to go through, like, imagine the last hundred years of change in this world. So go back to 1923 till today. We're probably going to go through that amount of human history and change in the next 20 or 30 years.
41:20 Speaker 04 Not in the next hundred years, because obviously change is accelerating. And by the way, that's both exciting and mildly concerning, right? Like, or terrifying, because we went through, like, multiple world wars. There were depressions, there were a lot of revolutions. And so we're going to have to be very, very careful. But just, we're staying on tech for a second. This is a major platform shift. And I think that's what I described this as. So we're kind of entering a mature zone where without AI, it seemed like the winners won. It was really hard to have a new mobile app and get it noticed in the store. And it didn't really seem like there were a lot of new players. And things were becoming a little, there was a little more stasis. And I also think that 10 years of low interest rates led to something that we had to learn the hard way. I think that there's always a saying, raise as much money as you can, hire as many people as you possible.
42:05 Speaker 04 And of course, you're probably familiar with this book, I think it's The Mythical Man Month, which says that the best way to slow a team down is add more people to the team. I found that the same way, that we were like a giant navy. And I said, instead of being the navy, we're going to be the Navy SEALs. We're going to be much more lean, we're going to be elite, we're going to move a lot faster. And I think a lot of tech companies have realized they have way too many employees doing way too many things. Honestly, I'll say this, like, not having so many new grads, not how many, so many people out of school. Some people, but not so many people that you can't actually train them. Because even then, you have too many first time managers, it's a free for all. So I think we were at the end of a natural period where there was too much capital, there were too many people probably in companies doing too many things at a platform that was maturing.
42:50 Speaker 04 I've seen three basic vectors for Airbnb. Just a step back. I think that, like, you think about it as a stack. We talked last time about a stack. There's like an AI stack. The bottom of the AI stack is what you might call base models. And there's like three to five base models. So Google has like maybe a couple of them. OpenAI is one, Anthropic has one, Microsoft Research kind of has one, although they seem to be mostly tied to OpenAI at this point. So those are the base models. Think of it like a highway. Those are infrastructure companies. They're building the highway. We're not going to be building base models because we're not going to be building infrastructure. The layer on top of that is now tuning the models. Tuning the models is going to be really important. If you and I go to ChatGPT and we ask it a question, we're probably going to get something like the same answer. And that would be because ChatGPT doesn't know your preferences. It doesn't know my
43:34 Speaker 04 preferences. And for many queries, getting the same answer is great. But what if you ask like, hey, like, where should I go on vacation? Or like, who's a good person to like, date? Well, depends. Who are you? What do you want in your life? And so I think that there needs to be a personalization layer on top of AI. And that's going to come from the data you have and the permission you get from customers. Now, I think our vision is eventually, one day, we're going to be one of the most personalized AI layers on the internet. We're going to design, hopefully, some of the leading AI interfaces. We're going to basically try to deeply understand you, learn about you, care about you, and be able to understand your preferences.
44:12 Speaker 03 Just one question. Do you think that interface is chat? I'm not 100% certain that that interface always looks like chat.
44:18 Speaker 04 It's definitely not. No way. Not even close. And I, by the way, have this, I've had this conversation with Sam Altman extensively. I'm going to give you an analogy. Do you remember when Steve Jobs launched the iPhone? That presentation, he said, the problem with the current so-called smartphones is the bottom half, all the keyboards, that the interface doesn't change. That, yeah, if you have a calculator, I want, if I have a camera, I want a different interface than a calculator.
44:47 Speaker 03 Yeah.
44:47 Speaker 04 Well, basically, every task wants a different interface. That is true of AI. That a text-based interface where I type text and I get text back is great for certain things. It is not great for, say, like, picking out an outfit or like, buying clothing, right? You want a more visual interface. And so I think that we're going to have to have more multimodal interfaces that combine photo, video, voice, all different things. It's almost like Minority Report, where you're like, pulling and pushing. And I think that like, text is actually a very low bandwidth form of communication. Sometimes giving something a picture and getting a picture back might be more intuitive, or pushing and pulling. So I think that the answer is text is great for
45:32 Speaker 04 some things. And I think that like, something more visual is great for others.
45:37 Speaker 03 Let me just ask you at the flip side of this. You run a user-generated content platform in the end, right?
45:42 Speaker 04 Yes.
45:43 Speaker 03 People who own homes put up listings. Every user-generated content platform executive I know is fearing the tsunami of garbage AI content. How are you gonna, how are you gonna push back on that?
45:57 Speaker 04 Oh my God, you just hit on a giant thing. I think everyone was fearing that like, the machines were gonna come to destroy us. Before they destroy us, what they're actually gonna do is mimic us, and we're not gonna know who they are and who we are. And that is actually the more near-term risk of AI. You know, already, you know, you saw that like iconic viral photo of the Pope, and I think, I thought that was a real photo at first. And maybe-
46:19 Speaker 03 I wanted that to be a real photo. That's actually the thing, I wanted it to be real.
46:23 Speaker 04 And that's today's technology. So what will the photo generation look like in two or three years? Now, it's possible, just like 20 years ago, when you saw special effects in a movie, you thought they were real, and now you have a more keen eye, and old special effects look fake. Our eyes might become more keen to artificial content, but I worry that technology may accelerate faster than our eye can adapt to what is real, it's not real. And that's just photos. Now, somebody can sound like an AI, they can voice-
46:50 Speaker 03 Right, but let me just put that into practice for you. You have a, I wanna list a house, and my house doesn't look so cool, and I ask an AI to stage better photos of my house.
47:00 Speaker 04 It could totally recreate fake photos. So, the point, yeah, so the point I'm getting at is authenticity of information and verification of information is now a whole new problem that we have to resolve on the internet. So like, I think that we need to develop new technology to re-authenticate photos, to re-authenticate people's identity, re-authenticate people's information. So, one of the things, I would like Airbnb, we created this thing called the host passport that comes with Airbnb room, but that's a gate with this bigger idea we have. We wanna eventually be able to create these identity, basically identities for people, which almost are like a digital passport, that you can use potentially on-platform or even off-platform. That's only possible if people trust the company, they trust that we've actually authenticated
47:45 Speaker 04 the person, and eventually that authentication might require things like biometrics, because you are gonna need some offline input to be able to authenticate, and this is some of the stuff we're looking at. But yeah, you're-
47:57 Speaker 03 You're getting biometric authentication of your hosts.
48:00 Speaker 04 And guest eventually. And I mean, I mean, to scale that is very, very difficult. But eventually I do think that you're going to need to have probably some biometric authentication mapped to a real physical identity to know that was definitively that person, probably.
48:16 Speaker 03 Okay, so one of my very favorite philosophical questions asked here at The Verge is what is a photo? And like, are phones are processing more photos than ever? And like Samsung phones will just concoct a photo of the moon. You have a very particular problem when it comes to what is a photo. I take a photo of my living room. A standard real estate photo is HDR'd to hell and back now, often has no bearing on reality. But that's what people expect. Then there's, I ask mid-journey to concoct a picture of a mid-century modern living room. And I put that on Airbnb. That seems like it would just be against the rules. Where's the line? There has to be a boundary where you're saying this is acceptable and this isn't.
49:00 Speaker 04 It's a really great question.
49:03 Speaker 04 Well, the one good thing about our platform is that like, after people book an Airbnb, they're asked to leave a review. And one of the really peculiar phenomenons of Airbnb is most people do. Seventy percent of people after they leave reservation leave a review. And on Amazon or like the App Store, it's like much, much lower. It's probably, I'm going to guess, the single digits. So we generally ask about accuracy. How accurate was the description of this listing? How accurate were the photos? And so I don't, I don't know possibly nearly where to, where to say where that line is. Like, clearly, like, like, increasing the saturation of photo, like, changing the exposure to put in its best, like, seems kind of like, kind of reasonable.
49:48 Speaker 04 But like, making it feel like the room is much larger than it is with a wide-angle lens, and you get there and it's small, is misrepresenting. So I kind of would leave it up to the community. There's going to be really subjective things where, even if we could know where the line is, How would we ever enforce it if we don't go and physically inspect the property? And so therefore, what we need to do is put it back on the community. And I think in this context, we're probably going to use the subjective measures of accuracy. People are going to rank the accuracy of the representation and then low accuracy listings are going to get down ranked and probably cross over. But you're probably asking a question we haven't reckoned with yet. Where exactly is that line between like mildly embellishing to make something look great and actually misrepresentation?
50:33 Speaker 04 I don't know the answer to that.
50:34 Speaker 03 Something else I wanted to ask you about is search. It seems like search is one of the things that will change first and fastest.
50:41 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
50:41 Speaker 03 I think about this quite a lot. Search is the architecture of the internet in basically every way you can think of. Most pages are designed to be indexed by search engines. Most people start at search in big ways. You actually bet against search a while ago. You've been saying, look, search isn't where our business is for a long time. But as search breaks apart even more and Google just starts answering the questions with AI or people use Bing instead of Google, which seems far fetched, but Microsoft is very hopeful about that happens. Do you see that changing the architecture of the internet? Do you see that changing your business?
51:14 Speaker 04 I think search is a tool. Like you need a hammer for some problems. You need a screwdriver for other problems. You need a spatula or you need like different tools for different problems. Right? I think we've been overly reliant on search for too many problems on the internet. The problem with search is it's basically a fill in the blank question. Right? So you have to know what you're looking for to search for. You have to type something in. And I think for many problems, that's good. But with travel, for example, that's not a good solution because, for example, Airbnb is in 100,000 cities. How do you know what to search for if you've never even heard about in the first place? And so now you have to use language like, well, I'm looking for something with da, da, da, da, da. Maybe you weren't even looking for it. Maybe you actually want to be inspired. You actually want to have more of a browse based functionality.
51:58 Speaker 04 So I do think search is useful if you know what you're looking for. I hope the architecture of the internet does break apart from an interface standpoint and that different interfaces are created for different use cases. So, you know, I think that like if I want to. Get medical advice like that might be a different kind of interface and maybe they can see me and I can show them something and if I
52:20 Speaker 03 This is a, this is kind of an old idea, right? This is what you might call vertical search.
52:24 Speaker 04 Yeah.
52:26 Speaker 03 It, it feels like we're in a moment for the internet where everything old is new again.
52:30 Speaker 04 That's probably true.
52:31 Speaker 03 I am running around saying like homepages are important to media and you're on the show saying, okay, we should go back to like verticals for different categories instead of funneling everything through a few major platforms.
52:43 Speaker 04 Here's one of the great things. What AI does, like think about it, 130 years ago, only probably a few people like could use a camera, right? It was a highly technical thing. It was expensive and so most people didn't take photos. Now, anyone in the world can basically use a camera. They're ubiquitous. They're on their phone. Never can point. I kind of think software development is going to be like that, that pretty soon everyone will be able to develop software because software is just a language you have to learn. Now, there's always going to be development below the stack at the deeply technical level, but a lot of that front end development is going to be replaced by natural language. As this happens, so many more people can develop software and as so many more people can develop software, I think you're going to see software in everything.
53:24 Speaker 04 We're going to have to create interface standards because we don't want to ping pong back and forth and just be like just totally confused. I don't even think search is the right use case for every task. Sometimes it's voice, sometimes it's a conversation. I also think ultimately it would be great if interfaces understood you better. This is a problem with Airbnb. Every time you come back to Airbnb, we show you a whole bunch of categories and if you're a budget traveler, we show you lux. And if you're wealthy, we might show you Airbnb room. We should know more about you. The way companies have tried to solve personalization is through data regression of clicks, right? So like if I clicked on something in the past, then I'm going to show you that in the future.
54:04 Speaker 04 But that's actually not a great way to understand somebody. Like maybe like I went on Amazon, I bought a bunch of alcohol, but I'm actually now recovering alcoholic and I don't want to do that. I'm trying not to drink and you don't know that, you know, and that the minibar like has alcohol there and that I, because I order all the time, but I actually feel bad about it and I actually don't want to drink. And so I think companies developing a better understanding of you, having a sense of your personalized preferences, having that then interface is going to be really important. And I actually think it allows many more people to participate in the economy. Cause in the past, the only people that could build software were engineers.
54:38 Speaker 03 One of the big opportunities for a company like Airbnb in a world where you can develop new kinds of software and you can personalize better is advertising. We're seeing the big platform companies, they're doing okay in their ad businesses, but the dollars are starting to move here and there. You have talked about building an advertising business for Airbnb, sponsored listings, that sort of thing. I think you've said it's an enormous opportunity. Where are you on the roadmap there? Do you see, do you see this as an opportunity because of the shift from platforms? Or is this a sort of a standalone next obvious business?
55:10 Speaker 04 It's just like a very obvious opportunity that can align incentives for people that are really motivated to want to promote their listings. And it's obviously an extremely high margin business opportunity. I mean, I don't know if I read the last Amazon earnings correct, but did I hear that they have like something like a $40 billion like advertising business now or something? And it's like almost a pure margin and that may be the most probable.
55:30 Speaker 03 But you have to categorize it because they're just advertising their own listings. It's very strange.
55:34 Speaker 04 It's very weird. So, I mean, clearly there's hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars of potential revenue if we built a pay for promotion platform. I mean, there's a variety of estimates of how, what that could generate. I think it's very.
55:50 Speaker 03 Do you think that ruins the purity of the platform? The way that you talk about Airbnb and the experience of using it, there's a, there's a pureness there, there's a sincerity.
55:57 Speaker 04 There's a trade off. There is a trade off between building an ad platform and the user experience, or there could be. And so I've been extremely cautious. I've been cautious about building an ad platform because I think first of all, ad platforms can be a little bit like drugs. You start with like one milligram, then you increase it to two milligrams, then five milligrams, and you never go backwards in dosage, you just keep going upwards in dosage. And you look at a lot of search platforms like Google and like a year ago, like 10 years ago, there was one ad and then there's two ads and there's four ads. There's four ads plus an ad module and you don't even really see organic results anymore. So I've been thinking a lot about like, how do we build something that could be beneficial to the business, that could align incentives, but it's actually good for the user experience
56:41 Speaker 04 and doesn't become a drug where you just continue to increase the dosage every year if you have more and more pressure from shareholders.
56:46 Speaker 03 You've given me so much time. Last question, we've talked a lot about Apple and how inspired you are by Apple's structures, by the organization, by some of their processes, by Steve Jobs. You do have this longstanding deal now with Johnny Ive and his agency Love From. Have they shipped anything with you? What does that relationship look like? What has it accomplished for you?
57:07 Speaker 04 In 2014, we were designing our new logo, this like what people know as our logo. And I knew Johnny Ive and I sent it to him and he said, oh, well, I'm not going to do a fake British accent, but he basically talked to me about like the continuous curvature that like you shouldn't have flat lines. So he and the team spent some time and he redesigned the spleens of the curb. And so the actual logo that you see on Airbnb, the final mark was designed by Johnny Ive. I kept in touch with him. And then when I read he left Apple, I said, like, we got to work together. We started talking a lot in the beginning of 2020. Again, it happened perfectly, coincidentally, with a period of time when I felt like we had a crisis, almost the size of Apple's crisis in the late 90s. And I turned to him
57:52 Speaker 04 and obviously he gave me a lot of great advice. He told me a couple of things. The first thing is we used to talk about our mission as belonging. And the problem with using the word belonging is I noticed that employees were confusing belonging with inclusion. And then they were conflating inclusion with the lack of discrimination. And then they said, well, our mission is to not discriminate. And I said, well, that's a really low bar. Of course you shouldn't discriminate. But when we say belonging, it has to be more than just inclusion. It has to actually be the proactive manifestation of meeting people, creating connections and friendships. And Johnny Ive said, well, you need to reframe it. It's not just about belonging. It's about human connection and belonging. And that was, I think, a really big unlock. The next thing Johnny Ive said is he created this
58:36 Speaker 04 book for me and the title of the book, like this little book of his ideas. And the book was called Beyond Where and When. And he basically said that Airbnb should shift from beyond where and when to who and what. Who are you and what do you want in your life? And that was a part of the inspiration behind Airbnb categories, that we wanted people to come to Airbnb without a destination in mind, and that we could categorize properties, not just by location, but by what makes them unique. And that really influenced Airbnb categories and some of the stuff we're doing now. The third thing is He really helped me think through the sense that Airbnb is a community. You know, this is really interesting. Most people think of Johnny Ive as like somebody who deals with like atoms, like aluminum and glass.
59:20 Speaker 04 But actually, he said that he spent 30 years building tools. And what he realizes now is that we don't just need more tools, we need more connections. And I thought that was a really profound thing. And he really helped us think of ourselves. This is a subtle word shift, Neelai, but going from a marketplace to a community. Because in a marketplace, everything's a transaction. And in a community, everything should not be a transaction. Otherwise, those aren't real relationships or real connections. And so he has thought helped me think about how to shift from a marketplace to a community. I think some of that inspiration is what led to, you know, Airbnb rooms, what led to the creation of Host Passport. But he and the team are heads down with me, working on stuff that's going to ship next May and next November. And I'm hoping that like where we are, and this is one of the things Johnny and I talked about,
1:00:04 Speaker 04 is we need permission to do new things. So I'll just rewind. It's the year 2005, 2000, maybe 2006. And everyone was hoping that Apple would come out with an iPhone. And in 2007, in January, Steve Jobs announced it. Now, the reason we all wanted Steve Jobs to come out with an iPhone in 2006 and 2007 was because most of us loved our iPods. None of us were asking Gateway Computer to come out with a phone because we didn't love Gateway's laptops. And so basically, I think we need to have permission to do new innovative things. And we have permission when people love the core thing. And I came to the conclusion that we needed to focus much more on a core service, that people were still complaining, they're complaining about pricing, they're complaining about cleaning fees,
1:00:48 Speaker 04 they're complaining about all sorts of things about Airbnb. And again, it comes from this disease that happens a lot of founders, or this thing that happens where we fall out of love with our core business. And I told you a few, a couple of years ago, that like when we almost lost our business, we stared into the abyss. There's something about almost losing something that makes you fall back in love with it. And I think maybe that happened to our core business. And we said, before we go on to new things, before we do like whatever we're going to do, we're going to get back to the core, back to the basics, and really just focus on making Making this product something that people love. And so for the last few years, that's what we've tried to do. We've tried to basically fix as many things as possible. That's why we created a blueprint. Let's be systematic about the complaints. Let's be systematic about how we address the feedback. And let's tell a story to the community, all the things we're fixing.
1:01:34 Speaker 04 And my hope is that the end of this year, we'll have addressed, to some extent, every single thing people are complaining about. They really do love the service. It feels truly delightful. So our vision for this company is the following. The Airbnb is a marriage of art and science, that we're a truly creatively led company. Our two core values are basically designing creativity, married with technologies, one, and then this idea of community and connection, a company with like this real humanistic feel, that you come to Airbnb, that we ask you a series of questions. We learn about you. We understand who you are, what you want. We design these incredibly simple interfaces. And then our job as a host is we develop these really robust AI algorithm, matching algorithms, and then we can match you to whatever you want.
1:02:20 Speaker 04 And so if we can build this incredibly robust identity system, if we can have the most robust profiles, almost like a physical, social network, where we can connect people together in this community. We can use AI to augment customer service, to deeply understand and resolve your issues within seconds, not just minutes or hours. And we can then build these incredibly simple interfaces where we match you to whatever you want in your life. That's basically the idea of where we're trying to go. And Johnny Ive and his team, they're working on things just in that area.
1:02:49 Speaker 03 All right, Brian, that was the most incredible, bring it back to the beginning, wrap up answer I think I've ever heard on Decoder. Congratulations. You did it. You got all the way back to the top. You've given us so much time. Thank you so much for being on the show, man.
1:03:00 Speaker 04 Thank you very much.
1:03:03 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Brian Chesky for taking the time to talk today. Thank you for listening to Decoder. I hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of the show. You can email us at [email protected] or hit us up directly. We're at DecoderPod on both Twitter and TikTok. If you like the show, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like the show, hit us with that five star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Jack McDermott with research by Liz Leung. The Decoder music is Red Breakmaster Cylinder. Our editorial director is Brooke Minter, and our executive producer is Norrie Donovan. We'll see you next time.
1:03:44 Speaker 06 Hi, work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know, I've made things a little difficult in the past. Okay, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG, and finally, I understand. Now I'm making work work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, Pay, and Workforce Management.
1:04:15 Speaker 07 Everyone's got a hard question about AI. Your job, your kids, where it's going. Anthropic was built to surface those questions and share what it finds along the way. Because there's hope in hard questions. Ask yours at claud.ai/spotify and keep thinking. That's claud.ai/spotify.
Previous The social media age for news is over. Former BuzzFeed News editor Ben Smith on what’s next Next Exclusive: Google’s Sundar Pichai talks Search, AI, and dancing with Microsoft Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated