Pod Insights Decoder How WordPress and Tumblr are keeping the internet weird, with Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg About this episode Matt Mullenweg is the CEO of Automattic, the company that owns WordPress.com, which he co-founded, and Tumblr, the irrepressible social network it acquired from the wreckage of AOL, Yahoo, and Verizon. Matt’s point of view is that the world is better off when the web is open and fun, and Automattic builds and acquires products that help that goal along.
Links:
Exclusive: Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg on what’s next for Tumblr
Verizon is selling Tumblr to WordPress’ owner
Automattic, owner of Tumblr and WordPress.com, buys podcast app Pocket Casts
Gutenberg
Tumblr Shop
Why Apple’s new privacy feature is such a big deal
Taylor Swift's Tumblr
Tumblr will ban all adult content on December 17th
How Tumblr Became Popular for Being Obsolete
Basecamp CTO David Heinemeier Hansson and Rep. David Cicilline on Apple's monopolistic app store fees
Inside Sonos' decision to sue Google - and how it won
After the porn ban, Tumblr users have ditched the platform as promised
The Trauma Floor: The secret lives of Facebook moderators in America
Vox Media adds The Coral Project
Transcript:
https://www.theverge.com/e/22741898
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott. Research was done by Liz Lian. It was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Sr Audio Director is Andrew Marino and our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 14,244 words · 8 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control. Set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards. All backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
0:28 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an ultra. Because it's not just a superior-like beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser-Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
0:58 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neil Appel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Matt Mullenweg, the CEO of Automattic, the company that owns WordPress.com and Tumblr, the irrepressible social network it acquired from the wreckage of AOL, Yahoo, and Verizon. Yes, Verizon owned Tumblr for a minute, but it doesn't anymore. Automattic does. And Matt runs it all. His point of view is the world is better off when the web is open and fun, and Automattic builds and acquires products that help that go along. It owns SimpleNote, the popular note-taking application. It owns the podcast player Pocket Cast, which some of you might be listening to this on.
1:41 Speaker 02 The bet is that you need an open alternative to Apple and Spotify. That bet is perhaps most pronounced with WordPress itself, which Matt co-founded. If you don't know, WordPress is one of the most popular web publishing platforms in the world. Something like 43% of all the websites on the internet run on WordPress, which is a piece of open-source software that anyone can download and use for free. It is officially administered by the WordPress Foundation, a charitable organization that Matt founded. But if you don't want all that hassle, you can just go to wordpress.com and pay Automattic to do all the work for you. It is an absolutely fascinating business model that has clearly worked very well.
2:24 Speaker 02 And I wanted to know more about why Matt set it up that way and what the challenges of that structure are. Automatic also runs WooCommerce, which is an open source competitor to Shopify. They're both platforms that enable people to sell things online. If you've been listening to Decoder, you know that we had Shopify's Harley Finkelstein on the show a few months ago. If you have a website, the next thing you might want to do is sell things on it. And the dynamics of the competition for commerce services are all over the place after Apple basically reset the online ad market when it enabled something called "app-tracking transparency" on the iPhone. It was great for privacy, but it made it harder to sell things online because it's now harder to target customers with ads.
3:08 Speaker 02 You can debate the trade-off between the two things endlessly, but I was curious how Matt saw things playing out. And of course, I wanted to talk about Tumblr, which, I mean, it's Taylor Swift's favorite social platform. It's one of those things that users have kept alive no matter how many corporate owners have tried to kill it. Under Automatic, it's thriving once again, but like every social platform, it has meaningful moderation challenges. Famously, to even get an app on Apple's App Store, it had to ban porn, which users are still upset about. Matt and I talked about these challenges, how Tumblr is currently moderated, and his ideas for the future of moderation, which he thinks they can do much better while still keeping Tumblr one of the more permissive social platforms for artists on the web.
3:52 Speaker 02 One note, Matt mentioned something called Gutenberg a few times. That's the new creation experience in WordPress, the part of the site where people actually make things. He is very proud of it. Okay, this one's long, but it's deep. I think you're gonna like it. Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Automatic. Here we go.
4:21 Speaker 02 Matt Mullenweg, you are the CEO of Automattic. You're the co-founder of WordPress. Right now, you just told me you are also technically the CEO of Tumblr. Welcome to Decoder.
4:31 Speaker 03 Very happy to be here.
4:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's been a couple of years since we talked. The last time you and I chatted was right after the Tumblr acquisition. That was fascinating conversation. That was years ago, so there's lots to follow up on. Automattic has bought a lot of companies. You've released a lot of products. Started with WordPress, which you obviously founded. You acquired Tumblr. You bought Pocket Casts. You have WooCommerce.
4:53 Speaker 02 Start at the start. What is Automattic? How do you think about it? And what are all of your companies?
4:58 Speaker 03 Sure. So Automattic is a fully distributed company since 2005, so 17 years now. That's trying to make the web a better place. We want to democratize publishing and commerce, which we've been saying for a long time, before democratizing was cool. To do that, we both build or partner or buy with things that make the web more open and fun. And we're on a podcast now. Pocket Casts, I believe, is one of the very best podcasting apps. It's very user-centric. It's an independent alternative to Spotify's and Apple's of the world. And we're just relentlessly iterating on it to try to respond to user requests and make it better. Most of our business models are through people paying us.
5:37 Speaker 03 So versus advertising or other models, we provide upgrades and those recurring revenue is what allow us to come to work the next day. We're about to come up on 2,000 people. We're working full-time at Automattic, so it's really grown a lot even since last time we talked. I think we hired over 700 last year.
5:54 Speaker 02 700 people. Where'd you hire them all?
5:57 Speaker 03 All over the world. We have folks in 93 countries now. From the very beginning, but still, especially last year, our big advantage is that we're not really geographically restricted in where we hire people. And of course, you know, strong believers that talent is evenly distributed in the world. Opportunity is not. So when we provide opportunity to places where they don't normally have it, like we find really, really amazing people. And they tend to be great colleagues that stay for a really long time. The other unusual thing we do is we pay global pay rates, which also helps for international recruiting. So we pay similar ranges for salaries regardless of what country you're in.
6:32 Speaker 02 That sounds great. I just want to dive into the practice of it real quick. You want to pay someone in your 92nd country and you only have one person there. Your compliance cost to that's very high, right? You've got to like, register with the government and figure out their tax situation. Like, how do you manage all that? Because that seems like, wow, that's a lot of overhead to be that distributed.
6:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, and there are companies as well that can manage this for you. Like even in the US, when we started, like, all 50 states have different rules and different counties have different rules and everything. So most people end up working with like a payroll provider. There are some international equivalents. The other answer, just very simply, is that some of these people are technically contractors who bill monthly a fixed amount every month. So that removes a lot of overhead, especially for places where you might just have a single person in the country. It puts a little burden on folks to have to handle their own taxes and they usually register a corporation, the contracts and things like that. But it does simplify things a lot.
7:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, I've always loved this model and it seems like for a lot of people who've tried it, that you just like run into the rocks of, in practice, there's actually some amount of complexity you have to manage through. And then also, I think the other question is, in practice, okay, I want to find the best podcast host in the entire world.
7:52 Speaker 02 How? Right? Like, that's, I can't, like, if there's one person who's the best at it for my role in there in Luxembourg, like, how am I going to find that person? How do you go find these people?
8:02 Speaker 03 You know, something I think companies don't do enough is just promote to their user base or promote to their audience, you know? There's probably three roles that you're really trying to hire for Virg right now. Like, say those. But run an ad for them. You run ads for other people. Run ads for yourself, you know? We try to put Easter eggs all over our products that lead people to our jobs page. We've tried to make all the about pages of our apps a lot better, like Day1, Pocket Cast, Tumblr. So like, if people are in there, like, point them to your hiring. And your existing audience, I think, is a fantastic way, especially if you, like us, have an audience of hundreds of millions of people.
8:39 Speaker 02 Yeah. You started to mention some of the products, Day1, Tumblr, Pocket Casts, WordPress. What's the, what's the suite? Can you do them all?
8:48 Speaker 03 Sure. Well, I'll say the big ones. So, wordpress.com.
8:53 Speaker 03 WooCommerce and our enterprise business, which is called WordPress VIP, are the drivers of Automattic's business. Yeah. And WordPress.com, a lot of people think of it as like a simpler place to host WordPress, but they don't know that it actually can run all plugins and themes to WordPress. And it's all auto updated, all auto secure. So think of it like a place you can run any WordPress site. It's totally bulletproof, highly secure, update and can get basically as much traffic as you could throw at it. WooCommerce is open source Shopify. So it's, I think the only ecommerce platform growing as fast as Shopify.
9:33 Speaker 03 We did 31 billion of goods sold through WooCommerce last year, which I think was doubling year on year. You can sell pretty much anything online and it integrates with WordPress. And then enterprise has been kind of fun. It's basically like large enterprises who want to use WordPress. Hopefully maybe The Verge someday. But some other sites, TechCrunch, one that just switched over is thewhitehouse.gov, which of course is very interesting right now with all the things happening internationally. So we, we can host any size of WordPress that you can imagine and also make it very, very secure. Just like, basically like the beefed up version of what we do for regular users. So that's what drives the business. So I don't want to distract them after these other things.
10:16 Speaker 03 But we also have always had what we call five for the future. And so this is an idea, one in the WordPress community, that companies put 5% of their resources back into open source. So this basically avoids the tragedy of comments. So 5% of the 2,000 employees work full time contributing to open source. They're not working on any of our commercial products or anything like that. And I feel like that's honestly the bare minimum that as users of WordPress, right? Cause we're, we don't build at all, that we can contribute back to make the community better. We also do 5% for like new stuff, like kind of our version of other bets or experiments or labs. And that's what some of these other products fall into, like Day1, Pocket Casts, et cetera.
11:00 Speaker 03 These are typically really well-loved products that have a very passionate user base. Simple Notes is another one that's really popular. And you've, Verge has covered really positively in the past. That we want to cross promote, we want to sort of bring our long-term. Investment to bear to see what could happen. I think, you know, that's what WooCommerce was seven years ago. It was kind of small, wasn't making a ton of money. And now it's a powerhouse. It's going to be as big as the rest of the company combined pretty soon. And I think that some of these other products, including Day1, have that potential.
11:36 Speaker 02 Let's start with the, you said the tragedy of the commons. It's a powerful phrase. What do you mean by it specifically as it relates to open source software?
11:43 Speaker 03 Tragedy of the commons is from economics, actually. And it's this story that there's like a common field that belongs to this town, but it doesn't belong to any one person. And so if all the farmers brought their sheep and cattle to graze in that field, but none of them were sort of investing in maintaining it, or maybe not having their particular sheep or cattle, lay off it so things can regrow. It will get overgrazed and die, and there's no more grass, and everyone loses. So how this happens in open source is that it's very easy for companies to use open source without contributing anything back. But that's kind of one of the features of it. So we can't complain about it, really, because that is what the license says you can and should do.
12:26 Speaker 03 But I think that companies who think more long term say, okay, I'm getting a ton of value for this. I'm not paying a penny. How do I make sure that this is around five or 10 years from now? Now, we've seen examples of libraries that the whole internet depends on.
12:42 Speaker 02 Yes, this is where I was headed towards, yeah.
12:44 Speaker 03 But we also have examples of, you know, open source projects that reach an exit velocity, where they become this positive flywheel, more people using them, which means more people contributing to them. And they become just totally ubiquitous, almost like natural monopolies, but not evil-like monopolies, monopolies that belong to everyone. So they do good. And that could be things like the Chromium browser engine, which is now powering Internet Explorer, Microsoft's product, in addition to Brave and Chrome. WordPress in the CMS space now has 43% of all websites. It's growing faster than all the others combined. So that'll reach probably 80, 85% in the next decade.
13:27 Speaker 03 You get kind of these Wikipedia for like online knowledge.
13:30 Speaker 02 You just definitely predicted that WordPress, both the open source and I'm assuming WordPress.com, will power 85% of websites in the next decade?
13:39 Speaker 03 I think that's what we could do. If you look at like number of handsets powered by Android, it's about 85%.
13:47 Speaker 03 Um, the browser share that I think Chromium as an engine is going to get to.
13:51 Speaker 04 Yeah.
13:51 Speaker 03 Eighty-five, ninety percent. So you'll, you'll always have like ten or fifteen percent of other stuff, new stuff, et cetera. But what happens is when you get the opposite of the tragedy of the commons, when you get the abundance of the commons, it becomes a super feature. Like I said, this positive flywheel where the more people that use something, the more people contribute, the better it gets. And since it's totally free and belongs to everyone, there are more reasons for people to use it. So the software can evolve really rapidly. If you think of the rate of evolution, it just outmatches anything, even including proprietary competitors that might have hundreds of millions or billions of dollars behind them. Uh, they just can't match the brilliance of the world working together on a single thing.
14:31 Speaker 02 Uh, you said it was about two thousand people now, seven hundred new people in the last year. How is that structured? Who works where?
14:38 Speaker 03 So we're structured a bit. We, we call ourselves like a, a digital Berkshire Hathaway. So, uh, myself as the CEO of the company and some centralized services, including like, uh, HR, legal, systems, try to essentially like serve these relatively independent teams that have a lot of autonomy for how to organize, run themselves, iterate on their product. So this middle part of the company, call it two hundred people, is doing everything we can to remove barriers and help the rest of the company go faster. And then the teams, they run like little mini companies. They have their own CEOs. They have executives, CMOs, they're, they're developing their own boards, actually.
15:21 Speaker 03 And, uh, then part of what, you know, the centralized part does as well is say, hey, we're doing this same thing in two places. Like, we're building a newsletter thing over here for WooCommerce, and we're building a newsletter thing for WordPress.com. How do we combine that and make sure that they work with each other and they complement each other? So I think all org structures are a series of trade-offs. So we trade off for speed and autonomy, but then sometimes we have to come back and make sure we're working with ourselves pretty well.
15:46 Speaker 02 The secretive decoder said fundamentally, this is a show about org charts. I don't know if anybody warned you, like.
15:51 Speaker 03 Really?
15:51 Speaker 02 Somewhere inside of the show is a, is a series of org chart conversations every single time. The reason I ask is, it, you'd be surprised. I think when you get CEOs, uh, uh, here, I'll throw this theory at you. The most important decision a CEO, any CEO is going to make is how is their company structured? So the most revealing, my theory is the most revealing question you can ask CEOs, how, how'd you structure your company? And it, everyone has to answer that question because they need to know. If you, if you don't know the answer to that question, you've revealed something very important about yourself as a CEO. Whereas if I just like came and hammered you, which I will soon, like, why didn't you solve this moderation crisis? The answer might be revealing, it might not be revealing, but it's not the central
16:36 Speaker 02 truth of like how you organize company. That's my thesis. I'm curious what you think about that.
16:41 Speaker 03 It reminds me of, I think it's a Picasso quote where it says like when, when art critics get together, they talk about like philosophy of art and what this movement means for this movement. But when artists get together, they talk about, "Lord, buy cheap turpentine." When brushes are kissing. It becomes a lot more tactical, but that's actually where a lot of the artistry comes from. It is true that when I get together with other executives, we often obsess about organizational design. But I think what I've learned there is it's not that one design is better than another. It's that you're choosing a series of trade offs and you need to be deliberate about what trade offs you're doing. One example of a trade off we've switched on over the years is for a while, our design was totally distributed across all the teams.
17:25 Speaker 03 Because we want these teams to be cross functional.
17:27 Speaker 02 Just like product design.
17:29 Speaker 03 Product design, yeah. And so for a few years, we actually centralized design. We brought all the designers into like a central team, reporting structure, had a really awesome, strong lead there. And that was part of like improving quality, what we're doing. But once we accomplished that, we put the designers back out into all the teams and divisions. The other fun thing I like to say about Automattic is that it's fractal. Meaning that when you zoom in or out, it's self similar. So when the entire company was 20 people, it looks a lot like what a team of 20 people looks like now. So we try to make it so there's a, there's sort of a natural growth and division of, of teams.
18:10 Speaker 02 That's fascinating. I think the big question for me is you described three things as all the business and a bunch of other things as other bets. When I look at other companies that are organized like that, there, there's a natural tension, right? Like, when are the other bets going to become bets? How are you thinking about that? Why are you thinking about, okay, I'll know Pocket Casts has graduated out of other bets and become a real business when X?
18:36 Speaker 03 An easy threshold would be 10% of revenue for the company.
18:40 Speaker 03 So it's under that, it probably is going to be part of the other best structure. And you know, maybe report up to a common executive or be abstracted a little bit. And if it's above that, you know, it's a serious business for us. And it's going to have its own representation that like, we're going to talk about to the board every, every quarter and things. I'll talk about it with you.
18:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
18:58 Speaker 03 It's uh, but the, you know, the tricky part is actually that we have, and particularly the press has like an addiction to novelty. And so the new thing draws a lot of the attention. But you have to balance that with like, we've launched like thirty new things on wordpress.com this year alone. That like drastically changed the user experience. Gutenberg is like redefining not just WordPress, but CMSs in general, being used by other CMSs. We're about to put it on Tumblr as well. So there's, there's some really exciting stuff happening, but it doesn't always necessarily fit easily into the narrative.
19:31 Speaker 02 Well, don't worry on this show, it's like org charts and decision making and then we'll get into WordPress. Actually, that's my next, this is the decoder question. How do you make decisions when, when you're deciding to centralize and then decentralize design? How do you come about that decision?
19:48 Speaker 03 Hmm, me personally or the organization?
19:51 Speaker 02 Both, and how are they different?
19:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, we, attention that we have is, there's definitely folks in automatic who want me, Matt, to have like answers. And they'll ask me a question and be like, what is the vision for XYZ or something like that? But almost everything we've done in designing the company is saying that the answers are at the edge. The wisdom is in the people talking to customers, doing the work, writing the code, like designing things, testing, doing user tests. And so we want to make it so the decisions come from the people with the most information. So I try to make as few decisions as possible and really say, how do we push that out to the teams, the divisions, you know?
20:37 Speaker 03 The edges of the, the branches of the tree versus the chunk. With the assumption that, you know, none of us are as smart as all of us and. Now, what do we build in there? So what are things I do ask? I ask for transparency, so that things are written down, shared, communicated. I love the idea of decision journals. So we use this internal blogging system built on WordPress called P2.
21:02 Speaker 02 I was gonna say movable type.
21:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's built on movable type. But what's interesting and automatic is there's no internal email. Like, I get a handful of emails a year from my colleagues. Everything happens on these internal blogs. And what that means is we have essentially like organizational blockchain, where every single decision going back to like 2007 now is on one of these internal blogs. So you can find how every piece of code works, or every business decision, or every logo, or every, everything is in there somewhere. So even if like you and I decided something on a meeting, we need to write it up afterwards. So it's on this P2 so people can participate in it asynchronously and future generations or future versions of ourself who've forgotten why we made a decision can tell why we did that. And then finally, we try to say reversible decisions quickly
21:49 Speaker 03 and irreversible decisions deliberately or slowly. You can kind of put pretty much every decision into two categories. Most, 99% of what you do is very reversible. Some things are really big. Who you take funding from? Acquisitions, like these things are hard to unwind. So you need to make those decisions very deliberately.
22:09 Speaker 02 What's a decision that comes to you that you have to make regularly?
22:12 Speaker 03 You know, what's funny is especially across 2,000 people, the things that come to me are the things which no one else has been able to resolve yet, ideally. So it's made it through a lot of layers of really smart, talented people trying to resolve it before it got to me. And so that means that my job is never dull. And I like, I see the edge cases. I see the things which across 2,000 people in 93 countries are like the stuff you never thought of. No one's thought of before or is completely novel.
22:45 Speaker 02 Let's talk about WordPress. It is a giant. It is perhaps an overlooked giant, as you were alluding to earlier. You did just roll out this big new upgrade to it called Gutenberg. How big is WordPress? How many, how many people work on it?
23:01 Speaker 03 At the company, it's probably about 500 people working on WordPress. But for every WordPress release, like version 5.9 that came out in December, we list all the contributors and people employed by Automattic are typically 10% or less of the contributors.
23:17 Speaker 02 Wow.
23:18 Speaker 03 So that's one of the cool things about WordPress community is that even though we've had this for-profit that I started Automattic for 17 years now, the community has grown and thrived over that. So there's lots of plugins, you know, tens of thousands of plugins, themes, billions of dollars of business that goes through other companies in the ecosystem. And that's something we very deliberately work on, like throughout when you study platforms, you know, whether that's Windows, other operating systems, platforms that were real platforms versus platforms that weren't, there's typically a ratio that comes in, which is one to 20.
23:59 Speaker 03 So the creator of the platform or the base contributor or the commercializer or whatever you want to call it, if they're making more than 5% of the revenue in that ecosystem, they're probably suffocating the ecosystem. So like, it's interesting also if you apply this to app stores.
24:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm gonna get there, it's all right.
24:18 Speaker 03 But I would also argue that there's a lot of money being made on top of app stores. Like, think of every, you know, DoorDash delivery or Uber ride taken. So there's actually, even though the 30% cut seems egregious and probably unsustainable, if you were to look at the total ecosystem of value built on top of Android iOS, actually, I would argue that they've been very successful platforms and Apple's take all their revenues, probably less than 5% of the value they're creating in the world. So that's what we target. It's also what distinguishes the WordPress ecosystem from the proprietary competitors like Shopify or X or Squarespace, which typically will make, you know, 50 to 95% of the revenue in their ecosystem goes to those companies.
25:01 Speaker 02 I think you might be our first open source CEO on the show, depending on when this runs. How do you manage that, right? So WordPress is a big open source project. Anybody can go download WordPress, start a site, you got nothing to do with it, no revenue flows to you. Anybody can modify it and do whatever they want with it. Then there's what they contribute back to the main open source code so that you can release new versions. You guys manage that. Then you have a business next to it. How does all of that work? Like, is there one person who's sort of like, I'm in charge of WordPress? And is like approving the patches that get submitted? Like, how are you managing that aspect? And how are you deciding, okay, this is the stuff that will make a release?
25:43 Speaker 03 So I was WordPress's lead developer before Automattic started, so a couple of years. So that's kind of the first hat I wear. You know, you dance with the one that brought you. So when I'm thinking long term, I'm thinking first and foremost, what will be best for the WordPress community? This year, 10 years, 30 years from now? Like, what will make us the most sustainable, the most resilient, the most anti-fragile? So I think of that first. I've tried to structure the company I also run, Automattic, in a way that its economic self-interest is totally aligned with what I believe to be the best long term for the broader WordPress community.
26:26 Speaker 03 And so that includes things like the way that we've chosen to monetize. For example, a lot of open source projects, when they monetize, they create kind of a extra features version and the good stuff. And that's usually how they get you to upgrade. We're very explicitly, like what you can buy from wordpress.com, you could also buy from Bluehost or GoDaddy or WP Engine or something. So the challenge there is that you can actually buy WordPress from anyone. It's literally a commodity in that anyone can sell you something called WordPress. And by the way, we put all the best stuff into that. Like Gutenberg, which vastly expands what you can do with WordPress. That's Incor. It's free. It's, anyone can use it.
27:09 Speaker 03 And in fact, that's part of what's so powerful about it. It becomes a new standard. We don't...
27:15 Speaker 03 Hold that back, but sometimes we do need to charge for something. So where we draw that line and how we draw that line is very, uh, it's very tricky. So something we sometimes do is I call it the Robin Hood business model. So there's this plugin called Akismet, it keeps spam off your site. It's kind of the best anti-spam, web anti-spam system on the web. A lot of people don't know, but it's actually the first code I wrote after leaving my job.
27:38 Speaker 02 Amazing.
27:38 Speaker 03 First commercial thing we created before WordPress.com was actually Akismet. And it works really well. It's free for personal use and then paid for commercial use. And it's kind of on our system, so we don't really police it that much. So it's a Robin Hood business model. We, we provide this free service that keeps spam off forty-three percent of the web, because almost every WordPress site uses it. And a very, very, very small percentage of people pay that. But that small percentage of pay make it sustainable. It makes it that we've now been able to use and develop and, you know, battle the spammers, battle the bad guys now for seventeen years.
28:12 Speaker 02 When you are thinking about, okay, how is this thing going to make money? We have lots of competitors, things, a commodity. What leaps to my mind is, oh, well, you have WooCommerce, which is this open source payment stack. When I think about what websites are in twenty twenty-two, they're most, it seems like they're mostly ecommerce sites. Like that's, that's mostly the web activity. It's like a handful of news sites and ecommerce sites. Like that's the whole web. The Wordle is like the most unusual website in the past five years, because it was, it's a web game, right? And like people went nuts, this is the old web. You see something different happening in that split? You know, like it's, it is fashionable to run around saying the web is dead and apps hate the world.
28:57 Speaker 02 But I'm like, well, the web's pretty healthy for at least two things. Right? And those two things are, are news and shopping.
29:05 Speaker 03 That I think that's your bubble. If I'm totally honest. It's it's but that's what's cool about the web is that we can live in a bubble and that can seem like the whole thing. One thing I'm explicitly trying to do in 2022 is make the web weirder.
29:18 Speaker 02 That's great. I fully support that project. Yeah.
29:21 Speaker 03 Because one of the fun things about working on both WordPress and Tumblr now, they both provide a lot of freedom. And Tumblr, you know, order magnitude more freedom than you get on other social networks that really try to make your site and your profile look like everything else. So they can sell ads more easily, etc. You can do some weird stuff on Tumblr, including like still allows JavaScript and other things. You could you could host Word on Tumblr if you wanted to. It's kind of wild and people do some really, really interesting, fascinating stuff there. It's also Gutenberg for WordPress. It's like, we're like, let's just stop writing text in a box. That's boring. How do we give you like full layout controls, full ability to create like something like, um, was it Snowfall? That, you know, your kind of story that blew everyone's mind? How do we put that?
30:04 Speaker 02 I want to say to verge to the Snowfall, Snowfall story before Snowfall, just my personal.
30:09 Speaker 03 Actually, 100%. Um, yeah, when y'all launched, you had, and you still do it with your editorial features. It's awesome. We actually have a publication called Atavist that publishes only once a month. And it's like, every story is like a visual journey, like, like the best magazines, basically. We want to make that easy for every single one of your authors to do with a few clicks. And it's part of also what kind of is cool about a system like WordPress is, uh, sometimes I describe it as permeation. Like we take the fire from the gods and bring it to the people. Um, you know, you created this fire, this cool design layouts, you probably have a proprietary CMS,
30:51 Speaker 03 but the only people have access to that, people who work for your company or that might license it out or something like that. So we say that how do we take these cool ideas and bring them to literally the whole world where regardless of? You know, in 50 languages, no matter if you have any money or what language you speak or anything, we can give you these cool tools. And it's not just news. So people are doing a ton. There's a ton of personal sites out there, a ton of personal blogging, so much arts, so many artists that are sharing. People, you know, who sold the NFT for $69 million has published on Tumblr every single day. That's where he published. That's where he got started. That's where he still posts every single day. I apologize, the name's escaping me, but like the biggest movie star in India is publishing the Tumblr every single day.
31:35 Speaker 03 He's done like 4,000 days in a row.
31:37 Speaker 02 Amazing.
31:38 Speaker 03 Like without fail. It's so, there's, there's people that are sharing and I think that's, that's to me really, really exciting because it's kind of like the personal web. It's, it's different. It's unique. And, you know, I go to a Medium article or even a Substack article and I read the article and I just remember Medium or Substack. I actually forget the author because the sites all kind of look the same. So like, how do you bring that, not just the editorial voice, but also the visual personalization? That you can really have your own home on the web. You don't just look like everything else.
32:07 Speaker 02 I buy all of that and I guess I, news is like too flat and too narrow of a description. Like it's, there's just not like a lot of the weird web, the web that you would have thought of where I made a little web tool that mashes up a map with a, another map, which is like that hard, that early web two spirit seems to have faded away into apps or features of social networks. So I'm just curious, like where do you see the growth for WordPress? Yep, some weird stuff, we hope. Maybe it is a lot of artists that are going to sell their NFTs. But I, I just think about where your money would come from. It seems like e-commerce is actually the, the place that you'd be most focused.
32:48 Speaker 03 Yeah. So we're doing a good job at democratizing publishing.
32:52 Speaker 02 Yeah.
32:53 Speaker 03 Like WordPress is on the right path there. And like I said, I think it'll get to like an 85%. I now feel so strongly about doing the same thing for commerce because I think that we need those same freedoms, freedom to publish, freedom to transact, freedom to use any payment system, freedom to, for the transaction fees to be just as low as humanly possible versus going up every year, expanding every year. Like we need an open source alternatives, not just a Shopify, but also Amazon and Etsy and everything else. Those are still great services, by the way.
33:24 Speaker 03 I give Amazon a big portion of my paycheck. I love it. And I think I actually would argue that it's making the world a better place. But we still need an open source alternative to serve as a check and balance in the free market towards these successful companies.
33:38 Speaker 02 So what does WooCommerce do for somebody? You, I don't know, you have a snowboard store that's the famous Shopify origin story. Instead of having to build Shopify, you're like, I'm just going to use WooCommerce. How does that work?
33:52 Speaker 03 So it's a plugin for WordPress. So you could go in your WordPress dashboard, search WooCommerce, one click, install it. And then you'd be taken through a workflow that'll help you set up like a merchant account, some of your first products, connected to shipping. Now Commerce is so complex. You have really taxes, shipping, inventory management. But because WordPress is open source, there's like a ton of extensions built for it. And you can kind of pick and choose and put things together to like have your own store on the web. And there's even now like you can have a point of sale. So if you had a physical store, you could have a WooCommerce little reader integrated for Stripe, et cetera. People can tap to pay and that will synchronize with your online store. So you can just pretty fun stuff.
34:33 Speaker 03 At the actual store, we just launched kind of secretly for Tumblr's 15th anniversary is shop.tumblr.com. We're putting like, kind of like Virgil Abloh inspired, like very limited drops of cool, high quality stuff. And we were able to launch that on WooCommerce in about two weeks, which shows like you can really do anything. Now, why would you choose it versus one of these other ones? Shopify is, by the way, awesome product, awesome company. Toby's an inspiring leader. I really like them a lot.
35:00 Speaker 02 We had Harley on the show a few months back and I think I ended it by being like, well, I'm going to go work at Shopify.
35:07 Speaker 02 You know, they're big personalities.
35:09 Speaker 03 I do also think that you're starting to see at the edges the complaints of their ecosystem. And that they're sort of like. Having so much of the revenue flow through them and their kind of commercial need to grow, the obligated growth obligations that they have, or embedded growth obligations are driving them to conflict with their community more and more. And the community is what really made them, I think. Basically, what we did with WordPress is what we're doing now with the e-commerce, which is WooCommerce is free, it's open source. And so at the low end, we just ruthlessly commoditize it. You know, the average person on Shopify is paying $1,200 per year. That's really expensive. It doesn't need to be that expensive. It can be one tenth, and then someday one one hundredth of that to do,
35:52 Speaker 03 have all that functionality. So WooCommerce is one tenth that today. And it's gonna get cheaper and cheaper every year. Like that's-
35:59 Speaker 02 When you say it's open source, can I, can I just take it and use it for free?
36:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
36:05 Speaker 02 But no one does that. Most, most people are paying you, what is it, $120?
36:09 Speaker 03 We try to make it easy to pay us, yeah. And, and WooCommerce is also different from WordPress in that WooCommerce is wholly owned and run by Automattic. So it's not primarily a larger community. It's really, it does have its own community, but it's, it's owned and run by Automattic, owned and operated. The other reason people leave Shopify and go to WooCommerce is at the high end. So we have this Barbara approach where we get to kind of ruthlessly commoditize the low end. And on the high end, we allow customization. So ultimately, a SaaS product will always, you always hit a ceiling with it or a wall. Or you might run into something that is different about your business model versus theirs, the SaaS provider. And open source is true freedom, you know?
36:52 Speaker 03 And especially once your store starts to make $100 million plus per year, even small things that could be a half a percent or percent on every transaction start to really add up and be millions of dollars of value. So that's why very, very high end stores switch to WooCommerce.
37:07 Speaker 02 I think my thing with WooCommerce is, that sounds great. I'm super interested in that kind of competition because I think that is kind of the best kind of competition. You're not head on.
37:20 Speaker 02 Shopify 2, you're like, this is a different model and you can make a series of business and personal and philosophical choices that lead you to our model versus theirs. But then broadly, you have some of the same challenges, right? So, Apple turns off app tracking transparency, Facebook's ad rates plummet because it's harder to target customers. I get a lot of ads for spoons lately, I don't know what's going on there, but it's like hard to find me, the one person in America who's in the market for spoons. On Facebook, the little ecommerce store that has the one hot pink spoon I'm looking for doesn't find me as cheaply, they fall apart. And then, at the end of all that, Shopify's stock price has crashed, right?
38:05 Speaker 02 You can see that Apple turning off ad tracking transparency had this like big ripple through the ecommerce stack. Did that hit you?
38:11 Speaker 03 WooCommerce stores who advertise on Facebook probably were impacted. But, one thing that people do when they or why they go to WordPress or WooCommerce is to build a direct relationship with their customers and not be entirely dependent or mediated by Google, Facebook, etc. So, they build mailing lists, they have, WordPress has the best SEO in the world and WooCommerce inherits that. So, these WooCommerce stores are findable or on organic search, not just paid search. And, because they integrate so with WordPress, they develop amazing blogs and people follow these blogs, you know? So, this is the things that I think made WooCommerce stores hopefully more resilient to these types of changes.
38:55 Speaker 03 Over time, like, we're also part of being developed primarily in an open source way is we really err on the side of like radical user privacy, radical ownership of data, like. So, we end up being on the right side of history when regulations or new things come in. Where open source gets in trouble is when the regulations are essentially written by the incumbents. So, something like a GDPR, which was written in a way that really benefited Google and Facebook and kind of penalized every other person in the marketplace. So, that's tricky when you have that sort of regulatory capture. But, you know, again, I always think about these things long term. That could happen for a few years, but if you look out five, 10, 20 years, ultimately,
39:40 Speaker 03 consumers and economics will drive these decisions.
39:44 Speaker 02 We need to take a quick break, but when we come back, we're going to talk about Tumblr.
39:56 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an ultra because it's not just a superior light beer. It's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
40:25 Speaker 05 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bullspend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
40:34 Speaker 06 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
40:42 Speaker 05 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
40:59 Speaker 02 We're back.
41:02 Speaker 02 Let's talk about Tumblr real quick. I think I have a handle on WordPress, which kind of is at this point, it's kind of like a B2B product, right? It's some individuals are using it, but the thrust of it is lots of businesses are using it. They're paying you, it sounds like whatever amount of money they want to pay you at whatever time. You've got a big commerce stack next to it that feels pretty enterprise-y.
41:29 Speaker 03 I'll tell you a stat most people don't realize.
41:31 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:31 Speaker 03 Is half of all users that we get signing up for WordPress.com every day are there to blog.
41:37 Speaker 02 That's amazing. They're still doing it.
41:39 Speaker 03 So, and to be honest, like even internally, we kind of assumed everyone was coming to us for CMS features. And I think we over indexed on that more business-y side that you just described. Also, that's because we're more, we thought more revenue was coming, but when we sliced the data differently, we actually found that half subscribers, half signups, actually more than half subscribers were. They primarily blog. So I think it's cool that people are still blogging.
42:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, I do too. We can end it here. My heart is warmed. I don't know further questions. That's great. I'm happy it's still happening. Okay, so even if you sort of like enterprise-ish is what I would call.
42:15 Speaker 03 It is more enterprise-y and one caveat I'll say to WooCommerce is it's a developer product right now. It's like a Stripe or Twilio. So it's really developer first.
42:23 Speaker 02 Okay, and well, right next to that is Tumblr. Which is like the most consumer product that has ever existed, right? Tumblr like.
42:33 Speaker 03 It's super consumer, yeah.
42:34 Speaker 02 It's, I mean, but it's also a super consumer in the sense that it's a playground for artists, for musicians. Taylor Swift is reading Tumblr and it shows up in the lyrics and there's a feedback loop between the lyrics and the Tumblr people. I mean, it's nuts, right? The things that happen on Tumblr are utterly unique to any other social platform. You bought it out of sort of the wreckage of Yahoo. When was this now?
43:02 Speaker 03 2019.
43:02 Speaker 02 2019. I asked you, what are you gonna do with it? And you're like, we've got some great ideas. But the first thing you had to do was like ban all the porn so you could get the app in the app stores.
43:14 Speaker 03 That happened before we bought it. That was actually under Verizon.
43:18 Speaker 02 That was under Verizon, but you, that was like a, it was gonna happen no matter what. If they hadn't done it, you were gonna have to do it.
43:23 Speaker 03 Um, I think Verizon is super conservative.
43:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
43:26 Speaker 03 So if you look at apps like Twitter and Reddit, they actually do have an astounding amount of adult content.
43:36 Speaker 03 And, but they, they do it in a way that is compatible with Apple's rules. So I think Verizon took an extremely conservative approach to try to get rid of even borderline things, things that I would call art from the app. And they did it in a way which I think penalized a lot of legitimate users. One user that contacted me after the acquisition said, I posted a picture of my manicure, you know, a picture of their hands. And some algorithm thought it was too much skin tone, their account got banned. And then because the support was so backlog, no one responded to them for months. So like, what's a good way to kill a social network? Ban your most active users and don't reply to them for months. But you know what?
44:20 Speaker 03 People will go someplace else and find someplace else to publish.
44:23 Speaker 02 All right, I'm just looking. Okay, but I'm just looking at our conversation from back then. You're correct. Verizon had done it, but your position back then was Verizon might have been more conservative. But you said to us, if you want big policy changes here, put pressure on the app stores. No one has a leverage.
44:42 Speaker 03 Yes.
44:44 Speaker 02 And so that's still true. So this
44:46 Speaker 03 Tumblr was in the news in December. We were scrambling right before Christmas because Apple came to us. You probably saw where we had to ban these like random tags. You know, the app store review process can be very inconsistent. And sometimes something you've done for years and years, they'll come to you and say, that's not allowed anymore. Or we searched for this, you know, search term. And now your app's banned unless you make these drastic changes very quickly right before Christmas. So it's, it's very tricky.
45:15 Speaker 02 Is so that hasn't calmed down. That was really the heart of my question is that you bought it in a moment of crazy back and forth with app stores. Tumblr's had a bit of a renaissance, right? In the pandemic, people are using it again. There's been glowing write ups of it here and there. But it's still like in this weird spot where it's because it's so consumer. It's so arty, it's so wild, which is this whole brand. It runs into app store moderation policies, maybe more than any other product that I can think of like that, that is like it.
45:49 Speaker 03 I think we talk about it more than other products, which is maybe why we get into trouble more.
45:55 Speaker 03 Maybe it's retaliatory. But yeah, I, if you, you know, have drinks with anyone who works on this process at pretty much any large app based business, including Twitter, et cetera, they'll tell you the same thing. Apps can get blocked at just things you never even thought of can be blocked randomly one day and your team scrambling to to address it.
46:19 Speaker 02 There's been a lot of noise, right? There's been hearings, there's David Hanson ranting and raving on our shows. You know, there's been a lot of scrutiny of Apple. There are potentially some bills in Congress now. Have is there posture changed at Apple and Google about this stuff? Or is it still the same as it ever was?
46:40 Speaker 03 Hmm. Well, you don't hear about this stuff with Google very much. So I will say that Play Store is a lot more consistent in their application of things. Honestly, Apple has a tough job here. So it's not dissimilar to trying to moderate user journey to content. It's that they're moderating hundreds of thousands of apps. And the team that does that, I have no idea how big it is, but let's call it at least 1000 people, would be my guess. I literally have no information. That's just a guess. Yeah. So you're going to get some, you're going to get new people, you're going to get mistakes. That's just part of it. And I do appreciate that, you know, we've been able to resolve everything so far. So all of our apps are still in the App Store. You know, sometimes, you know, we disagree,
47:21 Speaker 03 but we're usually able to talk our way into following what we think are the rules and and seems reasonable. But sometimes it delays features weeks or months, to be honest, which really slows particularly, it slowed Tumble down particularly the last three or four months. Because we're trying to launch a lot of user features like tipping and post plus, which is subscriptions. And we're trying to get some of this stuff in there. And we're, you know, we're trying to follow what we think the rules are. Like if the tips go 100% to the users, it doesn't need to, you don't need to charge App Store fee, right? Which is many other apps.
48:01 Speaker 02 I actually did not know that. That this is true. So if you don't take a cut, Apple won't take a cut?
48:07 Speaker 03 That's the idea. But. Yeah, that feature has been stuck a little bit. So we're trying to reconcile the UI for that and how it's presented and everything. So that's one of the, it's just a reality. You know, you live by the App Store, you die by the App Store.
48:24 Speaker 02 I mean, this is like my other big question, right? Is back in that interview from a few years ago, you were like, look, I know people say just make it a web app and screw Apple, but apps are it. And then the first half of this conversation, we're talking about the glory of the open web and making the open web weird again. And making these open source competitors to these proprietary solution vendors. Do you, I mean, are you of two minds? Do you like walk around your house, just like arguing with yourself that you run an app based business at the mercy of Apple? And you also run a completely open source publishing business over there?
49:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm a pragmatist. I'm a pragmatic person. So everything we build is going towards this future of an open web. But also you have to work with the reality of how things are today. And guess what? You know, like there's going to be like every human in the world over the next 20 years is going to have something like smartphones. And those smartphones will have something like app stores and you need to work within that world. I do believe over that timeframe, we're going to have open alternatives and we need to figure out how to make security and everything else work while we do that. So we've done it on the web pretty well. I think we can do it for native apps because we've done it for native apps pretty well and things like macOS and Windows. So I think it's possible.
49:45 Speaker 03 My hope is that the Googles and the Apples of the world as like two of the most valuable companies in the world with cash reserves larger than most countries. Like we'll stop acting like underdogs and start acting like stewards with responsibility to their communities and humanity that they are and behaving more open. So we'll always push for that. We'll always advocate for that. And I'm not personally someone who tries to affect change through legislation or lobbying. I prefer to do it in the market.
50:16 Speaker 02 This was going to be my question. You're on the air here a week or so after we had the CEO of Sonos. They've obviously gone to Congress. You're not trying to do that stuff.
50:25 Speaker 03 Just not my personal specialty.
50:27 Speaker 02 But you're not going to hire some lobbying firm for the open web? I think it would be great if somebody would hire a lobbying firm for the open web. So you know, just an idea.
50:36 Speaker 03 We do our best to represent these issues for the open web. So we do try to be present because WordPress is kind of like the dark matter of the web. And you know, if you looked at the top 10 websites in the world, you're not going to see the 10s and hundreds of millions of WordPress sites aggregated into one name. So people forget it exists. But if you add all those up, it might be the largest thing out there. Actually, that's why I call it the dark matter of the web. So we do our best to advocate for that, but we're also imperfect in that. Like we, we don't automatic and myself do not represent the interest of every single independent website and developer out there. So I do my best to just, you know, say what would make the things more open and advocate for that.
51:17 Speaker 03 But you know, I'm not trying to influence competitors or other companies we work with through legislation. That just feels, just not a thing.
51:26 Speaker 02 Let's stay on Tumblr for a minute. Tumblr is a social network. It is obviously very consumer. It is very horny. Just be honest about it.
51:36 Speaker 03 This might be, again, your, your personal lens.
51:38 Speaker 02 I don't even use it. I just hear what people tell me, man. You have moderators, right? How do you moderate the content on Tumblr?
51:45 Speaker 03 Can tell you some. So one, the name of the person I was trying to think of earlier on Tumblr. And I apologize because I'm going to mess up saying this name. Maybe you can help me. Amitabh Bachchan?
51:58 Speaker 02 Oh yeah, Amitabh Bachchan. He's like the most famous guy. He's the Indian actor. He's the, he's the angry young man. Yeah. Now he's a very.
52:07 Speaker 03 He posts, so look at this. He just posted today at 11:42 AM, day 5130 of his daily updates. It's, uh, it's awesome. He's like a daily active user of Tumblr.
52:20 Speaker 02 This is going to turn, this is going to turn my mom into a daily active user of Tumblr.
52:25 Speaker 03 Same thing. One of my best friends, you know, Om Malik, he was like, uh, at first he was a WordPress, but my best friend forever. He was like, Matt, this guy is on Tumblr. You gotta make a big deal of this.
52:36 Speaker 02 He's a big deal. He, I was just, I'm sure half of the listeners here are losing their minds. He's like a huge deal.
52:43 Speaker 02 Okay, so how are you moderating Amitabh Bachchan?
52:46 Speaker 03 You don't.
52:47 Speaker 02 You just let him ride.
52:48 Speaker 03 He moderates you.
52:52 Speaker 03 The other thing that astounded me about Tumblr, so one that had some users like, like this guy who are literally using it every day, like Taylor Swift said, like, all the other social networks are managed by a team, but they're actually using this themselves.
53:05 Speaker 02 Okay.
53:05 Speaker 03 Because Tumblr provides something that's different from you're gonna get on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram. Number two, 60% of Tumblr users are Gen Z, they're 13 to 24. I had assumed its user base was, you know, kind of people who were nostalgic, who like, used it in the early, early 2000s, early 2010s, were still using it. Some of them were being born then. And then two, we have users younger than Tumblr.
53:32 Speaker 02 That's wild.
53:33 Speaker 03 And then the other thing that blew me away is it's 85% of the usage comes through the app, and it's still getting tens of thousands of signups every day. Prime about half, Gen Z, so Tumblr is young, it's weird, it's primarily used on, produced on mobile. But we also have this power user kind of segment on web, so web's still pretty important for us. But, so to moderate that,
53:59 Speaker 03 I think moderating large social networks is honestly really hard. So you'll, you'll never hear me piling on to Facebook or other people, like, when they make mistakes moderating, because it's just, it's hard. You have tens or hundreds of millions of people, in Facebook's case, billions. So everything that happens for humanity happens on your network, and you have to try to make that not go wrong. So, one of the teams we've expanded the most since acquiring Tumblr is support, interest and safety. I think when we acquired it, Tumblr had a backlog of 80,000 support tickets.
54:35 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
54:35 Speaker 03 We got that to zero just a few weeks ago. So, this is an area that Automattic has a lot of experience with, our other products are generally well regarded for their not destroying democracy and being like healthy places on the web. And, and honestly, the past two years, we've been doing a lot of catch up there with Tumblr, and the problem was bigger than I imagined. You know, it used to be every post we did on Tumblr, people would say, oh, you launched this new feature, why, why haven't you gotten rid of the porn parts and Nazis? And, and so we had to do that. There were there were porn brots and bad people publishing on Tumblr and we've done our best
55:17 Speaker 03 and are still today doing our best to keep it a healthy, positive place on the web. And if I have to say what I would love for Tumblr to be is besides just an alternative, uh, another place you can go that's different from the other social networks, it's a place for art and artists.
55:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
55:32 Speaker 03 And art is, I think, necessary for society, feeds the soul. It's naturally transgressive, art pushes boundaries. And so we need to evolve what Tumblr, how Tumblr moderation and everything works to encompass that. It needs to be the best place on the web for art and artists and a place where they can have a direct relationship to their audience. And people can follow things, not be, you know, have an option from like the algorithm that's trying to enrage you to like, see things you want to see and get inspired and produce cool things like that's what Tumblr is going to be. It's what it is today for millions of people and we just need to make it much better for that. So this is kind of me saying that Tumblr's moderation policies are going to evolve in a very significant way that I can't announce entirely yet, but it's going to get a lot.
56:17 Speaker 02 Come on, you were so close. Is it because I called it horny? Is that what made you change your mind?
56:22 Speaker 03 Well, at the same time, it can't be a place for porn. That's not what our company can do. It's not what, it doesn't work. You know, if that needs to be, you know, companies like MindGeek or Pornhub and other things are specifically set up for that. A mainstream company in 2022 with the rules around payment processing, verifying identities, everything. Like adult content is rightly having a lot of regulation around it. And, um, and probably dedicated companies should service that. So that's not, I can't say we're bringing that back. I apologize. I know people want to say that.
56:59 Speaker 02 So the only question on the list, actually, I've been a long build up to, are you going to bring the porn back?
57:04 Speaker 03 But art and artists are really, really strong on Tumblr. And I want to make it a really great place for art and artists to thrive and create art and artists. And so I think that looks a bit more open than what Tumblr allows today. But it's not the stuff that you would see on a porn site.
57:22 Speaker 02 So let's get tactical on that for a minute. Are you going to have a definition of, it sounds like you're going to change the content rules for Tumblr. Is that correct? You're just not going to announce what they are?
57:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, so if you look at other products like WordPress.com, we have policies there that allow a lot more than what's currently allowed on Tumblr. And so that's what we're going to try to normalize because those policies have evolved and iterated and worked really well to allow, you know, a statue of David or the portrait of Venus, you know, right now that could get taken down or an old Tumblr could have gotten taken down. That's obviously art.
58:01 Speaker 02 Is that compatible with Apple?
58:04 Speaker 03 Yes, it's 100% compatible with Apple. And I think we can do this in a way that also puts a lot more control in the hands of the community to self moderate and self tag with their publishing in a way that gets the content to people who want to see it, but also protects it from people who shouldn't be seeing it, you know, people who are under 18, you know, things like that. Like we all agree that the app and services should not allow that. But how we implement that, I think, can be a lot more community driven than right now, which is like, again, trying to have algorithms that look at things, which is never going to work because honestly, as a judge at the Supreme Court famously said, like on the
58:48 Speaker 03 definition of pornography, I know it when I see it.
58:51 Speaker 02 He regretted that, by the way. I just want to point that out. That judge regretted saying that and he thought it was a mistake. It's a real, a real bugaboo for me.
59:02 Speaker 03 It is true that writing a strict definition is tricky. I think even like when you talk to Apple moderators, they'll point you to like the Webster's definition of it or something.
59:11 Speaker 02 Yes.
59:12 Speaker 03 And some of it is in the eye of the beholder. So, but there are certain objective definitions that you could say on a piece of content that we could allow better tagging of and then, you know, allow filtering of those tags.
59:29 Speaker 02 So that just like tactically, though, how many moderators do you have working at Tumblr?
59:33 Speaker 03 So there's external moderators as well right now at Tumblr. So the actual number is, I believe, above 400.
59:40 Speaker 02 Okay. And that's the whole site?
59:42 Speaker 03 Now, what's interesting is we actually have a lot less of that on our other services that I think are more effective. So part of what I think is necessary to create a really effective moderation scheme is building really, really good tools for the moderators to moderate lots of content quickly and do so in context. Both of those are really, really important for, I think, accurate, fast moderation. A single person working an eight-hour day could actually get through thousands or tens of thousands of things if they have the right tools. And so I would actually like to decrease our use of external moderation contractors
1:00:23 Speaker 03 and go really to internal teams with really good tools to be leveraged here, including using things like machine learning, AI, but not using it for decisions, using it to augment the humans. So the central approach that you've probably heard of, like AI on its own can be bad, humans on its own isn't as good at AI as something, but when you combine them, you can actually get like superhuman results and better than either on their own.
1:00:49 Speaker 02 One thing we've heard about a lot is, okay, the people who work in these moderation facilities, they basically have bad jobs. They leave with PTSD, with other problems. Are you thinking about that? Is that something that's on your mind that you have to solve? Would these tools potentially solve it?
1:01:02 Speaker 03 I honestly think about that all the time. And in fact, one of the first things I did when coming in to Tumblr team was do support and do trust and safety and, you know, right along with folks dealing with that content. I think folks working on this are the unsung heroes of the web as well, because they are, not unlike the police force or, you know, the veterans that are doing something really tough and hard to protect the rest of us and allow the rest of us to. Essentially live in a free society. But they're the online equivalents of that. And so that's part of the reason we try to have that team part of the rest of Automattic. And I do think it is a challenging job. So I have a ton of empathy for it.
1:01:45 Speaker 03 And that's why I try to do it myself sometimes, too. To both keep that industry strong and also see where we can use software to make it more effective.
1:01:54 Speaker 02 I think that's great. I think more executives at social companies should spend time doing the moderating function. Because ultimately, Tumblr is great and the celebrities are using it and the kids are using it. Ultimately, you are in the content moderation business. Like, that's the heart of the business. If you, for Tumblr, for Facebook, for Twitter, whatever, is moderating and ranking content in some way. Or like, yeah, I'm that surprised you're doing it, but I'm glad you're doing it.
1:02:23 Speaker 03 Y'all do it, too. Like, your comment section, you have a responsibility to keep that, to moderate that and keep it a good place you want to be on the web.
1:02:31 Speaker 02 We do. Do you know, do you know that our Coral forks? Like, you know, we have permanent moderators that work with us at The Verge. They're great. Eric, shut up. But we, our company, bought a thing called Coral that is, if you just like, look at how the software is expressed, it is a better tool for moderating comments. It has some user features, right? Like, it's meant for that. But the thesis of Coral is that the moderation screen is much easier to use.
1:02:59 Speaker 03 Ah, I'll have to check that out. I will paint a picture. Imagine if Verge was built on WordPress and Coral was an open source plugin, then everyone in the world could get these cool features and the whole web would have better conversations.
1:03:14 Speaker 02 The Coral project guys are... They're gonna be all over me when this gets published. That'd be great.
1:03:20 Speaker 03 I would love you to try Tumblr again. And send me your feedback. Whatever you want to follow is cool. Let me know bugs you find.
1:03:29 Speaker 02 I will put it on my phone. I will put it back on my phone today.
1:03:32 Speaker 03 Thank you.
1:03:33 Speaker 02 It's been a few years. You know, my blog was a Tumblr blog for a long time.
1:03:36 Speaker 03 It'd be cool to spin that back up, you know? Maybe it's a place to aggregate your articles or your podcasts or like, just be weird. Be weird again on the internet. It's fun.
1:03:46 Speaker 02 I, hey, that's my, that's my go-to. All right, I'll see if I can open up my old Tumblr blog.
1:03:52 Speaker 03 And if you if you post some cool stuff there and send it to me, I'll boost it as well. So we'll get it some cool.
1:03:57 Speaker 02 That's a quid pro quo now. So I'll see. I gotta gotta check the ethics layers. Uh, no, I'll definitely check it out again. I've heard, right? We look, I have Gen Z nieces and nephews are all over it.
1:04:08 Speaker 03 Oh, really? Ah.
1:04:10 Speaker 02 All their musicians, all their friends.
1:04:11 Speaker 03 That's cool to hear.
1:04:12 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:04:13 Speaker 03 You know, if we can create a third place on the internet and doesn't have an advertising model, you you might have seen, we just launched an ads free upgrade for Tumblr.
1:04:19 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:04:20 Speaker 03 Twitter and Facebook could never do that because they their business models don't allow them to. But because Tumblr luckily is not making very much money right now, we can do that and make it the model. And I think that's pretty cool. We have, I think, a really decent chance to bootstrap a non-surveillance capitalism based social network.
1:04:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:04:40 Speaker 03 Which I think is impossible for the incumbents right now. They just have the golden handcuffs.
1:04:44 Speaker 02 We need to take one more break, but I could not let this interview end without asking Matt about Web 3.
1:04:59 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an ultra. Because it's not just a superior like beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
1:05:26 Speaker 05 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
1:05:36 Speaker 06 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
1:05:43 Speaker 05 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06:01 Speaker 02 We're back with Matt Mollomick.
1:06:04 Speaker 02 We've only a few minutes left. I wanted to ask about podcasts, but I'm running out of time. So I want to ask about something else.
1:06:11 Speaker 02 You, you've been around, you, you know, you, you and the web grown up together. You wrote WordPress, you're in it. We are in the midst of what some people call a shift to web three.
1:06:25 Speaker 02 I feel like you might have many thoughts about the idea that there's another version of the web coming along.
1:06:32 Speaker 02 Are you in it? Do you own any blockchain securities? Are you, you have to laser eyes? What's the situation?
1:06:39 Speaker 03 Ah, I'm always playing with new technology because that's just what I do for fun. So I've tried pretty much everything, including like every CMS we've mentioned, every, everything. I think every 10 years or so, people try to brand a new version of the web. It's mostly marketing. It's mostly like fundraising and, and, but there's, there's always some truth to it. Otherwise it wouldn't, it wouldn't be something we talk about. It's also just fun to talk about and debate like, oh, what is web three? This isn't web three. This is web two. I had a thread where I was like, everything you're saying was web two actually wasn't web two. It was like what came after web two. Web two was actually totally open and you had Technorati and Flickr and, and Delicious. And it was all interoperable and tag, tagging and like open content.
1:07:22 Speaker 03 And then like these other things replaced it, like closed social networks and.
1:07:26 Speaker 02 Web two was the API era. That's what I meant. You'd have a map and you're going API from a thing. And then you like mash the two maps together.
1:07:32 Speaker 03 Yeah. And so what's cool to me is the thing we're calling web three is actually exactly what we call web two.
1:07:38 Speaker 03 And, but it's using some new technologies and I think that's cool. And you know what? Blockchain is not right for everything, but it's right for some things.
1:07:45 Speaker 02 And if he's not right for everything. Other than currency speculation.
1:07:50 Speaker 03 And immutable, it, well, it solves the, uh, what you call the something general's problem. It's a beautiful, immutable global record that is like, might be the first, might be the most secure software that humanity has ever created.
1:08:07 Speaker 02 Okay. I mean, it, this space is rife with scams. So like I, I buy you in theory, but in practice.
1:08:14 Speaker 03 I'm talking about Bitcoin and Ethereum here. Like that, the, like what I think of as like the top end blockchains. Like we've never created software this secure for this long.
1:08:26 Speaker 03 Right, like Microsoft, Apple, billions and billions of dollars put into the operating systems regularly have zero days and root exploits. There is a huge bounty if you're able to hack Bitcoin and yet it's it's still trucking along. I'm kind of astounded at that. That's incredible. Bitcoin is also open source. So another thing, everything I've been saying about open source, so is Ethereum. These are open source projects. So it's it's an example of open source being applied to new area, error, which is like finance essentially, and completely transforming it in a way that one is doing something humanity's never been able to do before. And two is, yeah, changing the course of things. It's influencing not
1:09:08 Speaker 03 just itself, but everything else in the market, which I think is pretty cool. Now, am I, you know, do I have laser eyes? No. There's so much to fix with this technology. But I do believe that, you know, the problems that people bring up, like resource utilization or whatever it is, yes, those are problems, but we're going to fix them. And when I say we, I mean, like broadly technologists, engineers working tirelessly to release new versions of these things every day, every week, every month, every year.
1:09:37 Speaker 02 Do you own any Bitcoin? Do you own any NFTs?
1:09:40 Speaker 03 I have a little bit of everything. Actually, wordpress.com was the first major internet service to accept Bitcoin. In 2012, we're on the cover of Bitcoin magazine and the article was written by Vitalik, but at the time was the editor and a writer.
1:09:58 Speaker 02 Vitalik is the inventor of Ethereum, in case people don't know. That's crazy.
1:10:03 Speaker 03 So we've been following this forever. And, you know, technologies go through adoption cycles. They go through peaks and troughs. They go through winters where everyone thinks it's the dumbest thing in the world. And that's actually where a lot of the innovation comes from. I think they go through hype periods and definitely a lot of what's going on, particularly NFTs to me right now, feels a little bit like ICOs in 2017 or something like that. Like there's, you said it, there are a lot of people who are in it for the wrong reasons, who are scamming folks. There's a lot of issues to work out. But fundamentally, things that give people more freedom, more control, and enable new, new features for humanity, I would bet on in the long term.
1:10:46 Speaker 02 But I would just make this split and I'll ask it one more time, but maybe with this proviso. I'm asking about Web 3, not Bitcoin, not Ethereum, the currency, but Web 3, which is, I would hazily define it, and I'm sure I'm going to get this wrong because it's up for grabs, right? But I'd hazily define it as the version of the web where everything you do is a tradable commodity and people are getting paid for all kinds of things vastly more often than now.
1:11:20 Speaker 02 Right? Like, that's kind of what you're, what everyone's getting at is you're a musician, you release a song, it's an NFT, people can sell it. When they sell it again, you get a cut and like, we show up on my website and I don't know, my website has a token and you buy the token. Like that piece of it, where you directly connect the technology to the cultural aspect of the web, is what I would call Web 3. If such a definition is even possible to exist.
1:11:47 Speaker 03 So let's just take that definition to true and I'll respond to that definition.
1:11:52 Speaker 02 Okay. So I just to the listeners who are freaking out in their cars, like, yeah, I just made that one up, but it's what I got, right?
1:11:59 Speaker 03 Well, that's part of what makes these things difficult to discuss is people will argue about the definition for hours and hours. But let's just take the two things you said. What was the first part? So everything is a tradable commodity?
1:12:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, everything becomes for sale.
1:12:12 Speaker 03 That's obviously not going to happen. One, I don't think we would want that. But two, like, there's lots of reasons for things not to be tradable commodities. So I would say that maybe we'll have, like, NFTs will exist, of course, but like, will everything go that way? Of course not. Two, creators getting paid, I don't think is dependent on blockchain technology. That's a separate trend that's happening that I think is just part of the disintermediation of distributors. You know, essentially what the social networks did was they allowed people to go more direct than before. And that's also what the open web's been doing for 20, 30 years now. And so, yeah, the power is in the hand of creators.
1:12:53 Speaker 03 I love that, you know, salaries are going up for writers and editors and all these sorts of things. Like, this is value going to where I think was being created. But you know what? That's happening on, you know, WooCommerce and Substack and other things just as much as it's happening on any of these. Quote-unquote web three platforms. So I think you have to really break out these trends, decide what's orthogonal and what's absolutely going to happen, which I think creators capturing more of the value that they create is 100% going to happen and what's absolutely not going to happen, like everything becoming a tradable commodity.
1:13:31 Speaker 02 The financialization of the web is like underway, I would say, and maybe it will stop and maybe it will reverse, but right now, right, all the energy is to financialize a bunch of things.
1:13:43 Speaker 03 Just as a, as a counter to that, I will add that one of the most amazing things about the technological revolution was allowing for economics of abundance, not scarcity.
1:13:54 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:13:55 Speaker 03 Things get more valuable, the more copies there are. That's where we're talking about the positive flywheel of open source earlier. As WordPress gets more valuable, the more free copies there are. So now we're getting more things to introduce scarcity and the value of scarcity into the web, perhaps even programmatically with stuff like NFTs. But that doesn't mean that I think the fundamental difference from what's come from tens of thousands of humanity and civilizational advance before is this idea that in the world of bits instead of atoms, you and I don't have a zero sum way of prospering and we can both benefit from the same thing. We can perfectly copy that, that software. And that actually enables entirely new business
1:14:38 Speaker 03 models that are pretty exciting. Or maybe that it's not a business at all, which is okay. Everything doesn't have to be for profit.
1:14:47 Speaker 02 I mean, if I, if we have one message to send, I think that that's the one we should end with. You've given me some extra time here. I really appreciate it. Thank you so much for coming on Decoder.
1:14:57 Speaker 03 Appreciate it. See you in a few years and hopefully we can grab a drink before then.
1:15:01 Speaker 02 Please, I'm dying to.
1:15:05 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Matt Mullenweg for taking the time to talk today. Thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of Decoder. You can email us at [email protected] or hit me up directly. I'm at Reckless on Twitter. If you like the show, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like it, hit us with that five-star review. Here's a secret. If you tweet the show, I will almost certainly retweet you. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Box Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott. Research was done by Liz Leon. It was edited by Callie Wright. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our senior audio director is Andrew Marino. Our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
1:15:57 Speaker 07 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
1:16:28 Speaker 04 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better. That's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous The future of computers is only $4 away, with Raspberry Pi CEO Eben Upton Next How the EU is fighting tech giants with Margrethe Vestager Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated