Pod Insights Decoder How the FBI built its own smartphone company to hack the criminal underworld About this episode Today, I’m talking with Joseph Cox, one of the best cybersecurity reporters around and a co-founder of the new media site 404 Media. Joseph has a new book coming out in June called Dark Wire: The Incredible True Story of the Largest Sting Operation Ever, and I can’t recommend it enough. It’s basically a caper, but with the FBI running a phone network. For real.
Joseph walks us through the fascinating world of underground criminal phone networks, and how secure messaging, a tech product beloved by drug traffickers, evolved from the days of BlackBerry Messenger to Signal. Along the way, the FBI got involved with its very own startup, ANOM, as part of one of the most effective trojan horse operations in the history of cybersecurity. Joseph’s book is a great read, but it also touches on a lot of things we talk about a lot here on Decoder. So this conversation was a fun one.
Links:
Dark Wire by Joseph Cox | Hachette Book Group
How Vice became ‘a fucking clown show’ | The Verge
Cyber Official Speaks Out, Reveals Mobile Network Attacks in US | 404 Media
Revealed: The Country that Secretly Wiretapped the World for the FBI | 404 Media
How Secure Phones for Criminals Are Sold on Instagram | Motherboard
A Peek Inside the Phone Company Secretly Used in an FBI Honeypot | Motherboard
The FBI secretly launched an encrypted messaging system for criminals | The Verge
Canadian police have had master key to BlackBerry's encryption since 2010 | The Verge
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. AMX Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:51 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking with Joseph Cox, who is one of the best cybersecurity reporters around. He spent a long time working at Vice's tech vertical motherboard, but last year, after Vice imploded, he and three other journalists co-founded a new site called 404 Media, where they are doing some really great work. Somehow, on top of that, Joseph also found the time to write a new book, which is coming out in June. It's called Dark Wire: The Incredible True Story of the Largest Sting Operation Ever. I can't recommend it enough. It's basically a caper, but it involves the FBI running a phone network. For real, that's the story. See, criminals like drug traffickers represent a market for encrypted, secure communications away from the eyes of law enforcement.
1:36 Speaker 01 In the early era of mobile, that gave rise to a small industry of specialized, secure phones, mostly BlackBerrys, that criminals used to conduct their business. Joseph's done a lot of reporting on this over the years, and the book ends up telling a really extraordinary story. After breaking into a few of these encrypted smartphone companies, the FBI ended up running one itself so it could spy on criminals around the world. And that means the FBI had to run a startup phone company with all of the problems of any other tech startup: cloud service management, manufacturing and shipping issues, customer service, expansion, scale. The company was called Anam, and for about three years, it gave law enforcement agencies around the world a crystal-clear window into the criminal underworld. But it ended because it was too successful.
2:18 Speaker 01 It all ended with a massive worldwide raid on criminal organizations. Again, this story is wild. Now, in the modern era with the rise of apps like Signal, most criminals no longer need specialized hardware with dedicated services. But that raises a whole new set of issues. There really are bad people out there using tech to help them do bad things. But the same tools that keep their communications private help give everyone else their privacy too. Whistleblowers, dissenters, people like you and me. There's a deep tension between privacy and security that constantly runs through the tech industry. And you'll hear Joseph and I really dig into the way tech companies and governments are forever going back and forth on it. There's a lot going on in this one. Also, the FBI runs a fund company. Okay, Joseph Cox, here we go.
3:12 Speaker 01 Joseph Cox, you are the co-founder and a reporter at 404 Media, an incredibly great new tech website. And you are also the author of a book called Dark Wire. Welcome to Decoder.
3:21 Speaker 02 Thank you so much for having me.
3:24 Speaker 01 I want to ask two questions about 404. And then I want to talk about Dark Wire, which is an incredible caper of a book. I highly recommend it. It's a, it's just got, it's like a beach read about encrypted smartphones. I don't know how else to describe it. It's great. It's a, it's a great read. I want to talk about it very quickly. I want to talk about 404, which is a new tech website that you co-founded with a bunch of people. Tell me about that and just how it's going really quickly.
3:45 Speaker 02 Sure. So as some listeners may know, there's a company called Vice, or there was before it went bankrupt because of a series of poor executive decisions. And me and my co-founders, Sam Cole, Jason Kebler, Emmanuel Mayberg, we decided to leave and make our own primarily subscriber-driven technology investigations website. We just wanted to make a sustainable vehicle for our journalism because we just want to keep exposing stuff. We want to keep writing stories. But with all of these layoffs in the media industry, that is getting harder and harder and harder. So why not just control sort of the website ourselves, the business ourselves, like other people have done, like Defector or Case Newton, a platformer.
4:28 Speaker 02 Inspired by those people, we decided to take the plunge ourselves. It's going really, really well.
4:32 Speaker 01 What's the most important thing you've learned running your own media business so far?
4:36 Speaker 02 The journalism has to come first, and that's always the case. But if you actually put the journalism first, people respect that and they will come and they will pay for your work. Like, we just did a piece about the exploitation of SS7 and how phones are being tracked in the US. Very complicated story, took me a long time. But people want to pay for that and people want to subscribe and they want to support that work. So center the journalism and stuff will follow. That's just not what some media companies are doing. They're not putting the journalism front and center.
5:06 Speaker 01 Are you going to start generating AI previews for Google Search soon, or should we look forward to that next year?
5:10 Speaker 02 I encountered that for the first time and it's made me allergic to Google and I I literally may not use that search engine anymore. It is that abhorrent. I hate it.
5:20 Speaker 01 All right. We'll have you back to talk about 404, maybe with some of your co-founders, because I'm very interested in how the business is going. Obviously, as you know, and I'm rooting for you guys. I think the work is great. But we're here to talk about your book, which is also great. I have no idea how you started a small media company and wrote a true crime book at the same time. You must be very sleepy, but the book is Dark Wire, the incredible true story of the largest sting operation ever. There's a lot of reporting that went into it on both sides, on sort of FBI side, on the criminal side. Let's just start at the beginning and lay out the timeline. It feels like the the book begins with smartphones in the 2000s. Criminals are like, smartphones are great, but the government can read what's on them. What happens there?
6:02 Speaker 02 It starts mostly with BlackBerry, like criminals started using BBM, BlackBerry Messenger, because it was seen as being more secure. And for a while it was, it was better than ordinary text messages. But, you know, the authorities started looking at that, including the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. They did these very large operations where they managed to read a ton of BBM messages. So some sort of like geeks or drug traffickers, a combination of those, they start making customized BlackBerrys where they've taken the microphone out, the GPS out, the camera as well. And it basically radically changes the BlackBerry into a really secure encrypted device. They add encrypted email on to there as well. That's not the end of it, though. Of course, cops start to catch up.
6:45 Speaker 02 With that, so then the criminals have to make more advancements as well. And what you basically have is what I see as like a shadow tech industry where we're all usually obsessed with, you know, the new Apple announcement, the new Google announcement, whatever it is. And then you have these top tier drug traffickers who are excited for the voice scrambling feature on their new encrypted smartphone. And there really is brand loyalty in the same way a lot of us are loyal to Apple or Google or whoever, or loyal to an encrypted messaging app. There really is this massive industry that really drives forward not only what criminals are able to do logistically, as in plan, multi-ton cocaine shipments, basically very easily.
7:29 Speaker 02 But it also radically changes the conversation around privacy and encryption and law enforcement as well.
7:35 Speaker 01 So there's a market for these products. And like you said, there's brand loyalty. The first companies that start are really doing the most basic thing you can do, which is they're running their own BlackBerry messaging server, which allows them to control the encryption keys. These companies quickly run afoul of the law because they're providing services to criminals. They get arrested. Other competitors arise. The big one that is introduced early on in the book is a company called Phantom Secure. How did Phantom Secure avoid the problems that sort of first wave of companies ran into?
8:05 Speaker 02 So what they did was rather than just customizing the BlackBerry or adding their own BlackBerry server, they added the encrypted email feature, which was very sluggish, obviously, at the time. They allowed these drug traffickers, including the Sinaloa cartel that used Phantom, to communicate securely. But they also did something interesting, which was that they used a network of resellers who know the criminals. There's a finite customer base, I would say, of drug traffickers who are going to buy these phones. And these sellers know who those people are, and there's an element of trust there. It's not like you just walk into a shop and buy one of these phones, at least not ordinarily. You have to know one of these resellers, you have to trust them.
8:46 Speaker 02 And of course, if they mess you over and sell you a bad phone, for drug traffickers, this gives somebody a target to go complain about. It's not really the same with Apple. Like if a drug trafficker, they're gonna go moan at Tim Cook or send an angry email to Microsoft or whatever. There's somebody here who can be held accountable. And that's a benefit and a curse for sort of these companies because those people ended up being targeted by the FBI as a way to get into these companies as well.
9:14 Speaker 01 You have almost like a franchise model. You've got your local franchise owner and that person is the face of local customer support for the drug dealer, but also the place where law enforcement can apply pressure. How long did that last? Because eventually, you know, it does fall apart. But it seemed like that was the dominant method for quite a while. And Phantom Secure was really, I mean, the book opens with a long story at which Phantom Secure is, you know, the heart of the whole story.
9:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I think these hardened encrypted phones, that's sort of what the FBI calls them, have been around basically for a decade before that was the BlackBerry stuff. And then you have these customized phones. Now you have complicated stuff that I'm sure we'll get into with criminals actually turning to Signal and more consumer apps. But that was the sort of timeframe that you had of these companies. And that's basically how long it took for the FBI and other law enforcement agencies to get a handle on it. And 10 years is like ancient history when it comes to the FBI or law enforcement or surveillance techniques, right? So for a while criminals were using these phones, not openly, but they basically didn't have to worry about it. They didn't have to think about it.
10:22 Speaker 02 They bought one of these phones for hundreds or thousands of dollars for a six month subscription and then they could go do a cocaine deal. Like it really was that simple.
10:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, you've got a story in the beginning where the sort of consumer messaging platform is the criminals use code words. And then they say, okay, let's switch to the secure phones. And they're like, okay, 50 kilos of cocaine, just straight out, no hedging. And this product works for major drug traffickers. What led to the downfall of this first wave, which I think Phantom Secure is kind of the major symbol of the first wave? What led to the downfall?
10:56 Speaker 02 The FBI start to target Phantom Secure by, well, a couple of different ways. But what they end up doing is flipping a distributor who sells these phones. And they are told, you need to get close to the CEO of Phantom Secure, which is a man called Vincent Ramos. That happens. Ramos makes some very incriminating statements to the FBI in an undercover operation and they arrest him and they say, You need to put a backdoor into Phantom Secure and let us read all of the messages of the 10,000 users or whatever of Phantom, or we're going to arrest you. For various reasons, the FBI don't get their backdoor. Ramos tries to escape. He nearly gets away. I won't spoil exactly what happened. It's all very, very dramatic. And then they arrest him and they shut down Phantom Secure.
11:40 Speaker 02 But yes, although the FBI did not get their backdoor then, it ushered in this wave of paranoia in the encrypted phone industry where these sellers realised, oh, we can't do this anymore. The gold rush of selling encryption to drug traffickers is basically over or is going to be over soon.
12:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, you describe a sort of lavish parties full of escorts and obviously drugs. These resellers were throwing for themselves. These companies, mostly men who ran all these companies, were throwing because this was the easiest money that any of them had ever made. And that party just ends.
12:17 Speaker 02 Yeah, and some people go on the run. Some of them make deals with the authorities. Eventually later, some of them just shut down their companies entirely because they presumably decide this just is not worth it. Like, we cannot provide these tools to criminals anymore. And I should just say, like, in most places in the world, it is not a crime to sell an encrypted phone nor to make a piece of encryption software. Uncontroversially, I think that's a good thing. I don't think it should be illegal to make encryption technology. It gets complicated legally and ethically when you are deliberately facilitating criminal networks and selling to those crime networks. And that's what a lot of these companies did.
12:58 Speaker 01 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
13:37 Speaker 03 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
14:07 Speaker 04 This episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom, Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still ad. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at nordstrom.com.
14:39 Speaker 01 Welcome back. I'm talking to Joseph Cox, author of Dark Wire, about how the FBI ended up not only intercepting, but actually running an encrypted phone network for criminals. To set the stage, Joseph just described how the feds busted up a company called Phantom Secure, which ran an encrypted phone network on BlackBerrys. And that left a hole in the market.
15:00 Speaker 01 So this brings us to about 2018. The gold rush is over, the 10 years of parties come to an end. And somehow, instead of another company or another strategy coming out of the criminal world, the FBI launches the next generation encrypted messaging platform for drug dealers. It's called Anam. How is it that the FBI launches the big competitor here? That's the heart of the book in it. To me, it's just the funniest thing in the entire world.
15:31 Speaker 02 So when Phantom is shut down, there is something of a vacuum. They have their 10,000 customers. They need to get back on an encrypted messaging platform as soon as possible. When you're a drug trafficker, time is money, obviously. And if you're not moving drugs, you are losing money. So somebody who calls themselves AFGU makes a deal with the FBI. And they say, I've been making my own encrypted phone company. Would you like to use it in your own investigations? And I cannot stress enough what an incredible ace that is both for AFGU. Because it's not just like, hey, I'm going to inform on this one criminal organisation. It's like, I'm giving you a tech startup and you can grow it. Like, I've done the bootstrapping,
16:14 Speaker 02 for lack of a way of pulling it. And you can now grow it. And you can get your hockey stick growth, or whatever Silicon Valley term you want to use. And you can put in your backdoor. In return, please don't prosecute me for crimes that you may or may not do in the future. And it's just an incredible deal. And one that is absolutely tantalising to the FBI and the AFP. They miss their backdoor and Phantom secure. Now they can make their own backdoor in any way that they want, essentially.
16:42 Speaker 01 So just logistically, AFGU has to show up to the FBI and say, I have this product. Would you like to take it over? And then we will sell it to the criminal underworld.
16:54 Speaker 01 The FBI has to say yes. Right? They have to agree that they're going to do this. There's there has to be some process. What is that process at the FBI like?
17:02 Speaker 02 At first, the DOJ and the FBI don't think the Americans, the senior DOJ, are going to get on board unless they prove this is actually real. So working with the Australian Federal Police, the AFP do something of a beta test. And they start to roll out the phones, AFGU does in Australia, just starting with five and then slowly ramping up. The AFP starts to intercept messages. And very quickly, they see that 100% of the messages at the time are criminal in nature. There's not people like just having normal chats. It's just like, okay, cocaine deal. Okay, methamphetamine deal, whatever. So it shows us it's a Success, right? But at that moment, the FBI isn't reading the messages for legal reasons.
17:47 Speaker 02 And they need to figure out the approval process. And there's a really great scene in the book where one of the prosecutors, Andrew Young, is trying to get everybody else in San Diego on his side to approve it. And they go around the table and there's all these seasoned drug prosecutors who've been doing this for years and years and years. And they say, no, this is a ridiculous idea. This is stupid. You can't do this. And eventually it gets to Bob Brewer, the most senior official there and the trumper pointy. And he says, I need to see the look on their face when I say we're going to do this. And he approves it. And interestingly, he is an outsider. He's never really been in DOJ until he was appointed. So he has this outside perspective of, well, why don't we just run our own tech company? That's a great idea. Let's absolutely go for it. I don't know if it would have got off the ground
18:31 Speaker 02 if there wasn't that outside perspective necessarily, because the DOJ is not the best place to run a move fast and break things tech startup, obviously.
18:42 Speaker 01 So this is the my next question is, then they have to run it. They have customers and resellers and I'm assuming they need to fix things when they break and they need to have uptime. How did the FBI run a phone company? The phone companies are bad at running phone companies. How did the FBI run a phone company?
18:58 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly. Everything you think you would have to do for a legitimate company, the FBI had to do here. So they had to hire developers, some of which I spoke to, and they had no idea they were actually working for the FBI. They had to fix bugs, introduce new features, all of that sort of thing. The FBI had to pay for the technical infrastructure that would include, you know, SIM cards or servers or anything like that. They had to deal with shipping the phones. There's one point where stock is running low in one part of the world. So the FBI flies a Gulfstream jet packed with duffel bags of Google pixels to introduce more stock there.
19:34 Speaker 01 This is more Google pixels than have ever been shipped in the history of Google pixels.
19:38 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly. Which could have been the flight risk, I mean, for obviously all of those batteries on our plane, but that's sort of another thing. But every problem you imagine a tech company would have, they had to deal with as well, including hackers, paying people. Running every single aspect of it, the marketing, trying to get a grip on some of these criminal markets where the resellers would say, well, if you switch to our platform, we'll give you a discount of $300 or something like that. And there was also a little bit of mystique in that when you went to the company's website, you couldn't get in unless you entered a code that you got from a reseller. It kind of reminds me of the early days of, was it Google Plus, where they were like, you have to know somebody to get in. And all
20:20 Speaker 02 of that came together to the point where the FBI, I mean, they are running a successful tech company, eventually grows to something like 12,000 devices, which doesn't sound like a lot in, you know, the grand scheme of things, but that's bigger than Phantom Secure was. Somehow the FBI actually did better than some of the criminal companies.
20:39 Speaker 01 Who was in charge of that? Um, was it, did they have a CEO? Was there a public face? Was it a committee? How did it work?
20:45 Speaker 02 AFGU was in charge of the day-to-day operations of the company. There were various people inside the company who tried to take it over, but AFGU was the one who basically called the shots for most things. You know, I'm going to push this update, all of that sort of thing. I think we should hire this person. But behind every single decision, there's the constant shadowy presence of the FBI. Obviously, the developers have no idea, the criminals have no idea, and neither do the people selling the phones. But I kind of think of it as like a VC or like an investor who like, isn't really in the public, but they're kind of pulling some of the strings in the back. That's how I see the FBI in
21:27 Speaker 02 this, as in, they did get final approval on, well, no, don't put that in the phone because that would actually make our job harder. Do put that in because that'll improve our backdoor. And it was stuff like, well, we'll give them a redaction image feature, but we'll secretly make it so the phone copies the original image and that sort of thing. So the FBI is like VC slash Tech North Star slash Ultimate Projects Manager, I guess, but AFGU is the face of it, at least to everybody else.
21:56 Speaker 01 That's the most complicated decoder structure answer I think we've ever received. Why did the FBI trust AFGU? Right? Here's, here's a central player. They came to them. They're the face. It seems like there's a lot of trust there. Do they know who that was?
22:10 Speaker 02 Yes, they knew who it was. And you're right, there's absolutely trust there. I think it was that if Afgu did anything to sort of go behind the FBI's back, their agreement would be void. You know, the agreement will fall apart and they could potentially face prosecution in the future. I feel like Afgu was probably in a corner. And when you are part of this very violent underground industry, this is sort of your last resort. And this is your way out. So you don't get killed by somebody and you can hopefully remain free as well.
22:45 Speaker 01 So Afgu has this hilarious CEO job where they report to the FBI. The FBI is driving a lot of literally tech features. But they have to grow the company, right? There's a vacuum after Phantom Secure goes away. Anam could potentially take over. It eventually does succeed. But in the middle, in the act two, as I always call it, they've got to go win. And they act like a tech startup there, right? They're disruptive. They squeeze their competitors. How did they actually win?
23:13 Speaker 02 So they won in a couple of ways. The first is that by they simply made a better product than some of the others.
23:18 Speaker 01 That's incredible that the FBI made a better product. I just very excited about this.
23:21 Speaker 02 Yes. They made a better encrypted smartphone for criminals with all of the fancy, interesting features it had. And people loved it. People flocked to it and they would tell their friends about it and they would encourage other criminals to get on board as well. The other part of how it really grew was that somewhat controversially, the FBI and its partners investigated another company called Sky. This was very similar to Phantom Secure, very similar to another one called Enkro Chat. The plan was deliberately, the FBI has their company sitting in the wings and then we're going to shut down Sky. Those users are going to have to go somewhere. Why don't we have them run over to our trap, essentially, our honeypot?
24:05 Speaker 02 And that was the most transformative moment for the company. It grew, I think, three times. And the FBI agents that I heard from, they were saying like, it was like starting all over. Again, and they really did have hockey stick growth where they now had entire new countries on there. They were getting new criminal syndicates every few days. And it was just like this exponential growth, sort of in the same way when you release an app and it goes viral. Only here, the FBI did something like, I don't know, maybe the DOJ should investigate the anti-competition sort of stuff here. Cause they shut down the competitor essentially.
24:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, I feel like if you told Mark Zuckerberg or Tim Cook that they could go arrest their competitors, they would do it. And the FBI was allowed to go arrest their competitors. Great. You mentioned scalability, that there's massive growth. Are they running on AWS? How do they handle all this growth? How do they scale?
24:56 Speaker 02 So I've seen network infrastructure diagrams of the company. And yeah, they used AWS as an accelerator. There was Google, there was Google infrastructure as well. They use commercial providers and, you know, obviously there would have been security concerns as well. But that kind of hammers the point home that they couldn't just run like the FBI's tech company. Cause it wouldn't make sense. They really, really had to emulate the successful players in the space. And that includes these very expensive unlimited data SIM cards. It includes using AWS to accelerate your traffic and try to get more reliable and have a lot of uptime. It was literally as they were just trying to run the most successful tech company they could.
25:39 Speaker 01 With a backdoor to law enforcement.
25:41 Speaker 02 With a backdoor to law enforcement, with that very, very small caveat. Yeah.
25:45 Speaker 01 Cause they are law enforcement. A strange thing about all this is the FBI is running this phone network, encrypted phone network criminals. They're not allowed to just use this stuff, right? They have to be careful in when they burn the customers and actually prosecute them. They have to, you know, obviously they're in the United States. We have a constitution, there are rules about what you can use and when you can use it. You have to get warrants in some ways. It feels like other countries were able to use this information much more effectively than the FBI was.
26:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's a constant tension in which. The authorities, and I mean more the Europeans or the ones in other countries, they really want to act. They want to seize this drug shipment. They want to stop this assassination. They want to seize these weapons. And especially for the threats to life, the FBI knows it's just had to act because when they see somebody is going to get killed, they can't ethically just sit there. Legally, it wasn't a wide app, but ethically they treated it as such. And again, that tension of, well, if we go too far too quickly, people are going to realize there's a backdoor and something very unusual happened where there would be a threat to life. Maybe a biker gang will want to kill somebody. The authorities would intervene and then rather than suspecting the phone,
26:57 Speaker 02 the criminals would suspect somebody else in their own organization and then want to kill them. And it's like this endless spiral of violence the FBI has to deal with. And it's basically getting out of control towards the end.
27:09 Speaker 01 How do they keep any of this a secret? I hear what you're saying, no one ever suspects their phone. But I feel like the reason they have the phones is because they suspect the regular phones. Is it just that they have a false confidence in anonym phones? What, how do, honestly, how do they keep this a secret?
27:26 Speaker 02 I'm genuinely shocked they didn't leak, as in really, really genuinely shocked that this didn't get out earlier. The FBI ran this for like basically three years, more. And one way they did do that is by only bringing in agencies that they really, really trusted. There are countries who were not looped in. I mean, countries like Serbia, for example, where I understand a lot of the violence took place. And I think some of the corruption as well. The FBI did not loop them in to this secret. On one side, it was a very large operation with 16 countries or something like that towards the end. On the other, it was only very, very, very trusted agencies and basically people. As in a lot of these relationships, they already knew each other from sort of other operations.
28:10 Speaker 02 They were actually friends in a lot of cases. And if they weren't friends at the start, they were at the end. You know, they were telling me about how they were going to the pub and the bars together and getting drunk and celebrating. So it really was this big mutual decision to keep it under wraps, which is not to say the criminals did not get suspicious because they absolutely did towards the end. And with other operations into Enkro Chat and Sky, those two other companies, some criminals did learn about those beforehand. So leaks do happen, but it's basically a miracle that this one didn't.
28:44 Speaker 01 We have to take another quick break. We'll be right back.
28:55 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
29:21 Speaker 03 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
29:56 Speaker 06 Hit pause on whatever you're listening to and hit play on your next adventure. Get double points on every qualified stay. Life's a trip. Make the most of it at Best Western. Visit bestwestern.com for complete terms and conditions.
30:15 Speaker 01 We're back. I'm talking to 404 Media's Joseph Cox about the absolutely wild true story of the FBI running a secure phone company for criminals that was not, in fact, as secure as it seemed. The massive project Anam held together for a few years, but then things got tricky.
30:31 Speaker 01 You've got all the problems of a regular startup. We got to pay the AWS bill. Then you have all these other scalability problems. Our service is getting bigger and it's leading to an escalating cycle of violence that we have to keep stopping and we have to... Keep it a secret and things are leaking. By 2021, people are starting to get the sense this isn't going to work. Describe the sort of the beginning of the end here.
30:54 Speaker 02 Towards the start of 2021, it becomes pretty clear to the FBI agents I've spoken to and other officials. Though this is just like untenable. There are more and more messages coming in every single day. The FBI can't keep, I think momentum is the term that was used. With the influx of messages and users, they are too successful to the point where what happens if a message falls through the cracks? And you know, and they can't stop a threat to life or something like that. And that actually did happen at one point, as in one person was killed on the FBI's app. Now, what happens if we let that continue? So they decide that the date is going to be June 7th, 2021.
31:37 Speaker 02 For the reason that stuff is growing to an enormous size, but also for a legal logistical reason. That that's when the the court order they obtained was going to run out anyway. So they start this massive flurry of activity leading up to June 7th, where it's like, well, now we're going to switch this from an intelligence tool into like an evidence judicial tool. And we're going to start investigating these people really, really aggressively. So I've read tens of thousands of pages of police reports related to a NOM. And this is when you start to see the cops on the ground in Europe, following cars, getting their normal text messages, getting hotel bills, getting the criminals' credit card information. Sort of all the normal investigative techniques we all know about.
32:20 Speaker 02 But now they're ramping those up, applying them to these messages with the hope of arresting 800 people is their list towards the big day. Which is just like an unfathomable amount of activity to have on one day. Like you think of a big raid, oh, wow, that was great. Literally multiply that by 800.
32:38 Speaker 01 And so 800 people actually got arrested in how many countries?
32:42 Speaker 02 I actually don't know how many countries, but it was 800 people arrested and a NOM was active in more than 100 different countries. And at the end, they had something like 22 million messages and nearly 10,000 police acted on that one single day in like this global relay race of arrests and raids.
33:04 Speaker 01 And what was the go signal? Did they send out an email being like, today's the day?
33:07 Speaker 02 I think there was basically a meeting where the FBI told everybody, this is the date. We're not going to negotiate it. We're not going to change it. This is the date. You have to figure out what you're going to do now to arrest the people that you want to target.
33:21 Speaker 01 How did they keep that a secret?
33:24 Speaker 02 I mean, this is when stuff does start to get a little bit wobbly. As well as the large size of the company, some users do start to get a little bit suspicious because more and more customers are coming on board and some of them even start to call the phones cursed because I give one to a friend, he joins it, he immediately gets raided. People do start to get paranoid about, well, maybe something is wrong with these phones. Fortunately for the FBI, this is around sort of the May 2021 time period and they're ready to go in early June.
33:58 Speaker 01 So they have the raids, everyone gets arrested. How do they shut it down? Do they put up like a laughing skull emoji on the webpage? Do they tell everyone or just go away?
34:09 Speaker 02 It's actually not too dissimilar from that. They put a big, they put a big message on the website saying, we've been running this company the entire time. Here's a little form where you can submit your information for us to tell you if you're implicated in this investigation. Obviously, if I was a criminal, I would not fill out that form. I think that'd be very, very stupid.
34:27 Speaker 01 Did anyone fill out the form?
34:29 Speaker 02 I don't know. But what I did, by what I did see is that a day or two after that came up, I did find a random tweet from somebody saying, hey, my phone is not working. I didn't include that in the book, but I was just like, this guy did not get the memo.
34:45 Speaker 01 He's on Reddit looking for customer support. That's incredible. So that's the end of Anam, right? It's the end of this moment where the FBI runs a phone company for criminals. You mentioned earlier in the episode, now there's a bunch of consumer tools that basically offer this from the jump, right? There's Signal, which is NDD encrypted. There's some other ones. Is that where it all moved? Is there a replacement for these companies? Is the action still in hardware or has it moved to software?
35:09 Speaker 02 So after the company was shut down, I spoke to people who sell encrypted phones to criminals. And one said, it's basically impossible to build a customer base now because customers don't trust it. They're like, I'm not going to buy this phone because what's to say? It's not just the FBI running it again. So that's one issue. And the consequence of that is that a lot of these criminals are moving to Signal. They are moving to consumer apps. And I just think that brings up a really urgent question, which is that what happens now? The FBI is not going to stop investigating encrypted communications. They told me as much. I snuck into a law enforcement only conference and one of the agents on stage said, I'm
35:52 Speaker 02 looking forward to the next iteration of this operation. In Europe, we have European authorities saying they want to scan the content of encrypted messaging for C-SAM initially, but that could easily expand. This is just a warning shot for what potentially could happen now because the FBI isn't going to pat itself on the back and go home. They're an aggressive agency, as are all law enforcement agencies. They're going to go where the criminals are. And in some cases, that's going to be consumer apps.
36:19 Speaker 01 We've covered encryption from the consumer side for a long time. You've obviously covered it on the sort of law enforcement criminal side for a long time. The pressure on all of the consumer companies to have backdoors around the world to break open iMessage or break open Signal or at least provide a key to the law enforcement agencies. The pressure waxes and wanes, but the answer from most of the companies has been the same throughout. No, we're just not going to do it. Apple says to the FBI, we're not going to unlock the iPhone of a shooter in California. That's not going to happen. The pressure is increasing, especially with things like C-SAM and all this other stuff that is obviously bad and kind of in the public consciousness in a real way now. Do you think that tech companies will crack? That these consumer apps will eventually be forced to open their encryption to law enforcement?
37:05 Speaker 02 I don't think necessarily the consumer apps will crack. I don't see Signal changing its very robust position on we provide minimal data to law enforcement. We're not going to put a backdoor into our code or anything like that. And I trust that. I use Signal every single day, and I think that's a fantastic thing. What I think it will do is create incentive for the FBI to keep trying these highly novel or audacious operations. And like, we could see them trying to compromise another encrypted chat platform, consumer or criminal run or whatever, or another alternative, if these apps are not going to provide data to law enforcement, is more targeted hacking, right? You know, generally stuff like NSO's Pegasus
37:47 Speaker 02 malware, which goes onto your phone. I think that broader society needs to have a conversation about those options, because the status quo is not an option. Like, we can't just say, oh, this is fine, and we're just not going to do anything, because the FBI and its partners are going to keep doing things. And it's sort of up to all of us, and the tech companies especially, where that pressure and effort is going to be placed by the FBI potentially.
38:12 Speaker 01 We've been in a pretty novel period where the tech companies have been very willing to stand up to governments. That does feel like it's changing, just in a variety of ways, it feels like it's changing. Do you think that things like state-sponsored hacking, or Pegasus spyware, or any of these other approaches that are getting more and more novel, do you think the tech companies are going to allow them to happen? Or do you think they're going to try to shut them down as aggressively as they have in the past?
38:38 Speaker 02 Well, when we look at WhatsApp, right, and Meta, they are suing NSO groups because they didn't really like the fact that NSO was hacking people on WhatsApp. But that's a sort of process. That's a court case, and there's ebbs and flows, right? And I think it's very similar to the cat and mouse game between law enforcement, the criminals they target, and sort of the vendors that provide the sort of capability. The price of iPhone exploits, I don't have the latest, but when I've reported by talking to people who make these exploits for the government, it's always going up. And then Apple makes it more secure, and then they find a new workaround, and it keeps going, keeps going, keeps going. I personally prefer that option where, okay, the FBI has to spare more money.
39:20 Speaker 02 Okay, I don't know, just find some more money or something rather than compromising an entire chat platform. The tech companies don't like the fact that they constantly have to fix vulnerabilities. I imagine that's very annoying for them. The FBI don't like the fact that hacking is not sort of a turnkey solution. Yes, annoying for both parties, but it's probably the best solution right now, as messy as it is.
39:43 Speaker 01 Right, because it protects the actual consumer, so we're not doing anything wrong. Well, the book is amazing how they're coming at it. It's just, it is a fun read, like, summer, read, read a crime book. What's your favorite story in the book?
39:53 Speaker 02 My favorite story is absolutely the arc of a criminal called Microsoft. Real name, Maximilian Rifkin. I don't know why it's called Microsoft, but he had a friend in prison who used the nickname Linux as well. So there's some computer stuff going on there. I would much rather be called Linux than Microsoft. He basically helps expand these phones around the world, getting all of his criminal network to use them. He's planning his own crimes on the platform as well. And then something starts happening. His amphetamine lab gets raided, some of his cocaine in an ocean near Hong Kong also is ruined, and lots of other things along the way. And he consistently blames other people or other phones. It is never the anon phone.
40:38 Speaker 02 And it's just this incredible arc of this criminal gang, his comeuppance, which, when I came across that in these mass of documents I've read and the people I've spoken to who know Microsoft, the, the arc like fell into my lap. I just could not have been more lucky or happy that this is perfect. This is, this is a book arc right there.
40:58 Speaker 01 That's amazing. Again, I can't recommend the book enough. It's Dark Wire, the incredible true story of the largest sting operation ever. Also cannot recommend 404 Media enough. Go read Joe's work there, the whole site is great. Really rooting for you guys. Joe, thank you so much for being on the cover.
41:12 Speaker 02 Thank you so much, I really appreciate it.
41:17 Speaker 01 Thanks again to Joseph Cox for joining us on the show. His book is Dark Wire, The Incredible True Story of the Largest Sting Operation Ever. It comes out on June 4th. You can buy it wherever you buy books. If you're into Decoder or The Verge, this is your summer read. You should just pick it up. If you have thoughts about this episode, or what you'd like to hear more of, you can email us at [email protected] . We really do read all the emails. Or you can hit me up directly on threads. I'm at reckless1280. We also have a TikTok for as long as there's a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like the show, hit us with a five-star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge, part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Kelly Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
42:06 Speaker 03 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in a wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple Conducted Study of Heart Rate Accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
42:37 Speaker 07 If you're building AI agents, you should check out Strands Agents. It's an open source SDK for Python and TypeScript. The idea is simple. Give a model some tools, let it decide what to call and when, and loop until it's done. No chain convicts, no graph orchestration, and works with any model provider. It's also open source and built and tested for production agents. Get started at strandsagents.com.
Previous Google's Sundar Pichai on AI-powered search and the future of the web Next Google Zero is here. Now what? Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated