Pod Insights Decoder How Arm conquered the chip market without making a single chip, with CEO Rene Haas About this episode One of the more interesting quirks of the modern tech world is that there’s a really important company at the center of it all that doesn’t make anything. But its work is in your phone, in your TV, your car and maybe even your laptop. I’m talking about ARM, a chip design company that’s been through quite a lot these past few years, and I'm talking to Arm CEO Rene Haas.
Arm designs the instruction sets for modern chips: Qualcomm’s chips are Arm chips. Apple’s chips are Arm chips. Samsung’s chips are Arm chips. It’s the heart of modern computing. Arm licenses the instruction set to those companies, who then go off and actually make chips with all sorts of customizations. Basically every smartphone runs an Arm processor, Apple’s Macs now run arm processors, and everything from cars to coffee machines are showing up with more and more arm processors in them.
We want to know what you think about Decoder. Take our listener survey!
Transcript:
https://www.theverge.com/e/23137412
Links:
The Vergecast: The HDMI Holiday Spec-tacular on Apple Podcasts
Biden signs $280 billion CHIPS and Science Act
Intel needs 7,000 workers to build its $20 billion chip plant in Ohio - The Verge
What comes after the smartphone, with Qualcomm CEO Cristiano Amon - The Verge
Why the global chip shortage is making it so hard to buy a PS5
Nvidia’s huge Arm deal has just been scrapped
What is a SoC?
What is an ECU?
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott and it was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Sr Audio Director is Andrew Marino. Our Editorial Director is Brooke Minters. And our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 12,037 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:34 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard, confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. So one of the more interesting quirks of the modern tech world is that there's a really important company at the center of everything that doesn't make anything. But its work is in your phone, it's in your TV, it's in your car, maybe even your laptop, or the data centers that keep all these things working. I'm talking, of course, about ARM, a chip design company that's been through quite a lot these past few years. ARM designs the instruction sets for modern chips. Qualcomm's chips are ARM chips. Apple's chips are ARM chips. Samsung's chips are ARM chips. It's the heart of modern computing. ARM licenses the instruction set to these companies who then go off and actually make
1:50 Speaker 03 chips with all sorts of customizations. And this business model has been a runaway success. Basically, every smartphone runs an ARM processor. Apple's Macs now run ARM processors. And everything from cars to coffee machines are showing up with more and more ARM processors in them. So today, I'm talking to Rene Haas. He's the newly minted CEO of ARM. He's only been on the job for six months. But that comes after a wild sequence of events that saw ARM get bought by SoftBank, which then tried to sell it to Nvidia. But that deal was blocked, not just by regulators, but by a consortium of ARM's biggest customers that compete with Nvidia. So the deal got iced, and now ARM is set to go public, which, well, the company said it would never do. So there's a lot to talk about. And of course, I was curious about some basics.
2:35 Speaker 03 How does ARM make its money? Who are its real customers? And how is ARM affected by the chip shortage, since they don't actually make the chips? This might be the most complicated company of all. A couple of notes before we start this conversation got directly into the weeds. IoT is short for Internet of Things. It's basically smart home stuff, sensors around the world. ECUs are electronic control units. They're the tiny embedded systems that control everything in your car, from the engine to the power windows. ADAS or ADAS is Advanced Driver Assistance Systems. That's automatic braking, or adaptive cruise control, or lane change detection, things like that. SoC is system on a chip. That's a very important term. That's a CPU and GPU integrated into one package.
3:17 Speaker 03 When we talk about smartphone chips, we are basically talking about SoCs. Okay, that takes care of that. Let's get into it. Rene Haas, CEO of ARM. Here we go.
3:38 Speaker 03 Rene Haas, you are the CEO of ARM. Welcome to Decoder.
3:42 Speaker 04 Thank you very much, Neil.
3:43 Speaker 03 I'm very excited to talk to you. You're pretty much the new CEO of ARM. It's been six months, seven months.
3:48 Speaker 04 I'm definitely new. It's been six months, but it's been a very fast six months. But yes, I am new to the position from mid February. Not new to ARM. I've been with ARM almost nine years now. But yes, certainly, this is the latest new role for me.
4:02 Speaker 03 Well, there's a lot to talk about. Lots of changes coming to ARM. You have a plan to go public. You just had your last quarter's earnings. ARM is a fascinating company, though. I think we need to start at the beginning. It is a critical puzzle piece in the entire tech ecosystem. We all depend on ARM. What ARM does affects all of us down the line, but it's also pretty opaque, because consumers don't really have a relationship to ARM directly. And the way that we have that relationship is mediated by lots of other companies in between. So let's start at the beginning. What does ARM make exactly?
4:35 Speaker 04 So ARM is not a well-known company, as you said, and not well-understood, but we like to think we're extremely important. So starting off, we sit inside the semiconductor world. So we are in the semiconductor value chain, and you can essentially find ARM technology in almost any type of semiconductor product and/or OEM product. We're in smartphones, we're in laptops, smart TVs. Looking around my desk here, there's probably dozens of ARM processors everywhere. We don't actually build anything. But what we do is we do the designs, and we do the design of pieces of the product that we call intellectual property. We build that design, and rather than building a chip using our design, we license that design to
5:19 Speaker 04 someone who's going to build the end product. And the primary product we're best known for is the microprocessor, the CPU, which is the brain of almost any type of electronics device. So when you think about the fact that we do these brains, and that we don't actually build chips, we license these brains to anyone who builds chips, and we'll license that brain to anybody who will build a chip. There's a lot of our brains out there. Kind of reflecting on the numbers, I think between all the semiconductor companies and OEMs in the world, last quarter, 7.4 billion chips were shipped and built with some type of ARM CPU inside or GPU or some ARM technology, which is a huge, huge number.
6:01 Speaker 04 So the way to think about it is, we're in the semiconductor value chain, but we don't build anything. We do designs and most of those designs are microprocessors.
6:09 Speaker 03 Who are your customers?
6:11 Speaker 04 You know, it's funny, Neil, in the electronics industry, it would be almost harder to say who isn't our customers. Almost anybody you can think of is our customer. TSMC is a customer, Samsung is a customer, Global Founders is a customer. These are people who physically build the chips. Intel is a customer, AMD is a customer, Nvidia is a customer, Qualcomm is a customer, Amazon is a customer, Microsoft is a customer, Google is a customer. Then when you get into other parts of the world, you've got Alibaba is a customer and Tencent is a customer and Byte Band. So just about, just about everybody is a customer of ours. It's kind of crazy.
6:51 Speaker 03 And how do you make money from those customers? So they're just licensing designs? Are they buying reference chips off the shelf? Are they just paying patent licensing fees? How does that work?
7:00 Speaker 04 Our business model has two components. We have an upfront license fee that our partners will pay us for access to the technology and that gives them the rights to build designs using our technology. If those designs ultimately find their way into production and into an end product, we then collect a per unit royalty based upon some arithmetic math relative to how the contracts are such. So high level, two sources of revenue. One is what we call licensing revenue and the other is what we would call royalty revenue.
7:30 Speaker 03 So if I go to Qualcomm and I just buy a Snapdragon chip from Qualcomm, do I have to pay you or does Qualcomm have to pay you or does someone else pay you?
7:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, you don't, but Qualcomm would. Qualcomm would report to us in that example. How many units were shipped that you bought? There's a pre-negotiated royalty rate and they would send us a, basically a payment to cover those royalties.
7:54 Speaker 03 So let's go Samsung. Samsung makes its own chips. It designs its own chips. It makes smartphones. Those divisions of Samsung actually have to contract with each other. If I buy a Samsung phone, how does the money flow back to you? A Samsung phone with an Exynos chip in it, not a Qualcomm chip, because some Samsung phones have Exynos chips from Samsung and some have Qualcomm chips. Well, let's specify a Samsung chip.
8:16 Speaker 04 Here's the beauty of the ARM business model, right? Qualcomm uses our technology, so does Samsung Exynos, as you gave. So in the case of when a Galaxy phone ships, we're likely getting paid. We're getting paid by Qualcomm. If that product went out of Qualcomm, and in the case of Samsung, we're getting paid. It depends on the licensing arrangements we have with partners, but typically they're with the semiconductor arms of these companies, no pun intended. So the chip division, whoever we have signed a contract with, let's just say in the case of Samsung, it was the chip group, then the chip group would be making the payments.
8:49 Speaker 03 All right, last one, top of the difficulty ladder, I think, is Apple, which has a very unique kind of license from you. It's called an architectural license. They fully design their own chips. I don't think they use a lot of your designs, but it's ARM intellectual property. When I buy an M2 MacBook Air, how do you get paid?
9:06 Speaker 04 Commercially, very similar. We have contracts with companies like, as mentioned, like Apple, and they'll pay at Cerroty, just like if the most does. No different.
9:16 Speaker 03 Can anyone go get that kind of license that Apple has, where they get to use your IP and but design their own stuff completely?
9:22 Speaker 04 You referred to an architectural license. What that basically means is it gives the rights to a company to build what we would call an ARM compliant processor. And what we require from anyone who does that is, and this is a very important point, is that the CPU that they build, and they can make minor modifications to the microarchitecture, and by that I mean how it's actually physically put down on the chip. But what they can't do is modify it in such a way that it doesn't run ARM instructions. And that's really important because at the end of it all, we have to maintain software compatibility such that if anyone is running an ARM processor somewhere, whether it's something that we build or it's something that a partner who has an architectural license,
10:07 Speaker 04 it has to be compliant to running ARM software. So that's really the way to think about it. Architectural licenses, we don't have many. It's hard to do. We build really good CPUs. And I'm biased, of course, but we build really good CPUs. And it's very, very hard to build a CPU that's ARM compliant. That's a whole lot different and better than what we do. So there aren't many people to do that. It used to be more, but now it's a smaller and smaller number. A, it's hard. And B, it's hard to find the people. These are hard, hard teams to go out and build. So most companies look at it and say, if I'm building an SoC or a system on chip and I've only got so many precious engineers to differentiate my product,
10:51 Speaker 04 differentiating the ARM CPU is probably not the best place to spend my energy. Better places are around areas like a camera or a modem or I/O or things that we don't do.
11:01 Speaker 03 When Apple ships a product or another architecture licensee ships a product, do you have teams that go and validate that it's running the ARM instruction set and they haven't broken the rules? Or are you just on our system? Is that we don't want to piss off Tim Cook too much?
11:16 Speaker 04 We have a set of requirements and we have a compliance suite that we test against. So we have to essentially verify that, end quote, what they have built is ARM compliant. So we run tests against that to basically see if it can run ARM instructions and run ARM code and compile properly and the compiler doesn't break. And somehow you're not able to. Recognize the right instructions. So yeah, short answer is we do have a set of compliance tests for anyone building an architectural license-based design.
11:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, I wanted to ask these questions and just sort of close the loop of here's this company that sits at the center of almost every modern chip, save the Intel and AMD CPUs that people might encounter, but it's somewhat opaque. And I think that that loop closing where you actually validate, okay, this is ARM stuff that works in the ARM way. I think most people don't understand it. So I wanted to ask that set of questions, just to feel for the business.
12:11 Speaker 04 They're very important questions, though, because one of the things that I think has helped us be so ubiquitous in our history is the fact that whether it's an ARM implementation or an architectural implementation, they run software targeted for the ARM ISA the same, just it doesn't break. Meaning, you know, there's been a lot of casualties in the CPU graveyard where they've allowed extensibility, meaning they'll allow customers to add custom instructions. And while that might sound innovative and cool, what really makes a CPU architecture relevant in the long term is developers just know it's going to run
12:55 Speaker 04 and they're not having to worry about if a developer is writing a piece of code for an OEM and ARM is embedded, the developer doesn't want to know or need to know or have, will even be in a position to know, oh, I'm designing a thermostat, it's got BOPS chip inside and BOPS got some extra instructions. I need to take advantage of that because they may not know in another OEM device whether that has the ARM chip that has those instructions. So leveling the playing field, just making sure that the software data set looks the same is really important. And our, our four founders did a fantastic job of adhering to that and making it pretty quite principled. And you can see it's really benefited us now.
13:38 Speaker 03 You have a lot of customers, those customers are all pretty full-throated competitors of one another in various ways. I have talked to a lot of executives in positions like yours, a lot of standards body executives, what have you. They all strike me as doing a lot more political work than engineering work or research work. How is that split for you? Do you think that you're a politician, just sort of keeping everyone on the level playing field? Or are you deep in the weeds of processor design?
14:10 Speaker 04 Well, we're definitely deep in the weeds of processor design. I mean, that's what we do. At the end of it all, we spend a lot of time and energy on developing these CPUs. We spend a lot of time and energy on the software ecosystem. We spend a lot of time and energy really ensuring that the products are leading edge, solve partners' problems. One of the things that's different about us, I think, is the fact is we deal with everybody. We have to maintain a consistency of how we manage our relationship with partners. And that's really around access to technology, that's around access to bugs, that's around access to people. The world kind of relies on our, and again, as you said, we're kind of a little opaque.
14:52 Speaker 04 And having me say on a podcast, the world relies on our, and some of listening says, I rely on you guys. I don't even know you guys. But at the same time, we take very seriously how we manage those relationships with our partners. So the politics of it, maybe not so much, we really just take the relationships pretty seriously. And make sure that fairness is at the top of what we do.
15:14 Speaker 03 Well, let me give you just like another very dumb example. And maybe you can laugh this one out the door if you want to, but it strikes me as instructive. A couple of years ago, we talked to the people who run HDMI, which is like the industry standard for how you plug PlayStations in a TVs. And I was like, there's this one feature of HDMI that's like, doesn't work well. Where your one remote is supposed to control everything. And honestly, the answer is like, they threw out their hands in the air and it's like, that problem's too hard to solve. No one wants to take it on and everyone will disagree with them. So it's never going to get solved. And that was basically the answer. And I understood why politically that was the answer. That's the lowest stakes of all, right? I just want to plug my DVD player into a TV and make the remote control work. And the politics of it were effectively insurmountable. Your politics are way harder stakes.
15:59 Speaker 03 And you're not an industry standards body. You're a company that reports earnings, that wants to IPO, that has to grow those earnings for shareholders. How do you manage that kind of tension?
16:10 Speaker 04 We really try to stay as neutral as possible and we're known to be the Switzerland of the electronics industry, which is not a bad parallel because we try to stay neutral. We don't try to to pick winners. We're involved in the ecosystem of ecosystems and by that I mean if you start at the lowest level of semiconductor value chain, Global Foundries, Samsung, TSMC, Intel, all the people who build chips, you have to work with all of them. We have to make sure that our technology is going to be able to be built on every semiconductor process in the world, which requires investment across all those partners. All the way up the stack, when you think about Android and Linux and Windows and all the the major operating systems that we support,
16:55 Speaker 04 we got to make sure we're there, we're there too. And we really don't try to to play favorites in terms of advantaging one versus the other. I'm not sure how we would do that at the end of this day.
17:06 Speaker 04 But but what it means is that we stand on the shoulders of a pretty big ecosystem. And I would say it's an ecosystem of ecosystems because there are design tools, there are fabrication processes, there are software, operating systems, there's middleware. So we work a lot with interest groups and we create them. We don't really work so much with standard bodies, but we do work very, very heavily with all the players that I mentioned, just making sure that we understand everything that they're trying to do from a from a roadmap standpoint and ensuring that we're going to be as compliant as possible because at the end of the day, since we license technology to someone building a chip, that person building a chip wants the broadest opportunity that they have from where they build it,
17:51 Speaker 04 what software it runs on it and how it ultimately goes into production.
17:55 Speaker 03 It's a very idealistic answer, but I want to come back to it in the context of ARM being a publicly traded company because I think that might change the dynamics a little bit, but let's hold on to that for one second because I just want to get through some of the additional basics of understanding ARM. How many people work at ARM?
18:11 Speaker 04 Last headcount number I saw was probably 5,800 plus or minus with contractors probably north of 6,000.
18:17 Speaker 03 And then how are they structured? Is it all chip design? Is it lawyers? Patent attorney and chip designers in a one-to-one ratio? How does that work?
18:25 Speaker 04 It is definitely not one-to-one lawyers to engineers. I'll tell you that much.
18:29 Speaker 03 Some companies are definitely one-to-one lawyers and engineers.
18:32 Speaker 04 We're nowhere close to that. We are mostly engineers. Most of our engineers are in the UK. ARM's headquarters are in Cambridge, north of London, a couple hours. We have a few different sites across the UK. We have engineering sites in France, different parts of the Nordics. We have a design center in a couple of the United States, in Arizona and Texas. And we also have a fair bit of design engineers in India, Bangalore and Noida. Most of our employees are engineers. Our legal department is pretty darn small. And if I was to say you have the thumbnail ratios, it's, it's, the proportions are pretty large relative to the number of engineers, number of lawyers. And we've done a very, very good job relative to understanding how our licensing model works, how to protect our intellectual property.
19:16 Speaker 04 So, you know, we don't have a huge legal department, but we have a lot of engineers because these products are really hard to build.
19:22 Speaker 03 And then who reports to you? How's your team structured?
19:25 Speaker 04 I'm the CEO and I have the classic chief financial officer, chief people officer, head of legal reporting into me. We are organized around business units. So we have a vertical line of business structure. We have automotive, we have IoT, we have infrastructure and a client. So I have those GMs that report into me. I also have a chief architect who reports into me. And I have our head of sales and head of engineering. So as I'm listing it here, yeah, it's a lot of direct reports. But that's what the team looks like. It's mostly people oriented around engineering in the business with the classic functions around people, legal and finance.
20:04 Speaker 03 All right. And then here is the classic decoder question, the one that everyone comes on to answer. I think anyone comes on to answer this. We ask everybody, even at ARM for nine years, they've been the CEO for six months. How do you make decisions? What's your framework?
20:17 Speaker 04 Yeah. So I'm going to have to cheat a little bit and say that I had dinner with, with Tony Fidel, who I know you interviewed
20:25 Speaker 04 a while ago and. You know, I like his analogy of opinion-based decisions versus database decisions. And I would say that the more white that you get in your beard and your hair, you get more comfortable with opinion-based decisions because pattern matching starts to come into play. The history repeats itself because humans repeat themselves. You know, we are humans and humans make the same successes and mistakes. So I'm a mix of opinion and data and probably the more experienced I get, the more I rely on intuition because experience helps. You know, it's the classic for those of folks who are who are football fans out there. You know, why is Tom Brady at 45 still playing quarterback even though physically he's playing with guys half his age?
21:10 Speaker 04 Hard to fool him. He's seen it all. Now, our business is far more complex than professional football, but it helps a lot. So, yeah, short answer to your question is I rely on both. But I probably move faster now than I did when I was younger because opinion helps me a lot more than data because my gut is more intuitive.
21:30 Speaker 03 My understanding of Tom Brady is that he doesn't eat any tomatoes and like use avocado ice cream every day. Is that is that on your list?
21:35 Speaker 04 He is kind of like Benjamin Button. You know, every time you look at him, he looks younger and younger and younger. I do have weird dietary habits, you know, and folks will know in the UK. I'll have like yogurt and granola every day for for lunch. And my assistant when I'm in the UK will almost preempt me and say, I've got your yogurt in the fridge. It's got your name on it. Part of it, part of it just comes down to, and I've seen this from other other leaders, not that I would put myself in that category of being super successful, but reducing the number of decisions you have to make. I've always kind of found personally helps me. I wear kind of the same attire. I eat kind of the same thing, which it's like, okay, it's food I like. It's stuff I know it's one less thing to worry about.
22:16 Speaker 03 I have definitely found the same to be true with myself over time. It helps that I picked really cool clothes. That's that's been my trick.
22:22 Speaker 04 I would not say I'm there.
22:24 Speaker 03 Let's talk about a big decision then. So you're the new CEO. ARM famously got caught up in the sort of SoftBank Vision Fund turmoil where SoftBank raised a lot of money for something called the Vision Fund, billions upon billions of dollars, vested a lot of companies, bought ARM outright, which is a big deal, then tried to sell it to Nvidia when the Vision Fund got a little shaky. You described yourself as Switzerland. The industry basically lobbied as hard as it could against that deal. We do not want Nvidia to own this core CPU technology, processor design technology. That's Qualcomm, that's Apple. It's down the line. The industry said, don't do this. Governments said they would block the deal. SoftBank backs off. You arrive as the new CEO. You say, we're
23:07 Speaker 03 going to take the company public. That's a big flip. Your predecessor was adamantly opposed to taking this company public for that reason we were talking about earlier, that the pressure of having to grow revenue puts some of the model of being neutral and being a fair provider to everyone at risk, because you could cut special deals to increase revenue, to extend the instruction set. Those pressures will arrive. But that's your decision. How did you make that decision?
23:34 Speaker 04 Well, the Nvidia transaction basically came apart at the end of last year and we announced the change and I took over. The next quarter, or not long after, I think it was mid Feb, I took over and our fiscal year ended in March and we were finally able to talk about our financial results. We hadn't talked about our financial results for a while. We were very quiet during the Nvidia period. And when we announced our revenues for the year, we had record revenues of, you know, well over $2 billion. We did 2.6, for example. We had never done anything over 2. We had a operating margin of nearly 40%. People thought we were losing money. And if you fast forward to this quarter, EBITDA margin was even higher
24:16 Speaker 04 than where we ended last year, north of 50 and 700 million in revenue, 450 in royalties. So several of the calls I had with analysts and reporters were, where did this come from? And what kind of funny math are you doing? And is this a pro forma equation? But actually, we knew we were doing okay because Back to my time at ARM, not long after SoftBank bought ARM, we reorganized, we created two business units. I took over what was classic ARM. And we began a pivot towards other markets. And that pivot was not only a business model, but it was products. We knew, for example, that a couple of things on data center was happening.
24:59 Speaker 04 We knew the TSMC was getting really good on process. We knew we were making good headway on software workloads. And we felt if we advanced our investment into some specific instructions, such as SME and SVE for, these are vector extensions for specific workloads on hyperscalers, we could make some hay in terms of the hyperscaler market. And so what you're seeing now-
25:24 Speaker 03 That, Mark, but just to be clear for everyone, that's the cloud computing market. That's your Google Cloud AWS stuff.
25:29 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's cloud. And AWS, significant partner for us. They announced Graviton 2. They announced some fairly eye-popping numbers relative to 40% improvement price performance over other architectures. So for us, we've diversified our business. And by not only developing different products, but also addressing it through different parts of the business model strategy, we knew our business was going to be, end quote, okay. And, and all of the results you're seeing now, financially, which are terrific, and the team has done a fantastic job on, really come from work that was done a few years ago. Because you're not going to be able to see royalty results on units that happen overnight. Back to how we work,
26:14 Speaker 04 we develop IP, that IP has to go to a customer, they have to develop a chip, that chip has to go into the product, the product has to be qualified. It can take three to four years. So we feel good about where we're going. And we also feel really good that in the areas that we have been investing in, cloud, automotive, IoT, these are large secular growth areas that I think we're very well positioned for.
26:40 Speaker 03 Let me push on that, though. So I spend a fair amount of time on CNBC. I'm a tech journalist. That's a business channel. I'm always struck at, you know, CNBC is for investors and they end every interview with like, and what's going to happen next quarter? And I appreciate that. That's their job and they're really, really good at it. But you're describing multi-year bets, right? You made some bets two years ago that are paying off handsomely now. Do you think that quarter to quarter investor pressure will change how you operate the company? Because that seems like the risk.
27:10 Speaker 04 I think anytime you're a public company, that that is part of how the, you know, part of how the world operates. I can't talk too much about what life would be like as a public company and under pretty strict orders to stay in my lane on that.
27:23 Speaker 03 There's one of those few lawyers that comes about to run into the room.
27:27 Speaker 04 Yeah, exactly. So I can't really say too much about that. But what I can say is we're pretty confident in terms of the secular growth that we're seeing in the markets we're involved in.
27:39 Speaker 03 We need to take a quick break, but when we come back, we're going to talk about the chip shortage. You knew that was coming. Stick around.
27:49 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them. That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
27:59 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it, it wasn't.
28:07 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
28:20 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it. When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton for the stay.
28:53 Speaker 03 We're back.
28:56 Speaker 03 You just expressed some confidence in automotive and IoT and cloud. Cloud seems that market exists. It's growing, right? Cloud computing, data centers, ARM has made the move. That seems like it's definitely going to happen. I talked to a lot of car CEOs. We spend a lot of time in the Vergecast talking about smart home stuff and era things. Those markets aren't quite there yet. They haven't really made the turn. Is that something that you can drive as a CEO of ARM? Or is it more, we're going to have the designs ready? We're going to have the products ready for when the cars actually become totally networked computers on wheels?
29:30 Speaker 04 So if you think about a car, people think about electronics in the car and they quickly automatically go to autonomous driving and what you see with cruise and such. And that's just one dimension. If you think about what goes inside an automobile and the amount of processing that takes place, amount of processing in the car, you have your instrument panel, which is all digital and completely computerized. And almost all of that runs on ARM. You have the powertrain, anything involved with the mirrors, the brakes, all of that. That is quickly moving to ARM. And by that, I mean, there's a number of things happening in the car that are moving towards ARM that are not having to do with the instrument panel or the autonomous.
30:12 Speaker 04 In the powertrain, you have many of these older ECUs that were standalone units. They might have an old proprietary microcontroller in them. They don't communicate to other parts of the car. All these ECUs are being redesigned. And inside a car, there's maybe 50, 60, 70 ECUs. I mean, there's lots of them. Each one of those might have had an old proprietary microcontroller that had no connectivity, that had no memory management in it, didn't talk to other parts of the car. So the car becomes a highly networked piece of equipment. And then you add on autonomous and ADAS, which is an area for ARM to grow. So I think for us, the car is a bit of a sandbox of multiple technologies.
30:53 Speaker 04 Instrument panel, powertrain, powertrain slash ECUs, and then autonomous. And autonomous, by the way, is a huge, huge opportunity for us because of The fact that, go back to the data center, you know, what really matters in the car in terms of compute is performance and efficiency. You can't have a server in your trunk, running off an EV and be able to be successful at it. And some of the cars today, that's kind of what they are. They're kind of a server in a trunk. That's going to get better over time. So, you know, we're very, very positive about the automotive market. We've been growing very, very fast there.
31:28 Speaker 03 So is that you're going to take some of those engineers that you have and say, "Go figure out ECUs. Go figure out an engine controller or a body control module that'll work across cars." And then people, Nvidia can kind of license that and sell it to Ford.
31:41 Speaker 04 Already happening. And what ends up happening with these CPUs that go into automotive, what matters there? Well, efficiency matters, power matters, functional safety matters. You have to have all of the redundancy to make sure that this can run in a safe way. Some people do it in software, through compute libraries, but people would prefer to do it in hardware, because it's more secure, it's much more effective. So we've developed automotive processors that have functional safety embedded. We do graphics processors that have functional safety embedded. Those are things we weren't doing in the past. We would basically kind of roll out a, here's a, here's a general purpose thing, use it wherever you want to use it. That was one of the things we did the big change on in
32:25 Speaker 04 the last number of years. So automotive is going to be a very large market for us.
32:30 Speaker 03 We're talking about the future, but let's bring it back to just the present for a second. We are in the middle of something that has been a chip shortage for a long time. It may or may not be coming to a close. Intel and Nvidia just had pretty bad quarters. Intel is saying we're actually going to raise prices. Where do you sit in the chip shortage? Is that something that affects you right now? Is that something you see coming and going? Right? You're kind of divorced from the actual hardware piece of this.
32:58 Speaker 04 We're divorced from it from the standpoint that we don't build anything, but we're very linked to it in the sense that our royalty model is linked to how many components that people ship. So for sure, we have a, an eye to it in a very big way. But back to the earlier discussion, we're pretty diversified in terms of the end market. And the other thing that's happening is just more and more CPUs are being used in these SoCs, where apps processors for mobile phones might have used one CPU and went to four CPUs. The the cluster per compute is nine or 10 different CPUs now, right? You have 10 CPUs and that's just the apps processor.
33:41 Speaker 04 When you had taken the control of touch sensor, anything with a display and a camera. So what we're seeing is even though units have been softening in some markets such as smartphones, we've been sort of shielded by it just from the standpoint of where our product goes. Broadly speaking, semiconductor shortages, boom bust, that's the nature of our our world. I do think this one is a little different. First off, it's not all technologies, it's not all areas. IoT is strong, industrial is strong, cloud is strong. Different nodes are strong. Sometimes the older technology, 14 nanometer, 20 nanometer, 40 is kind of hard to get. And all these devices and these complex systems require a mix and match.
34:25 Speaker 04 And you only need one thing not to be ready to have a problem. And then when you layer on top of that with COVID and the world not as flat as it was three or four years ago, doesn't take much for one supply chain to get messed up. And next thing you know, products such as toilet paper, which one would say, how are we short on toilet paper? Which by the way, this is the side I remember reading into that, trying to understand a bit more about the problem. And one of it was really around the fact that these toilet paper factories had a very, very fixed set of equipment that did commercial toilet paper for industries and businesses and residential toilet paper. And when we all went home and stopped going into the offices and shopping malls and movie theaters,
35:10 Speaker 04 the demand from commercial toilet paper consumer went out of balance. And that's why, and that's why the toilet paper thing came. And that's a simple.
35:18 Speaker 03 Did you listen to our episode with Willie Shi?
35:20 Speaker 04 I did not.
35:22 Speaker 03 He was on here. He told us the toilet paper thing and then we talked all about chip and LCD manufacturing. He's great. And he said they had too many SKUs. They were, they were selling too many kinds of toilet paper and he told them to reduce it and that solved all these sort of problems.
35:34 Speaker 04 Yeah, so that, so now, now think about a car, right? That needs all kinds of diodes and capacitors and resistors and thermal sensors.
35:44 Speaker 04 It's just not the fact that three nanometer is hard to get and a fab is hard to build. It's really all of it. And back to, you know, what's a little different this time is in that you can tell by the color of my hair. I've been in this industry a long, long time. I've been in bus cycles where people start putting the brakes on R and D. And they just slow projects down. They don't do new things. They stop innovating. I am not seeing that this time. And I think that is because the, the digitization of everything, the just super high demand for electronics products and how it changes our lives. There's just so much innovation going on. So we go back to, you know, what, what is our indicator of that? It's licensing, it's new design starts, and it's never been better for us.
36:28 Speaker 04 And it's broad, it's broad across all markets.
36:31 Speaker 03 One of the reasons that R and D is picking up the pace as much as it is, is what you're talking about, that the world isn't as flat anymore. Promise of globalization may be reconsidered broadly across the globe. Here in the United States, we just passed the CHIPS Act, really incentivizing chip manufacturing in the United States, really incentivizing all kinds of design investments in the United States. TSMC is building in the States. Intel just broke ground on the new fab in Ohio. Do you see that factoring into, okay, all these countries know we're heavily reliant on a handful of fabs that are in Taiwan. That's a geopolitically hot area. We need to move these critical dependencies into our countries. And is that something that you play a part in, or is that something you're just like watching from the sidelines?
37:16 Speaker 04 We're definitely involved in helping in the dialogue. So wherever we can help, talking to political officials in any country to amplify the need for this, we do. Because I think it's not just an arm issue, it's kind of an industry issue. A single point of failure for anything you're doing is, is, is not a good thing. And I think the world is, and again, COVID exposed a lot of things relative to people just having their eyes open and, oh my gosh, this is a real problem. And I give a lot of credit to folks who were, who are driving the CHIPS Act activity because I think it is very important. And by the way, very important, period. Not just very important in the United States, but 50 years from now, there should be world-class fabs in every continent.
38:01 Speaker 04 And we shouldn't have to be worried about geopolitical type of concerns for something that's just like oxygen for how the world operates.
38:11 Speaker 03 One of the realities of how the world operates now, though, is that the bleeding edge process nodes are mostly controlled by TSMC. It's 5 nanometers, 3 nanometers. They're way, way ahead of it. They're in control of it. That's theirs right now. Very few other people can compete on that level. And that is your smartphones. That is the bleeding edge of tech. The older process nodes, 40 nanometers, 14 nanometers, that go into cars and other things are deeply constrained, and no one's going to build those fabs anymore. That is not a good investment. How do you see that playing out? Right? You've got this tight constraint to TSMC at the bleeding edge. Everyone wants to build capacity there, but no one wants to build capacity for the old stuff. At the same time, all the governments in the world are like, we just need the capacity
38:55 Speaker 03 in our countries. What is the dynamic there that you see?
38:58 Speaker 04 You know, full disclosure, I'm not a manufacturing expert, but what I can tell you is what we see is a lot of work being done just relative to how you can transition certain fabs for new work, exactly as you said, right? Plowing a lot of money into N- minus 3 fabs. And people are usually going to be a bit averse for that. So you start to look at, can I convert fabs that we're building a certain process technology and move that to being a logic fab? Are there memory fabs that can be converted to logic fabs, et cetera? But it is, it is a very complicated problem, because there are only so many factories in the world, and so many people that know how to build these things. These companies are public companies. They have to make money. It's a very, very complex
39:39 Speaker 04 matrix. Very, very complex. If you think about Japan, 30 years ago, Japan was world-class and had the logic fabs all over the entire country. And that has essentially kind of weaned the way to almost, almost zero. So I think, you know, Japan is looking at ways to reinvent that and getting more fabs back online. So I think you'll see more of the Chips Act type of work that was done in the United States across other countries. Korea is mostly, you know, one fab, but I think also has a tremendous amount of capability. It is a complex, hairy problem, though.
40:11 Speaker 03 How dependent is ARM on TSMC? It feels like a lot of companies are recognizing that they are really, really dependent on one company, which is great, by the way. It's the industry leader for a reason, but there's a lot of dependency there. Do you think about that dependency as you're designing new processor types or architectures?
40:28 Speaker 04 We work really closely with TSMC. I would answer it by saying all fabs are important to us, going back to my Switzerland comment.
40:35 Speaker 03 There's your politician right there.
40:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, there's the politician, but seriously, they're all important. In an ideal world, we've got lots of people who can build all leading edge technology because our, generally speaking, in smartphones and certainly in the data center, that is usually on the leading edge processes because people are really trying to squeeze out the most performance that they can. Automotive and industrial, less so. So, any fab doing leading edge process is massively important to us.
41:05 Speaker 03 On the flip side, Intel famously was an integrated designer and fab company for the longest time. They got rocked by the TSMCs of the world, basically. They've got a new CEO, they're breaking that open, they're saying, okay, we're going to open our fab to other people. You just said Intel's a customer. Is that something you're working with them on? Okay, you're going to do fab services for other chipmakers. We've got ARM designs, you better be good at making ARM designs?
41:33 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'll bring my politician hat back on for a second. We'd love TSMC to be building lots of ARM products, which they do. We would love Intel to do the same.
41:41 Speaker 03 Are you optimistic about Intel being able to do that?
41:44 Speaker 04 I think Pat has done a lot of the right things. He has a hard job, but at the same time, I think he's done some very, very good work and we're very, very open to doing more with him.
41:53 Speaker 03 This is going to be another politician answer, but I got to ask it. On the Chips Act side, the bill passed, it got signed, everyone's excited. Intel immediately comes in for a lot of criticism because they announced they're cutting their capital expenditures and increasing their dividend instead of plowing it into fabs. Do you think broadly that's the right move? What kind of timeline should we be looking at for fabs in the United States?
42:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, gosh, I won't second guess Pat's decisions to how he spends his money, but back to the comment you made, we were talking about single point of failure. I think we need to move fast and get these facilities started as quickly as possible, have them online as quickly as possible, and build more redundancy and
42:38 Speaker 04 Less than the exposure to single point of failure. I think we need more fabs.
42:43 Speaker 03 We need to take a break, but when we come back, we're going to talk to Renee about making long-term bets.
42:53 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
43:03 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
43:11 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
43:24 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
43:57 Speaker 03 We're back. Just before the break, we were talking about the CHIPS Act and how it's going to be years before some of these new fabs come online. So I have to ask you, what kind of timelines do you make decisions on? It seems like, yeah, okay, a bill passes today or someone announces a new fab today, we're not going to see it for five years. Where do you think about your timeline of decisions?
44:18 Speaker 04 I tend to look that far out. I think the CEO job is in learning six months in. We have lots of responsibilities. I think for me, one of the biggest responsibilities I have is to be thinking about problems five years from now, both a function of the way our business model works. And the time that we design a product or the time we see revenue is quite long. So I think really thinking about where the opportunities are, where the investments need to be made, where the threats are, where is the puck going relative to system design, software design, setting the process, we think about those things all the time and we talk about them all the time. It's probably where I spend most of my mental energy, to be honest with you, is thinking about,
45:01 Speaker 04 what does the world look like in 2025 and 2026 as opposed to next quarter?
45:06 Speaker 03 There are some long-term bets there that are much more consumer than replacing the server in the trunk of a car. Maybe the hottest trend right now, as it pertains to ARM taking over things, is Apple shifted from Intel to ARM-based processors, their own M-series processors in Macs. That has been an enormous victory for them, right? They've increased the battery life, they've increased the performance. These are now basically the best laptops you can buy because of the chips in them. Is that something ARM can help the rest of the industry do? Or is that, well, here's the designs. Hopefully Qualcomm can make a chip that lets Microsoft and Dell do this as well. Like, where do you see that relationship to the industry from, from your perspective?
45:47 Speaker 04 I think there's more that we can do and probably will need to do going forward. And it's not so much because we need to help the industry, but these products are really, really complicated to build. And let's talk about the architectural license for a second. There was a belief at some point in time that I need to take an architectural license to build a better CPU to compete against ARM. The IPC, instruction per clock of a microprocessor, is only a micro fragment of what can really tip the design when you think about the memory subsystem, the interconnect, the size of the caches, how you interface into other parts of the SoC.
46:30 Speaker 04 Is the SoC in a multi-ship package where you've got die-to-die interconnect?
46:36 Speaker 04 And there are some customers that are really good at that stuff and can figure it out and don't need a lot of our help. But I think increasingly over time, there's going to be sections of the industry that will benefit greatly from ARM helping them and doing more. So it is an area that we we look at very, very closely because I think back to the opportunity going forward, you know, it's very, very clear that the demands of doing system on chips are just going to get harder and harder. And to get the kind of performance around the product that you just mentioned, it's going to be more than just, you know, throwing a thing over the wall and and hoping it works out.
47:15 Speaker 03 From your perspective, it kind of doesn't matter who wins as long as they're all ARM chips, right? If Apple takes 100% of laptop market share, that's great for you. If Microsoft and HP and Qualcomm can figure out a competitive Windows on ARM laptop and they take 50% of share, you still get paid. Does it just feel like no matter who wins, you win? Or is it, man, we got to get better at this because Intel is still taking a big chunk of the potential royalty pool from us?
47:43 Speaker 04 I think the way to think about it is if the products are shipping with the ARM ISA, it's a good thing for us. And if there's an alternative ISA being used, that means it's not using the ARM ISA, so less good for us. So we look to essentially, and I think when I was in my previous role, I had a little moniker under my name on the website that we did on the PR team that I helped with, that was basically said, wherever computing happens, ARM will be there. And I think wherever some level of compute is taking place, if ARM is there, and you would stand back and say, oh, it's a thermostat, or it's my microwave, or it's my Polycom, or my smart TV, or my laptop, or whatever it is. And then the second question is, yeah, that's ARM based? That's pretty good.
48:27 Speaker 03 Okay, but you just said wherever computing is happening. Where computing happens for most people is like their laptops and desktops. And I have heard about Windows on ARM for like 13 years, and it hasn't happened. Are you just content to let Apple eat the industry? Or are you saying we got to push on this because there's someone else's instruction set, namely Intel's, that is still dominating in that one extremely huge industry?
48:52 Speaker 04 We are very, very aware of that. Somebody just backing up for a second. I was at a previous company working on Windows RT. So back on your 13 year journey, I was the GM of that product line. I was with Nvidia before I joined ARM and that was my product line. So we've made massive progress on this and I think we're like the Borg that's not going to stop. I think the tipping point is really there. You know, Neil, the very first press interview I did on the Windows RT laptop, I remember meeting with a set of reporters. First question they asked me was, does it run iTunes? And we were like, gosh, SH, bang, bang, bang. No, it did
49:32 Speaker 04 not run. We did not. Yeah, did not. We didn't have a port and Apple wasn't helping us. But fast forward 10 years later, streaming audio is what's there. No one really cares about the apps. And if you think about all the apps that run on a PC that run on a mobile phone, it's kind of hard to say, okay, so what are the native apps that don't really run ARM? They're almost all there. So I think the PC thing, you know, stay tuned. We're like the Borg that's not going to stop. We're making great progress. You can see by the other ecosystems laptops what the capability is. I think that kind of was a wake up call to the industry in terms of what the capabilities potential might be and we're going to keep at it.
50:12 Speaker 03 But that wake up call is due to a very rich company spending a lot of money on a custom RIF on your instruction set, right? Like those are their chips. Are you saying we can, as ARM, develop products that are as efficient performance per watt wise as the M series chips and then we can sell those designs to Qualcomm? Or is it down to Qualcomm, which I believe also has an architectural license doing it themselves?
50:38 Speaker 04 I am very confident that the ARM implementations can deliver an extremely compelling performance per watt story. 100% confidence in that. You don't need an architectural license to let them do that.
50:49 Speaker 03 What's the timeline?
50:50 Speaker 04 I can't give you a timeline in terms of forward reaching stuff because again, my team of two lawyers would kill me. But
50:59 Speaker 03 I'm trying.
51:00 Speaker 04 Stay tuned. Your turn.
51:02 Speaker 03 I'm doing my best. That's the job. Your job is to dodge. My job is to keep coming.
51:06 Speaker 04 You're doing a good job.
51:09 Speaker 03 On the other side of that with, you know, with laptops, desktops, even with carmakers, right? I go and sit in a Rivian and I get told about the GPU and Unreal Engine driving the car. Like, graphics performance has become a key differentiator across this industry, across all kinds of products. You have had some GPUs in the past. You've got new GPUs. They've got a great name, Immortalis. Previously, they were called Mali. Apple's not using your GPUs. If you think about the big GPU vendors, they are not really thinking about performance per watt, right? And a high-end Nvidia card, you just need a nuclear reactor in the basements around that thing, and that's great. It looks great. How are you going to win in GPUs?
51:48 Speaker 04 We actually, we are the number one shipper of GPUs on the planet when you just go by units. So I remember, I remember that when we were in the Misty Nvidia acquisition, Jensen made a key point of that. We are going to stay true to our betting. We're performance per watt matters. We're not going to venture out and do 100-watt TDP GPUs and try to play in that space. We're going to be in the 1-watt-ish range and try to optimize in an envelope. And then there are areas where you could start to do more things in terms of multiple GPUs. What we're starting to see is people looking at doing machine learning extensions and potentially doing those kinds of things inside a GPU, which is kind of interesting because the GPU can benefit
52:30 Speaker 04 from some level of AI and machine learning to do shader drawing in a much more efficient way. And at the same time, maybe you can start to move ML workloads onto the GPU. So there is a lot of interesting innovation that is going to be able to take place on our GPUs, and we're investing heavily in that area. But to be clear, we're going to stay in an area where performance and efficiency matters.
52:51 Speaker 03 Yes, you ship a lot of GPUs. It's part of the SoC package for a lot of your customers. But the performance per watt from your customers that have their own GPUs or their own GPU extensions are ahead. Is that the same deal where it doesn't matter at the end of the day, they're shipping an ARM ISA and you're getting paid? Or is it, we've got to be competitive here because otherwise they'll just move off entirely?
53:14 Speaker 04 GPUs are a little different than CPUs because of the fact that the APIs are abstracted. So, performance per watt really, really does matter a lot. And we've done a lot to level the playing field. And with Immortals, I think we're now ahead in a number of areas. You know, the other thing that is very, very critical on these GPUs is efficiency in terms of the interface between the CPU and the GPU. So that's also an area that we're investing heavily in. But we have to be on our toes in the GPU market. There's no question about it. It's very, very competitive, as you said. You've got people doing your own and you've got other third parties doing products. But at the same time, it is an area we're very focused on and will invest in. Again, as I said, I think this machine learning, AI vector going on with GPUs in the future is a huge opportunity for us.
53:59 Speaker 03 GPUs are a big investment. You've got to spend a lot of money to compete. You've got to spend a lot of money to win the designs. Is that the sort of investment you're making because over time you're going to win those products back from the other custom GPUs and extract more of a rate? Or is it just to be competitive at all? We need to have competitive GPUs?
54:18 Speaker 04 It's a little bit more of the, again, I go back to machine learning and AI. If you have a heterogeneous compute system where you've got a CPU, a GPU, and an NPU, I think there will be a point in time where the compilers are going to be smart enough that they can potentially point parts of the code that could run better on a GPU versus a CPU. And if you think about the entire cluster as an entire subsystem, I think there is long-term benefit to that. So I think it for us, particularly in the system on chip, where you're trying to do all kinds of significant trade-offs to, I just don't want that workload to run on the CPU because it's going to be sucking up unnecessary power. I've got transistors in the GPU that I might be able to use if I'm not drawing.
55:04 Speaker 04 So we believe the GPU A is a pretty critical strategic component. And we think over time, it's going to be critical in the SoC for things other than just drawing triangles.
55:14 Speaker 03 Can you zoom out just a little bit? I feel like I can identify the GPU competitors. They're obvious in one way. One of them just tried to buy you. The CPU competitors are much harder, right? Like, who are your competitors just straight up that you think about?
55:27 Speaker 04 On the CPU side?
55:28 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:29 Speaker 04 Well, I think there's really probably only two choices. And biasly, I don't think even there are really choices. From an ISA standpoint, you have x86. But if you want to build an SoC on x86, there's only two companies in the world that will do that for you.
55:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:45 Speaker 04 You do AMD and or Intel. And then there's RISC-V, which is a completely different part of the stratosphere in that it's open source and lots of different versions exist. But the thing with RISC-V is that, two things. It's an extensible processor, which means its strength is its weakness, in my opinion, in that the extensibility will lead to fragmentation. That, I think, has hurt them in terms of getting any kind of software ecosystem. It's really kind of hard to look around and say, what is a major software ecosystem that runs consistently on a RISC-V processor? So where do we see RISC-V today? In a system on chip, in a deeply embedded part of the chip where the external programmer doesn't know it exists.
56:29 Speaker 04 An analogy I might give is you might put something in your microwave and hit start. The 30-second timer that displays probably ARM, because there might have been a little piece of open source application code that ran on it. The timer that actually turns on the oven and turns it off for 30 seconds, that's probably RISC-V. So those are really the only two options out there. It's just there's not a great deal. I mean, underneath all that are smaller companies, but those companies really haven't had much traction in markets here.
56:57 Speaker 03 Do you see a world in which ARM and RISC-V just completely obsolete x86?
57:03 Speaker 04 That's a hard, that's a hard thing to call, right? x86 has been around for a long time and has a, certainly has a very, very large installed base. I certainly wouldn't want to do anything to disparage what they're doing. I think the challenge with x86 is the fact it only comes from two companies. That in itself is a bit of a limiting factor in terms of how wide it can go.
57:23 Speaker 03 But even those two companies, right? Intel has its own fabs, AMD. There's TSMC once again. There is that other like manufacturing piece of the puzzle where it seems like those manufacturers over time are going to say, look, we're really good at ARM. We're going to get good at RISC-V. We don't want to be good at x86 anymore.
57:43 Speaker 04 And you argue that they're already really good at ARM, right? So yeah, it's going to get hard. There's no doubt about it. It's harder.
57:50 Speaker 03 Are there any other competitors on the horizon like RISC-V? I mean, RISC-V is another one of those things. It's like Windows on ARM. I've heard about it for a decade. And it seems like it's coming up in some of these applications they're talking about, but I just keep hearing about it. And it doesn't seem to be scaring you very much at all.
58:07 Speaker 04 Because it's all about software. At the end of it all, it's all about having a rich developer ecosystem that is able to just tap into writing software. And for us, we think there are 15, 20, 25 million developers who write on ARM. There are some that know they're writing on ARM because they take advantage of the instruction set. But there are others who don't because it's abstracted away. But the compilers and open source libraries are all there that it makes it just easy to run. Case in point, smart TV. If you're trying to write a new menu for a smart TV and trying to link into the version of Android that is essentially a kernel underneath, that's ARM. It's all
58:52 Speaker 04 been optimized for ARM. It's just a big advantage in terms of the software reporting. The libraries all exist. The optimizations have been done. And going back to the RISC-V thing, let's just say you tried out a RISC-V and company A added 17 new instructions to make their RISC-V thing look a little bit different. The developer's not going to know that. The developer, right? How is the developer going to take even advantage of that? So RISC-V probably ends up being reduced to the lowest common denominator.
59:19 Speaker 03 We had Qualcomm CEO Cristiano Aman on the show a couple of months ago. I asked him the same Windows and ARM question. He kind of pointed the blame at software developers, actually. He said, look, Microsoft, Adobe, the other big ISVs. They've got to get on board. They've got to make this stuff fast. You just said it's all about software. Do you spend time with those companies saying, look, you've got to shift your focus to the future, which is ARM?
59:44 Speaker 04 When you say those companies, the Microsoft of the world or the Adobe's of the world?
59:48 Speaker 03 Both.
59:49 Speaker 04 Yes. Yes, we spend a lot of time with both. And he's not wrong in that ultimately that is where the battle is to be won. I think it's much closer. And I know, like you said, you've been watching them for 10, 12 years as I have as well. It's much, much closer than it has been because what's happening is not, not only is a lot more work being done on the native apps, but a lot more of these native apps are already kind of being written for ARM. And just when you look at the, the two different OSs in the world, that other OS and then using their name and code, they use, you know, look at all the Microsoft apps that just run on, run on their system and they've all been ported that way. So all those Microsoft apps run on your phone. So we're not that far away.
1:00:32 Speaker 04 And I think when there's a lot of fairly good CPU products on the market that will be competitive with, with the other guy, I think the tipping point will be there. Cause to, to your point, what that product proved was two really important things. One was no compromise performance in a form factor with incredible battery life, game changing battery life.
1:00:54 Speaker 03 I know we're running out of time here. I always ask people what's next for their companies, but I'm going to ask you a more specific question. You announced that ARM would go public in March of 2023. That's coming right up. Are you still on track?
1:01:03 Speaker 04 Unfortunately, I just, not much I can say on it. We're in the part of the process now where I can't say much.
1:01:08 Speaker 03 All right, fine. What's next for ARM?
1:01:10 Speaker 04 We're going to keep investing in the areas that, that I had mentioned. We think there's really strong growth there, but some of the themes that we talked about earlier relative to these complex system on packages, more and more complex designs. We're looking really, really hard at the ability to do and provide more to the industry because I think there's a huge opportunity there.
1:01:30 Speaker 03 All right, Rene, thank you so much for coming on Decoder. We, we got to have you back. I want to do a full hour on Windows RT because I, I live through that from a very different perspective.
1:01:38 Speaker 04 That'll be PTSD for me.
1:01:39 Speaker 03 This was great. Thank you so much.
1:01:44 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Rene Haas for taking time to come on Decoder today, and thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of Decoder. You can email us at [email protected] or hit me up directly. I'm at Reckless on Twitter. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like Decoder, hit us with that five-star review. We really appreciate it. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott and was edited by Callie Wright. Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our senior audio director is Andrew Marino. Our editorial director is Brooke Minter, and our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
1:02:20 Speaker 06 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
1:02:51 Speaker 07 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card, even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous Can software simplify the supply chain? Ryan Petersen thinks so Next Pat Gelsinger came back to turn Intel around – here’s how it’s going Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated