Pod Insights Decoder Biometrics? Bring it on: Why Okta’s Jameeka Green Aaron wants passwords to go away About this episode Okta is a big company, a Wall Street SaaS darling. For most of us, it's the thing we have to log into 50 times a week just to get any work done. But from Okta's point of view, Jameeka Green Aaron told us, it's an identity company.
I spoke with Jameeka about what "identity" really means — in the digital space, in your real life, and at work — in 2023, and how an identity-based approach might be more or less secure than other approaches. I’m also gearing up to host Code in September (apply to attend here), and I’m thinking a lot about AI — very much a challenge for the future of security, even in a biometric-based era.
Links:
Apple IDs now support passkeys — if you’re on the iOS 17 or macOS Sonoma betas
How to use a passkey to sign in to your Google account
Windows 11 tests letting you sign in to websites with a fingerprint or face
Apple, Google, and Microsoft will soon implement passwordless sign-in on all major platforms
Microsoft called out for ‘blatantly negligent’ cybersecurity practices
Okta Faces Long Road Back
At Okta, CTO and CISO collaborate by design
Apply to attend the Code Conference
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Editorial Director is Brooke Minters and our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 14,795 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel. Editor in chief of The Virgin Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Jamaica Green-Aaron. She's the Chief Information Security Officer of Customer Identity at Okta. Now, Okta is a big company. It's a Wall Street software as a service darling. And it's also just the thing a lot of us have to log into at work 50 times a week to get anything done. So I was very curious to dig into the business of Okta's business. What is this company actually selling beyond just a login screen? Jamaica told me that Okta's point of view is that it's not just a security company. It's an identity company. So we talked a lot about the whole concept of identity and what that means in terms of computers in 2023.
1:51 Speaker 03 Is it your whole actual self? Is it a digital replica of your vital stats and permissions? Is it just what you need to log into at work? How does anyone define what it means to be a user of the internet in 2023? And how it relates to all the different technologies, tools, and systems we encounter as we go about our business online? And most importantly, how do you keep all of that secure? We also talked about what identity means in the offline world, some people might call the real world, and why that matters for the rest of us. There's a big push to tie our real world identities to our digital devices. And Jamika and I talked about the pros and cons of those ideas. I'm also getting ready to host the Code Conference in September, and AI is absolutely at the top of my mind.
2:35 Speaker 03 Cybersecurity is a big issue. Jamika told us that one of her real concerns about this new wave of AI tools is that they can move faster and they can disrupt security at the level of identity, making it harder to tell who's real. We can move a lot of identity to biometrics, but if AI can break biometric security systems, well, there's really no going back. A few notes before we start. Jamika and I talked about something called pass keys quite a bit. Pass keys are something that big companies like Apple, Google, and Microsoft are all signed on to as a biometric replacement for passwords. It's an industry standard. We'll put links in the show notes to the Verge stories explaining it all. But the basic idea is that you can sign into all of your accounts using your fingerprint or Face ID instead of a password. Google already supports it.
3:19 Speaker 03 Microsoft is testing it in Windows 11, and Apple will soon support it with the release of iOS 17 and macOS Sonoma. Jameeka and I also talked about the idea of keys and key management in general. At the most basic level, a key is what allows computers access to various systems. But once you have a big database with lots of users and complicated APIs, managing all of those keys becomes a big problem that affects everyone. And that's really very much the business that Okta is in. Lastly, you'll hear us refer to PII, which stands for Personally Identifiable Information. That means the data that's unique to you, like your name or your social security number, as opposed to more aggregate data, like what kinds of phones are accessing the system. PII being compromised is the stuff that security breaches are made of.
4:05 Speaker 03 This episode's pretty wonky, but I had a lot of fun talking to Jameeka, right up until she made fun of my iMac. Okay, Jameeka Green-Aaron, Chief Information Security Officer of Customer Identity at Okta. Here we go.
4:30 Speaker 03 Jameeka Green-Aaron, you are the Chief Information Security Officer, Customer Identity at Okta. Welcome to Decoder.
4:37 Speaker 04 Thank you for having me. This is cool. I've been listening and following you for a while, and you're a good interviewer, so I hope you go take it a little easy on me.
4:46 Speaker 03 The people who say that are usually the people who are most prepared. So get ready, because the OraTruck questions are coming. That's what we do here. Okta is a really interesting company. We use it here at Vox Media. It is a big company. It's a darling of Wall Street while we're talking today. Stock prices up. It's a big enterprise company. Everybody needs it. And then most people, as they experience it, it's the thing that comes in the way between the thing you want to use at work. So I want to log into Airtable at work. I gotta stop and use Okta and then check the two factors somewhere. And that's how most people experience Okta. So give people just a high-level view of the relationship between that, the thing they experience with Okta, and what Okta is as a business.
5:30 Speaker 04 So Okta as a business, we're about people, right? We're a technology company that's about people. Our goal is to enable everyone to safely log in anywhere they want to log in, essentially, safely use the internet and log in. And so when we think about what Okta really is, we're just a login box. In layman's terms, we're the login box. And we have, we're building a primary cloud for identity. Well, what does that really mean? Like, what is a primary cloud? So Salesforce is a primary cloud for CRM, or Workday is a primary cloud for HR. We are building a primary cloud using workforce identity and customer identity for identity. And so that's what we're trying to do, or that's what
6:14 Speaker 04 we're doing at Okta. And we touch people everywhere that they are. So yes, you see them at work, but what people don't realize is that you also interact with us on the consumer side. When you're logging into your banking application, or when you go to a baseball stadium, you are also interacting with the login process of Okta. And that's what we do.
6:34 Speaker 03 Web applications, I really think of all computer stuff as a series of modules, right? So I log into a bank, they need a database vendor and a web design company. And you're saying even through that, even through just logging in, you're the vendor that supplies secure logging into a bunch of people that need secure login. And then you can go and use your application. Is that where it ends for you or are you trying to go beyond that?
6:57 Speaker 04 Well, that's where it begins for us. We absolutely are trying to go beyond that because I think to take your example, when you log into a bank, you don't just log in. You log in and you're prompted for additional factors, some multi-factor authentication. So you're prompted either with a one-time PIN, a password, additional password. You're prompted with a social login or some other way to verify you. And so we are not just the login box. We're not just securing the login box. We're trying to blend the user experience into the login box. So there's that. I think there are other new technologies that are coming out and that are changing that are also going to change what we do. Like the way we protect personally identifiable information. And so we are now a part of that as well. And so I wouldn't say that that's where we end.
7:40 Speaker 04 I'd say we are the beginning of the process. We're trying to change the way people think about passwords and the way they think about how they log in. And that's hard because the password is deeply ingrained into society. As long as we've known computers, we've known there's a username and password. And we're now saying, hey, let's move beyond that. Let's get beyond that. Let's go into pass keys. Let's go into pass phrases. Let's go passwordless. And so we're thinking about all the ways in which we can do that securely, but also in a way that people will actually use the technology to keep themselves safe.
8:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, I want to talk about pass keys in particular. That seems like a big trend that's coming and Apple and Google are into it. Microsoft's into it. But I want to stay focused on Okta for just a second here. When you think about that problem space, we want to make identity and logging in better. That's a big problem, right? And it ties into a bunch of social factors. It ties into how people want to use the internet. It ties into the very notion of whether you should be the same person everywhere on the internet or different versions of yourself on different platforms. Does Okta have a view there or are you more, okay, we're for you at work. We're for you when you interact with the business.
8:54 Speaker 04 No, I think we have a perspective that the digital identity is important. From that perspective, when we think about digital identities, we want you to own your actual digital identity. I think that's the most important thing when we think about people and technology. I want Nele to own all the versions of Nele on the internet. And I want the threat actors not to own any of those versions. And so when we think about our trajectory as a cloud identity company or as a primary cloud for identity, we are thinking about how can we make it so that wherever you are, you actually own your true identity. And that's a really big problem space and it's hard. Because you have to think about passports, about driver's license and things that you physically hold
9:39 Speaker 04 that also can eventually relay into your digital identity. We're seeing some of that interplay now, right? You see your, your physical identities be scanned into digital platforms and verified that way. But ultimately, we want this to be a seamless process where who you are in real life and your digital identity align and they are both protected. And so Okta has the problem space of trying to innovate in a way that we can protect both of those identities at the same time.
10:07 Speaker 03 I hear that. That's the big vision. And I've heard that from a lot of companies over a long period of time. And then it kind of runs into reality for me, which is, boy, maybe I don't want my driver's license on my phone. Like, this is like a very practical thing that big phone companies would like me to do. Apple would love me to put my driver's license on my phone. Probably because they just want me to use their credit card, right? Like, throw away your wallet entirely.
10:31 Speaker 04 They want you to use your digital wallet.
10:33 Speaker 03 Right. Now, now use Apple Pay. We'll take some. Like, it's very transparent what's happening there, but they gotta get my driver's license on the iPhone for that to happen. And then I think I would never in a million years hand my phone to a cop. Like, just it, it's not gonna happen. Like, I need a warrant. You gotta show me a warrant before I hand my phone to a cop. But if I get pulled over and I drive too fast and I get pulled over, like, the first thing they ask for your divorce is to hand me their driver's license. As a business, Okta has a vision. That vision probably extends all the way to your state-issued ID should be digital in some way. And then there's the practical reality of a bunch of people are never gonna hand their phone to a cop. Like, is there an interplay there?
11:10 Speaker 04 But do you not have to hand your phone to a cop? That's the question. Do you actually have to hand your phone to a cop?
11:16 Speaker 03 I think if a cop has an excuse for me to give them the phone, they will take it.
11:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think so. In my, in my mind, when I think about a digital identity, I would not want to hand my phone to a cop here. So I agree with you there. I agree with that sentiment. But at the same time, you know, we don't hand our credit cards over now when we pay, when we swipe to pay. And so in my, when I think about just me, Shamika, the future of digital identity, I'm pulled over and I'm in my car. I'm driving my car. Let's give that example. And my driver's license is not only tied to my registration in my car. So when, when I'm pulled over and my license plate is run, there's, there's information that's given to a police officer says, this is Shamika's, Aaron's car, and this is her driver's license, and this is what she looks like. And so when they, they see me,
12:04 Speaker 04 they go, oh, we already have some of her information. Or we're using technologies like NFZ to actually transmit that information over to them. So I don't expect to hand over anything else anymore, essentially. I expect that when we think about the future of digital identity, I don't think people are quite ready to part with anything physical, and that's fair. There's the physical identities that we have, but then there's our ability to transmit that identity to those who need it for specific reasons. And I think it goes beyond that, right? It's not just transmit my identity, everything on it, my you, my name, my address, my social security number. It's, hey, in this particular case, all you need to know is my name and if I have a valid driver's license.
12:43 Speaker 05 Yeah.
12:44 Speaker 04 And so I think that when I think about the future of digital identity, I'm transmitting my name and the fact that I have a valid driver's license over to a police officer in a wireless way. And that's all they really need to verify at that point is, does she, is she who she says she is? She, here's her photo, and she has a valid driver's license. I think that's the future of identity. And I also think that that allows the consumer the ability to control what data is provided and where. And when you think about digital identity, that to me is what we should be thinking about. Right now, we don't have a lot of control over the information that we provide to anyone. If you go through the airport and they scan your driver's license or your passport,
13:26 Speaker 04 you don't actually really know what information is being garnered in that particular case. Future of digital identity is one that consumer controls, where the consumer decides which information is actually needed and do I want to provide that information? If I'm buying a drink and all you need is my name and am I old enough to drink? Then all I'm sending you is my name potentially, or maybe not even that. Maybe I'm just sending you information that I'm old enough to drink and yes, you can serve this to me. And so I think when we think about the larger world of digital identities, it's really one where the consumer decides. And that's, I think, what's important to to Okta. We're thinking about how do we put this back into the consumer's hands and give them choice while also keeping them safe.
14:06 Speaker 03 And that to you is there's one unified identity that I control, right? It's I have an identity and I'm picking and choosing what comes out of that database of.
14:15 Speaker 04 Absolutely. It's yours. It belongs to you. Correct.
14:17 Speaker 03 How do you go from a bunch of people have Okta accounts at their workplace with the name of their company in the login screen? To everyone has a unified Okta account that interfaces with everything from local bars to cops.
14:31 Speaker 04 Number one, I think public partnership is going to be critical to that. I think that, and that's not something that we're totally good at yet. The fact that we have state driver's license tells us that we're not good at unifying the identity space just yet. And we totally have the capability to just have a driver's license, right?
14:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's not the political will in this country to do that is does not exist.
14:52 Speaker 04 It's it's nil, right? But that's what it's going to take, right? It's going to take that level of unification, not just across states, but across companies. And one of the things that we kind of pride ourselves on is neutrality. We've decided that we're not going to pick. We're going to work across many platforms, across various platforms, thousands of partners, thousands of ways that we're connecting different infrastructures. That is what Okta is trying to do. Our goal is neutrality. And I think us choosing neutrality in some cases, it's it's everyone wants you to pick a side. And I think we have, we've picked the side of neutrality and the side of our customers and our consumers. On the flip side of that, Okta's not just workforce identity. My job is actually in the customer identity space. So it's the login box for everything else when you're not at work.
15:36 Speaker 04 And so we have a unique, you know, we have unique insight and unique data into how people. People actually move around and one of the things that we have to do is identity proof all the time. And when you when you think about identity proofing, it's hey, Tramika's got two email addresses and she signed into this account and is this the same one? And if it is, let's merge those together. And so I think that's the other space where we really have the opportunity to innovate because we can identity proof and we can go, both of these are Neelam. This is him. We know it's him. We know these are his two email addresses. And so when you think about putting that together in a larger identity space, we've got the ability to verify you at work. When you go to work, there are lots of verifications that happen and say, yes, you can work, you pay taxes,
16:19 Speaker 04 those things. And then we also have the ability to identify you in the consumer space. Now, our two products right now are totally separate, but what they offer us the data and the opportunity to do is look at people, how they move around and and put together the ideas of what digital identity will look like and how it will work. And so we're still working on that. We haven't solved the problem yet, but we understand that there's this wide problem space and we have a lot of data to be able to solve it.
16:47 Speaker 03 You mentioned neutrality. Do you think the solution is that Okta maintains a neutral, centralized database of identity and everyone picks and chooses from it? And then we all trust Okta to keep that database secure? Because that seems like a rich target in the end.
17:01 Speaker 04 I mean, I'm a CISO, so.
17:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's why I'm asking you. I think like this has to keep you up at night like, oh, I'm building the greatest honeypot known to man.
17:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, I never, I never think that it's the best thing to do to trust one place to do everything because hackers know that and they are good at what they do. And no, I don't think that you should just trust Okta. I think that what I think that the technology that we're building and what we're thinking about, you should trust the ideas that we have and the perspective that we have on the identity space. I don't think that that database will be sitting solely with Okta. I think it will be decentralized. But what I do think is that when I talk about public-private partnership, I do think there's an opportunity to say for Okta to say, hey, you know, US passport agency, we would like the opportunity. Opportunity to partner with you on digital identities and how we create the next space for
17:54 Speaker 04 digital identities. So I don't think that it's a good idea to have any amount of data, specifically PII data, because ultimately, identity-based attacks are still the number one attack, and they are effective. And so I don't think it's a good idea to have that data sitting in anyone's face. But I do think that the opportunity for partnerships sits there for us to to look at spaces and databases and really connect and figure out how do we keep those safe while also having the ability to transfer information and share information.
18:24 Speaker 03 A couple more questions about Okta, then I want to get into the decoder questions and how you operate instead of Okta. Really basic here. Who are Okta's competitors? When you have the big C-suite meeting, who's on the list? Like, we got to beat XYZ companies. Who are your competitors?
18:39 Speaker 04 We have no competitors. I'm just kidding. I mean, of course, Microsoft, Ping, OneLogIn. Those are some of the ones that come up pretty frequently. I think what's what's unique about Okta is that we are a cloud identity company, and that's what we do. That is our space, and we are, again, powered by neutrality. But we are not an on-prem company. That's not what we do. That's not in the stars for us. And we're really focused on the cloud identity space. And so that's why when I said, hey, we're building the identity cloud of the future, that's the space that we're ferociously focused on. There are not other lanes that we're trying to get into.
19:17 Speaker 03 You're not going to put out the Okta internet appliance that I can install in my my small business tech office? Microsoft is a huge competitor in many ways, right? They are on on-prem. They've had Active Directory for what seems like a billion years. For one minute, it seemed like a monopoly provider of identity services to big companies. They're under fire right now. We had Adam Slipsky from AWS on the show. He's like, Microsoft's security practices are horrible. He wouldn't say their name, but he He was like that company that starts with an N. Uh, other cloud providers are saying Microsoft has problems. They just had a breach. Is your pitch fundamentally the cloud is more secure? Or is it we're more secure than those guys?
19:58 Speaker 04 I am a firm believer in not trashing other companies because your day's coming. Um, and that's, that's me, the CISO speaking. I'm like, listen, everyone has their day on the front page of, of the Wall Street Journal. Um, and so we've had our day as well. And so I think that that's something that I just tried out to do. What I will say is that we work with Microsoft. We work with, it was on, we work with all of these companies, um, in various capacities, either because we're users of them also, but also because we're neutral. And so our, our goal is not necessarily to put other companies out of business. Our goal is to make the best experience for our customers. And so when we think about workforce identity, we're not just multi-factor authentication. We're single sign-on. We have partnerships.
20:42 Speaker 04 We have 15,000 partnerships and connections to, um, various partners to allow you to do your work securely. And so I wouldn't say that we are better than them in, in the capacity of we're more secure. I would say that we offer more options available to you. We, we are not trying to put you in the Okta ecosystem. We're saying, figure out what ecosystem works best for you and Okta will work with that ecosystem. Um, and it doesn't matter what company you are. And we're, we're, we're pushing very heavily on our partners to really create the space where it's frictionless for the users. Because once the users start abandoning our processes, it doesn't matter how secure you are. If the user abandons the process, you're going to get hit with an attack.
21:24 Speaker 04 And so, and, and again, because we are aware that identity-based attacks are, are number one, we're thinking about that because we're there. We're the identity provider for so many. I don't think of it in terms of who the competitors are, what we do better. I think of it in terms of our neutrality makes us strong, um, because it allows you to think about your seam and your source systems. It allows you to, um, integrate threat modeling. It allows you to look at our data, integrate our data and our threat intelligence into your model. So we're wide open. We're saying, hey, use whatever you would like, but also use multi-factor authentication. Use fishing resistant, use fishing resistant factors. Like really make sure that you're building an ecosystem that is secure.
22:07 Speaker 04 We're not necessarily saying choose a product, but if, if I had to say choose a product, I'd say, hey, choose us.
22:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, let me run at this slightly different way. There are these phrases that everybody uses. Security by design, privacy by design, innovate, make sure you build security in the beginning. Sort of every company uses these phrases. As you look at the breaches Microsoft has had recently, right? Some keys were leaked. They, I think they provide the Commerce Department with email. The Commerce Department email was like, these are huge breaches at Microsoft. What are you learning as a CISO at Okta from those about your own processes and about places where the attack surfaces might have been different than what you had assumed?
22:47 Speaker 04 When I look at some of what's happening just in general in this space, and key management is a challenge for everyone. You know, every, every company, every CISO that I talk to, key management is a huge challenge. I am an absolute fan of, of security by design. It is a practice that we employ implicitly within Okta's Customer Identity Cloud. It is a practice that takes co-conspiratorship of your CISO, your Chief Product Officer, your Chief Technology Officer. And one of the things that you have to build in your software development life cycle is key management and key storage and really flesh that out. And we have had to learn some hard lessons as well around this space.
23:30 Speaker 04 And so when I think, I think about it, we're just not there yet because the technology has moved very rapidly. We've all moved into the cloud very rapidly. I think that was the right thing to do, but sometimes security doesn't catch up. And now we're playing this catch-up game where we're trying to figure out how do we manage 40, 50, 60,000 keys in a space that all of our developers have access to and that they're writing code with, they're embedding them in many cases, they're in our GitHub repositories, they're everywhere, keys are everywhere. And so in this particular space, this is one that we all have to go take a look at, take a step back and go, we need to do a better job with key management. And what does that mean? It means, is it built into the products that you're using? Is it built into the clouds that you're using? Are you using a third-party key management system?
24:15 Speaker 04 And even within that space, when you think about keys and secrets and, and paths, these are all things that mean various things throughout this. ...for development lifecycle. And so ultimately, when you think about secure by design, this is one of the issues that we're going to have to tackle. Well, when do you tackle it and how do you tackle it when you've already got this architecture in place or you've got this stack in place? That's the bigger question, and that's where I think many industries are getting hit is because they they understand that they have a problem. They're working to solve the problem of key management, but they haven't gotten there yet because you still have a stack that's in place that didn't take that into account. And so this is where secure by design becomes critical because you build key management into the into your stack. And then it's always managed.
25:00 Speaker 04 And I think it's one that we struggle with. It's one that we're going to continue to struggle with. One of my people put it this way, it's an arms race. It is. This is one that we're going to have to get after because the ability to to pick up our keys, especially when they're hardcoded, when a hacker gets a hold of them, they have the keys, so they can get in and you won't be able to detect them.
25:18 Speaker 03 Right. Because they're using a real credential.
25:20 Speaker 04 They're using a real credential that belongs to you. It is yours, and now it is out there in the wild, wild west. And so this is a big deal, and it is unfortunate, but it's going to keep happening until we actually start to practice secure by design.
25:33 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break, but we'll be back in a minute to talk about what a pass key is and why it matters.
25:45 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard confessions.
25:54 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
26:01 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
26:44 Speaker 03 We're back with Okta's Jamaica Green Aaron, talking about what pass keys are and how to manage them.
26:50 Speaker 03 It seems like keys are a really big issue in security, especially when you're building software products and software businesses. Explain very quickly what you mean by a key and why they're important to protect.
27:01 Speaker 04 So a key is essentially a password that a machine uses. When systems are talking to each other, there is a need to protect the information and the data, and also to verify or authenticate that the information, the data is coming from trusted sources. So when you think about a key, a key is essentially a password that a machine or that an API might use to verify that it is who it says it is and it does what it's supposed to do. And that's the really simple, short version of what it is. We use them all the time as our systems talk or our containers talk to each other, or as they're passing data, there is a key that happens or that is exchanged in the process of that conversation. In many cases, there's key pairs, there's one key, there's a public key, there's a private key.
27:46 Speaker 04 There are all kinds of keys that look like that, but essentially they're passwords. They are a key to a door. You have a front door, it has a key to it. We have a front door, a back door, a side door, and 42 windows, they all have keys to them, and they all have different keys. And essentially, we will, in many cases, we will build our software to have those keys as a part of the software. So they're hardcoded into the software. We have to rotate them sometimes because we get broken into, they expire, you change neighborhoods or you change doors and you rotate keys. Essentially, when that key is compromised or someone who isn't supposed to have that key now has it, they can open all the doors.
28:28 Speaker 04 That's the problem space that we're in now. Key rotation is another big part of the key management process. And so in many cases, keys live in your software for a very long time or forever, and you have to go and find them and rotate them. And so that's the other part of the space. You need to rotate your keys and you need to manage your keychains. If you do neither, someone else will end up with your keys, they'll end up with your keychain, they'll end up with old keys and they'll go and they'll start unlocking doors. And when they do that, they have full access to your environment, depending on what those keys do.
28:58 Speaker 03 So let's say I'm a small business owner, I'm small startup making a piece of software. I'm like, look, I need a secure login. I'm going to hire Okta. Does Okta come in and say, we're also going to audit your key management in your software? Or do you come in and say, we're going to do this for you?
29:15 Speaker 04 This is where Okta is, it becomes super important. We do this for you. Essentially, when you think, let's put the keys back into, in the phrase of passwords, we are going to help you manage this so that you don't have to do it yourself. And Okta works with tons of startups. We have Auth0 for startups. We have free versions for small businesses. And this is really honestly, a big part of what I've been doing these last couple of years is talking to small businesses, talking to our NGOs, talking to spaces where they don't think they need to do identity management because they're not big enough for that. There's no size. If you have one employee, you should be thinking about this. If you have 10, you should be thinking about this. And so Okta is coming in and saying, don't try to do this yourself. Don't try to do identity yourself. Let us build it for you.
30:00 Speaker 04 Whether that's workforce identity with multi-factor authentication and single sign-on and fast pass, which is, allows you to go passwordless, or it's on the customer identity side where we're saying, you've got a login box that's facing the internet and you need some extra security. You need captcha, you need SMS, you need social logins, you need something else that's going to add an additional factor of protection. And so we're saying, don't build it yourself. Let us do this piece for you, the identity piece.
30:29 Speaker 03 And then inside of that, like I said, Okta's a darling of Wall Street. How do y'all make money?
30:34 Speaker 04 Um, how do we make money?
30:39 Speaker 04 I mean, that's it. That's kind of a, I mean, I guess it's not a tough question, but we essentially, we make money by protecting login.
30:46 Speaker 03 Like, do you get a nickel every time I log into work?
30:49 Speaker 04 Something like that.
30:51 Speaker 03 It's that simple. It's like, just every time. Because then I gotta keep my computer logged in a way, a lot more than I
30:58 Speaker 04 Well, it's based on the number workforce side. It's based on a number of employees. Okay, sure. It's not every time you log in. It's based on licensing and a number of employees. I'm it's based on it may use. And so it's based on a number of users. And this brings actually up another point, particularly on the consumer side. Because in the workforce, you know, I have 10,000 employees. I need 10,000 Okta accounts, right? The consumer side, not so. Yeah. And you, you don't have any employees. You have consumers. And this is also where we're saying, don't build this yourself because it's going to cost you more. So in many cases, there are, you know, consumer logins are incentivized. Log in and you will get some miles. Sign up and you will get 10% off.
31:41 Speaker 04 And ultimately, you are thinking about, you know, trying to get valid customers to sign up. Well, this is where the attackers come in. Yeah. They want those miles. They want those, those 10% offs over and over and over again. And so they're going to populate your space with fake logins and fake identities. And so this is the other thing that we do on the consumer side is we're, we're really trying to help companies make sure that those identities that are logging in are real identity and they're not bots. And they're not folks that are trying to take advantage of rewards programs. Because when that happens, when you have millions of false logins, not only are you taking up, you know, cloud computing space, which is costly, you also are not make, you're not going to be able to make any money. You're not going to be able to advertise. You're not going to be able, because these are not valid shoppers. These are not valid consumers.
32:26 Speaker 04 And so on the consumer side, we're really thinking, and I talked about identity proofing a little bit. This is where identity proofing comes in. We're thinking about, or we're working to resolve the problem of fake users, bots signing up, taking advantage of programs. We're going through, we're looking at databases and making sure that login credentials are valid. We're kicking out invalid login credentials. We're also going through, we have the capability of automatically resetting passwords of compromised credentials. And so when you ask kind of what we do, I guess I didn't dive into everything that we do. But we're, we are using lots of technologies to help us make sure that your consumers are your actual consumers that you want. Now, this is great for me as a CISO, but it's also great for our marketing teams.
33:08 Speaker 04 Our CMOs are thinking about omni-channel operations and they're thinking about, I want to make sure that Nilei gets this new shoe. And I want to make sure that he actually gets it and he gets the code and he is a valued customer of ours. And so a part of our job is to make sure your identity is protected, but also for the businesses that you actually utilize, they understand who you are, they are looking at real metrics about you that it's really your login. And so that's the other side of it. And so it's both for us. It's both the consumer and the workforce.
33:41 Speaker 03 I want to come back to that, but you've led me kind of directly into the big decoder question. Okta's a lot of things, right? There's a big enterprise part of it. There's a consumer part, which you're a part of. Then there's sales. How is Okta structured? How does the company work?
33:56 Speaker 04 So we have 18,000 customers. We have 6,000 employees and we're structured into our two primary clouds. So essentially, kind of how I've been talking about it, that's how we're structured. We have our CEO, Todd McKinnon, and then we're structured into our two primary clouds, our workforce identity cloud, which is focused specifically around workforce logins and employees, and then our customer identity cloud, which is focused around consumer internet, consumer apps, SaaS apps, internet placing applications. And then we have teams that support each of those primary clouds.
34:27 Speaker 03 And then there's the other big decoder question, which is always very interesting to ask security people, because the trade-offs around decisions when your focus is security is very different. How do you make decisions? How do you influence what the company does?
34:40 Speaker 04 I'm a product CISO, and this is my first time being a product CISO. And so it's, over my 25 years, it's changed. I would say when I first started in industry, I was hardcore security. There is no trade-off. It has to be secure and as little risk as possible, very risk averse. Now that I'm a product CISO, and our product is security, security has to be a business enabler. I have the unique position of not only being the CISO of CIC, but also of being the chief tester of products. I get to really look at some of our products. So when I first landed at the company, we were thinking about a product called Security Center. That product is now in GA, but we were thinking about it. They came to me and said, hey, would you like to have this?
35:22 Speaker 04 And I was like, hell, yes, this is a dashboard that gives me all of the data around bots, around credential stuffing attacks. And this is something that I would love to see so that I can actually make good decisions around security. So let me give you an example. We have the ability through Security Center to tell you if an influx of activity is actually consumers trying to log in because you maybe have a new product launch, like a sneaker, or if it's bots that are actually attacking you to take advantage of that new product. And then with that, you can turn our controls up and down. You can turn on advanced attack protection. You can turn on bot protection. And so for me, I was so excited about the product that I leaked it accidentally
36:03 Speaker 04 a bunch of times because I wanted to talk about it. I wanted to share it and I wanted other CISOs to see it. So for me as a CISO, this is like the best place to work ever because I get to really see how our products are going to impact my own peers. And I get to understand if they're going to be helpful, not just from talking to my peers, but from actually testing the products out myself. And so it's a really interesting role. It's very different than all the other roles I've had because my previous roles were specifically about protecting our intellectual property, protecting the crown jewel. This job is different. This job is about making security a business enabler, using the knowledge that I have of this industry to create better products for Okta and to create better products for our consumers, but also for our CISOs.
36:48 Speaker 04 And so we've got, you know, threat intelligence or threat insights coming out where it allows us to really seed information from our systems, which we see billions of logins every day. We get to see the real ones and the fake ones. So it allows us to share information and intel. The other thing about this role that I think has been fun and unique is that I am a fan of sharing information with other CISOs. We are so secretive, oftentimes because we just can't share. Our companies don't really want to share the details around cyber attacks, but ultimately, CISOs, I think, are a trusted community where we can share information because we're all fighting the same adversaries. And one of the things that the adversaries have on their side is That they share information. They go, I did this. This attack was effective and you try it now.
37:33 Speaker 04 We're not doing that. And I think we have to get so much better at it. And so one of the things that I get to do is share information about what kinds of attacks I'm seeing in real time with the community so that they can do something about it. And so for me, very different roles. Security is a business enabler now, but it's not just a business enabler to me. It's a business enabler to marketing, to our product officers, really, really helping them to understand how what they're doing in this space can change and uplift the entire community.
38:00 Speaker 03 There's a tension that you're identifying there and I kind of want to just push on it a little bit more. In your previous roles and other security folks I've talked to, a lot of their decision-making is about, okay, the company wants to go fast, but I need the company to go slower and button up and protect those crown jewels and make sure that we are not introducing new kinds of vulnerability, that we're thinking it through from a security perspective before we rush out to market. It sounds like you are in a different role now where you're selling the security to the market and you're able to act differently. How has that changed your decision-making process?
38:32 Speaker 04 So it's both, right? I am selling security, but I also am still the CISO of a line of business. And so we talked a little bit earlier about secure by design. I am hardcore about it. What I've had to do is really change my relationships internally with my counterparts. So my CTO, she's my co-conspirator. And we spend a lot of time together thinking about secure but by design and also thinking about the software development lifecycle and how we can build security into that. It makes my job easier on the backend because when there's a vulnerability, we are already thinking about, we don't just patch them. We roll out a new version of our product where the vulnerability is resolved.
39:14 Speaker 04 And so that's one piece of it that I get to impress upon the software development lifecycle that security should be built into it. So that's really my primary job is to to reduce risk as much as I can. The other side of it is while we're doing that, I'm also thinking about the final product and the ways in which that product can be helpful to a CISO. And so it's both, right? It's yes, I'm selling.
39:37 Speaker 04 Selling a product and yes, it's a security product, but I get this unique perspective on all the entire process. I'm from start to finish when we start ideating around what's next. I'm sitting at the table saying, I don't think that that's going to be what CISOs want, but let me go ask them. You know, or, or they actually, they, they will tell you, you know, obviously CISOs are vocal people. They'll share with you unsolicited, uh, this is what I want to see next. Uh, this is what I need from you. And so I get to be their voice in the process. Um, but I also get to see those outcomes. And so it's a very different kind of job in that security is not just there to reduce risk. I still have the standard teams, governance, risk, compliance,
40:18 Speaker 04 detection and response. We have platform and product security. So all of those teams still exist. Um, and they're still there and we still have our primary job, but I think we all are challenged with this really higher level of thinking about security and we're thinking about it from the consumer perspective as well. How do we create a product where a consumer can log in and it's frictionless or as frictionless as it can possibly be? Because ultimately they're our first line of defense. And so we're thinking about the entire process all the way through to the consumer. It's a very different role.
40:50 Speaker 03 Let's talk about that process because we are in a time of change for security right now. Probably in a few weeks, iOS 17 is coming along with the new iPhone. Apple's already previewed it. They're pushing into pass keys. Google said they're going to do pass keys. Microsoft has said they're going to do pass keys. This is a big change that's coming. Describe to listeners what's going on with pass keys and how you think it's going to change the experience of identity on the internet.
41:16 Speaker 04 I talked a little bit about friction and I think that ultimately what pass keys allow us to do is remove some of the friction from the login process. And in many cases, we've experienced pass keys already. Um, and we're just not completely aware of it because the process is very smooth. If you are using your mobile device in any capacity to log into something, there is likely a pass key involved. Most likely with your bank. Banks are really good and really forward leaning in terms of protecting the login space. Why is this important? Because everyone's on board. And the reason that everyone's on board is because we feel like this is the right way to go. This is the way that we need to drive in the industry. Well, why do we think that?
41:58 Speaker 04 Because the consumer ultimately decides how in the ways in which our products will work and if they're successful or not. Pass keys make it very easy to log into things. And they remove so much friction from the login process. What is friction? Because I've said it a bunch of times, but I've not actually talked about what is friction. Anytime you have to stop and think about something else in the login process, it's friction. So I'll give you an example. You're going to a website, you've put in your username and passwords. It says, we don't think this is you. We're going to send you an email. Now you've got to go to your email. That's friction. Or, you know, captcha pops up and it's maybe it's not the greatest captcha. And you can't really figure out how to get through it and you can't.
42:38 Speaker 03 At this point, I assume every captcha is me training an AI modeling system somewhere. I'm like, I'm just contributing to some, some AI model somewhere. I've identified all the crosswalks in America at this point.
42:50 Speaker 04 All the motorcycles, all the stoplights. So pass keys are the next version of, of our ability to log in without friction. They are critical and they are secure. And that's the other thing. And so when you see massive amounts of industry and you're in this industry with us, moving in one direction. It's because we feel like, you know, universally, it's the right direction to move in. Would I love to say that Okta spearheaded that? Yes, but I think it's a mutual agreement amongst all of us that, that safety and security of the consumer is of our utmost importance. And so that's why we're headed in that way.
43:24 Speaker 03 So the consumer experience of the pass key is I've got my phone. My phone authorizes me usually with some biometrics in every example that I've seen. Touch ID, Face ID, whatever. Now my phone knows it's me. And now all logins are handled everywhere because my phone is off to me. Is that how you see it playing out? Because I see a bunch of big companies saying, ah, we want you to, we still want our employees to log in.
43:48 Speaker 04 I think that that is how I see it playing out and the reason for that is that like people, it's not because of the technology, it's honestly because people hold on to their cellphones with the death grip.
44:00 Speaker 04 If you lose yourself, this is just my own perspective from just watching humans do humanity things. If you lose your cellphone, you lose your mind. You want to find it, you've got a tracker on it, you've got a way to embrace it. So the pass key takes advantage of something that we're already doing naturally. And I think that's why it's going to be more successful. We already are building biometrics, they're not our building, they're there. We're already building this additional vector of authentication into the capability of every cellphone. And we're so serious about holding on to our cellphones, having them near us. You know, most cellphones, even when you sleep, when you, you know, you wake up in the morning, you go straight. And so I think we're thinking about the way the world is actually moving and going. We need to build the technologies that people are really using.
44:45 Speaker 04 We don't want to come out with something new and force people to do it because they're still holding on ferociously to the username and password. And what we've done is iterated, pass keys are an iteration upon that. I love using biometrics, it's one of my favorite things to use. And in many cases, if a login box pops up and that's not an option, I am like, I don't even want to do this. I don't even, if I can't turn it on, but it also is predicated on building a login process that has FIDO2 technologies. Web often, you can't use these new technologies if you've not built those into your stack. And so there are some things that we still need to do to get to the place where everyone can use pass keys. But I do think it's the way of the future and I think it's the right thing to do. Biometrics are insanely secure. There's, you know, there's only one version of Jamaica's face.
45:30 Speaker 04 I think we still have a ways to go around biometrics ability to detect people. I'm a black woman and so I, you know, in many cases, biometrics has failed me. I don't use facial recognition, but I do use, I do use my fingerprint pretty often. And I don't use it because it doesn't work for me. The models have not been trained enough with diversity in mind to get there. But we are going to get there. I do think we're going to get there. And so I think when we think about the future with pass keys and with all of these different ways that we can use pass keys and we can access them. Yes, it's the way of the future. Yes, it's going to happen and we're all going to march in that direction. And people are going to, I think, when they realize it, they're going to like it. I just got my mom, it was her birthday two days ago, it was my mother-in-law's birthday, we got her a new iPhone. We got her a new iPhone and
46:15 Speaker 04 You know, she is using biometrics now and she thinks this is the best thing in the world. She's 73 years old. She was like, wait a minute. And she had an iPhone. Now, mind you, she had an iPhone six. So this just kind of tells you. But I think about the world, right? I think about my own family when I'm thinking about the new technologies that we're putting in place. So we got her a brand new iPhone. We set it up for her. She loves it. She literally, you know, uses her fingerprint. She also uses facial recognition and she thinks it's the most amazing thing ever. Which lets me know that when you get walked through the process properly, or when you get to understand what it is that you're doing, and you get to see the technology work, she literally was like, well, what else can you do with this? So now I've got to go back and
46:57 Speaker 04 give her a whole lesson in all the places that she can log in, using pass keys, right? Or using biometrics. And so I think that if a 73 year old can pick this up in 10 seconds, with a little bit of help from her kids, the world can pick this up. And I think that that's what we're thinking about is what is going to be easiest for the world. The other thing I think is that, you know, in many cases, technology is not accessible to everyone, but there are cell phones. And so even when you don't have a desktop or a laptop, I don't know anybody that has a desktop anymore. But even when you don't have a laptop-
47:32 Speaker 03 I'm talking about an iMac, come on. This is a 2015 iMac. This is state of the art.
47:38 Speaker 04 2015. Okay. Why?
47:42 Speaker 03 It's still rocking, man.
47:46 Speaker 04 Pass keys are coming.
47:50 Speaker 04 I can't even believe you just admitted that.
47:53 Speaker 03 I love it. I'm never letting this thing go. It's perfect. It does its job exactly right.
47:56 Speaker 04 But right to the, even to that point, she held on to her iPhone six. You've got your 2015 iMac. And so, and you're both going to get pass keys. So I think, I think that, yes, this is, we're thinking about making technology accessible to everyone. I know that the manufacturers of hardware products are thinking about that. And we're thinking about how we layer software on top of that, that makes it accessible and secure.
48:23 Speaker 03 We'll be right back to talk about everything that goes into making sure all of us, you, me, and Shemika's mother-in-law, can take advantage of biometrics and other tools.
48:34 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
48:43 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
48:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
49:05 Speaker 06 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up require compatibility and availability varies 18+.
49:33 Speaker 03 We're back and it's time to talk about standards. What will it take for all of these interlocking systems to support each other in a meaningful way?
49:41 Speaker 03 So a big piece of this puzzle here, right, is you bought your mother some new hardware. By the way, the CISO explaining all the websites you can securely log into to their mother, that's like a CISO, like it looks like a children's book for kids who want to grow up to be CISOs. It's great.
49:57 Speaker 03 But you're dependent now. Like Okta was a startup. It became a unicorn. Now it's very successful because it leaned into a technology shift that was happening, right? Away from on-prem into the cloud. You've talked about the cloud a lot. Here, you're saying, okay, well, Apple's got to ship face ID and fingerprint sensors. Google's got to enable this across the Android ecosystem. Microsoft has to do it on Windows. And then Lenovo's got to put that system on their laptops. And it's all got to work together. And Okta's going to sit in the middle of it. Does that create a new set of dependencies for you? Because that seems like it's going to get very complicated in a way that for Okta and the enterprise, the, you know, the entire pitch was just do this in the cloud. We'll handle it for you. And you weren't dependent on 50 of the biggest companies
50:41 Speaker 03 in the world all working together.
50:44 Speaker 04 That's what we're doing. These are companies are our partners. And yes, we compete in some spaces, but they are also our partners. And it is predicated on us as industry leaders to lead the way. And then so and sometimes so sometimes we have to work together. But this is also where industry standards become important. Because in many cases, we are building with an industry standard in mind. And so we're not necessarily saying that Okta is the dependency. We're saying build towards the industry standard. And if you build with the industry standard, then Okta will pick up and manage identity for you.
51:13 Speaker 03 Is there buy in around this standard? Because I
51:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
51:16 Speaker 03 We cover standards a lot here at The Verge. And boy, can that get loaded, right? Like,
51:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think there's tons of buy in around FIDO2 and Web auth. And I think, I mean, I guess I'm kind of a forward leaning technologist. So of course, I'm going to say yes. I haven't seen a space where I just couldn't use it. Yet. But again, I think I'm biased because I'm a technologist at heart. And so, you know, I'm trying to figure out more ways in which I can use it. But no, I think there has to be industry buy in for certain standards. USB C. It's all over the place now.
51:51 Speaker 03 Right. But when I say, boy, can that get complicated? Like, that's another hour of how that standard is not actually easy to use. And it has been corrupted in 50 different ways.
52:01 Speaker 04 Yes, but it but it is a standard. And I think that sometimes you have to, you have to have a standard for the sake of interoperability. And I think that that's what that's what the standards are about is its interoperability. Because capturing market share is really, really challenging. And in many cases, you cannot capture market share when you do not do not have that interoperability. There is no one company that owns the space completely. In many cases, we all work together in vast ways. In order for us to have that level of interoperability, we are working from a set of standards. Okta has 15,000 connections.
52:44 Speaker 04 Now, are some of them built on standards? No. Some of them are like, no, we just really need to make this API work. And so that's what we're doing. But we, we take that challenge, right? There are some that will be standards based. There are some where we will just partner and say, we need to make this work because it's going to be a benefit to our customers.
52:59 Speaker 03 Let me give you an example of, of just standards among these companies. And I will abstract it out. So you don't have to talk about your competitors slash partners directly. One big company agrees to do a standard with another big company. The first big company loves to just like, do the whole thing, like all in, idealistic, we're doing it. And then the other big company, which is just down the road from them, usually is like, we're taking three pieces of the standard and building our entire stack on it. And the rest of it will be completely ignored, because this is the jewel-like user experience that we're after. I'm not saying which companies are which. I'm just saying that that's a pattern I see happen over and over again. For you, as Okta, building on top of that, how do you manage that as you try to push out the consumer products that you're building in a secure way?
53:44 Speaker 04 I mean, some of it is just, well, in some cases, they just say no, and we go, okay. You know, and sometimes you'll hear us say, we're 80% of the way, because not everyone always wants to get on board. That's gonna happen. We know that. When you have your own ecosystem, you have flexibility to say, no, I'm not going to participate. It is our hope that when we think about identity, this is about people. This is not about market share. This is not about having your own ecosystem for Okta. This is about people. And this is about protecting people. And so it is my hope, it is Okta's hope, that that becomes the forefront of standardizing. If it is a benefit to people and protecting
54:29 Speaker 04 our consumers, because ultimately, when our consumers are compromised, or when we are compromised through our consumers, we lose trust. Trust like rides in on a tricycle and leaves in a Rolls Royce. Like, it's, it comes in slowly and it goes out on a jet pack. And so when we lose consumer trust, we all lose. And so what we are trying to do is to get the companies that be to say, yes, This is something that we all should do. Is it hard? Is it difficult? Absolutely. But is it the right thing to do? Absolutely. And it's a task or a challenge that Okta is willing to do. Because if we're going to say that we're neutral, we have to get as many partners on board as we can. And so that's what we're doing. And I'll tell you, we have been wildly successful in that.
55:13 Speaker 04 In talking to some of the larger companies and saying, it is important that that this particular standard, pass keys is the one that we agree on. Because it's about people. If we keep that in mind, it makes the conversations different and a lot more smooth. Because ultimately, nobody wants to be the company that's that is on there and saying, three million of our customers' data has been breached. That is what we are all facing when all of us don't get on board. We all are reliant on each other. And the failure of one technology, it's like dominoes falling. We get compromised in the identity space and many, many other areas are compromised as a result of that. We don't want that. And so we are really, really focused on not just only being a good partner,
55:57 Speaker 04 but building those good partnerships. And sometimes that means bringing everyone along, even if they don't want to come along.
56:03 Speaker 03 So let me ask you, that's the work? It sounds very complicated. You sound very passionate about it. How long until the password goes away? The password is we know it.
56:12 Speaker 04 Oh, gosh. You know, one interview, I say forever. One interview, I'm like tomorrow.
56:19 Speaker 04 I don't know. You know what? That's a question that I really don't know. I don't know how long it's going to be. I would like it to be in the next like five to 10 years. That's still a long time. I don't, I don't have the answer. I think we're really pushing towards it going away. But I don't know. That's one I just can't answer. I, I would love to say that it's sooner rather than later, but I don't think that that's true.
56:42 Speaker 03 You don't think that something like the release of iOS 17 with support for pass keys leads to rapid adoption? And then sort of an exponential curve of password going away?
56:52 Speaker 04 No, I don't. I think that it will speed up the adoption. And I think that this is what has to happen. I think that we have to have these kinds of releases where they speed up adoption. But ultimately, in order for passwords to go away, everywhere that there's a password, it has to have the technology built in for it to go away. Or they have to use a product in front of their login box for it to go away. No, obviously, we can do that for you. But I think that we can do that.
57:20 Speaker 04 That's a good plug. But I think that it's, I think we're still a ways out because people are emotionally tied to it. I think that they want it there. They think it's important. And so I think we're still a ways out because of the emotional connection, not because of the technical capability. I think the technical capability is there. I think that as we, again, as we continue to partner and we continue to release and do software releases and hardware releases, that this is available, people will just naturally migrate to it and then it'll become a part of how they do business every day. If you had to nail me down, I'd say we're five to 10 years away from the password going away.
57:56 Speaker 03 That's a good answer. That's what all the self-driving car CEOs say, too. It's just enough to be specific, but just fuzzy enough to be never. It's great. It's nail it. It's a real
58:05 Speaker 04 I don't know out of me. So that's the real answer, right? You got to, you got to say, yeah, I don't know, you know?
58:11 Speaker 03 It's true. I think a lot of people want us to go away and I think it's comforting to people. I want to come back to that, actually, that thought of the fact that it's real people that are going to drive the shift. But one more question, the pass keys in general. You mentioned biometrics. You really like it. There are big trade-offs with biometrics. You mentioned that you're a black woman and facial recognition systems generally have not been trained well on people with darker skin. I've experienced this as well. There's bias in that data. We're also coming up on a time of massive AI development and it seems like a lot of AI bad actors are going to point it right at biometric systems.
58:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
58:50 Speaker 03 The big trade-off in biometrics is once it's breached, it's done, right?
58:53 Speaker 04 Yeah.
58:53 Speaker 03 I can't change my fingerprint, at least not yet. How are you thinking about those trade-offs, especially in a time when AI systems seem poised to be used by bad actors to attack them?
59:04 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'm worried. If I had to say there's the biggest thing that I'm worried about is what happens when they lose my fingerprints? What happens when those are breached and what are we going to do about it? The tenants of protecting data and protecting PII, those are not new. As we start to think about how we're storing and how we're handling data and encryption and at rest, and we're going to have to, I think, up-level our skill set around protecting biometric data. It is I think, again, the thing that I am most worried about, what not, and again, not as a CISO, but as a human being, what happens when they lose my retinal scan? What happens? And I think that that's one of the reasons why I'm I'm such a fan of of having the capability on your cell phone.
59:48 Speaker 04 And because you you're holding
59:50 Speaker 03 Locally, you mean, not in a
59:51 Speaker 04 locally, right? Locally, right? When I say your cell phone, I mean locally. I'm a fan of of that technology. And because we're holding on to it with the depth grip, depth grip. But it also allows us to have some ownership and protection of it. I think that and because there are tons of ways to wipe and delete and remotely, there's tons of things that we can do with cell phones to really protect that. And so I think that's one of the reasons why I like the technology. But I am very worried about how we protect the data. We have not gotten to where we are, I think, universally good at protecting data and protecting databases. I think even more so, you talked a little bit about AI. When I think about AI, I think about, you know, these large language models that are being built
1:00:32 Speaker 04 and the ability for me as a CISO, one of the things that we we we can do right now is understand if it's a human or if it's a bot. AI is bringing generative AI is bringing in deep fakes that are human like. The the thing about generative AI is that it mimics us. And so our ability to detect if it's a human or if it's a bot is diminishing. It's going to diminish. And so this is where the challenge becomes really critical because what happens when those deep fakes can also mimic our faces and our biometric?
1:01:03 Speaker 03 Right, I can imagine an attack where I get between the camera and the facial recognition system and deep fake your face onto my head. That would be crazy. I can, I'm just saying, I can imagine it.
1:01:14 Speaker 04 That's our future. That's our future.
1:01:15 Speaker 03 That's where the attack happens, between the camera and the and the security system. And I deep fake your face and you've only got one face. And once that's done, that's over, right? That's the trade off with biometrics. It's easy and convenient and the most secure right now. But it's also, once you're off the cliff, you're done.
1:01:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, and this is the this is the CISO's journey, right? This is a part of what, you know, oftentimes they're like, our CISO is crazy and they're telling us about all these things. I know it, I know they say it. You know, we're telling these horror stories, but this is, you know, AI is real. It's not new technology. We've been using machine learning to defend against bots for years. It's not new to us. And so in that case, it's not new. What's new is how generative AI is being used. And so, yeah, I'm concerned. I think we, and I don't have an answer for how we fix this yet. OAS just came out with, you know, a top 10 for large language models. And I've been, you know, ferociously reading through it. It's 30 pages. It's a great read, though.
1:02:18 Speaker 04 And the Cloud Security Alliance has also put out some really great information around how we defend against it, but it's not solid. It's still very much a, you know, there's, we can use AI to defend against it. There's still a lot of thought around if it's going to be, the defenses that have been proposed are effective, and none of them are talking about biometrics kind of man in the middle attacks. They are talking about like, you know, adversary in the middle, but not this particular example that you've given. We're not there yet. And when we think about why there is so much consternation about AI, this is the reason why. Because we all can come up with these various examples that none of us have thought about how we defend against yet.
1:03:00 Speaker 04 And so while I am a super fan of AI also, I'm like, we also can't get so far behind the market of security as we do with other technologies. We've done it over and over again. We should know better by now. We really are going to have to get really, really good at this particular space of security and defensibility in the space of AI. Not happening at a rapid pace, the way I would like to see it. But what I do know is that I think it is as important to us as it is the folks who are making AI to do this work and to secure this work. We've let something out in the loose. I look at some of the AI generators around like headshots, and I'm like, these look great, and they look just like me. Yeah. And how would you know if I sent you a headshot that wasn't really me at this point? It's kind of hard to know.
1:03:45 Speaker 04 The good part of it because Jamaica looks great all the time. The bad part of it is when you take what I've sent you and use it biometrically to log into everything that I own. So it's both. I think we're going to have to be very, very thoughtful about security in the AI space. And I think, you know, there, there's lots of talk about like, hey, what happens when my developers dump all of my code in? I'm not super concerned about that. And the reason for, and, and I'll tell you why. The reason for that is there, you have to have a lot of data to change a large language model. And then the person who's attacking you has to know that your data is out there and that it's a part of the model. And so it's pretty sophisticated. You would have to dump all of the entire source code in there. They would have to know how to use it. You have to have all the secrets in there.
1:04:24 Speaker 04 And so, yeah, I mean, I don't want our developers doing that. But at the same time, in order for it to actually go into a public, large language model that's crawling the internet, you've got to really put a lot of instances out there for it to pick it up. I am much more concerned about what you've talked about here. And I think that it's, it's, I, I don't have the answer yet. It's one that we are all digging into in the security community and trying to figure out, how do we not create these scary stories, but really get finite, user-centric, um, details around what can actually happen with generative AI and what are the threats that are out there?
1:05:00 Speaker 03 Do you think that it's worth slowing down the sort of headlong rush towards pass keys and biometrics on phones while this gets sorted out?
1:05:06 Speaker 04 No. No, I don't.
1:05:08 Speaker 03 Why is that?
1:05:09 Speaker 04 There will be times when technology doesn't move at the same pace. And so I think that as ferociously as AI is moving forward, we are going to have to move forward as well. Because if we stop the rollout of pass keys and biometrics, AI is still going to keep going. And those deepfakes are still going to happen, except for now, those deepfakes are just going to be using username and passwords. And so it's one of those things where it's like, you shouldn't stop because ultimately the answer could be in AI technology. It will likely be we fight AI with AI. And if we don't keep moving to advance these technologies, AI is not going to stop. It's, it's not. As much as, you know, the flag has been raised and people said, no, no, no, you don't see it slowing down at all.
1:05:50 Speaker 04 And so why would we slow down when we know that this technology is moving that we need to be able to protect and defend against? And so I would say, no, actually, what needs to happen is that we need to move faster. And we need to be uniquely acquainted with AI and all of the risk and vulnerabilities and threats that it presents. And we need to continue to evolve these technologies to go right along with AI.
1:06:10 Speaker 03 All right, I want to end with kind of just a bigger picture question. We've talked a lot about people in this episode and how they behave and what they like and what they'll do and how you can get them to act in a more secure way by making it easier, by reducing friction. You have a pretty unique background here, right? You came out of the Navy, you're a woman of color in the security industry. That's fairly rare. It seems like understanding people's behavior broadly is really important to security and the kind of cast of characters in the community has been pretty narrow, been pretty insular. They've all pretty much looked the same from the same backgrounds. Do you see that changing? Do you see that pipeline of people from the military, for example, from other walks of life coming
1:06:51 Speaker 03 into the industry? How do you accelerate that? Because it feels like that's the key. You've got to understand the 73-year-old mom if you want to make Pasquis work and that the community kind of understands itself right now.
1:07:06 Speaker 04 It's my life's work to diversify the community that I'm a part of. It's important to me because diversity of thought is important. To your point, the 73-year-old mom, the person of darker complexion or darker skin. And so, you know, we have a ways to go. We didn't create the society that we live in overnight. This didn't just happen to us. This is hundreds of years in the making. It's been done through various mediums. And so what we're seeing now is the end result of intentional behaviors. And so what we need to fix this is intentional behaviors. We need people who are leaders, who are willing to go and find diverse candidates
1:07:49 Speaker 04 and not say things like, we're going to lower the bar. That's bullshit. You're not lowering the bar when you go and look for candidates of color. You're going out of your comfort zone. And that's what I want the community to be honest about, that we are going to have to get out of our comfort zone to create the community, a technical community that represents the world we actually live in. There is not a place where one person with one train of thought can do everything for everyone because you're not going to be able to include everyone's whole And dreams and wishes in that. But when you go and you seek out a diverse community and diverse thought, then you will get a larger intersection of the world. And it is my hope that someday I will look around
1:08:33 Speaker 04 and the world that I live in doesn't look like the world that I work in. I want the world that I work in to look like the world that I live in because it is incredibly diverse and it is a beautiful community of people who are brilliant and bright. I mean, who have all these great ideas. And so we've got to be intentional. The leaders in security have got to be intentional about how we recruit, but not just how we recruit. Because I see tons of diverse candidates come in through the pipeline. They get new jobs and then the culture of the workplace is horrible to them. We've got to retain those folks that we bring in. It's got to be, the, the culture has to be friendly. The culture has to be accepting. The culture has to be one in which people feel like they can bring their true selves
1:09:18 Speaker 04 to the office. Because when you do that, that's when you get brilliance. And I've said this to leaders that I've worked for before. I've spent many, many times in many, many positions where I was not an authentic version of myself. I was a version of myself that I felt was appropriate for work. And I spent so much time being that person that there were many great ideas that I didn't bring to the table. And then I came to Okta. And I have been able to be a very authentic version of myself. I mean, you can't do everything at work. It's work. It's not recess. But what they have gotten is some of my very best work and some of my very best thought leadership. Because I'm not thinking about, are they concerned with what Jameeka looks like? Are they concerned about how she talks? Are they concerned that, they're not concerned about these things.
1:10:02 Speaker 04 They're concerned about, number one, how can Jameeka bring her very best thought leadership? But number two, Jameeka also has unique challenges that the rest of us don't face. And we want to make sure that we're not a part of perpetuating that, that problem for her. This is not just a tech problem or a security problem. It's happening everywhere in every industry because we have not been intentional about diversity. And we, looks like we're walking it back a little bit in many cases. And so I think that we have to be. Really intentional about diversity and we have to be really intentional when we bring diverse candidates and employees in, we are also intentional about making sure that they are welcome and that their ideas are welcome and that we're listening. Because ultimately,
1:10:45 Speaker 04 when we think about these big jumps, there's someone out there who's going to solve this AI security problem and we don't know where they are in the world. And if we're not looking for them, we're not talking to them, we're never going to have the answer. And there are other answers out there in the world that we're not going to get because we don't have diverse audiences. And so that's kind of my my soapbox on that. But I think it's important to me. I've got a long time left in industry. And I think that it is going to continue to be a big part of what I do to make sure that we we have diverse spaces where people can thrive.
1:11:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, it seems very important to me in this security space, in particular, that you understand the people, like all the people, not just some of the people. But this, you've given us so much time, Jamaica. This has been an incredible conversation. That's a great place to leave it. It sounds like you have a lot of problems to solve. So we got to we got to let you get back to
1:11:31 Speaker 04 I got a lot of problems. So I got a lot of work to do.
1:11:32 Speaker 03 We got to let you get back to work. You got to come back soon. Let us know how this pass keys thing is going. This has been great. Thank you so much.
1:11:39 Speaker 04 Awesome. Have a good one.
1:11:43 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Jamaica Green Aaron of Okta for taking time to join Decoder today. And thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. I'll be at the Code Conference this year talking to a wide array of industry leaders about the biggest topics in tech. I'd love to see you there. You can go to voxmedia.com code to apply to attend. And as always, I'd love to hear what you think of Decoder. You can email us at [email protected] . I read every single email. Or you can hit me up on threads. I'm at reckless1280. I also have a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like the show, hit us with that five star review in Apple Podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate
1:12:25 Speaker 03 Cox and edited by Kelly Wright. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our editorial director is Brooke Minter, and our executive producer is Alan O'Donovan. We'll see you next time.
1:12:40 Speaker 05 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
1:13:11 Speaker 07 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous Fandom runs some of the biggest communities on the web. Can CEO Perkins Miller keep them happy? Next More than Sally Ride: Loren Grush explains how NASA’s first women astronauts changed space Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated