Pod Insights Decoder AI is on a collision course with the music industry. Reservoir's Golnar Khosrowshahi thinks there’s a way through it About this episode Today I'm talking with Golnar Khosrowshahi, the founder and CEO of Reservoir Media, a newer record label that I think looks a lot like the future of the music industry. As Golnar explains, Reservoir thinks of individual songs as assets, and after acquiring them, the company sets about monetizing those assets in various ways. This is a copyright-based business in an age where copyright is under a lot of pressure — from TikTok, generative AI, and all of the now-familiar threats to the music business.
If you're a Decoder listener, you know that I love thinking about the music industry. Whatever technology does to music, it does to everything else five years later. So paying attention to music is the best way I know to get ahead of the curve. I also just love music. Golnar is herself a musician. She obviously cares about music a lot, and she's clearly given a lot of thought to what happens next. So this was a great conversation.
Links:
Drake’s AI clone is here — and Drake might not be able to stop him
Hipgnosis made mega deals for song catalogs. Its future Is unclear.
Reservoir acquires iconic Tommy Boy Music for $100 million
Ed Sheeran wins copyright case over Marvin Gaye’s ‘Let’s Get It On’
Spotify is reportedly making major changes to its royalty model
Hipgnosis shareholders vote against continuation of UK-listed music investment trust
AI can actually help protect creativity and copyrights
Google and YouTube are trying to have it both ways with AI and copyright
No Fakes Act wants to protect actors and singers from unauthorized AI replicas
‘Glocalisation’ of music streaming within and across Europe
Transcript: https://www.theverge.com/e/23702539
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,027 words · 8 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spend can be complicated. Managing it shouldn't be. Amex Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments all in one place. That's less time managing work and more time doing work that matters. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:27 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them. That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
0:37 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:45 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:59 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking with Golnar Khosrowshahi, the founder and CEO of Reservoir Media, a newer record label that I think looks a lot like the future of the music industry. You might not have heard of Reservoir, but you've definitely heard of the artists it works with. Everyone from A-ha to John Denver to Evanescence and Joni Mitchell and even legendary film composer Hans Zimmer. What makes Reservoir different is that Golnar built the company through acquisitions. You might think of a traditional record label as sending people out into dive bars to find new talent and then break new artists, but Reservoir doesn't do any of that. It buys catalogs of existing hit songs
1:44 Speaker 03 from established artists. Reservoir owns the songwriting copyrights to about 150,000 songs and another 30,000 copyrights and master recordings. As Golnar explains, Reservoir thinks of those individual songs as assets, and after acquiring them, the company sets about monetizing those assets in various ways. This is a copyright-based business in an age where copyright is under a lot of pressure. There are the familiar issues on social platforms like TikTok and YouTube, and now there are new existential issues created by generative AI tools. You've all heard of Fake Drake. Fake Drake is going to upend copyright law one way or another, and it's the music industry that traditionally leads the charge in pushing back.
2:29 Speaker 03 Golnar founded Reservoir in 2007. So she's been in this game for a long time and she's seen a lot of tech-related change come and go. But now there are huge companies and hedge funds pouring tons of money into the same catalog-based business model, sometimes with disastrous results. You'll hear Golnar say, "All of her competitors seem to have $1 billion to spend on songs." And you'll hear us talk about a company called Hypnosis, which spent a ton of money building a giant catalog, but now has very unhappy shareholders after that catalog wasn't worth what they were promised. Of course, Golnar and I also talked about AI and training AI systems. A lot of record labels are very unhappy that their
3:10 Speaker 03 copyrighted work is being used to train generative AI tools. And a lot of artists are even more unhappy that their voices are being used by AI systems. Golnar has some surprising thoughts here, and one very instructive example she brought in to share. It'll definitely make you think about who should be making money, on what, and when. If you're a Decoder listener, you know that I love thinking about the music industry. Whatever technology does to music, it does to everything else five years later. So paying attention to music is the best way I know to get ahead of the curve. I also just love music. Golnar is herself a musician. She obviously cares about music a lot, and she's clearly given a lot of thought to what happens next. So this was a great conversation. Okay, Golnar
3:55 Speaker 03 Kusur Shahi, CEO of Reservoir Media. Here we go.
4:11 Speaker 03 Golnar Kusur Shahi, you are the CEO and founder of Reservoir Media. Welcome to Decoder. Thank you so much for having me. I am really excited to talk to you. Reservoir Media is kind of like a new look music label. It's newer than sort of the big giants that are floating around. You have a different approach to the business model. And as I was just saying to you, I really think that whatever happens to the music industry, happens to every other kind of creative industry five years later. I've been saying this since we started The Verge. And so I'm always trying to figure out what is going on in music right now, because then I seem like a genius when it happens to TV or Hollywood five years from now. And there's quite a lot going on in the music industry right now. The whole industry is restructuring itself. There's AI to talk about. Distribution on the internet seems to be changing. Marketing seems to be changing. Like, it's a lot.
4:56 Speaker 03 But let's start at the very beginning. What is Reservoir Media and why did you start it?
5:00 Speaker 04 You're characterizing us as the new look. But here we are, a precocious teenager at 16 years old. We started as a publisher and we built the business from there. Acquiring rights. It really wasn't until a few years in that we bought some a very small recorded music catalog, Philly Groove. And then it really wasn't until we acquired Chris Lush Records in 2019 that we got into the label business. So our business really is focused on publishing and we are looking at sort of revenues that are 70/30, publishing versus recorded.
5:36 Speaker 03 And just for the listener, publishing is songwriting?
5:38 Speaker 04 Songwriting. We own copyrights. We own the intellectual property. We own the words and the music. And that's a really, really important distinction versus the recorded music where you own that actual sound recording, that specific recording. When you own the publishing to a song like "Taking Me Home, Country Roads", you know, there are 500 covers of that song on streaming platforms. So you are monetizing that every time that copyright, those words, those notes are used, regardless of whether it's me or you or John Denver. Master recording is only, we don't own the master recording rights to that song particularly, but it's that particular execution. So that's the distinction there.
6:20 Speaker 03 And then when you bought Chris Lush, you own the masters from Chris Lush. And you own Tommy Boy Records as well, you own those masters. So you have a pretty broad base of copyrights.
6:29 Speaker 04 We do. And it's been interesting in growing that business. We've had incredible opportunities come before us. The Tommy Boy opportunity was just amazing. And then what we did with it afterwards and with De La Soul and the release of all that music was really a... Pivotal point career-wise, personally and professionally.
6:49 Speaker 03 Yeah. When I say it's a new look kind of company, I recognize it's been around for a while. What interests me the most is you have built the company through acquisition of really successful existing catalogs.
7:02 Speaker 04 Yes.
7:03 Speaker 03 When I think of a record label, I think of, I'm gonna go discover an artist, we're gonna pair them with a songwriter, maybe, we're gonna put them in a studio, we're gonna go market the hell out of some hit singles, oh, look, it's Justin Timberlake. Like, we've done a thing. That was the 90s approach. That was basically the approach that I grew up in, understanding the music industry. We discover talent, we market talent, we create new talent, we burn them out, we find some new teenagers, and off we go again. That was the music industry. You're really focused on, okay, there's a bunch of catalogs that are really valuable, and we're gonna acquire them, and then we're gonna get value out of them. Is that a fair characterization, that you're kind of the other end of it?
7:39 Speaker 04 I think so. We never really got into the business with the intention of developing a frontline label that was going to develop artists like Justin Timberlake. That's an expensive proposition. We're slightly more risk averse than that. We look at buying these existing assets and what we can do from a value enhancement standpoint, and what that translates to in the form of organic growth. That's what's really important to us. That's how we believe we're building long-term value for ourselves, for the artists, for the songwriters, regardless of, you know, who that rights holder, that other rights holder partner is that we have in the equation, and every deal is different. That continued value enhancement is what's really important to us. And yes, you're right, we're not out
8:21 Speaker 04 there finding the next thing. That's a different business, and I'm not sure how effectively a company our size with our risk profile or appetite for risk can compete with others in that area.
8:39 Speaker 03 This is a really fascinating fracturing of the industry, in my mind. On the one hand, the discovery, marketing of new artists.
8:48 Speaker 03 The social platforms are just completely encroaching on that. And I hear from young artists, the labels don't even talk to me until I have so many followers. I have a person I went to college with, literally got a record deal by buying followers on Twitter. And then that got him some attention. This is crazy. This is like a thing that has happened in the past. You're saying, we're going to leave that aside. That seems like the big labels business. We're going to go find successful artists and help them get more from their existing catalogs, help them gracefully retire. What's the pitch there?
9:19 Speaker 04 Every pitch is different and it really depends on where you are on your creative journey and where you are in your life. And are you 30 or are you 60? Are you wrapping things up? Or are you thinking about estate planning and legacy? Or are you looking at what your next portfolio looks like? So every deal is different, but I think the pitch from a bird's eye standpoint is, we want to be your creative partner in your musical journey. Whatever that means, that could be a go-forward deal. That could be, we're going to buy the back catalog and we're going to partner with you and enhance the value of this catalog. It really depends on who the client is because our goal is to be in business with people long-term.
10:01 Speaker 04 And I think that if you cater to and satisfy people's needs and their objectives, then you can have a pretty good shot at staying in business with people.
10:13 Speaker 03 You have quite a long list here. It's Joni Mitchell, John Denver, De La Soul, Evanescence, Hans Zimmer. It's a pretty intense range. Some of these artists are pretty current and relevant. Some are older artists, quite frankly. Do you have different strategies for each of these catalogs? Like you say, okay, we have the publishing right to a Cardi B song. Our songwriters wrote the Cardi B song. We can go out and license those for television or advertising or something like that. But then you've got an artist like Louis Prima, and I'm assuming that's a different strategy?
10:47 Speaker 04 It is a different strategy. I mean, I think, I would rather say that the strategy...
10:54 Speaker 04 Is different for each song, right, versus the writer.
10:58 Speaker 03 How many songs do you have in the catalog?
11:00 Speaker 04 A hundred and fifty thousand on the publishing side, just over thirty thousand on the recorded side.
11:06 Speaker 03 Okay.
11:07 Speaker 04 So this is a little bit of a bigger theme in that we do everything on a song by song basis. We actually assess value on a song by song basis. A lot of people assess value on an income type basis. But if you look at somebody like Hans Zimmer, you're looking at a portfolio that dates back to Driving Miss Daisy up until, you know, films from a few years ago. Very, very different films. You can't really look at these assets, you can't look at Driving Miss Daisy and Kung Fu Panda as the same thing.
11:33 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
11:34 Speaker 04 They have a different audience, different music, different genre, you know, it's all very different. So I think it's really important to look at song by song, especially because you're dealing with songwriters who have this range and who could do all kinds of work. And so the pitch is different. The pitch is different for every song, but the pitch is focused on film placements and it's focused on advertising placements. Digital licensing is super important for us. We were the first independent to actually do a direct deal with YouTube. That was back in 2014, I want to say. So we do things at a very granular level, but we can because we only represent a hundred and fifty thousand songs.
12:11 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:12 Speaker 04 It's the benefit of being nimble and independent and small.
12:14 Speaker 03 So there's a huge surge of money into companies that look like yours.
12:19 Speaker 04 Everyone has a billion dollars.
12:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, like KKR and BlackRock and Blackstone, not the Grille Company, the huge hedge fund. We've had the CEO of Blackstone, the Grille Company, we're working on the hedge fund. But these are huge private equity funds.
12:34 Speaker 04 Yes.
12:35 Speaker 03 Just dumping money into these catalogs. They have a pretty shaky investment thesis. Like I can never quite figure out why they want to own Pink Floyd's catalog or whatever. I can kind of understand your investment thesis because it seems like on a song by song level, you can evaluate, okay, here's the earning potential of the song. But in general, is there a model that you use that says, okay, we own a hundred and fifty thousand songs, we paid X dollars, we can expect Y return?
13:04 Speaker 04 Sure, we can get to that top line number, but the engine behind that is the song by song.
13:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:11 Speaker 04 Information and that song by song information can be organized by our top earners. So we can say, look. This many songs contribute to 80% of our revenue. And that's going to give us, you know, we paid X, that's now worth Y, here's our return. But it's still, the engine behind it is song by song. Because you've got portfolios of songs where you have significantly more valuable songs in completely different genres. I think the investment thesis for a lot of private equity is that you are looking at uncorrelated assets that behave very much like annuities, that have dependable cash flows in an industry where the data around growth and monetization is becoming more and more
13:55 Speaker 04 compelling every single day. That's in Western markets, coupled with compelling data in the emerging markets. So that's a pretty good investment thesis. And then it becomes a pretty great investment thesis when you're operating in troubled macroeconomic times.
14:12 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:12 Speaker 04 And so I think that's, that's the motivation there. It's also, it's fun.
14:17 Speaker 03 Well, there's, there's that part.
14:18 Speaker 04 It's music.
14:19 Speaker 03 A bunch of, a bunch of rich guys want to buy some boom music catalog. I, I get that part of it. The thing you're describing, we're going to describe massively important cultural works as annuities, and those are going to be safe investments in troubled. Isn't that a little bit heartbreaking? Like, to me, as somebody who's very much creative, and you yourself are a musician, there's something heartbreaking about that, right?
14:45 Speaker 04 There is and there isn't. There's something heartbreaking in that something that someone considers their child, which is really how these bodies of work are thought of by their creators, is thought of as an asset.
15:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:03 Speaker 04 Has the word, has that label asset. So that's heartbreaking.
15:08 Speaker 03 And commodified.
15:09 Speaker 04 And commodified.
15:10 Speaker 03 Inside of that, inside of that language switch is a commodification.
15:13 Speaker 04 Exactly, exactly. It has economic meaning around it. At the same time, it's really also nice to see creators be recognized for their work in the long term. That's not heartbreaking. Like, that's great to see that their art, their child, has that kind of longevity.
15:32 Speaker 03 Yeah. I think this is a central tension of like the entire music industry. In particular, I feel like Hollywood people are like, we want to be rich. And many musicians are like, we would prefer not to think about it.
15:44 Speaker 04 Right. And then so when are you, when are you hitting that edge of selling out versus?
15:51 Speaker 03 Do you think the artists care about selling out anymore? I'm a huge Clash fan. And, you know, there's stories like when they bought their first cars, they like, they were in a moral crisis. And I just don't think the artists do that anymore.
16:03 Speaker 04 I don't think so. I think that you have enough people in the music industry who are revered for their art, doing these kinds of deals, such that the stigma associated with doing the deals and hence selling out is, maybe it hasn't disappeared, but it certainly, it has been reduced.
16:28 Speaker 03 So the value of the catalog over time, you described it as, and the private equity guys think of it as an annuity. I know that you care about them as deeply cherished pieces of art. But if you describe a catalog as an annuity, we're going to buy all of John Denver's catalog.
16:41 Speaker 04 Okay.
16:42 Speaker 03 This is now going to generate returns at some rate for some amount of time. At some point, the fan base is getting older, maybe spending less money, maybe harder to advertise to. And you've got younger fans who need to be initiated into John Denver's music, but they're on TikTok and they're flooded with a bunch of new music. Is there an expiration date on these annuities?
17:06 Speaker 04 I think about that a lot.
17:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
17:09 Speaker 04 Because I have two 21-year-olds, right? So are they going to be listening? Do they even know, you know, what the song is? Where I have come to is that a great song is a great song, and great lyrics are great lyrics. So, next generation may not know John Denver, may not know his story, may not know this song. But if Google is taking this song and putting it in a commercial and launching Google Home during the Super Bowl with this song, an instrumental version, no lyrics.
17:46 Speaker 04 I feel that it's going to continue to have staying power and relevance. There were several different iterations of this song in The Kingsman. I think maybe five different iterations.
17:58 Speaker 03 Wow.
17:59 Speaker 04 That's a film that was catering to probably an 18 to 54 demographic. I mean, wide demographic. So again, people might be listening to that music and not knowing the history behind it, but it's a great song with a great melody and great lyrics. And so I think that relevance will continue.
18:16 Speaker 03 And do you chart that on a curve? The relevance will continue, but the instant hit of nostalgia that makes you buy a Google Home will decline for the younger audience. So the value of the song by song will decline.
18:27 Speaker 04 So we don't really look at it that way. We look at a rate at which cash flows will be generated over time. We have certain periods where there's a plateau. You see spikes every so often as it relates to something like the Kingsman event or, you know, some kind of big film sync event. And then we sort of smooth that out over time. So that's really how we look at it. And something like that is really in a mature state, and so it has plateaued.
18:56 Speaker 03 You have some competitors in this world. Everyone has a billion dollars, as you said. The big one was called Hypnosis, which just this week is in a moment of like bizarre controversy.
19:08 Speaker 04 Yes.
19:09 Speaker 03 And because it is a British company, the British press is covering it. They're having the time of their lives covering this controversy. We'll link to some of the stories. But basically, they wanted to sell some of their catalog to another part of the fund. They had to take some offers. Nobody bit, so they made the sale. And their shareholders are like, no, this is a disaster. The founder might leave. You could take that as evidence of owning these catalogs does not deliver the returns that it costs to build them. What do you see this as evidence of?
19:40 Speaker 04 I can't comment on somebody else's business.
19:42 Speaker 03 Fair.
19:43 Speaker 04 What I can say is that we take a conservative approach as far as how we value these catalogs. We look for compelling data around growth. Some things may be subject to growth and some things may not. And we tailor that to the assets that we're looking to buy. We take into account our cost of capital, which, keep in mind, we did business for, you know, thirteen, fourteen years with zero cost of capital to today's cost of capital. That's a very different environment to operate in. I mean, we had no cost of capital for that long. In fact, we had only known that environment.
20:24 Speaker 03 Right. Just to unpack that for the audience. You're talking about the zero-interest-rate environment.
20:28 Speaker 04 Exactly.
20:28 Speaker 03 And now it's very different.
20:29 Speaker 04 So we only operated in a zero-interest-rate environment, and now we're not. So we too take that into account. And it's important for us to create long-term value and return for our shareholders, and we're conscious of that. And so we're never going to do a deal that doesn't have the numbers that qualify for us making that investment. We're really passionate about music. We are all musicians somewhere along the way. We are trained. We love music. We're really dispassionate about our investments. And that's important. So I know that that's how we have run the business thus far. That's how we hope to continue to run the business. I think people have gotten very, very excited
21:11 Speaker 04 about music, about music assets, about subscriber growth. There's just been a lot of press, a lot of education. And sometimes you might, what's the saying? Get over your skis. So perhaps that's the situation.
21:25 Speaker 03 That was very polite. That was a very polite way of describing what's happening to your competitor right now.
21:29 Speaker 04 I'm a very polite person. And I would say that bad news in music is bad news in music. You know, there was a lot of traffic last week around accruals, for example, and how people were accounting for accruals over the course of the past year with the new royalty rates. That's bad news for music. Now, there is no issue around that. But do you see what I'm saying? We want generally investor positivity around music is important.
21:56 Speaker 03 Yeah. We have to take a quick break. When we come back, we're going to see if AI can write a song.
22:09 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
22:18 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
22:26 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
22:40 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18 plus.
23:08 Speaker 03 We're back to talk about one of the most controversial issues in the music industry today. Copyright and AI.
23:16 Speaker 03 I want to ask a couple of the decoder questions and I want to talk about AI and I want to talk about where copyright laws going because those things seem to be crashing into each other and you are very much at the center of those two ideas. But real quickly, tell me how Reservoir is structured. How have you organized this business?
23:31 Speaker 04 We are a very lateral organization and we have been since day one. We continue to grow that way. I think that at some point you get to a point of tension where it's not possible to continue with that kind of flat hierarchy, but we haven't hit that yet and it hasn't been a problem for us, but that's a lot to do with our culture. We've had zero senior level management turnover since inception. That has a lot to do with our culture. It's a very open environment with people who have. Grown in lockstep with the company. And I think that's just been really important. And I'm both proud of and indebted to my team. And so that's, that's a little bit about how we're structured.
24:16 Speaker 03 But get into it. So the function of the company, right? You go, you make acquisitions and then you license them out.
24:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's that easy.
24:24 Speaker 03 Right, yeah. But I'm saying mechanically, right? You like, you buy some stuff. You do a bunch of licensing deals. You must account for where the revenue goes. How is that structured?
24:32 Speaker 04 So we buy some stuff. When we buy the stuff.
24:36 Speaker 03 I see on decoders, everything's very simple.
24:38 Speaker 04 That's fine, I'm, I'm gonna decode it for you. When we buy the stuff, there is a team of six people who are analyzing the stuff. Those six people are really working during that deal process. Once we complete the transaction and we finish all of our underwriting and we finance the deal, we then have an ingestion process. That ingestion process is kicked off with a meeting that involves all the different functional areas so that people know, hey, we just bought this asset. Here are the rights that we're getting with this asset. Here's what we need to do with ingestion. Here's what we need to do with administration. Here are the rights that are not covered. Here are the territories that are not covered. Every deal is specific. Here's how we're going to ingest it into our licensing system, et cetera.
25:22 Speaker 04 From there, Digital Licensing Sync, et cetera, has a lot to do with actually taking the metadata associated with the music and then starting to pitch it out and register it and claim it and do all of the things that we do on the digital side. We also have marketing involved the entire time along the way because they will announce the deal. We will think about when we're announcing the deal. There's obviously some relationship building that needs to happen if it's a new client, not somebody that we've been in business before somehow or another. And there's a lot of creative discussion around what we can do with the catalog, especially if it's a relationship where it's catalog and an ongoing relationship with an artist. So that's something that we're focused on with our creative team. And then anything else that's specific to that deal.
26:06 Speaker 04 At the same time, everything's being loaded up and ingested by our royalties team to prep for next royalty runs and how these people are getting paid based on what rights, et cetera. It's a lot of very, very detailed work that goes into.
26:24 Speaker 04 Buying the stuff, getting the stuff, selling the stuff.
26:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. You've had to operationalize.
26:30 Speaker 04 Yes.
26:30 Speaker 03 Like quite a lot of licensing deals and royalty deals. That's up against the platforms, right? In large part, you've got big digital music distributors, Spotify, Apple, TikTok, YouTube. Do you have to build technology or have relationships to reconcile how those platforms think about royalties?
26:50 Speaker 04 We haven't had to build technology and we're not software developers and I don't see a world where we do that. I see a world where we're always going out and buying the best technology that we can.
26:59 Speaker 03 Yep.
26:59 Speaker 04 To actually accelerate our systems. So for instance, we use Disco to manage a lot of the music and how we license the music, et cetera. Relationships are very important with our DSPs and we are always looking to cultivate and evolve the relationships that we have there and continue to just improve and make the licensing more efficient and have relationships that go across marketing and playlisting and, you know, all kinds of things like that that can be beneficial to our catalog.
27:29 Speaker 03 Because you have catalog, when you talk about playlisting and marketing, you've got catalog. You don't have new stuff. A lot of the pressure on those services is promote new stuff, break new artists. Do you have people who are saying, okay, we gotta get some TikTok dances going on John Denver?
27:45 Speaker 04 We do.
27:45 Speaker 03 You do? How does that work?
27:47 Speaker 04 I mean, it works exactly that way. I mean, we have people in marketing whose expertise is looking at how you can, I don't know if that's John Denver, but.
27:57 Speaker 03 I just like to think of John Denver.
27:59 Speaker 04 We have a team that is pitching this all the time. Again, the record size of our business is not the largest part of our business, but it's, um, you know, as you said earlier, part of your value is determined by your numbers on social media. Whether you're a new artist or an existing artist, a new catalog, existing catalog. You know, those views, those eyeballs that you have are contributing to value.
28:27 Speaker 03 Do you look at something like, the joke I keep making is that I've been trying to get away from Fleetwood Mac since I was in high school and
28:34 Speaker 04 It's not working.
28:34 Speaker 03 I can't escape this man. They just keep coming back. Do you look at something like the resurgence of Fleetwood Mac?
28:40 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
28:41 Speaker 03 And say, okay, this is an opportunity for us. We have to operationalize that and figure out how to get value out of our catalog?
28:46 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
28:46 Speaker 03 What does that look like? What does that marketing meeting look like?
28:49 Speaker 04 I mean, I don't really participate in that marketing meeting, but you look at music, cigarettes after sex. That's music that has had a viral moment.
28:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:59 Speaker 04 That certainly was not their audience. And yet, when you attend a show that they had, say, in the last month, you know, you've got a completely different demographic than who was listening to their music because of the viral moment. So those are the types of events that you can't predict them. You can't plan them down to a very granular level, but you can certainly start developing opportunities around them. Not everyone's going to work, but that's what that team is focused on.
29:31 Speaker 03 All right. Last decoder question, maybe the most important one. How do you make decisions? Do you have a framework for making decisions? What does that look like for you?
29:40 Speaker 04 Coin flipping?
29:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's mine.
29:42 Speaker 04 That's mine.
29:43 Speaker 03 I feel like every CEO on the show wants to say, like, I don't know, man, I just make it up. And then they tell me about Amazon or something. But what's yours?
29:50 Speaker 04 I like to sit on things. I think it gives you perspective. I definitely see myself changing my mind. So when I have time, I really take the benefit of that time. I'm super conscious about not focusing on the wrong thing and not focusing on the noise. When I'm making decisions, I feel like I'm just, I'm looking at a bucket of stuff and I need to take everything that's irrelevant out, that's really clouding my judgment. And once I do that, I do certainly have a lot of clarity. I walk through a lot of consequences with decisions because I think that real life walkthrough helps how you think about the outcome. So that, that kind of sums it up.
30:29 Speaker 03 An enormous set of decisions you're going to have to make in the future. Is around AI, is around fighting through the courts to change copyright law, is about deciding whether to sue some of the generative AI companies around training. I want to come to that because I think that's a huge thorny problem that you are well suited to speak to. But I first just want to get a sense of how you think it's going in the industry right now. So we just had Larry Lessig on the show. I know you listened to that episode. His view is that fair use in the music industry is the worst of it all. That the things that I can do in text by quoting the New York Times are just not allowed
31:11 Speaker 03 by the norms of the music industry. And there are infinite stories about publishing rights getting taken away from songwriters because they quoted a song. There's the Ed Sheeran lawsuit. You name it. It's bad. And we've come to the place where major record labels are setting up songwriters with catalogs to do interpolations in new songs. So all new songs are now built on old songs because everyone's terrified of copyright lawsuits. Is that workable? Is that at steady state? Does that need to get fixed? Because I feel like if we don't talk about that part first, the AI conversation just begins on really shaky ground.
31:49 Speaker 04 I don't think any of us are changing copyright law anytime soon.
31:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
31:53 Speaker 04 The people who would be leading that charge, from my conversation, seem to be hesitant about going down that road because of the unexpected results that could come about in other changes in that exploration. So it's almost the devil you know is better than, what is the saying? I'm very bad with my idiomatic phrases.
32:16 Speaker 03 The devil you know is better than devil you don't. I think it's that simple. I might cut it wrong, but I think that's the idea.
32:21 Speaker 04 That one. What you know is better than what you don't know. So that's a little bit of the conversations that I'm getting. I think. You're always going to have these types of infringement lawsuits come out of the woodwork. I do think technology is going to help predict what's happening there. I think that we might live in a time where songs get delivered and they actually go through some kind of a assessment of likelihood.
32:50 Speaker 03 You have to, right, you have to tell the computer how to measure that likelihood.
32:53 Speaker 04 Right.
32:54 Speaker 03 And that, that feels to me like right now, the likelihood is a bunch of copyright owners like yourself deciding that the value of the catalog is suing Ed Sheeran for a new song that has nothing to do with the catalog, but might sound alike or share a chord progression. And that, that feels like it's on the shakiest ground right now.
33:14 Speaker 04 That's very much on the shakiest ground. That's not enough.
33:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay.
33:17 Speaker 04 I mean, there are a finite number of notes, chord progressions, you know, combinations. Every creator today consciously or subconsciously has been inspired by something in the past. The extent to which a work is a derivative work is what is that gray area and what that, where there needs to be a decision. I think we're always going to have these types of infringement cases. The degree to which they have legs to stand on today has certainly been compromised, I would say.
33:49 Speaker 03 Yeah. It, it feels like a fair use in music is more of a coin flip than ever before. And the risk of going to court, maybe you'll get the blurred lines verdict, or maybe you'll get the Ed Sheeran verdict.
34:04 Speaker 04 Right.
34:05 Speaker 03 And it's, that is a total coin flip. Like, I couldn't tell you why Marvin Gaye's estate got the money in blurred lines and didn't in Ed Sheeran.
34:14 Speaker 04 Because Ed Sheeran was in the courtroom.
34:17 Speaker 03 But that's what I mean by the, the coin flip, right? Like, if, you can only win if you provide Ed Sheeran and not on a legal basis, like.
34:25 Speaker 04 Right.
34:25 Speaker 03 That's we, to me, that's weird, right? Ex-copyright lawyer, that's, that's, and what I see is the music industry is like, screw that. We're going to build our own private copyright law system where we're going to do all these side deals and people will never really know. Right, and you see young artists have to give their publishing to older artists just to avoid the controversy.
34:46 Speaker 04 Right, well, that's, I mean, whether that has to do with what's happening today, for a young, breaking songwriter, that's often been the cost of entry.
34:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:59 Speaker 04 Right, so I don't think that's necessarily new news.
35:02 Speaker 03 For you as the catalog holder, do you see that as, okay, this is potentially an avenue for us, we can go assert our copyrights against a new artist because they sound like one of the songs in our catalog? Is that a line of business for you?
35:19 Speaker 04 No, I mean, we may have revenue that comes from that line of business, but our business is creating new, to an extent, possibly unique music.
35:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:29 Speaker 04 And cultivating the careers of artists and songwriters. That may become a revenue line item for us, but that's not one that we're going to build a team around to go and chase.
35:42 Speaker 03 You have competitors who are, right?
35:43 Speaker 04 I know, I know.
35:44 Speaker 03 The big, sort of, faceless private equity companies are like,
35:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, but-
35:47 Speaker 03 These are my chords.
35:48 Speaker 04 Okay, and say there's, I mean, you pick the number, there are 100,000 tracks being added to the streaming platforms a day, 150,000, whatever that number is, it doesn't matter, because it's just so many that nobody has the capacity to listen to that. But the consumer is not clamoring for that nameless, faceless content.
36:06 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:07 Speaker 04 So until there's market demand for something like that, I'm not really sure why we would go and develop it. Other people can develop it. If we have IP that has an interest in that new work, great, but, as I said before, we're not in the software development, technology development business, we're in the music creation business, so we'll continue down that road with people and artists and creators, because we believe that people's a connection- To music is a human experience.
36:36 Speaker 03 Right.
36:38 Speaker 04 And that is still, that still has value.
36:40 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:41 Speaker 04 So that's where we are.
36:42 Speaker 03 Well, that is a refreshing values-based approach to this. I appreciate that. I look at the industry, music industry famously not a values-based situation. But that brings us right to AI.
36:54 Speaker 04 Yes.
36:54 Speaker 03 Right, where you completely divorce people from it to even make these kinds of value judgments. You have big companies ingesting tons and tons of material to train various kinds of models, to do various kinds of things. And then you have a series of escalating problems. Do you think training the models is fair use?
37:14 Speaker 04 So I loved what was said in the last podcast, which was training is free.
37:19 Speaker 03 Yeah. That's what Professor Lessig believes.
37:22 Speaker 04 I know. And I kind of agree with that personally. Now, I may be saying something completely wrong from a business standpoint, like something I shouldn't be saying. But how is that any different than reading a history book, than reading a science book? It's training. You're learning, you're educating. If that training results in a product that is then commercialized and monetized, that's a different story. Then that IP is standing on the shoulders of IP before it, and so that creator should have recognition.
37:59 Speaker 03 So that's a derivative work in your opinion?
38:01 Speaker 04 Hundred percent.
38:02 Speaker 03 So the problem is, I understand it, and I'm very curious for your understanding, is that if you ingest the whole of recorded music in history and then generate something, a song, a voice, a vocal melody, whatever it is, there's no way to trace back the works that that was derived from. Right, you have the massive ingestion.
38:21 Speaker 04 I think there is a way.
38:22 Speaker 03 You think there is a way?
38:22 Speaker 04 I think there is a way. I think that you need to essentially hit an inflection point where a work is enough like another work, where there can be some IP, some ownership attributed to that other work. I don't know how you determine that threshold, whether it's court progressions, notes, et cetera, but there has to be some way to give credit. I generally agree with what you're saying in that. All of these ideas are based on a past idea. All of this new music is based on something you've heard before. But you've created something new, but this is a little bit different.
39:05 Speaker 04 Can I tell you my, my test that I ran this morning?
39:08 Speaker 03 Yes, I'm very excited about this.
39:09 Speaker 04 Okay.
39:10 Speaker 03 I want to tell the audience, Gona walked in here just glowing with excitement about this test. Go ahead.
39:16 Speaker 04 I asked Claude.
39:20 Speaker 03 That's the Anthropic AI.
39:21 Speaker 04 Correct. I asked Claude to write me a song about country roads leading me home. And Claude wrote me a song that has a very nice first verse. The chorus of the song that Claude wrote for me goes like this. Maybe it sounds familiar. Country roads take me home to the place I belong. West Virginia, mountain mama.
39:45 Speaker 03 No way.
39:46 Speaker 04 Country roads lead me home.
39:49 Speaker 03 Well, Claude, where do you think Claude derived that from?
39:53 Speaker 04 I don't know, but it might have something to do with.
39:56 Speaker 03 There's an Anthropic lawyer right now who's freaking out in their car, listening to this. I just want you to know that. That really happened.
40:03 Speaker 04 It's right here. I can show you. I printed it out.
40:05 Speaker 03 Let's see this. Yeah, that's, uh, that's just country roads.
40:09 Speaker 04 I also printed out the real lyrics so that we can.
40:11 Speaker 03 Oh, very good.
40:12 Speaker 04 Compare, compare and contrast. It sounds like a high school assignment.
40:15 Speaker 03 So in your mind, that's just completely unfair, right? Like Claude should not do that. And you own.
40:20 Speaker 04 Claude can do that. And that's fine. But if this is recorded and released and monetized and commercialized and used in the next Google Home product launch.
40:34 Speaker 03 I don't think Claude right now is a subscription product, right?
40:37 Speaker 04 It's not.
40:38 Speaker 03 When they start charging 20 bucks a month to use Claude, like OpenAI does with ChatGPT, should they pay you then?
40:43 Speaker 04 Yes.
40:44 Speaker 03 How much should they pay you for that?
40:45 Speaker 04 I don't know.
40:46 Speaker 03 Okay, I mean, but this seems like the problem, right?
40:49 Speaker 04 Right. Yeah, I don't. I really don't know.
40:52 Speaker 03 Like I pay Spotify in ever increasing amount of money a month at this point, right? And I can calculate to some pennies based on how much I stream from various artists, how much might go somewhere.
41:02 Speaker 04 Right.
41:03 Speaker 03 It seems impossible to do that with an AI.
41:05 Speaker 04 Yes, because there's so much volume of what would be generated and so much unique volume.
41:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:10 Speaker 04 Whereas those songs are. You and this many other people are going to listen to X. Yeah, I haven't thought about what the economic model looks like, but clearly this lyric is based on something that the Danoffs and John Denver wrote at some point.
41:35 Speaker 03 When you see that, do you get a call from the John Denver team saying, "What is going on here? They need to pay us for this."
41:45 Speaker 04 When I see this, I copy and paste it and put it in the digital licensing Slack channel.
41:51 Speaker 04 And then I see what happens with it.
41:57 Speaker 03 We'll be back in a minute with Reservoir Media CEO Golmar Khosrowshahi.
42:08 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
42:17 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
42:24 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
42:39 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18+.
43:07 Speaker 03 We're back, talking about disruption and what music licensing can even look like in the future. So, an interesting aspect of this problem, like I said, it's sort of unsolved. What does the deal look like? It could be a flat fee, it could be, hey, just recognize when you've obviously derived something from our work and pay us a percentage, who knows what that's gonna look like. You might get one deal from Anthropic, you might get another kind of deal from OpenAI, which is backed by Microsoft, and a third deal from Google, which owns YouTube, which is, as you said, a key partner of yours. How are you managing thinking about all of that? Right? And Anthropic has a bunch of money from, I think they have Amazon money now, right? Also a key distributor of your work. Is that part of the puzzle here?
43:52 Speaker 03 Okay, we're gonna go in through the music parts of these organizations, they're all gigantic companies, and tell the music executives to tell the AI executives to play ball?
44:01 Speaker 04 This is a dynamic that is ongoing in the music industry, where you sue each other during the day and then you have dinner together at night. And so, you know, you break bread and then the next morning, somebody files a lawsuit you didn't know about that was gonna happen. It's common to have to juggle these different relationships and a different level of tension in the relationship at any given time. We just have to navigate that. And, to some extent, I also recognize that they're navigating a similar set of tensions on their side. So, we are all in the business of monetizing content and putting that content in front of the consumer.
44:46 Speaker 04 What I think that value is versus what somebody at DSP thinks that value is, obviously differs, and hopefully we come together and get to some agreed-upon value. This is going to be a little bit of the same thing, and it's no different than all of the tensions we've had along the way with the DSPs and the settlements that we've come to, and it'll be a continued battle because we continue to fight for creators, and they will continue to fight for minimal cost on that side.
45:14 Speaker 03 The off-ramp for a lot of those battles, like you said, you have dinner at night, you see each other in the morning. The off-ramp is the legal system, which, at least in the case of music, until very recently, kind of knew what was going on. I'm trying to imagine just explaining to sort of the average federal judge what happened there with Claude and Anthropic and telling the judge to reach an outcome that is stable or reliable. And I don't know that that is possible at this point in time.
45:43 Speaker 04 But the off-ramp isn't the legal system.
45:46 Speaker 03 Okay.
45:46 Speaker 04 And here's the history on that. We go to dispute royalty rates every five years.
45:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
45:54 Speaker 04 We go through this proceeding with the Department of Justice. We've now concluded CRB four. We're going to continue. So the legal system has decided on a royalty rate and how that royalty rate is going to change within a five-year period. And when that five-year period is done, we're going to go back to the table and demand for greater compensation for creators. So, yes, the legal system made a decision, but we're still going to continue that battle because that decision is
46:25 Speaker 03 Yeah.
46:26 Speaker 04 has a finite term around it. So I don't know if that's always like that off-ramp. We're never getting off.
46:32 Speaker 03 [laughing]
46:33 Speaker 04 Because we're always going to go ask for more.
46:35 Speaker 03 This is like the problem you signed up to solve every day, right?
46:38 Speaker 04 Right.
46:39 Speaker 03 Like, how do we get more money for the catalog?
46:41 Speaker 04 Exactly.
46:42 Speaker 03 But inside of that, right, is thing, just this week, this is a very newsy week to have you on.
46:46 Speaker 04 It is.
46:46 Speaker 03 There's hypnosis.
46:47 Speaker 04 There is.
46:47 Speaker 03 Spotify is rumored to be changing its royalty rates.
46:49 Speaker 04 Yep.
46:50 Speaker 03 Right? So you need to have a minimum number of streams to get paid.
46:53 Speaker 04 Correct. And this is all in, you know, in this endeavor to remove a lot of content from the platform.
47:01 Speaker 03 Yeah. They want a lot of garbage off.
47:03 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
47:03 Speaker 03 And they know the AI stuff is coming and there's white noise chum all over the platform.
47:07 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
47:08 Speaker 03 Okay, you have a catalog, again, of older artists. Do you worry? Okay, at some point, the numbers, song by song, some of these songs are not going to get enough streams to get payouts. We need to negotiate with Spotify for deals to keep the whole catalog up. How does that work?
47:23 Speaker 04 So we don't have those specific deals. We're a much smaller company and so we don't
47:28 Speaker 03 Yeah.
47:29 Speaker 04 we don't have those specific deals. So I do worry about what you're saying because you have finite number of listening hours. And you have a growing content pool. And at some point, you have these, really what are standards, getting in front of fewer and fewer and fewer people and ears. I think that one of the ways we look at the industry is that the diversification across platforms has actually been accretive on a net basis. So you have Peloton, you have all of these new platforms that have actually supplemented consumption across the other platforms.
48:03 Speaker 03 So Peloton plays music in its classes, they obviously pay licensing fees for that.
48:06 Speaker 04 Correct. And Peloton specifically, TikTok specifically, these are also discovery channels. So now people are discovering our music that way because they heard it in a Peloton class because they are down some TikTok rabbit hole and are seeing a video of something. So that diversification across gaming and other social media platforms has been beneficial for us. It's always been accretive. We are always seeing this push and pull in our consumption and across these platforms. So we have to supplement with other value-add vehicles and channels to continue to build that value.
48:45 Speaker 03 We're kind of on time. I want to end by talking about an op-ed that you just wrote about AI.
48:49 Speaker 04 It's obsolete now.
48:50 Speaker 03 You know, you wrote it, it's good. You have a lot of ideas in there. The big idea is like, don't be so worried. The industry will solve this like it solves everything else. You have one idea in there that I just want to ask you about specifically, which is maybe AI will enable micro-licensing, where the AI will not just generate the songs, but it will also detect bits and bobs of the song and will pay fractions of pennies to various.
49:15 Speaker 04 Correct.
49:16 Speaker 03 How do you think that would work in practice? What I always worry about is the kid on YouTube who doesn't know what they're doing and they're just like putting their music on YouTube and then the industry comes and like takes all their pennies away. Right, and like, once you like, add computers and automated enforcement to art, it just, it seems like it gets really dicey. But I wanted to understand what you meant by micro-licensing.
49:38 Speaker 04 So, micro-licensing, really, think of it as outside of the big-ticket sync that we do. Outside of the trailer placements, the film placements, the, you know, big commercials, etc. We do a lot of micro-licensing. High-volume, low-cost music licensing. The way I think about how we could do that is that we have technology that actually understands all the characteristics and attributes of our music that we license for that use. So understands that metadata, classifies that metadata, and is searchable. And, you know, even though it's searchable now, I think it can be a lot more efficient as far as being used to
50:18 Speaker 04 then, search, create a license, obtain that license, and you've now completely automated a process that is still carried out by humans right now.
50:28 Speaker 03 I got it.
50:29 Speaker 04 So that's how we think about micro-licensing, is much more of the high-volume, low-price-point licensing that we do.
50:35 Speaker 03 And so that would be for advertisers, or Instagram brands, or whatever?
50:39 Speaker 04 Exactly, and a lot of commodity music. That's how we think about it.
50:43 Speaker 03 The other thing that I'm constantly thinking about in the context of AI is, we don't have a great system for fake Drake. Right, there is no federal likeness law, there's no right-of-publicity law that would cover it.
50:58 Speaker 04 It's another big news item this week.
50:59 Speaker 03 It's constantly. You're in it. This, you, perfect week. How did you arrange all this? You know, Universal is basically solving this problem by telling YouTube to make some stuff up, and have some like, private copyright enforcement system for Drake. YouTube will extract whatever concessions it wants to. That's not necessarily going to be able to a smaller label. It won't necessarily be available to independent artists without a label yet. It's not auditable. If YouTube makes a mistake in enforcement, there's no way to stop it. If a kid just wants to sound like Drake, and it's not an AI, should that be allowed? Lots of questions there. How are you thinking about that kind of idea?
51:35 Speaker 04 So, right now, we have... Two forms of protection. One form is that one of the reasons that the DSPs actually took that particular track down was that it was a violation of their agreement between Universal and the DSPs. There was a breach of contract there. The other is that there's a lot of attention around and disapproval just around this ability to create something that it sounds exactly like something else. Now, that's neither here nor there. What happened last week is the presentation, I think it was last week or two weeks ago,
52:17 Speaker 04 was the presentation of the No Fakes Act, which actually is an acronym that stands for name and likeness and, you know, all of that. Congresslessness. Yes. And that's being led by Schumer, I believe. And that's really what's in play right now. Obviously, it's not, you know, tomorrow, next week, this year thing even, but... I would say our current Congress is not well-suited to passing a complicated AI regulation. Exactly. Or doing anything. Yes, but at least that process has begun and there will be attention on that. I don't know if I have to believe this because of the business I'm in, but I really don't
52:56 Speaker 04 believe that we are operating in a business where the creative work and the artists and those creators are, the value is just going to be rendered zero. Yeah. I don't. So I'm going to have faith in the system and the people and an appreciation for art. What do you hear from your artists about it? What are they worried about? What are they asking you to fight for? They worry about their skill set being rendered obsolete. But at the same time, they are seeing efficiencies created in the studio with things that they can do and things that they can source and how...
53:41 Speaker 04 Engineering processes are accelerated and things like that. So there's a lot of B to B applications that are just not being talked about that are positive. You know, the focus is on this uncertainty around the machines are going to take over our lives. It's just not what I think is going to happen.
53:59 Speaker 03 Yeah. What do you think the near term future of the music industry looks like? What should people be on the lookout for? We're in a time of great change. What are the markers for you?
54:08 Speaker 04 I think that we're in a time of what's going to be a lot of creativity. I think we're in a time where a lot of people are focused on this globalization concept and a complete breakdown in barriers and just.
54:24 Speaker 03 Well, you have to say what globalization means. It's a great, it's a great term.
54:27 Speaker 04 Well, it came from Will Page's summary that, that white paper that he had written. And, you know, you have this world where all of these barriers are down and people have access to all different kinds of music. And so you have local music that's actually having a global impact. And so that's been really interesting to watch because we do have a business in the Middle East, then we have, represent a lot of artists out there. And there's going to be a lot of momentum in what's happening on that side of things. And we're interested in watching that. We're very focused on how culture moves, how culture moves from east to west and west to east. And that's something that I'd like to see shift and change.
55:04 Speaker 03 That's great. Well, Golnar, I could talk to you for hours and hours about this. I hope you can tell this has been great. Thank you so much for coming on Decoder.
55:10 Speaker 04 Thank you very much for having me. It was really an honor.
55:17 Speaker 03 I'd like to thank Golnar for taking the time to join Decoder today. She came all the way into our office to do it in studio with me, which was amazing. I'd also like to thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed the show. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of Decoder. You can email us at [email protected] . I read all the emails. Or you can hit me up on threads. I'm at reckless1280. We also have a TikTok, which is a ton of fun. Check it out, at DecoderPod. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like the show, hit us with that five star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt, who was edited by Callie Wright. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
56:00 Speaker 06 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every 5 seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
56:31 Speaker 07 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous Harvard professor Lawrence Lessig on why AI and social media are causing a free speech crisis for the internet Next Barack Obama on AI, free speech, and the future of the internet Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated