Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford examine the Hog Trail Murders, a series of killings in 1990s southwestern Florida linked to 72-year-old Daniel Owen Conahan Jr., who was convicted of murdering 21-year-old Richard Allen Montgomery. The hosts trace how survivors like Stanley Burden and David Payton came forward with terrifying accounts of being targeted by a man offering money for nude modeling before being bound with rope. Authorities connected Conahan through circumstantial evidence, rope marks, and matching paint chips, leading to a bench trial where Judge William Blackwell sentenced him to death. The hosts discuss the broader scope of victims, including the Hog Trail remains and the Fort Myers Eight, raising chilling questions about whether Conahan acted alone or if other predators operated in the area at the same time.
Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford open the episode with light banter about the weather and a brief intro to the case.
The hosts outline the geographic scope and the central figure, Daniel Owen Conahan Jr., scheduled for execution.
The hosts discuss the first discovered victims, their mutilations, and the pattern that links them to Conahan.
Conahan is arrested, charged, and chooses a bench trial, culminating in a death sentence.
Discussion of Conahan’s appeals, the scheduled execution, and the broader legal implications.
Hosts ponder whether other serial killers may have operated alongside Conahan in the same region.
The hosts conclude the episode, encouraging listeners to rate the show and stay tuned for future cases.
Trading Weather Complaintinsight
The hosts open the episode by discussing how Mike Ferguson's persistent rain in his area contrasts with Mike Morford's recent dry spell.
Stuck in the Mudstory
David Payton recounts how he accepted a ride from a stranger in a blue Mercury Capri who offered beer and weed before things took a suspicious turn.
Suspicious Valium Beerinsight
David suspected that Daniel Conahan spiked his open can of beer with crushed-up Valium pills after noticing the driver was not drinking.
Stanley Burden describes how a man who offered him $150 for nude photos instead tied him to a tree and tried to strangle him with rope.
An undercover detective in a park was propositioned by Conahan, who offered $7 to see his penis and $20 for oral sex.
Bench Trial Defense Strategystrategy
Conahan waived his jury right and opted for a bench trial, where Judge William Blackwell found him guilty in just 25 minutes.
The Body Dumping Groundsdebate
The hosts debate whether other killers might have dumped bodies in the remote Florida trails to intentionally shift police focus toward the Hog Trail murders.
“The first set of remains was identified due to a tattoo still visible on one man's shoulder.”
“He was convicted by a judge, not a jury, a judge, right? Heard all the evidence and convicted him, ultimately sentenced him to death.”
“The name is due to the remote locations, often near trails created by wild boars as they run through the woods.”
“The Fort Myers eight could have been killed by another person. And that's the thing about a case like this.”
8,158 words · 7 speakers
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated