Pod Insights Criminal The Christmas Fire About this episode The bodies of a woman and her child were found inside a burned house on Christmas Day, 1843. An autopsy showed that they’d died before the fire even started.
Alex Hortis's book is The Witch of New York.
Say hello on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter, The Accomplice. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more.
We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop.
Episode transcripts are posted on our website.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You know that feeling when the holidays are here at Starbucks?
0:03 Speaker 01 Welcome in. Peppermint mucus for Holly and Ivy? Thank you.
0:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, that one. Together is the best place to be, at Starbucks.
0:16 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Muccio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't. Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands, deep tech that changes the weather.
0:35 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand.
0:38 Speaker 01 We've got hardware that helps blind people see, and dairy? I never imagined my life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. This season is presented by Engine.
0:54 Speaker 03 On Christmas 1843, on Christmas night on Staten Island, there were a group of men that were walking towards the town's only tavern. One of them noticed smoke coming out of the kitchen chimney of Captain George Houseman. Didn't think much of it. There had been snow, and it might have been wet logs. But soon, a young kid comes down the road and yells, "Fire, fire, fire."
1:24 Speaker 04 Alex Hordes is a historian and lawyer.
1:27 Speaker 03 They run back. They arrive at this chaotic scene at the house. The back kitchen is on fire. There is flames spitting out of the windows, smoke billowing out. They break down the door. They find a way in. And inside, it's just a very intense fire. There was resin melting from the top. You know, it was permeated with smoke. Everything seemed to be on fire.
1:57 Speaker 04 Neighbors formed a line and started passing buckets of water from the nearest well. They were able to put the fire out. Three men volunteered to go into the house to check that the fire was fully out. Neighbors told them that the owner of the house, Captain Houseman, was out at sea on his oyster schooner, and that his wife, Emmeline Houseman, and their one-year-old daughter, Ann Eliza, were visiting relatives.
2:24 Speaker 04 When the volunteers entered the house, one of the men checked the kitchen.
2:28 Speaker 03 So as he's sifting through the ashes, he hits something hard. He initially thinks it's a sheep or a dog. Ends up being Emmeline Hausmann's torched and bludgeoned body.
2:43 Speaker 04 Next to her was the burned body of her daughter, Annalisa.
2:49 Speaker 04 The press reported that both bodies were wrapped in a blanket, but the blanket was barely burnt. They also reported that Emmeline's hands were tied with a silk black handkerchief in a sailor's knot.
3:05 Speaker 04 Captain George Hausmann returned from sea the next day.
3:10 Speaker 03 He docks his schooner, and then he's walking over to the ferryboat, and he literally runs into his sister Polly. It falls upon Polly to tell him the horrible news. They ride back in silence. He doesn't know what to say or think. He goes to the house, and all that's left is this burnt-out, scorched kitchen and the horrible remains of what was left of his family, Emmeline and Annalisa.
3:44 Speaker 04 The autopsy of the body found that Emmeline had a stab wound on her arm so deep that it fractured the bone. 18-month-old Annalisa's skull was completely fractured.
3:58 Speaker 04 They determined that the mother and daughter were murdered before the fire. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
4:13 Speaker 04 In the 1840s, Staten Island was mostly farmland. The farmers grew corn, wheat and potatoes for Manhattan in New Jersey. The first ferry service between Manhattan and Staten Island started only a few decades earlier. Only about 10,000 people lived on the island.
4:32 Speaker 03 Everyone knew everybody. But what was also distinct about Staten Island was just across the bay was the largest city in North America. And if you go over the hills, you could see some of the lights and all the ships going in and out from all over the world. So it was a very stark contrast between a very rural, small village that was connected to the great metropolis of the West.
5:04 Speaker 04 Captain George Houseman's family was one of the wealthiest and most important on the island. His father, Abraham, got rich from managing a granite quarry and farming oysters.
5:17 Speaker 03 He had a very prosperous oyster business. There was an oyster craze in New York, and so much of Staten Island's economy was feeding New York oysters.
5:27 Speaker 04 Abraham had eight children. George Houseman was his second son. And Alex Horder says George was closest to his younger sister, Polly. Polly got married when she was 15 to a 24-year-old man named Andrew Bedine.
5:45 Speaker 03 It was considered sort of a match made in heaven because it was a marriage between two great clans on Staten Island, and clans meant everything on Staten Island. And these were families that predated the formation of the United States, and in the case of the Housemans, predated even the English arriving.
6:05 Speaker 04 Polly and Andrew moved to a little house on the ocean. And within a year of getting married, had their first son. Soon after, they had a daughter. But after three years, their marriage fell apart.
6:18 Speaker 03 He ends up being a drunk, ends up being abusive towards her, and ends up spending all the family money. So she separates from him. And in the 1840s, this is, if not unheard of, it's certainly scandalous.
6:33 Speaker 04 Polly could only divorce Andrew if she could prove adultery, which would have been an expensive process, attracting even more attention from people in town.
6:44 Speaker 04 So instead, Polly decided to move in with her father, Abraham. Her brother George lived next door with his wife and daughter.
6:52 Speaker 03 He has a schooner business, but he's away at sea for long stretches of time.
6:58 Speaker 04 Polly and her daughter, Elizabeth, would walk across the yard and keep Emily in company while her husband George was away. Polly also spent a lot of her time in Manhattan. Her son Albert had an apprenticeship at an apothecary shop in Lower Manhattan. But Polly wasn't just visiting her son. She was having an affair with his boss. His name was George Waite.
7:24 Speaker 03 George Waite is a 30-something sort of merchant prince. He owns his own apothecary just off Broadway. Broadway is the commercial emporium of the Western world at this point. And she would go in, come for a long weekend, and travel back usually on Monday or Tuesday, back to Staten Island.
7:46 Speaker 04 Rumors began spreading about Polly. Soon, she found out she was pregnant. They decided to keep it a secret.
7:53 Speaker 03 They had no idea that the whole entire country would, in a few weeks, know about their adulterous relationship.
8:03 Speaker 04 We'll be right back.
8:19 Speaker 04 Support for Criminal comes from Wayfair. Improving your home doesn't need to be complicated. You can make a whole room feel different with just one new piece from Wayfair. If you have boxes of old books or collectibles in storage, you can find a great Wayfair shelf to display them on. Or if you want to get in the spirit of the holidays early, they have plenty of holiday-themed decor for you to choose from. They have thousands of products across every style and budget. I got a Wayfair shelf myself when I needed to organize my studio. It's great for storing all the books and notes I go through when I'm researching stories and makes my space look neat and put together. Find pieces made for real life and get even more
9:00 Speaker 04 value with Wayfair Rewards. Join Wayfair Rewards today to get 5% back on every purchase. Head to wayfair.com to shop all things home. That's W A Y F A I R dot com.
9:13 Speaker 00 Wayfair, every style, every home.
9:18 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Muccio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't.
9:29 Speaker 00 I definitely start to blank out when we're talking about like middleware AI wrappers.
9:35 Speaker 01 Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands.
9:40 Speaker 05 We're building Eight Sleep for daytime.
9:42 Speaker 01 Hardware that helps blind people see.
9:44 Speaker 06 They kept asking for middle finger. Next thing we knew, we had like 10 students running around flipping each other off.
9:50 Speaker 01 We've got deep tech to change the weather.
9:52 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand.
9:55 Speaker 07 What if you wanted to not make it rain somewhere else? Like, one day, we're just like, screw Arizona.
10:03 Speaker 01 And dairy? I never imagined my life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. This season is presented by Engine.
10:16 Speaker 04 What was the Penny Press?
10:18 Speaker 03 The Penny Press were the first newspapers to appeal to a mass popular audience. This was revolutionary at the time because before that, there were these really kind of dull merchant publications. They would carry stock prices, or they would carry official news, maybe some news from Washington, but they did not have a wide audience. So at the same time, the Penny Press papers were a penny, so they were affordable for the working person. The founders of it had this fantastic idea that you don't have to wait and sit back for subscriptions. You can sell it on the streets. So they start hawking the news. These are the first newsboys. And so they're selling to anybody who comes
10:58 Speaker 03 along and initially gets a working class audience, but then it becomes so popular and so addictive to get this. Different kind of newspaper that it goes all the way up to the upper classes of New York City, the mayor, everyone was reading the penny press. So when made the penny press very different, it would cover murder and suicides. It would cover scandals. It was about sex. It was really, in many ways, the forerunners to our current tabloids.
11:28 Speaker 04 The first penny press was printed in New York in 1833, and other cities followed. In 1835, a newspaper man named James Gordon Bennett founded one of New York's largest penny presses, The New York Herald. He claimed, "What Shakespeare did for drama, such shall I do for the daily newspaper press." The penny press headlines were catchy and vague, like, "Highly important if true," or, "From Florida, more murders," and, "Another one gone." The stories were not always accurate. In the mid-1830s, one penny paper reported a
12:11 Speaker 04 series of articles that an astronomer had found evidence of unicorns, two-legged beavers, and creatures that were part human and part bat on the moon.
12:21 Speaker 03 Everyone, from longshoremen, rope makers, to ladies in smoking parlors, to the mayor, to anyone who could read, was starting to pick up the penny press, and they loved these stories.
12:37 Speaker 04 On December 27, 1843, two days after the bodies of Captain George Houseman's wife and daughter were discovered, the Herald's headline read, "Destructive Conflagration at Port Richmond: Two Lives Lost." A rival paper's headline read, "Horrible Affair: Mysterious Murder and Arson at Staten Island."
13:02 Speaker 04 The police had barely started their investigation and hadn't made any announcements. But James Gordon Bennett published that a gang had killed Emmeline and her daughter.
13:12 Speaker 03 Gangs were very much a concern in New York City. And they would kind of roam through the streets, committing crimes, occasionally committing murders. He really didn't have much of anything to go on when he said that.
13:27 Speaker 04 The New York Daily Tribune reported that Emmeline had also been gagged, which wasn't true. But among Emmeline's family, there was a suspect, and it was Polly Bedine. Emmeline's father knew that Polly Bedine was the last person who Emmeline was seen alive with. And he began telling people that Polly murdered his daughter.
13:54 Speaker 03 The other thing that aroused his suspicion was George Hausmann had carried around $1,000 in silver coins at the time, which was a considerable amount of money, in big bags. And he had suspected that Polly had somehow tried to rob the money from Emmeline.
14:13 Speaker 04 At this point, the investigators didn't have any other real leads.
14:17 Speaker 03 Polly Bedine subsequently becomes the primary suspect. The reasons for this are a mix of rumor and some troubling facts. First of all, she's led a scandalous life. Her character is, quote, "considered low." And so she was always held to be suspicious. When authorities look at Polly, they find out about the relationship with George Wade.
14:45 Speaker 04 The police took George Wade in for questioning.
14:47 Speaker 03 He eventually quickly confesses to say that he had a relationship with Polly Bedine. They find a very suspicious note on him when they search him, written from Polly, which, quote, "says, 'Hide the things.'" This really alarms the authorities. They search the apothecary of George Wade, and they find this coral necklace that belonged to the infant, Annalisa, one of the victims.
15:19 Speaker 04 They arrested George Wait and started looking for Polly.
15:23 Speaker 03 Polly is in her father's house. Her brother-in-law comes in out of the rain and says essentially, Polly, you know, everybody thinks that you're the murderer. She immediately gets up. She goes to the back room. She gets her shawl and she takes off into the rain as she's eight months pregnant. She walks the length of Staten Island all night long. In the early morning hours, she's seen taking the Staten Island ferry, the Staten Islander over to Manhattan.
15:56 Speaker 04 Finally Polly went inside a restaurant where the owner saw her, pregnant and soaking wet, and offered her food and a bed. Polly said as she was falling asleep, she overheard other guests talking about a murder on Staten Island and that the authorities were looking for a woman suspect. She left and continued walking.
16:18 Speaker 03 And then she walks all the way up to Harlem, which at the time were country estates. So she, over the course of two days, she essentially walks a marathon in the cold and rain as she's eight months pregnant.
16:35 Speaker 04 Polly found a church where she could finally sleep. When she woke up, she continued roaming Manhattan. Then someone she knew recognized her and told Polly that the police were looking for her.
16:49 Speaker 03 And he talks her into giving herself up. She hasn't been charged yet, but they treat her like a fugitive.
16:56 Speaker 04 They took her to Manhattan's prison, the Tombs, and transferred her to the Staten Island jail. That day, the editor of the New York Herald, James Gordon Bennett, published a story about Polly.
17:10 Speaker 03 He went into George Wait's apothecary and he detailed evidence that Polly had essentially been sleeping with George Wait.
17:19 Speaker 04 The Herald reported that they found a nightcap, nightgown and hair, similar to Polly's color, in George's bedroom. Soon, all of the papers started publishing their own accounts of what happened. One reported that Polly had poisoned Emmeline with a dose of acid. Another used Polly's separation from her husband and her "bad" character as signs that she probably committed the murder. Another reported that Polly had confessed. She hadn't. A few days after her arrest, Polly went into labor alone in her jail cell and delivered a stillborn baby. One word got out.
18:02 Speaker 04 A penny paper reported that Polly had smothered her own child. James Gordon Bennett of The Herald printed that Polly had nearly a half dozen abortions during her relationship with George Wade.
18:16 Speaker 03 George Wade is an apothecary, of course, off of Broadway, so he sold abortifacients at the time, these herbal remedies which are very dangerous and noxious. So he is rumored to have procured, you know, maybe half a dozen abortions. There's really no proof of that. There's no way that the press could approve that, but they ran with the story anyway.
18:39 Speaker 04 During the investigation, the editors of the penny papers petitioned the commissioner and the district attorney to let the press observe the witness examinations. Previously, press weren't allowed to sit in on those proceedings. But James Gordon Bennett argued that the press was the living jury of the nation. The district attorney and the commissioner allowed it. From his jail cell, George Wade knew the penny press was writing about him. He was being charged as an accessory after the murders. He decided to publish a letter in the papers claiming his own innocence. He wrote he had no idea how Captain Houseman's daughter, Annaliese Beads, had ended up
19:24 Speaker 04 in his shop. And George did not come to Polly's defense.
19:31 Speaker 04 Polly's trial was scheduled for June 1844, five months after she was arrested. One reporter predicted that it would be a mess. Quote, "They manage these matters wretchedly in New York." That reporter was at Grouland Poe.
19:50 Speaker 03 At this point, he's a newsman, so he's writing essays for The Columbia Spy. But he was also very interested in crime. And he becomes fascinated with the idea of being essentially an amateur detective. And becomes fascinated in this idea that I can solve crimes using logic reported in the newspapers, and I can use deductive logic to solve crimes.
20:13 Speaker 04 He even invented a word for this way of thinking: "radiocination," the idea of using logic more than just facts to solve a crime. In post-detective stories, the main characters used radiocination to solve crimes police couldn't.
20:31 Speaker 03 So he's already writing detective stories. He writes the first detective story, The Murders in the Rue Morgue, in which this detective Dupan, who becomes his alter ego and becomes the first Sherlock Holmes character, solves an unsolvable crime. And then he comes across the Polly Bodine case. He's following it very carefully. And then he goes on and he criticizes the police. And he decides that Polly Bodine's clearly guilty, but he believes that the authorities will undoubtedly mess it up.
21:07 Speaker 04 To him, the police seemed, quote, "blown about in all directions by every varying puff of the most unconsidered newspaper opinion." The trial of Polly Bodine began on June 24, 1844, on Staten Island.
21:25 Speaker 03 As soon as The Herald and The Sun started reporting on the trial, it caused a huge furor. So people from Manhattan, people from Long Island, people from New Jersey, they all flocked to Little Staten Island and its courthouse. The case against Polly Boudin at that trial is largely circumstantial, but it's fairly extensive.
21:51 Speaker 04 The prosecution argued that Polly murdered Emmeline and Annalisa the night before Christmas Eve, stole their belongings, and then returned on Christmas to set fire to their house. They called a relative of Polly's who testified that she heard a scream coming from Emmeline's home the night the prosecution said she committed the murder. A neighbor said she saw Polly go to Emmeline's house that same night, but never saw Emmeline alive after that. She also said that the morning of Christmas Eve, she saw Polly leaving Emmeline's home with a shawl over her head. The prosecution also called two Staten Island ferry workers
22:35 Speaker 04 who said they saw Polly taking the ferry to Manhattan the morning after the murders were discovered. They said they noticed her because she ordered a slice of cake and a gin so early in the morning. Then Polly's son Albert took the stand. He was 16. He'd been subpoenaed. He said he didn't know where his mother was for part of the day on Christmas. Polly told him she was going to a neighbor's home, but that neighbor testified she never saw Polly.
23:09 Speaker 03 One of the key pieces of evidence that had come out was some pawn brokers had answered a reward in the newspapers and had said that somebody had come on Christmas Day. This is several hours before the murders were discovered. It had pawned Emmeline's valuables. So it raises the obvious question, how in the world were those goods pawned half a day before the bodies were discovered? How did it have somebody who had access to the house?
23:43 Speaker 04 Before the trial, authorities brought the pawnbrokers to the Staten Island jail, where Polly was being held.
23:50 Speaker 03 But what they did was, they had her dress up in her outfit that they had caught her with, and they brought the pawnbrokers to this lone cell. She was the only person there. There was no lineup. Like, you'd have, today, you would have to have a lineup. Otherwise, it'd be considered unduly suggestive. And he said, you know, basically said, "This is who we think it is, is that her." And they all said it was her.
24:15 Speaker 04 In her defense, Polly's attorneys told the jury that it was George Wade, the apothecary, who had committed the murders.
24:23 Speaker 03 And her family, Polly Bedine's family, the housemen, say, "George Wade's the killer. Polly's innocent. George Wade essentially killed her for money."
24:31 Speaker 04 The defense also argued that Polly wouldn't kill Emmeline and her niece because they were so close.
24:38 Speaker 03 Was this defense's strongest point in many ways. She had actually delivered Annalisa, the young girl, an 18-month-old girl. Why in the world would Polly Bedine murder her 18-month-old niece over Christmas? Why would she murder her sister-in-law? The prosecution suggested that Polly was, in fact, in financial distress. The problem with this is that Polly came from a wealthy family.
25:07 Speaker 04 So what is the verdict?
25:09 Speaker 03 There was an eccentric juror, who actually was a fairly prosperous farmer on Staten Island, and he holds out, and he says, "I'm not going to convict her under your circumstances." There were some reports that he had been opposed to the death penalty. And so, they have an all-night deliberation. And remember, these jurors, you know, they're, these are not comfortable beds here. They're in a very small jury room. They don't have much to eat. They have bread and water. They used to actually withhold bread and water from jurors till they reached a decision. But, he's the lone holdout. Everyone else votes to convict. He literally jumps out the window and runs away.
25:54 Speaker 04 We'll be right back.
26:10 Speaker 04 Support for Criminal comes from Mint Mobile. Some things appear too good to be true, but a $15 monthly phone plan isn't one of them. Mint Mobile has affordable, premium wireless plans, and they include high-speed data and unlimited talk and text. And they make signing up easy. You can do it all online. We have a friend who switched to Mint Mobile. He said that it's a great deal, and he liked that he didn't necessarily need to get a new phone or phone number when he switched. To get your new wireless plan for just $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com/Phoebe. That's mintmobile.com/Phoebe. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at mintmobile.com/Phoebe. That's it. There's no catch. $45 upfront payment required, equivalent to $15 a month.
26:54 Speaker 04 New customers on first three-month plan only. Speeds slower above 40GB on a limited plan. Additional taxes, fees, and restrictions apply. See Mint Mobile for details.
27:11 Speaker 04 Support for Criminal comes from Talkiatory. Mental health support can come in many forms, but it's not always easy to access. Talkiatory is different. It can help you find a psychiatrist, and it makes the experience simpler and more flexible. You can find someone who takes the time to get to know you and provides a clear, personalized treatment plan. Talkiatory is 100% online psychiatry practice. They provide comprehensive evaluations, diagnoses, and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, and more. Unlike therapy-only platforms, Talkiatory is psychiatry. That means your medical provider is qualified to diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication whenever it's appropriate.
27:55 Speaker 04 Head to talkiatory.com/criminal to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y.com/criminal to get matched in minutes. Talkiatory.com/criminal.
28:16 Speaker 04 After the jury failed to reach a unanimous decision because one juror ran away, they had to start over. A second trial was scheduled. The court couldn't find 12 jurors on Staten Island who hadn't already read everything about the case in the penny papers. So they moved the second trial to Manhattan.
28:35 Speaker 03 And it becomes this enormous social event. It far attracted women spectators far more than men. They'd be dressed up in the latest stylish outfits. They'd be eating lunches. They'd bring their children. They treat it like a show, essentially. On the first day of trial, there was a near riot and the police had to beat down spectators because it had caused such strong feelings about it. It's really the first case in which the entire country is following details of the case. And you have very able reporters that are transcribing it and doing very detailed day-to-day trial testimony.
29:15 Speaker 04 The head of a museum down the street from where Polly's trial was held, a man named P.T. Barnum, noticed all the excitement. P.T. Barnum, short for Phineas Taylor, had started his career with a traveling musical, Barnum's Grand Scientific and Musical Theater. He bought a museum in Lower Manhattan. It featured exhibits like the Siamese twins Chang and Ang, an alleged orangutan's torso with a fishtail that he called Fiji Mermaid, and bearded ladies.
29:50 Speaker 03 So he creates this disgusting wax figure of Polly, essentially as this old witch, killing Emmeline and Annalisa. In the American Museum, he advertises this during her trials. There are undoubtedly were many, many thousands of people who saw both this horrible wax figure and then went over and sat in the trial, which was only about two blocks away.
30:17 Speaker 04 The museum called the wax figure a faithful representation of the celebrated Polly Boudin.
30:24 Speaker 03 Curiously, P T Barnum was not, you know, probably trying to endanger. He wasn't a bloodthirsty person. He opposed the death penalty, but he also knew he believed in selling tickets. That was his modus operandi. And so he really becomes one of the first people to make true crime entertainment.
30:43 Speaker 04 It cost 25 cents to see the wax figure. The real Polly was down the street in court.
30:50 Speaker 03 Trial goes on extremely long, about five weeks. And the defense pulls out all the stops in this case. The defense floats the idea for the first time that it was a gang in New York. The Bowery Boys, the Dead Rabbits, the Roach Guard. These were menacing street thugs.
31:09 Speaker 04 The Dead Rabbits and the Roach Guard were Irish gangs in New York City. Their rivals were the Bowery Boys, an anti-Irish gang in Manhattan's Bowery neighborhood. They were known for committing crimes like looting and starting riots throughout the city. The longest riot, a fight between the Dead Rabbits and the Bowery Boys lasted two days. Eight people died. New Yorkers were scared of the gangs, and the defense knew that. Then the defense brought forward Polly's sister, Caroline. She testified that she had seen Emmeline alive the day after the prosecution, claimed Polly had murdered her.
31:51 Speaker 03 This is a big problem for the prosecution. It disrupts their timeline.
31:55 Speaker 04 Polly's niece also testified that she saw Emmeline on Sunday morning. She said she knew it was her by the way her arms were swinging when she walked.
32:05 Speaker 03 These two witnesses are enormous problem for the prosecution, and Polly then starts to have less opportunity, less of a window to cover the murders.
32:15 Speaker 04 Polly's lawyer also had an answer to why Polly lied to her son about her whereabouts the night of the murder.
32:21 Speaker 03 He said that Polly was going to a place to deal with her pregnancy, where there's euphemisms for an abortion, or alternatively, there were these houses where women gave up their children. He calls no witnesses to substantiate this, but it's a brilliant way because he knew how to play to the press. He knew that people cared about abortion. He knew people would pay attention to this. It was plausible, you know, on its face at least, for why then she would have lied to her son. It gives her, quote, "an alibi," but of course, there actually is no alibi witness. But he knows he has to play to the press. He's very good at manipulating the press.
33:04 Speaker 04 Polly's lawyer asked Polly to dress in black from head to toe to show that she was in mourning for her sister-in-law and niece. Outside City Hall, New Yorkers debated the case. Gamblers in Brooklyn took bets on the verdict.
33:21 Speaker 03 There are some jurors that want a manslaughter conviction because the cause of death, the prosecution never could really prove the exact cause of death. They might have been bludgeon. It might have been something else, poisoning.
33:37 Speaker 04 The jury settled on a murder conviction with a recommendation that she not be executed. She was sentenced to life in prison. But in response to the verdict, the Washington Union wrote, "Whosever shedeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed." Polly's defense attorney appealed the case to the New York Supreme Court. He argued that the jury in the second trial had been influenced by the penny press. He said, "No man knows the degree of credit which he attaches to a rumor or report." The court granted the appeal. The court interviewed 4,000 potential jurors,
34:22 Speaker 04 but couldn't find 12 people who said they were unbiased. Polly's lawyers asked to move the trial out of the city to a small town of 9,000 people upstate called Newburgh. But reporters in New York City kept writing about the case and calling for Polly's death. And at the Brooklyn Eagle, a young reporter in his 20s named Walt Whitman had been following along. A decade before Leaves of Grass, Walt Whitman had been covering executions and joined the anti-Gallows movement.
34:56 Speaker 03 He had long opposed the death penalty and was radically opposed to the death penalty. And in part is because he had sort of a radical Christian sympathy.
35:08 Speaker 04 In his reporting on Polly's case, he called it a vindictive penalty and described Polly as a miserable creature being dragged from prison to prison. He went on to write, "Who cannot look upon her and not pity the pale, withered, glassy-eyed woman, whatever her guilt may have been?"
35:28 Speaker 03 So he projects his own kind of ideological views onto the case, just as Edgar Allan Poe projected his views about how the police should conduct investigations onto the case, and just as how many people on the abortion issue project their views onto the case. What this all had to do with her guilt or innocence, you know, very tenuous. In the last trial, the prosecution suffers from a number of problems. First of all, it's the third trial, and these witnesses are tired of being abused. Their names are run in the newspapers, they're savaged under cross-examination.
36:02 Speaker 04 One of the ferry workers and a pawnbroker dropped out of the trial.
36:07 Speaker 03 What also happened was Newburgh got turned off by all this vitriol towards Polly. There was this scandalous pamphlet that had made up, you know, these stories about her being a harlot, basically. And the people of Newburgh were just so turned off by the red meat press at the time that they start swinging sympathetically towards Polly as if she were a victim. And so they acquit.
36:36 Speaker 04 At the Brooklyn Eagle, Walt Whitman wrote that this case proved that the death penalty should be abolished. The National Police Gazette blamed the death penalty abolition movement for her acquittal.
36:49 Speaker 03 And so Polly is let go eventually, the following year, but in essence, she's not free because the people on Staten Island all believe that she's guilty. She lives in this small cottage. She never leaves Staten Island, and she is sort of this recluse. There are rumors about her, and she lives out her very long life as a recluse on Staten Island, still shunned.
37:18 Speaker 04 Some people on the island claimed that she eventually confessed to the murder. Visitors would travel to the site of the murders to see the kitchen where the victims were found. Her wax figure at Barnum's American Museum stayed up until the museum's closure in 1865. In the book, Heads Faces and How to Study Them, phrenologists analyzed the physical qualities of criminals and concluded that Polly was one. They wrote that her face lacked the loving mouth, the lips looked punched, critical, fault-finding, unloving and unlovable, and that her nose was long, sharp, inquisitive,
38:00 Speaker 04 and inclined to interfere and disagree. Five years after her acquittal, Polly, who'd been written about extensively for years, wrote something herself. It was published in the New York Herald, the paper that had called her "a wretched woman" and "the living embodiment of despair." The paper published an inaccurate story that she was peddling fruit in Philadelphia hotels. She wrote to the editor, James Gordon Bennett, and said she was a daily reader of his entertaining paper, but she said she wasn't selling fruit, and asked for a correction. Quote, "You, as a gentleman, will oblige me." The New York Herald retracted the story.
39:01 Speaker 04 Criminal is created by Lauren Spoor and me. Nidia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susanna Roberson, Jackie Sajikko, Lilly Clark, Lena Silson, and Gabrielle Burbay. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti. This episode was mixed by Emma Munger. Julian Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. And you can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com/newsletter. We hope you'll join our membership program, Criminal Plus. Once you sign up, you can listen to Criminal episodes without any ads, and you'll get
39:43 Speaker 04 bonus episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spoor, too. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com/plus. We're on Facebook and Twitter at Criminal Show and Instagram at Criminal underscore Podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com/criminalpodcast. Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
40:16 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Muccio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't.
40:28 Speaker 00 I definitely start to blank out when we're talking about like middleware AI wrappers.
40:33 Speaker 01 Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands.
40:38 Speaker 05 We're building Eight Sleep for daytime.
40:41 Speaker 01 Hardware that helps blind people see.
40:43 Speaker 06 They kept asking for middle finger. Next thing we knew, we had like 10 students running around flipping each other off.
40:48 Speaker 01 We've got deep tech to change the weather.
40:50 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand.
40:54 Speaker 07 What if you wanted to not make it rain somewhere else? Like, one day, we're just like, screw Arizona.
41:00 Speaker 01 And dairy. I never imagined. My life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
41:11 Speaker 01 This season is presented by Engine.
41:14 Speaker 00 Life can be messy and complicated, especially during the holidays. One thing that isn't: switching to the Simplicity Plan from Verizon. It's one plan, one price. Just $30 a line per month, for you or the whole family. Make the simple choice this season. Switch to Verizon and shop their best holiday deals today.
Previous Turtle vs. Toilet, a Monster in the Closet, and a Surprise Possum Next Moon Rocks Wanted Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated