Pod Insights Criminal Extraordinary and Compelling Reasons About this episode In 1993, Gary Settle was sentenced to 177 years in prison. Twenty-six years into his sentence, he started helping other inmates get out of prison through something called compassionate release - a policy that allows people in prison to petition to be let out for “extraordinary and compelling” reasons.
You can learn more about Gary Settle in Anna Altman’s piece, "The Quality of Mercy," in The Atavist Magazine.
Say hello on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter, The Accomplice. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more.
We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop.
Episode transcripts are posted on our website.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from FAIRE. If you have your own store, you don't want your shelves to be stocked with generic products that your customers could get anywhere. FAIRE makes it easy to stock your shelves with the unique, high-quality products for more than 100,000 small businesses. Sign up today and get 50% off your first wholesale order, up to $100, at FAIRE.com/criminal. That's FAIRE.com/criminal. Terms may apply. Support for Criminal comes from FAIRE. If you have your own store, you don't want your shelves to be stocked with generic products that your customers could get anywhere. FAIRE makes it easy to stock your shelves with the unique, high-quality products for
0:44 Speaker 00 more than 100,000 small businesses. Sign up today and get 50% off your first wholesale order, up to $100, at FAIRE.com/criminal. That's FAIRE.com/criminal. Terms may apply.
1:05 Speaker 00 Okay, well, here we are. Well, let's just start with you introducing yourself.
1:11 Speaker 01 Okay. My name is Gary Settle. You want my current situation?
1:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, where are we right now?
1:18 Speaker 01 These nice ladies have come to visit me at FMC Butner, which is a federal prison hospital in North Carolina.
1:25 Speaker 00 Butner is one of seven federal prisons that houses inmates with significant health issues. Bernie Madoff was treated at Butner. So was Ted Kaczynski. Gary Settle has been in prison since 1993. What's your day-to-day life like here?
1:42 Speaker 01 Um, all right, well, it's just like any prison. We're confined to our cells for a part overnight and for different parts of the day. But for me, I get up in the morning, get my medication together and all that. I have a class at 12:30, living with chronic illness, that I'm a mentor in that class too. Then I'm hopefully gonna get outside and get some fresh air.
2:08 Speaker 00 How long can you go outside for a day?
2:10 Speaker 01 Um, the chemo I'm on, it causes me to flushing. And my face will get purple if I stay out too long. But I generally get a couple hours a day anyway. Sometimes more. As it cools off, I'll probably get a little bit more.
2:23 Speaker 00 And what time do you have to be in your cell at night?
2:26 Speaker 01 Eight thirty.
2:28 Speaker 01 And they open the doors around six in the morning. And most of the day we're out. We have a little hour period of time in the middle of the day where they count. But every three weeks I do immunotherapy on a Wednesday and chemotherapy on a Friday.
2:42 Speaker 01 And I have some other issues. So I have appointments throughout the week. But for the most part, I do a lot of reading,
2:50 Speaker 01 communicate with my friends and family, and sit around and wait.
2:56 Speaker 00 Wait for what?
2:58 Speaker 01 Either to go home or die. I mean, that's because I don't think I'll leave here again.
3:07 Speaker 00 In 2018, after he'd been in prison for over two decades, he went to the doctor for a checkup. At the time, he said he felt weird. His blood work came back abnormal. The doctors did a biopsy that showed he likely had prostate cancer.
3:26 Speaker 00 Gary was transferred to a prison with medical facilities, Butner Federal Correctional Complex in North Carolina. While we were waiting to go see Gary, we watched doctors come in wearing protective vests over their scrubs and putting their stethoscopes through the metal detector. How are you feeling?
3:46 Speaker 01 About like you'd expect after six years of treatment.
3:52 Speaker 01 I'll say this. I'm better off than some of the poor guys I see up there on the floor. When I first came here, I had never really been around sick people. It's strange to say, but in the institutions I was incarcerated in, they were all pretty, everybody was pretty healthy. When you were gone, when you were sick, you came to a place like this.
4:12 Speaker 00 People, Butner, when you hear Butner, people have heard about this place before. It's not a little unknown prison somewhere. I mean, this place has a reputation.
4:22 Speaker 01 Yes. It's ironic. My first day here, people get newspapers and they'll leave them laying around for the next person. My first day here, I picked up the USA Today and I looked in around the state section and it had a lawsuit, Butner, this place had just paid someone because the guy came here and lost his vision.
4:41 Speaker 00 The man, Vinar Nar, knew he had a degenerative eye disease. According to the lawsuit, as his eyesight got worse, he repeatedly asked staff for treatment. By the time he did see a surgeon, the doctor said he urgently needed an operation and scheduled it for the next day, but it was too late. We asked Butner about this. The Bureau of Prisons replied saying that, for privacy reasons, they could not comment.
5:11 Speaker 01 And I don't want to criticize the medical staff here, per se, but it's a bureaucracy. And I probably had cancer. I probably had this cancer for a year or two before I was diagnosed, because you don't get the normal test that a normal person would get.
5:26 Speaker 00 When you heard that you were going to be moved here to Butner, what did you think?
5:31 Speaker 01 That's when I really realized that there was really something wrong with me. Because in a regular, I keep saying a regular prison, but a normal prison that's designed for security reasons more so than medical, like this is, you didn't get a lot of medical treatment there because you didn't need it. So when I knew that they took the step to bring me here, that I was worse off than what I thought.
5:54 Speaker 00 You know, I've always thought about this. My father had cancer and I was with him when he was having chemo and radiation. And he was really sick after you'd get chemo or the radiation. And we'd take him home and I would be trying to get him to eat and drink and he'd be nauseous and feeling, and I'd be trying to feed him anything I could to get him to...
6:16 Speaker 00 Does that happen here when you finish your treatments? So they giving you lots of food options and?
6:22 Speaker 01 No, see, I did the 42 radiation treatments first. And now I've done 12 rounds of chemo and six rounds of immunotherapy.
6:30 Speaker 01 No, they don't give us a lot of food options. And it's so strange, the more I've read into my own cancer, I found out that sugar isn't really bad for cancer. Well, the options that we can buy on the commissary here, which is the inmate store, it's predominantly sugar items. We can't buy any fresh produce. And there's security concerns, and I understand all that. But I just always thought that a place like this that was designed for medical cases, for the most part, that you should have healthy alternatives here that might not be available in a place that didn't have medical conditions. But nobody listens to me.
7:04 Speaker 00 And if you've had a hard chemo treatment, is someone checking up on you? Is someone saying, you know, Gary, let me, what can I bring you? I see that you're, you know, struggling, you know?
7:17 Speaker 01 So a lot of us rely on each other. And so there's like little support groups. And they have inmate workers here that do a good job, too. The ICPs are inmate cadre program, I think it is. But a lot of us take care, check on each other. And it's about the best you could do.
7:36 Speaker 00 They would push each other in wheelchairs if they were having trouble walking to meals or to doctor's appointments or to use the bathroom.
7:43 Speaker 01 It's fundamental to how I was raised in my family. It's part of how I am. And the staff doesn't do a bad job, but they're overworked, understaffed.
7:53 Speaker 00 In 2019, Gary happened to read an email newsletter from an organization called Families Against Mandatory Minimums. There was a new law called the First Step Act. It included changes to the minimum amount of time judges could sentence people for some drug-related crimes. Correctional officers could no longer use restraints on pregnant inmates. And it ordered the Bureau of Prisons to assign inmates to prisons as close to their home as possible. It also changed how inmates could apply for something called compassionate release.
8:34 Speaker 00 Compassionate release was introduced in 1984. It allows the director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons to ask a judge to reduce an inmate's sentence for extraordinary and compelling circumstances, like terminal illness and serious health issues related to old age. In 2019, The New York Times reported that about 20% of people in prison were 50 years old or older. Researchers say that people in prison age faster than people outside of prison, so in many cases, age 50 and up is considered elderly. But most prisons weren't designed to support aging inmates' health needs.
9:18 Speaker 02 You know, people are still required to walk far to get their pills, or they might not be able to have the same kind of pain medication or with the same frequency. And so the ability to provide a comforting environment is certainly circumscribed by the prison environment.
9:41 Speaker 00 Anna Altman is a journalist who's written about compassionate release.
9:45 Speaker 02 People who have been in prison for a long time, which many people who are dying in prison have been in prison a long time, they don't necessarily trust the system that is containing them, and they don't therefore necessarily trust the doctors that are employed by that system to care for them. So they don't know if they're getting full information, they might not be able to request certain things. And so there isn't a feeling that they are able to advocate for themselves, or ask for the medication, or the comfort measures that might make them more comfortable in their final days. And so I do think it's a different experience of receiving hospice or palliative care in a prison setting than it would be in the community.
10:29 Speaker 00 Before the First Step Act, prisoners had to apply for compassionate release from their warden, who could choose to send it up the chain until it reached the director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons. The BOP would review the requests and decide whether to approve or deny them. If they were approved, the application would be seen by a judge.
10:49 Speaker 02 In practice, what that meant was that someone might request from the warden that they go home, because let's say they had a terminal cancer diagnosis or they were on dialysis or something of that variety. But the warden didn't have to respond. The warden could basically put that piece of paper in a drawer and forget about it. And if that happened, the prisoner had nothing that they could do about it.
11:13 Speaker 00 Between 2013 and 2017, The Marshall Project and The New York Times found that out of 5,400 requests for compassionate release, the Bureau approved 6% of applications. They usually only approved them if an inmate had a terminal illness with less than one year to live. One report found that over a span of six years, 13% of prisoners died before finding out about their application. In 2018, the process changed. The First Step Act allowed inmates to petition a judge on their own if the BOP denied their application or if they didn't respond to it within 30 days.
11:58 Speaker 00 In the newsletter about the new law that Gary Settle was reading, Families Against Mandatory Minimums mentioned something called "the compassionate release clearinghouse."
12:09 Speaker 02 Which was basically the system that they set up where they had pro bono lawyers and federal defenders who were willing to work with prisoners to help them apply for compassionate release.
12:18 Speaker 00 Gary didn't think he qualified, but he realized that many of the inmates at Butner did, like one man named Bobby Smith.
12:27 Speaker 01 He weighed about 90 pounds. And he had a feeding tube. And he had lung cancer because he couldn't eat. And he would have cough so bad that he would expel the feeding tube. He was one of the guys we were watching because he had good and bad days. And...
12:43 Speaker 01 Like I said, he had lung cancer and he ended up getting pneumonia on top of that. And I asked him, hey, you know, this organization, you know, they're willing to look at your stuff to see if you have any, as we would say, anything coming in court. And it was, it's like, you don't find many atheists in a foxhole. You're not going to find many people on that floor that'll turn down help if someone says, hey, you want to take a shot to see if you can go home?
13:08 Speaker 00 Bobby was in the hospice ward at Butner. The doctors thought he had less than a year to live.
13:14 Speaker 01 He couldn't even get on the computer. He couldn't type, so I was interacting for him.
13:18 Speaker 00 Gary wrote an email to Families Against Mandatory Minimums, FAM for short, to see if they could help Bobby. FAM found a lawyer to help Bobby, but the lawyer wasn't able to get updated information from the BOP about how Bobby was doing. Gary would provide updates, telling the lawyer when one of Bobby's lungs had collapsed and when Bobby was taken to a hospital outside of the prison for treatment.
13:44 Speaker 02 The lawyer was able to get that information in front of a judge so that the judge could grant Mr. Smith's release.
13:51 Speaker 00 Gary remembers that the judge made the decision while Bobby was still in the hospital. When Bobby got back to Butner, Gary told him he was going home. He says Bobby didn't know what to say.
14:04 Speaker 02 For FAM, they had always had this idea that if the law changed and if they could communicate to people in prison that they had the option to have legal representation and ask a judge directly that that could change access to compassionate release, but they didn't know for sure if that was true. So that was a really important case for them.
14:23 Speaker 01 Everybody kind of watched, and that's kind of how everything took off and steamrolled, and it became the thing that it became.
14:30 Speaker 00 Gary Settle estimates that he's helped more than 40 inmates go home. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
14:48 Speaker 00 We'll be right back.
15:01 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from Monarch. Paying off debt can feel like a never-ending project. Monarch can help make the finish line feel more within reach. Monarch's debt paydown simulator shows your exact debt-free date based on your real balances and payments. It lays out your whole payoff journey as a clear, motivating timeline. You can play out your options and pick the fastest one that makes the most sense for you. That way, you're in control and can put more toward debt repayment without feeling deprived. While other apps might only tell you what you've already spent, Monarch can help you look ahead. The app has tools that help you set goals, map out big purchases, and see if you're actually on track before it's too late to adjust.
15:46 Speaker 00 Write your own money story with Monarch. Use code CRIMINAL at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code CRIMINAL.
16:07 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from Shopify. To start a business, you have to be resourceful, always on the lookout for opportunities to grow. For example, by using Shopify to launch your business. And if you launch with Black Friday approaching, you can take advantage of the extra online traffic. Shopify can help businesses at every stage reach their goals this holiday selling season. Their online tools make it easy to launch a beautiful, professional-looking website, and you don't ever need to touch a line of code to do it. They also have a mobile app that lets you run your online store from anywhere. And their AI tool Sidekick can help you manage almost any business task, including holiday discounts.
16:48 Speaker 00 If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/criminal to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com/criminal. Go to Shopify.com/criminal today to hear your first
17:06 Speaker 00 Gary Settle says that whenever he saw another inmate at Butner getting really sick, he would ask them if they wanted to try to apply for compassionate release.
17:15 Speaker 01 I got a little practice doing the paperwork, and that's a lot of what it is, just paperwork. And a lot of them just wouldn't have done it, just because they wouldn't know what to do. They wouldn't even know how to communicate or get their medical records, because that's part of it. I would get their medical records and then explain to the lawyers or fam in the submission what's going on with them. I do a small part. I just help them with the paperwork in here and maybe communicate with the lawyers for them, because some of them aren't comfortable with the communication. And some of these guys that have been locked up very long don't know how to use the computer. So I just help with some of the bureaucratic stuff and bring attention to certain cases. And when you look at them on paper, once
17:58 Speaker 01 you understand what those words mean, these guys are really bad shape.
18:03 Speaker 00 Have you ever gone up to someone who's in really bad shape, very sick, and said, "Hey, I think we should work on an application for you"? And have you ever had a guy say, "I'm so sick. I don't..." You know, "It's not even worth it. I'm too sick. I'm too tired. I don't have the energy to try to fight for this"?
18:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I have had that happen. And before the compassionate release law was changed, there was essentially no chance. But honestly, after the first couple cases here, and I'm sure it was like that in other places, when people actually saw, because we were shocked to see people going out the door. I think a lot of guys who might have felt that way prior to the law change, not only did they change their mind or their thought process of it, I think it actually gave a lot of guys a lot of a mental boost to be stronger in their fight.
19:06 Speaker 00 Tell me about some of the other men that you've helped.
19:09 Speaker 01 There was a young kid here from Montana and it struck me because he was at the time close to my son's age, in his late twenties. And he was half white and half Native American. His name was Victor. And he had a terrible cancer. I can't recall the name of it, but it attaches to the long bones of your body. They actually had to remove his rib cage on the right, left side of his body. Well, to make a long story short, he came back with the cancer spread. And I had just got involved in this. He was a good friend of mine. So I began helping him. And right before the end, he made it about four or five months
19:50 Speaker 01 out on the street. And I spoke to him a couple of times. He was able to spend some time with his nieces and nephews and his family before he died.
20:04 Speaker 00 Gary says that once, one of the men he helped was granted compassionate release, but couldn't find anywhere to stay once he got out.
20:12 Speaker 01 The court would grant him release if he could have had a place for him to go. And he didn't. And he passed away here. And I don't really count him as a victory, even though he kind of got justification in the court that he should go home. And there's another gentleman, Richard Hawes is a real country guy. And he had hepatitis C real bad. And he was approached, I think, by one of the colleges in Kentucky and asked if he wanted to participate in this situation where they would give him a liver and kidney transplant from a person who had died, who had hepatitis C already. And they did that. And then they gave him the new hepatitis C treatment to see if it would work. It would
20:56 Speaker 01 be like a clinical trial type thing. He did that. And then he lived and the hepatitis was cured. But he had to take these drugs to suppress his immune system from attacking those organs over the years. Well, when COVID kicked in, you know, we were making the point, hey, he can't take the vaccine. And he's also taking something that's lowering his immune system. And he got really, really sick.
21:22 Speaker 00 During the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers found that infection rates were five to six times higher in prison than in the general population. It's hard to know how many people in federal prisons like Butner died from COVID. The New York Times reported that the Justice Department stopped collecting and analyzing data about federal and state prison deaths in 2019. Researchers at the University of California Irvine and Brigham Women's Hospital estimate that people in prison died at a rate over three times higher than people outside of prison in 2020.
22:02 Speaker 02 And so, very quickly after COVID started to spread in prisons and it was clear how many people were getting sick and dying in prison from the virus, people saw this as an extraordinary and compelling circumstance that was impacting people's health.
22:20 Speaker 00 In 2020, the number of compassionate release requests went way up, from just under 2,000 to almost 31,000. Richard Hodge, the man with hepatitis C, was one of those applicants.
22:34 Speaker 01 He got out and he's still doing good. I've communicated with him recently. He wrote a really heartwarming email about his family and about the situation he was in out there. And it just makes the point of the whole term compassionate release. He was able to get out because he was still during COVID. He almost died the first time he got it. The second time he got it, he probably would have.
23:02 Speaker 00 Have there been cases where someone who you've tried to help has had their compassionate release denied?
23:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, nobody, this sounds bad, but the only person who I've ever been involved with who had a terminal diagnosis that was denied is me.
23:25 Speaker 00 In 1990, Gary Settle was 24 and living in Florida. He got an idea to rob a bank.
23:32 Speaker 01 We were, this was not a crackerjack organization. This is more like the Apple Dumpling Gang. It was me and some of my idiot buddies, because we're just a bunch of dumb kids. We weren't, we didn't have, you know, this cops and robbers thing. It was just done more of a, of a, well, I think I can do that type thing. So I remember laughing about it afterwards when I had dumped out a big bag full of money and then we went and proceeded to get drunk. That's just, that's how childish it was.
24:06 Speaker 00 He decided to do it again.
24:09 Speaker 00 By 1992, Gary was wanted by the FBI for robbing seven banks over a year and a half. The FBI said he was armed, dangerous, and ready to strike again. And what was your life like at the time? You were just kind of like, you know?
24:26 Speaker 01 I, I lived in Florida. I owned my own construction company. It wasn't a big company, but me and my buddy were the bosses.
24:36 Speaker 01 I lived in a nice place, had a nice car, a boat. Everything was golden. I don't, I drank a lot. And I think I'm what I always considered, not just a functioning alcoholic, but I think I had some kind of alcohol dementia because for about a good 10 years, I drank a lot. And I guess if I was sober, I might have, I was doing pretty good. I probably would have enjoyed it more. My parents lived in Florida. My, my, my son and my ex-wife were around. I was able to spend time with my son. Had my, a group of friends of mine around that I had let in, I had let into this. None of them went to jail, except the, the two guys that got caught and testified against me.
25:24 Speaker 01 I think I had a pretty decent life for a, for a middle-class upbringing, you know, without any college. I thought I was doing pretty good.
25:32 Speaker 00 Did you know the FBI was looking for you?
25:36 Speaker 01 No. Had, and I was so naive about the law. I thought that once the robberies were over with and all this stuff, the evidence was gone, that was the end of it. I had no idea there was conspiracy laws or someone could say he did that. I didn't know. And...
25:53 Speaker 00 So I got away with it. Okay, we're safe.
25:55 Speaker 01 Yep. Yep. Because no, I wore a mask and gloves. And I wasn't very smart. I just thought, eh, no, I didn't give, and I actually didn't even think about the consequences if I was caught because I was putting it on a, my scale of right and wrong. Well, I didn't hurt anybody. I just took some money. I, I wouldn't have thought that the consequences wouldn't be that bad if I was caught.
26:19 Speaker 00 How much did you steal in total?
26:21 Speaker 01 Um, they say the, the government's contention is a hundred and ninety, around a hundred and ninety thousand from the robberies. And then they allege I was involved in another robbery in, in another state, which I, I don't know what they're talking about. I wasn't charged with it. But, um, not much, nowhere, nowhere near enough. Uh, but there, no amount of money would be enough for what I put my family through and what I did to those people just trying to work a job in those banks.
26:48 Speaker 00 What did you do with all the money?
26:51 Speaker 01 Well, most of it just got spent in a, a partying lifestyle. I, I, most of it was spent on frivolous stuff.
26:59 Speaker 00 Like nothing, nothing that you could show for it now?
27:04 Speaker 01 No. No. I mean, my liver might be a little enlarged, I guess, but, uh, no, nothing, nothing worthwhile. I don't.
27:13 Speaker 00 In 1992, while Gary was on a trip in Massachusetts, he was stopped by police for a traffic violation. When they ran his license, they found a warrant for his arrest. He was indicted on nine counts of bank robbery, one count of attempted bank robbery, one count of conspiracy, and 10 counts of carrying a firearm while committing a violent crime. He was eventually convicted on the robbery and firearms charges.
27:47 Speaker 00 For the times that Gary had used a gun in a robbery, the judge gave him a total of 165 years, the mandatory minimum for the charges, plus another 12 years for the robbery charges. She ordered Gary to serve the 177 years consecutively. At the time, the judge said, "I do not think this is an appropriate result, but I feel bound by the law." Less than 10 years earlier, in 1984, Congress had passed the Sentencing Reform Act. It was intended to prevent judges from choosing any random number of years in prison as a way to counteract a perception
28:31 Speaker 00 that judges were being too lenient. What did you think when you heard?
28:37 Speaker 01 I'd never been through anything like that. Probably the most vivid memory I have is my sentencing. And how those work is the judge, the prosecutor, some of the other court people, figure out the math, how much time you have. And they were throwing numbers around, "No, it's 2,147 months with all the stacking." And it went on for a while. And it was real casual, like they were ordering lunch. And as they were going through the numbers, I was thinking, "Well, 120 months is 10 years." And they were sitting there talking about several thousand months.
29:19 Speaker 00 We'll be right back.
29:31 Speaker 00 Thanks to Fetch Pet Insurance for their support. You might know I have a dog. Her name is Eight. She's only a few years old, and luckily, she's in great health. But last year, I had to take her to the vet after she ate something she shouldn't have. So I know firsthand that vet bills can be unexpected, and they can be high. Fetch is built so you can afford the best care for your pet, the most complete coverage for dogs and cats, according to consumeradvocate.org. You get paid back up to 90% of vet bills for accidents, illnesses, diagnostics, and more. Every vet in the US and Canada is a network, so you keep the vet you trust, and you can build a plan that fits your budget. Once your claim's approved, you're paid back in as little as two days. Don't wait until your pet has a health problem.
30:14 Speaker 00 Go to fetchpet.com/save for your free custom quote. It takes about two minutes. That's fetchpet.com/save. Fetch love longer.
30:30 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from Home Chef. When life gets busy, it can be hard to find the time to cook every night. That's why Home Chef delivers restaurant-quality meals right to your door. Home Chef has more than 30 meal options each week with choices for different tastes and dietary needs. I got to try Home Chef myself. The meals I received were easy to prepare, and I didn't have to worry about meal planning, which can be especially helpful now with the holiday season coming up. And people really love it. Home Chef is rated number one by users of other meal kits for quality, convenience, value, taste, and recipe ease. For a limited time, Home Chef is offering our listeners 50% off and free shipping for your first box, plus free dessert for life.
31:15 Speaker 00 Go to homechef.com/criminal. That's homechef.com/criminal for 50% off your first box and free dessert for life. Homechef.com/criminal. Must be an active subscriber to receive free dessert.
31:34 Speaker 00 A few years after he was convicted and sentenced to 177 years, Gary Settle tried to break out of prison, along with two other prisoners, including Woody Harrelson's father, who'd been convicted of murder. They made a rope and tried to climb over the wall. They gave up when a guard fired a warning shot. It made the news. Gary told us that he wasn't always a model prisoner, or, quote, "a big follower of the rules."
32:06 Speaker 01 I participated in illegal activities like gambling and just things like that. Like I said, you can have an altercation with someone, you can be in the wrong unit. You could, you can get into, there's a lot of rules. There's a lot of rules. And to put it in perspective, I've been locked up for 32 years. I have had 14 incident reports and 10 of those were in the first 10 years of my incarceration. So, I mean, it's not good. Some guys have none, but it's easier here just to out of trouble because there's more stuff to concentrate on to do, more positive stuff to do. And you just don't have the energy for it either, getting cancer treatment.
32:48 Speaker 01 So it's just time to just rest and let my body heal itself when it can. I just, I'm tired, uh, I got tired of fighting with them about stuff. So now I'm just trying to do what, do the right thing. I've come to be more, um, accepting of my responsibility and, and, and no matter how much I don't approve of the way the law is structured that has me, it's a strange law that has me in this situation. Well, my actions have me in this situation, but I made the choices that put myself in, in this position ultimately. That's, I can't make it better.
33:27 Speaker 00 How old are you?
33:28 Speaker 01 I am 58 years old.
33:31 Speaker 00 You're not that old.
33:32 Speaker 01 Well, I feel that old.
33:36 Speaker 01 I was relatively healthy until 2017 and then I kind of started falling apart since then. I've had knee replacements. I got problems with my wrist and, and just a bunch of different things going on. Not as bad as some guys, um, but bad enough and it makes me feel old. I guess I feel old too because I, I feel I've had a fruitless life, you know?
34:01 Speaker 00 In 2020, a lawyer friend told Gary that he should apply for compassionate release for himself. At the time, his cancer was in remission, but Gary also had a thyroid disorder and was at risk for severe COVID. She helped him file a motion in January 2021. The motion read, "During his almost three decades of incarceration, Mr. Settle has grown from a reckless young man into a thoughtful, middle-aged man known for the meaningful relationships he builds with others." His lawyers argued that Gary's work helping other inmates get compassionate release
34:40 Speaker 00 demonstrated his sincere rehabilitation. The application also included letters from the people Gary had helped. Gary wrote his own letter and said, "I have a very small family, but I dream of an opportunity to be part of their lives." About a month later, a judge denied Gary's motion. He said that because Gary wasn't terminal and was independent enough to care for himself, he did not qualify for compassionate release, even with his risk for COVID. Almost two weeks later, Gary found out that his cancer had returned. In September of
35:21 Speaker 00 2021, Gary says he was given a prognosis of 18 months. He applied for compassionate release again. Until then, he had kept his cancer secret from his mother, but this time, he would have to tell her. She would be the person he would live with if he was released. He asked her to come visit so he could tell her in person.
35:44 Speaker 01 She took the diagnosis to heart because she hadn't seen me. So I wanted her to come here so she could talk to me and see me face to face because I didn't want to be on the institutional phone. They're all recorded. I didn't want to say something that could be misconstrued. I wanted her to see me.
36:02 Speaker 00 Gary's mother is 84.
36:04 Speaker 01 Still working on her yard, cancer survivor. My father died of cancer early on in my incarceration while I was locked down because of not being a model prisoner. So she went through that by herself.
36:24 Speaker 01 You'll be surprised how many people, probably wouldn't be, how many guys in prison you meet are mama's boys like me.
36:32 Speaker 00 After he was arrested in 1992, he remembers his mother visiting him in the county jail.
36:38 Speaker 01 First thing she said, "Do the glass," because it was with the phone. She looked at me and mouthed the words, "Did you do it?" And I looked at her and I said, "Yes," and nodded. And she put her head down and then brought her head up and has been with me the whole time ever since.
36:57 Speaker 00 How often do you get to talk to her?
36:58 Speaker 01 Every day.
37:00 Speaker 00 When was the last time you saw her?
37:03 Speaker 01 Let's see, I think it was May.
37:08 Speaker 00 Gary filed his second application for release in 2022. His prostate cancer was now stage four and scans indicated that it had spread to his spine and lymph nodes.
37:22 Speaker 00 That May, he tested positive for COVID.
37:27 Speaker 00 Gary's lawyers filed his motion for compassionate release and requested to expedite it because of his COVID infection.
37:36 Speaker 00 The judge denied the request. He said he didn't see any evidence of rehabilitation and found Gary's remorse disingenuous. He was concerned that Gary had never directly apologized to his victims. Gary told us he doesn't know how he would have. He's continued to help other inmates at Butner with their own applications.
38:00 Speaker 01 It's a bittersweet thing. It's great to see someone go home, like some kid went home yesterday. It just sometimes I have to think, you know, I hope they're going to go out there and do good. You know, I think they are, but... I it's that, okay, he's getting out. And it's it's it's I'm being completely frank here. Sometimes it's, you know, it's great that the people are be getting let out, but they're how about me? You know, it's it's selfish to say, but it's it's the thought that I do have. Doesn't discourage me from doing it because in the end of the day, or end of my day, at least I'm trying to do something positive. And I can't I can't not do something. Looking at these guys. If anybody can look at these guys up here and have even the slightest ability to help
38:44 Speaker 01 them and not do it, there's something wrong with them.
38:47 Speaker 00 So where are you in your you've been denied really as compassionate twice. Is that it? Can you can you apply again?
38:55 Speaker 01 Well, my the the many great lawyers that were involved with my the efforts on my behalf, Juliana and Donnie, and there's a bunch of them. Really good people, Mary Price mainly. They've advised me that my option right now is what's they're they're trying to they're submitting a petition for executive clemency right now. That's what's and it's going to have attached the prior motions and all the medical reports and everything. So that's what's being done right now.
39:26 Speaker 00 How far are you into your sentence right now?
39:29 Speaker 01 I couple of weeks ago, I completed 32 years straight.
39:33 Speaker 00 You know, 140 years left.
39:36 Speaker 00 Gary was told he had 18 months left to live in 2021. We spoke to him at Butner in September 2024.
39:45 Speaker 01 It's a tough, tough, you know, I who'd have thought I was going to get cancer and you know, and and I don't know about how the diagnosis stuff works. I know I've watched guys with my same cancer, so I kind of have an idea where things are going, you know, going forward. I could be worse. I'm a mentor in a pain management class here. And we had a class yesterday and some of the new guys, the new class, and some of the guys were listing their issues. And I said then that I didn't really want to say what I have because I felt because these guys are, as I said, again, I keep saying this, but I mean, I know hospitals are pleasant places, but there's some guys in bad shape here.
40:29 Speaker 01 And some of the ailments these guys are dealing with on a day to day basis, besides pancreatic cancer and all these other things is could be worse.
40:38 Speaker 00 Gary says recently, he helped a man with a rare brain cancer get out. He also helped another inmate, whose application had gotten stuck waiting for review by the Bureau of Prisons. You know, why, why do you keep doing this?
40:56 Speaker 01 Um, I can't give you a specific answer, other than, I feel like, like I'm compelled to, because, one, it's very empowering to see somebody go home from a cancer floor.
41:15 Speaker 01 As I said, that's how I was raised. And, um, I don't know, 100%. I like to, part of it, I guess, I'll be frank, part of my motivation is, I know that a lot of people that are involved in the criminal justice system, don't like to see people get released. I've always thought that in some of these submissions, that we should take a picture and just show the judge, "Look at this guy." Because what they rely on, like they did in my case, essentially, is I'm a threat to society. You see these guys up here, they're not a threat to nothing. They can barely get out of bed, some of them. And most of us just want to go home and see our families, and try to mend fences. That's what most of us want to do, spend time with our families.
42:03 Speaker 00 Since 2019, over 5,000 people across the country have been granted compassionate release.
42:12 Speaker 00 You can learn more about Gary Settle in Anna Altman's piece, "The Quality of Mercy", in The Atavist Magazine.
42:26 Speaker 00 Criminal is created by Lauren Spoor and me. Nidia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susanna Roberson, Jackie Sajikko, Lilly Clark, Lena Silison, and Megan Kinane. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti. Julian Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. And you can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com/newsletter.
42:56 Speaker 00 Consider supporting our work by joining our membership program, Criminal Plus. You can listen to Criminal, This is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery without any ads. Plus, you'll get bonus episodes. These are special episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spoor, telling stories from the last 10 years of working together. And at the end of each episode, we share things we've been enjoying. Recently, I recommended the Apple TV series Mosquito Coast. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com/plus. We're on Facebook and Twitter at Criminal Show and Instagram at Criminal underscore Podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com/criminalpodcast.
43:37 Speaker 00 Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
44:04 Speaker 00 It's the season to come together at Starbucks. Cozy up with a classic like the rich peppermint mocha. Feel festive with a fan favorite,
44:11 Speaker 03 the caramel brulee latte. Or make the season a little sweeter with the sugar cookie latte. Together is the best place to be at Starbucks.
44:20 Speaker 03 When everything feels nonstop, movement becomes the pause. So give Lululemon this holiday season. Smooth, seamless running gear builds momentum through every mile. Targeted support adds steadiness to every pulse and hold. And dynamic stretch expands presence through every pose. Give the feeling. Shop in store and on lululemon.com.
Previous The Reverend Next For the Sake of American Youth Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated