Pod Insights Criminal E. Jean About this episode We visited E. Jean Carroll at her house in the woods to talk about her two trials against President Donald Trump.
Say hello on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more.
We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop.
Episode transcripts are posted on our website.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at Odoo.com/vox. That's O-D-O-O dot com slash vox.
0:39 Speaker 01 I'm Anna Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Chloe Mel. We talk all about her taking on the top job at Vogue, finding her personal style, and her favorite lunch order in the iconic Conde Nast cafeteria. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.
1:17 Speaker 02 This episode contains a description of sexual abuse. Please use discretion.
1:24 Speaker 02 A few weeks ago, I visited E. Jean Carroll at her house in the woods in New York. She offered to read me some of the messages she'd gotten online that day.
1:34 Speaker 03 Okay, here, here's a typical. "You all ended up in jail, hopefully. Your day will come. Absolutely no evidence." Okay. "You'll never see a dime. Still making money off the grift, huh? And you are a liar." I'm surprised there's no how ugly I am here.
1:53 Speaker 02 So it just keeps going? I mean, it won't stop?
1:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, these are pretty, this is actually, this puts me in a good mood because there's not even a mild threat here.
2:05 Speaker 02 E. Jean Carroll has been getting messages like this since June 2019, when she first publicly accused President Donald Trump of sexually assaulting her in her Bergdorf Goodman dressing room in the 1990s. E. Jean was a well-known writer by then.
2:23 Speaker 02 She'd moved to New York from Montana in her late 30s after she was assigned her first magazine story. In the 80s, she was hired to write for Saturday Night Live. And by the mid 90s, she was writing an advice column for Elle magazine called Ask E. Jean, which was so popular, it was turned into a cable television show. Have you always been good at giving advice?
2:47 Speaker 03 I'd... It's... Here's the thing. It's very... I'm a cheerleader. So I figure out what the person wants me to tell them when they send the letter. And then I just tell them, "Do it or don't do it." It's fairly simple.
3:07 Speaker 02 It's kind of a black and white thing.
3:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, but then the gray areas, when after I send the answer, then I worry about it for days afterwards, sometimes weeks afterwards, sometimes months afterwards. But you really got to give them a solid yes or no. You can't... You know, that's why my column was liked, because many advice columnists will enter into the very fascinating gray parts. I'm not interested in the gray parts. I either want you to do it or not do it. Life is short. You got to do it or not do it, right?
3:41 Speaker 02 What's life like for you? I mean, what are you feeling in the mid 90s in New York?
3:47 Speaker 03 Oh, I'm living at 90 miles an hour. I have like three outfits. Have a pair of cowgirl boots. I have my jeans. I have... I'll show it to you. We'll walk over. I have it sitting there. I have it hanging on the mall. It's a buckskin jacket. I had a black corduroy shirt. I had a white dress shirt that I picked up off the street. And I... I thought I was fabulous. 4 o'clock in the morning, we'd be running down the boulevards. We'd be going to Brozary for a cup of coffee before... at the end of the night. We... It was... The magazines were at their peak. It was great.
4:27 Speaker 02 So, let's talk about what happens... When you run into Donald Trump in 1996. Tell me about that day.
4:35 Speaker 03 Well, at the time, I had a talk show based on the Ask You Gene column in Elle. And it was called Ask You Gene. And it was on a network started by Roger Ailes, who went on to create Fox News. So I had a live talk show every day for one hour at 4 o'clock. And it reran every night at 11. So I am coming out of Bergdorf's. And I don't remember why I went there. It was after the show. It was around 6:37.
5:17 Speaker 03 And I come out and Donald Trump is standing on the other side, out in the street, ready to come in the door. And he stopped me. And he came on through. And he said, hey, you're that advice columnist.
5:33 Speaker 03 And I said, hey, you're that real estate mogul. So he knew me because Donald Trump watches television. And then, so he asked me for advice on buying a present for a girl. And I thought, oh, boy.
5:50 Speaker 02 What did he, what did he say? I need to buy, I mean, do you remember what he said to you?
5:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, he said, I have to buy a present for a girl. Come advise me.
5:59 Speaker 03 What could be better? I was, you know, I could have dined out at Elaine's, you know, for five nights in a row on a story like that. So, of course, I said, yeah, let's, yeah.
6:11 Speaker 02 And what happened next?
6:13 Speaker 03 Well, I suggested he get her a handbag. He didn't like that idea. And the handbags at Bergdorf's. I think your listeners probably know Bergdorf's. It's a, it's a seven-story building. It used to be a home of the Bergdorf Goodman family. And it's a luxury specialty store. So when I said, how about a handbag? We're looking at six and seven, $8,000 handbags in the 1990s. Beautiful works of art. But he wasn't interested in that. And then I suggested a hat. And, but, you know, he really wasn't. And then he suggested lingerie. And I just thought the story was getting better and better. So, of course, we took the escalator up. And we went to the lingerie department.
6:56 Speaker 03 There was nobody on the floor because it's 6:30, 7:00. And he snatched up a bodysuit that was on the counter. He picked it up and he held it up and he said, "Go, go put this on." I said, "You put it on." "What, are you kidding?" And he said, "No, no, no, you're in shape, go put it on." I said, "No, you put it on." And at the time, it was very light, very funny, very joshing. It couldn't have been better. I had written a sketch. I was a writer at Saturday Night Live. I had written a sketch somewhat similar. So I'm thinking, "This is hilarious."
7:41 Speaker 03 What was the sketch for Saturday Night Live? Oh, William Shatner, standing in front of a mirror in his underwear, falling in love with himself. Nor Dunne is standing off putting lipstick on, belittling as he's telling himself, "Don't ever die," and things like that. So the sketch was somewhat similar, a guy in underwear standing in front of a mirror. So I pictured him putting this bodysuit on over his pants, which to me would have been hilarious. So he said, "After you." He said, "Let's go put this on." He said, "After you." And I just walked in the dressing room, not thinking.
8:26 Speaker 03 Was he funny? He was light. He was light. "Let's go put this on." And then he did the big gesture, "After you, ma'am." You know, everything overdone. And I did. And my intention, of course, was just to see what happened next, which was him putting those pants. But now the door slammed behind me and he shoved me up against the wall and hit my head, hit my head very bad. That's how fast it was. I walked in laughing and that was it. You had no time to say anything? I laughed to try to get the situation in hand.
9:07 Speaker 03 No, it happened so quickly, there was no words, I couldn't say words. I could laugh to think, to, you know, kill any eroticism that was in him. But when it starts, it's a fight, it's a fight. And you, and he was stronger than you? Well, I weighed a hundred and ten, I weighed a hundred and twenty at the time. He weighed about two twenty at the time. He was six two and a half, six three. I was five nine, in my stocking feet, but I was wearing four inch heels, so I was six one. So he had a hundred pounds on me. But at least I was tall enough.
9:49 Speaker 03 So it was, once, once all that weight comes against you,
9:55 Speaker 03 once his whole weight came against me, against my chest, it was rough. But I got out. How'd you get out? First of all, I was stamping, but second of all, I got my knee wedged up so I could push him out and off. That's all it took, I just needed something. And for some reason, I still had my handbag in my hand. I didn't, and I got out. Did he say anything when you walked out of the dressing room? Not that I recall. He could have, I don't, I don't, he could have.
10:30 Speaker 03 I remember clearly his breathing right next to my face. That I remember.
10:38 Speaker 03 You know?
10:40 Speaker 03 I can remember that. What did you do when you got outside? I called my friend. What'd she say? She said, "You're not gonna believe this." Were you still laughing? Well, she told me, "I don't think this is funny, Jean," so I guess I was.
10:58 Speaker 02 The friend she called was Lisa Birnbaum, who was also a well-known writer.
11:03 Speaker 03 So, my psychiatrist, she has a theory of why I called Lisa Birnbaum. Because it was an odd person for me to call. It would be just odd for me to call Lisa. Because she wasn't like my best friend at the time, but she was the funniest person I knew. I mean, nobody's funnier than Lisa Birnbaum. She wrote the Preppy Handbook. So apparently, I was thinking, if Lisa laughs, it's not so bad.
11:28 Speaker 02 What did you say to her?
11:30 Speaker 03 I said, "You're not going to believe what happened."
11:34 Speaker 03 And Lisa also said, this is from her court transcript, "He pulled down my tights. He pulled down my tights. Apparently, I couldn't get over the fact that he pulled down my tights." And then, unfortunately, Lisa said the words that shocked me. She said, "He raped you, E. Jean." She was feeding her kids dinner. She had to leave the room because she didn't want to use the word in front of them. They didn't know what it meant, but she didn't want to. And it was, I couldn't process it.
12:08 Speaker 03 And even though, at the time, I thought I'd been killed in that dressing room. I didn't know what had happened. I thought I'd died in that dressing room. I had sort of that feeling.
12:21 Speaker 03 But Lisa was going to make everything all right. I guess, you know, Lisa was going to make it because we're going to laugh about this. And then, I'll go to Lanes and I'll, you know. So, no, she says, "We've got to go to the police." And, oh, that was too much. I said, "No." She said, "Come to my house. I'll give you dinner."
12:42 Speaker 03 I told her, "No, I just wanted to go home." So I did. So I went home. And I went to work the next day.
12:48 Speaker 02 And that was the only conversation you had about pressing charges? Was when Lisa brought it up? You didn't wake up the next morning and think,
12:58 Speaker 03 No, Lisa and I agreed at the end of the phone call, we were never gonna speak of this again to anybody. This is it, it's over. This is not to ever be spoken of again. Of course, the next day, or possibly the next day, I'm not sure, but I saw Carol Martin, one of my very good friends. She also had a TV show at the same network. And that was it. I just saw Carol and I had to tell Carol then. I had to say, you know, you're not gonna believe it. So she said, let's go to my house, because she lived 10 minutes away. We sat in her kitchen, like you and I are sitting here in my kitchen. And I told her what happened. Well, Carol said, do not go to the police, because he has two hundred lawyers and he'll bury you.
13:42 Speaker 03 That's what Carol said. It was, listen, it's the same today as it was then. Yes, I could have gone to the police, but I would have lost my job. Roger Ailes would have fired me on the spot. This is why women don't come forward against a powerful man. You'll lose your job and he will retaliate.
14:09 Speaker 02 How were you doing in those weeks immediately after? Was it still, you know, were you still just in shock? Or did you find that you were moving forward in some ways, but other parts of you weren't?
14:21 Speaker 03 Well, I thought I was getting along fine. No, I was saying, I put it behind me. I'm not a, I'm not a woman who like dwells. So I thought I was doing that. So that's what I thought I was doing.
14:37 Speaker 02 But you know, but you were never intimate with anyone after that again?
14:43 Speaker 03 Well, see, there's that.
14:47 Speaker 02 Did it all change for you? I mean, you were moving on and you were, but in a deeper level, was that, could you see that that was, that was kind of shut down now?
14:58 Speaker 03 I didn't see it at the time. No, I, anytime an attractive, available man would look at me, I couldn't look back. I'd turn my eyes down. I wouldn't smile. I wouldn't do anything.
15:20 Speaker 02 Did you, did you try to go on dates?
15:25 Speaker 03 Well, the dog would have adjusted.
15:27 Speaker 02 The dog would say, "No man's coming in here." Did you, did you try, though, to, to date?
15:34 Speaker 03 No.
15:37 Speaker 02 It's, it's, it's not fun.
15:39 Speaker 03 I started to dating sites, if that has anything to do with it.
15:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, you weren't dating, but at the same time, you were...
15:45 Speaker 03 I was in there doing the stuff. I started greatboyfriends.com, which were, where women recommended their ex-boyfriends to each other. Um, so I was psychologically pulling strings behind my own back of getting me out there again, but no. Uh-uh.
16:01 Speaker 02 I mean, you wrote a book about finding the right guy.
16:05 Speaker 03 Oh, God, yes, I did.
16:07 Speaker 02 E. Jean's book was called Mr. Right: Right Now, Man-Catching Made Easy. It was published in 2004.
16:17 Speaker 02 Years later, E. Jean spoke to a psychologist about what had happened to her. She realized she blamed herself. When she saw Donald Trump come into Bergdorf Goodman, she thought he was attractive. She'd flirted with him. She told the psychologist, quote, "I can feel the shutdown. It's like when shopkeepers pull down the metal grate to secure the store. I can feel it when it happens. When you're interested in someone, you communicate it in a million little physical ways. And when you like them, you pursue them. I haven't done that since then. I shut it down."
16:55 Speaker 03 You know, it'd be nice for me to call up my fella and say, "Come over, let's make dinner together." And then we'd watch him Netflix, then we'd make out like crazy, but no, I don't have that.
17:09 Speaker 03 So, yeah, I lost a lot.
17:14 Speaker 02 When you would hear about him, Donald Trump, and the new, you know, coming up for whatever he was doing, in those years after, what would, what would it do to you when, when you would hear his name?
17:25 Speaker 03 I got really good at, uh, well, luckily, oddly enough, it's sort of exposure therapy with Donald Trump, because you see him so much, you either have to learn to deal with it, or your life is shattered. Right? So, I learned very quickly to bat it away, bat it away.
17:46 Speaker 02 When and why, after all those years, did you decide to come forward and go public with what had happened to you?
17:53 Speaker 03 Oh, it was the Weinstein story hitting the front page of the New York Times. I thought, well, my God. Yeah, OK. All right, let's do it. OK. And I thought, I've been silent. I'm 75. Jesus, Gene, get the fuck over it and come forward. So that was it. Of course, I couldn't really have foreseen all the damage. But even at the time, I thought, OK, I'll just pay the price. I gotta do it.
18:24 Speaker 02 I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
18:32 Speaker 02 We'll be right back.
18:43 Speaker 02 Support for Criminal comes from Skylight. This time of year, families settle back into their busy routines. Schedules start filling up again, and it might be too much to keep it all in your head. Skylight can help. It's an all-in-one digital smart calendar that syncs with Google Calendar, Apple Calendar, Outlook, and more. Beyond appointments and events, you can organize chores and grocery lists and color-code everything by family member. So each person has a clear idea of where they need to be and what they need to do. One of our producers has tried Skylight and says our family really likes the grocery list. They can easily organize the items on the list by grocery aisle and check off items as they go through the store.
19:26 Speaker 02 Families are better when they're working together. Right now, Skylight is offering our listeners $30 off their 15-inch calendars by going to myskylight.com/criminal. Go to myskylight.com/criminal for $30 off your 15-inch calendar. That's spelled M-Y-S-K-Y-L-I-G-H-T.com/criminal.
19:54 Speaker 02 Support for Criminal comes from Quince. Quince makes elevated everyday essentials using premium materials like Mongolian cashmere, organic cotton, and premium stretch denim. The designs are timeless, thoughtfully crafted, and made to be worn again and again. Think about the first shirt or pair of pants you reach for after laundry day. That's the kind of pieces Quince makes. And it's not just apparel. Quince also makes bedding, kitchen essentials, and thoughtfully designed furniture. I have a lot of pieces from Quince, and the one item I find myself wearing more than I expected is their organic cotton t-shirt. It's comfortable and easy to wear. Find the fall pieces you'll reach for most at Quince.
20:37 Speaker 02 Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was Criminal. It's the best way to support the show. Once E. Jean Carroll decided to talk about what happened, she said she sat down at her kitchen table and wrote everything down in one sitting. Her story was published as an essay in New York Magazine in June 2019. E. Jean was on the cover too, photographed wearing the same wool Donna Karen coat dress she remembers wearing that day in 1996.
21:21 Speaker 02 She still had it at the back of her closet.
21:23 Speaker 03 I was in New York City because when it came out, people thought it'd be best if I'd be in New York.
21:31 Speaker 02 Why? For press or for security?
21:36 Speaker 03 We weren't talking about security then. It never occurred to us. New York Magazine wanted me available. So I was aware there was a buzz coming on, and I didn't really know anything until I got back to my hotel, the little tiny cheap hotel I was staying at on 10th Avenue, opened up my computer.
22:02 Speaker 03 And I just saw slut, skank, lying bitch, you know. And so then I went to my Ask E. Jean email because I always know I will get something nice. And there was something nice, "You go, girl." And there was something. And then I opened up the third one and it was, I stared at it and I thought I was going to get hit with a bullet at that minute. It was, it was a threat to kill me. And I thought, when you get a threat to kill you, you look around, there was no curtain over the window and I like ducked because I thought I was going to get shot.
22:44 Speaker 03 That's how, that's what it's like getting a ducked because you feel, you read the threat and you think it's happening. And then I got several that night. So my life had, was, that I used to know was over. And the new life began.
23:00 Speaker 02 Donald Trump denied E. Jean's story. He said that he had never met her, that he didn't know her, even though there was a photo of the two of them together at a party in the 80s.
23:12 Speaker 03 And he said, "I made it up to sell books." And so that's what happened.
23:17 Speaker 02 You knew he would react, though.
23:20 Speaker 03 I thought he would say it was consensual.
23:24 Speaker 02 Soon after E. Jean's story was published, Lisa Bernbach and Carol Martin both confirmed to the New York Times that E. Jean had told them the same story over 20 years ago. Lisa said she thought E. Jean might have called her first because Lisa had just written a magazine article about Donald Trump. She remembered they fought about what E. Jean should do next. When Lisa told her to go to the police, she said E. Jean said, quote, "It was 15 minutes of my life. It's over. Don't ever tell anybody. I just had to tell you."
24:06 Speaker 02 Carol Martin remembered sitting in her kitchen with E. Jean and she remembered that she told her, quote, "I wouldn't tell anybody this."
24:16 Speaker 02 Donald Trump kept denying anything had happened. He repeated that he didn't know who E. Jean was. And in one interview, he said, quote, "She's not my type." Do you think if he were 35, he would have said, "She's not my type"? Was it something about the fact that you were 75? And, you know, that...
24:38 Speaker 03 Dude, well, of course, everything to do with it because I was on the cover of New York Magazine with no makeup. From the artistic point of view, it was brilliant. Here she is, no makeup, she's telling the truth. This is a woman. This is an old... So what it was, is this shriveled crone on the cover.
24:59 Speaker 02 After her essay came out, E. Jean was at a party and ran into the lawyer and activist, George Conway. They talked about Donald Trump's comments about her. She said it was during that conversation that she realized she could sue Trump for defamation. So in November 2019, she did. But the case was stalled for years. And then, in November 2022, a new law went into effect in New York State called the Adult Survivors Act. What is the Adult Survivors Act?
25:35 Speaker 03 It is a brilliant idea, which is now happening in many states across the country, where it opens a window for victims of sexual assault to make a complaint in civil court against their abuser. And normally, the statute of limitations usually is shut down in most states after five or six or seven years. But in New York, they opened it up. And we sued him at, I think, two minutes after 12 o'clock on the day it became legal to do it.
26:16 Speaker 02 E. Jean filed a civil lawsuit against Donald Trump for battery and, again, for defamation, based on more comments he had made about her in 2022. He'd repeated that her story was a lie and that she was not his type. This time, E. Jean didn't have to wait. A trial was scheduled for the spring of 2023. She started preparing, and she says her legal team scheduled a mock trial.
26:42 Speaker 03 Lawyers like to present their arguments to people who could be on a jury to find out how their arguments are working.
26:51 Speaker 02 E. Jean says they selected three different juries for the mock trial, trying their best to reflect the New York Court's jury pool.
27:00 Speaker 03 And I did not appear. What they had was tapes from me from my deposition. All three juries agreed that, yes, a man and a woman could end up in a dressing room in Bergdorf Goodman in 1996, and, yes, something sexual could have happened in a Bergdorf dressing room in 1996, and, yes, of course, one of those people was Donald Trump and the other was E. Jean Carroll. Yes. What they didn't agree on was, they thought I wanted it, because I was so ugly and so old that there was no way in hell Donald Trump ever attacked me.
27:39 Speaker 02 E. Jean was worried that might happen. She said she'd even talked to her lawyer, Robbie Kaplan, about it.
27:46 Speaker 03 I had suggested that. I don't like the way I look, because I was getting constant. My, much of my social media feed concerned how ugly I was. So what we did is, I had said, let me show you some clips from the old Ask E. Jean show from 1996. Let's do my hair like this. And Robbie said, no, forget it. We'll just show pictures of you. We don't need it. Then the mock jury happened. First thing Robbie said was, cut your hair.
28:20 Speaker 02 So go back to how you looked in 1996.
28:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, so this is the look I had in 1996. And then we did the color I did in 96 and the makeup, and I wore clothes exactly that I wore in 1996.
28:36 Speaker 02 The trial started in April of 2023. On the second day, E. Jean was called to the stand, and she told her story to a jury for the first time. She told them she flirted with Donald Trump. She said, quote, "I didn't picture anything about what was about to happen. That open door has plagued me for years because I just walked into it." She told them that inside the dressing room, Donald Trump forcibly penetrated her with his fingers and his penis. One of Donald Trump's lawyers, Joseph Tacopina, cross-examined E. Jean for hours. He asked repeatedly about the details she couldn't remember clearly,
29:20 Speaker 02 like whether Bergdorf Goodman had a revolving door. He spent a lot of time asking her why she didn't scream. She was in a department store, not the middle of nowhere. Why didn't she cry out for help? He brought up the fact that instead, she laughed. She told them she wished she had screamed so more people would believe her.
29:42 Speaker 03 It's such an old argument, that women have to behave one way and never another. There's the perfect victim. She always goes to the police. She always screams. She never laughs afterward. She never goes to a party. She never smiles. She may go to work, I don't know. But usually, she just sits home depressed because she's been attacked. That's the perfect victim.
30:12 Speaker 02 How do you not keep your cool in that type of an environment where you're being asked these questions and you want to say?
30:23 Speaker 03 Fuck you!
30:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, how do you? But you know, you can't.
30:27 Speaker 03 No, you can't. No, no, I, no, I kept my cool because I knew at that point, Tacopina was really getting on my nerves. Where I lost it was when my own attorney, Mike Ferrara, having made it through the day and a half of doing my direct testimony, he asked me, was I glad that I came forward? And that's all it took. And I just, that was it. The tears like were exploding behind my eyes. That's, when somebody handled me gently, that was, that, that, that was a moment where my anger against Trump just came pouring down my face.
31:06 Speaker 02 E. Jean was prepared for Donald Trump's lawyers to ask her personal questions. In a deposition before the trial, she says another one of his lawyers asked her how many people she'd slept with. She said eight. Then she was asked to list them. The list ended with her second husband, the anchorman, John Johnson. She said no one talked to her about the ninth man, Donald Trump. Lisa Bernbach and Carol Martin both testified during the trial and confirmed E. Jean's story. Donald Trump never appeared in court, but he gave a taped deposition.
31:47 Speaker 02 During the nearly hour-long video played in court, Trump called E. Jean "a nut job", "a whack job", and "mentally sick". He denied the story again and said again that she was not his type. Well, when the jury went to deliberate, how are you feeling? Were you feeling confident?
32:07 Speaker 03 When the jury went out, are you insane? No, we had, uh, six men and three women. No, I was a wreck.
32:18 Speaker 02 The jury deliberated for just under three hours. They found Donald Trump responsible for sexually abusing E. Jean Carroll, but they rejected her claim that he raped her. Under New York law at the time, rape was defined as "non-consensual vaginal penetration by a penis". The jury did not agree that that had happened, but they did believe Donald Trump had forced sexual contact without E. Jean's consent. The jury also found him liable for defamation and awarded E. Jean $5 million. Trump called the verdict "a disgrace".
32:59 Speaker 02 The next day, during a CNN presidential town hall, he denied the story again. He called the case "fake news", and he called E. Jean "a whack job".
33:08 Speaker 03 He did it in front of a huge crowd and made the audience laugh. So, we sued him again, absolutely.
33:19 Speaker 02 E. Jean amended her original defamation lawsuit, the one she had filed in 2019, to include his comments from the town hall. The trial began in January 2024. This time, Donald Trump showed up. So what about that in the second trial, the moment that you see him for the first time in the courtroom? What was it like?
33:42 Speaker 03 Well, while I was preparing for trial, I lost my ability to speak. So that was the thing.
33:49 Speaker 02 Tell me about that.
33:51 Speaker 03 I did not want to face him in court. I didn't want to do it. And I kept saying, I'll be fine. I'll be fine. Then we went for a prep session. I couldn't talk.
34:03 Speaker 02 E. Jean says in the years since she made her story public, the death threats never stopped. She says she was sent emails with pictures of women who had been violently killed. One picture, she remembers, was from a car accident. Another looked like it was taken from a crime scene, and the woman had been murdered. E. Jean's team organized a meeting with a psychologist.
34:28 Speaker 03 So I had to talk to Dr. Leslie Leublitz over the Zoom. And I said the problem was I couldn't talk. And pretty soon, she says, just now, you don't have to say anything about it, but just give me an example of a threat that you can't talk about. So before I know it, I'm reading the threat to her. And then she solved the problem. I don't have to say how I feel about the threat. Just tell what's happening in my body. That's all I had to do. And that's then I could talk. I can't breathe. I could answer, that could be my answer. I can't breathe. That's it. I can't get my breath. My heart is beating too fast.
35:13 Speaker 03 That's, that's, and that's, that's what I did.
35:18 Speaker 03 The first day, the attorneys were having a sidebar with Judge Kaplan. And I'm sitting in the plaintiff's table, and he is sitting at the defendant's table, which is right behind me. So when nobody was there, I turned all the way around in my seat, all the way around, and lanced him in the eye. This is just to give myself courage, okay? Just to give me courage. And he jerked and looked back at me. I got his attention. And then I held his eye, and he held my eye. And then I told him what I wanted to tell him. And he got it. He got it.
36:02 Speaker 03 What did you tell him? I'm not telling you. I told him, and I looked right in his eye. And he, he knew what I was saying to him. And then I turned back around. So by, after I had forced myself to do that, I was all full of beans, let me tell you, for the rest of the trial. And I looked at him the whole time I was giving testimony. And he never looked, anytime our eyes would cross, he would look away.
36:37 Speaker 02 We'll be right back.
36:51 Speaker 02 Thanks to Fetch Pet Insurance for their support. You might know I have a dog. Her name is Eight. She's only a few years old, and luckily, she's in great health. But last year, I had to take her to the vet after she ate something she shouldn't have. So I know firsthand that vet bills can be unexpected, and they can be high. Fetch is built so you can afford the best care for your pet. The most complete coverage for dogs and cats, according to consumeradvocate.org. You get paid back up to 90% of vet bills for accidents, illnesses, diagnostics, and more. Every vet in the U.S. and Canada is a network, so you keep the vet you trust, and you can build a plan that fits your budget. Once your claim's approved, you're paid back in as little as two days. Don't wait until your pet has a health problem.
37:34 Speaker 02 Go to fetchpet.com/save for your free custom quote. It takes about two minutes. That's fetchpet.com/save. Fetch: Love Longer.
37:50 Speaker 02 Support for Criminal comes from Quince. As the nights get cooler, you might be thinking about getting an extra blanket or quilt for your bed. Quince has lots of high-quality, comfortable bedding to try. Quince makes hotel-quality bedding using premium natural materials. Their 100% European linen is made from premium flax and gets softer with every wash. Their organic cotton bedding is breathable and also incredibly soft. And it's not just bedding. Quince also makes thoughtfully designed clothing, home essentials, cookware, and furniture. I love my organic cotton t-shirt from Quince, and I'm really excited to try their organic cotton bedding, too. Make your bed your favorite place to be this season with Quince.
38:34 Speaker 02 Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know Criminal sent you. It's the best way to support the show. One day, Donald Trump posted 40 times on Truth Social about E. Jean Carroll in less than an hour. He called the case "a witch hunt" and accused E. Jean of changing her story. When he testified in court three days later, he was on the stand for less than five minutes. He was asked if he stood by his video deposition from the previous trial where he called E.
39:17 Speaker 02 Jean "a whack job" and "sick." He answered, quote, "100%." E. Jean stayed in New York City during the trial. One day, the people taking care of her dogs at home told her they noticed an unfamiliar car driving up and down her street and parking at the end of her driveway. When she testified, she told the jury about her first death threat, the night her essay was published in June 2019. She said she was so afraid she was about to be shot in her hotel room that she tried to hide and tried to hang her clothes across the windows.
39:57 Speaker 02 Before the verdict was announced to the court, E. Jean heard the judge ask the jury foreperson a question. She said he asked, quote, "The M that appears next to various numbers, what does it mean?" You wanted a kind of a lot of money.
40:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, 83.3 million. But it's more now because of been getting interest.
40:22 Speaker 02 Did you ever imagine it was going to be that much money?
40:25 Speaker 03 Look at me. Do you see? I don't even like stuff. I don't like stuff. I don't think about money. I don't imagine money. I never for a minute thought, oh, I'm going to get a bunch of money. Can you tell?
40:36 Speaker 02 We are drinking out of salsa jars.
40:40 Speaker 03 I don't care. Oh, I gotta go buy some pretty glasses.
40:46 Speaker 02 E. Jean hasn't gotten any of the money yet. She won't until the appeals process is over. Trump appealed both verdicts. But she said that she plans to donate the money. She has a running list of ideas. One is to start a fund supporting victims of sexual assault. Right after we finished our interview, E. Jean gave me a tour of her house. She's lived alone there for years, plus her two dogs. She showed me her bedroom, which is right off of the kitchen. In it, there's a twin bed. And next to the bed, there's a shotgun. Oh, it really is right next to your bed?
41:28 Speaker 03 Well, of course it is.
41:30 Speaker 02 Wow, do you practice?
41:31 Speaker 03 No.
41:32 Speaker 02 I mean, I guess you know what you have to do.
41:34 Speaker 03 I used to do. I used to practice with a nice little revolver because that I could handle a high, you know. But this one, I don't. This is locked. This is loaded. All I have to do is push off the safety and shoot in the general direction. You know what? They can come. They can come and shoot me. I don't care. I'm ready to. I don't care because they're not going to get far.
41:58 Speaker 02 I mean, you might not care that they shoot you, but they're still. How do you feel about them coming to shoot you?
42:06 Speaker 03 Well, they would be coming because of Donald Trump. He has an enormous impact on his followers. So when he says, "She's a liar. You better keep your wits about you." That's all.
42:21 Speaker 02 In 2023, Donald Trump's lawyers went to court to try to get a retrial against E. Jean. A judge rejected their motion, and he added a comment about the jury's original verdict. Quote, "The finding that Ms. Carroll failed to prove that she was raped does not mean that she failed to prove that Mr. Trump raped her, as many people commonly understand. Indeed, as the evidence makes clear, the jury found that Mr. Trump, in fact, did exactly that." In January of 2024, the governor of New York changed the state's law to expand the
43:03 Speaker 02 legal definition of rape and mentioned E. Jean's case the day she did it.
43:09 Speaker 03 And now the definition of rape includes what Trump did to me in the dressing room. So that is, that is, we, we were way behind the times there. So that's been fixed.
43:37 Speaker 02 Criminal is created by Lauren Spoor and me. Nadia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susanna Roberson, Jackie Sajikko, Lilly Clark, Lena Silasen, and Megan Kinnane. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti. Julian Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com, and you can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com/newsletter. We hope you'll consider supporting our work by joining our membership program, Criminal Plus. You can listen to Criminal, This is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery without any ads. Plus, you'll get bonus episodes. These are special episodes with me and Criminal
44:21 Speaker 02 co-creator Lauren Spoor, talking about everything from how we make our episodes, to the crime stories that caught our attention that week, to things we've been enjoying lately. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com/plus. We're on Facebook at This is Criminal and Instagram and TikTok at Criminal underscore podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com/criminalpodcast.
44:44 Speaker 02 Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
Previous The Bus Ride Next This is Phoebe Judge from the IRS Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated