Pod Insights Criminal Death in Eden About this episode In the early 1930s, eight people settled on an uninhabited island in the Galapagos. Within five years, two were missing and two were dead.
Abbott Kahler’s book is Eden Undone: A True Story of Sex, Murder, and Utopia at the Dawn of World War II.
Say hello on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more.
We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop.
Episode transcripts are posted on our website.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at Odoo.com/vox. That's O-D-O-O dot com slash vox.
0:37 Speaker 01 LinkedIn is pretty amazing at helping you grow your small business. We cannot stop your new clients from emailing you at 3 a.m. We can help you sell, market, and hire in one place. We cannot help you be in three places at once. And while we can't help you organize your calendar, LinkedIn can help you land more clients so you have a calendar to organize. Grow your small business on LinkedIn. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/smallbusiness.
1:09 Speaker 02 Before they even left, Frederick decided to yank out all of his teeth and have them replaced by a set of steel dentures.
1:18 Speaker 03 In the late 1920s, a German doctor named Frederick Ritter decided to leave the country. He said he wanted to leave modern society altogether.
1:29 Speaker 02 He was a veteran of World War I. He suffered quite a bit of trauma on the battlefield there, came out with severe lung damage, and afterward went into holistic healing and believed in the healing powers of water and also believed in the powers of the mind and was into philosophy. He was into Nietzsche and various philosophers and fancied himself to be a philosopher.
1:51 Speaker 03 This is author Abbott Kahler.
1:54 Speaker 02 And so he decided that civilization had nothing more to offer him and he had nothing more to offer it and began dreaming of escaping civilization and going somewhere to a remote island where he would be able to test his theories and write his philosophy and sort of, I guess, develop a new world order that people might want to follow.
2:14 Speaker 03 Friedrich Ritter believed it was possible to live to be 150 years old. Abbott says he didn't trust manufactured clothing, especially, quote, "the civilized shoe." He made his own shoes. He called society "a monster forging ever-new chains with which to shackle the free development of its members." Abbott says he was also unpredictable.
2:40 Speaker 02 Friedrich was somebody who was quite violent when he came home from the war. There's one anecdote where he sort of lost his mind for a moment and shot his sister's dogs, then turns around and says that he is so against violence that he won't even eat potatoes because they have to be yanked from the earth by force.
2:58 Speaker 03 He told people he was a strict vegetarian. He worked as a doctor at the Hydrotherapeutic Institute in Berlin, and one of his patients was a young woman named Dori Strouch.
3:11 Speaker 02 So Dori was a few years younger than Friedrich Ritter. She was in her 20s when she became a patient at his hospital in Berlin. Dori was suffering from multiple sclerosis, and every other doctor told her, you know, "You are incurable. Your condition cannot be cured." Friedrich, however, said that she was choosing to be sick, that her mind had told her she wanted to be sick. And if she could just train her mind to give her a different message, she would not suffer from multiple sclerosis at all. Instead of, you know, telling Friedrich this was crazy, or she was annoyed, or, you know, whatever, stomping out of the room, Dori started to think maybe he was on to something. She was at first terrified of him, but then she became very enamored with Friedrich,
3:54 Speaker 02 I think partly because she had been married to an older family friend and was very unsatisfied in this marriage. In her memoir, she actually talks about how bad the sex was in her marriage, which is kind of an orthodox thing for women to have been writing about back at that time, to be so candid. But she learned of his dream of abandoning civilization and decided that it was her role in life to accompany him on this journey and be instrumental in spreading his ideas and philosophies throughout the world, and she begged to go with him.
4:24 Speaker 03 At first, Friedrich said no. He said, "I cannot have a lovesick woman full of romantic notions trailing after me in the wilderness." But eventually, he gave in. Even though they were both married to other people...
4:41 Speaker 03 They decided to go to the Galapagos Islands.
4:45 Speaker 03 How did they pick the Galapagos?
4:48 Speaker 02 Well, it's interesting. You know, when you think about the Galapagos, I think most people who have never been there or don't know much about it think of, you know, sandy beaches and waving palm trees and a lush tropical vegetation. But the Galapagos, of course, were formed by volcanic eruptions. They're covered in lava rock. Many of the islands don't have any fresh water source. They're barren. They're incapable of growing anything.
5:12 Speaker 02 And I think Frederick liked this challenge. He wanted to prove that he could go to a difficult place like the Galapagos and not only survive, but thrive. And they picked an island called Floriana, which is in the southern part of the islands. And Floriana's saving grace was that it does have one freshwater spring. So if they were able to tap into that, they would at least be able to have a chance of cultivating a garden and sustaining themselves.
5:36 Speaker 03 How big was Floriana?
5:37 Speaker 02 It's not large at all. It is one of the smaller islands. And at that time, it was completely uninhabited. It had been, in the past, a very popular transient point for pirates and people on the trade routes. And it was more of a place where people came and went rather than stayed there, although people tried and failed.
5:59 Speaker 03 Before they left, Frederick and Dory started preparing for their new life. That's when Frederick decided to have all of his teeth removed and get a set of steel dentures to replace them.
6:11 Speaker 02 You know, he was anticipating dental problems on the island and he just, I guess, wanted to, you know, stop that from even happening in the beginning. Of course, he did not account for the fact that his gums would shrink.
6:23 Speaker 03 Which meant the dentures sometimes fell out. But Frederick had a backup plan.
6:29 Speaker 02 Frederick also wanted to test gums. He thought that gums could become, quote, "horny enough to substitute for teeth."
6:38 Speaker 03 He and Dory sailed from Amsterdam on July 3rd, 1929. They brought mosquito netting, gardening tools, and philosophy and Latin books. Frederick wrote to a friend, "I feel as if I am dying in one world in order to be reborn in another." At the end of the month, they arrived in Guayaquil, on the coast of Ecuador. Frederick didn't like it there. He said he noticed a "completely intolerable cult" having to do with shoes. He didn't like that there were shoe shiners everywhere. From there, they took another boat to Floriana. Once they got there, they found a place to sleep in some caves. They were known as the island's "pirate caves."
7:23 Speaker 03 A pirate named Patrick Watkins had lived in them decades earlier.
7:27 Speaker 02 So they stayed in his cave, and this was something that did not so well with Dory.
7:33 Speaker 03 She later described feeling something sinister and frightening in the air on the island.
7:39 Speaker 02 She began believing that if they did not behave themselves on Floriana, if they did not yield to the will of the island, Floriana would come to hurt them in the long run.
7:49 Speaker 03 Almost immediately after they arrived, it became clear that life on the island was going to be harder than they imagined.
7:56 Speaker 02 The lava rocks are very sharp. They had pretty thin shoes. And Dory, of course, you know, suffering from multiple sclerosis, had a bad leg that pained her quite a bit. And Frederick, he could be a very cold person and sort of got frustrated with Dory whenever she would express that her leg was bothering her. And there was tension that started to brew with them pretty much right away. Frederick would tell her to, quote, "erect a defense psychology around herself," and that would protect her from the pain. And, you know, of course, Dory would just get annoyed that he couldn't show a little bit more care and concern.
8:32 Speaker 03 Frederick and Dory also had to deal with all of the wild animals that lived on the island. There were wild cattle, boars, and donkeys, and a lot of insects. Not long after they arrived, Dory's feet became very swollen. She and Frederick discovered that a kind of sand flea had burrowed beneath her skin to lay eggs. Frederick cut Dory's feet open to remove them. He found 32 in all. Then he told Dory that she should develop a defense psychology around her feet.
9:05 Speaker 03 At one point, Dory's teeth started rotting from eating too much sugarcane, which Frederick scolded her for. But he did agree to share his steel dentures with her. For a while, she would only talk and smile when she was wearing them. Frederick and Dory built a small home for themselves. They called it Frito, a combination of their names, and also a reference to the German word for peace. There were bananas, pineapples, oranges, and papayas growing on the island. And they were also able to grow their own food: tomatoes, radishes, cucumbers.
9:42 Speaker 02 So Frederick, for all of his faults, did build a really ingenious contraption. He was able to sort of rig a shower and a water source and piping from the spring that delivered water to their area. Their garden flourished. They had wonderful fruits. Dory wrote quite lovingly about these fruits, that they were bigger than babies' heads and anything, much better than anything she had ever seen in Europe.
10:08 Speaker 03 And then, a few months after they arrived, they started getting unexpected visitors.
10:14 Speaker 02 In the 1930s, after everybody was suffering from the Great Depression, the stock market had crashed. People were really just desperate. Anybody with money decided to, "I'm going to build a yacht and go on oceanic exploration." And it sort of became an escape from the hell that had been descending upon the world after the stock market crashed.
10:37 Speaker 03 In January of 1930, a wealthy American arrived on Floriana. He had no idea Frederick and Dory were there.
10:45 Speaker 02 He had gone just in search of treasure and to gather some exotic animals and flora and fauna to bring back to the United States and was quite shocked when he came upon Dory and Frederick. He gave them some tools. He gave them ammunition. He gave them a gun. He gave them dynamite to blast away the wild boars that were eating their fruits and vegetables. And he even gave Frederick some steel polish. And when he went back to America and gave a press conference, he joked that he didn't know what Frederick was going to do with steel polish unless it was to polish his teeth. But he called them the modern day Adam and Eve. And everybody immediately became fascinated by the idea that that these two, you know, had it figured out, these two actually escaped civilization when civilization
11:30 Speaker 02 was falling apart. And it almost became sort of an aspirational thing, you know, wow, wouldn't it be great if I could just get away to a remote island and get away from all of my problems?
11:39 Speaker 03 Newspapers reported on the German Robinson Crusoe. A reporter for the Austin Statesman wrote, their story was, quote, liable to make one wonder when the next boat leaves for the South Seas and how much a ticket costs. Frederick and Dory had no idea they had become famous. But a few months later, a boat delivered a large package of mail, dozens of letters and newspapers. All of the letters were from strangers, many writing that they also wanted to move to Floriana. Dory was devastated. She later wrote their piece was destroyed, quote, as surely and swiftly as a single
12:22 Speaker 03 stroke of lightning destroys a living tree. She told Frederick, this is the end of everything. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
12:41 Speaker 03 We'll be right back.
12:47 Speaker 03 To listen without ads, join Criminal Plus.
12:56 Speaker 03 Support for Criminal comes from Skylight. This time of year, families settle back into their busy routines. Schedules start filling up again, and it might be too much to keep it all in your head. Skylight can help. It's an all in one digital smart calendar that syncs with Google Calendar, Apple Calendar, Outlook and more. Beyond appointments and events, you can organize chores and grocery lists and color code everything by family member. So each person has a clear idea of where they need to be and what they need to do. One of our producers has tried Skylight and says her family really likes the grocery list. They can easily organize the items on the list by grocery aisle and check off items as they go through the store.
13:39 Speaker 03 Families are better when they're working together. Right now, Skylight is offering our listeners $30 off their 15-inch calendars by going to myskylight.com/criminal. Go to myskylight.com/criminal for $30 off your 15-inch calendar. That's spelled M-Y-S-K-Y-L-I-G-H-T.com/criminal. Support for Criminal comes from Ritual. Staying healthy isn't always about making drastic changes. It's about maintaining routine. Ritual makes one part of your nutritional routine easier. Ritual's team of scientists looked at thousands of studies to find the common gaps between
14:24 Speaker 03 nutrient needs and what people are actually consuming. Their Essential for Women 18+ contains nine key nutrients in two delayed-release capsules, so the body absorbs them in the best way possible. And they're gentle on the stomach, so you can take them with or without food. I've been taking Ritual for a while now, and I've made them part of my morning routine. I take them at pretty much exactly the same time every day with breakfast. Instead of striving for perfect health, support your foundational health. Save 25% on your first month at ritual.com/criminal. That's ritual.com/criminal for 25% off your first month. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.
15:09 Speaker 03 This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. In a letter to a relative, Frederick Ritter wrote that people, quote, "obviously believe that we are living an idle life like Adam and Eve in paradise, eating delicious fruits, swimming in the ocean, or walking about admiring the beautiful landscape." This is a pleasant delusion.
15:37 Speaker 03 On August 28, 1932, a new family arrived on Floriana. A man named Heinz Whitmer, a woman named Margaret Waldbrill, and Heinz's 12-year-old son, Harry.
15:50 Speaker 02 And by the time that they arrive on Floriana, Margaret is five months pregnant with Heinz's child, and they directly go to Frederick and Dory to pay their respects to the famous Dr. Ritter, as they called him. And it does not go well. Frederick was kind of put upon and resentful. He's thinking, "I left Berlin in a medical practice because I did not want to do this any longer. I didn't want to be responsible for a woman and her child and this delivery, and they're going to impose upon me." Dory, for her part, was hopeful at first that she might have a woman friend on the island, but she and Margaret didn't hit it off either. She looked at Margaret and thought, "What kind of fool would want to give birth on a deserted island?"
16:34 Speaker 02 And Margaret looked at Dory and says, "What kind of fool quotes Nietzsche on a deserted island?" And they really didn't have anything in common. And so the two couples get off to a very bad start.
16:45 Speaker 03 I mean, you know what? I kind of get it. I kind of get how I would be kind of mad, too, if people showed up on my island.
16:54 Speaker 02 Yeah. And I think this is where they start having differing accounts. I should say that I had several sources I consulted for this story, and Margaret and Dory have very different ideas of how things unfolded at different points. And this was one of them. Dory, in her memoir, acts like she was very accommodating and offered to do anything she could. And Margaret basically read about how standoffish Dory was and how it was actually not a very friendly meeting.
17:22 Speaker 03 Margaret Heinz and Harry settled several miles away from Dory and Frederick. They built a log cabin and planted a garden. Margaret spent a lot of time sewing baby clothes. She was due at the end of the year. And then, in October, another group arrived on the island.
17:44 Speaker 02 There's a woman in Paris. Her name is Antonia, actually. Antonia Wagner von Werborn-Bosquet is her entire name. She's usually described as a self-proclaimed baroness or a so-called baroness. But she actually was an authentic baroness. She inherited the title from her grandfather. And she's in Paris with her two lovers. She has quite a reputation in Paris. She's known for throwing wild parties and orgies, seducing men and women alike. There are rumors that men have fought duels over her. There's rumors that she actually murdered somebody herself. And she declared that God Himself ordered her to go to Floriana and conquer it and claim it for herself.
18:26 Speaker 02 So in 1932, she leaves Paris, brings her two lovers with her, shows up on Floriana with these two men, Robert and Rudolph, and a gun and a whip on her person, and decides that she is going to turn Floriana into Miami and build a luxury hotel that will cater to American millionaires.
18:48 Speaker 03 She wanted to call it Hacienda Paradiso.
18:51 Speaker 02 And of course, this really does not get over well with anybody, including Heinz Whitmer, Margaret Frederick and Dory.
18:59 Speaker 03 And the men she brought with her, Rudolph and Robert, what were they like?
19:03 Speaker 02 Well, Rudolph was blond and pale and a little bit frail. And sort of, he had been friends with the baroness, I think, for a longer period of time than Robert. She and Rudolph had been in business together in Paris. They owned a trinket shop, a lingerie/trinket shop. And there were also rumors that she had been cooking the books a bit on that, and that when they left, they were fleeing debtors. And Rudolph was quite despondent about this because he had claims later that she had cost him all of his money and his reputation as a good businessman. So in a way, I think he felt that he had no choice but to accompany her because there was really nothing left for him in Paris. He had no money to start somewhere else. And part of him was still in love with the baroness.
19:47 Speaker 02 And Robert, he was this sort of very, very good-looking, strapping, dark-haired, very muscular. She was very openly sexual with him and was clearly her favorite.
19:59 Speaker 03 I mean, the things that she chooses to bring with her seem a little wild, a wild decision for a deserted island.
20:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, she brings, you know, bees with her. I remember one particular thing that she brought a bunch of bees. I think she was going to try to be a beekeeper and make honey. She brings various exotic clothing, lingerie, all kinds of skimpy outfits. I guess in her mind, you know, the idea that she was going to build this luxury hotel and sort of seduce American millionaires, the lingerie was a necessity for her, I suppose.
20:34 Speaker 03 Margaret was the first to meet the Baroness, who showed up outside her home riding on a donkey. Margaret noted that the Baroness immediately had Rudolph wash her feet in a freshwater spring that was also Margaret and Heinz's drinking water. Then the Baroness went to visit Frederick and Dory. According to Dory, she extended her hand in a way that suggested she wanted them to kiss it. They didn't. They showed her around Frito, and Dory noticed that the Baroness kept Rudolph close at all times, constantly ordering him around. Dory thought he seemed very young, and later wrote that the Baroness, quote, "must have caught him early."
21:19 Speaker 03 And then, not long after the Baroness arrived, Frederick noticed some of his mail had been tampered with. At one point, the Baroness offered to store some rice for Heinz, but when he tried to retrieve it, she told him he had to pay. I mean, it's kind of like this woman gets there and Frederick and Heinz says, "You can't... What are you doing?" And she said, "I'm gonna do whatever I want."
21:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, you know, I remember when she was first deciding where to set up her hotel, she had been staying quite near Heinz. And once Heinz sort of realized that this woman was up to no good and had nefarious motives, he said, "I don't want you anywhere near him. You know, go live somewhere else." And she taps her revolver in her, you know, waistband and says, "I'm not going anywhere. I will stay where I like." She's not afraid to threaten anybody, and at the same time, she extends invitations to both Frederick and Heinz to, in Margaret's words, "visit her wigwam." So she was trying to seduce these men. At the same time, she was also threatening to kill them.
22:21 Speaker 03 On New Year's Day, 1933, Margaret had her baby.
22:25 Speaker 02 It's quite a harrowing scene, and she is alone. She, Heinz and his teenage son, had gone out somewhere. She doesn't know where anybody is. It's pitch black. She stumbles from her bed, trying to call out their names, and sort of faints in pain. And all the while, wild animals are circling around her, the wild hogs, the goats, the pigs. And, you know, it's kind of terrifying. And it's in this, you know, this way. She gives birth alone.
22:51 Speaker 03 It was a boy. They named him Ralph. This seems like kind of a hard blaze to have an infant.
23:00 Speaker 02 It was. You know, it's very difficult. She, you know, does the best she can, and I think manages quite well. You know, when American explorers would go visit the new baby, they would remark about how well he looked and how chubby. And she depended on them quite often to bring milk. She wasn't able to nurse after a while. It sort of, her body stopped producing milk, and she had to depend on milk from them. And of course, there was another problem when the Baroness, it was discovered, had been stealing milk from Heinz and Margaret.
23:32 Speaker 03 When visitors came to the island, the Baroness would often tell them to leave the milk with her, and she'd pass it along. But she kept it for herself. By this point, one of the men the Baroness was living with, Rudolph, wasn't doing well.
23:50 Speaker 02 He started suffering from tuberculosis, is one of the diagnoses that he received. And at the same time, the Baroness was kind of demoting him. You know, she, you know, always ordered these two men around, but she started giving Rudolph the more menial chores and also the more physically demanding chores. So his body would just wear out. He would collapse, and then every time he collapsed, she would berate him. And she began staging physical fights, actually, between Robert and Rudolph, and sort of egging them on to beat each other. And Robert, the stronger man, was always the victor in these fights. And every time Rudolph would lose, she would just demote him further and make things worse for him. So...
24:31 Speaker 02 There was a period of time where he just started visiting Margaret and Dory separately and complaining about the Baroness and saying, "I don't know what I'm going to do. I'm getting desperate. I want to leave this island. I can't leave this island. I don't know what I'm going to do." And, you know, Margaret and Dory both just started worrying about how bad things were getting with the Baroness.
24:51 Speaker 03 And then, a couple of months after the baby was born, Heinz's canoe went missing. He asked the Baroness about it, and she lied and said Dory and Frederick had taken it.
25:02 Speaker 02 When Heinz and Frederick begin comparing notes, it becomes quite clear that the Baroness is their common enemy. And that's when they really try to band together and decide, "What are we going to do about her?" Because the Baroness seems to be able to charm whoever she's with.
25:18 Speaker 03 Frederick and Heinz decided to try writing to the Ecuadorian authorities.
25:22 Speaker 02 And Frederick, you know, says, "I think this woman has medical problems. I think she's seriously off. I think she belongs in a sanitarium. Please come and investigate." And they both sign the letter. The governor of the Galapagos does visit Floriana, and what happens? But the Baroness manages to seduce him, too. And he even invites her on a vacation with him, so she sort of trots off with the governor for six weeks. And when she's back, he decides to give her even more land and clear authorized access to Heinz and Margaret's spring. And she's sort of triumphant and emboldened by this. And, you know, it's kind of, they're at a loss at that point.
26:05 Speaker 02 They realize that there's no institutional help available to them.
26:08 Speaker 03 In a letter to a friend, Dory said that the vague feeling of something being wrong had, quote, "crystallized into a feeling of murder." She wrote, "Dire events were on the way."
26:24 Speaker 03 And then, some new visitors arrived on the island. They stayed with Frederick and Dory.
26:29 Speaker 02 And there is an incident in which the baroness invites them to go on a hunting trip. And they're a bit reluctant because the baroness, I think, is throwing herself all over this one man, a very handsome man. In Dory's words, he's named Lind.
26:44 Speaker 03 Another one of the visitors noted that Lind didn't seem interested in the baroness. But Abbott says the baroness had a plan.
26:52 Speaker 02 The baroness, you know, she said that if you wound an animal and nurse it back to health, that animal is going to be loyal to you forever. So it seemed that she wanted to test this theory on human beings. And her idea is that she's going to shoot Lind and nurse him back to health, and he's going to be forever loyal to her.
27:14 Speaker 03 But she accidentally shot the wrong man. He didn't die, but was badly injured.
27:19 Speaker 02 She had first tried to blame it on an Ecuadorian soldier who had been accompanying them as bodyguards. She tries to deflect blame on everybody but herself, and she finally admits it. She fully confesses and starts crying and saying she didn't mean to. And what is she going to do? And she's never going to shoot a gun again. And I think it was something that made Frederick really reach the breaking point of feeling like this woman is really clearly a danger, and I can't really brush off her threats anymore.
27:50 Speaker 03 Not long after that, the weather on the island changed. It didn't rain for months.
27:56 Speaker 02 And it was hugely problematic for everybody. I mean, everybody's crops were failing, their animals couldn't eat or drink. There was nothing, the animals were dying. Everybody writes about the carcasses that were turning up everywhere. It just looked like a complete wasteland of animal carcasses and wilted vegetation. And people were desperate, really, really, truly desperate.
28:19 Speaker 03 And then, one day five months into the drought, Dory said she heard a scream. We'll be right back.
28:44 Speaker 03 Support for Criminal comes from Mint Mobile. Some things appear too good to be true, but a $15 monthly phone plan isn't one of them. Mint Mobile has affordable, premium wireless plans, and they include high-speed data and unlimited talk and text. And they make signing up easy. You can do it all online. We have a friend who switched to Mint Mobile. He said that it's a great deal, and he liked that he didn't necessarily need to get a new phone or phone number when he switched. To get your new wireless plan for just $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com/Phoebe. That's mintmobile.com/Phoebe. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at mintmobile.com/Phoebe. That's it. There's no catch. $45 upfront payment required, equivalent to $15 a month.
29:28 Speaker 03 New customers on first three-month plan only. Speeds slower above 40 gigabytes on a limited plan. Additional taxes, fees, and restrictions apply. See Mint Mobile for details.
29:45 Speaker 03 Support for Criminal comes from Talkiatory. Mental health support can come in many forms, but it's not always easy to access. Talkiatory is different. It can help you find a psychiatrist, and it makes the experience simpler and more flexible. You can find someone who takes the time to get to know you and provides a clear, personalized treatment plan. Talkiatory is 100% online psychiatry practice. They provide comprehensive evaluations, diagnoses, and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, and more. Unlike therapy-only platforms, Talkiatory is psychiatry. That means your medical provider is qualified to diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication whenever it's appropriate.
30:29 Speaker 03 Head to talkiatory.com/criminal to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y.com/criminal to get matched in minutes. Talkiatory.com/criminal.
30:50 Speaker 03 On March 19, 1934, Dory said she was at home with Frederick when she "heard a woman scream." She wrote, "It was an outcry of such terror that it was hardly human." Frederick said he heard the scream too. Dory said they didn't investigate. They assumed if they were needed, someone would come get them. Two days later, Dory said Rudolph came to visit. She knew things had been bad between him and the Baroness for a while, but now he seemed happy. Dory asked him if he'd made up with the Baroness, and he said, quote, "Not this time." About a week after that, Rudolph visited Dory again. This time, he brought Margaret.
31:34 Speaker 03 Margaret announced that the Baroness and Robert had left on a friend's yacht to go to Tahiti. Dory and Frederick hadn't seen a yacht, but the Baroness and Robert had disappeared. Abbott Kahler says everyone has different accounts of what happened. Dory and Frederick stuck to their story about the scream. Frederick was sure it had been the Baroness. But Margaret and Hines, who lived much closer to her, said they hadn't heard anything. Margaret later recalled that Frederick seemed to know more than he let on, and that he had told everyone that the Baroness, quote, "won't come back.
32:17 Speaker 03 Take my word for it." In a letter to a newspaper, Frederick wrote that he thought Hines had killed the Baroness and Robert. Dory believed Rudolph had done it. Abbott says Rudolph did seem to be acting strangely.
32:32 Speaker 02 He shows up at Dory's and weeps. He moves in with Margaret because he just doesn't want to be down where the Baroness was. And he's with Margaret. He's crying all the time. He seems lethargic, even more lethargic than usual. But she says that he is also very helpful and helpful with the baby. And he just seemed to be kind of all over the place. Despondent one minute, calm the next moment, happy one moment. So it really seemed that nobody quite knew what to make of his behavior at this time.
33:07 Speaker 03 Rudolph was still very sick and weak. Dory started to think that if he had killed the Baroness, he must have had an accomplice. She just wasn't sure who. Rudolph spent a lot of time walking to the bay and waiting to see if any ships would come. He wanted to get off the island. He brought his things to the beach so he'd be ready to leave at a moment's notice. One ship wouldn't take him because he was so sick. Another ship passed by without Rudolph noticing, but the crew stole most of his belongings. In July, several months after the Baroness and Robert disappeared, a passing fisherman finally agreed to take him off the island.
33:52 Speaker 03 After Rudolph left, Frederick wrote a letter to an American explorer who had visited the island several times over the years, Captain George Hancock.
34:02 Speaker 02 I think Frederick always knew more than what he let on. And he writes a letter to Hancock and says, "I need you to come to the island once more. I know something, but I have no proof of it." So that's, you know, Hancock, you know, does make another voyage. He's determined to get to the bottom of it.
34:22 Speaker 03 Captain Hancock made plans to set out from Los Angeles in November. And then, right before he was scheduled to leave, he heard that two bodies had been found on another Golopkos island called Marshana. Captain Hancock headed straight there. It was clear the bodies had been there for several months. They had been mummified by the sun. Captain Hancock was barely able to recognize them, but he could tell that one of them was Rudolph. The other was the sailor who'd taken Rudolph from Floriana.
35:00 Speaker 02 And it seems that the two men died of thirst. Marchana is an island that has no fresh water. And they really had nothing to drink and just sort of died horrifically of thirst.
35:14 Speaker 03 Captain Hancock left the island and headed right to Floriana to tell Hines, Margaret, Dory, and Frederick what had happened.
35:22 Speaker 02 And I think Frederick is just worried that everything is imploding at this point. Tensions between him and Dory are escalating. He is becoming more volatile. Margaret reports that Frederick hit Dory at this time. And so he seemed to be losing it as well.
35:40 Speaker 03 Frederick had started eating meat again. And one night, he ate some meat from chickens that had gotten sick and died.
35:48 Speaker 02 Dory was sort of like, is it safe to eat this? And he's like, sure. And so according to Dory, they eat it. And she has various versions of what happened. She says she took a bite. She says in one version that she immediately vomited this bite. Another version, she ate the plate and was totally fine. Another version, she didn't really eat at all. But Frederick does eat some of this chicken and immediately starts exhibiting signs of illness. He's sweaty, he's feverish. At some point, his arm doesn't move. He seems immobile. He's gasping. And it's quite some time before she actually goes to Margaret and says, can you please help me? Dr. Ritter is in bad shape.
36:33 Speaker 03 Margaret agreed to come help, but it was too late. She saw Frederick was clearly dying.
36:40 Speaker 02 And she has quite a different version of Dory and Frederick's interactions during this time. According to Dory, it was all gentle and they caressed each other's hands. And Frederick was whispering sweet words to her. And according to Margaret, Frederick said to Dory, I curse you with my dying breath, and made a jerky movement as if to leap up and hit Dory. And so this very interesting differences in their accounts of how Frederick died.
37:11 Speaker 03 Was Margaret suspicious of Dory?
37:14 Speaker 02 She does make a comment that she doesn't understand why Dory waited so long to come and seek help. So I think that that's as far as Margaret wanted to go in accusing Dory of maybe, maybe, you know, letting Frederick suffer and linger there a little longer than she might have.
37:32 Speaker 03 What does Dory do after Frederick dies?
37:36 Speaker 02 Oh, you know, she has lots of flowery language for him in her memoir, but she's pretty eager to get off the island at that point.
37:45 Speaker 03 By this time, Captain Hancock had arrived on the island. He agreed to take Dory back to the mainland, where she could book a trip home to Germany.
37:55 Speaker 02 There's all kinds of interesting behavior on Hancock's yacht from Dory. And what's really fascinating is during the research of this book, I was lucky to come across video of these people. So I actually watched footage of Dory leaving the island and saw exactly what she looked like, what she was doing, what she was wearing, her facial expressions, how she was crying. She was wearing this sort of jaunty little sailor dress. And once she got on the ship, you know, I see, there, the footage stopped, but there's pictures of her on the ship where she actually looks quite serene. I think she spent quite a bit of time in her cabin and then decided to come out and mingle and started, you know, you know, showing a new side of herself and being a little bit more outgoing.
38:39 Speaker 02 And I think Frederick probably stifled her a lot.
38:43 Speaker 03 Were the Baroness and Roberts bodies ever found?
38:46 Speaker 02 No, they were not, no.
38:50 Speaker 03 Abbott says there are lots of different theories about what happened to them. Some people believe they hadn't died.
38:59 Speaker 02 For a long time, Margaret, I think she never went back on that declaration that they went on a yacht in Tahiti. And she said she, you know, heard the reports of later, years later, that the Baroness was there. There were rumors that the Baroness had gone somewhere else in Ecuador, maybe to another island where she was starting a new colony. There are rumors that they got swept out to the ocean somehow, and which seemed doubtful because it seemed the tide would bring them back in if they didn't have anything to hold them down. And when I went to Floriana myself in May of 2022, I talked to several native Ecuadorians and they said when they were growing up in Floriana, they always heard rumors that the bodies were in a cave somewhere. And when they were children, they would actually
39:44 Speaker 02 go peer around in caves and try to look for bones.
39:48 Speaker 03 What do you think happened?
39:51 Speaker 02 I really think that Rudolph is behind the disappearance of the Baroness and Robert, and that Frederick Gitter helped him. I don't know if he actually assisted in the murder. I think he certainly assisted in disposing of the bodies or getting rid of them in some way, or hiding them in some way. And I think that Dory suspected this, and I think it made her terrified of Frederick. And I also think that Margaret, you know, she might not have been aware of what Frederick was doing, but she certainly aided and abetted Rudolph after the fact and gave him safe harbor and lied for him, you know, talking about this mysterious yacht that came and picked up the Baroness and Robert Phillipsen and brought them to Tahiti. So everybody seemed guilty of something, but, you know,
40:35 Speaker 02 varying degrees of severity.
40:39 Speaker 03 Were Dory and Hines and Margaret questioned by authorities ever?
40:43 Speaker 02 They were. Authorities, of course, did question them after all the disappearances. They sort of passed that investigation with flying colors.
40:52 Speaker 03 Dory Hines and Margaret wrote a joint statement about everything that had happened leading up to the Baroness and Robert's disappearance. They wrote about how miserable Rudolph had been and how badly he wanted to leave. They wrote, "We know nothing of the Baroness's whereabouts, dead or alive."
41:13 Speaker 03 One story left. It was only Hines, Margaret, and their children left on Floriana.
41:19 Speaker 02 The Whitmers, you know, seemed to be most suited for island life since the beginning, and they proved that correct. You know, one of their guests recently said something to the effect of, "When the sun sets and the hacienda Paradiso is in smoldering ruins and Dory and Frederick have abandoned the island, you know, the Whitmers will be sitting there, rejoicing at the sunset, Hines smoking his pipe, and Margaret playing with their children, and they're the ones who are going to live out their days there." And that's exactly what happened. And they had another child who is actually still alive and who I met when I was on the island. She's in her 80s now. And her two daughters run two hotels on Black Beach.
42:04 Speaker 02 One of them's called Hotel Whitmer. And the ground floor of Hotel Whitmer has this sort of museum that's built to honor Heinz and Margaret's life on the island with many of their artifacts, their luggage, a phonograph, several of their tools, guns, things like that. And they have quite an extensive library shelf filled with books about Floriana and people who had memoirs, people who had lived there. I think the only book that is missing conspicuously is Dory's memoir.
42:34 Speaker 03 Margaret and Dory both published memoirs about their time on the island. Dory called hers Satan came to Eden. Eight years after leaving Floriana, Dory died in Germany from complications of multiple sclerosis. She was 42. Heinz died on Floriana in 1963. Margaret died on Floriana in 2000. She was 95.
43:02 Speaker 02 And she really, I think, enjoyed when people would come to visit her on Floriana. You know, there's reports of people sort of making a pilgrimage to see Margaret and she would serve them homemade wine and for a certain amount of money, she would start talking about the days of all these people on Floriana and what happened. And, you know, she had some one saying that she would say, "A closed mouth admits no flies." So she would never tell all that she knew, but she really, really enjoyed talking around it and suggesting things and taunting people. And my favorite line from her, of course, is when she would ask people, "Do you think I did it?"
43:56 Speaker 03 To learn more, check out Abbott Kaler's book, Eden Undone: A True Story of Sex, Murder, and Utopia at the Dawn of World War II. Criminal is created by Lauren Spoor and me. Nadia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susannah Roberson, Jackie Sajikko, Lilly Clark, Lena Silhison, and Megan Kinnane. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Semenetti. Julianne Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. And you can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com/newsletter. We hope you'll consider supporting our work by joining
44:38 Speaker 03 our membership program, Criminal Plus. You can listen to Criminal: This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery without any ads. Plus, you'll get bonus episodes. These are special episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spoor, talking about everything from how we make our episodes, to the crime stories that caught our attention that week, to things we've been enjoying lately. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com/plus. We're on Facebook at This is Criminal, and Instagram and TikTok at criminal_podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com/criminalpodcast. Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
45:53 Speaker 01 LinkedIn is pretty amazing at helping you grow your small business. We cannot stop your new clients from emailing you at 3 a.m.
46:03 Speaker 01 We can help you sell, market and hire in one place. We cannot help you be in three places at once. And while we can't help you organize your calendar, LinkedIn can help you land more clients so you have a calendar to organize. Grow your small business on LinkedIn. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/smallbusiness.
46:24 Speaker 04 Now streaming on Paramount+. I'm Dexter Morgan. I've been killing killers for half my life. It gets to you. You're having a midlife crisis. I'm not ready for this. He's back. I'm older. I'm wiser. And sharper than ever. Things are gonna get messy. But if I can't believe in myself, I can't believe in anything. Dexter Resurrection. New season now streaming on the Paramount+ Premium Plan.
Previous The Double Next The Clock Starts Ticking Page updated November 2, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated