The Long Island Serial Killer | The 911 Call That Exposed The Gilgo Beach Murders (Part 1)
Hosted by Derrick Levasseur and Stephanie Harlowe
- 1h 44m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the disappearance of 23-year-old Shannon Gilbert, whose frantic 911 call from inside a stranger's house in Oak Beach on May 1, 2010, ultimately exposed the Gilgo Beach murders and the Long Island Serial Killer. The hosts examine Shannon's tumultuous background, her work as an escort, and the chaotic night that ended when she fled into the dark marshlands, leading to the later discovery of multiple bodies along Ocean Parkway. The discussion highlights conflicting witness accounts from her driver Michael Pack and client Joseph Brewer, questions the local police handling of the case, and sets the stage for a deep-dive investigation into corruption, serial murder, and unidentified victims.
- Shannon Gilbert's frantic 911 call from a gated community in Oak Beach ultimately led authorities to uncover multiple sets of human remains along Ocean Parkway. 0:36
- Local police initially classified Shannon's disappearance and death as an accidental drowning despite her final 911 call stating someone was trying to kill her.
- Driver Michael Pack and client Joseph Brewer were both cleared as suspects by police after passing polygraph tests, despite inconsistent accounts of that night. 50:33
- Shannon's mother, Mary Gilbert, relentlessly pushed law enforcement to investigate further when local authorities initially dismissed the case as an accidental disappearance.
Chapters
- 0:00Introduction to the Long Island Serial Killer
Hosts introduce the case and explain the scope of the investigation.
- 1:59Aftermath, Arrests, and the Gilgo Beach Murders
The episode explains how the investigation expanded to uncover multiple victims and the eventual arrest of Rex Huerman.
- 6:44Background on Shannon Gilbert’s Early Life
Hosts detail Shannon’s family, foster care, and early struggles that shaped her future.
- 35:00Shannon’s Transition to Adult Life and Escort Work
The discussion covers Shannon’s move to New Jersey, her escort career, and relationships that influenced her path.
- 45:36Recounting the 911 Call
Hosts analyze the recorded 911 call, noting Shannon’s fear and the men’s attempts to get her out of the house.
- 48:32Background on Joe Brewer and Michael Pack
The hosts provide context on Brewer’s and Pack’s roles, their relationship to Shannon, and their statements about the incident.
- 50:28Police Investigation and Polygraph Results
Discussion of the police’s handling of the case, the polygraph tests Pack and Brewer passed, and the lack of suspicion against them.
- 53:50Shannon’s 911 Call Details
The hosts explain how Shannon’s call was transferred to state police, its length, and why it was withheld from the public for years.
- 56:00Family’s Fight for Answers
Mary Gilbert’s relentless pursuit of truth, her confrontation with police, and her belief that her daughter was murdered are highlighted.
- 58:00Police Response and Public Perception
The hosts critique the police’s handling of the case, the public’s perception of accidental death, and the impact on Shannon’s family.
- 1:00:00Unanswered Questions and Ongoing Investigation
The episode ends with unresolved questions about the 911 call, the possible involvement of Pack and Brewer, and the broader implications for the case.
- 1:01:48Sponsor Breaks and Production Notes
The show includes sponsored segments and brief production remarks between story beats.
- 1:11:43The Mystery of the Missing Body
Hosts outline the timeline of Shannon’s disappearance, the multiple 911 calls, and the eventual discovery of her body months later.
Highlights
- 0:36
Shannon Gilbert's Final 911 Callstory
Shannon Gilbert calls 911 from a stranger's house in Oak Beach at 5:00 AM, terrified that someone is trying to kill her, initiating a sequence of events that uncovers a serial killer's dumping ground.
- 21:58
Arrested for Prostitution Workdata
Shannon worked as an escort for the agency Lace Party Girls and was arrested during undercover police sting operations in New Jersey in 2007 and 2009.
- 36:29
The Appointment at Brewer's Housestory
Shannon books a two-hour appointment with Joseph Brewer through Craigslist, arriving at his Oak Beach house around 2:00 AM with her driver Michael Pack waiting outside.
- 47:38
Audio from the 911 Callinsight
Audio from Shannon's 23-minute 911 call reveals background voices of Brewer and Pack attempting to get her to leave while Shannon expresses extreme fear and confusion.
- 1:06:55
Fleeing to Gus Coletti's Housestory
After bolting from Brewer's house, Shannon pounds on the door of retired investigator Gus Coletti, then flees and hides under his boat when an SUV approaches.
- 1:28:29
First Remains Discovered by K-9data
A police officer and his K-9 dog Blue discover human remains wrapped in burlap along Ocean Parkway while searching the brush during an operation.
- 1:32:58
Discovery of Shannon's Remainsstory
Police recover Shannon Gilbert's remains in a marshy area nearly a year and a half after her disappearance, alongside a titanium plate matching her jaw surgery.
Quotes
“That call lasts about 23 minutes.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 1:01 “She tells the dispatcher, "Someone is after her."”
Stephanie Harlowe · 0:53 “It would take 13 years, a corrupt police chief, a green pickup truck, and a pizza crust thrown in a Manhattan trash can before anyone was charged.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 1:49 “She stays on the line for about 23 minutes.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 54:09 “Shannon's family attorney, John Ray, who we're going to talk about a lot, he's never bought that.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 48:55 “They weren't buried, they were in different stages of decomposition, which means they weren't all left there at the same time.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 1:30:03 “Shannon's family was outraged. She'd spent 23 minutes on the phone with 911 saying someone was trying to kill her.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 1:34:07 “Shannon is what started this whole ball rolling.”
Derrick Levasseur · 1:40:13 “We need to find answers for, for her.”
Derrick Levasseur · 1:40:02 “We will come back to what the autopsies found and we will come back to the fight over Shannon's cause of death because it's important and the person that many people believe were involved in her death.”
Stephanie Harlowe · 1:35:42
Sponsored segments
- Jolie 18:15–20:30
- Smalls 39:48–42:04
- Criminal Coffee 1:42:12–1:42:35
- Criminal Coffee 1:43:36–1:43:45
About this episode
Shannan Gilbert was 23 years old. It's just before five o'clock in the morning on May 1, 2010, and she's calling 911 from inside a stranger's house in a small gated community on Long Island called Oak Beach. She's terrified. She tells the dispatcher someone is after her. At one point she says, "They're trying to kill me." But she can't tell them where she is. That call lasts about 23 minutes. Then Shannan runs out of the house, banging on doors and screaming for help, and then she runs into the dark. She's never seen alive again. Now, if this were the whole story, it would be one more tragic missing persons case, the kind that never makes the news. A young woman who worked as an escort, who struggled with her mental health, who disappeared in the middle of the night. And for months, that's exactly how it was treated. But Shannan's mother would not let it go. And because she kept pushing, police eventually went looking for Shannan in the thick brush along a stretch of highway called Ocean Parkway. They didn't find her, but they did find someone else. Then they found three more women. By the following spring, they had uncovered ten more sets of human remains. It would take 13 years, a corrupt police chief, a green pickup truck, and a pizza crust thrown in a Manhattan trash can before anyone was charged. And when police finally made an arrest, the man they put in handcuffs was an architect who'd been living with his family in Massapequa Park, a short drive from where the bodies were found. This is the story of the Gilgo Beach murders.
Transcript
19,933 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Long Island
- Quince
- Ocean Parkway
- Oak Beach
- Wayfair
- Gilgo Beach
- Allenville
- Craigslist
- 48 Hours
- Fairway Drive
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated