Pod Insights Crime Weekly S3 Ep268: Crime Weekly News: Father Tracks Down and Saves Daughter! About this episode 14-year-old Emmarae Gervasi vanished from her East Patchogue, New York, home on December 9, 2024. After nearly a month of relentless searching, her father, Frank Gervasi, received an anonymous tip leading him to a boat docked in Islip, Long Island. There, he found Emmarae alive, ending a 26-day nightmare. Try our coffee!! - www. CriminalCoffeeCo.comBecome a Patreon member -- > ｿ https://www.patreon.com/CrimeWeeklyShop for your Crime Weekly gear here --> ｿ https://crimeweeklypodcast.com/shopYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/c/CrimeWeeklyPodcastWebsite: CrimeWeeklyPodcast.comInstagram: @CrimeWeeklyPodTwitter: @CrimeWeeklyPodFacebook: @CrimeWeeklyPod
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 When your workday is constantly disrupted, your workflow isn't flowing. It's come to a grinding halt. You don't need an assistant. You need superpowers. Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly is built for how you actually work. No new tabs, no switching apps, no losing your place. Go handles busy work like finding documents or summarizing email threads, so you can focus on the work only you can do. Try Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com.
0:30 Speaker 01 You need to clean your gutters before they become a bigger, more costly issue. So let the pros at Leaf Filter handle that for you. You'll get a free gutter inspection and a no obligation estimate, plus a lifetime warranty and no clog guarantee. Right now, you can get up to 35% off when you go to leaffilter.com/gold. That's up to 35% off at L-E-A-F-filter.com/gold. Restrictions apply. See representative for warranty and promotion details.
1:14 Derrick Levasseur? Hey, everyone. Welcome back to Crime Weekly News. I'm Derrick Levasseur.
1:17 Stephanie Harlowe? And I'm Stephanie Harlow.
1:19 Derrick Levasseur? And we're going to start off with something positive, because as you can tell from the title of this episode, it's not a great, it's not a great piece of news, although there is, I guess I would call it a better ending than we usually get. But before we get into that, as we all know, Valentine's Day is around the corner, and we wanted to do something special for Criminal Coffee. So we've come out with a limited edition Valentine's Day Criminal Coffee hoodie. If you're not on YouTube right now and you're only listening on audio, it's basically a pink hoodie with red letters and the Criminal Coffee fingerprint, instead of it being a little thumbprint, it's actually been turned into a heart. So it's still a coffee bean thumbprint, but now in the shape of a heart. We promoted it on our social media and on our newsletter.
2:02 Derrick Levasseur? So if you're not following us on social media or you're not subscribed to the free newsletter, you're only hearing, hearing about it now. It's not too late. You can order the sweatshirt right now. It's a preorder and every order that's placed before January 27th. You, we can guarantee you, you'll get it before Valentine's Day. We're gonna continue it. You can still buy it. But if you order after January 27th, you may not get it before Valentine's Day. We're still gonna try, but no guarantee, but Stephanie loves the sweatshirt.
2:34 Stephanie Harlowe? I don't even care if I would get it after Valentine's Day. I would wear this all year round. Like I was in Rhode Island. I don't know, like a week and a half ago, two weeks ago. I can't even tell at this point. But when I was at the, yeah, when I was at the warehouse, I saw the mockups and there were a couple of other designs too. And I was like, oh my God, I want every single one of these. I love these. They're adorable. Um, there was one that said, you're so cute. It's criminal on the back, but we wouldn't get it in time. So if you guys want us to release that next year, let us know because I do. I do like, I was like, Derek, where's this one? Where's this one? He's like, oh, it wouldn't come out in time, blah, blah. And I'm like,
3:10 Derrick Levasseur? Well, not in time for, yeah, for Valentine's.
3:11 Stephanie Harlowe? I want it so bad. So these are adorable. I love them. I'm not even a pink person. Like I'm really not, and I love these designs. My, some of my favorites so far.
3:21 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, we've already sold, just with the newsletter and social, just full disclosure, we've sold hundreds already. So it's going to be a lot, but again, if you order before the 27th, we will do our best. I, I pretty much, unless there's something that comes up, we'll have it to you before Valentine's Day. After that, you'll still probably get it in February. We'll probably do it for the whole month of February and then we'll shut it down. We have a lot of exclusive, like limited time, merch that we're gonna come out with. As Stephanie was saying, we have so many designs that you guys haven't seen yet for both Criminal Coffee and Crime Weekly. It's just a matter of the process, the logistics, all that stuff. So we got it coming, but yes, if you want the Valentine's Day sweatshirt, you can go get it right now at CriminalCoffeeCo.com. Okay.
4:01 Derrick Levasseur? Now for why we're here today, because again, this is a story that is not a good story. It's actually very scary as a parent. With a little bit of a better ending than we normally get, but yet there's still a lesson to be learned here because we share this not because it's something that can be covered on Crime Weekly, but something that every parent has to be aware of. So here's the overview and it's a little clunky. A lot of details have not came out yet. We're going to learn a lot more about this story. But from what we're finding so far, there was a 14 year old girl that was essentially kidnapped after being drugged out of Long Island. And the story is kind of like almost a movie taken, if you've seen that where
4:40 Derrick Levasseur? essentially from what we know, this this young girl who's been identified as Emma Ray by her father Frank Gervasi, she's had some ongoing problems. And there's more to the story that Stephanie is going to get into. But basically, she was with some unsavory characters. That's a direct quote from Frank. And they drugged her, they abducted her and they took her to a boat. And how this story all turned out, it's pretty incredible that we're sitting here right now reporting that Emma Ray is still alive. That's, that's the good news. But there's a lot more to get into. It's almost like a movie plot. Stephanie, what's, what's the specifics?
5:16 Stephanie Harlowe? So Emma Ray Gervasi, a 14 year old from Long Island, she was reported missing on December 9, 2024, after she was seen getting into a car outside her home without shoes or a jacket. According to her father Frank, he said that she had stepped out of her house to get something from the driveway. She was taken from there. He said, quote, I believe that she might have left willingly to get something out of a car and maybe got pulled in at that point, end quote. And Frank said that he believed she was being held against her will. And after 26 days, on January 3, 2025, her father Frank received an anonymous tip that led him to a boat docked in
5:56 Stephanie Harlowe? Islip where he found Emma Ray. She was then taken into a hospital for evaluation and in connection with her disappearance, two individuals so far have been arrested. There's no saying that there won't be more people arrested or more people implicated. But the two individuals who were arrested were Francis Buckhite, 65 of Islip. He was arrested and charged with rape, kidnapping, and acting in a manner injurious to a child. And then just recently Bernice Knight, 47, was arrested and charged with rape in the second degree, endangering the welfare of a child, and criminal sale of a controlled substance. Now, both suspects have pleaded not guilty to the charges because the audacity. Yeah.
6:40 Stephanie Harlowe? Uh, the investigation is ongoing. Authorities are working to uncover the full details surrounding Emma Ray's disappearance and her subsequent discovery by her father. And like I said, this is where the Taken aspect comes in because we all know the movie Taken, Liam Neeson. If you don't know it, you should definitely watch it. I think there's like three or 12.
6:59 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, there's three.
7:00 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, there's a three or 12 Taken.
7:01 Derrick Levasseur? They're not as good as they continue on.
7:02 Stephanie Harlowe? Yes, definitely not. But the first Taken is amazing and I think every parent would want.
7:08 Derrick Levasseur? I told you I would find you.
7:09 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
7:10 Derrick Levasseur? Best line ever.
7:10 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah. Good, good luck.
7:13 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, that's it. And then he hears it when he's in the, I don't want to go there. We're gonna make this about Taken.
7:17 Stephanie Harlowe? It's so good.
7:17 Derrick Levasseur? Great part.
7:18 Speaker 04 You know those days when you're nonstop busy, but by the end you've got nothing to show for it other than a ton of open tabs and another missed lunch break? You don't just need an assistant, you need superpowers. Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly is built for how you actually work. It's right there when you need it, on the side of your browser, already aware of what's in front of you. No new tabs, no switching apps, no losing your place. You can ask it to draft something, summarize a long thread, pull up a file, or even prep you for a meeting. Staying busy doesn't mean you're also staying productive. When your to-do list is disrupted by back-to-back meetings and searching for buried email threads, your workflow isn't flowing. It's come to a grinding halt.
8:03 Speaker 04 Go handles the busy work without you ever leaving the page you're on, so you can focus on the work only you can do. Try Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com. That's superhuman.com.
8:18 Speaker 01 You need to clean your gutters before they become a bigger, more costly issue. So let the pros at Leaf Filter handle that for you. You'll get a free gutter inspection and a no obligation estimate, plus a lifetime warranty and no claw guarantee. Right now, you can get up to 35% off when you go to leaffilter.com/gold. That's up to 35% off at L-E-A-F-filter.com/gold. Restrictions apply. See representative for warranty and promotion details.
8:47 Stephanie Harlowe? So Frank, he spent weeks looking for his daughter. He was driving around night and day. He was offering a $15,000 reward for her return, as any parent would do. And then he received a tip on Friday from a woman who told him that there was a child on a boat in Islip. Frank followed it and then he, he explained in a video on Saturday, what, what happened, kind of when, when he arrived and, and everything that went down. Should we play that?
9:14 Derrick Levasseur? Uh, yeah, if you want to play it.
9:16 Speaker 05 A lot of confusion, a lot of dumb comments I'm reading, that Emma could have just left on her own will. Completely incorrect. Emma was being held against her will. She was not allowed to leave the boat unless she was escorted by somebody. And she was being forced to do things that a 14 year old girl shouldn't have to do. So I do believe this is sex trafficking and it's being looked into. So can we just leave the stupid comments off the page that, you know, my daughter's a runaway and things like that? She may have left the house with a stupid thought. What happened to her in this really bad world we live in is what we're talking about here. Trafficking is a huge problem across the world.
10:02 Speaker 05 It's a very big problem on Long Island and I, and I, and I stress that parents should keep an eye on their children, keep an eye on your little girls, even your boys, okay? Because these people are predators and they will stop at nothing to get to your kids. Anytime a kid is being held against their will or forced to do things that they don't want to do, um, whether it's for addiction purposes or whatever it is, that's a form of sex trafficking, okay? They get these girls, they, they get them hooked on drugs and they make them do stupid stuff for it. That's called sex trafficking. So it's being, you know, brought to the light and we're working closely with detectives on it.
10:46 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, this clip was, it's troubling because there, there's obviously more to this story that we're going to find out about. Clearly.
10:54 Derrick Levasseur? Emma Ray was wearing a bracelet, an ankle brace, a monitor and there was another clip where Frank kind of explained why that was and I guess she was a runaway slash wayward child and he filed a petition to put this ankle monitor on her and, and that's why she had it on her and he's very transparent, she's had some issues before and he even said in the first clip that she might have taken some drugs voluntarily and then while on those drugs, this is when these other drugs were administered and they just completely knocked her out and made her incoherent, which is why she was able to be taken. But he goes on in this clip that you just saw basically saying, hey guys, can we hold off on the comments and you know, she did this and she's responsible for it? No, hard stop,
11:35 Derrick Levasseur? not true. The 65-year-old man who took her and held her on a boat and did things to her that she did not consent to and she couldn't consent to at 14 years old regardless, he's the bad guy here. In fact, just to kind of go on a little bit of a rant, and I don't know if it's changed since, but the only reason we know about Francis is because Frank identified him. And then obviously, the New York Post and others were able to go cross-reference it and see who was arrested on that date and time, their age, etc. And they're able to connect the dots. But when the last time I saw law enforcement had not released the suspect's identity, are you kidding me?
12:16 Stephanie Harlowe? I know. I'm glad he, I'm glad he said his name. I'm glad.
12:19 Derrick Levasseur? Of course, of course. Listen, everyone's innocent until proven guilty, but we want to know who this guy is because there's definitely some truth to it. At minimum, he's on the boat with this 14-year-old girl. At minimum. What are you doing? But I, I think there's a lot more to it. And again, obviously she went to the hospital. You can see from the charges that law enforcement has filed, that there was obviously some evidence to support that. So yeah, you know, this guy, release his name. Everyone else's name is out there. His name should be out there as well. And these are the things that just drive me insane as a former cop. Like, this is why people get pissed off. I see it. Like, I just don't get it. What are we doing? Like, everybody else's name goes out there for a weed offense, or for, you know,
13:03 Derrick Levasseur? driving without a license and get arrested on a warrant. It's in the dispatch log the next day. But we're not gonna put this guy's name out there?
13:09 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
13:09 Derrick Levasseur? It's just ridiculous, but I have my, uh, my qualms, that's for sure.
13:14 Stephanie Harlowe? The fact of the matter is, it doesn't matter if she had a history of running away. In fact, that just makes her more ripe to be a victim.
13:22 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, and this person knew that?
13:23 Stephanie Harlowe? Or chosen, exactly, so...
13:25 Derrick Levasseur? That's why they cut off the ankle monitor as soon as they got her. They knew it was up.
13:27 Stephanie Harlowe? So, you have a history of running away. Not only does that make her a better victim for them, because she might be considered just a runaway by police, which we've seen happen.
13:36 Derrick Levasseur? Did they take it as serious? Probably not.
13:39 Stephanie Harlowe? And, and secondly, there's a reason why she's running away. Whether she's got, you know, issues, she's feeling lonely at home, she's talking about this on social media, she's making friends on social media, quote-unquote "friends" on social media. Most children who are trafficked, it's, they know the person who's doing it. There's a relationship being built. It's not they're just, they're walking down the road and then they're snatched. There's some sort of personal relationship that the, the bad guy puts time and effort into building and creating, so that this person, the victim, feels safe enough to put themselves in a vulnerable position where they can then be snatched. The fact of the matter is, this, this poor 14-year-old girl was trapped on a boat with this guy, and, and who knows,
14:24 Stephanie Harlowe? honestly, how many others. We don't know the extent or the scope of this yet, for almost an entire month. And what happened to her was hell. And it's gonna take more than some medical care to, to make her whole again. Her life is going to be drastically different after this. And anybody out there who's saying like, "Oh, she ran away," or, "Oh, she knew this was gonna happen," you can also go [bleep] yourselves, because she's 14.
14:52 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, she don't have that, she don't, she can't make that decision.
14:55 Stephanie Harlowe? Clearly, she's going through something, whether it's, you know, substance abuse, or mental health issues. There's an epidemic of both amongst young people in this country right now. She's going through something. It made her a vulnerable target. But in no way ever in any scenario in any universe that exists could anybody with a brain and two brain cells to rub together to make a spark, look at this and blame her in any way. And if you're doing that, you have issues.
15:25 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, you're a part of the problem.
15:26 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
15:27 Derrick Levasseur? For sure. And there's so much more to it. This could have been a lot worse. You can go read the articles yourself.
15:32 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, they could have left in that boat and not come back.
15:34 Derrick Levasseur? Right. And from what Frank is saying, there's a whole crew of people involved. Allegedly, when she was first taken, she was brought to a hotel first and then transferred to the boat. And from what Frank is telling us, again, Frank is the only source right now. His daughter told him that she had overheard them saying they were going to take the boat, they were going to move it, and maybe there was a plan to even move her down south. Again, this is all alleged. We don't know about that. We only know what we know so far. We know about the arrests. We know where she was found. And on a positive note, there was a quote from Frank that I thought, as a father, you know, it was good to read that. And he said, basically, when he got on the boat, there was nobody else on the boat. And his daughter just looked at him and said, Oh, my God, Dad, what are you doing here? Thank you. Thank God. And she basically just gave him a big hug.
16:17 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, she rushed into his arms.
16:19 Derrick Levasseur? Yep. And he said it was the greatest feeling in the world. So, listen, Frank's out there acknowledging there's things that need to be worked on. And the fact that she's still with us and she has the opportunity to work on those things after going on what was a horrific experience, this could be something that hopefully, in the long run, she's able to process it like some of the courageous people out there who go through this type of trauma and are able to use it for positive, to not only help themselves but help others.
16:45 Speaker 04 When your workday is constantly disrupted, your workflow isn't flowing. It's come to a grinding halt. You don't need an assistant. You need superpowers. Superhuman Go, from the makers of Grammarly, is built for how you actually work. No new tabs, no switching apps, no losing your place. Go handles busy work like finding documents or summarizing email threads, so you can focus on the work only you can do. Try Superhuman Go, from the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com.
17:15 Speaker 06 Hey, everybody. Chris Koonahan here for Leaf Filter. I often give homeowners advice on TV, but I wanted to share my expertise here, too. The question I'm most often asked is how does Leaf Filter work so well? Well, our trusted pros clean out your gutters, realign and seal your gutters, and install Leaf Filter, America's number one gutter protection system. Leaf Filter inspection and estimate are always free for new customers. Plus, you can get up to 30% off if you go to leaffilter.com/go.
17:38 Derrick Levasseur? That's leafilter.com/gold. See representative for warranty details. Promotion is 20% off plus a 10% senior military discount. One discount per household. So yeah, the people condemning her and the father, we all have problems. Listen, we all live in glass houses. Nobody should be judging.
17:53 Stephanie Harlowe? Now educate yourself about human trafficking, what it looks like, what the victims of it look like. Educate yourself and and shut your mouth until you have.
18:00 Derrick Levasseur? Exactly. And I think it's a lesson for all of us because yes, Emma was more susceptible to it. But it can happen to any young adult or even a young child where someone out there who has these malicious intentions. Finds something that interests your child, even if they're not wearing an ankle monitor, they haven't run away. And they get them just outside the home and that's all it takes is a couple of seconds and your life is changed forever. So. Again, I would rather not be discussing this case, but I will say it's part of the reason I was. Okay with it was because there is a little bit of some, I don't want, I hate to even use the word like a good ending because it's not good.
18:41 Stephanie Harlowe? It's she, she didn't get taken and we've never heard from her again. That's the best, that's the best case scenario when something happens because if they start moving her, they move her down south.
18:52 Derrick Levasseur? That's it. She's gone.
18:53 Stephanie Harlowe? They're bringing other people on this boat now. They're selling her, things like that. And now maybe then they move her to a different country. We don't know what happens to her. So obviously we, I'm sure all of us wish and Frank as well and her parents wish. This had not happened to begin with, but he came in clutch, grabbed her, took her home. Before she could have become a ghost and that is the best case scenario that we can hope for in this situation.
19:21 Derrick Levasseur? Of course, and I, and for full disclosure, we're not, we're not oblivious to the fact that there's some other things going on here. We're not. We're not on anybody's team.
19:29 Stephanie Harlowe? Does not matter. I'm on her team.
19:32 Derrick Levasseur? I'm on her team for sure, but just to be transparent, part of the criticism coming to Frank and the family. And this is something that Frank has admitted. Apparently Frank and his wife have made some videos that they have posted online on OnlyFans and other websites. And so that's where a lot of the criticism is coming from. The environment that was created that could have led to Emma. We're not here to judge that. We're here to talk about the crime.
20:02 Stephanie Harlowe? That's, yeah. I'm on Emma Ray's team. I'm on her side. Whatever adults in her life did, whatever they did.
20:11 Stephanie Harlowe? This is not what should have happened to her and this is not what she was meant for. So, yeah.
20:15 Derrick Levasseur? Correct. So, we're just looking out for the children because somebody has to and we're hoping we find out more about these individuals. Have they done this before? I'm sure they were going to do it again. At minimum, we got them off the street and now we won't have any more victims at their hands.
20:32 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, unfortunately, there's 15 more to replace them when they go away. That's why we have to remain vigilant. Remain vigilant. Watch what your kids are doing on the internet, please.
20:40 Derrick Levasseur? Yes, absolutely. Well, we'll knock them down one at a time. Any other words from you? This is kind of more of a quick episode, but we wanted to cover it. We really want to get into this, the new series this week. We're going to be recording it later today. Do you want to tell them what it is, considering this is a shorter, let's tell them. Let's change it up.
20:57 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, so Derek and I, I think it was a few months ago that we had mentioned the Ray Rivera case. It was on Unsolved Mysteries a few years back, the reboot. And I was talking about how I had covered it on YouTube back in like 2020 and that other things have come out since and it's just such a really good, mysterious case. Even Shannon, our editor, had texted me and said, "What case are we doing?" And I said, "Ray Rivera," and she's like so excited. She's like, "Oh, my God, this is such a great case. I'm so excited to hear what you guys think about it." And so we've decided that we're going to cover the Ray Rivera case on Crime Weekly and really do a deep dive and get Derek's take on it, so.
21:34 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, I'm looking forward to learning more about it with all of these cases. Yes, I've heard the name before. I don't know the specifics of the case. I always like learning more because something that happened in this case, based on, I don't even know if it was solved or not, but. Whatever actions were taken by law enforcement, I always like to keep notes because you can apply it to future cases that we discuss here or in my own investigations going forward. So you're always learning, you're always growing. It's another tool in the toolbox. That's why I love covering these cases. As far as Emma, we're happy for her and her family that they're reunited. This could have been a lot worse and we're hoping that moving forward, it can bring their family closer and that this, this ultimately results in something positive where they can all learn from it, grow from it.
22:16 Derrick Levasseur? And again, potentially share what they've been through to help others who may be going through similar situations. We've got to always hope for a better place, a better world for everyone. So, but that's going to do it for us, guys. Looking forward to covering the Ray Rivera case. We'll be back soon. Until then, everyone stay safe out there. Have a good night.
22:32 Stephanie Harlowe? Bye.
22:44 Speaker 04 When your workday is constantly disrupted, your workflow isn't flowing. It's come to a grinding halt. You don't need an assistant, you need superpowers. Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly is built for how you actually work. No new tabs, no switching apps, no losing your place. Go handles busy work like finding documents or summarizing email threads so you can focus on the work only you can do. Try Superhuman Go from the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com.
23:14 Speaker 07 You're listening to Leaf Filter Radio and the guru of gutter protection himself, Chris Koonahan is here to take your most pressing leaf-related questions.
23:22 Speaker 06 Hey everybody, Chris here. I understand we have Ron on the line. Ron, where are you calling from?
23:28 Speaker 07 Uh oh. Ron, are you calling from a ladder? Well, I was. Uh, I wanted to ask Chris what I need to do to get my gutters ready to have Leaf Filter installed?
23:38 Speaker 06 Oh, Ron, you don't have to do anything. A Leaf Filter Trusted Pro will come out and clean out your gutters, realign and seal your gutters and install Leaf Filter, America's number one gutter protection system.
23:48 Speaker 07 So I didn't need to get on this ladder?
23:50 Speaker 06 Ron, Leaf Filter Trusted Pros are in your neighborhood and ready to help. Just visit leefilter.com/gold to schedule your free gutter inspection and get up to 30% off.
24:00 Speaker 07 Thank goodness. What was that site? That's leefilter.com/gold for your free gutter inspection today. See representative for warranty details. Promotion is 20% off plus a 10% senior or military discount. One discount per household.
Previous S3 Ep267: Jason Burgeson & Amy Shute: Golf Course Double Homicide (Part 2) Next S3 Ep269: Rey Rivera: Pursuit of Happiness Ends in Tragedy (Part 1) Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated