Pod Insights Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder Ep. 53 | Terrifying Stalkers Who Turned Into Killers About this episode In today's episode, we look into cases where stalking becomes a little more than anticipated, or was that their plan the entire time? Let's dive in!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Imagine a future where your child takes on every school challenge confidently. With WiseAnt, the nation's largest network for online tutoring, their confidence is just a lesson away. WiseAnt tutors have helped millions of students conquer tough subjects like algebra and chemistry, get into the college of their dreams, and build a lifelong appreciation for learning. Unlock your child's full potential today at wiseant.com. That's W-Y-Z-A-N-T dot com. And use code PODCAST15 for $15 off your first lesson. Imagine a future where your child takes on every school challenge confidently. With WiseAnt, the nation's largest network for online tutoring, their confidence is just a lesson away. WiseAnt tutors have helped millions of students conquer tough subjects like algebra and chemistry,
0:44 Speaker 00 get into the college of their dreams, and build a lifelong appreciation for learning. Unlock your child's full potential today at wiseant.com. That's W-Y-Z-A-N-T dot com. And use code PODCAST15 for $15 off your first lesson.
0:59 Speaker 01 It begins with a glance, a casual interaction, a friendly smile from across the office, or a message in an online chatroom. And most of us forget these moments the next day. But for a stalker, it's the beginning of a fantasy. One that grows darker, more obsessive, and eventually deadly. Stalking is often dismissed as harmless, a joke in pop culture, or shrugged off by authorities as just someone being weird. But in truth, it's a pattern of control, obsession, and entitlement. One that can scale and escalate in terrifying ways. And in this video, we'll examine three cases where stalking didn't end with unanswered calls or restraining orders, because these stalkers didn't back down.
1:41 Speaker 01 They waited, they plotted, and when their illusions were shattered, they turned violent. What you're about to hear are stories of manipulation, jealousy, and murder. Crime, conspiracy, cults, serial killers, and murder, all things that I love to consume, and I know you do too, you sick, twisted, intellectually beautifully-minded freak! I think I said that wrong. Whoops. Anyway. Today, we are getting into three very, very disturbing cases.
2:10 Speaker 01 That involve stalking and sometimes murder. So if you're sensitive to that, you can skip this video. But if you're here for it, let's unbuckle our seat belts, go Mach 5 down the highway, slam on the brakes and bust through this windshield into these three stalking cases together. Also, for the only audio listeners, you won't be able to appreciate this, but for my video what people, look at, oh, Ruby, Ruby, Ruby, you can see Ruby down there. He's my little true crime buddy now. I gotta get him a higher pedestal so you guys can appreciate his wonder. Anyway.
2:57 Speaker 02 Network freedom and flexibility. That's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to build Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
3:32 Speaker 01 It was a chilly morning in February 1986 in Van Nuys, California. A newlywed Sherri Rasmussen woke up feeling slightly under the weather and decided to stay home from work. And her husband of just three months, John Rutten, would kiss her goodbye as he did every morning while she lay in bed, completely unaware that this would be their final farewell. Because when John returned home later that evening, he would walk straight into a nightmare. He would find that their townhouse was in complete disarray with broken glass, overturned furniture, and blood staining the carpet. And in the middle of it all, lay his brand-new wife, Sherri, lifeless, still wearing her robe. And she had been brutally beaten and shot three times at close range.
4:13 Speaker 01 And Sherri's face would be very badly injured as well, smashed by a very heavy ceramic vase that was ...in nearby her body. But the defensive wounds on her body told the story of a very ferocious fight for survival. She had even torn off two fingernails clawing at her attacker. There was also a deep bite mark on her inner forearm, which was just evidence of a very fierce struggle. Yet oddly, the scene bore signs of a robbery gone wrong. Because stereo equipment and a VCR were stacked by the front door, and valuables were kind of scattered around, and Sherry's new BMW was missing from the garage. So initially, the L.A. P.D. thought that Sherry might have stumbled onto a burglary in process and paid with her life. And it was a very plausible theory.
4:57 Speaker 01 But soon, deeper questions would emerge. And those questions were, who would have killed Sherry? And why had the attack seemed so intensely personal? Now, Sherry Rasmussen, by all accounts, was a very vibrant, intellectual, and highly accomplished woman, whose life had held immense promise. She was born and raised in Los Angeles, California, and she was known from an early age for her determination, kindness, and impressive intellect. And by the age of 27, Sherry had already built a remarkable career in nursing, recently becoming the director of nursing at a prestigious Los Angeles hospital. A very rare achievement for someone of her age. And colleagues would go on to describe her as extremely inspiring, passionate about her profession, dedicated to her patients, and just beloved by those who worked with her.
5:41 Speaker 01 And her personal life was just as fulfilling. Because in late 1985, Sherry would marry John, a man she deeply, deeply loved. And they would move into a townhouse together in Van Nuys, a very comfortable and quiet neighborhood in the San Fernando Valley, which was ideal for a young couple starting their married life. And the couple, again, had only been married three months at the time of this tragedy, still in the honeymoon phase of their relationship. And friends and family said that the two seemed genuinely happy and excitedly planned their future together. And in her personal time, Sherry was very athletic and energetic. And she often spent the weekends playing tennis and staying active. And on February 24th, 1986, Sherry decided to stay home from work because she was feeling under the weather. But that decision placed her unknowingly in the path of a violent attack that would
6:26 Speaker 01 shock everyone who knew her. So it just left in vestiges. ...grasping to understand why would anyone kill this young beloved woman? So like I said before, the LAPD initially thought this was a robbery gone wrong because all the signs were there. Sign of forced entry, electronics stacked at the door, valuables rummaged through, and Sherry's BMW was missing. And in 1986, in Los Angeles, violent break-ins were tragically very common. But almost immediately, that conclusion began to fray. And there were clues, obvious ones, that didn't quite fit a burglary theory. Because Sherry had clear defensive wounds, torn fingernails, suggesting a very prolonged and violent struggle. The shattered vase that lay near her body, the bite mark that was visible on her forearm,
7:11 Speaker 01 and the stacked electronics had blood on them, meaning they were moved after Sherry had already been mortally wounded. So if theft was truly the motive, why didn't the killer actually take anything? Leads were scarce. Because DNA technology was rudimentary at the time, and the partial fingerprints and bite swab were left unanalyzed. But to those who knew Sherry best, all of the pieces just didn't add up, and they never believed that it was random. And Sherry's father, Nels, was one of the first to raise the alarm. Because as he comforted John, Sherry's husband, in the wake of his daughter's murder, John mentioned something unsettling. And that was that there was a woman from his past that hadn't taken his new marriage very well. So for more than two decades, Sherry's murder sat cold in the LAPD archives, classified
7:56 Speaker 01 as a tragic but unsolved home invasion. And the grieving Rasmussen family never stopped believing that the true killer had been overlooked. But the pleas seemed to fall on deaf ears. Then, in the early 2000s, a spark of hope would emerge. And not through testimony or confession, but through science. Because in 2005, advances in DNA technology gave the LAPD an opportunity to revisit evidence that had once been impossible to process fully. And criminalists would reexamine that bite mark collected from Sherry's arm at the time of the crime. And this time, the results would be definite and startling. Because the DNA profile revealed the attacker was a woman. And this revelation just shattered the long-held assumption that two male burglars had killed Sherry. Yet, even with this breakthrough, the The case didn't move forward.
8:41 Speaker 01 So the results were logged, but not pursued, just falling through the cracks of bureaucracy and internal disinterest. And it wasn't until 2009, during a comprehensive cold case review, that Sherri's file landed on the desk of Detective Jim Nuttall. And as he combed through the evidence, something immediately caught his attention, and that was the stacked stereo equipment near the door that had Sherri's blood on it. And that detail had been missed or ignored before. But to Jim, this was crucial. So someone tried to make it look like a burglary after Sherri was already dying on the floor. So from that moment, the direction of the investigation shifted. And Jim and his team now believed that this had not been about theft at all. It was just a personal attack disguised as a break-in.
9:24 Speaker 01 And the DNA profile of a female suspect only deepened the mystery, because this was a brutal attack. So what woman would have brutally attacked Sherri? And then staged it as a burglary? So two questions now haunted the detectives. Who was this woman? And why had no one looked into her before? So as DNA results pointed unmistakably to a female suspect, Detective faced a unnerving realization, because the evidence seemed to implicate one of their own. And that was Stephanie Lazarus. And she had long since become a respected figure within the LAPD. And by 2009, she was a seasoned detective in the department's elite art theft unit.
10:08 Speaker 01 And she had decades of experience and an outwardly spotless record. She was liked, known for her work ethic, and she was even featured in the department newsletter and photos. So to most of her colleagues, she was the embodiment of a trustworthy police officer. But behind the scenes, a small team of investigators began digging into her background, comparing it to what they now knew about the Rasmussen case. And their suspicions had been handled delicately. Because if Stephanie had learned that she was being investigated, she could manipulate the evidence, alert potential allies inside the department, or just flee. And investigators also knew that she still had access to weapons, insider knowledge, and a badge. So the risk was immense. So they would work
10:50 Speaker 01 In secrecy, and Stephanie would be quietly added to the shortlist of five possible female suspects. And one by one, the others were eliminated based on DNA. And by the end, only Stephanie would remain. And in a carefully orchestrated operation, a surveillance team actually shadowed Stephanie through her daily routine. And one day, while she stopped at Costco, she sipped from a soda cup and tossed it into the trash. And when she walked away, the officers would retrieve the discarded cup. And lab tests confirmed what investigators feared most. Because the DNA on the straw matched the saliva from the bite mark on Sherri Rasmussen's arm. And that bite mark overlooked and underutilized for more than two decades now revealed a horrifying truth.
11:31 Speaker 01 And that was that the killer hadn't just been an LAPD detective all this time, but also that the killer actually knew the victim very, very personally. So this DNA match was airtight, because the odds of that saliva coming from anyone else but Stephanie was astronomically low. So armed with DNA evidence, the investigators knew they had their prime suspect. But the question now was, why? Why did this LAPD officer kill Sherri? Well, two decades earlier, her name had actually lingered in the background of the original investigation. Mentioned briefly by both Sherri's grieving father and Sherri's husband. Because Stephanie had been Sherri's husband's old ex-girlfriend. A jealous one at that.
12:16 Speaker 01 But at the time, investigators dismissed the notion completely. Because the attack looked like a burglary gone wrong, and the attack was so incredibly violent, they thought, how could a woman have done this? But now with this DNA evidence, they knew that she was not just capable of it, they knew that she was guilty of it. So who really was Stephanie? Well, she had been John Rutten's ex-girlfriend. A college ex-girlfriend, actually. And they would meet at UCLA, and date it off and on throughout college. And eventually, they would part ways romantically, but not emotionally for her. So while John moved on, earning his engineering degree and falling in love with Sherri, Stephanie remained very close. A little too close.
13:00 Speaker 01 She would become a police officer, which was her lifelong dream, and was known around the department for her outgoing personality and her dedication to her work. But privately, Stephanie had been unable to let go of John. And in the months leading up to Sherry's murder, Stephanie's jealousy had become more and more overt. Because she had shown up unannounced to Sherry and John's condo while Sherry was home alone, which is terrifying. And she would be dressed in full LAPD uniform and said that she was just checking in. And Sherry would be obviously shaken and would ask her to leave. Because she would know at this point that this was John's ex. And another time, Stephanie would confront Sherry at the hospital that she worked at and would issue a very disturbing warning, saying that if John's marriage didn't work out, she'd be waiting.
13:44 Speaker 01 And as we know now, these were not idle comments. They were a prelude to murder. So by early 1986, Stephanie knew her last chance with John was gone. Because in an emotional moment shortly before John's wedding with Sherry, she had convinced him to sleep with her one final time. And this was a decision that John did confess to Sherry later on. And Sherry would forgive him, but Stephanie could not forgive the rejection. And then would come February 24th, 1986. So John, as we know, would leave for work that morning, and Sherry, feeling slightly unwell, would stay at home. And it would be a quiet weekday in venues, as usual. And at some point during the day, Stephanie showed up at the condo, most likely off-duty but armed.
14:27 Speaker 01 And she might have knocked and claimed she just wanted to talk. And she knew that Sherry was home alone. And once she got inside, things would escalate. And the physical struggle that followed was brutal. So Sherry, taller and athletic, fought back ferociously. So much so that she managed to tear off two of her fingernails clawing at Stephanie. But that's when Stephanie would grab that heavy ceramic vase and smash Sherry's face, completely breaking the right side and leaving it disfigured. And during the struggle, she bit Sherry on her inner forearm. And this was the deep, aggressive wound that would later carry the damning DNA. And seeing that Sherry was completely subdued at this point, Stephanie would stand up, pull out her 38 ...revolver, likely her off-duty weapon,
15:12 Speaker 01 and fire three shots, execution-style, into Sherri at close range. And the grouping of the wounds and the muzzle imprint on her skin confirmed how close the shooter was. And then, to cover her tracks, Stephanie would stage the scene. She stacked stereo equipment by the door, ransacked drawers, and stole Sherri's BMW, making it look like a burglary gone wrong. And it was a cover-up that unfortunately worked for decades, and no one had seriously suspected her. And the LAPD obviously had not considered their own. Even though Sherri's husband and father brought it up, it was completely dismissed. But luckily, DNA sealed her fate decades later, and now the real story of Sherri Rusmasen's death was out.
15:57 Speaker 01 It was a love triangle turned deadly and a jealous ex who used her badge to hide a brutal, brutal crime. So on June 5th, 2009, investigators would lure Stephanie into an interview room under the pretense of consulting her on a case involving a suspect. Because they didn't really want to tip her off right away, because she knew she was armed, they knew she could flee, they knew she could do something to potentially get away. So they had to trick her, basically. So she would come into the room unarmed and unsuspecting, and inside the interrogation room, two detectives would tell her that they wanted to ask her about an old incident. And that old incident was the death of Sherri in 1986. And at first, Stephanie just laughed off the question, just brushing them aside.
16:39 Speaker 01 But as the conversation deepened, and the detectives said that they had physical evidence of her trying to murder her, her demeanor completely shifted. And she started to become very visibly nervous, then combative, and eventually tried to deflect, saying stuff like, "You're accusing me of this? Am I on candid camera or something?" She said, "Dumb bitch." And that's when the tension in the room would escalate. And for a few more minutes, Stephanie stood up and demanded a lawyer, but it was too late. And as she exited the room, officers were waiting, and she would be immediately arrested for the murder of Sherri Rusmasen. And this arrest would send shockwaves through the LAPD, because the seasoned officer who had had decades of experience was now being being let out of headquarters in handcuffs.
17:22 Speaker 01 And in 2012, Stephanie would stand trial for first degree murder. And the prosecutors would lay out the full timeline. Her obsessive fixation on John, her confrontations with Sheri, the brutal slaying and the staged burglary. And they would just walk jurors through the overlooked warning signs, which was the ignored pleas of Sheri's father and the DNA that had ultimately broke the case wide open. So the evidence was just overwhelming. And John, Sheri's husband, was devastated but determined. And he would take the stand to recount the past with Stephanie and the loss of his wife. And the courtroom would fall silent as he would describe how he warned police back in 1986 about Stephanie's presence in their lives and how no one had listened at the time or taken it seriously.
18:06 Speaker 01 And Sheri's family, especially her father, Nels, sat through the trial with a heavy heart. Because for four years, Nels had insisted that Stephanie was the killer, even personally begging the LAPD to investigate her. But in 1986, pleas were just brushed aside. And now in court, justice finally had a face. And it was the same woman the system had once protected. So in March of 2012, the jury had its verdict. And that was that Stephanie Lazarus was guilty of first degree murder. And she would be sentenced to 27 years to life in prison. And she would appeal multiple times claiming the delay in prosecution was unfair. But the courts consistently upheld their conviction, thank God. And years later, in 2023, at a parole hearing, Stephanie finally confessed to the murder and offered an apology.
18:50 Speaker 01 Wow, so big of you. And luckily, her parole would be revoked and she remained incarcerated. And for Sheri's family, the long awaited conviction brought both closure and sorrow. Because justice had come, but it had taken two decades. And only after a persistent advocacy, DNA advancements and a fresh pair of eyes on a cold case file. And the LAPD, for its part, was forced into reflection. And investigations were launched into how Stephanie had evaded scrutiny. And questions arose about whether colleagues had ignored, minimized or even buried evidence in the original case. And ultimately, the case of Stephanie became one of the most haunting examples of what can happen when obsession, jealousy, And insider access converge. And when institutions fail to look inward.
19:35 Speaker 01 But today, Sherri's legacy lives on. Not just in memory, but in the systemic changes her case helped trigger. Because it is now a story that's told in classrooms, policing seminars, and true crime documentaries. And it's a stark warning that the greatest threats aren't always strangers lurking in the dark. Because sometimes, they're people we once trusted. And sometimes, they wear a uniform. And sometimes, they just sit down the hall.
20:02 Speaker 01 It was a quiet night in Buffalo, New York. The hum of the evening shift at the Dynebraide factory had faded. And most of the workers had clocked out. But in the shadowy corners of the employee parking lot, a figure waited. Brian Barret, a 22-year-old college student and factory worker, had stayed late helping to close up. And after he was done closing up, he would climb into his truck, unaware that someone was watching him from the darkness. And this figure would approach him silently, camouflaged, masked, and armed with a military-grade 30 caliber rifle. And in a moment, the silence was completely shattered. Because three shots rang out, fired at point-blank range through the truck window. And Brian never had a chance. And the killer would vanish,
20:45 Speaker 01 leaving the young man bleeding to death in his own front seat. And for two days, Brian's truck sat in the corner of the lot, completely unnoticed. And it was only when a coworker actually reported the vehicle hadn't moved and the police discovered Brian's body. And this wasn't a robbery. It was a cold, calculated, personal ambush. So the detectives would arrive at the scene and find no immediate motive. Because Brian was really well-liked. He was bright, and he was known to have no enemies. And nothing was stolen, and his truck was clearly undisturbed, besides the shell casings that were around it. And there were no signs of a struggle. And security footage offered really little evidence. Because the killer had moved under the cover of night and left no witnesses. So the crime appeared very professional,
21:30 Speaker 01 like someone who had planned this down to the last second. But who would do this to a quiet, well-liked college kid? And why?
21:40 Speaker 01 As we dug into Brian's personal life, something strange surfaced. His coworkers described him as friendly and outgoing, but also mentioned that he had recently been caught up in an unusual online relationship. Because Brian had been spending a lot of his time, hours upon hours, chatting with a woman online. And this was someone that he had never actually met in person, but who called herself Tall Hot Blonde, Subtle. And his friends would say that he was just completely infatuated. But this wasn't just any harmless fling. There was tension, jealousy even. It was a love triangle of sorts that had emerged online, including Brian, whose username was Beefcake, and the mysterious Tall Hot Blonde. And then the third name was Tommy,
22:24 Speaker 01 who used the screen name Marine Sniper. It's a terrifying username, but okay. And the chats between the three were intense and very emotional, and sometimes even aggressive. So investigators began to suspect that this digital romance had spiraled out of control somehow. But to understand how we got there, they needed to start at the beginning. So who really was Brian Barrett? Brian was from Western New York. And he was a digital student, and he was attending Buffalo State College while working part-time at Dynabrade, which was a local manufacturing company that made abrasive power tools. And by all accounts, Brian was friendly, popular, and driven, as we know. And he played sports in high school and kept close ties with his family. And he had big aspirations beyond the factory work that he currently did.
23:08 Speaker 01 But like many adults, Brian also spent time online, in forums and chatrooms, connecting with people beyond his small-town world. And that's when he would meet her. And it would start with a simple message, a playful exchange. And Tall Hot Blonde, the screen name of a flirtatious 18-year-old girl named Jessie, caught his attention on an online gaming platform called Pogo.com. And she claimed to be a softball-playing teenager from West Virginia. And she was blonde, athletic, bold. And she would send photos, and they would flirt, and they just hit it off, quite seemingly, right away. So the messages would start to turn more and more romantic. And over time, Brian just fell for her completely. He wasn't the only one.
23:52 Speaker 01 Because in the same chatroom, Jesse had also been talking with Tommy. And he was a marine stationed overseas. And he was charming, tough, and just full of confidence. So Jesse's conversations with both men kind of overlapped, and Brian found himself caught in a bizarre rivalry. Because at first, the chats between the trio were kind of playful, but soon, things would escalate and people would get jealous. So as investigators would just pour through the archived chat logs and emails, they saw how the situation had become dangerously intense. Because both Brian and Tommy had written long, heartfelt messages to Jesse. And she had returned to both in kind. But something about Tommy specifically was off.
24:35 Speaker 01 Because the man was very possessive, even obsessive. And Tommy didn't take too kindly to Brian's interest in Jesse. And their conversations quickly started to become very hostile. And Tommy would even go to say that Brian had made a deadly enemy. So taunts and threats and ultimatums were exchanged, just escalating into a full-blown digital war over Jesse's affection. But it wasn't just words anymore. Because Tommy had allegedly sent Jesse photos of himself. And he was young and fit. And he described his military life in vivid detail. And Jesse just ate it up. Or at least she appeared to. So she would kind of egg on both of them, just flirting with each of them and playing them off one another.
25:18 Speaker 01 But to Brian, it seemed like there was no competition, really. Because Jesse had told him that Tommy was just too intense. And she would even share screenshots of their chats together, portraying Tommy as completely unstable. But Tommy was not backing down. And he would warn Brian to stay away, and he claimed that Jesse belonged to him. Creepy. And he hinted that he knew things about Brian's workplace and his schedule. So the tone would shift from romantic rivalry to something much, much darker. But that's when the messages would completely stop. And the silence, investigators would later realize, wasn't peace. It was a countdown. So with the chat logs and photos in hand, ...were close to determining the real identity of Tommy.
26:03 Speaker 01 With the emotional intensity, the jealousy, and the threats, it all pointed to someone very unstable and someone possibly very dangerous. But Tommy had claimed to be in the military, possibly even stationed overseas. So was he real, or was it a lie? And it turns out, there was no Marine named Tommy involved in these chats at all. In fact, Tommy didn't exist at all. And behind the bravado was a 47-year-old man named Thomas Montgomery. So I guess there was technically a Tommy, because his name is Thomas, but it wasn't the Tommy we're talking about. Because Thomas was not a soldier. He was a middle-aged, married father of two teenage daughters. And he wasn't stationed overseas.
26:45 Speaker 01 He lived and worked in the same factory as Brian Barrett. He was Brian's coworker. And he had been catfishing both Jessie and Brian the entire time. So the web just started to unravel quickly. And Thomas Montgomery had created this fake Tommy persona years and years earlier. Initially, just to escape his midlife crisis and dissatisfaction with his own personal life. And he'd chosen the name "Marine Sniper", and invented a full-blown backstory. A young, youthful, battle-hardened Marine with years of service, courage, and masculinity. And when he met Tall Hot Blonde in the chatroom, the lie just blossomed into obsession. And at first, it was just harmless flirtation.
27:29 Speaker 01 Well, not harmless, because he was frickin' married! And then that flirtation would evolve into Jessie's attention becoming his entire life. And Jessie would actually even send him gifts, pictures, even lingerie as a token of her devotion. But unfortunately, or actually luckily, his wife would eventually discover the gifts and was completely horrified. And she was horrified not just at the complete infidelity, but at the childlike nature of the woman Thomas was obsessing over, because she's 18 years old! And she would send Jessie a photo exposing her husband's true identity. Boss-ass move. But the digital affair wouldn't end there. And after-
28:10 Speaker 01 That revelation, Tommy disappeared and a new character would enter the chat. And that was Tommy's father. Supposedly a remorseful man contacting Jessie on behalf of his disgraced son. Dies an Oscar-winning chat actor. Because this obviously was just Thomas trying to be someone else again. Grasping at any excuse to maintain contact with Jessie, his obsession. And that's when Brian would enter the picture. And Brian, as we know, was young and real, and Jessie seemed to like him a lot. And they quickly began to show off their relationship all over Pogo. And they were even hostile to Thomas. Because Jessie, at this point, would paint him as a predator and she revealed his true identity to Brian.
28:55 Speaker 01 So for Thomas, this wasn't just jealousy, it was humiliation. Because his fantasy life was unraveling in front of his face and the person replacing him wasn't an imaginary rival. It was a real person, a colleague no less. A threat that he couldn't just block or delete. And even though Jessie continued to seem against him in public view, she would still message him privately, occasionally still flirting. So in his mind, he believed that she still wanted him, even after all this fucking fiasco, she still wanted him. Or at least pretended to. So for Thomas to fully live out his imaginary relationship that he had in his head, he needed to remove the one thing that was in his way.
29:37 Speaker 01 And what began as a fantasy had now evolved into something far more dangerous. And this is some of the chat between Thomas and Jessie shortly before Brian's murder. Marine Sniper: On Friday or Saturday, you can say goodbye forever to me and Tommy. Jessie: Why? Marine Sniper: We're leaving for good. Jessie: No. Marine Sniper: Yes, Jessie, you are having fun in your life now, so it's time for us to leave. Jessie: No, Tom. Marine Sniper: So it's time for Tommy to be put to rest. Jessie: I will leave. Marine Sniper: I wish I had a perfect life like you and Brian do. So while all of this is happening and coming to a head, and the twists seem like they have come to a close...
30:20 Speaker 01 A new twist emerged, and it was the final blow. Because the woman who initially drove both men to obsession wasn't who she said she was either. Who are these people? Because Jessie, the supposed 18-year-old blonde softball player, was in fact Mary Sheila, Jessie's mother. What in the mother? So Mary, Jessie's mother, had been using her daughter's photos and identity to pose as tall, hot blonde in online chatrooms, which is so fucking disgusting. And obviously Jessie knew nothing of the online romances that were happening online. So Mary, a middle-aged woman,
31:01 Speaker 01 had manipulated both men for her own amusement, gratification, and just general loneliness. Take a walk, Mary. Go to a fucking coffee shop. Don't pretend to be your daughter online and use her image, you psycho. So when authorities finally confronted her, she admitted to the deception completely. But there would be no criminal charges filed against her. But her actions were pivotal in stoking the emotional firestorm that led to murder. I don't understand how she got off scot-free because she was quite literally using someone else's image and pretending to be them. There has to be a law somewhere in there that that's illegal. I'm pretty sure it is, but whatever. So now, with all of the identities finally exposed, investigators turned their attention to the night of the murder,
31:46 Speaker 01 which was September 15, 2006. And Brian had worked a late-night shift at the factory, helping to shut down the factory for the weekend. And he had parked in his usual spot, in the far corner of the lot, away from the building's main entrance. And unbeknownst to him, Thomas Montgomery, his coworker, had spent the day preparing. And he would dress in full camouflage and a ski mask to obscure his identity. And he would bring with him a 30-caliber military-style rifle and waited in the shadows. And at approximately 10:00 PM, as Brian sat in his truck, Thomas would approach him. And that's when he would raise his rifle and fire three shots at close range through his window. And Brian would be hit in the neck.
32:30 Speaker 01 and in the arm and the young man would unfortunately die instantly and that's when Thomas would flee the scene slipping away completely undetected and it wasn't until two days later as we know that the coworker noticed Brian's truck hadn't moved at all and that's when police were called and they found the grisly scene inside and as we know investigators would quickly piece together all of this madness after Brian was murdered and coworkers immediately would point the detectives toward Thomas Montgomery recalling his obsessive behavior and escalating animosity for Brian in the weeks prior to the murder and with all the chat logs threatening messages and online exchanges between the trio investigators were faced with an overwhelming amount of proof and Thomas was arrested and in custody
33:14 Speaker 01 Thomas would admit his guilt and his explanation was tragic he claimed he'd become lost in the fantasy describing the online romance as like an addiction but even then he still continued to say that he was manipulated emotionally positioning himself to remain the victim as well just pathetic and luckily prosecutors were not sympathetic at all and they depicted Thomas Montgomery as a dangerous calculating man who had spun an elaborate and deadly web of deception and after weighing his options Thomas would accept a plea deal and avoid trial completely so in 2007 he pleaded guilty to first degree manslaughter and received the maximum sentence which was 20 years in prison and in court Thomas
33:55 Speaker 01 appeared resigned offering only a brief and half-hearted apology to Brian's family and the judge sharply rebuked him highlighting the senseless and disturbing nature of his crime one born of online fantasy that spiraled into real world violence but Thomas wasn't the only person at the heart of this tragedy because Mary the woman behind tall hot blonde faced intense public scrutiny and condemnation once her deception was revealed and although she committed no legally defined crime which I find so hard to believe but okay the damage she inflicted was incalculable and Jessie her real daughter was completely blindsided and horrified when she learned that her own mother had appropriated her identity to engage in sexual
34:40 Speaker 01 and emotional manipulation online. I can't even imagine like my mom pretending to be oh my I don't want to imagine it. I gotta push it out of my fucking brain. Oh my God, that's terrible. And as for Brian's family, they were devastated by grief and left with haunting questions because their son's life was not ended by a traditional adversary, but by an anonymous stranger's twisted game. Just a cruel manipulation built entirely from pixels and deceit. But determined that Brian's death wouldn't be meaningless, they took to speak publicly, warning others about the hidden dangers lurking in online relationships. And they would push for greater awareness, trying to ensure no other family would experience the kind of pain that they had endured. In the aftermath, this case became a dark and
35:23 Speaker 01 chilling cautionary tale, a reminder that digital fantasies can quickly escalate into deadly realities.
35:34 Speaker 01 Laura Black was bright, ambitious, and just beginning to chase her dreams. And Laura stood out not only for her technical skills, but for her unshakable focus. Because after graduating from college, she landed a coveted job in Silicon Valley at ESL Incorporated, which was a defense technology company in Sunnyvale, California. And this job was a huge milestone. It was a very promising start in a high-paying prestigious industry. And at only 22, she was one of the few female engineers in the company. And she would carry herself with professionalism, committing to succeeding in a challenging environment. But what Laura didn't know is that she had caught the attention of someone working just a few feet away from her. Someone who, over the next four years, would slowly and methodically
36:18 Speaker 01 turn her life into a waking nightmare. And this someone was Richard Farley. So when Laura Black first joined ESL Incorporated in 1984, the environment seemed very welcoming. ESL was a major defense contractor, and the company's Sunnyvale office was filled with engineers, analysts, and researchers. And they were all working on highly classified government projects. So the atmosphere was intense, but also very collaborative. And employees shared long hours and tight deadlines together, often working in very tight quarters. And that's where Laura would meet. Richard Farley. And Farley was a computer technician at ESL. And he would be older than most of his coworkers, being in his mid-30s when Laura started. And he had joined ESL after a brief stint in the Navy, doing several tech support roles.
37:03 Speaker 01 So to outsiders, he probably just seemed like an average, middle-aged employee, who was quiet, competent, and maybe a little awkward. But Farley harbored deeper issues. Because when Laura Black arrived, young and new to the company, she became Farley's fixation. And if it start with just mere glances, and then it would start to be excuses to be closer to her. And then it was Farley becoming completely obsessed with her. Because he truly believed that Laura was supposed to be his. And at first, Laura Black, being kind and polite, and just wanting to do really good at her job and not tip anybody off, just brushed Richard Farley's behavior off as flirtation. But then he would start to bring her gifts. Notes, candy, even homemade baked goods.
37:47 Speaker 01 And when he did this, he would ask her out repeatedly. And Laura would always decline, but she would decline politely but firmly, saying she wasn't interested and she barely even knew him. But Farley did not take a hint. In fact, he didn't take no at all, and his behavior just escalated. And the escalation started when he began appearing in places that he shouldn't have been, such as standing in hallways right outside her office during weird hours. He left personal notes on her desk. And then he even started sending her letters. And they were long, rambling messages, just professing his love and obsession for her. And he would repeatedly call her office phone. She just could not get a break from this guy. And it was to the point where every time her phone would ring, she would dread that it was him.
38:31 Speaker 01 So Laura would try to set boundaries repeatedly. She would tell Farley she was uncomfortable, and she would ask him to stop contacting her. And when that didn't work, she finally reported his behavior to Human Resources. But it didn't matter. Because though ESL was a major defense contractor with clear policies about harassment, the company did little, if anything, to protect her. Which is just so incredibly sad. Because at the time, workplace stalking was not taken seriously. At all, especially when there was no physical threat yet. So Farley would barely get a slap on the wrist and he would not even get fired. He was simply directed to attend psychological counseling, but that wasn't even followed up. And Laura was just told to avoid him.
39:16 Speaker 01 But Farley had no intention of being avoided and Laura unfortunately knew it. So every time Laura walked the halls of ESL, she felt the weight of his presence. Just watching her and following her and studying her every move and each day, the signs became more alarming. So Richard Farley's fixation on Laura Black didn't just persist, but it metastasized into something much darker and more unstable. And after she rejected him and involved HR, he began to completely unravel. His work performance began to decline and coworkers noticed he seemed agitated, volatile, and sometimes even mumbling to himself. And his obsession with Laura just consumed him. And he would even start keeping bizarre personal records such as doctored photos,
39:59 Speaker 01 notes about her schedule, and imagined romantic milestones that never happened between them. And Farley would consistently send Laura messages that became more and more disturbing. And these messages would be long letters claiming that they had a relationship and insisted that she owed him a chance. He was just delusional at this point and thought they were destined to be together. And when Laura didn't respond and she avoided him as the ESL staff told her to, he completely went nuts. He would accuse her of betrayal, he would say that she was so cruel, and said he would never forget what she had done to him. And Laura, who was now growing increasingly frightened and scared, contacted HR again. And she would also reach out to management and security.
40:44 Speaker 01 And then in 1986, he was finally let go from ESL. Took you long enough. And for a time, Laura had hope and she hoped it would be over and things would just go back to normal. But unfortunately, they didn't. Because even after being fired, Farley continued to stalk her. And by now, Farley was no longer pretending to be a heartbroken romantic. He was angrier, more erratic, and more threatening. And he just fixated on what he believed Laura had done to him, which was ruining his life, costing him his job, and ignoring his love. So he had become convinced that she deserved to suffer. And in 1988, that conviction turned into something far more dangerous.
41:26 Speaker 01 So by the start of 1988, Laura Black had done everything she could think of to protect herself. She had reported Richard Farley to her employer, she had filed complaints, she had begged her workplace to intervene, she had documented his obsessive behavior, she had changed her life routines, and she just lived in ultimate fear. But still, no real protection ever came. So on February 2nd, 1988, she took the most serious step yet. And Laura would file a temporary restraining order against Farley citing the years of harassment and her escalating fear for her life. And the court would grant this restraining order. And this restraining order forbid Farley from contacting her or coming near
42:07 Speaker 01 her home or workplace. And the hearing was set for two weeks later on February 17th to determine whether the order would become permanent. So this was a very bold move on Laura Black's part, but extremely, extremely necessary. But for Richard Farley, this was the final trigger. Because after being served this restraining order, Farley did not back off. He just snapped completely. Because in his mind, Laura had now fully betrayed him, and he began preparing for violence. So despite the restraining order, Farley legally purchased a new shotgun. And at the time, California law didn't automatically block firearm purchases because of someone having a restraining order, which is fucking
42:50 Speaker 01 insane to me. And he would also gather weapons he already owned, which was rifles with scopes, handguns, semi-automatics, and amassed more than 1,000 rounds of ammunition. So his plan was already forming, and he would actually send a package to Laura's lawyer. And inside that package, he claimed there was evidence to their supposed relationship. And this evidence was doctored photos of him and Laura together with bizarre receipts and rambling letters. Just a complete fucking crazy
43:20 Speaker 01 But included in the package was Laura's garage door opener to her home. So it wasn't just a deranged package to the lawyer. It was very deliberate and terrifying. He just wanted Laura to know that she was not safe. And Laura, meanwhile, was absolutely terrified. And she would tell her friends and coworkers that she was super anxious for this upcoming court hearing and that she just felt super alone and watched. And worst of all, she felt that no one could stop him if he tried to do anything. And she would have no idea that Farley was not planning on showing up to that hearing. He was planning something far, far more devastating. So the day before the restraining order hearing on February 16th, 1988,
44:01 Speaker 01 Laura Black was at work like every other day, just trying to hold herself together through all this fear-ridden anxiety that was building up within her. Meanwhile, Richard Farley was preparing because he wasn't going to fight the restraining order in court. He wasn't going to let the system decide his fate. He was going to end it violently. So that morning, Farley would climb into his motorhome and drive to Sunnyvale, California. And he would park outside ESL Incorporated. And he had come prepared for war because Farley wore a bullet-resistant vest. He would be armed with two shotguns, a rifle, and several handguns on his body or within reach. He would also have knives tucked into his belt and magazines of ammunition just bulging from his fatigue-style jacket.
44:46 Speaker 01 And his pockets overflowed with 1,000 rounds of extra cartridges and shells. So it wasn't just a mass killing that he was planning. It was targeted vengeance because he was only looking for one person, and that one person was Laura Black. And he would tell himself later that he had planned to confront Laura Black, and if she rejected him again, he would take his own life in front of her. But the arsenal he carried and what followed told a completely different story, one with premeditated slaughter. So just before 3:00 PM that day, Farley approached the entrance to ESL's M5 building, but a security door blocked his path. So he would raise his shotgun and fire through the glass. And that's when the building would just erupt into chaos with screams echoing
45:30 Speaker 01 Through the halls and phones ringing and workers would dive under their desks and sprint for exits. And others would freeze unsure if what they heard was actually real. And that's when Farley would step through the door and fire his shotgun at Lawrence Kane, which was a 46-year-old employee walking to his car. And Kane would unfortunately die instantly. And that's when Farley would turn and point his weapon towards another employee nearby. And he would wound him as he fled for cover behind his car. And inside the building, 23-year-old Buddy Williams was near the front desk. And Farley would walk up to him and fire at him in point-blank range. And Williams would be killed instantly. And this was just the beginning because with every step that Farley took, he would get closer and closer to Laura Black, taking people's lives during the process.
46:14 Speaker 01 So as Richard Farley stormed into the ESL building, the halls were filled with terror. And he moved methodically through this building because he knew it at the back of his hand. And in the stairwell, he encountered another employee and would shoot them without any hesitation. And then would come the next four victims, which were two men and two women. And all gunned down in the hallway as Farley moved closer to Laura's wing. And at this very moment, Laura was inside her office. And she heard those gunshots. And she was absolutely terrified because she was hearing the screams outside her office. She was hearing the shotgun shells go off. And she knew exactly who it was. It was a person that she had warned people about, the person that made her beg for help, but nothing happened. And now he was coming down the hallway.
46:59 Speaker 01 So terrified and unable to move, Laura would just sit in her office and wait. And she would know for sure that it was Farley when he shouted her name down the hallway. And at this point, Laura would scramble to barricade the door in her office. And she would wedge furniture against it. But it wouldn't be enough to stop Farley because he would get to his door and he would raise his 12-gauge shotgun and fire directly into the wooden door. And that blast towards the door would shoot into Laura's left shoulder. And it would throw her back on the floor completely, and shrapnel and pellets ripped into her chest. And unfortunately, some of that shrapnel would puncture her lung. And blood would spread across the carpet. But she didn't die because barely conscious,
47:40 Speaker 01 Laura lay still, pretending to be dead. And this was a decision that may have actually saved her life. And Farley, seeing what he had done, he had actually hit Laura Black, the obsession, his whole world. He decided that that was enough, that she didn't necessarily need to die now. And he would later state that he wanted her to remember what she had caused, which is so fucked up. So he would not fire at Laura again, but he would continue his rampage. And more employees would be wounded, and some were even shot through doors, while others hid in closets and under desks. A few people even jumped from windows to escape Richard. But Farley was still inside, armed and mobile.
48:21 Speaker 01 Meanwhile, Laura Black was bleeding, dazed, and gasping for breath. So she would clutch her shoulder to slow the bleeding, just drifting in and out of consciousness. But for the moment, Richard Farley was still in control of this building. So at approximately 3:15 PM, alarms blaring and the building under siege, Richard Farley called the police himself. And what he did, he picked up the phone and his voice was calm. And he would say to 911 dispatcher, "I'm the one who's been wasting people." And he would describe what he had done. And he would blame Laura Black and the restraining order for pushing him over the edge, which is fucking insane. And then would come the threat. And that was that if the police came any closer than 300 yards, he would begin killing hostages.
49:05 Speaker 01 And thus began a five-hour standoff with SWAT team position snipers and Farley in the building, ready to wreak havoc. And snipers would try to find Farley in the building, but he kept moving through the building, so it was very difficult to find a clean shot. But Lieutenant Ruben Grealva, a trained police negotiator, made contact with Farley by phone. And for hours, Ruben engaged the killer in conversation, navigating his mood swings from rage to self-pity to eerie detachment. And Farley never expressed any remorse during these hours. And he would claim that the people he shot, besides Laura Black, were simply in his way. But he did say one thing that stood out. And that is that he had hoped that Laura Black had actually survived because he wanted her to-
49:50 Speaker 01 Remember what she had caused. Meanwhile, Laura had actually gained consciousness despite the immense pain and a collapsed lung. But she would stay in her office, quiet and hidden, just terrified that he might return to finish her off. But eventually, other survivors would actually help Laura Black move to a safer location. But the standoff would just drag on. And by 4:30, negotiators would actually convince Farley to let a rescue team into the building to help wounded survivors. And several people, including Laura, were rushed out to waiting ambulances. And still, Farley fucking yapped. And he would mention slurslide. He said that he wanted to gloat a little before giving up. And even bragged about having enough ammo to fight for two more hours.
50:32 Speaker 01 On top of being a psycho stalker killer, he's also narcissistic as hell. But finally, as darkness fell, Farley would make an unexpected demand. And that would be, quote, "I'll come out if you get me a number 26 sandwich from the deli. Turkey, ham, and cheese, and a Diet Pepsi." And the police would agree. Just, I have no words. So at 8:30 PM, Richard Farley would lay down his weapons and exit the building with his hands raised. And SWAT officers would swarm him and arrest him on the spot. But inside ESL, the aftermath just looked like a complete war zone. Because seven people now were dead and four others had been shot. But Laura Black was alive, and now finally, so was the truth.
51:18 Speaker 01 So in the weeks and months following the massacre at ESL, the community struggled to process what had happened. Because the name Laura Black became known far beyond the walls of Sunnyvale Office Park. She wasn't just a survivor, but a symbol of resilience, of missed warning signals, and of a system that failed to act in time. And Laura would spend 19 days in hospital recovering from the gunshot wounds, and she would undergo multiple surgeries. But despite all of the fear and trauma, she decided to actually testify at Farley's trial. And Richard Farley would ultimately be convicted on seven counts of first degree murder, among numerous other charges, and sentenced to death in 1991. And he still remains on California's death row to ...this day, having exhausted most of his appeals.
52:02 Speaker 01 And throughout this whole process, he never expressed any sort of genuine remorse, continuing to blame his actions on everyone but himself. Just a genuine piece of shit. But Farley's violence had a consequence he could never have predicted, and that was that it actually changed the law. Because at the time of the shooting, stalking was not a specific crime, and restraining orders were often ineffective. Because in Farley's case, the restraining order had not even prevented him from legally purchasing firearms. And that oversight and the overwhelming public outrage that followed sparked rapid change. And in 1990, California became the first US state to pass an anti-stalking law, making credible threats and repeated harassment criminal offenses. And that law soon became a model for the nation.
52:47 Speaker 01 And within just a few years, every state in the US had passed similar legislation. And as one court commissioner bluntly put it, quote, "Pieces of paper do not stop bullets." So the new laws aim to give those pieces of paper some teeth, providing legal recourse for the victims and earlier intervention for authorities before violence could erupt.
53:06 Speaker 03 I think that they need to be encouraged to take action if in fact they're being stalked.
53:12 Speaker 01 And in the years since the attack, Laura Black rebuilt her life. She actually returned to ESL, then later continued her engineering career elsewhere. And quietly but persistently, she actually became an advocate for workplace safety and stalking awareness, sharing her story to help train law enforcement, employers, and mental health professionals on the warning signs that were missed in her case. So in the end, Laura Black's case is not just one of survival, but transformation, from targeted victim to national advocate. And her experience helped ensure that future victims might not have to suffer the same fate, and that stalking would never again be dismissed as harmless infatuation. So that is the end of the video. Please let me know any other cases you want me to deep dive in down below.
53:57 Speaker 01 I always read your comments. And also, just be safe out there and know that I appreciate you so, so much, and I will see your beautiful face in the next video, okay? Bye.
54:11 Speaker 04 You sound horrible.
54:12 Speaker 05 Oh, I feel worse. This flu is not playing around.
54:15 Speaker 04 Dad, you promised you'd be in my band, and it's showtime. Then it's Dayquil Intense Flu time.
54:21 Speaker 06 For fast and powerful relief of your flu symptoms, try Dayquil Intense Flu.
54:26 Speaker 04 Hit it! Yeah!
54:28 Speaker 06 Dayquil Intense Flu, the fast-acting daytime coughing, aching, aching, aching fever power through your flu medicine. Use is directed. Keep out of reach of children.
54:38 Speaker 02 At Humana, our Medicare Advantage plans are easy to understand and easy on your wallet. Like offering more benefits than you'd get from original Medicare alone, and including dental, vision, and hearing coverage in every plan. And the best part is, every plan has a $0 or low monthly plan premium, which makes it easier to save, too. So this Medicare planning season, plan well with Humana. Learn more at gethumana.com. Humana is a Medicare Advantage, HMO, and PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
Previous Ep. 52 | Did They Set A Brutal Killer Free? | Amanda Knox Next Ep. 54 | Who REALLY Killed The Black Dhalia? Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated