Pod Insights Conspiracy Theories Who Shot Vincent Van Gogh? About this episode For over a century, common belief was that Vincent Van Gogh died by suicide. But in 2011, two Pulitzer Prize-winning biographers suggested the art world had it all wrong, and Vincent covered up his own homicide.
Keep up with Conspiracy Theories! YouTube: @ConspiracyTheoriesPodcastInstagram: @theconspiracypodTikTok: @conspiracy.pod
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:06 Speaker 00 Vincent Van Gogh is a pop culture phenomenon. From college dorms to national museums, from immersive exhibitions to AI plugins, from priceless collections locked in airtight vaults to the aisles of TJ Maxx. His work is legendary, so is his biography. He depended on his brother. He cut off his ear and he died by suicide the year he sold his first painting. Or did he? In the early 2000s, two Pulitzer Prize-winning biographers made a shocking claim. The story the public believed for a century was wrong.
0:47 Speaker 00 Their evidence suggested Vincent did not shoot himself. He actually covered for the person who killed him, and he took the truth to his grave. But when the biographers brought their findings to fellow experts, they were told, "It wouldn't be good for your career if you talked about this."
1:12 Speaker 00 Welcome to Conspiracy Theories, a Spotify podcast. I'm Carter Roy. New episodes come out every Wednesday. You can listen to the audio everywhere and watch the video only on Spotify. And be sure to check us out on Instagram at the conspiracy pod. This episode contains discussions of violence and suicide. Consider this when deciding how and when you'll listen. If you or someone you know is struggling emotionally or feeling hopeless. This episode is brought to you by Petivity. Every cat has a few unsolved mysteries. Why the 3 a.m. zoomies? What's so fascinating about that one empty box?
1:54 Speaker 00 And at mealtime, are they actually eating differently or does it just seem that way? The new Petivity Smart Feeder for cats turns everyday meals into meaningful health insights, helping you identify changes in your cat's habits and be more proactive about their health. Take the mystery out of mealtime. Visit P E T I V I T Y dot com slash cat feeder to learn more.
2:24 Speaker 01 Observe: The North American Dad. 50s, great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, "Dang, that's a good offer." The highest form of approval. No haggling, no hassle, no one called him "boss." He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
2:56 Speaker 02 Born from the intensity of a night in the Eternal City. Introducing Born in Roma Fragrances by Valentino. Feminine perfume Donna Born in Roma features juicy black currant, central jasmine, soft cashmerin and warm vanilla. Masculine leaning but unisex Womo has notes of fresh violet leaf, aromatic sage, green vetiver and mineral salt. Shop holiday gifts at macy's.com.
3:24 Speaker 00 Visit spotify.com/resources. Stay with us. Before we dive into the major controversy, a minor one: the artist's name. Depending on where you live, it's pronounced Van Gogh, Van Ho, Van Gogh, Van Go or mm, whatever the speaker feels like. We'll stick with how he signed his paintings. Vincent. Though Vincent's work is wildly popular now, he didn't sell a painting until 1890 when he was 37. The sale came after a review that was both glowing and insulting.
4:06 Speaker 00 According to scholar Stephen Naffey, the review essentially said, "The greatest artist alive is this madman in the south of France." Within months of the sale, Vincent moved to Auvers-Rouvres, a village outside Paris. He lived in the Auvers-Rouvres, an inn run by Arthur Gustave Rouvres.
4:28 Speaker 00 In Auver, he painted and he drank. The paintings were landscapes and portraits. The drink was absent. All of this was bankrolled by his younger brother, Theo. For the better part of a decade, Vincent used Theo's money to buy paint, pay rent, and even visit brothels. Theo worked as an art dealer and in the weeks before Vincent's death, he contemplated spinning out his own business. Besides Vincent, he had a new baby to support. Both brothers were feeling the winds of change. But in July 1890, they kept the status quo.
5:10 Speaker 00 That month, Vincent painted almost every day, including at least two portraits of his doctor, Paul Gaché. On July 27th, Vincent left the inn. Later that day, he stumbled back with a gunshot wound in his abdomen and no gun in sight. Vincent trudged upstairs to his room and lay in bed while someone summoned Dr. Gaché. Unfortunately, the doctor's notes were not preserved. Neither were Dr. Mazaris, who Gaché brought in for a second opinion. Luckily, Dr. Gaché's son, Paul Gaché Jr., did write something down. Paul described Vincent's wound as a
5:54 Speaker 00 "small brownish-red circle with a purple-brown halo. The opening was pea-sized with no exit wound. The bullet was lodged near Vincent's spine." The gun used was a small-caliber pistol, pointed at an oblique angle, not head-on, and not touching Vincent's body. While the wound was painful, it seemed survivable. Vincent was cogent, smoking, walking, even talking. But he provided zero explanation for how or why he'd been shot. Naturally, the gendarmes, the French authorities, came to investigate the next morning. According to witness accounts,
6:39 Speaker 00 they asked Vincent, "Did you want to commit suicide?" He answered, "Yes, I believe so." And added, "Do not accuse anyone. It is I who wanted to kill myself." Dr. Gachet wrote to Vincent's brother, Theo, informing him Vincent has wounded himself. Theo traveled from Paris that day, July 28th. He sat with Vincent as he rested. And there wasn't much the doctors could do. Both Dr. Gachet and Dr. Mazurie deemed it unsafe to move Vincent to a hospital, and neither was a surgeon, so they weren't comfortable operating to remove the bullet. They dressed the wound and kept an eye on him.
7:24 Speaker 00 Without proper treatment, Vincent's wound grew infected. As day turned to night, he became less animated, going pale, and eventually struggling to breathe. Just after midnight, about 29 hours after he was shot, Vincent died in Theo's arms. His death left limited records. No doctor's notes, no autopsy, no cause of death on his death certificate. With so many holes in the story, witnesses, scholars, and filmmakers filled in details over the years, resulting in the historically accepted theory that Vincent intended to die by suicide.
8:09 Speaker 00 The book Lust for Life and its film adaptation cemented those details in pop culture. But almost everyone agrees, Lust for Life is inaccurate. In fact, one major witness only came forward with her version of events after the movie was released in 1956. Adeline Ravu was the innkeeper's 13-year-old daughter, and she knew Vincent in his final months. He even painted her, hoping to set the record straight. Adeline gave multiple interviews. Her account joined those of Vincent's 22-year-old mentee, Emile Bernard, and Paul Gachet Jr., the doctor's 17-year-old son.
8:52 Speaker 00 These accounts came out piecemeal, but put together, they told this story. Adeline said sometime in the weeks leading up to his death, Vincent either borrowed or stole her father's pistol. Paul Jr. claimed that Vincent carried it about a kilometer out of town to the wheat field behind Chateau de la Re, in the same area captured in his painting, Crows in Wheatfield. He sat down and took out the gun. The shock of the gunshot knocked Vincent unconscious. Hours later, the cool evening air woke Vincent up. Leaving the gun behind, he stumbled back to the inn where he died.
9:37 Speaker 00 When Theo arranged for Vincent's funeral, the church refused to hold a ceremony, let them use its hearse, or bury Vincent in their graveyard. This was normal protocol for suicide victims back then, much less was known about mental health and suicide. After the funeral, Vincent's mentee, Emile Bernard, wrote a letter to an art critic saying Theo told him, quote, "Vincent's suicide had been absolutely deliberate and that he had done it in complete lucidity." Historians took his word for it, perhaps because of Vincent's mental health history.
10:19 Speaker 00 You've probably heard that Vincent cut off his own ear and presented it to an unrequited love, but that's more of an urban legend. The reality is more complex. First, instances of self-harm usually have multiple causes. Experts agree it can stem from a mix of emotional, psychological, and even neurological factors. Research out of Cornell University found that a history of self-harm doesn't prove suicidal intent, or explain later events. It just shows that Vincent's mental health was suffering. Second, that unrequited love, it might not have existed.
11:04 Speaker 00 Some biographers assert the ear incident was actually spurred by his tense relationship with painter and sculptor Paul Gauguin. In 1888, two years before he died, Vincent hoped to form an artist colony. He invited fellow painters to live with him in what he called "The Yellow House." Gauguin was the only taker. After Theo bribed him. The two artists disagreed on everything. Budgets, models, home decor, and unflattering portrait Gauguin painted of Vincent. It goes on. After two months, Gauguin told Vincent he was moving out.
11:49 Speaker 00 Gauguin stepped out that evening, presumably going to a brothel. It's unclear what transpired next, but the night culminated in Vincent presenting a bloody handkerchief to the woman at the brothel's front door. Inside was part of his ear. Supposedly, he wanted her to give it to Gauguin, saying, "Remember me." Gauguin left, anyway. Shortly after, Vincent was diagnosed with epilepsy. And today, most people think it was temporal lobe epilepsy. Temporal lobe epilepsy seizures can cause hallucinations, erratic behavior, and memory loss.
12:30 Speaker 00 It's possible Vincent had a seizure and woke up with no ear and no memory of the night before. And shortly after this, Vincent voluntarily checked into the asylum of Saint Paul de Mausole. That's where he painted "The Starry Night," one of his most famous works. It's also where he experienced suicidal ideation, though he wrote in letters that he believed it was immoral. Like many people, his thoughts around life and death seemed to shift over time. Three months after checking out of the hospital and moving to Auver, Vincent died.
13:11 Speaker 00 Decades later, in 1960, a farmer unearthed a gun in a field near the Auberge-Ravoux. The make and model lined up with both the time period and Vincent's wound. It seemed like the gun. So for 100 years, suicide was the accepted truth. But in 2011, a new theory rocked the art world. As Van Gogh expert Martin Bailey wrote, "A few years ago, the question I was most often asked about Vincent Van Gogh was, why did he cut off his ear? Now it's..."
13:49 Speaker 03 Honey, that flu keeping you up? Did you take Nyquil Intense Flu?
13:53 Speaker 04 Nah, I got this. Hmm, okay, I don't got this.
13:58 Speaker 03 Yeah, you need Nyquil Intense Flu.
14:01 Speaker 05 Undo your flu with Nyquil Intense Flu. Nyquil Intense Flu provides powerful relief of your flu symptoms so you can sleep.
14:09 Speaker 03 You do got this.
14:11 Speaker 05 Nyquil Intense Flu. The nighttime sniffling, aching, aching fever, best sleep with the flu medicine. Uses directed, keep out of reach of children.
14:18 Speaker 00 Did he commit suicide? Or was he actually murdered?
14:25 Speaker 00 Over a hundred years after Vincent van Gogh's death, art historians Stephen Nafy and Gregory White Smith decided to profile Vincent. They previously won a Pulitzer for their biography of Jackson Pollock, so they knew what they were doing. The authors spent a full decade in primary source documents. They even scored an invite to the Van Gogh Museum's private vault, where they got to see Vincent's letters firsthand. They peered deep into his life and concluded that history got his death all wrong.
15:04 Speaker 00 First off, the authors believed none of the three key witnesses could be completely trusted. Each had something to gain. Remember Vincent's teenage mentee, Emile Bernard? The one who wrote that Vincent intended to end his life? This wasn't the first time he'd written about Vincent. According to Nafy and White Smith, Emile previously penned an over-dramatic and heavily fabricated account of the ear incident. Plus, everything Bernard reported was secondhand. He didn't arrive in Auvergne until Vincent's funeral. Even in discussing the funeral, his statements contradicted themselves.
15:47 Speaker 00 Next, Paul Gachet Jr., the doctor's son, who provided the location for Vincent's deadly injury. This information comes from a 1904 painting Paul made, a landscape of a wheat field behind the Château de l'Arrie in Auvergne. On the back, he labeled it "The Place Where Vincent Committed Suicide."
16:12 Speaker 00 The wheat field Paul Jr. painted was over a mile away from the auberge Ravoux. Nafy and Whitesmith didn't believe Vincent would have been able to walk that far with a gunshot wound alone. They proposed Vincent was shot elsewhere and found research to back it up. In the years after Vincent's death, other locals slowly came forward with reports. One saw Vincent in a farmyard near a "dung hill." One classified the area as "farm off rue Boucher." And another heard gunfire in the same area.
16:52 Speaker 00 To top it off, Vincent's nephew said Paul Gachet Jr. was "highly unreliable." Possibly because Paul played up his proximity to Vincent to kickstart his own career. Paul Jr. might have referenced Vincent in his own paintings title to grab attention, regardless of the truth. The third account Nafy and Whitesmith questioned was Adeline Ravoux's. She explained the source of the gun. Notably, it took her 70 years to admit the gun belonged to her dad. People asked about the gun as soon as Vincent was shot. Why keep it secret for so long?
17:36 Speaker 00 Well, when she finally talked, Adeline was in her 80s, so perhaps it was a deathbed confession. However, Nafy and Whitesmith found her accounts inconsistent and filled with hearsay. Understandable, considering she was only 13 when Vincent died. And like the Gachets, the Ravoux's turned their Vincent connection into fame and money. This all left Nafy and Whitesmith scratching their heads. Why did Vincent bleed so little if he laid unconscious for hours? How could he get home alone with that wound? Why weren't the medical records preserved when so much of Vincent's ephemera was?
18:20 Speaker 00 At some point, the authors came across Wilford Neils Arnold's 1992 book, Vincent Van Gogh: Chemicals, Crises, and Creativity. Arnold suggested that Vincent shot himself accidentally during a temporal lobe epilepsy seizure. Vincent's seizures happened roughly every three or four months, and by late July 1890, it had been close to three months since his last seizure. This could explain Vincent's confusion and his seemingly non-lethal wound. Also, why Vincent believed he shot himself and didn't want anyone else taking the blame. He couldn't remember what happened.
19:04 Speaker 00 Naifian White Smith claimed that when Vincent was shot, people initially saw it as an accident. Both Vincent's brother Theo and Dr. Gachet used that exact word. They wrote Vincent was the victim of a "accident." The only letter that says suicide is Emile Bernard's. The authors also suggest that the church's refusal to host Vincent's funeral wasn't necessarily due to suicide. They noted there was no stated reason, and it was equally likely they wouldn't bury him because the church was Catholic and Vincent was a foreign Protestant. But that left Naifian White Smith wondering.
19:48 Speaker 00 If it was an accident, why would Vincent have a gun? To kill birds, as shown in Lust for Life? To paint it in a still life? To face someone in a duel? More importantly, why wasn't the wound consistent with a self-inflicted gunshot?
20:09 Speaker 00 Then, the authors heard a rumor that changed everything. Back in the 1930s, art historian John Riewold visited Auver and heard that Vincent was "shot by young boys." To Nafian White Smith, that was the final puzzle piece. That was why none of the accounts lined up. Vincent was shot by someone else, and a willing participant in the cover-up. Putting together their findings, Nafian White Smith published their book. In a final appendix, they proposed a new story. In the summer of 1890, things were looking up for Vincent.
20:51 Speaker 00 He'd earned recognition in the art world, he was extremely productive, and his paintings were good. His brother Theo had even named his firstborn son after him, "Baby Vincent," a huge honor and a sign of the closeness Vincent always longed for. Over the years, Vincent constantly tried to make friends, striking up correspondence and seeking like-minded artists, like Paul Gauguin and Emile Bernard. But those same artists said Vincent was difficult. He'd led a deeply lonely life. But now, he had a new nephew, and he'd even made a new friend in town, an artsy young
21:35 Speaker 00 Parisian named Gaston Sakretan. Vincent was thrilled. He'd tracked down Gaston in the village to chat, and the pair had great discussions about art. Gaston was only 18, so Vincent might have seen it as another mentor relationship. And the trouble was, Gaston didn't come to Auver alone. He summered in his father's villa with his parents and siblings, including his little brother, 16-year-old Rene Sakretan.
22:10 Speaker 00 Rene was his brother's opposite. Mischievous, adventurous, athletic. Got the girls straight from the Moulin Rouge. Though he grew up in Paris, Rene idolized the American Wild West. He dressed like Buffalo Bill and even carried a .38 pistol. Pistol the wannabe cowboy took from the Auberge Ravoux by his own admission. In a later interview, he made one thing clear. He never returned the gun. And yes, this is the same gun that allegedly shot Vincent. Unlike his brother, Rene couldn't care less about art.
22:55 Speaker 00 So when he saw Gaston hanging around Vincent, he didn't see one of the greatest artists of all time. He saw a weird loner. Rene and his cronies spent the summer sneaking snakes into Vincent's paintbox, slipping salt into his coffee, and sprinkling chili pepper on his brushes. Vincent was known to suck on the tips when he was deep in thought. At every scare and spit take, Rene and his friends watched and laughed. For weeks, Vincent turned the other cheek, ignoring the pranks and even hanging out with the group at the local bar. Perhaps because Rene always paid for everyone's drinks.
23:38 Speaker 00 And definitely because Gaston was Vincent's only friend in Auver. Vincent may have even sketched Rene. Throughout his career, Vincent struggled to convince models to sit for him. So a willing model may have been worth some salt in his coffee. This all came to a head on July 27, 1890. That day, Vincent packed up his easel and brushes and went out to paint. One account the authors uncovered said Vincent walked along the, quote, "road to Secretin Family Villa," not far from the fishing hole and local bar Rene and Gaston frequented. At some point, Vincent encountered the brothers.
24:22 Speaker 00 Some or all of the trio may have been inebriated.
24:27 Speaker 00 Navy and White Smith theorize a few things could have happened next. Maybe Rene heckled Vincent. Perhaps he even aimed his gun toward Vincent as a joke. Or he aimed to shoot nearby to show off and scare him. Maybe Rene pulled another prank and Vincent's temper finally came out. Rene later said Vincent "once turned red with anger and wanted to kill everyone." Perhaps Rene unsheathed his pistol in self-defense. He called himself "trigger happy." Or maybe Vincent tried to take the pistol from Rene. Somehow, the gun fired.
25:07 Speaker 00 Even if Rene shot on accident, he could be charged criminally for injuring Vincent or killing him. So, everybody panicked. In the chaos, they split up. The Secretoan brothers stayed behind, cleaning up the scene and perhaps burying the gun. Since he was only about half a mile from the inn, Vincent could return easily, especially if Gaston helped him part of the way back. Cafe patrons on the inn's terrace saw him stumble inside alone, clutching his abdomen without any art supplies. Vincent appeared confused and asked for help like he was "the victim of an accident." That night Vincent mulled over what he'd say when the gendarmes inevitably arrived.
25:52 Speaker 00 He "chose to protect the boys as a final act of martyrdom." Navy and White Smith suggest it was because Vincent was "at peace with dying." But to our team, it makes more sense if he wasn't protecting Rene, but Gaston. Most people would intervene if their friend and their brother got in a fight. Assuming he was present, Gaston could have grabbed the gun from Rene or Vincent, accidentally causing it to go off. Remember, the local rumor was "shot by SOME boys, not shot by a boy." Vincent longed for an intimate relationship his entire life and never quite achieved it.
26:39 Speaker 00 His two closest relationships were with his brother Theo, which had an air of family obligation, and with a sex worker, which was transactional. He was used to being friendless, alone, and mocked. It's natural to think he'd protect his only friend in Auver. To Nafian White Smith, the theory that Vincent protected the brothers explains why Vincent's answers were, quote, "oddly hedged." In their full review of his letters, the authors found this in-character for Vincent. He lied all the time. Throughout their biography, they demonstrated how he concealed the truth, stretched it, fibbed,
27:24 Speaker 00 and manipulated people to get what he wanted, mostly money from Theo. In a memorable incident, Vincent asked Theo to lie on his behalf. During the time he lived with Gauguin, he felt insecure about never having sold a painting, so he asked Theo to start telling people Vincent's works were too precious and dear for him to ever give one up. Nafian White Smith also described Vincent's smarter tendencies. When he briefly attempted a career as a pastor, Vincent dressed in rags, restricted his food, and neglected to heat the shack he moved into. He wasn't impoverished.
28:09 Speaker 00 His family offered him money and urged him to think of his health. But Vincent was the type who'd risk frostbite to show his devotion. With this in mind, it's easier to see how Vincent might have covered for the Secretan brothers, even as his wound brought him closer to death. And he may not have been the only one concealing the truth.
28:37 Speaker 00 When authors Stephen Naife and Gregory White Smith proposed that Vincent covered up who fired the gun that killed him, they quickly realized he couldn't have been the lone secret keeper. Obviously Rene and Gaston Secrétin would have been complicit, but so would the innkeeper Gustave Rauvoux. Rene confessed to carrying Gustave Rauvoux's gun around all summer. Now, Rauvoux probably wouldn't admit to giving a prankster teen a gun, and admitting to a theft at the inn he ran wasn't a great look either. It made sense to keep quiet, especially because the
29:16 Speaker 00 Secrétin family were big spenders at the inn's café. His silence would ensure their continued business. That summer, the Secrétin family returned to Paris unusually early, in the middle of the season, and they returned to Auvergne in subsequent years, but Rene was never seen with a gun again. He and his brother Gaston went on to live full, successful lives. Gaston became a singer-songwriter, and Rene was a businessman and shooting champion. If Vincent did cover up his own killing to protect the boys, he succeeded.
29:59 Speaker 00 But any secrets around Vincent faced a major challenge: his growing fame. That's what brought John Riewold Auvergne, where he heard the rumors, and that's what brought Rene Secrétin to finally give interviews at age 82. Like Adeline Rauvoux, he saw lust for life and wanted to set the record straight. Rene contacted French writer Victor Duattou and spoke to him several times during 1956 and 1957, the final two years of Rene's life. Like Adeline, his account resembled a deathbed confession. He described bullying Vincent
30:44 Speaker 00 and using Rauvoux's gun, which he said "often misfired." However, Rene upheld the story that Vincent shot himself. Rene told Duattou, "We used to leave the gun around with all our fishing gear, and that's where Vincent found and took it." Like in the other accounts, Nafi and White Smith found contradictions, which they saw as evidence of a cover-up. For example, Rene said Vincent shot himself after the Secretans left town, but then said Vincent stole the gun the same day he was wounded.
31:27 Speaker 00 Rene claimed he always had the gun with him, but didn't notice it missing until after Vincent died. He also said he learned of Vincent's death from a Parisian newspaper, but no Paris newspaper reported it. Reading the interview, Nafi and White Smith couldn't ignore their sneaking suspicion. And as they wrote in Vanity Fair, they weren't the first. Quote, "We found out later that another museum researcher had already expressed his own suspicions about the suicide story. In 2006, he brought them to the attention of a senior official,
32:08 Speaker 00 who advised him to abandon that line of inquiry as 'too controversial.' And when they brought up the idea to experts at the Van Gogh Museum, one agreed it was believable but said, 'The biggest problem you'll find after publishing your theory is that the suicide is more or less printed in the brains of past and present generations and has become a sort of self-evident truth. Vincent's suicide has become the grand finale of the story of the martyr for art. It's his crown of thorns." Nafi and White Smith published the theory anyway in their 2011 book, Van Gogh: The Life.
32:52 Speaker 00 Once the book was out, the critiques flew in. In their Vanity Fair article, Nafi and White Smith wrote that the art world didn't just disagree with our new reading, they were enraged by it. One expert called them "just dead wrong", and another was so choked with indignation that he refused even to discuss the subject.
33:17 Speaker 00 In 2013, senior researchers at the Van Gogh Museum, Louis van Tilburg and Theo Madendorf, published a takedown. They attacked Nafian White Smith's understanding of ballistics, insisting it was possible for Vincent to shoot himself. They accused the authors of misinterpreting the French descriptions of Vincent's wound, and they noted a translation error. The gunshot was described in French as "too low and too far out." Nafian White Smith understood that to mean "too low and too far out" for Vincent to have shot the gun. Van Tilburg and Madendorf said it meant the shot was "too low and too far out"
34:02 Speaker 00 to hit vital organs. In response, Nafian White Smith teamed up with a ballistics expert, Dr. Vincent de Maio, for further analysis. In 2014, they published a response to the Van Gogh Museum researchers, including de Maio's findings. De Maio said the way Vincent needed to hold the gun for this shot was "too awkward to be intentional", and the shooter would have been covered in gunpowder, but no account mentions gunpowder on Vincent's arm or clothes. Meanwhile, Nafian White Smith said the Dutch scholars referenced
34:43 Speaker 00 a self-published work that contradicted eyewitness testimony, neglected to name a cited ballistics expert, and ignored questions around the gun found in 1960. Speaking to Live Science, Nafian called out his issues with this gun, saying no forensics tie it to Vincent. But the controversy continues. In 2021, another book was published heavily promoting the suicide theory, Van Gogh's Finale by Martin Bailey. He's a respected scholar with a regular column on Vincent for The Art Newspaper. Like Nafe and White Smith, Bailey intensely analyzed Vincent's letters and the
35:27 Speaker 00 primary source documents, but he largely debunks their version of events. Bailey agreed Rene Secretan's account contained lies, noting Rene said Vincent, quote, "had given him and his brother six paintings," and that would mean that these 16-year-old tykes received almost as many works as Van Gogh's friend Roulan. In his eyes, that put Rene's entire interview under suspicion. Bailey also asserted that Vincent could have bought his own gun. He supplied the account of a man who claims his great-grandfather sold one to Vincent.
36:06 Speaker 00 And finally, he detailed how Vincent showed multiple potential risk factors for suicide, including expressing suicidal thoughts, recent major life changes, and family history. As of 2025, people still debate who shot Vincent. But maybe the better question isn't who held the gun, but why it matters. Talking about the biography, Stephen Nafe quoted French writer Emile Zola: "The man behind the canvas is as important as what's on the canvas."
36:46 Speaker 00 Basically, knowing Vincent's experience allows us to connect more deeply with his work.
36:54 Speaker 00 The suicide story paints Vincent as a tortured artist, a common archetype, easy to understand, easy to sell, but it doesn't reflect who he was as a person. Meanwhile, the self-sacrifice tale echoes who Vincent was throughout his life. Nafe and White Smith present his death as the final act of a man who yearned for companionship and died to preserve it. The self-sacrifice isn't as easy to understand, but it makes you think. And isn't that what art's supposed to do?
37:37 Speaker 00 Thank you for tuning in to Conspiracy Theories. We are here with a new episode every Wednesday. Be sure to check us out on Instagram @TheConspiracyPod. If you're watching on Spotify, swipe up and give us your thoughts. For more information on Vincent Van Gogh, amongst the many sources we used, we found Van Gogh: The Life by Stephen Naife and Gregory White Smith, and Van Gogh's Finale by Martin Bailey, extremely helpful to our research. We'd also like to thank the JED Foundation for their help with this sensitive topic.
38:15 Speaker 00 If you or someone you know is struggling emotionally or feeling hopeless, visit spotify.com/resources. Until next time, remember, the truth isn't always the best story, and the official story isn't always the truth. This episode was written and researched by Maggie Admire, edited by Mickey Taylor, fact-checked by Lori Siegel, engineered by Marcelino Ortiz, and video edited and sound designed by Ryan Contra. I'm your host, Carter Roy.
Previous Untraceable Poison? The Bogle-Chandler Mystery Next The (Faked?) Death of an Argentine Tycoon Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated