Pod Insights Civics 101 What's it like being a scientist facing federal funding cuts? About this episode It’s a weird time to be an environmental scientist. The proposed cuts to federal science funding in the United States are profound, and if they come to pass, it’s not clear what American science will look like on the other side. But for many researchers, science is much more than a career: it’s a community, lifestyle, and sometimes even a family business.
This episode was produced by our fellow NHPR podcast Outside/In. You can check out photos and more related to this episode right here.
CLICK HERE: Visit our website to see all of our episodes, donate to the podcast, sign up for our newsletter, get free educational materials, and more!
To see Civics 101 in book form, check out A User's Guide to Democracy: How America Works by Hannah McCarthy and Nick Capodice, featuring illustrations by Tom Toro.
Check out our other weekly NHPR podcast, Outside/In - we think you'll love it!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 5,532 words · 18 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Speaker 00 The award-winning American Airlines Advantage program rewards more than travel. It takes your whole life to new heights. Earn miles when you fly, as well as with thousands of your favorite brands. And then redeem those miles for flights, upgrades, and experiences worldwide. Advantage members also enjoy earlier boarding and free high-speed Wi-Fi in-flight. Join for free and start earning towards your next adventure at aa.com/spotify.
0:31 Speaker 01 Now for a quick message from Anthropic, the team behind Claude, the AI built for businesses. Customers count on their bank, and banks count on their most important systems. Now those systems count on Claude, and nine of the Fortune 10 companies use it for critical work. See why leading companies trust Claude at claude.ai/span.
0:55 Speaker 02 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And, no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month, or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
1:25 Hannah McCarthy? This is Civics 101. I'm Hannah McCarthy. Today, we're going to zoom in on a small sample of a big change happening in the United States. Over the past months, the Trump administration has paused, reduced, restricted, or eliminated federal funding for programs, research, and jobs that advance medicine, science, technology, and education, to name a few. Grants have disappeared, people have been laid off, years of progress has been put on the shelf. Now, I'm working on an episode that will explain what this kind of funding actually is and how this is all happening. Stay tuned for that. But in the meantime, we're trying to understand who and what is being affected by these changes.
2:08 Hannah McCarthy? We're turning to our friends at Outside In, a podcast that I warmly recommend you start following if you haven't already. Producer Justine Parry spent time with a community of researchers who are trying to understand a threat to drinking water for millions of people. This is the story of how these scientists are navigating this task, increasingly unsure of how or if anyone will be able to pay for it. I'll let Outside In take it from here.
2:36 Speaker 04 Hey, this is Outside In, a show where curiosity and the natural world collide. I'm Nate Hegy.
2:43 Speaker 04 Our story starts at a barbecue at a park just outside of Ithaca, New York. It's a warm day in late spring. There's a waterfall nearby. Swallows are nesting in the rafters. And almost every person here is a scientist. They're grilling, catching up, and making so many PhD jokes.
3:05 Speaker 05 They're having a good laugh about too many PhDs cooking the barbecue.
3:10 Speaker 04 How many does it take?
3:13 Speaker 05 All of them. All of them, of course, because they all have an opinion.
3:19 Speaker 04 This group has spent the past few days together, collecting samples on the lakes in the area. They're studying a growing environmental problem: toxic algae blooms. But one thing that struck our producer, Justine Parry, who was there, was that pretty much everyone appeared to be in a great mood.
3:38 Speaker 06 You know, part of that, what I'm curious about coming here is understanding just the general mood of scientists right now. And everyone seems so happy, at least at this table. We've got some wine.
3:53 Speaker 07 What's the alternative? Just roll over and be like, okay, the world's gonna, you know, just end up like a Star Wars scene? Like, I mean, come on. No one expects us to do that. It will all work out.
4:08 Speaker 07 Don't know how, but it will.
4:09 Speaker 04 That's Renee, a researcher at Cornell. She motions at her colleague across the table, Bob Howarth, a bio-geochemist.
4:16 Speaker 07 He says I'm an optimist.
4:18 Speaker 08 I don't know that I am. I mean, the world's got a lot of problems, but I'm tremendously excited about being in this group of people. I mean, on the average day, what we're doing is tedious as hell, quite frankly, and yet it's still really fun.
4:37 Speaker 04 This is a weird time to be an environmental scientist. That guy, Bob Howarth? He's one of the most widely cited scientists in his field. "A legend," one of the others said. And the questions they're working on have global implications. But there's also a feeling of unease in the air because funding for this type of research is changing dramatically.
5:01 Speaker 08 It's going to be very, very difficult. And for our graduate students, extremely, extremely difficult. And I'm OK. I'm an old guy. I'm retiring, and I've got friends, and we're doing exciting things. But the future scares me.
5:24 Speaker 04 You've probably heard about all the cuts being made to research programs and federal grants. These changes are so widespread and happening so fast, it can feel dizzying just to keep track of it all. So, Today on Outside In, producer Justine Paradis is focusing on one group of scientists: researchers from three different countries and seven universities who are trying to continue their work at a time of huge transition and uncertainty. We'll meet some of the people behind the headlines, find out how the cuts are impacting their science, and why they're willing to put themselves on the line to keep doing it. Stay tuned.
6:15 Nick Capodice? Haven't you out there ever Googled your own name? Like, actually done it? You'll find your address, your phone number, maybe even that police report from the time you went to see Rain Man in the movie theater, but you were underage? Maybe that one's just me. But here's the thing. There are companies called data brokers whose entire business model is collecting your personal information and selling it to advertisers, to strangers, sometimes to people running scams. And once your data's out there, it just keeps circulating. That is where Incogni comes in. Incogni contacts data brokers on your behalf and sends them removal requests over and over, so your info doesn't just pop right back up. You set it up once, and they keep working in the background.
7:00 Nick Capodice? You can even track the progress on a dashboard. And for our listeners, we have an exclusive 60% off an annual Incogni plan. Just go to incogni.com/civics or use the code civics at checkout. There's a link in the episode description. Remember, they can't harm you if they can't find you.
7:22 Speaker 00 The award-winning American Airlines Advantage Program rewards more than travel. It takes your whole life to new heights. Earn miles when you fly, as well as with thousands of your favorite brands, and then redeem those miles for flights, upgrades, and experiences worldwide. Advantage members also enjoy early boarding and free high-speed Wi-Fi in-flight. Join for free and start earning towards your next adventure at aa.com/spotify.
7:50 Speaker 02 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
8:23 Speaker 06 This is Outside In. I'm Justine Paradis. The morning after the barbecue, I headed out bright and early to meet the research team at a boat launch at Owosco Lake.
8:32 Speaker 10 So we can do four transects.
8:33 Speaker 08 Yeah, let's do four.
8:34 Speaker 10 Come back and then go back in and then go up.
8:35 Speaker 08 And then do the next four. So we're doing the work on shore, which is easier, right?
8:39 Speaker 06 This was their last day collecting samples, and they were getting organized.
8:43 Speaker 08 We're compromised.
8:46 Speaker 06 Owosco Lake is one of upstate New York's Finger Lakes, a cluster of long, narrow troughs carved by retreating glaciers beginning millions of years ago. Historically, they are deep and beautiful, and clean. But the team here is trying to understand something new happening on these lakes: harmful algal blooms. Generally speaking, harmful algal blooms, or HABs for short, are not uncommon in the summer. But globally, they're on the rise. Factors like heat and agricultural runoff can feed pre-existing microbes until their populations suddenly explode.
9:29 Speaker 06 The ones that these scientists are most interested in are actually caused by cyanobacteria, which is technically not actually an algae, but anyway. These blooms can look weird: foamy or scummy, turning the water as green and thick as pea soup. They can also smell weird, like sulfur or rotten eggs. But the scary part is less immediately perceptible. The blooms produce toxins, harmful to your nervous system and to your liver, and that makes the water undrinkable and dangerous. Here's Bob Howard.
10:02 Speaker 08 Exactly. They'll stick to a dog, and the dog goes home and licks them, and it'll kill them.
10:08 Speaker 06 Yikes.
10:09 Speaker 08 Some of the toxins are also volatile, so it'll be released to the air, and even kayaking through the bloom can be hazardous.
10:15 Speaker 06 No way.
10:21 Speaker 06 Until 2015, no one had ever documented a hab in all but one of the Finger Lakes. That's because typically, harmful algal blooms occur in muckier water, places that are high in phosphorus. According to scientists, these blooms should not be happening in the Finger Lakes. But they are. And they're starting to appear in other places where they shouldn't. In Lake Superior, Quebec, lakes further north in the Canadian Shield. So the scientists here are calling them unconventional harmful algal blooms.
10:55 Speaker 08 I thought I understood lakes. I thought I understood cyanobacteria blooms, and I don't. What am I missing?
11:02 Speaker 06 This week's sampling will be, they hope, a start of an answer.
11:12 Speaker 08 Doug says we're on station. Roger, Roger.
11:17 Speaker 06 Today, they're sampling a shallower area. But all week, the team has been pulling cores of mud in very deep parts of the lake, layers of sediment that will let them look back at conditions for the past couple centuries.
11:28 Speaker 10 The front side of the boat is just the muddy part.
11:30 Speaker 05 I'm in the mud zone.
11:32 Speaker 10 You're in the mud zone.
11:33 Speaker 06 That's Joshua Thienpont, a Canadian paleolymnologist. He studies ancient lakes.
11:38 Speaker 10 There's like these hands here. It looks like some swamp monster has come out of the bottom of the lake and was clinging to the front door. In reality, it's just me.
11:48 Speaker 06 You're the swamp monster.
11:50 Speaker 10 The mud monster.
11:52 Speaker 06 Josh is a flurry of activity, tossing the unwieldy core into the water, then lying down flat on the deck, leaning over the side, then up again, hauling ropes like he's pulling up an anchor.
12:01 Speaker 10 Coming up.
12:03 Speaker 06 It is really physical work, and it's going, okay.
12:06 Speaker 10 Sorry.
12:09 Speaker 06 Josh loses one coring tube, and then, a few minutes later...
12:12 Speaker 10 Another tube.
12:13 Speaker 06 He loses another.
12:17 Speaker 11 Sorry, I'm here to capture the hard day.
12:20 Speaker 10 That's okay. I don't want it all looking like sunshine and rainbows. There are some sediments that just give up their secrets a little bit less easily. So...
12:35 Speaker 06 From the outside, science might feel far away from everyday realities. Maybe a sterile or even elite life of papers, journals, lab work. But today, Josh is literally getting his hands dirty. He's got mud splattered everywhere, on his clothes, on his face, even in his mouth. You've got it in your teeth.
12:56 Speaker 10 Yeah, I can taste it.
12:59 Speaker 06 It looks clayey.
13:00 Speaker 10 20% sand.
13:03 Speaker 06 And the stakes of this work are very real. It's hard and expensive to remove the toxins caused by harmful algal blooms. Boiling the water doesn't help, it actually makes it worse. And the Finger Lakes alone are the water supply for over a million people. And that's one reason why, for many of these folks, science is more than a career. It's a community, a lifestyle, and sometimes even a family business. Josh, for instance, has a six-year-old. When he gets back to Toronto, his wife, who's also a paleolimnologist, will take off to do her own fieldwork. Irina Creed, one of the leads this week, is a hydrologist at the University of Toronto.
13:46 Speaker 06 And she's here with her 20-something-year-old daughter, Nico Trick.
13:50 Speaker 12 I've tagged along all my life, actually. Since I was like 10. I've done coring in particularly since I was about 10.
13:58 Speaker 06 Nico's dad, Charlie Trick, he also studies harmful algal blooms, but on the ocean. About 20 years ago, after returning from an 18-day ocean cruise sampling a particularly big harmful algal bloom off the coast of Vancouver, Charlie got sick. Here's Irina.
14:17 Speaker 13 He was giving a lecture at Western University in Canada. It was the time of chalk and blackboard, and he's writing there. And by the end of the lecture, he had dropped the line that he was writing, and it just fell right down to the bottom, and he had no strength whatsoever left.
14:35 Speaker 06 It was neurological damage in his shoulder. Charlie couldn't lift his nine-month-old baby. And he says the doctors said this was one in a million neurological damage caused by a poison. And their family thinks the timing was such, that it was caused by the algae.
14:51 Speaker 13 It makes it very personal. I've seen firsthand the harm that these toxin-producing algae can create. And so it makes me feel even more wanting to solve the problem. Not only for my husband, I can't solve what happened to him. But maybe we can avoid it happening to others, or at least understand it better so that others can benefit.
15:14 Speaker 06 Is he still living with that?
15:17 Speaker 13 Yes, since that time, which would have been 22 years ago. The recovery has not been complete.
15:33 Speaker 06 You might think that all this personal sacrifice and proximity to climate change and pollution and the problems of the world might be a good reason for scientists to feel depressed. But at least here, that doesn't appear to be so. Back at the barbecue, I overheard Irina reflecting on the week.
15:51 Speaker 13 Do you ever just feel lucky? This whole week has been luck. Everything working out, good weather. You come here with a good heart, everything works out.
16:03 Speaker 06 I heard this kind of thing repeatedly, expressions of positivity, gratitude, and curiosity. But the truth is, there is also a whole other set of feelings running in the background: fear, anxiety, and shock.
16:19 Speaker 13 Well, I work with US EPA, USGS, US Forest Service, and it's almost like we're mourning on the call for the first 20 minutes about what the loss is. And it's very heavy. It's very heavy.
16:33 Speaker 06 Here's Bob Howard.
16:34 Speaker 08 Hey, Cornell. I'm on the faculty at Cornell University. I lost $1.2 million worth of funding over the last month or so. We had a grant from the USDA to measure methane emissions from dairy farm operations. That funding's been pulled, it's gone.
16:48 Speaker 06 The Trump administration is making major cuts to science funding. Shuttering the entire scientific research arm of the EPA, pausing federal grants to universities. So there's hiring freezes all over the place and fewer opportunities for students.
17:04 Speaker 08 Our graduates are scared. They're wondering whether there'll be jobs available for them when they get out. Our undergraduates, if they're majoring in environmental science, some of them are doing it just because they are so in love with the field and so dedicated. But those who have a practical bent are going, "Look, we're giving up on environmental protection. Research stuff is going away. Will there be jobs?" I get asked that on an almost daily basis when I'm at work advising students. There isn't a good answer. You can't be reassuring, I don't think.
17:38 Speaker 08 We're not being reassuring.
17:39 Speaker 13 We're not safe. If I gave that impression, we're not. I have colleagues in Canada who receive funding from the United States, who have expended funds on doing research for American organizations, and that funding has just been cut off. And there are debts that are associated with that that Canadian universities have to reconcile and address. We're not talking about tens of thousands of dollars. We're talking about hundreds of thousands of dollars.
18:09 Speaker 06 Another member of this international group is Fulbright scholar Anita Dedich, a Bosnian scientist with a special focus on algae. This is a huge career moment for her, years in the making.
18:21 Speaker 14 For me, it was confirmation that I'm on the great way.
18:27 Speaker 06 You almost couldn't come, right?
18:29 Speaker 14 Yeah.
18:30 Speaker 08 She's worked for years to apply to get here, right? It's a very, very competitive process to be a Fulbright scholar. Anita, you started applying three years ago, working on...
18:41 Speaker 14 Four.
18:42 Speaker 08 Yeah, right?
18:43 Speaker 14 Yes.
18:45 Speaker 06 Earlier this spring, just as Anita was set to get her visa, the entire Fulbright program was frozen at the State Department. Bob had to personally intervene to get her here.
18:56 Speaker 08 It just adds chaos and stress. And that's true of virtually everything we're doing now.
19:10 Speaker 06 And that's just the money. Travel to the United States wasn't a simple choice for everyone. So for the Canadians in the room, crossing the border, how was that feeling these days?
19:22 Speaker 13 Uncomfortable.
19:26 Speaker 06 Because of nerves or? Tell me more.
19:29 Speaker 13 It's a complex situation. I think some of my colleagues have been afraid to cross the border, especially ones that are visible minorities. We've had national academic organizations giving advisories for us not to come to the United States, especially if you're socially active on media and custom officers can stop and check your social media. And there have been reports of computers being taken and academics being detained.
20:01 Speaker 06 These experiences aren't the norm, but Irene says it only takes a couple stories to make everyone scared. So they did take precautions, like instead of the Canadians driving their equipment across the border, Bob, an American, drove up and brought it back himself, just in case.
20:19 Speaker 13 These tense times, you just don't know. Things are not normal. And so you kind of feel a blessing when it works and pray for the best.
20:33 Speaker 06 Pray for the best. This project involves acts of faith. Faith that they'll find a boat capable of doing this kind of sampling, in this case, lent and driven by a local dairy farmer who even paid for the gas out of his own pocket. Faith that the delicate work of deepwater coring will go well. And faith they'll find the money to even pay for it. They don't actually have any dedicated funding for this project. Some are earning their regular salary this week, while others aren't getting paid at all. But their time is just one part of it. There's also the cost of analysis. Six lakes, 120 samples each, each sample costing about $1,000 to process.
21:18 Speaker 06 So hundreds of thousands of dollars.
21:21 Speaker 13 Frankly, I'll be completely honest with you. I don't know where I'm going to get some of the funding. Maybe we've been at this long enough that we believe that it will come and we'll figure it out. But that's where we're, that's the situation we're in. You hope.
21:36 Speaker 06 Outside and we'll be back after a break.
21:54 Nick Capodice? Haven't you out there ever Googled your own name? Like actually done it? You'll find your address, your phone number, maybe even that police report from the time you went to see Rain Man in the movie theater, but you were underage? Maybe that one's just me. But here's the thing. There are companies called data brokers whose entire business model is collecting your personal information and selling it to advertisers, to strangers, sometimes to people running scams. And once your data's out there, it just keeps circulating. That is where Incogni comes in. Incogni contacts data brokers on your behalf and sends them removal requests over and over so your info doesn't just pop right back up. You set it up once and they keep working in the background.
22:39 Nick Capodice? You can even track the progress on a dashboard. And for our listeners, we have an exclusive 60% off an annual Incogni plan. Just go to incogni.com/civics or use the code civics at checkout. There's a link in the episode description. Remember, they can't harm you if they can't find you.
23:00 Speaker 00 The award-winning American Airlines Advantage Program rewards more than travel. It takes your whole life to new heights. Earn miles when you fly, as well as with thousands of your favorite brands, and then redeem those miles for flights, upgrades, and experiences worldwide. Advantage members also enjoy earlier boarding and free high-speed Wi-Fi in-flight. Join for free and start earning towards your next adventure at aa.com/spotify.
23:29 Speaker 02 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data in hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
24:00 Speaker 06 This is Outside In, a show where curiosity and the natural world collide. I'm Justine Paradis. We spent the first half of the show on and around upstate New York's Finger Lakes. Now I want to take you to another place, not far from there, to a hill just south of Ithaca, New York.
24:18 Speaker 15 So, there's our precipitation collector. And up there is where we're collecting air quality samples.
24:26 Speaker 06 This is Tom Butler, today sporting a Cornell Ornithology baseball cap and a t-shirt depicting the state fossil of New York. He manages this site in the woods outside of Ithaca, one of the longest-running atmospheric monitoring stations in the country. It's modest. At the top of the hill, there's a little hut with a small tower. And down the hill in the meadow... Basically, it's like a wooden platform with a couple buckets. That's what it looks like from here.
24:53 Speaker 15 Yeah, bucket science.
24:55 Speaker 06 Bucket science. Tom tells me this method was originally designed to measure nuclear fallout in the mid-20th century. But here, they're using it to measure rainfall chemistry, notably acid rain. Up the hill, he's measuring atmospheric gases, like ozone.
25:13 Speaker 15 So, there's, the ozone is 32 parts per billion, 33 parts per billion, which is pretty good. You want to keep it under, under 70.
25:24 Speaker 06 This site is one of hundreds across the country, which together offer a window into the atmosphere. The data is available for free, for anyone to use, and has been critical for designing policy that tackles things like acid rain. Every week, Tom visits the site to collect the samples and mail them off to a central lab in Wisconsin for processing.
25:45 Speaker 15 Okay, and then, you know, they ask about sensor heater and motor box operated properly? Yes, spring gauge.
25:54 Speaker 06 It's quiet, routine, even kind of boring. The only drama today was the question of if a bird had pooped in his samples.
26:02 Speaker 15 Bird droppings, no.
26:03 Speaker 06 It hadn't. Or if the hornets were still nesting on one of his platforms. They weren't.
26:10 Speaker 15 Okay, how long have I been doing this? We found this location in 1976.
26:18 Speaker 06 So you've basically been coming here at least once a week for 50 years?
26:23 Speaker 15 Yeah, yeah. Stuck in a rut.
26:28 Speaker 06 You think?
26:30 Speaker 15 No, I think it's worthwhile. It's a real worthwhile. You know, long-term monitoring is not sexy. Lots of times, people don't want to fund it, but it's very, very valuable stuff.
26:42 Speaker 06 Why?
26:43 Speaker 15 Because you can see what's happening over the long term and what direction things are going. And you only get that with long-term data. And it takes a while to consider something long-term.
26:58 Speaker 06 In recent years, these monitoring stations have started to pick up something new, not just here at this site in upstate New York, but in a lot of places across the country. A rise in ammonia. Ammonia is a form of nitrogen gas. It's not regulated as a pollutant, but plenty of people consider it to be one. And one reason why this matters...
27:21 Speaker 15 Around here, everybody's concerned about these harmful algae blooms.
27:26 Speaker 06 Is that it could be connected to these new, unconventional, harmful algal blooms.
27:36 Speaker 06 That ammonia hypothesis, it's Bob's. Bob Howarth, Earth Systems Scientist and Cornell Professor.
27:43 Speaker 08 My hypothesis is that it's nitrogen. I think it's safe to say that no one can claim with certainty and understand what's going on.
27:51 Speaker 06 Bob's getting ready to retire next year. And he's been around the block. Again, Bob is one of the most widely cited environmental scientists in the world, and he's worked under a lot of different political winds. He's even served on the Clean Air Science Advisory Committee under multiple presidents.
28:07 Speaker 08 When Mr. Biden became president, he fired everyone on that panel, including me, in order to have a clean slate. And then they reappointed me. And as far as I know, as of today, I have not yet been fired again.
28:19 Speaker 06 Through it all, he's found a way to get a lot of different work funded. But this moment is different. And one way to understand why scientists are so concerned is by understanding the distinction between basic science and applied science.
28:36 Speaker 06 Applied science is a targeted way of looking at an issue, pursuing ways to make batteries more efficient, to support renewable energy, or trials of new treatments to fight cancer. Basic science is much more, well, basic. It's the pursuit of understanding almost for the sake of it. Things like, how do black holes work? Or spike proteins on viruses.
29:01 Speaker 08 You know, in order to do strong science long term, you can't only do applied science. You really need to encourage people to do basic science, follow their curiosity, follow their creativity, and that's how totally new discoveries are made.
29:17 Speaker 06 This spring, on top of the canceled grants, the Trump administration proposed about $15 billion worth of cuts to basic science. That's a third of the nationwide budget for this work. This is, of course, all in flux, and that number may change. But if big cuts come to pass, a lot of scientists think that would be a huge mistake. There are proposed cuts to applied science, too, but the folks I talked to are specifically alarmed about the cuts to basic research. And that's because basic science is specifically long-term in nature, an investment in the future. They say, with this level of cut, we don't know what we won't know.
30:05 Speaker 06 Plus, applied science, the more targeted kind, tends to be built on basic science. Take the research into the harmful algal blooms. It doesn't fall easily into one category. It's both.
30:19 Speaker 08 If we're going to manage it, we need to understand it. You can't manage what you don't understand. So that's a real applied issue. My interest in it, you know, I'm interested in that management aspect, but, you know, I'm driven equally by just raw curiosity. I thought I understood lakes. I thought I understood cyanobacteria blooms, and I don't.
30:38 Speaker 06 To do applied science, to manage harmful algal blooms, we're gonna need information from cool international teams doing deep-water coring out on the Finger Lakes, from unsexy stuff like long-term monitoring, and who knows where else.
30:53 Speaker 08 As a basic scientist, you can never tell what will matter and what won't, right? You just, you can't tell.
30:58 Speaker 06 I did, by the way, reach out to the National Science Foundation for this story to ask about what's getting cut and why. They declined to comment. For Bob and the scientists sampling in the Finger Lakes this week, the project has involved acts of faith, a gamble that things will work out. But that's not just true for the scientists. Investing taxpayer money into scientific institutions and research grants, that's kind of an act of faith, too. A gamble that the scientific process is a pretty decent way of stress-testing new information and ideas. That supporting scientists to follow their curiosity ultimately benefits society, or at least the country.
31:39 Speaker 08 We live in the richest country in the world, richest country that's ever existed in the world, and that's in large part because of our technological prowess, and that comes from high-quality science and engineering.
31:55 Speaker 06 Without that federal money, some research, perhaps the most obviously profitable kind, might be fine. But environmental research, bucket science, and long-term monitoring, Bob's doubtful.
32:09 Speaker 08 You know, would someone else fund it? Well, no one else has, you know? No one's stepped forward for this so far. So that's one answer, and I don't think, I don't think it would happen.
32:24 Speaker 06 A little scale here.
32:28 Speaker 15 So I got a weight and I want to subtract the lid. I know the weight of the bucket.
32:36 Speaker 06 Back at the hill, just outside of Ithaca, Tom Butler is wrapping up a sampling for this week, collecting information on acid rain and ozone. Just one site in a couple of networks of nationwide monitoring programs built over decades.
32:51 Speaker 15 You know, this data is used by people all over the country and all over the world. Just since 2007, they've estimated over 3,000 publications related to these networks.
33:06 Speaker 06 Over the years, Tom's routine has changed, largely for a reason that you might be able to guess: money. Tom used to come out twice a week. Now it's once, every Tuesday. Right now, they're testing new, cheaper types of samplers. They're also planning to combine samples to save money on analysis, not to mention to save on postage. How much does it cost to run this site?
33:30 Speaker 15 Boy, that's a tricky question because there's analytical costs and, you know, site operator costs
33:42 Speaker 15 per year, I would say. If you're including everything, it's probably $25,000 a year, or something like that.
33:52 Speaker 06 So what happened this spring?
33:56 Speaker 15 So, April 30th, CARRY Institute got a letter from the federal government.
34:06 Speaker 06 The CARRY Institute is Tom's employer.
34:08 Speaker 15 Saying, "Your contract is immediately terminated at the convenience of the government as soon as you acknowledge that you received this message." And we acknowledged we received the message. So at 1:53 PM on April 30th, our contract was terminated.
34:34 Speaker 06 Right at a moment when the Trump administration is moving to open coal plants and loosen regulations on power plants, the federal government is pulling their funding from one of the country's oldest atmospheric monitoring sites.
34:48 Speaker 06 The kind of place that can tell us what's going on in the atmosphere and if acid rain is on the rise. As for Tom, he's been doing this 50 years. He could have retired a long time ago. But for now, funding be damned. Tom's out here every Tuesday. Yet you have kept coming out to take the samples.
35:12 Speaker 15 Yeah. And I'm going to keep doing it as long as I can.
35:20 Speaker 06 Later, after I turned off the mic and we got back in the car to drive down the hill, Tom added something else. "It's easy to wreck stuff," he said. "It's a lot harder to build it."
35:51 Speaker 04 Justine, you took a ton of pictures of science in action during your reporting, right?
35:55 Speaker 06 Yes, to see pictures of bucket science and of late coring in action. You can check out the show notes. We've got a link to our website and to our Instagram. We are at OutsideInRadio there and on Blue Sky and TikTok.
36:08 Speaker 04 That's it for Outside In this week. This episode was produced, reported, and mixed by Justine Paradis.
36:13 Speaker 06 Special thanks to all the folks who talked with me for this episode, including Jean Leikens, Charlie Trick, Doug Young, Roxanne Moreno, Gareth Smith, and Renee Santoro. At AAAS, thanks to Sudip Perik and Alessandra Zimmerman.
36:26 Speaker 04 This episode was edited by our executive producer, Taylor Quimby. I'm your host, Nate Hedgy. Our team also includes Marina Hanke, Jessica Hunt, and Felix Poon.
36:35 Speaker 06 Music in this episode came from Low 5, Silver Maple, and Blue Dot Sessions.
36:39 Speaker 04 Outside In is a production of NHPR.
37:07 Speaker 16 US democracy is being held together by duct tape. But what if the solution isn't more tape, but a fundamentally different design? Check out More Like Us, the new podcast for more equitable democracy, the award-winning racial justice organization focused on election reform, hosted by me, Colin Cole. Each episode, More Like Us provides smart, accessible conversations at the intersection of policy, culture, and democracy. Hear from the people reimagining our political future without the jargon or the lecture. So follow More Like Us wherever you get your podcasts.
37:38 Speaker 17 Are you ever shopping online and suddenly a discount that helps you save pops up? It makes your day, sometimes even your week. Want that feeling month after month? Well, new customers who save by switching their home and auto insurance to Progressive save hundreds. Cue your happy dance. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Not available in all states.
38:05 Speaker 11 Ready to transform your career in real time from where you are? Brown University's flexible online master's programs will help expand your business influence and your network in just 16 months. Choose from management, business analytics, or organizational leadership programs that will prepare you for today's most pressing business challenges without putting your life on hold. Scholarships available. Tap to learn more.
Previous Cinema Civics: Mr. Smith Goes to Washington Next How can the president take over a city's police department? Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated