Pod Insights Canadian True Crime The Twisted Story of Sergeant John Wilson [replay] About this episode A two-part series—A gripping, action-packed miniseries about a mountie who finds himself at the centre of a sordid love triangle.
Pieced together from a treasure trove of real love letters, forged letters and police and court memos, this series paints a vivid snapshot of Canada as World War I raged on.
— This series is a carefully selected replay from our archive, and was originally titled The Murderous Mountie.
Full list of resources, information sources, credits and music credits:
See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes https://www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/148?rq=murderous%20mountie
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hi everyone. Quick note before we start. As I explained in yesterday's update, we'll be back with new episodes in April. So this is a specially selected replay from the archive. It's one of my favourite cases and it has a pretty special origin story. A few years ago, my journalist friend Danielle Parody tipped me off about something fascinating sitting in the collections at Library and Archives Canada. It was a massive file connected to a strange love triangle that unfolded during the First World War. Inside were hundreds of pages of documents, love letters, forged letters, police notes
0:40 Speaker 00 and court memos, all piecing together a story with multiple twists and turns that ended in a brutal murder. When I saw this treasure trove of archival material, I knew there was a story that had to be told. So we purchased scans of the entire file and handed them over to Toronto true crime author Nate Henley, who I know would appreciate the rabbit hole. Nate combed through every page, added additional research from the news archives and built the narrative that I then adapted into the podcast series you're about to hear, called The Murderous Mountie. There's a special presentation of some of these letters and notes on our website for you to look at, link in the show notes.
1:25 Speaker 00 And because this story begins in Scotland, we hired Scottish voice actors to read some excerpts from the letters, which brought some extra colour to this series. The Murderous Mountie went on to be named the number eight podcast episode in Canada for 2023 in Apple Podcasts. So I've decided to share it again to meet our sponsor commitments while we prepare for new episodes in April. I really appreciate your patience and understanding. This is a two-part series and part two will be released tomorrow. We'll be right back to begin after this short break.
2:10 Speaker 01 Your call has been forwarded to an automatic voice message system.
2:13 Speaker 02 A missed call doesn't feel like anything. No red flag, no notification screaming at you. It just disappears into your call log. And nine times out of 10, that was someone ready to hand you money. That's why today's episode is brought to you by QUO, spelled Q-U-O. The business phone system built so you never miss a call. Here's what I like about it. All your calls, texts, and voicemails live in one place. So anyone on your team can pick up a conversation, see the full history, and respond fast. No more, "Wait, who talked to this customer last?" And if you're worried about after-hours leads slipping through, QUO's optional built-in AI agent can answer questions and even book appointments while your team's offline. It's the number-one rated business phone system on G2,
2:57 Speaker 02 and over 90,000 businesses already trust it to stay reachable. Money is on the line. Always say hello with QUO. Try QUO for free. Plus, get 20% off your first six months when you go to quo.com/tech. That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech.
3:14 Speaker 03 When you're running a growing business, the right systems can unlock your full sales potential and make fulfilling every order effortless. Switch to ShipStation before peak season so you're prepped and ready before the rush hits. ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 more marketplaces with one platform that does it all. You can manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all automatically. Everything your operation needs, all in one place. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to shipstation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free.
3:48 Speaker 04 Canadian True Crime is a completely independent production, funded mainly through advertising. The podcast often has disturbing content and coarse language. It's not for everyone. Please take care when listening.
4:06 Speaker 00 The date was September 27th, 1918, and 32-year-old Mary Wilson was on a train from Regina, in the prairie province of Saskatchewan. Just a month or two earlier, she'd been living with her husband, John Wilson, in Regina, where he worked with the Dominion Police. But then, he was suddenly posted to Saskatoon, about 260 kilometres north. Mary was newly pregnant, and John told her to stay put in Regina until he had purchased a home for them to live in, and then he would send for her to join him in Saskatoon. Born Mary Hutchison in Scotland, she was a very long way from home.
4:50 Speaker 00 And although it wasn't ideal for her to be pregnant and alone in a foreign city, at the time, she really had no choice but to agree to her husband's plan. But that was over now. Mary Wilson was finally on that train to Saskatoon and would soon be reunited with her husband. Photographs of Mary reveal a pleasant-looking woman with dark eyes and hair neatly arrayed upwards in a popular style of the day. That September, the temperature hit 24 degrees Celsius, but Mary had been living in the prairies long enough to know that autumn evenings could be cold, so she was bundled in multiple layers,
5:34 Speaker 00 a white button-down blouse and blue skirt over her underclothes with lace-up boots.
5:42 Speaker 00 Mary's train pulled into Saskatoon at 4pm, and her husband John was waiting for her in the new car he'd recently purchased for work, a grey Dort, a Canadian-made vehicle that resembled the iconic Ford Compact Model T.
5:59 Speaker 00 After the couple had exchanged greetings, John threw Mary's small suitcase in the car and invited her to get into the passenger side. At his instruction, she'd left all her other luggage and personal items in Regina with the plan to send for them separately, likely because of her delicate condition. Mary already knew that they had to make one stop for John to take care of some police business, but after that, they would be headed onwards to their new home.
6:34 Speaker 00 John drove out to the countryside north of Saskatoon, the flat landscape consisting of farms, trees, grain crops and vast empty spaces. Mary had plenty of time to look at the scenery because the grey dort could only go about 30 kilometres an hour and the roads were not exactly smooth. As John drove the car, he occasionally sipped from a bottle of liquor and he didn't talk much. He certainly didn't mention to his wife that he had a fresh marriage licence in his pocket, made out to himself and his secret girlfriend Jessie. On the marriage licence paperwork, John had declared himself a bachelor.
7:46 Speaker 00 John Wilson and Mary Hutchison met in their early twenties while working at a drapery company in Carluke, a village near Glasgow, Scotland. Mary came from a deeply religious and impoverished working class family who lived in Slomanen, a small village in central Scotland. Her father wanted to be a minister but couldn't afford to attend a divinity school, so he became a coal miner instead. Mary had five siblings, including a sister named Elizabeth, who was a keen writer known for her descriptive details. Here's how she would write about Mary.
8:26 Speaker 05 As a girl, she was like a wee fairy. She was so thin with a mass of long golden curls. She was always brave and would have laughed at what had made me weep.
8:38 Speaker 00 Fairy qualities aside, Mary, who was known as Polly to her friends and family, was by all accounts an upbeat, pleasant young woman. A 1919 letter from a parish minister would describe her as sweet and amiable, liked and trusted by everyone who knew her.
8:59 Speaker 00 Mary's husband, John Wilson, had a considerably different upbringing. His parents had been relatively wealthy owners of a grocery store and grain business in Kalook, but they had long since passed away. While John and his three siblings shared in a decent inheritance, John's older brother was the one who took the reins of the family business. Problem was, he was a terrible businessman, focusing on the single goal of amassing personal wealth. It didn't take long before the business was in trouble. In the meantime, John was trying to figure out what he wanted to do with his life.
9:41 Speaker 00 He tried his hand at apprenticing at a tomato greenhouse. He took a job as a junior railway clerk, then as a draper, a person who sells cloth and dry goods. Mary Hutchison worked as a dressmaker at the same outlet, and the rest was history, literally. John Wilson and Mary Hutchison were married in 1908, and a year later, Mary gave birth to their first child, a son named George. After that, John decided to build some greenhouses for tomato farming and convinced a few relatives to join as partners, including Mary's sister Elizabeth and her husband. The business did quite well,
10:26 Speaker 00 but the partners had no idea the profits were being secretly diverted to prop up the failing family business. Eventually, in 1911, the bank foreclosed on all the family's business enterprises, and both John and his older brother ended up bankrupt.
10:49 Speaker 00 John Wilson was now a failed farmer with a reputation for dubious ethics, but he soon had a new plan. He would move to Canada and start all over, and eventually send for Mary, little George, and the second child she was now six months pregnant with. Or maybe he would just earn some decent money in Canada and then return home with it, John wasn't quite certain. His plan was to figure things out once he settled in Saskatchewan, with his ultimate destination being the bustling city of Saskatoon, on the flat, south-central Saskatchewan prairie. While he was gone, Mary would look after the household in Scotland
11:34 Speaker 00 and prepare for the arrival of their second child, which she of course would have to face without him. Her husband promised to write letters and send money back to them often.
11:51 Speaker 00 John Wilson departed for Canada in July of 1912. He didn't have a lot of money, so he couldn't afford to travel in style. He booked a ticket on a low-end ship that took two weeks to cross the Atlantic, a sluggish pace compared to speedy ocean liners which made the passage in days. Then again, just three months earlier, one of those speedy liners had collided with an iceberg off Newfoundland and sank, resulting in the deaths of more than 1,500 passengers and crew. No doubt, the tragedy of the Titanic played on John's mind during his lengthy voyage.
12:36 Speaker 00 He landed in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and took a train west to Saskatchewan, observing the rugged, stony terrain of northern Ontario turn into the flatlands of the prairies. John had made an excellent decision in selecting his destination. He was one of countless people from the British Isles tantalised by the prospect of new beginnings in the dominion of Canada. The Canadian government had been particularly eager to welcome settlers to the recently established Western provinces of Saskatchewan and Alberta, and a flood of promotional posters, brochures, flyers and other material was being churned out.
13:19 Speaker 00 Promotional material heavily emphasised the fertile soil, cheap land and vast opportunities, depicting the West as some kind of rural heaven. And it was working. The Western provinces were booming at the time, with plenty of jobs and opportunities for young, able-bodied men, like John Wilson. In the decade from 1901 to 1911, Saskatchewan's population had exploded from about 90,000 residents to just under half a million, and the city of Saskatoon's growth rate was even higher. This growth, of course, came at the expense of the indigenous inhabitants of the land,
14:04 Speaker 00 who were forced into reservations.
14:09 Speaker 00 After John Wilson arrived in Saskatoon, he took a job working with a bridge construction crew, then as a city gardener. He learned that back in Scotland, Mary had given birth to their second child, a daughter she named Helen. John continued to try and get ahead in Canada, toiling in various manual labour positions. Eventually, he decided to tempt fate again and venture into the entrepreneurial world. He was in a new country now, perhaps this time the results would be different. He purchased some property near Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, and started farming tomatoes
14:50 Speaker 00 once more, hoping for a taste of his past success without the problem of his older brother. But there was a new problem: the volatilities of prairie weather. A hailstorm in the summer of 1914 wiped out his entire crop.
15:11 Speaker 00 John was done. Having failed twice in farming, he pondered his next move.
15:19 Speaker 00 In Europe, events were starting to unfold that would prove disastrous for millions, but inadvertently fortuitous for John. The June 1914 assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, the next in line to the throne of Austria-Hungary, was the spark said to have ignited World War I. Armies mobilised and three months later, Europe was at war.
15:48 Speaker 00 While Canada had technically become semi-independent in 1867, the nation was still culturally and politically tied to Great Britain. So when Britain went to war against Germany, the Canadian Army scrambled to find new recruits to join the effort. And John Wilson tried to enlist, bursting with patriotism, or maybe just because he needed a job. But he was rejected on physical grounds by a military doctor and Prince Albert. As it turned out, this rejection provided him with an enormous opportunity. Two weeks after the army turned him down, a poster in Prince Albert caught his eye.
16:33 Speaker 00 It was a recruitment drive for the Royal Northwest Mounted Police, a paramilitary organisation and predecessor to the RCMP, Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
16:49 Speaker 00 Later, John Wilson would say the reason he decided to apply for the Royal Northwest Mounties was that he was hoping the organisation would send troops to Europe to fight, which would allow him to get closer to home in Scotland, while also doing his part for the war effort. But realistically, it's more likely that he just wanted secure employment and steady pay as a Mountie. After all, the Royal Northwest Mounties had enough to do at home in Canada, enforcing the law and controlling the indigenous population.
17:26 Speaker 00 So if John Wilson wasn't accepted into the Canadian Army, what made him think he would be successful with the Royal Northwest Mounted Police?
17:38 Speaker 00 Well, now that Canada was officially participating in the war, the force had been tasked with searching for war spies and saboteurs, particularly in western Canada where there were a high number of immigrants that were being referred to as foreigners. Obviously, these foreigners did not include the white, English-speaking settlers from Britain that the Canadian government historically preferred. The prairies presented challenging terrain that wasn't so attractive to the favoured settlers, so a controversial decision was made to open up immigration to farmers from central and eastern Europe. This included a large number of peasants and farmers from Ukraine
18:23 Speaker 00 who saw an opportunity to escape the oppressive conditions of their homeland, half of which was controlled by Russia and the other by Austria-Hungary. Ukrainian farmers had been brutalised by these authorities, who kept them indebted, miserable and landless. But they built up a reputation for being tough, hardy and used to horrible weather. So when the Canadian government invited them over and offered them the ability to own land, they couldn't believe it. Ukrainians started pouring into the prairies in such large numbers that today, Canada is home to the largest population of Ukrainians outside of Ukraine.
19:08 Speaker 00 But the English-speaking settlers soon started to get irritated about the sudden influx of eastern Europeans they referred to as foreigners. It's an age-old story. The main complaints were that they didn't speak English or follow British customs. And worse, some of these foreigners harboured progressive political ideas and weird religious beliefs. A Russian Christian sect called the Dukabors liked to strip naked in public to express their grievances, a move that was particularly shocking to the prudish and moralistic white settlers. And as World War I unfolded, their suspicions only intensified,
19:51 Speaker 00 especially towards Ukrainians who had come from the area controlled by Austria-Hungary, which was an ally of Germany and technically the enemy of Canada in the war.
20:04 Speaker 00 Many Ukrainians, along with other nationalities in Canada, were confined in internment camps and closely monitored for most of World War I. And those who weren't confined were assigned to the Royal North West Mounted Police for strict monitoring and told to report to them regularly. This increased scope of duty resulted in a recruitment drive to get more Mounties. And that's how John Wilson, a 30-year-old army reject with no policing experience, was accepted to join the organisation. John was reasonably tall and spoke English, good enough for a force that badly needed new recruits.
20:48 Speaker 00 He was given regimental number 6020 and listed his wife Mary Wilson as his next of kin on his enlistment form. He started his training in Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, that fall, with endless drills, lessons in marksmanship, fist fighting, first aid and criminal law. Recruits also had to master horseback riding as a practical move. Cars were scarce at the time, so Mounties often rode horses while on patrol. Horses were better than cars anyway when it came to chasing suspects in dense woods or across farm fields.
21:29 Speaker 00 After John's training was completed in the summer of 1915, he was assigned to a small Saskatchewan community called Blaine Lake. Part of his job was to enforce the law over vast spaces featuring scattered settlements and dirt roads, and he was also expected to root out spies and subversives. It wasn't a fun or glamorous job, and John put in long hours for the low pay of a new recruit. The Blaine Lake area had a local Dukabor community. Known as wildly eccentric pacifists, they refused to sign up for the army draft, which was seen as treasonous, not admirable.
22:14 Speaker 00 The reports and letters John wrote during this period contain many mentions of the Dukabors and his interactions with them.
22:25 Speaker 00 At first, Sergeant John Wilson was diligent with his duties with the Royal North West Mounted Police, but his head was soon turned at the sight of a potential love interest. Her name was Jessie Patterson.
22:45 Speaker 00 Sixteen-year-old Jessie was one of four children who had recently moved to Blaine Lake with their parents. Jessie's father, Mr Patterson, purchased a horse boarding stable there and rented stables to nearby horse owners while the family lived next door. One of those horses belonged to Sergeant John Wilson of the Royal North West Mounted Police, and that's how he got to know the Patterson clan. Jessie's good-natured father figured the new mountie might be lonely, so he invited him to dine with his family. It would be a decision he would later regret.
23:35 Speaker 01 Your call has been forwarded to an automatic voice message system.
23:38 Speaker 02 A missed call doesn't feel like anything. No red flag, no notification screaming at you, it just disappears into your call log. And nine times out of ten, that was someone ready to hand you money. That's why today's episode is brought to you by QUO, spelled Q-U-O. The business phone system built so you never miss a call. Here's what I like about it: all your calls, texts, and voicemails live in one place, so anyone on your team can pick up a conversation, see the full history, and respond fast. No more, "Wait, who talked to this customer last?" And if you're worried about after-hours leads slipping through, QUO's optional built-in AI agent can answer questions and even book appointments while your team's offline.
24:19 Speaker 02 It's the number-one-rated business phone system on G2, and over 90,000 businesses already trust it to stay reachable. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free. Plus, get 20% off your first six months when you go to quo.com/tech. That's Q U O dot com slash tech. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation. The only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings.
25:03 Speaker 02 Go to shipstation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.
25:19 Speaker 00 30-year-old John Wilson accepted the dinner invitation with the Pattersons. While eating, he took note of 16-year-old Jessie. He liked what he saw. John began spending a lot of time at the Patterson abode, developing a serious interest in Jessie despite the disturbing age gap between the two. John would later recount that up until that point, he had his head down, working hard for the force.
25:49 Speaker 06 During all this time, I had nothing to do with girls, until the fall of 1916, when I became acquainted with Jessie Patterson. She was always so good to me, above everybody else.
26:05 Speaker 00 At first, Jessie had no clue that John was married, much less that he had two young children back in Scotland, one that he hadn't even met yet. He certainly didn't volunteer any information about his private life. Jessie just thought he was a dashing, mounty bachelor, and was delighted by the attention he showered on her. Throughout 1917, as the grinding war in Europe continued, John and Jessie saw each other as frequently as possible. He received decent performance reviews for his work with the Royal North West Mounties, even earning a cash bonus for his work on a murder case.
26:48 Speaker 00 But he still really wanted to join the war effort, this time for a slightly different reason. John would claim he was having reservations about his relationship with Jessie and wanted to put some distance between them. Even though the army had rejected him before, he considered trying to enlist again, but that plan was hampered when he suddenly developed tuberculosis. TB is a serious illness caused by bacteria that typically attacks the lungs. In an era before antibiotics, tuberculosis or TB was a killer with no known cure beyond rest, sunshine, and nutritious food.
27:33 Speaker 00 John Wilson got so sick, he had to take a discharge from the Royal North West Mounties in late August of 1917, and because he was too weak to travel, he was forced to remain in Blaine Lake. He stayed with the Pattersons and became more reliant on young Jessie as she endeavored to nurse him back to full health. Later, she would enter nursing school and become a professional caregiver. For now, she was content to focus her healing efforts on one patient. John would later write:
28:11 Speaker 06 "I was very sick all that winter. Jessie Patterson looked after me and was very kind to me. She was absolutely pure and innocent in all this. And many nights I lay awake in bed, trying to make up my mind to leave her for her sake. But I think I was not right in my mind by this time, and remained at Blaine Lake until April 1918."
28:35 Speaker 00 Pure and innocent as she might have been, Jessie was clearly as smitten with John as he was with her, despite their age difference. But Blaine Lake was a small community, and soon rumours started to spread that former Sergeant John Wilson was actually already married. Jessie's parents confronted him about it point blank, and John fessed up with the truth, or a version of it at least. While he said he had been married, he was now divorced, and the reason he didn't say anything earlier was because he was ashamed. John added that divorce papers were on their way from Scotland,
29:19 Speaker 00 and once they arrived, he would show them to anyone who asked.
29:26 Speaker 00 It was all nonsense, of course. John was still married to Mary, who was by this point barely getting by in Scotland. She was still working as a dressmaker, but it was hardly a well-paying occupation, and now she had two young children and a household to look after. John had kept his promise to send letters and money for some time, but the money stopped coming. Friends and family helped out when they could, but Mary was getting desperate. And the letters John promised to write were arriving less frequently, and when he did send one home, it was often to offer Mary a bizarre excuse as to why he didn't send money to her and the kids.
30:11 Speaker 00 Mary's sister Elizabeth, a prolific writer, actually wrote about one of those letters.
30:20 Speaker 05 Once he told her he had seventeen pounds ready to send her, but his horse got buried in the snow on the way to the post office and had to be dug out. My sister quite believed that and other equally glaring lies. She loved him and could see no wrong in him, and it was not for us to wound her by showing her his falseness.
30:43 Speaker 00 According to Elizabeth, the last letter her sister Mary received from her husband was dated April of 1917, right around the time that he first met Jessie Patterson. That letter was filled with cheerful news and a promise to return home. Mary joyously prepared the house for John’s arrival, believing her family would soon be reunited. But months went by and she never received another word from him. Mary Wilson was loyal, she was also determined and tough-minded, and she was now extremely concerned, fearing her husband’s silence meant he might be dead or ill.
31:28 Speaker 00 She decided to take things into her own hands and travelled to Canada to find out for herself.
31:40 Speaker 00 Mary Wilson received government permission and booked her ticket. Leaving her children in Scotland to travel to Canada to look for her husband was not a decision lightly made. Ship travel across the North Atlantic was dangerous at the best of times, and that danger was heightened as war raged on land and sea. German submarines were lying in wait, ordered to cut off supplies to France and Britain by sinking every vessel they encountered, including passenger ships. But Mary was unfazed by the risk of a German submarine attack.
32:20 Speaker 00 She departed Scotland in April of 1918, a year after she received her husband’s last letter, and she wanted answers. She didn’t send him any kind of advance letter or telegram to let him know that she was on her way. Perhaps, in the back of her mind, she had an inkling that John may have been deliberately ignoring her. Whatever it was, she had to find out the answers for herself.
32:55 Speaker 00 As Mary set sail for Canada, John Wilson was starting to ruffle some feathers there. When he took his discharge from the Royal North West Mounted Police, he told them his plans were to wait until the weather started to turn cold and then he would move to a warmer climate to recuperate from tuberculosis. But he didn't do that. A memo from the police organisation at the time states:
33:22 Speaker 07 It was later learned after taking his discharge that Wilson opened an automobile agency in Blaine Lake and did not leave the country as stated.
33:30 Speaker 00 Apparently, John Wilson's recovery from tuberculosis was not hampered by the cold weather. As soon as he felt well enough, he had moved out of the Patterson family home but decided to stay in Blaine Lake and become a car salesman. When John wasn't busy selling cars, he was taking care of other matters, like maintaining that house of cards he'd built on a foundation of lies.
33:59 Speaker 00 John suggested to his secret teenage girlfriend Jessie Patterson that it would be nice for her to write a letter to his sister back in Scotland. He even offered to take Jessie's letter to the post office and post it himself, helpful guy that he was. After an appropriate amount of time, Jessie received a lengthy response from John's sister, apparently written from her deathbed at the Royal Infirmary in Glasgow. The letter, dated March 4 of 1918, began: "Oh Jessie, I am dying and the doctors say the end will be here in about one hour. If I could only have lived until I had seen you and John, I would have died content."
34:45 Speaker 00 After this dramatic opening, John's sister heaped praise on him, describing him as a good boy and her mother's favourite child. She also described him as a super trooper who joined the Scottish Highlanders and made a splendid-looking soldier. I used to be proud to walk down the street with him as people would turn around and look at him.
35:07 Speaker 05 He had lots of money and made friends with all the boys in his regiment. He got the gold medal for two years in succession for being the smartest soldier in the brigade.
35:19 Speaker 00 John never served in the Scottish military, but no matter, the nonsense continued unabated. Apparently, John's sister really liked him. Jessie continued reading as the letter turned to John's sister disparaging Mary, depicting her sister-in-law as a shameless gold digger from the very first second she entered John's life.
35:42 Speaker 05 One Glasgow holiday, John hired a pleasure steamer and took all the boys in his company on a pleasure trip. He took all the girls from a dressmaking shop on the trip, and that was where he met the woman who ruined him. A few weeks later, he told me he was getting married. He had hardly known the girl a month, and I did not like her. I was sure she was only after his money.
36:06 Speaker 00 John's sister wrote that he had tried to break off the engagement, but alas, Mary threatened legal action. So through gritted teeth, John went through with the marriage, which, according to his sister, cost him a thousand dollars. Now Jessie was too young and inexperienced to know that a Scottish person would never have described money in terms of dollars. Their currency were shillings and pounds. The letter continued, John's sister writing that he was miserable in his marriage to Mary, and that the couple never indulged in any husband and wife connections.
36:46 Speaker 00 If the point was unclear, the letter went on to claim that John was not the biological father of his own son, George. Apparently, poor John came home one day to find his scheming wife in bed with another man. A devastating discovery, apparently. The letter ended with John's sister making a pathetic plea.
37:09 Speaker 05 He has had a hard life, Jessie, but you are his first love, and I know.
37:14 Speaker 01 No, he will make you happy. He must love you very dear, or he would not give up all his property for you. He is upright and honourable, and you can trust your life to him. I can die happier now, knowing that he is in your care.
37:31 Speaker 00 This letter, reportedly sent from John's sister in Scotland to his mistress Jessie in Canada, had red flags galore, especially for anyone familiar with rural Scottish life in the early 20th century. For starters, Mary Wilson had come from a strict religious family where marriage vows were taken very seriously, so it was extremely unlikely that she would have jumped in bed with another man. And as for John's sister, why would a person dying in hospice expend so much energy glorifying a sibling they hadn't seen in years to a girlfriend they'd never met?
38:12 Speaker 00 But as ridiculous as it was, John's forgery had Jessie fooled, and now he was on a roll.
38:22 Speaker 00 He followed up by forging an even more unbelievable letter to Jessie, this time from a Scottish reverend then in his mid-seventies who knew the Wilson family well. In this letter, supposedly from Reverend Frances M. Huxwell, Jessie read that all of John's siblings were now dead, which wasn't true, but tied up the loose end with a dying sister. Echoing the same details that sister had written in her letter, which of course was also forged, the reverend told Jessie that John was the favourite child, and his wife Mary was an awful woman.
39:01 Speaker 00 The reverend wrote that he was willing to bend his own principles after seeing how miserable John was in that marriage. I do not usually approve of divorce, but in this case I'd... advised John to get one long ago.
39:15 Speaker 00 The idea of an elderly Scottish minister urging a husband to ditch his wife seemed unlikely. But again, Jessie was too young and inexperienced to understand these nuances, and never challenged John about whether the letters were authentic. John's reasons for this forgery campaign soon became clear. He proposed to Jessie Patterson, and she agreed to marry him. Jessie wasn't completely naive, however. She reminded her new fiance about his promise to produce his divorce papers. John assured her they would turn up any day now. He had no idea that the woman he said he had divorced
40:01 Speaker 00 was on a ship headed for Canada to find him.
40:08 Speaker 00 Divorce papers did not arrive, but Mary Wilson did. Her ship docked in Halifax, Nova Scotia on April 12, 1918, and after she passed the requisite medical exam, she headed west to find her husband. She took a train to the Prairies, likely marveling at the immensity of the land outside her train window during the journey, and the changing terrain. But Mary Wilson was on a mission; she wasn't in Canada to sightsee. The train took her to Regina, Saskatchewan, the last place she believed her husband had been posted with the Royal North West Mounted Police.
40:52 Speaker 00 She immediately placed a call to the local detachment, identifying herself as John Wilson's wife, who was trying to get in contact with him. The official receiving this call checked his files, and then suggested that Mary contact the Prince Albert detachment because they might have a better idea where John was. Mary hung up and prepared to make her next call. In a strange coincidence, John just happened to be hanging around the Prince Albert detachment that very day. He had recovered from tuberculosis and had opened his car dealership, but he still wanted to join the war effort.
41:34 Speaker 00 After he heard that the Mounties were forming a cavalry unit for overseas duties, John rocked up to the Prince Albert detachment to apply, thinking he would be a shoo-in. But plenty of other men had the same idea, and the Mounties ended up with more applications than they needed. When John learned he didn't make the cut, he walked over to the office of the superintendent. As they were chatting, the phone started ringing, and the superintendent was startled to hear the person identify herself as John Wilson's long-absent wife. He passed the phone over to John, who uttered a greeting before hearing the voice of his
42:17 Speaker 00 estranged wife for the first time in years. A subsequent memo from the Mounties read:
42:25 Speaker 07 He appeared to be surprised when he learned that his wife was speaking to him.
42:30 Speaker 00 The superintendent watched as John steadied himself, and then made a show of appearing happy to hear from his wife. He gave Mary a very dramatic account of his bout with tuberculosis, saying he'd been so sick that it was impossible to write home. Every ounce of his strength was required to recover from the potentially deadly ailment. While Mary might have doubted this explanation, she eagerly agreed to meet. After all, she had come to Canada to find her husband, and now he had been located. Mary had no idea about the existence of Jesse Patterson.
43:12 Speaker 00 All she knew was that she and John were reunited, and he appeared happy to see her. The next step was them to find a place to live together. John went along with it and the pair moved into a Regina boarding house together. But it was not a happy reunion. John mostly ignored Mary, except for when he wanted sex. Before long, Mary fell pregnant with the couple's third child and John took a new job. She had no idea that he was plotting his next move.
44:01 Speaker 00 The youth mental health crisis is growing and social media is a major driver. Kids are spending up to nine hours a day on screens, often unsupervised, and studies show a direct link to anxiety, depression, and even suicidal thoughts. That's where Gab comes in. Gab offers safer phones and watches for kids with no social media,
44:22 Speaker 01 tailored to every age, offering the right tech at the right time, or Tech in Steps. From GPS-tracking-enabled watches for younger kids to phones with parent-enabled apps for teens, each device allows kids to more safely grow their independence. Visit gab.com/getgab and use code GETGAB for an exclusive offer. That's G A B B dot com forward slash get gab. Gab: Tech in Steps. Independence for them, peace of mind for parents. Your call has been forwarded to an automatic voice message system.
44:56 Speaker 02 A missed call doesn't feel like anything. No red flag, no notification screaming at you. It just disappears into your call log. And nine times out of 10, that was someone ready to hand you money. That's why today's episode is brought to you by QUO, spelled Q U O. The business phone system built so you never miss a call. Here's what I like about it. All your calls, texts, and voicemails live in one place, so anyone on your team can pick up a conversation, see the full history, and respond fast. No more, "Wait, who talked to this customer last?" And if you're worried about after-hours leads slipping through, QUO's optional built-in AI agent can answer questions and even book appointments while your team's offline. It's the number-one-rated business phone system on G2,
45:40 Speaker 02 and over 90,000 businesses already trust it to stay reachable. Money is on the line. Always say hello with QUO. Try QUO for free. Plus, get 20% off your first six months when you go to quo.com/tech. That's Q U O dot com slash tech.
46:07 Speaker 00 The Dominion Police was an old force founded in Canada in 1868 with a mandate to guard parliament buildings, protect government leaders, gather intelligence on enemies of the state, and later, arrest counterfeiters. But in late May of 1918, the Dominion Police were given a new role: enforce the controversial Military Service Act. The Canadian public generally supported the war effort, but on the ground, many were growing wary about the increasing amount of Canadian casualties with no end to the fighting in sight.
46:48 Speaker 00 Young men were becoming decidedly unenthusiastic about signing up to go to war, so the government introduced conscription to force them. The Military Service Act required all able-bodied Canadian male citizens aged 20 to 45 to sign up for the draft, and the Dominion Police were reformulated to track down anyone who should have signed up but didn't. These people were referred to as deserters, pacifists, and draft dodgers. As John Wilson learned the ropes of his new job, he penned a stream of love letters to Jessie. He used them to garner sympathy from her
47:31 Speaker 00 because he also had to provide some kind of explanation for his sudden absence. He wrote that he'd fallen sick again and was in a medical tent recuperating from a lung ailment.
47:44 Speaker 06 Dearest, if only you knew how miserable it is here for me alone. A chum with no one, and every night when I go to the tent, I wonder if there is any other person in this world with as few friends as I have. Jessie, I would gladly give my life any time if it would help you any. You are all I have in this world to care for, and I love you with all my heart. You have been the kindest friend I have known since Mother died.
48:13 Speaker 00 Of course, John made no mention of the fact that he was living in Regina with his actual wife, who he had just conceived a third child with. In fact, the letters John wrote to his teenage mistress Jessie suggested that physical intimacy was not yet a part of their courtship. In one love note dated June 18, 1918, John wrote:
48:38 Speaker 06 "I will kiss you this time whether you slap me or not."
48:41 Speaker 00 In another, he wrote:
48:43 Speaker 06 "What a pleasure it will be to love and to care for you and never to be parted till death comes."
48:51 Speaker 00 Poetic and sensitive as these letters to his teenage mistress might have been, John continued to be inconsiderate and disrespectful with his wife. He never wanted to be seen with Mary outside their apartment during the daylight hours. The way he treated her was so callous that even their boarding house landlady was shocked. According to another Royal North West Mountie memo, the landlady quote:
49:20 Speaker 07 "Noted that Wilson very seldom took his wife out, and when he did so, it was always in the evening and they would walk towards Wisconsin Park, apparently avoiding public spaces."
49:31 Speaker 00 John would later admit that he was a jerk and his poor treatment of his wife was because he was struggling internally. He quote "couldn't keep away from Jessie Patterson." Mary had no idea why her husband was so moody and distant, but that was soon to change. One day, after he'd hung up his coat and made himself scarce, her eye was drawn to something near his coat pocket. There was an open letter bulging from it, practically begging Mary to read it. So, she did. To her shock, it was a love note to her husband, from someone named Jessie, who didn't seem to know he was married.
50:16 Speaker 00 Mary confronted John, who confessed all, well, sort of. Yes, he and Jessie had a relationship, but he explained that Jessie was just a foolish young woman who mistook friendship for love. He had no clue as to why she thought he loved her romantically. John promised Mary he would sort things out and make sure Jessie knew for sure that he was married and off limits. Mary was hopeful for a time, but she soon found another love letter from Jessie and realised her husband had been lying. Shaken, she commiserated with their boarding house landlady, who felt very sorry for her.
50:59 Speaker 00 That summer of 1918, Mary started to sink into a deep depression.
51:07 Speaker 00 Meanwhile, John busied himself with his duties with the Dominion Police, while maintaining a steady correspondence with his "wee girl" Jessie, who was now training to be a nurse in a Prince Albert Hospital. In one letter, he told Jessie that his boss had praised his skill in rounding up eligible young men who were trying to avoid the draft.
51:32 Speaker 06 When we left Regina on Tuesday, we were going to raid the German wedding at Humboldt and then come on to Prince Albert. But when we got to the dance at 11:30pm, we got only seventeen of them and found there was from twenty to thirty in the bush, so we had to wire for armed soldiers.
51:51 Speaker 00 Because John had been deemed unfit for duty multiple times, he was thrilled to be able to finally make himself useful for the war effort. In a follow-up letter to Jessie that August, he offered another disturbing anecdote.
52:08 Speaker 06 I have to attend several big cases in the city police court on Thursday as two of our men were trying to arrest some Germans, and the Huns used guns in evading arrest, but they are all safe under lock and key now. Jessie, you might think sometimes that I am a big silly, but dearest, I just love you with all my heart.
52:29 Speaker 00 Jessie wrote back, telling him that she was heartbroken. For starters, she wasn't feeling well, but her mother had asked her, "Why couldn't she just marry someone else?" The lack of divorce papers had become a major issue that was driving a wedge between Jessie and her parents. Once again, she insisted that John finally produce the divorce paperwork as promised.
52:58 Speaker 00 That summer, John also wrote to his relatives back in Scotland, asking for money that he said was to buy a house for Mary and their new child. Mary's sister Elizabeth and her husband Archie, once devastated partners in that greenhouse business fiasco, generously sent John £100, but were disappointed when he never wrote back or acknowledged it. As it turned out, no house was ever purchased. John did, however, buy Jessie a car, which pleased her greatly.
53:39 Speaker 00 John actually had another opportunity to end his money troubles. He had been offered a promotion as chief inspector with the Dominion Police in Saskatoon, and it came with a $200 a month raise. In a letter to Jessie, John bragged about the possible promotion.
53:58 Speaker 06 Nothing but death can separate us now.
54:02 Speaker 00 But he decided not to take the job. John had always been obsessed with money, but in this instance, he'd had a rare moment of self-reflection and decided he just wasn't qualified. He was offered another posting in Saskatoon as a sub-inspector, which he accepted. John Wilson left his pregnant wife Mary in Regina and moved to Saskatoon. He promised her that he would buy some property and set up a home for them, and then he would arrange for her to join him there and they would start their new life together. He also wrote a creepy follow-up note to his mistress Jessie, referring to the then
54:44 Speaker 00 18-year-old as his "little girl" and promising to buy her a ladies' gun.
54:55 Speaker 00 Sergeant John Wilson did not excel as a sub-inspector for the Dominion Police for several reasons. For one, he was boozing openly on the job. He'd always liked a good drink, but his escalating alcohol habits had been noted by many of his colleagues. They also noticed that when John collected fines from men who violated the Military Service Act, those fines had a way of vanishing before making their way to the central bookkeeper. If John was aware that his colleagues were on to him, it did not change his actions. And he remained lovestruck, penning countless letters to Jessie and Prince Albert where she was nursing.
55:40 Speaker 00 And one, he mentioned the possibility of buying a wee cottage for the two of them once they were married. When he wrote to his pregnant wife Mary back in Regina, John mused about getting a nice three-roomed house for their growing family. There was no mention about their two eldest children back in Scotland, though. Finally, Mary received the letter she was waiting for. John was ready for her to join him in Saskatoon. He asked her to catch a train north to the town of Colonsay, about 70 kilometres away
56:23 Speaker 00 from Saskatoon where he would be waiting for her. Because Mary was by this point about six months pregnant, John told her to leave her luggage behind in Regina and they'll have it sent later. He also had some advice for her. As you'll remember, Mary was known as Polly to close friends and family.
56:45 Speaker 06 You will need to wear warm clothes, Polly, as it is cold driving, but it is not so very bad in the car and that will be better than you waiting for me in Regina and wearing your life out. I remain your loving husband, John.
57:03 Speaker 00 A week before Mary was to catch the train, John took his new car, the grey Dart, in for servicing. The morning of September twenty-seventh, the day that Mary was to catch the train from Regina, he suddenly contacted her by phone with a last-minute change. He asked her not to get off the train at Colonsay Station, but instead, continue on and get off at Saskatoon Station. Mary agreed. John spent the morning at the office and then headed to a retailer called Wheatley Brothers, described in the 1915 Saskatoon Directory as 'jewellers and opticians and issuers of marriage licences'.
57:49 Speaker 00 John had no interest in gems or glasses. He wanted the marriage licence. He told the clerk he was an unmarried bachelor and wrote the name Jesse Patterson on the form as his wife-to-be. With the marriage licence in his pocket, John got back in his grey Dart and drove to the Saskatoon train station, where his real wife Mary would soon be pulling up in a train. He had already written to her to let her know that they wouldn't be driving straight to their new home in Saskatoon. He said they had one pit stop to make first so he could take care of some police business.
58:42 Speaker 00 The next morning at around 5am, a farmer located about fifty kilometres north of Saskatoon, near the sleepy hamlet of Waldem, was just waking up. His name was Isaac Newfeld and something caught his eye when he glanced out the window. There was a thick plume of smoke in the distance. He went about his business only to have a stranger start banging on his door around 5.30am. He opened the door to a tall, bedraggled man who seemed dazed and reeked of smoke. The stranger asked for a glass of water and after gulping it down, he said:
59:24 Speaker 06 "That damned car burned down."
59:27 Speaker 00 He blurted out his tale of woe, which apparently started earlier that morning. He said he'd been driving along a dark country road when his car suddenly caught on fire. He said he'd steered the car towards a bank at the side of the road, figuring there might be some water in the bank that could extinguish the flames. But instead, the car became embedded in earth and weeds, so he had to abandon it to get help. He walked up the road to the nearest farmhouse, and here he was. The farmer wasn't quite sure what to make of this. He would say that this stranger acted kind of like he was drunk or had been drinking.
1:00:12 Speaker 00 The man appeared to be alone, and didn't mention that there was anyone else with him. Isaac was wary but gave him the benefit of the doubt, and agreed to accompany him to the crash site, a kind gesture, given how busy area farmers were. He would recall that as they walked down the road, the stranger seemed kind of nervous. About half a mile down, they came across a smashed and still burning grey dord. Here's how Isaac would describe it, as noted in a police report.
1:00:48 Speaker 07 Car was on wheels, but one wheel, the front one, was broken. All seats and upholstery were burned and windshield broken. There is some brush nearby, grass about one and a half feet high in the culvert. Top of car was not up. He said he was in the car when it went over the grade. He was not hurt, apparently. I saw no blood around where he might have cut his hands. His hands were all right. He said his overcoat was burned.
1:01:14 Speaker 00 The smoke from the car fire began attracting more people, including some farm labourers from nearby who showed up to gawk and find out what happened. One of them would say:
1:01:26 Speaker 07 We asked the owner of the car how he got in that position, and he said he looked round to the back of the car and saw fire, and at that time accidentally switched off the grade. I saw the tracks where he switched off. The tracks for about a half a mile down the road south were going all zigzag across the road. The zigzags on the road were large and showed he was going awful fast.
1:01:47 Speaker 00 It didn't go unnoticed that the man originally told farmer Isaac Newfeld that he intentionally steered off the road. He clearly wasn't thinking straight, and they would all tell the police that he acted as if he were drunk. They watched as the man went to a part of the car that wasn't on fire, grabbed a spade, and babbled as he started tossing shovelfuls of dirt on the blaze to smother it. He informed those gathered that he was a member of the Dominion Police in Saskatoon, and as for the cause of the car fire, he stated that he must have put too much gas in the tank back in town, and the fuel that dribbled out then combusted.
1:02:31 Speaker 00 The farmers didn't buy it. They might have been considered simple rural folk, but they were observant witnesses who quickly picked up on this Dominion Police officer's weird behaviour and inconsistent recollections. One of the farm labourers would tell police that the story didn't seem reasonable or believable.
1:02:54 Speaker 00 At that time, Isaac Newfeld's brother Jack, another farmer who lived nearby, drove up in a car and joined the group. He'd been drawn over by the smoke still billowing into the air. He got out of his car and walked over to the dramatic scene: a man furiously shoveling dirt on a burning vehicle. He recognised that man. It was Sergeant John Wilson, one of five Dominion Police officers who dropped into his place about a week earlier asking for gas, saying they'd come from Blaine Lake. And here he was again, with his car burning. Despite the weird stories and behaviour,
1:03:37 Speaker 00 Jack Newfeld generously invited the sergeant over for breakfast. John put his shovel down, grabbed a suitcase and shotgun from the vehicle, then got into Jack's car.
1:03:51 Speaker 00 When the car pulled up outside the home, John slammed open the car door, stumbled out and threw up on the lawn. The farmer noticed his face was white and he looked pretty sick, but he soon righted himself and they went inside for breakfast. John told the farmer he had to get to Blaine Lake as soon as possible to testify at a trial. There was no trial. He wanted to get married as soon as possible to his secret teenage fiance. Jack Newfeld agreed to help him out and give him a ride, possibly to get rid of him. The farmer brought along four of his older children,
1:04:34 Speaker 00 all six of them packing into the vehicle for what must have been an animated drive to Blaine Lake. On the way, Jack's adult daughter Katie glanced at John Wilson's satchel and saw some stains that she instantly recognised as being blood. She asked him how they got there. He told her he'd killed some geese.
1:05:00 Speaker 00 Back at the crash site, some of the farm labourers had also heard John mention something about goose hunting and tossing a trophy bird in the car. They would tell police that when they glanced inside the burning car, they saw some shotgun shells and a suitcase on the back seat. But none of them saw or smelled any sign of a dead bird.
1:05:33 Speaker 00 We'll continue to unravel this story in part two, starting from when John Wilson is dropped off in Blaine Lake and what he does next. And back in Scotland, what Mary's family decides to do when they notice she has suddenly gone radio silent.
1:05:51 Speaker 00 All comments and dialogue were real, thanks to Scottish voice actor Paul Warren, who provided the voice for Sergeant John Wilson. And Jessie Hawke, our production assistant, just happens to be Scottish and agreed to voice the letters written by Mary's sister Elizabeth. Special thanks to them both. Part Two will be released to all in a week, and if you subscribe to one of our premium feeds, it's available ad-free right now on Amazon Music, included with Prime, Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast. For more information and for the full list of resources we relied on to write this series, visit canadiantruecrime.ca.
1:06:35 Speaker 00 The podcast donates monthly to those facing injustice. This month, we have donated to Women's Shelters Canada, an organisation that supports over 600 shelters across the country for women and children fleeing violence. You can find a shelter near you by going to sheltersafe.ca. Special thanks to Danielle Parry-Di for research, and Nate Henley for additional research and writing. Check out Nate's highly-regarded true crime books, including The Beetle Bandit, which won the Crime Writers of Canada Award of Excellence for non-fiction. There's a link in the show notes.
1:07:15 Speaker 00 Audio editing was by Nico from The Inky Paw Print, aka We Talk of Dreams, who also composed the theme songs. Production assistance was by Jessie from The Inky Paw Print, with script consulting by Carol Weinberg. Script editing, additional research and writing and sound design was by me, and the disclaimer was voiced by Eric Crosby. We'll be back in a week with Part Two. See you then.
1:08:08 Speaker 00 The youth mental health crisis is growing, and social media is a major driver. Kids are spending up to nine hours a day on screens, often unsupervised, and studies show a direct link to anxiety, depression, and even suicidal thoughts. That's where Gab comes in. Gab offers safer phones and watches for kids with no social media, tailored to every age, offering the right tech at the right time, or Tech in Steps. From GPS-tracking-enabled watches for younger kids to phones with parent-enabled apps for teens, each device allows kids to more safely grow their independence. Visit gab.com/getgab and use code GETGAB for an exclusive offer.
1:08:49 Speaker 00 That's G-A-B-B dot com forward slash get gab. Gab: Tech in Steps. Independence for them. Peace of mind for parents.
1:09:00 Speaker 02 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings. Go to shipstation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.
Previous Robert Pickton: The Final Chapter [5] Next The Twisted Story of Sergeant John Wilson [2] Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated