Skip to content

Unlocking Hidden Histories: Eric Marcus, Executive Director of Making Gay History, on the Power of Storytelling

The Brand Called You

32m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Eric Marcus, historian, journalist, and executive director of the Making Gay History podcast, joins the host to discuss the craft of oral history, the power of marginalized voices, and how personal backgrounds shape storytelling. Drawing parallels to Studs Terkel's work, Marcus explains how he began collecting the forgotten stories of LGBTQ pioneers in the late 1980s, turning fragile cassette tapes into a global archive. The conversation explores the hidden influences of intergenerational trauma, the emotional architecture of effective interviews, and why understanding the past requires listening to emotional truth rather than expecting rigid factual perfection. They also examine the current political landscape, the recurrence of backlashes, and the importance of learning from previous generations.

  • When conducting interviews, stay with the emotional through-line instead of rigidly following a prepared list of questions. 9:38
  • In oral history and personal testimony, emotional and psychological truth matters more than strict factual accuracy. 10:49
  • Audio recordings capture nuances like silences and vocal emotion that get lost when testimonies are transcribed into print. 16:34
  • Sharing first-person historical narratives helps younger generations realize they are not alone and provides a roadmap for resilience. 22:04

Chapters

  1. 0:08
    Podcast Intro and Host Background

    The host introduces herself, her upbringing in Clifton, NJ, and her passion for theater and storytelling.

  2. 1:25
    Introducing Eric Marcus and Making Gay History

    The host presents Eric Marcus, his early work with oral histories, and the founding of the award‑winning podcast.

  3. 2:11
    Studs Terkel Influence on Marcus’s Work

    Eric explains how Studs Terkel’s methodology inspired his own oral‑history approach and the creation of his book.

  4. 3:09
    Interview Strategy: Eliciting Authentic Voice

    Marcus discusses his techniques for drawing out genuine stories without losing the interviewee’s voice.

  5. 4:24
    Personal Trauma and Hyper‑Awareness

    Both speakers reflect on intergenerational trauma and how it shapes their sensitivity to hidden stories.

  6. 8:03
    Secrets, Truth, and Storytelling Tactics

    They explore how indirect questions and emotional follow‑ups help uncover deeper truths in interviews.

  7. 10:49
    Historical Accuracy vs. Emotional Truth in Oral History

    Marcus explains why memory and feeling can be more important than precise facts in telling history.

  8. 12:04
    Cultural Differences in Story Reception

    Discussion of how American listeners differ from international audiences in their expectations of factual accuracy versus emotional truth.

  9. 22:30
    The Power of One Story to Inspire Others

    Examples of how a single testimony can spark connection and inspiration across generations and borders.

  10. 26:03
    Optimism Amid Backlash and Future Outlook

    Marcus reflects on past LGBTQ backlashes, current challenges, and his optimistic outlook for the movement.

  11. 30:42
    Upcoming Projects and Closing Remarks

    Marcus shares plans for new theater productions, animated shorts, and thanks the host before concluding the episode.

Highlights

  • 3:09

    Mining For Gold In Oral Historyinsight

    The guest explains how his editorial commissioning mirrored Studs Terkel's approach of mining long interview tapes to extract the best narrative without losing the subject's authentic voice.

  • 5:51

    Hyper-Awareness From Intergenerational Traumainsight

    Both speakers discuss how growing up with volatile, mentally ill parents and family secrets creates a hyper radar where children constantly check the temperature of a room.

  • 11:30

    Cultural Differences In Listening To Storiesinsight

    The host notes a distinct cultural divide where American audiences uniquely demand factual proof from performers, whereas foreign listeners are more comfortable with emotional truth.

  • 12:38

    Uncovering A Forgotten Prison Historystory

    The guest shares how a researcher discovered a forgotten 19th-century gay ward and holiday show at a men's penitentiary on Roosevelt Island, which inspired a new podcast series.

  • 16:39

    Capturing The Noisy Silence Of Traumainsight

    The guest reflects on discovering a powerful, audio-only tape where he unknowingly interviewed an activist shortly after the man received an AIDS diagnosis.

  • 19:43

    Tracking Down A Clinic Social Workerstory

    Decades after receiving an HIV-negative test result, the guest used a code number and a first name to track down the social worker who offered a kind gesture in a New York clinic.

  • 22:30

    Finding Connection Across Generationsstory

    A fifteen-year-old disabled girl in Moscow translated a historical LGBTQ transcript into Russian after finding deep personal inspiration in the life of activist Vito Russo.

Quotes

  • “I must have listened to it every single day for an entire year, because it was about ordinary Americans who were singing about their jobs and their lives in their own words.”
    Unnamed speaker · 0:41
  • “I found it very challenging. Like your mother, there are things you might not want to talk about.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:58
  • “Follow the emotion, because that's where you'll get interesting material.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:43
  • The Brand Called You 31:21–32:11

About this episode

In this inspiring episode of The Brand Called You, host Lisa Lipkin sits down with Eric Marcus, Executive Director of Making Gay History, journalist, podcast creator, and celebrated author. Eric shares his journey growing up in New Jersey, his passion for collecting personal stories, and his work preserving LGBTQ+ history through oral history and storytelling. The conversation explores the complexities of memory, truth, emotional authenticity, and intergenerational trauma, while highlighting Eric’s unique approach to interviewing people and uncovering stories that might otherwise remain unheard. Eric explains why following the emotional thread of a conversation can reveal deeper truths, how unexpected questions can unlock powerful memories, and why the human voice can communicate layers of meaning that written words sometimes cannot. He also reflects on the impact of personal testimony, sharing how stories can create connections across generations and continents. The episode further explores resilience, social change, LGBTQ+ history, and the importance of learning from the past while remaining hopeful about the future. Eric also discusses upcoming projects, including a theater production and animated shorts inspired by remarkable historical testimonies. Join Lisa Lipkin and Eric Marcus for a thought-provoking conversation about history, storytelling, authenticity, resilience, community, and hope. 🔔 Don’t forget to subscribe, like, and hit the notification bell for more powerful conversations from The Brand Called You.

Transcript

0:00
32:11

6,010 words · 3 speakers

Topics

  • Uruguay
  • Making Gay History
  • Working
  • PFLAG
  • Roosevelt Island
  • New York Post
  • The Fag Ward
  • PAC NYC
  • Good Morning America
  • American Foundation for Suicide Prevention

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated