Pod Insights The Brand Called You Interdisciplinary Engineering and Systems Thinking |Guru Madhavan, Sr Director of Programs, National Academy of Engineering About this episode In this episode of The Brand Called You, Guru Madhavan, Sr. Director of Programs at the National Academy of Engineering, discussed his career trajectory and key influences. He highlighted three inflection points: his early morning discipline from assisting his grandfather in a village temple, his engineering education emphasizing systems thinking, and a transformative anthropology course in grad school. Madhavan's diverse experiences include working in various industries, developing biomedical instruments, and leading vaccine development during crises like Ebola and Zika. He emphasized the importance of systems engineering, interdisciplinary thinking, and addressing "wicked problems" through a holistic, generative approach. 00:51- About Guru Madhavan Guru Madhavan is the inaugural Norman R. Augustine Senior Scholar and senior director of programs of the National Academy of Engineering. He is also founding director of the Forum on Complex Unifiable Systems (FOCUS). He has served as a technical advisor to the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services and the European Union Malaria Fund.
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hey Guru, thank you for coming in. You have an amazing background of accomplishment, dating back decades, a continuing self. So I appreciate you coming in and sharing your insights with our audience.
0:21 Speaker 01 Thank you, Stu, and it's a pleasure to be here. Looking forward to our conversation.
0:26 Speaker 00 So Guru, you know, what got you, or maybe let's reword this. I mean, you got this amazing career. I mean, it's outstanding, very unique, very distinguished across so many different domains and so much contribution. What were those three inflection points in your life that made you who are today? And I'm not talking later in your career. It's got to be things that happened when maybe when you're five or 10, maybe something inside the family, outside the family, perhaps things in school, and there may be some early career moves as well. So if you can go as early as possible, those things that really helped shape you to who you are today.
1:12 Speaker 01 But thank you. I've not been asked this question before, so this allows me to reflect a little bit. Let's look at a couple of inflection points in my life. And as my career has developed, as my understanding of the world has developed, and they have happened simultaneously. I think systems engineering is the kind of the identity and the background and the presentation and the philosophy with which I identify most. To do that, if we go back even to my upbringing in South India,
1:49 Speaker 01 I was born in an orthodox Hindu family, and I have a fairly unromantic entry into engineering, akin to an arranged marriage, basically, because everyone around me was studying engineering. So I too fell into it, and it was only years later, through practice and through a broader appreciation of engineering's cultural significance, so to speak, I actually fell in love with it. So it's marriage first, love later. And a couple of early...
2:24 Speaker 01 Influences, I'm happy to share here. First is when I used to be an assistant priest to my grandfather in our village temple. And these early influences and their value can be recognized only decades later, as you like to point out. So I'm happy to reflect here. I used to support him and we used to open our village temple early in the morning on 5:30 or so. And kind of that early getting up early in the morning. I mean, I still get up four in the morning and maintaining the discipline since that young age has proved to be vital. It's not necessarily an inflection point, but I think over time through an accumulated practice,
3:08 Speaker 01 it has turned out to be an inflection point because I've been able to create some productive hours upfront in the day. So let's just call it as a backdrop inflection. However, some of the professional influences I've gotten were all in engineering school. I studied instrumentation and control systems. So I was trained in the Newtonian paradigm of chasing efficiency and achieving perfection and pursuit for errorlessness, flawlessness and faultlessness.
3:48 Speaker 01 And a civil engineering professor told me to imagine a system far before it existed. So let's say you're imagining a bridge. You have to feel the load of the columns on your shoulders, so to speak, to get a visceral feel of what exactly you're trying to engineer. So in engineering, there's the concept of a mind's eye, which is mean to imagine a system before its existence. And that allows engineers to bring structure to situations where none exists. So, and I think that was an inflection point to see possible structures, possible patterns,
4:33 Speaker 01 and even possibilities in general on what could be done that is better than the existing scenario. So that's a philosophical take on what's otherwise a very practical point from the realm of engineering. Importantly, another transition happened when I became.
4:53 Speaker 01 Or when I transitioned rather from a Newtonian to a Darwinian. And that happened when I was in grad school.
5:01 Speaker 01 The in the United States. When I took a fluke anthropology course with an evolutionary biologist, David Slonbolson. And all the standard engineering courses were so popular, they were all sold out. So I had to take something to fulfill a requirement. So I ended up taking an anthropology course. While I was pursuing a PhD in engineering and an MBA. And that allowed me to bring in the evolutionary framework. How do you understand quote unquote, design from Mother Nature's perspective? And I know that's a very provocative word for some evolutionary biologists. Because Mother Nature doesn't really brute force design like engineers do. But still, there are aspects of
5:44 Speaker 01 the work that Mother Nature has done over billions of years that could be particularly valuable to the way we think about it. Of course, in engineering, we run our work based on schedule, technical requirements, cost and so forth. Mother Nature doesn't quite have those requirements. So how do you incorporate that kind of open, open ended, open minded sensibility into the heavily deeply constrained engineering practices is something was was a key influence in me becoming a broader thinker and a broader practitioner of engineering as it relates to culture and society. So those are somewhat three examples that I can share.
6:28 Speaker 00 So let's go go back again. I mean, as you were a young person, and this is in India, right?
6:36 Speaker 01 Correct.
6:36 Speaker 00 And
6:39 Speaker 00 were you were you speaking the native languages then? Or were you learning English at that time? What was your sort of the nature of your linguistic skills at that time?
6:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, so like many Indians, I know multiple languages, about five of them, I can recite in Sanskrit and what's comfortable in Hindi, Tamil and Kannada and a couple other languages I can just pick up. Um, and function, basically. So, well, Tamil and Sanskrit are two of the most complicated, two of the oldest languages in humanity. And I think getting an upfront start on that could have um, helped my interests in getting engaged with complex systems uh, at once. And and as I've grown in, uh, I mean, in India and I've lived in the United States for a couple decades.
7:33 Speaker 01 I go about translating uh, the concepts. And now I've reached a blur. I don't know what language I think in. Um, and uh, and what languages can do so for certain forms of thinking, whether if it is an artistic or poetic form of this. Of course, Indian languages are more helpful to me than the, let's say, the, the rational uh, way of approaching in which English becomes a dominant uh, theme and the frame uh, for my analysis.
8:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, in fact, maybe Tamil's even older than Sanskrit, isn't it? Uh, even predates Sanskrit. And those are very complex, difficult languages. And but it gives you access to a lot of ancient knowledge as well, right?
8:14 Speaker 01 Yes, and um, it's and that kind of takes me back to my upbringing and my grandfather had a particularly important influence on me, whose value I recognize only years after he passed away. What, five years ago, at the age of ninety-seven? And um, it's, I've uh, I've been grateful uh, to him in his absence now, uh, because.
8:44 Speaker 01 Some of the engineering concepts fusing themselves with the religious concepts as we took care of our temple. So when I was a kid, my grandfather would renovate the temple at a periodic basis. And I was part of it at least once or twice in this. So we had a temple for Vishnu, the maintainer in the trinity of the Hindu gods, Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. And so the temple of Vishnu and he would be, he would sit on his vehicle, which happens to be the eagle, another god. So Vishnu on sitting on an eagle and go around the village.
9:29 Speaker 01 And the entire village would contribute to the renovation of the temple. So there is this social capital involved in this. But I think the act of renovating is, again, engineering in this regard. So my interest in the philosophy and the policies for maintenance over years and how we as society needs to prioritize can be actually tracked back to my earliest years. And that's where your, your idea of bringing the linguistic approach to characterize such rituals. We have the, we have a term called jirno dharan in Sanskrit. Jirna means digesting. Udharan means advancing.
10:11 Speaker 01 So you digest and advance, digest and advance, much like how your body adapts to the, the various realities in which. So here, however, we're taking care of a temple and the biological metaphor from Sanskrit. And of course, there are concepts in Tamil as well that fuel in. So there's something about language, spirituality and engineering that has, that has some deep connection that we have forgotten to increasingly explore in recent years. And that's why some of my favorite places to go, whenever I go to India are temples that are thousands of years old and what led to them.
10:53 Speaker 01 So at that, if you look at the way I was trained as an engineer and the way I look at engineering systems now. It's quite different because these are not just structures, but they served a purpose beyond, let's say, the hardware. Um, I think it was a pulling together of community, whether it is for political ambitions, religious reasons and so forth. So engineering in this viewed this way is uh, a far ancient act of know-how than the sciences of know-what. So we were all engineers way before, as an original cultural choice, even before science and the practices and the methods for science even evolve.
11:37 Speaker 01 That's how I've uh grown to see engineering as I get older.
11:43 Speaker 00 Okay, so you're you're a very young man, you're five and six and and you have this capacity for different languages and including some of the most difficult languages, which gives you access to all of this ancient knowledge. And this intertwining between humanity and knowledge and spirituality and systems thinking. And and you're recapturing that. But and so in your and and you're helping your this family member from from a priest standpoint, right? And that would awaken you from a broader perspective, again, this kind of systems thinking. So at what age did you say to yourself, I want to be an engineer? I mean, what triggered that
12:29 Speaker 00 desire? Was it family or you just kind of self-initiated this sort of tendency towards? I I want to understand how things work. I want to understand, I want to also study the under underpinnies to make, become an engineer. You know, the mathematics, the physics and chemistry and so on, because initially as an engineer, you study everything. You specialize. So what what triggered your interest in that aspect? Um, and how early was it?
13:01 Speaker 01 I would say maybe after tenth grade, my interest got more serious. So maybe between like a fifth grade and tenth grade, I was just interested in exploring a range of things. I wasn't even particularly good in math in middle school. And I think I became better with the practice. Um, when I got to the high school level competition and of course studying in India and some of the schools that I studied in, it's intense, intense. And so, uh, my interest in physics and chemistry were enormous. Uh, I did very well in biology at the high school level, but of course I think I departed from there and I picked up computer science.
13:41 Speaker 01 Um, uh, as a, as a mode, um, to help me prepare for, um, engineering. But I think the biology would come back to bite me in a way, um, when I, um, did extremely well in my undergraduate degree. And I got one of the top ranks in the, in the state for biomedical instrumentation and everything. But I think I needed to get a deeper understanding of biology when I came to the United States, uh, to pursue a PhD in biomedical engineering. And which means I had, the last time, at that point, I had taken formal biology was tenth grade. And the people in my class, they were all like MD PhD students with like years of knowledge and practice.
14:22 Speaker 01 And I was basically failing the first half of the semester, uh, in the first year of my presence in this country. And the TA basically gave up on me, um, thinking that maybe you need to start memorizing this stuff, uh, to pass this course and so forth. Then the second half of the course contained electrophysiology, so balancing the equations came up and everything. And I think I, uh, I, I kind of got back up to speed and the professor was kind enough to curb everyone up. And so, uh, that's how I escaped the tragedy, um, potentially. Um, but then it was, as I mentioned earlier, it was the evolutionary perspective. Um, that I think took me away from the standard reductionist tendencies, um, to this.
15:07 Speaker 01 I think I was young enough not to understand, um, you know, the value and the limits of reductionist thinking and the value and the limits of, um, more comprehensive systems thinking at this stage. But I think comes to the, the bigger question, how do you? Can you teach systems thinking? Or does one gain only in practice? And that's a question we need to confront. I mean, I think as educators, as practitioners, and we don't have a clear answer to that yet.
15:40 Speaker 00 So let's mine this then. I so you. At the 10th grade, you you start realizing that you want to get into sort of the practical aspects beyond the curiosity across a broader range of kind of science related areas and and other areas, languages also. And and you get this taste of biology, but you end up getting into the kind of a systems engineering thinking. You get your masters in your PhD in biomedical engineering and MBA also. And then what was your first job?
16:18 Speaker 01 So I went through a number of professional experiences even while I was studying. So call it call me a junior engineer or project engineer. So I went through six different experiences. I worked for a fertilizer factory, worked in a power plant. And I worked at a at a a a transducer company and then a candy factory, believe it or not, which was one of my favorite and sweet experience, literally. And then eventually I found myself in a hospital when I had the first exposure to imaging. It was a brand new MRI scanner that was brought into and established in a hospital,
17:03 Speaker 01 and it was just a month or two old. And a kid was getting scanned for a brain injury. And I sat next to the imaging engineer and how the doctors were talking about it. And I had a. Kind of a inspired moment there about getting involved in radiology. So that really got me interested in it and that spiked my interest in specifically biomedical instrumentation. So I had some early industry experiences even while I was studying and so that was extremely helpful. After my masters, I found a job, selected to work for a startup company in the Bay Area.
17:46 Speaker 01 And it was a profound experience for me. It's a small company, four people and R and D team. And we were in a very dynamic market, trying to establish approaches to treat atrial fibrillation, which is the quivering of the upper tumors of the heart. And if you don't control it, treat it, you get some bad consequences like stroke and so forth. And it affects a lot of people in the United States. It can be pharmaceutically treated, but I think the market that we were in was like, how do you minimally invasively approach this? Because a prior approach was to cut open the chest and a surgeon basically cuts and sews the tissues and you create what's called a conduction block.
18:29 Speaker 01 So you're basically creating an insulation to prevent these bad rhythms to float across the cardiac tissues. And what can we do to make it better? And that's the standard engineering approach here. Okay, we know this, we don't know this. Okay, now what can we know a little bit more about what we don't know? And then try to make progress there. But then you have many different platforms. We specifically exploited microwave energy, much like baking a potato. We were baking cardiac tissues. And as someone with my background and a priestly background, I'm a lifetime vegetarian and I was doing animal experiments to the point that my colleagues started calling me a vegetarian butcher and to get some understanding of all of this.
19:14 Speaker 01 But I think there was also another influential moment there because I was involved in a surgery with a surgeon in Northern California and someone's heart just stopped during the surgery. And I'm in my twenties and I'm trying to understand the meaning between life and death. And as I'm trying to navigate into, let's say, more serious adulthood, I think that really kind of forced me to think hard. Now, how do I prevent these conditions from happening before? So microwave ablation techniques.
19:49 Speaker 01 Really became handy when surgical robots, the DaVinci robotic system came in. And I think the the procedures that would have normally taken four or five hours are brought down to an hour, hour and a half. And the very minimal side effects after the fact. And the competition with the other modalities like radio frequency, laser, ultrasound, cryo and so forth. Really fascinating market. And then that company got acquired by another company, a midsize company. And that eventually became part of Boston Scientific. So it was our excellent span of experience that I got. But then I came back to finish my dissertation in New York.
20:34 Speaker 01 And my entire lab moved from Long Island to upstate New York and to Binghamton, New York. And the difference there was, even though I easily transferred on there, was there was no medical school in upstate New York in the program that I was enrolled in. Whereas at Long Island, we did what instead they had was a nursing school, which give very different perspective or on horizon to think about care. And what it means to, let's say, engineer a system. You don't build a bridge for for a weekend or three weeks, but, you know, build it over thirty years. And how do you robustly maintain it?
21:13 Speaker 01 And I think that contained a far practical philosophy than, let's say, going through the surgical load that people encounter. So you can see there was in a phase one bioengineer, leading to a phase two bioengineer in me. And one was heavily physics driven and the other one was more formally biology driven. So there was so. That approach and I've been involved, I was involved also in consulting for companies in improving lower limb blood circulation through neuromuscular stimulation and so forth. So I've maintained my touch with the industry throughout. After I finished my PhD,
21:58 Speaker 01 I was selected again, very accidentally, for an economic policy fellowship in Washington DC at the National Academy of Sciences, which is my intellectual home fifteen years after. And that has given me the kind of the platform to conduct technical work on vaccine development and was fortunate to run a program for about eight years during Ebola and Zika crises. And I stopped that work just basically a year and a half, two years before COVID happened. And then I also did work on prescription drug pricing. So that's
22:39 Speaker 01 heavily political subject, at least in the United States. So my professional work has basically triangulated devices, drugs and vaccines. So largely medical products segment. And for the past now approaching six years, I've had a leadership role in the National Academy of Engineering, looking at how do you incorporate engineering and technology insights as advice to the federal government and also develop international, internationally relevant approaches to think about systems engineering possibilities for issues like how do you deliver on large engineering projects and mega projects? And how do you
23:23 Speaker 01 think about peace building? And how do you think about food and engineering, food and agricultural systems? So my horizon has significantly broadened over the past decade, but engineering remains the root.
23:36 Speaker 00 You know, there's so much here. I mean.
23:42 Speaker 00 You're a pre-senior degree and your advanced degrees, you end up working with a startup. And the startup is working in sort of this area of surgical catheters or cardiac ablation, and you talked about breakaways and then you get into numerous muscular stimulators for improving blood circulation. So you have this kind of direct application of engineering. And then you get into the vaccine and drug aspect, it's just like the biological aspect of of engineering in a very practical sense. But then you also get into kind of the economic
24:26 Speaker 00 side of it. I would say even some of the policy sides, and this comes now as director of programs of the National Academy of Engineering, which would look at kind of holistic solutions and ways to apply engineering principles, systems thinking to broader ecosystems or broader platforms like the federal government. And like you said, maybe this is adaptable to bring peace in some way, using engineering principles to to bring peace if you can talk to other engineering societies. It really consists of so many different disciplines. And I can see how now this maps to your degrees you have, but you have an MBA as well. And
25:09 Speaker 00 then, of course, you got into this very interdisciplinary thinking because of your childhood and and Indian culture and Tamil and Sanskrit.
25:19 Speaker 01 Exactly. I'm so glad you picked it up because that's something that I have very little conversations about. Maybe my early exposure to these very complex languages, which is exactly what I do in whatever meeting I go to. I'm constantly translating, interpreting them in many different languages that I was kind of, you know, grew up in.
25:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, and so I can see this now reflected in things like the awards you win. Like you you got awarded the Edward Weisband Distinguished Alumni Award for Public Service of Contribution to Public Affairs. I can see how that weaves in. You got the I triple E Nobel Wiener Award for Social Political, uh, Social Professional Responsibility. Again, because of this interweaving, right? Uh, you got this Henry Lawrence Grant Medal for Business Leadership because you have this business element in there. You have um, this other, this Lofman uh, Great Box Award for Contribution to Health Technologies
26:22 Speaker 00 because you're doing that. The Alfred Goldsmith Award for Outstanding Achievement in Engineering Communication. Because you you're actually bringing communities along and you have to communicate the kind of work you're doing. You have the I triple E USA Award for Distinguished Literally, Literary Contribution Furthering Public Understanding for the Advancement of the Engineering Profession. Because you've written books like Applied Minds, Engineering State, and Wicked Problems, How to Engineer a Better World. Uh, so you're communicating and you're speaking on all of this kind of intersection. You're you're kind of like the poster child of interdisciplinary, uh, transdisciplinary thinking. And now you're, you know, you're a companion of the aeronautics.
27:07 Speaker 00 Where does that fit? Companion of the Royal Aeronautical Society? And and I I could see the member of the European Academy of Scientists and Arts because you bridge everything. But how does the Royal Academy or Royal Aeronautical Society fit into all of that?
27:22 Speaker 01 Now, that was a stunning um, um, shock and honor. Because my latest book, Wicked Problems, How to Engineer a Better World, features um, in a, in a parallel track, a protagonist who revolutionized aviation. And my interests increasingly are also like, you know, I, I wanted to pick up a subject I knew nothing about. Because most people read books on subjects they didn't know something about. So you're, I picked up something entirely new and it's also, it's a book dedicated to Benhamton. Um, and the protagonist is from the Benhamton, Edwin A. Link, Ed Link.
28:02 Speaker 01 And he pioneered the very first flight trainer, what in our modern parlance we call a flight simulator. And It, he issued specialties and you were talking about, we were talking about interdisciplinary earlier and EdLink is, I think, a mega poster child of disregarding disciplinary thinking and really coming up with some core competencies that allow people to cut through complex systems here. EdLink was very interested in aviation as a kid, but his family discouraged his interests and learning how to fly.
28:44 Speaker 01 And we're talking about now 1920s, basically a century ago, was a very expensive endeavor and a very costly endeavor even in life and limb as well because how do you, they used to charge hundreds of dollars, which, that's worth thousands of dollars here. It is an expensive hobby. But then EdLink was inspired to, you know, working in the piano factory that his dad ran and gets the idea for using the suction mechanisms, but that was widely applied in
29:21 Speaker 01 player pianos and theater organs and so forth that EdLink worked on directly. But to use that phenomena to provide a feel for how you go for an airplane without leaving the ground. And, and so it's risk-free, yet you get the same experience of flying an airplane. That's how that technology enabled the training of cadets of US and British armies during, and then the World War II's collective cost of it can only be imagined without flight trainers, even the original moonshot in the 1960s.
30:02 Speaker 01 And without flight simulators, we can even think of the global cultural connectivity even with the level of aviation traffic and expectation to perform reliably come up. So that's why in aviation, when something goes wrong, it's punished heavily because it's a very unforgiving business. So that's why training to, training for it is, I think, as important as anything.
30:35 Speaker 01 Anyone can, or let me put it this way, um, making ten thousand aircrafts is a very different endeavor than making ten thousand qualified pilots to operate them. And that kind of gets us to, you know, why education is such a tough business in society. So Wright Brothers, um, duly so get all the recognition for showing us how to fly. Um, but Ed Link pivotally told us how to train uh to fly, which is as important as the act of flight itself. So that's why I got very interested in Ed Link's story and I think it got recognized by the aeronautical society uh for that.
31:16 Speaker 01 And the more and more talkable to be, but Ed Link is such an unrecognized figure in this world. Yet, without him, um, we wouldn't be where we are with the modern aviation and surrounding commerce.
31:30 Speaker 00 You know, this kind of reminds me, there's these kind of fundamental principles of life. Uh, and it's sort of the root of innovation and and successful innovation, and that's constantly asking questions, uh, running experiments on the edge, you're kind of at the, at the, at the boundaries, because that's how you uh stretch. So stretch goes encompassing within the questioning and running experiments. And then, um, but observing uh different circumstances from different diverse points of view. And and again, looking at the boundaries of these across many, many disciplines. And then part of that is cognitorial thinking. In other words,
32:14 Speaker 00 you're, you see fits pieces here on the left side, in the middle, the right side, and to the and you, you look at how are they relating to each other? Can I combine them in novel ways? And that's what you're illustrating, all of this kind of cognitorial thinking, so question, observe, and experiment, associating, and and forming relationships and and novel ways and cognitorial thinking, which is what your whole background is about. And so that's evidence here in this story. Now, you, you wrote this book, Applied Minds, How Engineers Think. So how do they think?
32:48 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, I could even call how engineers should think, but that won't go too well. But it comes down to the theme, which I posited as modular systems thinking, understanding the world in pieces and in combination, which you had beautifully alluded to. But the three attributes that drive that kind of, you know, gravity toward understanding or engaging with the world, or first seeing it's bringing structure where there's none. And second is the ability to design under constraints, which, I mean, without constraints, one can even argue there is no engineering.
33:30 Speaker 01 And third is the ability to prudently make trade offs. In life, you can't have everything. And I think that is more salient to realize in the act, in the practice, in the responsibility, in the accountability of engineering. And I think that's why we are so practical creatures. Yeah. I mean, sure, there's the value of idealism in engineering. But still, ultimately, the damn thing has to fly at the end of the day reliably and safely.
34:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, with the, with the, and these are not just technically constructed requirements. These are socially mandated expectations. And in that regard, I think that's why engineering is peer reviewed by reality. And as I said, it is, I think, one of our oldest cultural choices. And I think that's where I'm increasingly trying to find myself. I mean, I find myself in situations where there's this duty to articulate this important element that's kind of, engineering forms a society and society shapes engineering.
34:51 Speaker 01 It is such a synergy here.
34:56 Speaker 01 It's unavoidable, unignorable.
35:01 Speaker 00 I mean, it's kind of a delicate balance, though, right? You know, being sort of governed by constraints and yet not letting that fetter innovation. I'm just thinking of Elon Musk, right? I mean, he innovates in an unconstrained way and yet there are constraints, but he does it in a way where it goes out the boundaries of what normal people would typically or typical engineers would think is possible. And then he people go, wow, he did that. He got the that giant spacecraft that was grabbed by these pincers. And I mean, he's constantly innovating in a way that are at the at the boundaries of constraints, right? So I mean.
35:44 Speaker 01 You're right. I mean, I think, how do you build that bridge between your cognition to culture? Or in this case, cosmos, rather. I mean, like, so it's very interesting. I mean, in my first book, I think I talk about how you work backward from an ideal design. You imagine this vast prairie of possibilities, and then you add constraints after constraints after constraints. Then you come down to like, you know, basically a block on Fifth Avenue in New York. And that's a very different set of constraints from there to here. And that happens in your mind. And that goes back to the concept of the mind's eye. What an engineer sees it?
36:25 Speaker 01 How do you feel that stresses and strains on your on your shoulders for the bridge that doesn't exist yet? And then you work backward. And worse, how do you, after the bridge is built? How do you do continual environmental reviews, upgrades, upkeeps and everything while the traffic is running? And in one of my recent pieces, I talked about the reengineering of this bridge in New York, the Bayonne Bridge. And how, when it was first built in the 1930s by Atmar Aman, the legendary engineer, who built multiple bridges in New York City that we now, well, including George Washington and Verozano Bridge. So this Bayonne Bridge was built under budget, under schedule in the 1930s.
37:09 Speaker 01 There were no seismic requirements even back then. Uh, and now they tried to um modify the bridge. Because the bridge's vertical um height uh was not conducive to the ships that were bigger. Um, so especially with the widening of the Panama Canal, you got bigger ships um coming to the New York region. And some of the bridges need to be retrofitted so that they could go through. So they needed to raise the bridge by several feet and they had multiple options. One was to either like build a tunnel, get rid of the bridge, build a tunnel. And that would cost billions of dollars over some years.
37:50 Speaker 01 The second one was to like, you know, maybe come up with a hybrid bridge, maybe use this um. Um, then create a a cable stayed model and so forth. And the bridge wouldn't look beautiful. It was going to be awkward looking, but still would serve the purpose. And the third was like, um, people thought, maybe why don't we build another roadway on near the apex of the bridge? Kind of thing. So now you're building a bridge within a bridge. While keeping it open to traffic. Now, this is, this is what the modern life engineering is because we are so constrained here. Um, and someone actually compared it to conducting open art surgery on a running patient. Uh, with the, with all the cranes and the staging operations and everything.
38:33 Speaker 01 And of course, the with the reduced impact on local resident life. And lo and behold, uh, there were some rare uh birds that came a couple of times a year for nesting under the bridge. So the environmental review alone takes like, you know, five years, millions of dollars. And has to uh involve stakeholder consultation with like three hundred different groups. And has to go through special reviews and everything. This is modern day engineering. Like when, when we go on a highway or when we go on somewhere and we are complaining about orange cones on this. I mean, oh, my God, there's so much traffic. I, you know, hate going on this road and everything. That's engineering trying to improve um our quality of life in in their own way. So that's how deeply constrained we are.
39:18 Speaker 01 I call them, unlike the grand challenges, which kind of pushes to the frontiers of uh innovation. These are the grind challenges, um, which are the kind of the mundane, um, frustrating acts. Um, of bureaucracy, um, and.
39:38 Speaker 01 Care work, standards work and everything that people don't pay attention to. But that's as important as others. Most of the engineers, but seventy percent of engineers are actually involved in operations and maintenance, such as the acts that I just talked about. A very minority of engineers are involved in innovation, the kind of the disruptive work that we frequently associate engineering with. Both are important, of course, but one gets more credit and more spotlight than the other. One is sexy, the other is vexing. So now the question is, how do you think about what what does the politics of recognition, even the identity, this tension between visibility and invisibility that drives engineering? It's something we need to think about.
40:23 Speaker 01 And how do we bring people into engineering? And how do we communicate engineering? And with the the increasing emphasis on diversity, equity and inclusion, are we maybe excluding people from engineering if we just emphasize one act over another, which might be more fruitful, more supportive of the civilization that we live in?
40:50 Speaker 00 So we're running to the last few minutes of our interview, but I want to tackle maybe three or four additional topics. One of which is wicked problems, how to engineer a better world? Can you describe some concepts in there or how to engineer a better world? So that's one question. And then I'd like to get into your the founding director of the Forum of Complex Unified Systems or FOCUS. So what are your goals and can you give me maybe an example with the area? And then the kind of the the sort of third part is, you know, you served as technical advisor to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the European Union Malaria Fund.
41:35 Speaker 00 So where does that connect? And then, of course, so there could be too many questions in the remaining minutes. And the other one is your final recommendation to the audience, enter questions to the audience. But first of all, Wicked Problems, your book, right? How to engineer a better world? Can you, can you give some insights from that book?
41:54 Speaker 01 Sure, let me reverse the order, Steven, if that's okay with you, because I think, let's start with the HHS and the European Commission, and this was an opportunity that I got, represented the National Academies for my work on vaccine development. So my work was primarily funded by the Department of Health and Human Services of the United States, and we created a systems analysis platform to prioritize new vaccines for development instead of telling what the government should be prioritizing in a rank ordered list, which gets quickly outdated.
42:31 Speaker 01 And we saw that, especially during Ebola crisis, when we had actually vaccine candidates for Ebola, but they were shelved for commercial reasons, low profitability, low incidence. But then, when the epidemic started in Africa, it created a global commotion around that subject, and then we didn't have viable vaccine candidates at that point. So how do you prioritize those things is something important? So I helped the government
42:58 Speaker 01 and went to the European Commission to look at malaria candidates using a systems analytic approach. In one case, we developed a software system for it that was eventually field tested in multiple countries, in Africa and Southeast Asia. And the malaria fund work cut through the COVID crisis as well. So there were
43:27 Speaker 01 potential candidates looking at combination malaria Ebola vaccines and so forth. But they were unsuccessful at that time, but because we didn't fully understand COVID at that time. So, so that's the gist there. The second is, let's say, the forum on complex unifiable systems. And
43:49 Speaker 01 Which is a program that we created at the National Academy of Engineering, where I'm responsible for all the programs. Our programs are guided, again going back to how we started the conversation, by three basic themes: people, systems, and culture. And there's a parallel to that. You know, it's like, it's... The basic idea there is engineering for people, systems, and culture alone isn't sufficient. You've got to focus on the people, systems, and culture of engineering. How do you make the profession itself more welcoming to the widest range of philosophies, perspectives, and participants? So the systems theme directly connects with the focus program, which I've led, and it uses systems engineering as the kind of the base
44:33 Speaker 01 to begin exploring the adjacent possibilities of what it is. I mean, there are hundreds of ways my colleagues do cost-benefit analysis. This is cost-benefit analysis. You put a dollar in the numerator and you put a benefit measure in the denominator. Out comes a number to rank something, whatever. That's being done in many different ways. Even for a ratio, we don't have a common approach in our complex world. So how do you think about the many interconnections that we are subjected to and that affect our performance? So this program is very open-minded in terms of taking on these big problem sets
45:15 Speaker 01 and try to bring in the systems engineering attributes to better guide our discussions. And it is discipline-agnostic. We have had forums with philosophers, to people who study failures in education, to refineries and so forth. So very broad-minded program. That, of course, ties in closely with my book itself, and I think one forms and informs the other, so to speak, here. And as you can see, the systems engineering theme deeply linking each of these works. So my latest work, and I talked about Ed Link, who is the protagonist in The One Track. So his life is used as an archetype
46:01 Speaker 01 to elaborate on what wickedness means when it comes to engaging with problem sets. It begins with the problem. Engineers love to call themselves as problem solvers. That's where the trouble begins. And I'm very proud of the fact, and I was indoctrinated that very way. But that's where the trouble begins. Because we cannot run around and say that we can solve wicked problems, which means you're only dealing with an aspect of the problem. The wicked problem, much like a nested doll, is composed of what you call a hard problem, which are bounded and boundable. And they can actually succumb to solutions. We have a number of things. If you use a QR code to order tacos, or you're checked into a plane using your phone.
46:44 Speaker 01 Those are all hard problems with solutions. You have then soft problems, and soft is just in the name. They're actually harder problems than the hard problems. Because making a car is a hard problem, but managing traffic is a soft problem. And that brings together a whole range of issues, including economics, like congestion pricing. I mean, it's only effective if people can afford it. There are bridges in New York that charge 25 bucks each way, the Varazana Narrows Bridge, that is. Some people can afford it, many cannot, which means you have to deal with the different type of problem set and everything. So the problem really becomes something else. So that's a soft problem, and you cannot really solve it.
47:28 Speaker 01 You can only resolve it, which means you don't have a perfect situation for it. You can only take it to a good enough situation. The third problem is a messy problem, where our value sets, our deeply held ideologies, convictions, beliefs,
47:48 Speaker 01 play a major role in it. We were talking with Ebola earlier, and the example that I like to use here is like during the epidemic, we neglected the early stages of the epidemic. That is, we neglected the role of cultural practices in the spread of the epidemic, specifically burial rituals. People touched the deceased, they kissed, they bathed them and everything, not realizing that was a source of transmission. And so you couldn't just go into a community with deeply held religious practices and tell them not to do. So how do you then create a more dignified ritual that's acceptable by the community?
48:33 Speaker 01 That goes beyond tech.
48:37 Speaker 01 So how do you reframe the problem out of existence so that the local community actually sees the value in it? And that's the area where engineers are, I think, least experienced in at this point, and we have much more work to do. So unlike a hard problem that can be solved, unlike a soft problem that can result, a messy problem can only be dissolved, which means you have to transform it to a different manageable state. Now wicked problem emerges when the hard and the soft and the messy interact. They conspire to produce something different, which means you have to solve, resolve, and dissolve simultaneously. And we don't have that experience, and it has to, it has to be trained much like how pilots got the experience in a flight trainer.
49:22 Speaker 01 There are a lot of things that they can control, but Mother Nature has a mind of its own. So this allows one to fly under conditions where the terms are set by nature. So this allows us to engage with the problems in their terms, not ours. So, and I think how do you take that more generative approach is the substance of my book.
49:50 Speaker 00 It's fascinating. In the world, there's messy and wicked.
49:54 Speaker 01 Increasingly, increasingly, and you had asked me to share a thought for the listeners here. There's a word, there's a word that has really.
50:06 Speaker 00 So it could be a final recommendation and or question to the.
50:09 Speaker 01 Sure, okay. Let's offer a suggestion then. I mean, there's a word that has really been in my mind.
50:18 Speaker 01 And that relates to our cultural pressure, commercial pressure, to pursue a single action item to implement. This is something that we're all, there's some, the, the, the kind of the push to come down to a single action item. The word that's related to this monocausal taxophilia, which is our addiction, addiction for single point explanations for everything.
50:51 Speaker 01 And.
50:55 Speaker 01 How do you overcome that addiction while managing the side effects? This is something we need to keep in mind.
51:04 Speaker 00 That's a good thought for the audience. You know, Gauri, I really enjoyed this really far-reaching interdisciplinary discussion where you clearly are a master across many different areas and continuing to grow. Because you're you're part of this universe, which is always so dynamic and you're always so changing. So, thank you for coming in and sharing so much of your wisdom with my audience.
51:32 Speaker 01 Stephen, thank you very, very much. It was a joy.
51:36 Speaker 02 Thank you for listening to the brand called You videocast and podcast. A platform that brings you knowledge, experience and wisdom of hundreds of successful individuals from around the world.
51:49 Speaker 02 Do visit our website, www.tbcy.in to watch and listen to the stories of many more individuals. You can also follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Just search for the brand called You.
Previous Leadership and Consciousness Integration | Aang Lakey, Founder, Increasing Next Navigating Real Estate and Entrepreneurship | CEO & Founder of Charioteer Capital Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated