Pod Insights The Brand Called You Exploring the Cosmos: Prof. Neil Comins, Professor of Physics & Astronomy, University of Maine, USA About this episode Dive into the mysteries of the cosmos with Prof. Neil Comins, Professor of Physics & Astronomy at the University of Maine, USA, in this illuminating episode of The Brand Called You, hosted by Ashutosh Garg. In this thought-provoking conversation, Prof. Comins shares how personal adversity shaped his journey into astrophysics and why he chose to specialize in general relativity—one of the most challenging fields in science. The episode explores:Common misconceptions about galaxies and the Big BangThe search for life beyond Earth using the James Webb Space TelescopeAncient India’s remarkable contributions to astronomyIndia’s growing global role in space researchThe transformative impact of artificial intelligence on astronomyThe scientific foundation behind his bestselling “What If” books
Transcript 0:09 Speaker 00 Welcome to another episode of The Brand Called You, a podcast and podcast show that brings you leadership lessons, knowledge, experience and wisdom from thousands of successful individuals from around the world. I'm your host, Ashutosh Garg, and today I'm privileged to welcome a very senior and respected professor from Maine, USA, Professor Neil Cummins. Professor Neil Cummins, welcome to the show.
0:33 Speaker 01 Thank you. It's an honor to be here.
0:35 Speaker 00 Thank you. Neil is a professor of physics and astronomy at the University of Maine in USA. Given the amazing work that he has done over his life, understandably, he has been recognized, felicitated and awarded several times, and he's a published author of several books and articles. So Neil, before we come to astronomy and some of your books, a few questions for you. You began your academic journey in engineering physics at Cornell and eventually earned a PhD in astrophysics and general relativity in Wales. What first drew you toward astronomy and the cosmos?
1:12 Speaker 01 Well, it's probably not the reason you might think. When I was a child, I was severely abused by my father. My physical and emotional self-images were terrible. So when I went to university, I decided to see whether or not I really was, you know, a worthy person. And so I did many physical things. I became a pilot, a skydiver. I sailed in oceans. I even raced against Prince Charles once. And I then, in the intellectual realm, I took so many courses at university that I finished in three years, but I stayed on for a fourth
1:56 Speaker 01 year of graduate courses. And then I...
2:01 Speaker 01 Decided I I was doing okay, you know, I was. But I needed something to finalize my self-image. And that was I decided the hardest possible subject that I could take. That's what I wanted to take, and that was general relativity.
2:20 Speaker 00 Wow.
2:21 Speaker 01 So I I got my PhD. I presented my work to Stephen Hawking. And in nineteen eighty-three, punchline here, nineteen eighty-three, Subramanian Chandrasekhar earned the Nobel Prize.
2:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:36 Speaker 01 In physics.
2:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:37 Speaker 01 And in his nineteen eighty-three lecture, he cited my work.
2:43 Speaker 00 Amazing. Congratulations. Incredible. But what an incredible journey you've had. And, you know, I've met so many people, not someone who decided I'm going to start the most difficult topic and then win so many accolades there. So tell me, Neil, what have been some of the most rewarding moments from your life as an educator and a communicator?
3:09 Speaker 01 Okay, well, one of them was creating the book Genre Exploring What If Questions. The Washington Post called it a new genre back in the day. That was that was one of the very most rewarding things. Another was to have my first book, What If the Moon Didn't Exist, made into a theater show in Japan of movie type on screens all around the audience that played for seventeen years every day. So that was quite quite an honor.
3:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
3:47 Speaker 01 And another was discovering the importance of addressing misconceptions in science to my student audience and to the public. And there are lots and lots of, I've identified over seventeen hundred science misconceptions. And finally,
4:10 Speaker 01 for this for this list, having my book, Discovering the Universe. It's a textbook.
4:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:15 Speaker 01 Used in hundreds of universities and colleges around the world.
4:21 Speaker 00 Wow, wow.
4:24 Speaker 00 Let's now move on and talk about astronomy. And this is such a fascinating subject.
4:31 Speaker 00 The common human being, a common purveyor and listener, knows about astronomy, is fascinated by it, but not too many people know about it. And therefore, my first question for you, Neil, what are the biggest misconceptions people have about how galaxies form and evolve?
4:50 Speaker 01 Sure.
4:52 Speaker 01 Well, one of them is that the solar system is a galaxy. It's not.
5:02 Speaker 01 Another is that the Milky Way and the solar system are the same thing, which is related to the solar system being a galaxy. In our Milky Way, there are at least 100 billion stars like the sun. Another one is that the Milky Way is the only galaxy.
5:23 Speaker 01 There are at least 2 trillion, with a T, trillion galaxies. Another, galaxies are the largest groupings of objects in the universe. Galaxies are clustered together, and clusters of galaxies are clustered together. So,
5:41 Speaker 01 another is that galaxies only contain stars.
5:43 Speaker 00 Yep.
5:44 Speaker 01 But there's a huge amount of interstellar gas and dust in the galaxies. And another is that spiral arms, the Milky Way has spiral arms, are solid entities, you know, rigid things rotating, but they're not. They're made of gas and dust and stars, all orbiting around.
6:06 Speaker 01 Another is that the galaxies have formed at the beginning of the universe, the life of the universe. They didn't. The universe, the Milky Way galaxy, formed a billion years later.
6:17 Speaker 00 Wow.
6:20 Speaker 01 And the...
6:24 Speaker 01 Our solar system is only 4.6 billion years old, whereas our galaxy is 13.6 billion years old. And I could go on, but I'll stop there for a moment.
6:37 Speaker 00 But you know, given us a very interesting perspective. I mean, I didn't realize the Milky Way was almost three times older than our solar system. Thank you for telling us.
6:50 Speaker 01 Right, yeah.
6:51 Speaker 00 Neil, you've explored what life would be like in metapower or older universes. How close are we to identifying planets that could support life in such unfamiliar conditions?
7:06 Speaker 01 Oh, that's an interesting question. With the James Webb Space Telescope out there now, we are able to study the chemistry of planets. And we are beginning to discover chemicals in the realms of other planets like dimethyl sulfide, which are typically created by life. So if those gases are there, then maybe there's life that created the gases. Dimethyl sulfide is created by algae, marine algae, for example. So I would say that we're within a few years, a decade maybe.
7:51 Speaker 00 Yeah. You think it could be as soon as that?
7:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think so. I like to be optimistic.
7:58 Speaker 00 I agree. And I'm going to come to the big thing that's happening on the 3I Atlas, where people say maybe there's life, but that's, I'm going to reserve that for a little later in our conversation. Neil, you've spent years studying astronomy misconceptions, and you told me a few just now. Which misunderstanding is hardest to correct even among educated audiences?
8:19 Speaker 01 Oh, the hardest misconceptions that I can think of are that the Big Bang.
8:33 Speaker 01 Began at one point in space. In other words, when people visualize the Big Bang, they think it was here and then you could watch it and it grew like that. But it didn't. The Big Bang created space as well as matter and energy and time. So that's one of the hardest ones to correct. Another is that the seasons are caused by changing distance from the sun.
8:59 Speaker 00 Okay.
8:59 Speaker 01 Intuitively, most people think that when we're closest to the sun, it's honest.
9:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:05 Speaker 01 Right. And in fact, we're closest to the sun in December.
9:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
9:11 Speaker 01 It's the seasons are due to the tilt of the Earth's rotation axis. And another is, and almost everyone is taught this, that the the moon orbits the Earth. In the sense that if this is the Earth and this is the moon, the orbit of the moon is an ellipse around the Earth, and that's wrong.
9:35 Speaker 00 Oh.
9:37 Speaker 01 The two bodies are orbiting like this.
9:40 Speaker 00 Around each other?
9:41 Speaker 01 Yes, actually, there is a central point, which is about 1,067 miles under the Earth's surface in a straight line, not the center, here. And and as the two go around, they are going around that point.
9:58 Speaker 00 Hmm, wow.
9:59 Speaker 01 So.
10:00 Speaker 00 Wow. And I wanted to ask you a few other questions relating to, say, India. India has a rich legacy of astronomical thought. Which contributions from ancient India do you find most scientifically remarkable?
10:18 Speaker 01 Great question. How about, here are a few. The Earth orbits the Sun.
10:24 Speaker 00 Hmm.
10:25 Speaker 01 It used to be believed that everything orbited the Earth.
10:29 Speaker 00 Hmm.
10:30 Speaker 01 Another discovery by Indian astronomers is that the Earth rotates, spins on its axis.
10:39 Speaker 01 And the the shape of the orbits of the planets around the sun are ellipses, egg shaped, if you will. And why do eclipses occur? These were all discovered, identified by Indian astronomers. And interestingly, the concept of gravity. Ramagupta came up with this idea and it had not been around before the 7th century.
11:11 Speaker 00 Wow. Amazing, amazing. Modern observational astronomy in India is gaining global attention, Neil. How do you view India's role in today's astronomical research landscape?
11:25 Speaker 01 I I think the the Indian contribution is astronomical. Uh, so to speak. Uh, so here are some of the the things that India is doing right now. First of all, there are space missions run by the ISRO, Indian Space Research Organization. It has 133 missions at present.
11:49 Speaker 00 Got it.
11:51 Speaker 01 Among them is orbiting the moon. And the in 2008, that satellite discovered water on the moon. There's ice at the poles of the moon. It also mapped the lunar surface. Um, there is also in space a an observatory of the sun, Solar Observatory. Aditya L1, L1 stands for Lagrange Point. It's a place in space where the gravity of the earth and the gravity of the sun balance each other and the satellite stays there because it can't float away. It's pulled back by those two bodies.
12:35 Speaker 01 Uh, there's a fascinating, in my realm of general relativity, research for gravitational radiation. Gravity waves and.
12:49 Speaker 01 My thesis advisor led this for many years, but India is deeply involved. It's called LIGO, Laser Interferometer Gravity Observatory, Gravitational Radiation Observatory. And India is involved in that project, or has its own, actually.
13:11 Speaker 00 Right.
13:12 Speaker 01 There's also a 30-meter telescope that is being planned to be put in Hawaii on Mauna Kea. And then Jean Narlikar's work on cosmology is bringing us new insights all the time. Also, Indian astrophysicists are studying stellar evolution, black holes, and supernovas.
13:46 Speaker 00 Wow. And as telescopes like Hubble and James Webb redefine our understanding of the cosmos, what unanswered question in astronomy do you think we are closest to solving?
14:04 Speaker 01 Do you want one or a few?
14:06 Speaker 00 Give me a few.
14:07 Speaker 01 All right. Are there any other planets in our solar system besides the eight we know of and Pluto? There may be planets out beyond Neptune that are so dim that we haven't been able to see them yet. So that's one of the things, and people are looking for them. Another related topic is in orbiting other stars. Are the planets orbiting, and we know there are planets, by the way, are the planets orbiting in similar orbits to what is going on in our solar system with our planets? Or are they completely distributed differently?
14:48 Speaker 01 And if they're distributed differently, how would those different orbits affect the possibility of life? Because life would have to occur on a planet where the water can be liquid. And so that's a real issue. Couple others. What is the nature of dark matter?
15:10 Speaker 01 And dark energy. Dark matter is what is, provides the gravity that holds the Milky Way together.
15:18 Speaker 00 Right.
15:18 Speaker 01 Dark energy is what's pushing the universe out faster and faster all the time.
15:24 Speaker 00 Amazing.
15:27 Speaker 00 How do you see artificial intelligence accelerating discoveries in astronomy from data analysis to simulation modeling?
15:38 Speaker 01 Absolutely. You've covered it right there.
15:43 Speaker 01 The data analysis sets.
15:48 Speaker 01 AI can look for things like supernovas and exoplanets and things that are changing brightness, we call them transients, much, much faster than we can in any other way. And they can also look for things that have never been seen before. So in other words, they have a list of the features that they should see out there. And if there's something that isn't in that list, they might discover it and they can do it much, much, much faster than we can without them. They also can do, as you said, large computer simulations of evolution of galaxies like
16:30 Speaker 01 the Milky Way, collisions of galaxies, things like that. And a third thought is that they can be much more efficient in controlling telescopes that are observing things. Because the telescopes can start to drift and AI can be much more aware of what's going on and if it sees clouds, it can adjust things similarly appropriately and so on, more efficiently than any other way.
17:02 Speaker 00 Wow, what a great response, thank you. One more question and then I want to come to your books. Neil, there's been a lot of discussion about this interstellar object, Three Eye Atlas.
17:17 Speaker 00 I've been fascinated by astronomy because I spent seven, eight years in aerospace. Not that I know too much about it, but I love to read or listen to podcasts about it. I wanted to ask you, you know, this Three Eye Atlas has generated significant scientific interest. What does this interstellar body tell us about the nature of interstellar visitors, if any? And how might such objects reshape our understanding of the planetary systems beyond our own?
17:50 Speaker 01 That's a question which I'm afraid the answer isn't going to be as exciting as you'd like.
17:56 Speaker 00 I know.
17:57 Speaker 01 First of all, I should say that 3I Atlas is the third object from outside our solar system to pass in close to the sun that we have been able to detect. There have been many more, of course, but this is only the third that we've detected. The chemistry that we've seen of its atmosphere, the gases given off due to the heat from the sun, is very similar to the gases we see on comets that orbit the sun continuously.
18:32 Speaker 01 So those things are not providing insights into what's going on on other stars. I might add parenthetically that that object, 3I Atlas, has been traveling in space so long that we have no idea what star it came from, or what star system it came from. Furthermore, I should add that there are no signatures of life in the emissions from that object. So we just, you know, it's out there, it's interesting, but it's not telling us any
19:15 Speaker 01 profound insights into the evolution of the...
19:20 Speaker 00 Obviously, you know, the social media is full of exciting stuff, and therefore I thought I had to ask you, but thank you so much.
19:29 Speaker 01 No, that's fine. They are finding, you know, like water, ice and vapor and carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, but they're the same as in the comets in our solar system.
19:43 Speaker 00 Correct, correct. Neil, I want to kind of come to your books now. Your book, What If the Moon Didn't Exist, became a bestseller and inspired theater shows in Japan. What led you to explore these alternate universe scenarios?
20:02 Speaker 01 Great question. The backstory of this is that when my son James was three years old, he was pointing to things all the time and saying, what that, what that, meaning, what's that?
20:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
20:19 Speaker 01 And when he was four years old, the questions evolved from what's, what that to why, why, why, why? Why is the sky blue? Why does the ball fall? You know, lots of, and there were some interesting ones. When he was five, he evolved the questions to what if questions?
20:44 Speaker 01 You know, what, what if the sun was hotter? What if, you know, what if I hadn't fallen?
20:52 Speaker 01 Things like that. And when he was five, a colleague of mine, David Batouski, walked into my office one day and he said to me, you know, we astronomers are thinking about the cosmos too much the same, which is really bad English, don't get me wrong. But I said, I agreed with him and I said, okay, let's try to think of it differently. And my son's what if questions came to mind.
21:19 Speaker 01 And I grabbed the first what if question I could think of, which was, what if the moon didn't exist? Dave and I kicked it around for a while. He had to leave and I was hooked. And it's been what if ever since.
21:34 Speaker 00 Wow, wow. I must get a whole copy of this book and read it. Your next book was in what if the earth had two moons? Which scenario surprised even you when you first modeled it?
21:53 Speaker 01 That's an interesting question. I should add parenthetically that both of these books have ten scenarios in them.
22:01 Speaker 00 Okay.
22:02 Speaker 01 And the one that intrigued me most is what if the Earth was a moon of a larger planet, like Jupiter?
22:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:15 Speaker 01 What if Jupiter was orbiting where we are and we were orbiting Jupiter? How would Earth be different? And the answer is profoundly.
22:25 Speaker 00 Wow.
22:27 Speaker 00 Wow, amazing.
22:28 Speaker 01 I mean, I could obviously provide some of the insights, but I don't know how time would allow.
22:34 Speaker 00 No, I mean, give me one example, you know.
22:37 Speaker 01 Yes, sure.
22:37 Speaker 00 What would have happened if Earth was a moon of Jupiter?
22:41 Speaker 01 Okay, in that case, the tidal, the gravitational pull of Jupiter on the Earth, okay, would cause the Earth, which was spinning, who knows how it would be spinning, but the tidal force from Jupiter would cause the Earth's rotation to change so that the same side of the Earth always faced Jupiter. So people who lived on Jupiter's side would always see that big object in the sky. People who lived on the other side would never see it. And for example, you can imagine somebody wandering from one side to the other
23:24 Speaker 01 and seeing this big world for the first time.
23:27 Speaker 00 Hmm.
23:29 Speaker 01 So many possible.
23:31 Speaker 00 How interesting. I have two more questions for you, Neil. Many readers say your speculative writing feels like science fiction grounded in real physics.
23:44 Speaker 00 What boundaries do you set between imagination and scientific accuracy?
23:50 Speaker 01 The the the boundary is literally what the science says. In other words, if the science says that something is not possible, but one can express whatever that is, that's science fiction. To the best of my knowledge, to the best of my effort, all of the information in my books is based on science. So there isn't any any way that those, I hope, that those worlds couldn't exist. But they presumably exist somewhere else. And the chances are very good that they all do.
24:35 Speaker 01 So so that that's the separation. If it everything I write about is based on hard science. I can actually do the equations, blah, blah, blah, to to verify these things. And I do, and I do. But I do not include anything which is not scientifically possible, which is science fiction.
24:59 Speaker 00 So it's it's often said, and this is a very hypothetical question, but I've read a lot about it, is that somewhere in on some planet, in some part of the solar system, not our solar system, but somewhere in the Milky Way or the universe, there is another Earth in another time zone where there's another Professor Neil Comins and an Ashutosh Garg having an identical conversation. And I remember reading this as a science fiction sometime. Do you think that is within the realms of possibility at all?
25:33 Speaker 01 No.
25:34 Speaker 00 No.
25:34 Speaker 01 I I take it as pure science fiction.
25:37 Speaker 00 Okay, okay, thank you. And my last question to you. If you had to choose one more what if scenario for a future book, what would you like to explore?
25:51 Speaker 01 It would be, what if life was discovered on Mars?
25:57 Speaker 01 That would be what I would most like to explore. Because it's entirely possible it will be discovered on Mars.
26:08 Speaker 01 And what kind of life would it be? Would it be intelligent life, quote unquote? I don't think so. But there are more fundamental kinds of life that could exist. For example, in underground oceans.
26:24 Speaker 01 And what would be the consequences? For example, what would be the consequences of people migrating to Mars? And then interacting with these other forms of life, which our bodies had never experienced and never adapted to? Would they kill us off right away? Would it change the, you know, the people living there?
26:49 Speaker 01 Those kinds of questions.
26:51 Speaker 00 And I guess, you know, if Mars is colonized, as Mr. Musk keeps saying, it will happen. A new evolution will happen to the human species to adapt to life there. And we may just have a different set of human beings, the new life forms on another planet because we went to colonized. But on that note, sorry, go ahead.
27:13 Speaker 01 I was just gonna add, just briefly, that for those people who are planning to go, one of my other books is The Traveler's Guide to Space.
27:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
27:24 Speaker 01 And The Hazards of Space Travel is even another book, so.
27:28 Speaker 00 Amazing, amazing.
27:29 Speaker 01 There you go.
27:30 Speaker 00 Then I'm sure my viewers and listeners would love to pick up your books because they get a perspective of how deeply you have thought about it. But on that note, Neil, I just want to say, what a fascinating conversation this has been. You know, from the time you decided to get into this, from, you know, from the time you were very, very young and why you chose it to, talking about your son, who decided to, you know, point you in the direction of what if? And how you took it forward. Thank you for speaking to me about so many different aspects of astronomy. You know, I could just keep on learning and listening to you because you know so much. But I will reach out to you maybe in a few months and ask for another podcast
28:13 Speaker 00 or maybe on another subject on astronomy because it fascinates me. Thank you for speaking to me, sir, and all the way best to you.
28:21 Speaker 01 Thank you. It's been my pleasure. Great talking to you, Ash.
28:24 Speaker 00 Thank you.
28:26 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to The Brand Called You, videocast and podcast. A platform that brings you knowledge, experience and wisdom of hundreds of successful individuals from around the world.
28:39 Speaker 00 Do visit our website www.tbcy.in to watch and listen to the stories of many more individuals. You can also follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Just search for The Brand Called You.
Previous Curing Public Speaking Phobia: Insights with Robert Summa, Public Speaking Phobia Expert & Founder of Public Speaking Cure Next Forged in Crisis. Building the Future. | Ken Nguyen, Managing Partner, Pan Industrial Platforms Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated