Part Two: Heinrich Schliemann: The Archaeologist Who Destroyed Troy
Hosted by Robert Evans
- 44m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the destructive legacy of Heinrich Schliemann, widely considered one of the worst archaeologists in history. The host and guest examine how Schliemann became obsessed with proving the literal truth of Homer's Iliad, leading him to conduct reckless, high-speed excavations at Hisarlik in Turkey and Mycenae in Greece. Rather than practicing careful, methodical science, Schliemann used pickaxes to plow through millennia of irreplaceable human history, destroying the very layers of Troy he was searching for while discarding artifacts and fabricating stories to match his preconceived notions. Driven by egomania, racism, and a capitalist approach to antiquities, he cut out collaborators like Frank Calvert and even his own wife from the official credit.
Despite his abysmal methods and frequent forgeries or misidentifications, such as declaring a cooking pan to be Achilles' shield and a bronze hoard to be Priam's treasure, Schliemann inadvertently pointed future archaeologists toward the actual site of Troy. The episode highlights the painstaking decades of work required by competent scholars like Wilhelm Dorpfeld and subsequent Turkish archaeologists to try to undo the catastrophic damage Schliemann caused in his blind quest for fame and gold.
- Heinrich Schliemann divorced his wife in Indiana under false pretenses in 1869 solely to protect his wealth. 11:24
- Schliemann used an agent to select a 17-year-old Greek bride, Sophia Ingastrominos, based on her willingness to study Homer. 15:47
- Frank Calvert originally identified Hisarlik as the real site of Troy and provided Schliemann with the crucial guidance for the dig. 18:14
- Schliemann's savage excavation methods caused him to tear straight through the actual layers of Troy II and destroy historical strata. 30:45
Chapters
- 0:05Podcast Intro and Host Greeting
The hosts welcome listeners and introduce the episode’s focus on the destructive archaeologist Heinrich Schliemann.
- 1:06Schliemann’s Early Archaeological Ambitions
Schliemann’s fascination with archaeology after visiting Pompeii and his impulsive first dig attempt are described.
- 3:33Marriage, Divorce, and Personal Scandal
Schliemann’s manipulative marriage to Sophia and his use of American divorce laws to cheat his wife are revealed.
- 7:21The Quest for Troy and Legal Fallout
Schliemann’s partnership with Calvert, illegal digs at Hisarlik, and the Ottoman legal backlash are outlined.
- 10:05Racist Ideology and Personal Attitudes
Schliemann’s documented racism and disdain for non‑European peoples are exposed through his letters.
- 11:33Controversial Artifacts and Alleged Forgeries
Schliemann’s alleged forgery of the Agamemnon mask and the debate over the authenticity of his finds are discussed.
- 28:23Destructive Methods and Fabricated Finds
The podcast details Schliemann’s brutal excavation tactics, falsification of layers, and claims of Priam’s treasure.
- 48:54Legacy, Criticism, and Historical Impact
The episode concludes with reflections on Schliemann’s lasting influence, the loss of cultural heritage, and ongoing scholarly debate.
- 49:28Schliemann’s Reckless Digging and Money Focus
Schliemann’s obsession with spending and profit over archaeological rigor is highlighted.
- 50:14Wilhelm Dorpfeld’s Methodical Approach
Dorpfeld is hired to restore order, but Schliemann resists his systematic work.
- 51:55Schliemann’s Return for Royal Cemetery
Frustrated by critics, Schliemann returns to Troy to find a royal burial site.
- 52:27Dorpfeld’s Layered Excavation and Legacy
Dorpfeld uncovers Troy’s multi‑layer history, restoring scholarly credibility.
Highlights
- 4:46
Searching for Odysseus's Castleinsight
Schliemann visits Mount Athos in Greece and decides without any evidence that a small ruin was Odysseus's castle, unearthing funeral urns and a small shack.
- 11:24
American Citizenship for Divorcestory
Schliemann acquires American citizenship in Indiana by lying about establishing residence simply to exploit state divorce laws and cut off his wife from his money.
- 14:29
Schliemann tasks a friend in Greece with finding him a poor, well-educated teenage girl who reads Homer, eventually marrying 17-year-old Sophia Ingastrominos.
- 27:29
Savage Trench Excavationsstrategy
Ignoring professional advice to dig slow survey trenches, Schliemann arms workers with pickaxes and cuts a massive V-shaped trench straight through the center of the Hisarlik mound.
- 33:43
Discovering Priam's Treasurestory
Schliemann uncovers a major hoard of gold and silver artifacts, immediately declaring them to be Helen's jewelry and King Priam's treasure while undermining the fortifications.
- 36:46
The Mask of Agamemnoninsight
Excavating at Mycenae in 1876, Schliemann discovers a gold funeral mask and claims it belonged to Agamemnon, though modern research dates it centuries later and hints at forgery.
- 46:14
Erasing Collaborator Frank Calvertinsight
Schliemann famously cuts Frank Calvert entirely out of his published accounts and letters, refusing to acknowledge the man who actually led him to the site of Troy.
- 50:50
Wilhelm Dorpfeld's Stratigraphystrategy
Schliemann finally brings in expert archaeologist Wilhelm Dorpfeld, who begins the meticulous work of mapping the multiple distinct layers of occupation at Hisarlik.
Quotes
“He hasn't taken any classes. He just kind of watched a guy and decided he was too slow.”
Robert Evans · 4:37 “Schliemann's methods were savage and brutal. He plowed through layers of soil and everything in them without proper record-keeping.”
Robert Evans · 28:23 “Their pickaxes and shovels obliterated history. In his diary, Schliemann wrote, 'Unfortunately, we are obliged to destroy the foundations of a building 59 feet long and 43 feet broad.'”
Robert Evans · 31:24 “His relations with even his closest friends and associates remained stormy. At one time or another, he fell out with all of them.”
Robert Evans · 46:14 “Schliemann took from others liberally, but in essentials claimed credit for himself.”
Robert Evans · 47:02 “He made his return trip to Troy on March 1, 1882.”
Robert Evans · 49:42 “He does hire real archaeologists for this dig.”
Robert Evans · 50:14 “And Dorpfeld sets to work trying to figure out what's happening in this disastrous dig site Heinrich left behind years earlier.”
Robert Evans · 50:24 “He has a railroad constructed to the site this time, so that he can more quickly throw away dirt dug up in this quest.”
Robert Evans · 52:12
Sponsored segments
- Healthy Sexual from Gilead Sciences 1:02–1:36
- OnDeck 1:38–1:56
- Melissa Jelton 2:08–2:34
- The Devil's Quarry 3:15–3:20
- pushkin.fm 4:07–4:15
- OnDeck 22:07–22:36
- OnDeck 41:30–41:58
- Kristin Conger 55:02–55:17
- Cool Zone Media 56:12–56:31
- iHeart True Crime Plus 57:07–57:28
- iHeart Radio app 59:00–59:02
- The Black Effect 59:28–59:34
- Black Effect Podcast Network 59:42–59:47
About this episode
Robert concludes the thrilling story of how Heinrich Schlieman destroyed a crucial piece of our shared human heritage after purchasing a child bride. See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
10,831 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Troy
- Digging for Troy
- Hisarlik
- What Happened to Her
- Turkey
- Athens
- Mycenae
- The American Way of Killing
- Bloodline Crimes
- Naples
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated