FAN FAVORITE: Stonewall | Why Don't You Do Something? | 3

Resistance at restaurants in San Francisco and Philadelphia showcased the building tension as trans activists challenged long-standing policies of discrimination. But leading gay rights groups continued to stress a calm, non-confrontational approach to reform. That all changed in the early morning hours of June 28, 1969, when police raided the Stonewall Inn. For police, it was just another raid, but this time would be different: the Stonewall’s patrons would fight back. The clashes on Christopher Street would become an uprising against police oppression with long-lasting reverberations for the LGBTQ rights movement. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Lindsay Graham?

  Audible subscribers can binge new seasons of American History Tellers early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts. We are hard at work on our 100th season of American History Tellers coming up, but in the meantime, we're revisiting a fan favorite, our season about the Stonewall uprising. And for listeners who would like to learn more about queer history, we recommend the new Audible original, The Pansy Craze. In this six-part, live-recorded podcast-variety show, co-creator and host Mason Alexander Park transports audiences through time to tell raucous stories of queer history that none of us learned in school. You can listen

• 0:40Lindsay Graham?

  to The Pansy Craze right now, only on Audible. Imagine it's June 28, 1969, the blurry hours where Friday turns into Saturday. You're a young gay rights activist named Craig Rodwell, who runs a bookstore in Greenwich Village. Tonight, you're walking home down Christopher Street with your boyfriend Fred. Oh, it's crazy that it's this hot right now. What is it, 1:00 in the morning? We've only gone two blocks and, look, I'm drenched. Yes, it's hot. It's June. What's eating you? That whole card game, and you barely said a word. Bridge partners are supposed to help each other out, you know?

• 1:22Lindsay Graham?

  Ah, no, I'm sorry. I'm just not thinking about cards right now. Well, what is it? Say it. Don't stew on it. I just keep thinking about how they let that cop go free. He shot and killed a man down by the waterfront. Kill a gay man and you just get put right back in circulation. Oh, yeah, that. Oh, no, it's terrible. Yes, it is terrible. But it's all part of the same thing. Gay men are targeted every single day in the city, and there's no one to protect them. Who's going to police the police? You can't fight back. They throw you in jail. You can't cause a scene, you end up on an FBI list or something. But you're trying to help your magazine, your bookstore? I just don't know what good any of my help is doing. Even Mattachine, we're all just

• 2:05Lindsay Graham?

  taking these tiny little baby steps. But towards what? Well, acceptance, equality. Sure, but those are just words right now. If you just keep thinking about words long enough, they lose all their meaning. As you get closer to the Stonewall, you can hear faint traces of music coming from inside. There's a dozen or so people on the sidewalk just ahead of you, smoking cigarettes and chatting. Fred stops abruptly, though. Hey, hold up. Those cops in Christopher Park, see them? Over by the trees? In the darkness, you can just make out their figures, standing in the shadows near a streetlight. They're right across the street from the Stonewall. Just like a gang hiding in the bushes.

• 2:45Lindsay Graham?

  And just then, the whole group of police emerge from the shadows and hurry across Christopher Street to the front door of the Stonewall. Fred turns to you. I think we should get out of here. No, no, no. Wait, hold on.

• 2:58Speaker 01

  This is the police. This is a raid.

• 3:02Lindsay Graham?

  The small crowd of revelers on the sidewalk splits apart as the police force their way through the front door of the Stonewall. There must be at least eight cops. You can feel Fred next to you getting tense with anger. God, look at them, raiding another bar. Yeah, but something feels different about this. Some of the Stonewall patrons outside start to leave, but a lot of them haven't. They're standing around, not going anywhere. And then a police wagon rounds the corner. No siren. It comes to a stop in front of the bar. You don't know what's about to happen, but this is definitely a planned police operation. You turn to Fred. Okay, come here. Let's get up on this stoop. Five minutes. Let's just stay for five minutes. Fred reluctantly follows you up a few steps, and the two of you take a seat.

• 3:46Lindsay Graham?

  No one's leaving. You see that? They just cried out, "It's a raid," but no one's going anywhere. And it's true. Even with a police wagon pulling up to the curb, no one is going anywhere. There's a tension in the air, an odd feeling as you watch the crowd start to pace and jostle. This is different. This is something new. This might just be resistance.

• 4:14Speaker 02

  Raising Canes has one love: craveable chicken finger meals. And they do it better than anyone else. Hand-battered, cooked-to-order chicken fingers, legendary cane sauce made fresh every day, crinkle-cut fries, and buttery Texas toast. Simple, done right, and delicious every single time. Every meal is made with quality you can taste. The chicken fingers are always crispy, always hot, and always fresh. Pair that with a freshly squeezed lemonade or a refreshing sweet tea, and you've got yourself the perfect meal. Whether you're feeding your crew on game day or grabbing a quick bite, Raising Canes has you covered with tailgates of chicken fingers and cane sauce and meals the whole family will love. Order online at raisingcains.com. Raising Canes Chicken Fingers, one love.

• 4:59Speaker 03

  I'm Lauren Malloy, the host of the podcast My Mom's Murder. For 30 years, I thought my mom died of natural causes. That's what everyone told me. That's what I believed. Until one day, I got a phone call that changed everything. A woman claiming to be my mom's best friend told me my mother was murdered and that no one had ever investigated it. So I did what the detectives wouldn't: pulled the threads, knocked on doors, and confronted the contradictions. And what I found? It's worse than I imagined. Something happened to my mom. Someone killed her. And I won't stop until I find out who. The system may

• 5:42Speaker 03

  have given up on my mom, but I never will. Listen to My Mom's Murder wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all 10 episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts.

• 6:04Lindsay Graham?

  From Audible Originals, I'm Lindsay Graham, and this is American History Tellers, our history, your story.

• 6:26Lindsay Graham?

  By the mid-'60s, the civil rights movement, the anti-war movement, and the politics of what was being called "the new left" had energized the country. Police and protesters were confronting each other in the streets as news cameras rolled. But the LGBTQ rights movement still struggled to find its footing. Despite sporadic acts of physical resistance led by transgender activists and people of color, organizations like the Mattachine Society and the Daughters of Billitists continued to stress a calm, non-confrontational approach. By the summer of 1969, all that would change. Calmness and non-confrontation were failing propositions for many. Amid ongoing discrimination, anger was simmering, and it would take one

• 7:08Lindsay Graham?

  night at the Stonewall Inn for that anger to reach a boiling point. This is episode three, Why Don't You Do Something?

• 7:20Lindsay Graham?

  By 1966, New York's Greenwich Village, with its rich history of counterculture, had become one of the nation's biggest hubs of gay life. Tea rooms and coffee houses, night clubs and bars quietly served gay customers. But gay bars and clubs in particular were not just places to get a drink. They were rare safe spaces for LGBTQ people in the bustle of the city. And by the late '60s, these safe spaces had increasingly come under fire from New York City police. Police raided gay bars at will. Customers were lined up against the wall and asked to produce ID. Anyone without ID, or anyone wearing less than three items of clothing corresponding to their legal sex, would be booked and taken to the closest precinct station. Owners and managers of bars that were caught serving

• 8:05Lindsay Graham?

  LGBTQ customers could have their liquor license revoked and their businesses closed. Bars that survived the purge had to operate under constant fear of being raided or shut down. Anti-cruising practices were also put into effect. Bars and restaurants had to install signs that read, "Patrons must face the bar while drinking." The reasoning went that if gay men were facing straight ahead while sitting at the bar, they wouldn't be able to turn around and flirt with other men passing by. As head of the Mattachine Society in New York, Dick Leish had pushed back against these kind of rules. He and other advocates had campaigned successfully to get Mayor John Lindsay to promise to end one of the most aggressive and dangerous abuses known as entrapment. Next on Leish's list were the

• 8:47Lindsay Graham?

  problems facing owners of gay-friendly bars and their customers. But it wasn't easy for Leish and Mattachine to figure out how and where to even start their fight against discrimination. New York state liquor laws were complex and daunting. After hiring a lawyer to dig through the legal code, Mattachine discovered that it wasn't technically illegal for LGBTQ people to gather in bars. There was no law that flatly denied them service. But a bar could be shut down if its clientele became disorderly. That one word, disorderly, used in a broad and vague context held up the entirety of the state's ability to discriminate. And for Leish and his allies, it finally provided a focus for their strategy.

• 9:35Lindsay Graham?

  Imagine it's April 20, 1966. Around 3 o'clock in the afternoon, inside a Greenwich Village bar called Julius's. It's no longer lunch, not yet happy hour. You're a member of the New York Mattachine Society. Dressed in a blazer and tie, you and your colleagues could be any other trio of businessmen walking in for a drink. But you're actually embarking on an unusual kind of protest to draw attention to discrimination against the gay community by the New York State Liquor Authority. Behind you are a small group of reporters with cameras. You flag down the bartender. He walks up with a quizzical look in his eyes. Yeah, can I help you? Yes, we are homosexuals, and we would like a drink, please. It all started a week ago, when another bar in the neighborhood put up a sign reading,

• 10:20Lindsay Graham?

  "If you're gay, please go away." Because of a vague provision in the law banning disorderly conduct, the New York State Liquor Authority can shut down any bar in the city if it serves gay people. So your idea was to go to a bar in the village, announce that you were gay, and ask for service. Then, when you were denied, you could file a complaint against the State Liquor Authority. A lawsuit would force the city to defend its discriminatory practice out in the open. Okay, well, what will you gentlemen have? And there goes your plan. A city full of bars who won't serve gay people, and you get the one with an enlightened bartender. You lean forward, lowering your voice. Are you aware that this bar could get shut down just for serving us? Yeah, well, I mean, sure, but you know, your money's good here.

• 11:05Lindsay Graham?

  Just say no. I'll explain later. The manager looks at you and the gathering reporters. Are they homosexuals, too? They're from the newspaper. A worried look crosses the manager's face. Listen, I don't want any trouble. We're already facing a license suspension. Mattachine can help you with that. We can get you a pro bono lawyer, and the press on this will be great PR for you regardless. The manager thinks it over, while you continue to press your point. All you have to do is say no. The rest is on us. After all, you're just following the law. And after a long pause, the manager shakes his head. I'm sorry, gentlemen, I'm not going to serve you this afternoon, and I think it's the law.

• 11:48Lindsay Graham?

  You take a step back as the reporters move in to get a quote. One of them raises his camera and tells the bartender to cover the glass with his hand. Satisfied, you turn around to one of your companions, Craig. You weren't expecting to see him today. He quit Mattachine a while back when he got frustrated with how you do things. But when one of your fellow activists insists on bringing him along, you couldn't say no, and hoped he'd see how you and Mattachine are trying to move the needle. I think that photo's a good touch, right? I mean, a picture's worth a thousand words. It'll tell an obvious story. But Craig doesn't look convinced. Yeah, it might, but do you really think all this is going to change anything? I do. People need to know that New York is discriminating against gay people. A lawsuit against the city will make that public. What would make it public is getting people in the streets.

• 12:33Lindsay Graham?

  Oh, so you'd just like to start a riot? Craig throws up his hands in exasperation. No, you're not listening to me. People read a newspaper and they toss it away. People marching in the streets sends a direct message. You can't look away from that. Well, right up until the police show up, then people's lives are at risk. Yeah, well, at least we'd be taking the risk. What we're doing here... Craig gestures at the bar. What we're doing here is academic. You know, Craig, you didn't have to come. I do know. You didn't invite me. You turn away in frustration. There's no use arguing with Craig when he gets like this. For now, you'll continue with Mattachine to protest in a safe, constructive, legal

• 13:16Lindsay Graham?

  way. The newspaper coverage generated by Dick Leish and Mattachine's creative demonstration at Julius's, a tactic borrowed directly from the Black Civil Rights Movement, forced the State Liquor Authority into a corner. In 1967, the year following the sip-in at Julius's, a New York court decided that the State Liquor Authority could not revoke a bar's license on the basis of serving LGBTQ customers. It was a win for activists. But it was another bar entirely that would become a flashpoint between the city and the LGBTQ community in Greenwich Village. Since 1930, the Stonewall Inn, located at 53 Christopher Street, had been an Italian restaurant.

• 13:58Lindsay Graham?

  It was never an actual inn, just two doors and a pair of windows set into a brick facade that looked out into the street. Begone as a speakeasy and called the Stonewall, the name itself was a coded literary reference to lesbian love. As the decades passed, the two words were compressed into one, and the Stonewall Inn became a restaurant and bar with a hunting lodge decor. It was a popular venue for weddings, banquets, and other civic and social events. But after a fire, the restaurant was sold, and in 1966, four businessmen took over the property. $3,500 was all it took for the Stonewall's new owners to make slight renovations on the inside and clear out the space for dancing. To get around State Liquor Authority restrictions and to help legally protect themselves from

• 14:43Lindsay Graham?

  raids, the new owners declared the Stonewall a private bottle service club. Being a private club meant that, without a proper search warrant, even a police officer could be denied admission or thrown out. Still, the Stonewall's proprietors covered up and reinforced the front windows with plywood and two-by-fours. They also installed a set of steel doors behind the existing heavy wooden front doors in a safeguard against police if ever they decided to rush the place. And when the Stonewall opened its doors for business in March 1967, it became very popular very fast. Unlike many other bars serving gay clientele, the Stonewall was a large club on a main street, just across from Christopher Park and 7th Avenue, with a neon sign flashing.

• 15:26Lindsay Graham?

  At the front entrance, the Stonewall doorman would assess any approaching customer through a peephole. If you fit in, if you looked like you weren't a cop or a straight person, you would be admitted. Then you'd have to sign the guestbook, although fake names were commonplace. Once inside, you could purchase tickets that could then be exchanged for drinks at the bar. The lights were kept very dim, and the air would be thick with a mixture of cigarette, smoke, and perfume. Drinks were both watered down and overpriced, but the bar was often packed because of the two dance floors, each one with a lighting system and its own jukebox. Radio hits by bands like The Beach Boys and The Doors played in the front room, while the side room was reserved for soul and R&B singles from artists like Otis Renning and Carla Thomas.

• 16:09Lindsay Graham?

  One young gay Stonewall patron recalled that the first time he visited the bar, the most incredible sight was men dancing with other men. When I saw couples dancing together, I had such a thrill in my stomach, it was like an electric shock. Another Stonewall patron, Danny Garvin, recalled breaking his own personal taboos in the Stonewall's back dance floor. I was at the point that I would have sex with men, but I wouldn't kiss. I was still in the early stages of coming out. Then one night at the Stonewall, a man named Frank asked me to dance. I felt embarrassed and nervous, and I realized that I liked this guy. That was the first time I allowed myself to dance, to be part of gay life, to go ahead and kiss a man in public.

• 16:50Lindsay Graham?

  Raymond Castro, a 27-year-old Puerto Rican baker, remembered how safe he felt at Stonewall. Stonewall was a place where you could be comfortable being yourself. It was a place to meet your own kind and hang out with your own kind. It was refreshing to know you were not alone. We were all the same. That was comforting. But not everyone felt welcome. Some patrons recall that lesbians were often turned away for looking too straight. Others claim that transgender people were turned away. But for many, including writer and Stonewall patron Vito Russell, it was a bar for people who were too young, too poor, or just too much to get in anywhere else. Over the next two years, Stonewall grew more popular, nestling itself into the fabric of the LGBTQ community.

• 17:33Lindsay Graham?

  But beneath the nightly party, something else was going on. The four businessmen who had remade the Stonewall into a popular, dance-friendly venue were members of the Italian mafia, the Genovese crime family. The owners had provided a sanctuary for the LGBTQ community in the village, but they'd also created a trap where the mafia could turn huge profits by preying on their own clientele. Through blackmail and corruption, they were putting their gay customers at risk and threatening to bring down the bar that was quickly becoming a cornerstone of New York's gay nightlife. Inside a dive bar kitchen in upstate New York, the owner cracks open a box and discovers her chicken order misdelivered. All she has to work with are wings.

• 18:18Lindsay Graham?

  So with a little culinary genius and a dash of luck, the Buffalo Wing is born. Well, so the story goes, that game day staple has humble origins, but its popularity gave rise to two empires: Buffalo Wild Wings and Wingstop. Hey, I'm David Brown, the host of the podcast Business Wars. Every season, we bring you the true stories behind the companies that shape our world: their rivalries, their reinventions, and their spectacular rises and falls. Buffalo Wild Wings built a sports bar empire. Wingstop went the opposite direction, focusing on getting wings out the door. For years, Buffalo Wild Wings was the undisputed king, but when Americans started ordering in instead of going out, Wingstop was ready to tear down its rival. Make sure to follow Business Wars wherever you get your podcasts.

• 19:01Lindsay Graham?

  Audible subscribers can binge all episodes of Business Wars early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts.

• 19:10Speaker 04

  You stepped out for your morning jog. Except it's not your usual morning jog. You started listening to an epic sci-fi book on Audible. Thirty chapters later, you've accidentally run a half marathon. You've lost track of how far you've run, somewhere just past the city limits. You can't stop. You have to find out what happens next. Then it's over. The universe seems bigger. You feel different. You feel like you have no idea where you are. Audible: Stories That Speak to You.

• 19:46Lindsay Graham?

  By 1968, the Stonewall Inn had become central to the fabric of the LGBTQ community in New York. But for Stonewall's mafia owners, the steady stream of business only meant one thing: profit. With their rent hovering around $300 a month, the bar's owners were pulling in around $12,000 over an average weekend. The police crackdown on gay bars throughout the 1960s had created a vacuum that the mob was eager to fill. They found that the cops would look away for a price. Like many other gay bars in the city, the Stonewall made regular cash payouts to their local police precincts. Chuck Shaheen, one of the men who helped the Genovese family open the club, would later confirm that these payments were made on a regular basis, saying, "The police

• 20:29Lindsay Graham?

  were very much on the payroll of the Stonewall. Once a week, they would come by to collect. There were two envelopes, because in those days, there was an officer and that was his beat, and then someone in the precinct, usually the captain or the desk sergeant, would get an envelope." By some estimates, the payouts amounted to as much as $1,200 a month, nearly four times the rent, but merely a drop in the bucket when compared to the club's profit. For a long while, the Stonewall continued to make money off their LGBTQ clientele, and for the most part, neighborhood police kept their distance. The precautions taken by the club's mafia owners for their own protection, the reinforced steel doors, the blackout windows, the doorman, discouraged the cops. But they had the added

• 21:09Lindsay Graham?

  benefit of protecting the bar's patrons and concealing them from the prying eyes of passersby. In theory, Stonewall's customers were safer inside than at any of the other neighborhood bars. But mob protection came with trade-offs. There was no fire escape or emergency exit, and no running water behind the bar, toilets often overflowed. For Craig Rodwell, the sense of safety was merely a facade. He later told an interviewer, "Bars have always been our only place, our haven in a sense. I was always furious that the mob controlled so much of our social life. They liked our money, hated our guts. There was collusion between the cops and the mob, and we were caught in the middle all the time." The need for places where the LGBTQ community could safely gather meant that any gay club

• 21:54Lindsay Graham?

  that managed to stay open long enough would draw a crowd. Stonewall's crowd was bigger than most. Its patrons just had to settle for dirty and dangerous conditions, because there were simply no other alternative. It was around this time that the New York Mattachine Society discovered something troubling. They were getting phone calls from men who had fallen victim to what they described as an extortion ring operated by Stonewall's management. Stonewall's customers were being shaken down, tracked and followed to their homes, visited by mob enforcers pretending to be police. The enforcers would then threaten to out the victims publicly, forcing them to pay as much money as they could, often thousands of dollars, to keep their sexual orientation a secret.

• 22:39Lindsay Graham?

  Imagine it's the mid-1960s. You work for a large insurance company, one of the few in Manhattan. This evening, you've just walked into a small hotel room on a midtown side street. The room is featureless and drab, just like you feel. Glad you could make it. Not like I had much choice in the matter. The man you're here to meet is standing over by the hotel room window. You once thought he was handsome, but now you can't stand the sight of him. I've got some room service coming up in a second. My apologies, I probably didn't order enough for both of us, though. I'm not planning on sticking around. Here, here's your money. That's too bad, but I probably wouldn't want to stick around either if I was in your shoes. You're not in my shoes. The money's there, count it if you want, do whatever it is you do, then I'm gonna

• 23:24Lindsay Graham?

  leave. I'll count it in a second, but we need to talk about the next payment. No, this is it, this is all I have. You said that last month, and yet here you are with more. I can't get any more, this is it. My bosses aren't gonna like that. Maybe you should've thought twice before you picked me up down in Greenwich Village. I didn't know what I was getting into. Now you do. I understand. You don't want your family to find out. Don't you threaten them. I'm not threatening anyone. I'm simply telling you how it is. And I understand, if you can't get more, then maybe you can go back to the Stonewall some night and find yourself a young man, a young man with money, like yourself. Bring him back here. Tell him that you're going to need a payment from him. And if he doesn't pay, you'll tell his family, you'll tell his wife. You're disgusting.

• 24:09Lindsay Graham?

  Maybe. I'm just doing a job. I'm also giving you another chance. Look, if you can't find the money, and I don't care how you do it, we'll call your wife. We'll tell her where you hang out, who you hang out with, what you are. And that will be the end of it. Your awful secret will be out. This wasn't what we agreed to. She'll leave you, and she'll take the kids. She'll eat you alive in divorce court. Or you can keep coming here, once a month, and giving me the money I need. It's up to you. You bring your hands up to your face, rub your eyes. The world goes dark as you press your knuckles against your eye sockets. You made a mistake. Then you made an even bigger mistake by thinking you could buy this man's silence with a few hundred bucks.

• 24:53Lindsay Graham?

  This is your new reality: drab, featureless nightmare, and you can't see a way out. In 1966, The New York Times uncovered a blackmail ring that had swindled almost $2 million from several highly successful men. The victims included a member of Congress, two army generals, a Princeton professor, and a Navy admiral. The last of these, Admiral William Church, took his own life rather than testify about his sexuality before a grand jury. These stories were shocking, but even more shocking for some Stonewall patrons was that one of the extortionists named in The Times' expose was also the club's doorman. "Tip to the danger," the 1968 New York Mattachine Society newsletter

• 25:38Lindsay Graham?

  warned its readers that Stonewall's doorman, Ed Murphy, was in fact an ex-felon. In and out of jail his whole life, Murphy had been charged with larceny, extortion, and impersonating a police officer. Murphy pled guilty under a federal indictment to the extortion charges. But because Murphy had made a deal to provide the state with more evidence, his sentence was reduced to a mere five years probation. With just a slap on the wrist, Murphy had escaped any jail time and was now back on the street. Mattachine's newsletter reported, "Murphy has an interest in the Stonewall, along with several other gay clubs in New York. We caution our readers to never use your real name when cruising. And remember, that trick-or-hustler you just picked up may be working for the management."

• 26:21Lindsay Graham?

  But it wasn't just Stonewall's doorman, Murphy, extorting money. The scheme filtered down to Stonewall waiters and busboys as well. They targeted middle-class gay men who looked like they could afford to pay. Victims who could not pay were pulled further into the scheme and forced to turn around and blackmail other gay men. There was nowhere, it seems, where LGBTQ people could exist without having to look over their shoulders. Not Stonewall's dance floor, not the whole of the village. The extortion rings stretched all the way to Wall Street. According to one bartender who also worked as a page boy on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, the pickings were all too easy. Between the brokers, married and single, and the exchange employees, there were more gay men on Wall Street than

• 27:03Lindsay Graham?

  at any gay bar. The New York City Police Department had been willing to turn a blind eye when gay men were being shaken down at a nightclub. But the potential blackmail of Wall Street traders and bankers, even gay ones, was a claim they took very seriously. So seriously that the city police assigned a special team to the case. The leader of this team was a decorated deputy inspector named Seymour Pine. Just shy of his 50th birthday, Inspector Pine had been transferred to the Morals Division of the NYPD after a career spent fighting the mafia in Brooklyn. Pine's team was tasked with tracing the source of counterfeit bonds that had been appearing in Europe. It was thought that these forged bonds were coming from the mafia and that the extortion schemes on Wall Street could be traced right to the LGBTQ bars the mob owned in Greenwich Village. Pine's

• 27:48Lindsay Graham?

  commanding officer wanted these clubs shut down permanently. So Pine and his team began securing the proper warrants they would need to start raiding gay clubs in the village. The warrants would help them legally search the private clubs, and the other officers would train undercover. By the summer of 1969, Pine and his team had raided several bars, but turned up nothing. Then, late in the evening on Friday night, June 27, Pine and a small team of plainclothes police officers gathered in Christopher Park across the street from the Stonewall. Even though Pine had already orchestrated a raid on Stonewall just three days before, he decided to return. This time, his team would move in during prime time, after midnight on a Friday, when the club was at its busiest. A Friday

• 28:32Lindsay Graham?

  night raid would be a surprise to just about everyone, and perhaps his team could finally dig up something useful. But now Pine was nervous. He'd sent two female undercover officers inside around midnight. When they emerged from the bar, it would be a signal for the raid to start. That was well over half an hour ago, and they were nowhere to be seen. By 1:20 in the morning, Pine felt he had waited long enough. He and four officers strode across Christopher Street to the front doors of the Stonewall Inn, and then demanded to be let inside.

• 29:08Speaker 04

  Imagine you're reading Pride and Prejudice, except you're not reading it. Harris Dickinson and Marissa Abella are reading it to you on Audible. Her barbs sting you. His coldness sends a shiver up your spine. Your heart aches. Your ears burn. You yearn for Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy to profess their undying love for one another. You can't bear it any longer. Well, maybe a chapter longer. Performance is so good, you'll give love a second chance. Audible, stories that speak to you.

• 29:39Lindsay Graham?

  On January 1st, 1892, a young Irish immigrant named Annie Moore became the first person processed at the new immigration station on Ellis Island. For the millions who followed her, this small island in New York Harbor would become the place where their American dream would either begin or end. Hi, I'm Lindsay Graham, the host of the podcast American History Tellers. We take you to the events, times, and people that shaped America and Americans, our values, our struggles, and our dreams. In our latest series, we trace the history of Ellis Island. For more than three decades, it served as the gateway through which millions of hopeful immigrants entered the United States. But as the nation struggled to decide who belonged, some would find the gate shut to them. Follow American History Tellers wherever you get your podcasts.

• 30:23Lindsay Graham?

  Audible subscribers can binge all episodes of American History Tellers early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts. Friday, June 27th, was Yvonne Ritter's 18th birthday. She could think of no better way to celebrate it than with her friends at the Stonewall Inn. Ritter now identifies as a transgender woman, but at the time, she was still keeping her identity a secret from her parents. She'd taken to borrowing her mother's dresses, she'd begun saving up for gender confirmation surgery. That night in June 1969, she'd selected an elegant black and white stripe cocktail dress from her mother's closet. But wearing women's clothes in public still made her nervous.

• 31:08Lindsay Graham?

  Ritter knew that transgender people were often physically assaulted, but she tried not to dwell on it. She recalled later in an interview, "I was a big girl, so people didn't bother me that much." Still, leaving for the bar that evening, she kept a change of clothes with her in a bag, just in case. That night on the Stonewall dance floor, Yvonne lost all her nervousness. She could drink legally, and she was about to graduate from high school in three days. She was elated. She recalled, "I felt like I had finally come of age, that I was growing up, I was going to be able to finally live the life I wanted to live." By 1:20 in the morning, Yvonne Ritter was fully immersed on the dance floor as the Rolling Stones blasted from the jukebox. Then, all of a sudden, white lights flooded the room.

• 31:51Lindsay Graham?

  Confused, Ritter at first didn't realize it was a raid. Near the club's front door, Inspector Pine and a team of about a dozen officers shut off the music and instructed everyone to line up against the wall and produce identification. There were around 200 people in the bar. Ritter made a dash for the bathroom, where she knew there might be a way out through a window. She recalled, "When I stood on the toilet to get out, a policeman grabbed me by the leg. He told me I wasn't going anywhere. They pushed me up against the wall with the other people. Then we were herded to the front of the bar, along the wall that led to the exit door. I was frightened. I was young, and I was scared." Pine and his officers quickly began checking IDs. Several Stonewall employees were immediately cuffed.

• 32:33Lindsay Graham?

  Anyone who couldn't produce an ID, anyone looking under 18, and anyone who stood out because of their clothing, were also taken into custody. Yvonne Ritter recalls, "I was up against the wall with other transgender people and drag queens. We were taken aside from some of the other people and grouped together because we were not in the appropriate attire." Ritter was terrified that she would be arrested, and she was doubly terrified that a picture of her wearing her mother's dress might appear in the paper or on TV, where her parents would see it. As an officer led Ritter outside to the police wagon, she was thankful that at least she hadn't been handcuffed. She noticed that the air was just as hot and stifling outside as it had been in the club. She also noticed something strange.

• 33:15Lindsay Graham?

  Lots of other people had not been arrested, they were free to leave, but it didn't look like they were going anywhere. As Ritter waited for the police van to arrive, the crowd grew larger. People in the crowd were loudly complaining about their treatment at the hands of the police. Many were discussing the unjustness of the raids themselves. Others were striking campy poses as a demonstration for a growing audience of onlookers. The mood was shifting quickly from anger to theatrics, then back to anger. But still, no one was leaving. Inside the Stonewall, Pine noticed the same thing. So far, everyone had cooperated. Typically, the patrons of places like this would vanish into the streets as soon as they were released, but Pine noticed small acts of resistance bubbling up.

• 34:00Lindsay Graham?

  One of his officers shoved a woman, then she almost struck the officer back. He could hear voices in the crowd complaining loudly, one saying, "Why do we have to take this?" Outside, a police van had pulled up, but the crowd was still not dispersing. First, the police escorted the mafia employees into the back of the van. The crowd on the sidewalk began to cheer, or jeer, as the Stonewall management and workers ducked and climbed inside. But once the cops began to bring out Stonewall customers who'd been arrested, the crowd began to boo loudly. The cops had targeted mostly transgender people. Following at the end of the line, Ritter watched as some of the arrested patrons struck poses of their own on their way to the police van.

• 34:41Lindsay Graham?

  Even on their way to jail, they were resisting, and the crowd was feeding off of it. Soon, pennies began to ricochet off the side of the police van, thrown by people in the crowd. Others were yelling squarely at the cops, calling them pigs, while still others had gotten on one side of the police van and started to rocket back and forth. Some people began chanting, "We shall overcome." For Ritter, it was at this moment that something miraculous happened. As she was stepping into the police van, the police officer turned away. The van was already getting full, and the cops were distracted. Ritter quickly stepped back down onto the pavement and began to walk towards the crowd. She later recalled, "I was walking away, and the cop who put me in saw me. He said, 'Hey, you, come over here.'"

• 35:24Lindsay Graham?

  He was a young guy, and I begged him, "Please, it's my birthday, I'm 18, and my mother's gonna kill me." I was crying, and my makeup was going. The cop almost looked the other way, kind of gave me the hand motion, and I kept walking. I thought, "If he comes after me and grabs me by the scruff of the neck, he's gonna arrest me again." But he didn't. By the time Ritter got to the edge of the crowd, she couldn't believe it. She'd managed to escape. Outside, tension was building. As one of the police officers pushed a woman into the back of the police van, she turned around and hit him with her purse. The officer in turn hit her with his nightstick. At that moment, a voice rang out. The bystanders would later disagree whether it belonged to the woman resisting arrest or someone else. "Why don't you guys do something?"

• 36:08Lindsay Graham?

  The question was a call to action that lingered in the tense air. And then soon, people in the crowd began to act as one, rushing the police van as it drove away. Then, they rushed Pine and his officers, who remained on the sidewalk. The simmering anger had boiled over. Pine suddenly faced a very real problem. With the police van gone, he and his men were hopelessly outnumbered, pinned against the building, encircled by the crowd. Objects were being thrown, someone had found a pile of bricks. So the cops retreated back inside the Stonewall Inn, barricading the doors behind them. Imagine it's early Saturday morning, June 1969.

• 36:51Lindsay Graham?

  You entered the doors of the Stonewall a few hours ago, looking for a drink and a fun night out. Now, you're in handcuffs on the floor. Even though you showed ID, the police still cuffed you, but you put up a struggle, and they never got you into the police wagon before it left. Now, you can hear chanting from outside, and the sound of people beating on the front windows. But inside, the feeling is even more desperate. You can't see much, but you can hear cops talking to themselves. They sound panicked. From your position on the floor, you turn over to try and get a look at what's going on. There's a few other people like you, handcuffed and laying on the ground, or propped up on a couch. Only the cops are in motion. The very cops that just busted the bar, the cops that sent your friends off to jail, those cops are now stuck here inside with you.

• 37:35Lindsay Graham?

  "Hey, get me out of these cuffs, officer." The police have barricaded the front door with tables and chairs, but it doesn't look like that's going to hold out for long. "Officer, can you take these off? It's not like I've got anywhere to run." A nearby officer glances back. "Stay where you are, we're trying to get the situation under control." "Yeah, good luck with that." Suddenly, the officer is in your face. "Listen, those are your people out there. That's a mob outside, and they want to tear this place apart. A mob? You guys are the one busting up the place. We weren't hurting anyone. We're just fed up with being hassled all the time. We've had enough." Your argument is interrupted by the sound of smashing glass, and you see a glint of flame out of the corner of your eye.

• 38:19Lindsay Graham?

  Are they throwing firebombs through the broken window? Just an hour ago, the people outside were dancing to music. They were flirting. It was Friday night, and anything was possible with one more drink. Now, everything's changed. It's no longer just a party. It's something different. A resistance.

• 38:40Lindsay Graham?

  The New York City Fire Department arrived before Pine's reinforcements could. When Pine and the police retreated into the Stonewall, the assembled crowd began to pelt the building's facade with bottles, bricks, cobblestones, and makeshift Molotov cocktails. Two hundred people directed all of their fury and frustration against the police barricaded inside. A Stonewall regular, Michael Fader, later recalled, “It was like the last straw. It was time to reclaim something that had always been taken from us. It was something that just happened. All kinds of people, all kinds of different reasons, but mostly it was total outrage. Anger, sorrow, everything combined. We felt like we'd been booted out of our home for no reason.”

• 39:21Lindsay Graham?

  The crowd tried to break back into the Stonewall, and in doing so, managed to dislodge a parking meter and use it as a battering ram against the windows of the club. Someone began throwing firebombs through the broken windows, prompting a call to the Fire Department. Stonewall patron Raymond Castro recalled being inside the club during the melee. “It was like everything was in slow motion. You're not getting any answers. You're not sure what's going to happen next. Time did not move. You could hear screaming outside from the protesters. It was a good sound, to know that you had a lot of people out there pulling for you.” City fire trucks wailing their way up Christopher Street prevented what could have been a bloodbath by police had the crowd actually forced their way back inside the Stonewall. But the crowd did not break in.

• 40:05Lindsay Graham?

  Craig Rodwell, from his position on a stoop next door, watched as the scene unfolded. Soon after the fire trucks arrived, more police vans pulled up. These were tactical police units, wearing riot gear and helmets. They came up Christopher Street towards Seventh Avenue in a V formation and managed to disperse the crowd from the front door. Rodwell got off his stoop and joined the melee. “It was like a tug-of-war that went on for a few hours. They would just chase us down the street, and we'd go around the block and come back and chant things and throw bottles.” Some of the crowd taunted the tactical police by linking arms like Rockettes dancers to mimic the cops advances in formation, singing, “We are the village girls, we wear our

• 40:46Lindsay Graham?

  hair in curls, we wear our sweaters tight, we give the guys a fright.” Danny Garvin, who was part of the crowd that night, recalls the police's reaction to this theatrical protest. “Cops just charged with the nightsticks and started smacking them in the heads, hitting people, pulling them into cars. I just can't ever get that one sight out of my mind. That kick line, which was a spoof on the cops' McKeesmo, making fun of their authority. People were getting smashed with bats, and for what? A kick line?” Fire trucks turned their hoses on the protesters, but the kick lines would form again and again. The two lines would advance on each other, disperse, then advance again. During the melee, Raymond Castro tried to resist arrest.

• 41:27Lindsay Graham?

  As two policemen forced him inside the back of a police wagon, a handcuffed Castro managed to put one foot on each side of the open doors. Kicking back, he knocked the two policemen to the ground. Still, he was eventually subdued and dragged back into the police wagon. Miraculously that night, no shots were fired. In total, thirteen people were arrested, including Raymond Castro. But because he was not read his Miranda rights, his case was later dismissed. Craig Rodwell and Yvonne Ritter both escaped injury, but others were not so lucky. Many suffered minor wounds, but some were hospitalized. By around four in the morning, the crowd had dissipated, vanishing into the surrounding streets. Madacheen Head Dick Lysch, who had been alerted by a very early morning phone call, described

• 42:12Lindsay Graham?

  the scene. “I remember the street being so empty, except for the cops, and seeing very few civilians anywhere around. Then I remember the sky being very dark, there being a terrific moon, and the village being eerily quiet.” Lysch couldn't help feel that something enormous had just happened. An oppressed and harassed underclass had refused to do what they were told. It was like the moment after a battle, there had been an uprising on Christopher Street. But the uprising didn't end Saturday morning. It would continue for the next six days as people gathered night after night in front of the Stonewall. Something entirely new was beginning. The gay rights movement had changed. The gay rights movement was out and proud.

• 42:57Lindsay Graham?

  On the next episode of American History Tellers, the fight for gay rights moves on from its trial by fire at Stonewall with a promise of greater influence and growing visibility. But soon divisions emerge on how radical the movement should become and which voices the movement will ultimately serve. American History Tellers is only possible because of listeners like you, so thank you. And don't miss an episode. Be sure to follow American History Tellers on Audible or wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge new seasons of American History Tellers early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts. And to find out more about me, including my other podcasts, my live show, the history

• 43:42Lindsay Graham?

  tours I'm arranging, and all sorts of other things, go to historyishuman.com. That's historyishuman.com. From Audible Originals, this is episode three of Stonewall for American History Tellers. For more information on the Stonewall riots, we recommend Stonewall: The Riots That Sparked a Gay Revolution by David Carter and Stonewall by Martin Duberman. American History Tellers is hosted, edited, and produced by me, Lindsay Graham for Airship. Audio editing by Molly Bach. Sound design by Derek Behrens. This episode is written by George Ducker. Edited by Dorian Marina. Special thanks to Sylvion Consulting for serving as an advisor on this series. Executive producer for Audible, Jenny Lauer-Beckman.

• 44:25Lindsay Graham?

  Head of creative development at Audible, Kate Navy. Head of Audible Originals North America, Marshall Louis. Chief Content Officer, Rachel Giannza. Copyright 2026 by Audible Originals LLC. Sound recording copyright 2026 by Audible Originals LLC.

• 45:02Speaker 05

  There are books that change how you see the world, and there are books that change how you see yourself. In a new podcast series, A Great Book with Barack Obama, President Obama sits down with a series of surprising and sharp guests to explore six books that have shaped his life and perspective on the world. From Song of Solomon and the Fire Next Time, to All the Pretty Horses and Gilead, the President is joined by guests like Tom Hanks and Ta-Nehisi Coates to reflect on how these timeless stories shaped his thinking on everything from fatherhood to leadership. And discover together what they tell us about the world we live in and the world we want to create.

• 45:45Speaker 05

  Audible subscribers can listen to all episodes of A Great Book with Barack Obama ad-free right now, plus access each audiobook discussed in the series. Download the Audible app today.