Pod Insights All In The Mind The baby decision — how to decide when you can't decide About this episode There are some decisions in life that can be trickier to navigate. Do you want to get married? Should you change careers? Do you want a baby?
Parenthood is a choice more vexed than ever in a world threatened by climate change, political instability and cost-of-living crises.
So how can people approach this choice? And if you're lucky enough to have a choice, how do you make peace with your decision?
Decision coach Merle Bombardieri has been working with couples on this very topic for decades — today, we ask her about the tools, tips and strategies you can use to tackle the baby question.
If you're interested in hearing more about parenthood, check out our episode called Why do we sing to babies? https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/why-do-we-sing-to-babies/102638772
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 So the year is 1970. Merle Bombardieri is a 21-year-old university student. She's majoring in psychology and she's got this boyfriend, this guy called Rocco, who's a PhD student in zoology. And one day, Rocco proposes to her.
0:24 Speaker 02 I was deeply in love with him. I wanted to spend the rest of my life with him and I knew that.
0:30 Speaker 01 But Merle does something almost unthinkable for women who are in love back then. She says no.
0:37 Speaker 02 He knew that he wanted to have children, not just a child, but children. And I thought that I wanted to be child-free.
0:44 Speaker 01 Right.
0:44 Speaker 02 So I said no. And my husband assumed that because I loved him and because I was a woman, at some point in our relationship, I would just automatically wake up and say, yes, I'm ready to have a baby. But I said, Rocco, there are no guarantees of that at all.
1:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:00 Speaker 02 And I would deprive you of a child, and I certainly don't think it would be good for us to have a child I don't want. So the answer has to be no until or unless. We can get a different view on this.
1:12 Speaker 01 What did your family or friends think? Like, was that pretty radical to say no because I don't know if I want kids?
1:18 Speaker 02 It was radical. My friends understood. I actually can't remember what comments my parents might have made.
1:26 Speaker 01 Oh, right.
1:26 Speaker 02 Actually, I'm Jewish and he's Italian, so they might have been hoping I wasn't going to marry him anyway.
1:34 Speaker 01 Family judgments aside, Merle had good reason to be reticent about kids.
1:39 Speaker 02 This conversation was in 1969 and 1970. The women's movement was just getting started. And there were no role models for feminist mothers.
1:54 Speaker 02 There were no role models for women who loved their careers, continued to work, but also had a child and actually managed to be good mothers and enjoy parenthood.
2:03 Speaker 01 But she also wasn't 100% sure either way. So Merle spent the next 18 months. Mulling over the choice. She soul-searched. She had long conversations with her boyfriend. She looked for mothers who were professionals.
2:18 Speaker 02 I was very lucky, actually. I was working in the infant daycare unit of Michigan State University. So all the babies I was taking care of were children of professors or children of brilliant graduate students. So I, without having to, you know, and of course, the internet didn't even exist then, without having to do lots of outreach, saying, "Do you know anyone? Do you know anyone?" You know, I talked to them every afternoon when they came to pick up their babies. And I could see their joy with their babies. So I really needed a role model.
2:50 Speaker 01 Eventually, Merle decided she was open to having children. And she would go on to have two of them with that very patient college boyfriend. Her family wound up loving him, too.
3:00 Speaker 02 And being very happy with two children who are half Italian and half Jewish.
3:04 Speaker 01 Right. But she realized there must be other people who agonize over this decision just like she did. As a licensed clinical social worker, decision coach, and author of one of the first books on the topic of parenthood indecision, called "The Baby Decision", she's now spent decades helping others figure out what they really want. Because for people on the fence about kids, and of course, not everyone is so lucky to have a choice, but for those who do, the question can become all-consuming.
3:36 Speaker 03 If I'm uncertain about my own future on the planet, how can I bring children into this uncertainty?
3:41 Speaker 04 I have worries about choosing not to, like having regrets later in life.
3:46 Speaker 05 I definitely think the way the world is going has changed how many I would have, when I would have them.
3:51 Speaker 04 But choosing yes really scares me. I'm mostly worried that I won't be a good enough mum.
4:01 Speaker 02 When people are confused and agonizing, it's like cats chasing their tails. Because the yes baby, no baby, be child free are so mixed together in a big tangle.
4:13 Speaker 01 So today, if you're struggling to decide whether you want a kid or not, we've got practical advice on how you can untangle your thinking from one of the OG voices on parenthood and decision. And a disclaimer, just because she eventually had kids, Merle is not a proponent for either decision. She sees both choices, to remain child free or pursue parenthood, as completely valid. This is a no judgment space. This is also all in the mind. I'm Sana Qadar.
4:52 Speaker 01 So you've worked with couples for decades now who are grappling with the question of whether or not to have a child. And you published kind of like the seminal text on baby indecision way back in 1981. I want to know what prompted you to write about the topic back then? And where was the conversation at about the choice to have kids or not back then?
5:14 Speaker 02 Okay, pretty much no one was talking at all about not having children other than some zero population growth advocates. So in 1970, when my husband proposed to me, I thought that I wanted to be child free. So I said no. And during a period of about 18 months, I spent a lot of time learning some things about children, having a lot of long conversations with my husband. And I concluded that I could say yes to having a child. So I was fascinated by the whole process because we really got to know each other very well. We learned a lot. I was just very curious, how do other people make this decision?
5:58 Speaker 02 You can't compromise. You can't have half a child. You can't be parents in odd numbered years and child free in eight numbered years. So the whole question of how you go about making this decision. Fascinated me. And when I started writing the book, I was thinking about specialties and interests. And I thought, well, this is something that nobody else seems to be doing. And I was living in Nashville, Tennessee, which is a very, very conservative part of our country. Obviously, in the Southern Christian traditional background, everybody has kids.
6:30 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:31 Speaker 02 So I just happened to tell some of my other psychology and social work colleagues that I was thinking about writing on this topic. And they all said, our case loads are full of couples who are tearing their hair out. They don't know what to do, and we have no idea what to tell them. So I said to myself, if there are this many people in conservative Nashville, Tennessee, who can't decide, are so aware that they might want to be child free, there have to be a lot more in San Francisco, in Boston, and Sydney, and London, et cetera, et cetera. So I started interviewing people and coaching people. So that's how it got started.
7:09 Speaker 01 With those people that you were encountering at that time, what were the issues giving them pause?
7:15 Speaker 02 I think that there was a lot of awareness of how difficult children are, and how much divorce there was among parents of young children, and that people automatically having kids without thinking about whether they actually wanted to, could create a lot of unhappiness. Women were beginning to be able to get into graduate school, have careers. So there was, you know, a lot of people were saying, can I do this all? And do I want to? And then also, I think, just the division of roles. There was a lot of concern about, could this be fair? How could this work? Also, zero population growth was being discussed a lot. So there was concern about, you know, can the planet take more children?
7:58 Speaker 01 And then, fast forward, and you updated and republished the book in 2016, which kind of brought the whole book to the millennial generation. I'm wondering, what are the issues you find that give people pause now? Some of those practical and philosophical issues you've just mentioned, I imagine are still, you know, the things that are floating around now. But yeah, what gives people pause now?
8:20 Speaker 02 Very much so. Well, one big issue, of course, is the environment. And people are really worried about carbon footprint. And for a lot of people who are thinking about the environment, it's really more than one thing. You know, there's so much concern about racism, sexism, war. So there are many, many things that are on people's mind. And then the other thing which is really interesting is there's been a lot of attention to what's being called the mental load or the emotional load.
8:45 Speaker 01 Yep.
8:46 Speaker 02 So that's something that couples are talking about and negotiating.
8:50 Speaker 01 And then there's a factor that Merle says is kind of new on the scene, and it fascinates her.
8:56 Speaker 02 And that is terror of pregnancy. Now, women have died in childbirth ever and ever. And it's certainly being pregnant is safer now than it has been for most of the time. But so I've worked with many generations. I'm just about to turn 76. So I first coached baby boomers and then, you know, Gen Xers and then millennials and so on. It's really interesting that the young millennials and the Gen Z's are more terrified of pregnancy than any other generation I've encountered.
9:25 Speaker 01 That's interesting.
9:26 Speaker 02 And I think some of it has to do with the internet. I think people read so many horrible, horrible stories.
9:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:32 Speaker 02 And they assume it's going to happen to them. So if there is one zillionth of 1% of a likelihood that you're going to die in childbirth, or that you're going to pee in your pants for the rest of your life, or whatever, they're going to be convinced that's going to happen to them. So there's just a lot of assuming that if you hear a horror story, kind of contagion that it's going to happen.
9:52 Speaker 01 That's really interesting because that was actually a big one for me. I grappled with whether or not to have a kid for a while. I now do have a child. But yeah, I was terrified of birth. I wanted no part of it. I didn't want to breastfeed. I didn't want to be pregnant. I didn't want to give birth. Yeah, that definitely, that speaks to me.
10:10 Speaker 01 There are just so many reasons a person might struggle to arrive at a decision about whether they want kids or not. Like, maybe it's worries about financial security. Or maybe it's a fear of losing your identity and sense of self after becoming a parent. Or maybe you had a terrible childhood yourself, and that makes you wonder, could I ever be a good parent? I can't cover every scenario in this episode, but Merle does tackle these issues in her book. And whatever your circumstances, there is some core advice and some exercises that Merle uses to help people figure out what they really want. We're going to get into some of those exercises in just a moment.
10:52 Speaker 01 But first, step number one is to stop panicking. I know, easier said than done.
11:00 Speaker 02 A lot of people who come to me if we're talking about a straight couple or even a gay, a lesbian couple, the woman who is considering getting pregnant is in the range of 32 to 35, 37. So they're feeling the time pressure.
11:16 Speaker 01 And how do you manage that?
11:17 Speaker 02 I actually have a section in the baby decision saying, "Take your hand off the panic button." Usually, it's not a matter of you've got to decide right now. Now, if you have a medical condition and your doctor says you need a hysterectomy in the next year, so if you're going to have a child, you need to have it now. But most of the time, it's a matter of degrees. And getting medical information can be very useful because people are assuming, "Oh, I'm 37 or I'm 42, so I'm going to have trouble." And they might find out that their hormones are great. Not that they should wait until they're 49 to start trying, but that they don't have to decide in the next two months, kind of thing.
11:53 Speaker 01 Right.
11:54 Speaker 02 So, you know, setting goals for decision making. How soon would you like to have a decision made, for instance? The other thing that is really reassuring and helps people is people think that there's only one right decision. And if they make the wrong one, their life is going to be miserable. And I tell them, and this really helps their panic, because you are talking to me and trying to make a decision, you're finding some things attractive about both choices. So probably you have the capacity to be happy with either choice. So rather than seeing this as life or death, a perfect choice or booby prize, and your life is going to be wretched, I'm thinking about not, "Will I regret the decision?" But which decision will I regret least?
12:34 Speaker 01 That's a great reframe.
12:35 Speaker 02 Every decision involves loss. The word "decide" comes from a Latin root, meaning "to cut away from." If you can figure out, "Which one am I likely to have less regret?" Then you can feel more in control of being able to make a choice.
12:50 Speaker 01 That is such good advice. That is such a great way to be able to think about it. And you write about getting excited about making the decision, which feels kind of unusual over something so weighty. Can you talk about what you mean there about getting excited about this choice that people, you know, otherwise kind of agonize over?
13:07 Speaker 02 Well, if you think about, let's say you are reading a suspense novel and you don't know the answer and you're eager to find out, there's a certain excitement. And if you read the novel and in the first chapter, you found out whodunit and all the denouement, you would be bored. There's a kind of a fascination. You know, what is it? How is it going to unfold? And that can happen in relationships and with decisions too. So it's possible to get excited about the journey.
13:35 Speaker 01 Right. Okay. Another good reframe. Okay, let's move on to talking about some of the specific exercises you have in the book that can help people clarify whether they want to have a kid or not. Let's start with a chair dialogue. What is this and what can it do?
13:51 Speaker 02 The chair dialogue comes from gestalt therapy. And the idea is that we have different parts of ourselves that we can talk to and that there is a voice that says, I'm having a child no matter what. I don't care what would be hard about that. And another voice saying, are you crazy? Why would we even talk about the possibility of having a child? And the idea is not to be polite, not to be intellectual. This is two parts having an argument with each other. So one would be saying, are you crazy? How can you even think about having a child? You hate being around babies. And then the other one would say, but it would be so nice. You know, I held my niece the other night and that was
14:34 Speaker 02 nice, you know, but really back and forth, what matters. And this is an exercise which is great to do more than once. So people might do this when I'm first working with them, or readers might do this to just sort of get a sense of what each voice has to say. And then there is the, what we might call the executive voice that's going to listen to both voices and do negotiation.
14:59 Speaker 01 And just so it's clear, we're not talking about metaphorical chairs here. If you want to do this at home, you need to get two actual, physical chairs and place them face to face. And you can label one, "I want to have kids," and the other, "I want to be child free." It's when you sit in each chair that you speak in that voice, and you can move back and forth as much as you need to. Now, to ensure total honesty with yourself if you're doing this at home, Merle says it's best to do this alone.
15:28 Speaker 02 And if they do it a month later, two months later, six months later, they will get different answers. And one of the things that happens is, I'll ask people, "How did you feel in that chair?" One voice may be louder than the other, one voice may be more confident. If I'm working with people, I work with everybody remotely now, but I can see on the screen, if they're shrinking and slouching in one chair, and the other, they're sitting up proudly and smiling. Body language, voice, energy, which felt more like you, which felt more energetic? People start realizing, I do have feelings. I am maybe 60/40, or 70/30, or whatever. So, a lot of people say that it's doing that that enables them to make a decision.
16:12 Speaker 01 So battling it out like this in these two chairs allows them to bring to the surface what they're really feeling about either choice?
16:19 Speaker 02 Yes, and it also teases out the two voices. So when people are confused and agonizing, it's like cats chasing their tails, because the yes baby, no baby, be child free are so mixed together in a big tangle. When you sit in one chair and speak for one voice, and then sit in the other chair and speak for the other voice, you have a chance to listen to those two parts of yourself. And also, when people start finding an answer, let's say they're getting 60/40, or 70/30, instead of getting that other voice to shut up and leave me alone, they need to ask that voice, "What do you need from me so that you can be willing to go along with this choice?"
17:00 Speaker 02 So let's say if someone is deciding to be child free, and that's the stronger part, to ask the voice that wanted a child, "Tell me what you really longed for." About being a mother, you know, and if it's I love children's books curling up and reading stories. Can you be a volunteer at the library? Can you, you know, read to your nieces and nephews? That kind of thing. And if you are deciding to be a parent, but you, you want freedom, what are the ways that you can have free time for solitude? So those doubts, rather than ignoring them, the other voice, you can learn from the other voice, how you're going to make things work.
17:36 Speaker 01 Another exercise is called the rocking chair. Can you explain how that works and how it can help?
17:42 Speaker 02 Yes. So in the rocking chair, there are two different scenarios. So you are imagining that you are, let's say, seventy-five or seventy-nine, and you've been blessed with good health, you've had a good life, you are maybe, I mean, the stereotype of an older person is rocking in the chair by the fire. Most seventy-five-year-olds are much more active than that, but on a winter night or after skiing or whatever, one could be sitting by a fire. But kind of either meditating or kind of half asleep and just reflecting on life and what you liked and what you didn't like.
18:18 Speaker 02 And you do one scenario where you had a child and another scenario where you did not.
18:28 Speaker 02 And what I often do when I do this live in workshops is we flip a coin as to which one we do first. And I ask people afterwards, were you glad that it landed on a child coin? Were you hoping to do that first? Or were you like, oh, no, that doesn't appeal to me? So there's a lot of ways to play with this. And our creative minds and our unconscious minds have so much information that's not available when we're panicked or when we're obsessing or we're trying to be so intellectual. So many people need to get more in touch with their emotions and gut-level feelings before they can make an analytical decision.
19:07 Speaker 01 Another exercise that people can use to help clarify how they feel is called photo album. And you give a series of vignettes of a child through various stages of life.
19:18 Speaker 02 Yes.
19:18 Speaker 01 And I looked at this list of vignettes and I found myself really shuddering at some and mentally going aww at others. Can you walk me through this exercise and the vignettes that you have and then talk about what this can eliminate for people?
19:33 Speaker 02 So, the idea of photo album is that people, if they're leaning towards parenthood, might be thinking about all the joys. And people who are thinking about being child free are saying, oh, everything's bad about kids. But this photo album allows them to kind of think about experiences that they have had, positive and negative, with children at all ages. And the idea that children change over time. So, you might hate having a surly teenager, but you might love going to your eight-year-old school play, for instance.
20:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'll read out some of the vignettes you have in there. The first one is, "A wailing, red-faced newborn. A peacefully nursing three-month-old baby. A toddler in a supermarket, rolling on the floor, kicking and screaming." That is the stage of life I am in right now with my child. "A three-year-old in her nightgown, dancing in the moonlight." That one is quite sweet. And then it goes on and on. "A nine-year-old, serving you breakfast in bed, even though the toast is scorched. And a 16-year-old, smoking marijuana in their room." These are really lovely to see, because yeah, I think a lot of people, when they think about whether or not they want a child, they're kind of thinking about the baby. They're not necessarily always thinking beyond that.
20:47 Speaker 02 Yes. Or if they're leaning towards being child free, they might only be thinking about the negative stuff. And if they don't think about the positive stuff, they're not really recognizing what they're losing. And in order to have the best life with the choice you make, if you have been ambivalent, you really need to grieve what you're not getting.
21:06 Speaker 01 Right.
21:06 Speaker 02 So, that nine-year-old with the breakfast in bed, if you're going to be child free, you're not going to get that. So, rather than making an across-the-board decision, "Oh, I know that parenting isn't for me," people who are most likely to regret their decisions are the ones who are not allowing themselves to recognize what they're giving up, what they're grieving.
21:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:24 Speaker 02 And that sorrow about that actually enables them to have all the energy and life to put into enjoying what they did decide to do.
21:33 Speaker 01 Right, so is the way to guard against regret and fear of regret, to really think through these things and grieve what you're going to let go of, depending on whichever choice you make, is that the way to sort of like minimize the likelihood of regret?
21:48 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
21:52 Speaker 01 But what if you work through these exercises? You figure out what you really want and you decide, yes, I do want to try for a child. But then you look up and you think, hang on, climate change. Climate change renders this untenable, or irresponsible, or just plain scary. What do you do then? Well, unsurprisingly, there's no easy answer. But Mural is working on a new book that will tackle some of these more modern concerns weighing on people.
22:22 Speaker 02 Yes, it is, it is very difficult. I think, I mean, people who are more hopeful about climate change and finding solutions, obviously are more likely to decide to have kids. One thing that a lot of people have found helpful is deciding to have just one child, or if they want a second child possibly, to adopt that child. And also working with their children on working with climate change. There are two states in the Pacific Northwest, and there was another one in the Midwest, with situations where children, teachers, and parents all work together to try to stop certain environmental actions that were planned. And they actually won all three of those lawsuits. So these are examples of where it's not just have a child and, you know,
23:07 Speaker 02 say to hell with climate. Or don't have a child and then you're good for the climate. But thinking about different ways of, of dealing with these things. And, you know, and some people's children are going to work on solving these problems. But this is the hardest thing I've ever written about, because I'm scared too, and I don't know what's going to happen. So with everything else I've written about, I've had enough research, personal experience, to think things through and say, well, here's what I think will help. Now I'm just guessing. So the hardest chapter I've ever written.
23:40 Speaker 01 Basically, if you're to override fears about the climate, you kind of have to see having children as an act of hope.
23:51 Speaker 01 For the people you work with, what percentage do you find end up deciding to try for a baby versus deciding to go child free?
24:00 Speaker 02 I would say it is probably 60/40. 60 to have a child and 40 to be child free. And I'm very happy about that change because, you know, back when I first did this work, it was probably more like 10 or 15% were deciding to be child free. And back then, I really felt a lot of people who would have been happier child free decided not to do it because of the social disapproval.
24:23 Speaker 01 Hmm, right, okay. That was just so strong. What that makes me think about is like, I think as a society, we have become pretty accepting of child free people, at least in some pockets. But then you also get comments out there about, you know, childless cat ladies and the like. Where do you think the cultural messaging is now and the conversation is at these days?
24:46 Speaker 02 Well, I think, you know, it's very complicated because there's a wide range of who accepts and who doesn't accept child free choices. It is becoming much more acceptable and supportive. And I think one of the things that's helped that is that so many child free people are really talking about being child free, talking about their lives. There are a lot of wonderful child free podcasts, for instance, some really good books. And people are able to see and understand that living a life without children can be really beautiful and wonderful. And that stereotype that child free people are selfish is not borne out by reality. There's more acceptance as it becomes more common.
25:26 Speaker 01 The other option becoming more common as well, which Merle mentioned a moment ago, is having just one kid. Whether that's because of concerns about climate change or a compromise between partners who might be on slightly different pages about kids or a financial decision, one child families are on the rise.
25:45 Speaker 02 It is much, much more common. We live in Japan, UK, the United States. The one child family is becoming the predominant family of foreign.
25:54 Speaker 01 And in Australia, one child families, which are sometimes called triangle families. Have more than doubled in the last four decades. They now represent more than a million of the 7.5 million families in this country.
26:07 Speaker 02 A one child family can be a great solution for couples who want the experience of parenthood, but don't want to spend years at home, are very involved in other things besides parenting. It gives them a chance to experience parenthood, but still experience so much of what they really enjoy in their lives.
26:27 Speaker 01 Oh, my gosh, I completely agree. That's kind of the compromise we, my family has ended up at because we were very ambivalent for a while. And then we decided to have a kid and we now we have one. And I'm pretty sure we'll stay at one because actually, yes, exactly that. We get the experience of parenthood, but I still feel like we both throw ourselves fully into our careers. I even traveled solo with a girlfriend this year, which I don't think I could leave two children alone with my husband, you know? That wouldn't happen. So I feel like that's really been the perfect compromise.
26:57 Speaker 02 That's great. Yes.
27:01 Speaker 01 Finally, for those who are listening, who are weighing up this choice right now, going through this process, what's a final thing you'd like to leave them with? You know, in terms of what do you think they should keep in mind as they go through this decision making process?
27:14 Speaker 02 Keep in mind that there is an answer to this question, even if they don't know what it is yet. And if they can find some curiosity, they will discover that there are things about themselves they don't know yet, not just about parented or non-parented, but what matters to them, what they want to happen between now and when they die. And a lot of people find comfort in thinking about a decision you had to make in the past which seemed impossible. Maybe it was choosing between two jobs or what country or what city you were going to live in. Any decision that seemed impossible, but you made it and you've made the best of that life can be very encouraging for assuming that this too is something that you can solve.
27:56 Speaker 02 So a sense of discovery, a sense of hope and trust in yourself and your partner, if you have one, there is a solution and you might be surprised about the interesting path to get there.
28:11 Speaker 01 Perfect. Merle, that was so lovely. Thank you so much for your time.
28:14 Speaker 02 You are so welcome.
28:16 Speaker 01 That is Merle Bombardieri, author of The Baby Decision, licensed clinical social worker and parenthood decision-making coach. Thanks to producer Rose Kerr and senior producer James Bullin and sound engineer Roy Huberman. And a big thank you to those of you our listeners who sent in voice notes talking about your decision-making process and what's been weighing on you as you try to decide whether you want a child or not. We really appreciate your input, so thank you for taking the time to send those. That is it for All in the Mind this week. I'm Sana Qadar. Thanks for listening. I'll catch you next time.
28:57 Speaker 01 Before I go, I just want to let you know about this brand new science podcast that's dropped from the ABC. Take a listen.
29:04 Speaker 06 Have you ever seen a news story and thought, huh, what's the science behind that?
29:08 Speaker 02 I remember thinking, gee, Lancer, how did you publish this? You know, it's not great.
29:14 Speaker 06 Well, chances are, I have too. Obviously, everybody poops. And depending on what depth it gets to, it could be sequestered away from the atmosphere for decades to millennia. Hi, I'm Belinda Smith, the host of Lab Notes, where every week, we bring you the science behind new discoveries and current events. Find it by searching for Lab Notes on the ABC Listen app.
29:34 Speaker 01 That is Lab Notes. Find it by searching that title on the ABC Listen app or wherever you get your podcasts.
29:42 Speaker 00 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC Podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 'My brain snapped': Harry's sudden psychosis Next 'Bad behaviour' or just misunderstood? What to know about kids' mental health Page updated November 4, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated