Pod Insights All In The Mind Inside a sociopath's mind: "I'm capable of almost anything" About this episode Patric Gagne is a sociopath, but she doesn’t fit the stereotype.
From a violent kid, to a PhD and author - we track the unusual story of a sociopath who learned to be 'good'.
Plus, there's been some controversy and questions about the veracity of her PhD - so, we fact checked it.
This episode was first released in May 2024.
Need something to listen to next? Check out our episode Why heartbreak hurts so bad https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/why-heartbreak-hurts-so-bad/13808926.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 So, early on in the book, you write, "I'm a liar, I'm a thief, I'm highly manipulative, I don't care what other people think, rules do not factor in my decision making, I'm capable of almost anything." And in a few reviews online, that's led people to wonder about the veracity of your memoir, you know, if you don't care about rules and should we be wary of what was written. What do you make of that?
0:29 Speaker 02 I understand it. Listen, I know that my stories are true, but I also understand that not everybody's going to believe that.
0:37 Speaker 01 Patrick Gagné is a sociopath, which is a word that conjures all kinds of images and emotions, but she isn't what you'd perhaps imagine typically when you imagine a sociopath. So, she's not a murderer, although she has been violent in the past. She's not in prison, although she has done criminal things in the past. She's a mother, a wife, she's a PhD, and she's an author. In fact, her book is called Sociopath: A Memoir.
1:06 Speaker 02 I think what's more problematic is less the skepticism and more that, you know, I'm finding by virtue of the fact that I have outed myself as a sociopath, that some people are reacting to me, ideas of who I am, and more concerning who they want me to be. They want me to be a liar, they want me to be fake, they want me to be that stereotypical sociopath. And I find that to be particularly problematic, because if people are going to insist on their version of sociopathy being the only version, this extreme, untreatable, unrepresented version, then other people like me are going to be very reluctant to come forward, very reluctant to seek treatment, they won't want to advocate for themselves.
1:50 Speaker 02 And that's my, that's my bigger concern.
1:54 Speaker 01 This is All in the Mind's summer series. I'm Sana Qadar. Today, from a little kid who couldn't feel certain feelings, to an adult with a habit of breaking into homes, to now an advocate and author, this is one sociopath's unusual story.
2:11 Speaker 02 I know that for me, once I was able to normalize my internal experience, I was able to stop a lot of the destructive behaviors I was committing, I was able to accept myself, and that's something that I want for other people like me.
2:29 Speaker 01 As early as age seven or eight, Patrick could tell that she wasn't like other kids.
2:34 Speaker 02 I had a sister, so I knew what complex emotional development looked like by watching her, and I knew that I didn't have it. My sister is four years younger than me, so probably by the time she was a toddler was really when I was coming to a conscious understanding. I experienced things this way.
2:55 Speaker 01 And what was she experiencing? Like, what were her emotions that she had that you were like, "I don't have that and I don't know that"?
3:02 Speaker 02 I just remember watching my mom socialize my sister in the sense that helping her understand right versus wrong, how people's feelings get hurt. And I remember thinking, "I don't, I don't care." These things don't resonate with me the way it seems to be resonating with other people. Which is not to say that I didn't like other people or I wanted to cause them pain, because that was not what it was. And, and I noticed that that tends to be conflated quite a bit with sociopathy or psychopathy. The automatic assumption is, if you don't care, then you must want to hurt. And that really wasn't the issue for me. It was simply a matter of a lack of resonance.
3:47 Speaker 01 Right.
3:47 Speaker 02 I remember my mom talking to me about, "You don't want to upset your teacher, do you?" And I remember I understood, well, no, I don't necessarily want to upset her, but I also don't know how much I care. And that was not the answer anyone wanted to hear.
4:04 Speaker 01 Right. Not caring, not connecting with the ideas of right and wrong, these are key features of sociopathy. And actually, before we get any deeper into Patrick's story, we should define what sociopath means more clearly. Because it's not really a term that's used clinically much anymore. It's kind of more used colloquially. And that's because although it was once a diagnosis in the DSM, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, it's not there anymore. Now sociopathy and psychopathy have been folded under the umbrella diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder. But still, sociopathy and sociopath are the terms that Patrick identifies with.
4:46 Speaker 02 That's what I was diagnosed with. I understand that sociopathy has been, has advanced to be known as secondary psychopathy. But it's tricky because when you're looking at the research and you see psychopathy, sociopathy, it's sort of hard to parse out which is which. My understanding of the research is that the primary psychopath suffers from brain abnormalities that make it impossible for them to move through complex emotional development. So while they are capable of experiencing the inherent emotions, anger, joy, trust, fear, they are incapable of moving through these so-called learned emotions.
5:30 Speaker 02 Love, shame, empathy, remorse. That is different from sociopathy, which is now known as secondary psychopathy. People suffering from this disorder are capable of learning the social emotions. They just learn them differently. And that's a really big distinction because one type of this personality disorder can benefit from treatment and the other type can't.
5:57 Speaker 01 But as a kid, Patrick obviously didn't know any of this. She just knew she was different. There's another feeling you describe really well in the book, and it's the feeling of the pressure that would sort of build within you before you did something bad. Can you explain that here? What would happen that would lead you to act out?
6:16 Speaker 02 I would feel just this rise in tension, this rise in stress. And some part of me understood that acting out destructively was the quickest way to neutralize that pressure, that tension. And so that's what I did.
6:32 Speaker 01 What would you do?
6:33 Speaker 02 I remember taking backpacks and I remember not wanting them. I remember. A lot of times I would take the backpack and as soon as I had it, I would toss it in some bushes.
6:45 Speaker 01 Right.
6:45 Speaker 02 Because it wasn't the acquisition, it was the act itself that neutralized the pressure.
6:51 Speaker 01 You could say stealing backpacks was at the less bad end of the spectrum of her behavior as a kid. On the really bad end was the time she stabbed a girl with a pencil in the head.
7:02 Speaker 02 I remember I had been feeling a lot of pressure. And looking back, what I believe it was, it was a reaction to apathy. As long as I was struggling with apathy, I was always going to be othered. I was always going to have to fake it. I was always going to have to assume emotional reactions I didn't have. So when I would feel that apathy start to build, I would also feel this understanding of you better force something, you better force the feeling because if you don't, you're going to have to fake it. And who knows how long you're going to be able to do that before you're out. And on this particular day, I'd been feeling that tension building for quite some time and none of my destructive mechanisms had been helping.
7:47 Speaker 02 And there was a child next to me who was, who was something of a bully. And she was angry at me for not letting her spend the night. And she was just grading, grading, grading. And I remember picking up a pencil and stabbing her with it.
8:04 Speaker 02 It wasn't, I don't remember feeling any rage. I don't remember feeling any remorse. I don't remember feeling as though I wanted to hurt this child necessarily. I just felt like, actually, I don't think I felt like anything. That was, you know, that it was more, it was more autopilot. But as soon as I did it, all of the tension instantly vanished. But unlike the other times I had acted out destructively, it hadn't just vanished, but it had been replaced with a type of euphoria.
8:39 Speaker 01 Wow.
8:39 Speaker 02 That I wasn't really expecting, but that I understood on some level was not ideal.
8:47 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah, that was, was that? Was that scary? Could you feel scared about that? Or like, how did you make sense of this is not a good thing?
8:55 Speaker 02 No, I wasn't scared. It was more the image that comes to mind is of a child trying to pour orange juice by herself and having it spill over the cup, all over the floor. It was more like, ugh.
9:13 Speaker 02 It was that. So less fear and more acknowledgement that this was not sustainable.
9:18 Speaker 01 Okay, right. And can you tell me a bit more? Why do you think those acts release that tension? Like, why did it take destructive behavior to release your tension?
9:27 Speaker 02 I think I was trying to force a feeling. And I've been asked before, well, how about acts of altruism? Why not good things? And I think it's because I don't connect to other people that way, at least not without effort. But I did remember getting those emotional jolts from destructive behavior.
9:52 Speaker 01 And that feeling of apathy? So like, when you weren't having one of the inherent emotions, you were feeling apathetic. Is that correct? And I don't think a lot of people necessarily can relate to that feeling. Can you describe what it feels like to feel nothing? Is that even possible?
10:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think it is. Because I think that people spend thousands of dollars in yoga classes trying to feel nothing when they meditate. And I remember being in Los Angeles and taking one of these meditation courses and joking to the instructor, like, oh, wait, I can do this at home for free. But it does. When I heard this yogi describe what it is that most people are seeking when they meditate, I remember thinking, oh, this is my default state. It's not good or bad. It's not hot or cold. It's just tranquil. And I think that's... That's a really important distinction as well because when people talk about apathy,
10:52 Speaker 02 you know, the absence of emotions, the lack of remorse, shame and guilt, these are always spoken about with such a negative, heavy tone. And certainly, apathy can be used to engage in destructive, negative behaviors. But apathy can also be used to engage in neutral behaviors. And that was something that it took me a long time to figure out. For so long, I was trying to do something to fill that void. But what I learned eventually was that I've learned to accept the apathy and to exist within it from a place of acceptance as opposed to a place of resistance.
11:31 Speaker 01 But before she arrived at that place of acceptance, she had to figure out how to control her more destructive impulses. Patrick decided at some point that she didn't want to be hurting people anymore.
11:42 Speaker 02 I understood that hurting people was not sustainable. There was only a matter of time before I was going to be caught, no matter how careful I was. And, you know, I don't want to give myself credit that I don't deserve. I made that decision purely for selfish reasons.
11:55 Speaker 01 But she still had to do something to relieve that pressure that would build inside. So she switched to a new, less violent behavior, but one that was still not exactly a good thing to be doing. She started breaking into houses, some abandoned, some definitely not.
12:13 Speaker 02 When I really started to understand that smaller, although I understand that for most neurotypical people, breaking into houses wouldn't exactly fall into the smaller category. But smaller acts of disciplined deviance were more effective than larger, more spontaneous ones. And I decided to put myself on a type of behavioral prescription. And for me, breaking into homes when people weren't there was less risky than stealing cars or engaging in any, certainly engaging in any type of violent behavior. This felt innocuous to me. I never took anything. I never disturbed anything. I simply existed where I wasn't supposed to exist.
12:56 Speaker 02 And I remember feeling all of that pressure just vanish.
13:04 Speaker 02 And when I would leave the houses, I would feel very normal, which was something that I really craved for a long time. And over time, I was able to shift, shift that behavioral prescription toward more pro-social behaviors. I understood that breaking into homes was wrong. And even though I didn't have remorse or I didn't have any shame about it, again, I understood that it wasn't something that I could do for the rest of my life, nor was it something I particularly wanted to do. If I wanted a family, if I wanted an honest relationship, I was gonna have to come up with more, with healthier coping mechanisms. So that's ultimately what I did.
13:44 Speaker 01 When did you stop breaking into houses?
13:50 Speaker 02 Well.
13:53 Speaker 01 What does that laugh mean?
13:55 Speaker 02 Well, because I'm trying to, I, I, I, I know that there have been times where I've done it since, since I was doing it all the time.
14:03 Speaker 01 Right.
14:03 Speaker 02 But it, it was, it's been at least a decade, I think.
14:09 Speaker 01 And did you ever get caught?
14:12 Speaker 02 I, I, I was saying no. And then I was reminded recently that I was in a house and I saw the homeowners come home early. And the only, and I remember thinking, all right, I'm gonna walk out of this house and the homeowners are gonna see me, but I'm just gonna walk out as if nothing's amiss. And I did.
14:35 Speaker 01 And they didn't say anything?
14:37 Speaker 02 Not a word.
14:37 Speaker 01 Wow.
14:39 Speaker 02 So, so the yes and no, was I ever caught? I not, I think that was the only time. And again, I think say a word.
14:47 Speaker 01 I guess that is the benefit of being a white lady, a little bit, maybe.
14:51 Speaker 02 One of many. One of, yes, no, I, I, I, there's no question that if I looked clearly, I, I would have absolutely been forced to answer for that transgression.
15:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, can you talk about that? Like, things could have turned out so much worse for you. Why, why do you think you didn't end up in prison and with much worse outcomes?
15:12 Speaker 02 Because I am a white woman of privilege. I mean, there's really, there's no other way to say it. I, I was extremely fortunate in that I had the resources to not just go to therapy, but to stay in therapy. I was able to go to college. I was able to go to graduate school. But these were gifts. And I am very, very aware that my life would have turned out dramatically different if my race, gender, or socioeconomic background had been any different.
15:49 Speaker 01 You're listening to All in the Mind. I'm Sana Qadar. Today on the show, Patrick Gagny. She's the author of Sociopath: A Memoir.
16:02 Speaker 01 I want to talk about the emotion of love for a hot minute because people expect that a sociopath wouldn't be able to feel love or fall in love. But you did. Can you talk about that? Like, how did that work for you in your head?
16:15 Speaker 02 The same way that, that other social emotions like empathy and remorse work. It's not that sociopaths can't feel these emotions. It just takes us a little bit longer to get there. So when I met my now husband, I remember thinking, okay, this isn't the feeling that I've read about in books. This isn't the feeling that I've seen on television, but it's something. I felt safe. I felt accepted. I felt respected. And I don't know that I could come up with better words to use to describe, you know, not just for me, but I think for anybody.
16:55 Speaker 02 I remember feeling very matter of fact, this is the man that I'm going to marry.
17:01 Speaker 01 Right. So did you not get like the butterflies and the thinking about that person constantly and the smiling all the time about it? Like, I'm trying to think of my experience of falling in love. And it was a full body, full emotional kind of, yeah, obsession.
17:13 Speaker 02 Right. Perfect word. I didn't have that obsession element. I just remember thinking, it was so matter of fact. It was, this is my name. This is where I live. This is my favorite color. This is the man I'm going to marry. This is what I'm having.
17:27 Speaker 01 Patrick wrote about her experience of love in a New York Times Modern Love column a few years ago, and that's what eventually led to her book. Now, as an adult, Patrick started to grapple with her sociopathy more deeply. She started going to therapy regularly, and it was her psychologist who eventually diagnosed her with sociopathy when she was in her twenties. In the book, Patrick recounts how her psychologist took her through a checklist, something called the PCL SV, the Psychopathy Checklist Screening Version, which is the version of that test that's used for the general population, by which I mean people not in the prison system. There's another version, used for people with recorded criminal histories.
18:09 Speaker 01 All of this detail, by the way, was stuff that Patrick was learning on the go, and it was pretty confusing because, remember also, if you're to go by the DSM, sociopathy isn't an actual diagnosis anymore. But also, the DSM has its own problems, of course, with how it classifies various disorders, which I won't get into here. The point is, some experts still might use the term psychopath and sociopath. Anyways, Patrick writes how she was told her scores showed an above-average range of symptoms across the four facets that the test looks at. And although her scores were not high enough to put her in the extreme psychopathic category, they were high enough, her psychologist said, to indicate sociopathy.
18:51 Speaker 02 And I was very fortunate to receive that diagnosis because, you know, sociopathy, secondary psychopathy, is roughly believed to represent about 5% of the population. But when you take into consideration that most of the diagnostic interviews take place within the prison system, it's really hard to imagine that that number isn't actually much higher. But it's not easy to find people who are qualified to administer that measure. And that's one of the reasons why I wrote my book, because there should be more diagnostic opportunities, there should be more research, there should be more treatment interventions. There is a tremendous amount of research that indicates that sociopathy is receptive to treatment, particularly when started early.
19:36 Speaker 02 I remember hearing the word sociopath and I remember when I would try to find a definition or an example of it, it was always these really sensationalized extreme examples over and over again, which is not to say that that's not an accurate example of an extreme sociopathic personality.
19:58 Speaker 01 Right.
19:59 Speaker 02 But it's not the only example. By only focusing on the extreme, we continue to exacerbate the problem.
20:05 Speaker 01 Have you had much pushback on that kind of idea since the book came out?
20:08 Speaker 02 No, they, and if they have, I haven't been the recipient of that, of that direct conversation and I welcome that conversation. I, again, this isn't I'm right, you're wrong, or you're right, I'm wrong. This is a personality disorder and there are so many nuances that I believe are grossly under-researched and misunderstood.
20:31 Speaker 01 During this time, you were also working in Hollywood, which I think is really funny that you write, you know, it seems like the perfect industry for a person who is a sociopath. But at a certain point-
20:45 Speaker 02 I agree.
20:46 Speaker 01 -you decided to stop working in the music industry in Hollywood and do a PhD instead. Can you describe that moment?
20:52 Speaker 02 I remember really struggling with that decision. It was a risk because the people that I wanted to study, nobody really cared about. And I really wanted to understand myself better first and foremost. And it was going to require a lot of work, whereas the music industry was just this unchecked environment in which I could just stay hidden and-
21:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:15 Speaker 02 -not really do much self-reflection. I didn't really understand that in pursuing a PhD in psychology, I would be forced to learn about all types of different personalities, which-
21:27 Speaker 01 Right.
21:28 Speaker 02 I probably should have, but I, in learning about all these other personality types, it really helped inform my understanding of myself. And, and I remember being told that in order to graduate, I had to log hundreds of clinical hours working as a therapist. And I remember going into that kicking and screaming. It was the last thing I wanted to do. But again, I'm really glad that I had to because sitting in a room, listening to people talk about their struggles at first sounded like a hellscape, but eventually I found that it was a lot like breaking and entering into the homes that I had been breaking and
22:11 Speaker 02 entering for most of my life, only instead of breaking into these people's minds, I was given access. They were inviting me in and it helped me understand everything about the human condition.
22:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a very unexpected thing to hear about a therapist who is a sociopath.
22:29 Speaker 02 I'm kidding.
22:32 Speaker 01 One thing I'm wondering is, so early on in the book, you write, "I'm a liar, I'm a thief, I'm highly manipulative, I don't care what other people think, rules do not factor in my decision making, I'm capable of almost anything." And in a few reviews online, that's led people to wonder about the veracity of your memoir. You know, if you don't care about rules and should we be wary of what was written? What do you make of that?
22:55 Speaker 02 I understand it. Listen, I know that my stories are true, but I also understand that not everybody's going to believe that. When I think about people's skepticism, I welcome it in the sense that I would love for people to be so skeptical of me that they go out and they do their own research. They, they try to prove me wrong because I, I feel that if everybody who read my book or was skeptical of the message that I'm trying to convey, went out and did their own research, the narrative around sociopathy and psychopathy would start to shift. And that's the main reason that I wrote the book to begin with. I think what's more problematic is less the skepticism and more that
23:35 Speaker 02 You know, I'm finding by virtue of the fact that I have outed myself as a sociopath that some people are reacting to me of ideas of who I am and more concerning who they want me to be. They want me to be a liar. They want me to be fake. They want me to be that stereotypical sociopath. And I find that to be particularly problematic because if people are going to insist on their version of sociopathy being the only version, this extreme, untreatable, unrepresented version, then other people like me are going to be very reluctant to come forward, very reluctant to seek treatment. They won't want to advocate for themselves. And that's my bigger concern.
24:20 Speaker 01 In the buzz around Patrick's memoir, there's also been some questions raised online and in some reviews about the veracity of her PhD, whether she actually completed her PhD in clinical psychology, because people can't seem to find her dissertation. We put those questions to Patrick, and she was able to give us the name of her dissertation, the year she got her PhD, and the school she got it at. And we put all of those details to the school. It's a private university called the California Graduate Institute of the Chicago School of Psychology. And they confirmed she did, in fact, get her PhD in clinical psychology from there.
24:58 Speaker 02 I believe that those who don't believe it, they simply don't want to believe it. And I understand that. The things that I am saying are not convenient. I think that the idea that most people have have come to understand about sociopathy is that it's very easy to spot. You would know if you were sleeping next to one. You would know if you were friends with one. You would know if you gave birth to one. And what I'm saying is very different. And that's uncomfortable for people to take in.
25:27 Speaker 01 What is life like for you these days? You're now a wife, you're a mom. Do you still struggle with that rising tension and stress? Do you, how do you parent with your personality type?
25:38 Speaker 02 You know, it's, again, I understand the social emotions cognitively and to a certain extent emotionally. I have grown those emotions. They do resonate with me beyond the cognitive. But even if they didn't, I am capable of raising pro-social children in much the same way that as a woman, I'm able to raise male children. I understand these concepts, therefore I can teach these concepts. In terms of my stress, I, it's funny, someone asked me this a couple of days ago. And if I had been asked this question a month ago, I would have told you that I hadn't experienced the stress in quite some time.
26:19 Speaker 02 But I have found that this experience of promoting this book and, and being away from my family for stretches at a time, I've felt a little bit of the, of that.
26:32 Speaker 01 And so how do you manage that now? What are your strategies now for either addressing it when it does pop up or keeping it at bay?
26:39 Speaker 02 The exact opposite of how I used to do it, which is before I used to try to run, outrun the apathy or fill the apathy with something else. Now I lean into it. Before, I constantly felt as though I was required to act in a way that didn't feel authentic to me in order to enjoy the perks of society.
26:58 Speaker 01 So like pretend to be happy and friendly kind of thing?
27:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, not necessarily happy and friendly, but pretend to care about things. Pretend to empathize, pretend to have enthusiasm. And what I've found that constantly wearing that mask, constantly having to pretend, it really made me very isolated. And the isolation also drove a lot of that destructive behavior. What I do now is I communicate. If someone says, are you so excited about this? I just say, no, no, I'm not. I can't access that feeling. I wish I could, but I can't. Same with my children. My kids are young. I share transparently and age appropriately, but there are some times where I have to say, mommy doesn't really understand those emotions very well. Maybe I can help you in a, in a different way because I don't want to fake it with
27:46 Speaker 02 my kids either. Now I just cop to it. No, I don't want to go to that party. I find that person very boring.
27:53 Speaker 01 It kind of sounds like the journey that all of us are on to try and be more authentic about what we want and don't want.
27:58 Speaker 02 You're not the only person that said that. And I, and I felt that way my whole life in terms of people pleasing is a great example, you know.
28:05 Speaker 01 Right.
28:06 Speaker 02 People who really, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to make people in your life happy. I'm not suggesting otherwise, but it's, but once it starts to become a sacrifice, you know, where you are constantly depleting your own reserves. I, I don't do that. And I encourage other people in my life not to do that as well, because I think that that is also inauthentic in its own way.
28:28 Speaker 01 That is Patrick Gagny, former therapist, now advocate and author of Sociopath, A Memoir. And that is it for All in the Mind this week. Thanks to producer Rose Kerr and sound engineer Tegan Nichols. I'm Sana Qadar. Thank you for listening. I'll catch you next time.
28:57 Speaker 03 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC Podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous The skills supercommunicators use (and how you can learn them) Next What influences your inner voice? Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated