Pod Insights All In The Mind How the housing crisis is warping people's view of the future About this episode Madi's had 25 rental applications rejected. Seen absolute horror houses while searching for a rental. It's all driving her to despair.
Today, how housing insecurity can alter our sense of agency and how we perceive the world around us.
This episode was first broadcast in May 2024.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:10 Speaker 01 Is there one place that's been like the worst place you've seen in your hunt for a rental?
0:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, actually, one immediately came into my mind because it was traumatizing. Like, walked into this place and the line was out the door and this street was super narrow and there were so many cars. It felt like people were in a panic because they wanted to make sure they could find a parking spot to get to the viewing on time. I think the property was about 650, almost 700 a week. And for a price like that, you'd expect it to have like a fresh coat of paint at least or some sort of recent renovation or maybe there's a dishwasher. Like something to sort of pull you in.
0:50 Speaker 01 Right.
0:51 Speaker 02 But I walked in and it just felt like someone had died in there is the best way I can explain it. Like, it just felt like it was being haunted. Everything was dusty and dark. It was old and had not been loved.
1:05 Speaker 01 This is long-term renter Maddie.
1:08 Speaker 02 And this house, they had a tiny, tiny staircase to go upstairs and everyone sort of just waiting at the bottom for an opportunity to go up and just folded arms and shared glances. And like, you could feel the negativity. They would just see more and more and more people lining up to go up the staircase. And you're like, this is never going to be my home. Like, I have to compete with all of these people and this place sucks. Like, this place is expensive and it sucks and I'm still going to fight with you guys to get it.
1:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:36 Speaker 02 It's just insane.
1:39 Speaker 01 What was at the top of the stairs, anything worth seeing in the end?
1:42 Speaker 02 Like, the tiniest, creepiest bedroom you've ever seen. It was so awful. And like, like, I've never been so sure in my life that someone died in a house. I don't think I've got any powers, but I walked in there, I was like, this is not right. I'm certainly not paying 650 for that.
1:55 Speaker 01 Right. Maddie might be laughing as she tells me about this haunted house, but it's been no joke trying to find a place to live. Forget trying to buy, that's impossible enough. Now trying to rent is a nightmare.
2:09 Speaker 02 We've probably been looking since January and attended at least 30 to 40 viewings and made at least 25 applications that so far have all been rejected.
2:23 Speaker 01 And with no signs of the housing and rental crisis easing anytime soon, you have to wonder about the psychological fallout of all of that.
2:31 Speaker 03 It makes sense when housing is such a central part of our experiences as humans, like where we dwell and the ability to dwell securely really is kind of the bedrock of the rest of our lives.
2:44 Speaker 04 We know that when people get constant knockbacks like that, we know that can lead to a sense of helplessness.
2:50 Speaker 05 I feel like I'm not dreaming as big in terms of the future.
2:54 Speaker 02 And it's just had quite an intense effect on my mental health and how I sort of look at society as a whole. That might sound a bit dramatic, but that's, that's sort of where it's pushed me.
3:09 Speaker 01 This is All in the Mind. I'm Sana Qadar. With the federal election now underway, we're replaying this episode from our archives because the crisis remains a crisis and it's weighing on a lot of voters. So today, how the housing crisis is warping the way people think about their futures, make decisions about their futures, their very sense of having agency over their lives.
3:43 Speaker 02 Yes, so I'm in the front courtyard. I'm looking at a relatively dreary gray sky, but...
3:51 Speaker 01 Maddie has been bouncing around rentals since she was 18 years old. But now at 26, she and her partner have had to do what a lot of young people are doing now. They've moved back in with her partner's family.
4:03 Speaker 02 Legs crossed in some Qantas pyjamas.
4:05 Speaker 01 And that's why she's chatting to me from outside on a cold Perth morning.
4:09 Speaker 02 And I don't want to wake everyone up within the house.
4:12 Speaker 01 Okay, fair enough, fair enough. And it's funny because it kind of illustrates the, the point of what we're going to talk about.
4:17 Speaker 02 Exactly. Did she? I was like, no, this will be great content. This is fine.
4:21 Speaker 01 Although she's grateful to have somewhere to land, this is definitely a Plan B or C or D scenario.
4:30 Speaker 02 You just feel like an inconvenience. My partner works late being a chef, so we sort of feel like we're disrupting the flow of the house. As accommodating as everyone is and as loving and caring as everyone is, you just feel like you're stepping on someone's territory and invading their space.
4:45 Speaker 01 In their last rental, Maddie and her partner had signed a two-year lease, but they were constantly being asked to leave or agree to a rent hike. And then the place was bought by new owners who offered them a deal they couldn't refuse.
4:58 Speaker 02 And they said that they would back pay us three months' rent if we were out by the first of April.
5:03 Speaker 01 Okay.
5:03 Speaker 02 So we rushed and raced to get that all done.
5:06 Speaker 01 All up, they were there a year and a half. And so dozens of viewings and rejected rental applications later, they're feeling more dejected than ever.
5:17 Speaker 01 And so how has all this upheaval affected you?
5:22 Speaker 02 It's sort of just made me feel less human. It's, it's really made me feel like I'm a product or like a service, like I need to sell myself to these real estate agents or these owners. It's making me feel like I'm sort of, you know, on the corner saying like, just please give me a house. Like, I don't know what else, what bells and whistles to put on, like what I need to do to be acceptable for one of these homes. Because, you know, you go to school, you try uni or you do whatever it is you want to do outside of uni. And then, you know, I've got a full-time job and my partner works full-time as well. How are we finding ourselves incapable of finding a home as two full-time income earners?
6:02 Speaker 01 Hmm.
6:03 Speaker 02 Like, what, what is it on our applications that's making us come across as not a viable option? It's just sort of made me very negatively introspective about, I should have saved more. I should be smarter with my money. I should be doing this and this, and this is what my parents had at this age. It's just really crushing.
6:25 Speaker 01 It's not surprising to hear about the toll that Maddie's hunt for a home has taken when you consider the fact that in a single generation, the Australian dream has basically died. It's getting harder and harder for young people, first time buyers, single people, all kinds of people to own a home, unless you have family that can help. And now with the rental crisis, it's like a generation is being kicked while they're already down.
6:50 Speaker 06 Australian median rent has hit a record high.
6:52 Speaker 01 Like, take this as an example. As of April 2024, the national median rent hit a new record high, $627 a week, according to CoreLogic, and that is 8.5% higher than the same time period in 2023.
7:08 Speaker 06 It's most pronounced in regional Australia.
7:10 Speaker 01 Of course, there have been housing crises before, and certain parts of society have long struggled with housing. But there are factors that make this crisis different.
7:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, so I guess I want to talk about the framing of crisis in the first place, because I find this pretty interesting, just thinking about the way that we talk about housing crisis, and I guess the acute kind of focus that that places on how bad things are at the moment.
7:36 Speaker 01 This is Priya Kunchan, a postdoctoral research fellow at the RMIT Centre for Urban Research.
7:43 Speaker 03 When we think about housing insecurity as an issue, it's really sort of been this commodification of housing post the Industrial Revolution, where people who are on lower incomes have always been experiencing some sort of housing stress. So at the moment, I think what we're seeing that is maybe qualitatively a little different is an increase in vulnerability for people that are more middle class, that have higher incomes, when they're seeing the low rates of affordable rentals and looking towards the future, not necessarily being able to guarantee that they'll be able to fulfill the Australian dream of homeownership. And, you know, that pressure is definitely not experienced the same way. Like, money definitely mediates that experience, so that some people
8:28 Speaker 03 may be able to quite easily absorb a rent hike. It won't be pleasant, but it's not something that... That's going to put them into extreme financial stress. Whereas other people will then be forced to say, move house and then, you know, cop the massive cost of moving house, which is a very expensive process. And have all of that added insecurity of not being sure if they can find a place because there's so much competition for cheaper rentals.
8:56 Speaker 01 Priya has been studying the emotional impact of the crisis on a group of renters in Melbourne. It's part of a broader three-year-long project at RMIT called Precarious Dwelling: Encounters with the Housing Crisis. The project has an Australian Research Council grant behind it, which is a pretty big deal in this current research climate where money is tight.
9:19 Speaker 03 For this project, what we were interested in is, you know, this experiential kind of aspect of the housing crisis. And actually taking the way that people are made to feel about their situations as a source of deep investigation. And for that, it meant that we didn't speak to a huge amount of people. We started out by putting out a survey where people would self-select in terms of self-identifying that they were experiencing housing insecurity. It's a bit of an interesting way to go about it is to, rather than say, oh, what is your income versus how much money are you paying in rent? It was saying, do you feel insecure in your housing?
10:02 Speaker 03 If you feel insecure in your housing, can you tell us a little bit about what that means to you? Because that actually allowed us to capture some of those folks who may not have been extremely economically insecure. There certainly were quite a few people that I spoke to who were. But also provides a different aspect of what security means to people in terms of their housing. So I ended up speaking to 11 private renters. And we did a series of two interviews. And we really talked about what makes a place feel like home. And I asked them to take me to a place or to multiple places that were important to them, that had a specific significance to their housing journey.
10:44 Speaker 03 And that either really felt like home or really made them think about that question of home. So it could have been a place where they didn't feel like they belonged.
10:52 Speaker 01 Some people took Priya to neighbourhoods they used to live in, like Footscray in Melbourne's West, or to parks that held special meaning to them, like Derbin Parklands in Melbourne's North. And another person who had been homeless for a few years took Priya to a public library that they spent most of their time in while they were sleeping rough. And one other person chose a McDonald's to meet in because it was where they had spent a lot of their time with their kids.
11:20 Speaker 03 We spoke to a couple of parents. We spoke to a couple of single people that were share housing. Some people had, you know, middle-class incomes. Some people, their primary source of income was Centrelink.
11:33 Speaker 01 And it is a pretty small sample size, though, overall. Why, why do you feel like what this group was able to tell you is still significant enough that it can give us something of value to understand the issue writ large?
11:46 Speaker 03 No, this is, this is an important question, a good question, because the goal was to go deep and to look at the various places where policy instruments were government decisions and where non-government entities touched people's lives. We were interested in putting those experiences into context. So rather than necessarily looking at a representative sample, and I think both in terms of the practicality of having a small research team, but also in terms of honouring the stories that people told us, we wanted to kind of get, I guess, a set of vignettes that then give us a broader picture
12:28 Speaker 03 of what it means to say housing crisis in this place at this time.
12:32 Speaker 01 And so when you ask them, what felt like home? That's a really interesting question. What, what did people say to you? What felt like home? What made a place feel like home?
12:40 Speaker 03 So it does really come back to that question of whether you can see yourself in the future and then where you see yourself in the future. And being able to sustain a tendency, being able to put that worry to the side so that they can then think about things like investing and being in place. Was something that was so important to people. And I, you know, really heard across several interviews, this real feeling of disappointment for people who had maybe spent several years, you know, hanging on to various tendencies in the one suburb. And so they'd been able to invest in place in terms of building relationships with neighbors, participating in local politics.
13:24 Speaker 03 But then being priced out of those areas was a massive disjuncture for people. So actually having the time and the ability to look into the future and say, I'm still going to be here in X amount of years, allowed people to really start settling in and feeling like they were at home.
13:44 Speaker 01 And so when people were on shaky ground and were at risk of losing that, when they didn't have that security in their future, how did that affect their view of the future?
13:54 Speaker 03 Well, some of the conversations that I had got to a bit of a dark place. The way that living through a time of ongoing, rolling housing crises has almost forced people to really lower their expectations about what is a reasonable standard of living. And the trade offs that people are making have become normalized was, you know, concerning, whether that was making sure that they could pay rent. So that meant that they neglected their healthcare or they neglected activities that brought them a sense of joy and well being. It's a very reasonable conclusion for people to make
14:39 Speaker 03 because they're just trying to stay in their housing. But the very sort of matter of fact way that people spoke about it, where they were like, well, this is the only option. I can't really see the possibility for change.
14:52 Speaker 03 You know, this idea of a constricted sense of time where you're always living in that moment before a crisis, the idea of being in that constant tension was something that resonated across a lot of the interviews. And yeah, it just this feeling like their lives, their housing was at the whims of others. So not having that sense of agency because it was somebody else's decision to sell the property. It was somebody else's decision to raise the rent. It was someone else's decision to come in and crack down on subletting.
15:30 Speaker 01 This lack of a sense of agency, it came up again and again in my conversations with people while putting together this episode. And I want to drill down on that a bit more because it ties into a concept in psychology called locus of control. And this can influence how we think and behave in ways both subtle and profound.
15:51 Speaker 04 A sense of agency or a sense of locus of control, we sort of use the terms interchangeably in psychology. There's two parts to it. There's there's internal locus of control and external locus of control.
16:03 Speaker 01 This is Jean Hodgins, an associate professor in the School of Psychology at Charles Sturt University. And he's also a clinical psychologist.
16:11 Speaker 04 So a sense of agency or locus of control, if you like, is how much people feel that they actually have control over the outcomes in their lives. It's their perception, if you like. It might necessarily be reality, but it's their perception of what's causing the main events in their life. So someone with an internal locus of control will be more likely to believe that things that happen to them are influenced by them. They're influenced by their abilities, by their actions, or even by their mistakes sometimes. A person with an external locus of control, on the other hand, feels that forces outside of them, so things like random chance, you know, things in the environment, the actions of others,
16:53 Speaker 04 are actually more likely to be responsible for what's happening for them.
16:57 Speaker 01 He says generally, research has found that people who have a more internal locus of control.
17:02 Speaker 04 So people believe that things in their lives are within their control, are within their power.
17:08 Speaker 01 Tend to.
17:09 Speaker 04 Have higher levels of resilience. They tend to have lower levels of depression and anxiety.
17:13 Speaker 01 That's because these people have a sense of power over their lives. They don't feel helpless. And just a quick aside before I tie this back to the housing crisis. Jean says this sense of agency operates on a continuum.
17:27 Speaker 04 So some people have, you know, very internal locus of control. Some people have very external locus of control. And being at either extreme end of that continuum is probably not the best. So let's say that you believe absolutely everything is in your control. Then that's where we actually start, you know, getting into areas like narcissism, where you might believe that you're in control of the weather, or you're in control of the government, or you're in control of everything that's going on around you. And of course, that's not healthy. In just the same way as it's not healthy to have a totally external locus of control, to believe that you absolutely have no power over anything. So we tend to talk about having a healthy internal locus of control or a moderate internal locus of control
18:10 Speaker 04 to get the best benefit, I suppose, when it comes to resilience and better wellbeing.
18:17 Speaker 04 What's important about it is it gives you a sense of agency into the future. So if you believe that you've got certain levels of control over what happens in your life, then you're more likely, I suppose, to try hard. So, you know, a really good example is, you know, in an exam or in a job interview. If you believe you've got some power over the outcome of that exam, then you'll study for the exam and you'll try really hard for the exam. Or you'll study for the interview and you'll try hard for the interview. Whereas if people have more of an external locus of control, that can often lead to feeling like, you know, why even bother? So if you believe that you've got no control over the exam because your professor or your school teacher hates you
19:01 Speaker 04 and they're going to fail you anyway, then you're probably less likely to try. And so what's unfortunate, I suppose, is that sometimes when people have an external locus of control, they become more helpless. And then, of course, that leads to a reinforcing cycle, where actually things do become outside their area of control because things are happening to them and they don't even try.
19:22 Speaker 01 So if we bring it back to the housing crisis, which clearly is impacting many people's sense of having control and agency over their lives, could that also be shifting their overall locus of control?
19:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, the housing crisis and people's sense of agency is really interesting concept. There's a little bit of research around, not so much for the housing crisis, but with homelessness. There's some research to show that the people with healthy levels of internal locus of control are less likely to be homeless. When it comes to the housing crisis, and I suppose, you know, people not being able to, you know, perhaps afford deposits or afford mortgages, you know, even rent to some extent. The research is not as clear, there's not as much research around. But certainly, if we take it back to first principles, what we do know is that, say in a housing crisis where you keep on putting in for housing, you know, to rent,
20:17 Speaker 04 and you keep on getting knocked back, or you keep on finding that the house that you're after is just, it's worth too much, you can't afford the rent, or you can't afford the deposit. We know that when people get constant knockbacks like that, such as, you know, employment, we know that can lead to a sense of helplessness. It's nearly like a coping mechanism of why keep on trying? Going to keep on getting a bad outcome? And that learned helplessness certainly leads to having more chance of having external locus of control.
20:49 Speaker 01 And Jean says this can, in some circumstances, have long lasting effects.
20:54 Speaker 04 Human beings have this amazing ability, which often helps us, but sometimes doesn't, is to generalize. When something happens in one area, we tend to start thinking, well, this could happen in other areas as well. And so if we start to generalize that that hopelessness, generalize that sense of I don't have control over it, it could certainly then impact the way we act in the future in other situations.
21:18 Speaker 01 But he doesn't want to overplay the role of locus of control either. He says, you're better off thinking of it as one factor that can influence wellbeing and decision making, among many others.
21:29 Speaker 04 Locus control is just one way that people think about things that happen to them. And there's certainly other areas, you know, that are linked into locus of control, like, like self-esteem and aptitude and those sorts of things. But probably the most important thing about locus of control is that, is that it's not black and white, it's shades of grey. And we can find some people who can have lots and lots of things that seem to be within their control. You know, they've got lots of money, they can afford whatever they want, they can work wherever they want. Seemingly, they actually have a really external locus of control. So while it certainly can be something to be aware of, there's no doubt.
22:12 Speaker 04 And for some people, it can have a quite important impact on their well-being. It's a risk factor.
22:19 Speaker 01 And so for Maddie, who's been living with her partner's family after 25 of their rental applications were rejected in the last few months, some of this is starting to resonate.
22:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think the part of my like existence as a human has always been like, I feel a lot of shame. So that's just a personal thing. I don't know if that's where that came from, but that one's definitely just a baseline feeling I sometimes have. But when it comes to this instance in particular, it's sort of like shame around how you've spent your money and the decisions that you've made to get you to this point where you are so, you just feel like you've got no control. You know, you've lost your sense of autonomy or agency. And I do feel like I've failed, you know, I've got the job, I've tried to save the money, I'm trying to be an active member of my community, I'm trying to do all the things that I would expect of myself and that I think my family
23:13 Speaker 02 or the greater community would expect of me. And I just feel like unless I go work in the mines or, you know, go do something else, if I don't follow the career trajectory I actually wanted to follow, I might not ever get where I needed to get. So it's just sort of making me feel like my dreams are a little bit less obtainable now because of the finances of everything.
23:34 Speaker 01 Yeah. Are you, are you thinking of changing careers? Like, what, what did you want to be doing? And what do you feel like you should be doing now?
23:41 Speaker 02 Um, I don't, I don't want to change careers. I've always, I want to work in like politics or the social justice realm. Like, I've always been in the social services or community services based jobs. And that's what's made, made me the most happy.
23:54 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:55 Speaker 02 But I'm now thinking about something like mining or going into mining admin, just so that I might have a chance at getting a house or getting financial freedom. And it's, I never would have thought that I would think to do that. And I don't have any, any inclination to go do it, other than it feels like it's always necessary at this point.
24:16 Speaker 01 While Maddie's search for a rental continues, at the moment, she also feels like she has no control over her time.
24:23 Speaker 02 Like, I constantly have to ask work if I can leave early or go out for lunch or come in late so that I can attend a viewing. And I just don't feel like I have any control over if I can attend the viewing or when the viewing's going to be. You know, I don't have the ability to sort of just have alone time as well. Like, I have not had that in quite some time, which, you know, you need that to recharge for your mental health so that you can be a nice person and not just a snappy person all the time.
24:50 Speaker 01 Because you're always working or looking at viewings or can't afford it or all of that?
24:55 Speaker 02 All of it. Like, I'm either at work or out of viewing, or if I'm at home or with friends, I'm still thinking about viewings, or I'm thinking about how I should be working a second job to have more money coming in. Like, I should not have any free time because it means that I'm wasting time. Like, I'm sure you can hear it in my voice. It's like this sense of urgency constantly, that if I'm not doing something, then it will disappear and I won't have a chance. And it's just, you've got absolutely no control at all.
25:24 Speaker 01 And why did you want to share your experience? What do you hope speaking out will do?
25:29 Speaker 02 Well, I think I have so many friends in my life who are currently in rentals, but, you know, their rental agreements are coming to an end and they might find themselves in a similar position very soon. And I don't, I don't want anyone I love and care about to feel like this or to go through this. And I just think, I think people need to take into consideration people's context as well. You know, there are a lot of people, like my sibling, who stayed at home, you know, longer than I did and built up a nest egg and had some financial support when he first left the house. And he's doing a lot better than I am in terms of his trajectory for a house. But there are lots of people out there like myself who moved out at 18 or younger for, you know, whatever their
26:11 Speaker 02 reason might be, who have just constantly felt like they're behind. I think people just need to have a bit more empathy for the fact that not everyone comes from the same background or the same context. And everyone's doing the best that they can and they wouldn't be where they are by choice.
26:34 Speaker 01 That is 26-year-old Maddie from Perth. You also heard from Priya Kuntan from RMIT and Jean Hodgens from Charles Sturt University. This episode originally aired in May 2024, a year ago. But as we said at the start, with the federal election now underway and the housing crisis being a key issue on the minds of many voters, we thought it would be a good time to replay this episode. Now, before I go, we're planning an upcoming episode of All in the Mind on road rage, looking into what it is about being behind the wheel of a car that makes so many of
27:15 Speaker 01 us irrationally mad and makes us act in ways that we wouldn't necessarily act outside of the car. And so we want your stories of road rage, specifically your own reactions to things that have happened, times that you got irrationally, maybe foolishly, mad. So tell us what happened, how you handled it, how you felt afterwards. If you can record that in a voice memo and send it to us on [email protected] , we might include it in the episode. And so just to reiterate, we're looking not so much for stories about what other people did to you, but stories of what you perhaps did to others, or ways that you maybe reacted
27:57 Speaker 01 privately in your own car that you're not so proud of. Basically, we want you to fess up to your own road rage. And that is it for All in the Mind this week. Thanks to producer Rose Kerr and senior producer James Bullen. I'm Sana Qadar. Thanks for listening. I'll catch you next week.
28:57 Speaker 00 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous Fighting for focus in the age of distraction Next Dissecting the brain - live at the World Science Festival Brisbane Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated