Pod Insights The Agile Daily Standup - AgileDad Is the Party Over For Scrum Masters and Agile Coaches? About this episode Is the Party Over For Scrum Masters and Agile Coaches? Over the past decade, agile adoption in organizations has seen an upswing. Large enterprises—banks, insurance companies, automakers, and many others—have all been at the forefront of launching agile transformations to achieve business agility—the elusive elixir. The promise of increased flexibility, faster delivery, and enhanced collaboration across teams is almost impossible to resist in today’s competitive world, where markets change rapidly, bringing risks and opportunities. How to connect with AgileDad:- [website] https://www.agiledad.com/- [instagram] https://www.instagram.com/agile_coach/- [facebook] https://www.facebook.com/RealAgileDad/- [Linkedin] https://www.linkedin.com/in/leehenson/
Transcript 0:16 Speaker 00 To be or not to be, that is the question. But is it the question? I get so many questions regarding agile and its imminent death and dismemberment. The latest one is the party over for Scrum Masters and agile coaches? Why are companies rethinking all the agile roles? And I think that's a valid question. Over the past decade, agile adoption in organizations has seen a huge upswing. Large enterprises, banks, insurance companies, automakers, Department of Defense, entertainment, have all been in a forefront of launching agile transformations to achieve greater business agility. The promise of increased flexibility, faster delivery, enhanced collaboration across teams
0:59 Speaker 00 is almost impossible to resist in today's competitive world where markets change rapidly, bringing risks and opportunities. Scaled agile brought agile to the enterprise in many cases, and with it came a flurry of large-scale agile transformations. The rush to become agile overnight resulted in explosive demand for more Scrum Masters and agile coaches, the two roles that were the torchbearers of the transformation. However, a new development has emerged, especially recently. Companies are either reducing or pausing the hiring of agile roles. And I want you to know, if you're listening to this podcast, I just did air quotes when
1:41 Speaker 00 I said agile roles, because what we're seeing is the roles are still there, but the set of accountabilities tied to the roles is more focused on change management, quality management, and making certain that we understand agile from end to end. At one point, everybody, everybody gets so excited about execution of Agile that they lost focus of initiation, discovery, and all the things that were important to make things work. And it created this shift in the Agile landscape. Now, most organizations are shh and doing it silently. But some have gathered a lot of media attention. For example, Capital One, when they said, "We're going to fire all of our Scrum Masters," they eliminated more than 1,100 Agile positions just about a year ago.
2:24 Speaker 00 Interestingly, Capital One's official statement reveals a lot about how they went about their transformation. That approach, though not unique to them, is one of the key resources of the developing challenge. Here we go. Here's their quote. It says, "The Agile role in our tech organization was critical to our early transformation phases. But as our organization has matured, the natural next step is to integrate Agile delivery processes directly into our core engineering practices." So let me explain to you what that means. Translated, Agile runs in phases. Did I just say that? How about this? "I said Agile was a four-phased approach in 2015." Shh, that was 10 years ago.
3:09 Speaker 00 Agile runs in phases, and it does. They don't mention it explicitly here, but what they're trying to say is Agile, with a holistic focus, so Agile with a holistic focus on delivery, isn't going to work. It's not going to pan out. You need to focus on Agile end-to-end. In order to do that, some of the things that you need to do may not fall inside of that Agile umbrella. Wow. Agile coaches and educators are, are available in magnitude. But the problem is, many of them don't understand the entire thing from initiation, ideation, process design, and at the end, education. They don't understand all of the,
3:52 Speaker 00 the legal compliance and the, the regulatory and the governance that goes into the change management piece of this. So what's happening is you have this unfinished piece of work in the middle without any bookends. And Capital One's not alone. Freddie Mac let go of 75 Scrum Masters. There are countless others who, who are changing or shifting. Now, here's another secret. Ready?
4:15 Speaker 00 Many of these organizations are getting rid of Scrum Masters and hiring Agile project managers. I did those air quotes again. So what's an Agile project manager? It's a Scrum Master with different or other accountabilities. There we go. So buzzwords and certifications of our expertise and experience are starting to shift. People are hiring, especially niche skills. It's always been tricky, but in an eeriness to joining Agile bandwagon, many companies just prioritize style over substance. And they're blinded by the Agile industrial complex's flashy marketing and fly-by-night certifications. This is why you're starting to see organizations like the Scrum Alliance lean in on micro credentials.
4:57 Speaker 00 And one of the things that I've done is I've really started to focus on those micro credentials because I really think that's the aha or the ah that's going to give you the biggest impact in a short burst. While there may be, while they may be certified, many Scrum Masters and Agile coaches don't have the necessary background to operate in a complex technical environment that modern software development is all about. Without that background, they often remain on the outside of what's going on. Additionally, many Scrum Masters and Agile coaches haven't had organic growth or mentoring to hone their skills in change management. They were thrust into transformation with theoretical knowledge and they struggle to drive real change and innovation. And their presence in the organization has no significant impact on business results.
5:41 Speaker 00 So they're good to have, but not critical. So given there was no entry barrier regarding background or experience to being a Scrum Master and Agile coach, many of what we call "empty suits," air quotes again, found their way to these roles. All you needed was to shell out money, a lot of money, to get the coveted certification. And then with budgeting demand, there was a high probability that you would find a client somewhere that would take you in. It didn't help that most companies set a very low bar on expectations from Scrum Masters. They didn't need Scrum Masters for more than teaching Scrum, scheduling Scrum meetings, and updating Jira boards. It didn't matter if the Scrum Master didn't understand what the team was doing,
6:26 Speaker 00 neither the technology nor the domain. They made no attempt to learn them and that made them almost obsolete. All they had to do was carry the Scrum flag and continue ranting about the importance of adhering to the rules of Scrum. Do you hear the people? Oh, sorry. I was having a Les Mis moment. But they were merely facilitators. And they didn't facilitate the right things. Uh, there were so many quotes that I heard, you know, we have a lot of people, empty suits, who compare it, a lot of agile talk, but they have no real transformation experience. And this is where I launched an initiative at Agile Dad. So one of the things that I talk about is the difference with Agile Dad is it's agile training that doesn't suck. And I know that sounds horrible, but it's true.
7:11 Speaker 00 I'm telling you how the real world does agile, not just, you know, sure, I do offer certification classes, guilty as charged. But it's not so that you have the credential to letters behind your name. I want you to be able to go into the workplace and really make a difference. And I think that's one of the keys. And I think that in many organizations, you have team members who graduated from a university less than five years ago. They've never worked in a traditional waterfall environment. And, and they're, they're native agile users, but, but they don't understand agile implicitly. They just understand and focus on agile delivery. And when you have that, and they don't see the big picture of where agile came from, what the roots are, how they can better themselves. And then even worse, you have people who are in the organizations who've been there for a long time,
7:57 Speaker 00 who aren't focused on continual improvement.
8:00 Speaker 00 They're not trying to take the steps to advance their knowledge. And they're certainly not becoming strong coaches and strong leaders within the organization.
8:09 Speaker 00 So if you are a Scrum Master in an organization right now, I have a couple of pieces of advice for you. One is learn AI. If you are a Scrum Master and Agile coach and you don't know AI, you will be obsolete. Not because AI is going to take your job, but because someone who knows AI is going to take your job. That's just the way it is. Many Scrum Masters and Agile coaches don't come from a technology background and that's okay. But if you're not from a technology background, or even if you are, you should learn more about change management. You should learn more about quality management. You should learn more about systems thinking and understand things from end to end because the traditional role of a Scrum Master is folding into more of an Agile Project Manager. And I think that the big thing you need to understand
8:54 Speaker 00 is that if you're going to get training or coaching from an individual or an organization, you need to make sure that you're not just going for the low price leader. I saw a recent video and it made me shake my head and say, "That was a good video." And I said, "If you are getting Scrum training and you're paying less than a certain amount for it, it's not valid. It's just not, you get what you pay for." And I think that finding a trainer or coach that you have some type of attachment to, that you can relate to, that understands practical implementation of how to do things, is going to help you and your organization embrace Agile more successfully. That's going to do it. I hope you enjoyed this episode. If you have a topic you want us to discuss, learn more at agiledad.com. We'd love to hear from you. And as always, we encourage you to stay healthy, stay well, and stay agile, my friends. Until next time, do take care.
Previous Five Most Forgotten Parts From The Scrum Guide Next Three Ways to Handle Unfinished Work - Mike Cohn Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated