Pod Insights The Agile Daily Standup - AgileDad Is Agile Coaching a Waste of Money? About this episode Is Agile Coaching a Waste of Money?
Around the world, software organizations are desperately trying to improve how their teams build and deliver software. Companies will hire herds of “wise sage” coaches to bring them out of the Dark Ages but are often disappointed when nothing extraordinary happens. Despite pouring loads of money into coaching efforts, their applications still fail to perform, their customers are still not having their needs met, and it still takes forever to get an idea to become reality. This project is 50% over budget, that one has missed three delivery dates now, and nothing seems to be going as planned. While all this is going on, agile coaches are hard at work “making the world a better place.”
How to connect with AgileDad:
- [website] https://www.agiledad.com/ https://www.agiledad.com/
- [instagram] https://www.instagram.com/agile_coach/ https://www.instagram.com/agile_coach/
- [facebook] https://www.facebook.com/RealAgileDad/ https://www.facebook.com/RealAgileDad/
- [Linkedin] https://www.linkedin.com/in/leehenson/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/leehenson/
Transcript 0:16 Speaker 00 I recently had an executive come up to me and we were having a conversation about agile coaching. And I think what was most interesting is that they came in with the approach that agile coaching is like wasting money. And it made me feel a little bit sad because I provided agile coaching in the past that's really, really effective. But I wanted to take, I wanted to hear his take on it. I wanted to hear what he had to say. And I was completely surprised when he sent an email to me. And this is kind of the gist of what the email said. "Around the world, software organizations are desperately trying to improve how their teams build and deliver software.
0:58 Speaker 00 Companies will hire herds of wise, sage coaches to bring them out of the dark ages, but are often disappointed when nothing extraordinary happens. Despite pouring loads of money into coaching efforts, their applications still fail to perform, their customers are still not getting their needs met, and it still takes forever to get an idea to become a reality. The project runs 50% of our budget. That one has missed three delivery dates. Nothing seems to be going as planned. And while all of this is going on, coaches are hard at work making the world a better place. Let's stop." Okay. A few observations here.
1:38 Speaker 00 One, one of the things that I always teach my coaches when I go out and coach a client is when you're out on an agile coaching engagement, your job is to work your way out of a job. I don't want you to have to go back there unless it's just to check in on a success or work with another group or another team. If you're there long-term, you are helping burn through their budget and you're not delivering value. And I think this lends itself to a couple of symptoms. So the first symptom I wanted to briefly discuss is if you have too many things in progress. So work in progress limits. If you've got too many things flying in the air at the same time, whether it's a software delivery, hardware delivery, product to service delivery, doesn't matter. If you've got too many things going on, you're going to see the extension of our budget.
2:22 Speaker 00 You're going to see dates slip and not progress. Limiting focus is what helps you or expanding focus and limiting whip is what helps you get there, right? We need expanded focus, driven focus, and we need to limit whip. The second thing that comes to mind is symptom is that your organization hasn't hired the right agile coach. Now, this is where it gets interesting. Most agile coaches work on what I call the big three model. And what I mean by that is the big three organizations that do coaching, consulting, and those types of things, they operate on a premise of we need to generate as much money as we can. We need to have as many billable hours as possible. We're not here to solve your problems and move on.
3:04 Speaker 00 We're here to embed ourselves until your budget is out and then we'll help solve your problem at the end. And it's a nightmarish thing, but I've actually had friends who work for those big three companies and operated under that model. It's quite scary. Obviously, every company is different and there are no silver bullet answers, but there are patterns that frequently occur in the business world. That is true. The reality is that leaders can often be part of the problem. That is also true. Inhibiting effectiveness of agile coaches themselves. Instead of allowing coaches to come and do their jobs without interference, they often leap into the fray and make things worse, often not realizing what little visibility they actually have. Periodically, a leader is brought into who has, I'm sorry.
3:49 Speaker 00 Periodically, a leader is brought in who actually has solutions to our problems and everyone in the organization runs to the other side of the boat because that's where leadership told them to go. Simon says embrace safe. Simon says, stop using safe. Simon says, feel empowered. Simon says, submit detailed approval request. Simon says, give us feedback. Oh, no, wait. It just says, give us feedback. Simon didn't say. And year after year, nothing gets any better. If you wake up in the morning, just hoping to survive until the next organizational shift, you are not alone in that boat. It's a vicious cycle. Like, it eventually escalates to the point of drastic measures, like shifting to an offshore workforce,
4:32 Speaker 00 or outsourcing external vendors because our own workforce just can't be trusted. Unfortunately, these solutions don't address the real root cause of the problem. All too often, leadership is sitting on the bridge of the ship, listening to the guys in the lookout tower, who forgot to bring binoculars or even a flashlight. After all, leaders rarely want to just sit there when things get tough at their business. They want to do something about it. Sadly, they sometimes turn the ship directly toward danger, when things would have been fine if they just stayed the course. These periodic massive pivots often derail the efforts of change agents actively working down below, uh, before we can reasonably ask to resolve the problems or solve the issues. It might help if those of us who are leaders
5:17 Speaker 00 stop getting in the way. Leaders should never make decisions that are based solely on part of the iceberg that they can see ahead of them. This is a surefire way to put their ship at the bottom of the ocean. Instead, why not allow those closer to the ground to weigh in on the game plan and ensure it actually works and doesn't hamper or obliterate the progress?
5:40 Speaker 00 I think the question here becomes, what makes a great leader? What makes a leader exceptional? And I have a couple of just thoughts on this. I'll share these brief thoughts because I think this is going to help. So number one, leaders relentlessly invest in those underneath them and expect them to do the same for others, to uplift each other. They actively listen and mentor each person from a position of trust and accountability. I love that. Number two, they cast a clear vision for what other teams can achieve if we all work together. We're all in this together. Sorry, I had a high school musical moment there. Number three, they identify every high performing individual in their group
6:23 Speaker 00 and reward them in a meaningful way, instead of rewarding with more work. Yes, I went there. Number four, they identify those who are not high performing and encourage them to improve while still holding them accountable. I think that's important, but I think the key is encouraging them to improve. Sometimes somebody just says, I'm stuck. I don't know the subject matter. I just don't know where to go with this and that's fine, but you can't always be that way. All right, let's go with five. They do their best to trust their people and avoid making decisions that create roadblocks or speed bumps. In other words, they stay out of the way. That's interesting. If every leader in the organization prioritized these things, the company would be forced to be wrecked with it.
7:08 Speaker 00 They would be unstoppable. Best of all, the company's agile coaches would have so much room to breathe that they could actually focus on making improvements on the things that you've been waiting for, the things that are going to make it more operationally efficient. So what about these coaches? Who are they? Who are the coaches and what do you look for? While there's plenty to say about leadership, but it's not like all agile coaches are off the hook. If you've worked with a coach in the past, I'm sure that at least some of the time doesn't feel fruitful in hindsight. Can you point to a real return on investment from the whole, for any entire experience? What was actually being measured during that time? Was there data to show clear improvement?
7:53 Speaker 00 Did things get measured and aligned with and positively impact your company's goals? The answers to these questions depend on what kind of agile coach you work with. What I've found is primarily there's two types of coaches. There's two types of agile coaches and they both sit kind of at each end of the spectrum with some middle ground in between. The first one is general practitioner. This refers to a standard team focused agile coach who puts every new patient through a lengthy physical exam. They accomplish this through several weeks of test observations, concert, conversations and follow ups to ensure all of the problem areas are identified. Once this is complete, a list of identified problem areas, recommendations and prescriptions
8:37 Speaker 00 are documented and presented to the patient. Then the patient is asked to come back in three months to start the process over again with another physical exam to see where improvement has occurred. On the opposite end of the spectrum is what I like to refer to as the self-help blogger. This refers to a newer and more modern agile coach who wants to make patients better at scale. It's not enough for them just to focus on one patient at a time. So instead, all the patients are presented with a predefined cookie cutter list of things to remember and work on. In essence, these coaches ask their patients to perform surgery on themselves. These are the ones that I picture have those inspirational posters on their walls, you know, sail well, fly sore together, you know, right?
9:20 Speaker 00 Both of these coaches have very admirable goals that drive how they operate. The general practitioner is more focused on specific needs of their patients. However, they often provide so much information that patients get overwhelmed and don't know where to start. The process is incredibly slow. In contrast, self-help blogger is a pivot meant to provide improvement at scale because team by team approach that was used historically takes forever to show progress. This is especially true when there aren't enough coaches to go around. When this happens, low performing teams can sit for months without any coaching because the coach hasn't been able to get to them yet. But this new approach is more effective, right? Not quite.
10:02 Speaker 00 The problem with the modern agile coaching technique or the newer approach is that's too disconnected from teams and it isn't addressing the real issues they're currently experiencing. When coaching at scale, coaches inevitably want to talk more than listen because they're often tricked into thinking that talking is how they can have the greatest impact. As a result, they end up recording hours and hours of presentations to go at all the pages of insight they've written in confluence. After they're done, they pat themselves on the back for being so helpful to the teams being served, when in reality, the masses are no closer to getting their specific questions answered than they were before. These coaches aren't providing actual solutions to your problems. Instead, they're sharing solutions to problems some other team had however long ago.
10:48 Speaker 00 Those of us who are self-help bloggers are confident that we have all the answers based on years or decades of agile experience. So it seems reasonable for us to disseminate that knowledge from our ivory tower in the hills. It's often assumed that teams will perfectly understand what we're communicating with nothing getting lost in translation, but this is simply not true. Inevitably, someone will end up with a proverbial swing going through the middle of the tree. Maybe you've watched that happen in your organization. So the burning question becomes, how do agile coaches find a middle ground and improve organizations at scale without becoming irrelevant and tone deaf?
11:29 Speaker 00 In other words, how can you combine the best aspects of both of those coaching styles? The end game sadly is a focus on metrics and analytics, but this focus must be used correctly. I often hear weapon weaponized metrics and analytics, right? If your spidey senses went off, you know exactly what I'm talking about. After all, you've seen well-meaning leaders who care about numbers.
11:58 Speaker 00 They care more about the numbers more than they do about the behaviors of those numbers that are intended to drive or intended to represent. The problem is the metrics and analytics. It's how they're used to weaponize. Metrics should always be viewed as a discussion starter or a red flag waving. If a team has a metric outside of the target range, that doesn't necessarily mean they're doing something incorrectly. There may not be a problem at all. It just means that we need to have a conversation to understand why the data looks the way that it does and hopefully learn something in the process. More often than not, discussions tend to highlight the dysfunctional process that are enforced organizationally. We shouldn't assume that out of bound metrics highlight the team problem.
12:42 Speaker 00 Either way, we'll never know unless we have the conversation. Today's agile coaches are almost universally aware that the agile agile values, individuals and interactions, yet some coach teams to go out of their way to avoid individuals and interactions, which is interesting. Thus, the solution to scaling agile coaching isn't to separate ourselves from the teams who need us. Instead, we must use data responsibly.
13:08 Speaker 00 To determine who needs us the most. That way, we're focusing on the teams whose improvement will have the most bang for their corporate butt. We can't wait for them to come to us. Why? Because the teams who need us the most are probably just trying to hide just below the radar and keep their head above water. And that's not who's knocking at our door typically. That's going to do it for this episode. I hope that you enjoyed it. If you have a topic you want us to discuss, learn more at agiledad.com. We would love to hear from you. As always, we encourage you to stay healthy, stay well, and stay out of my friends. Until next time, do take care. Bye now.
Previous Celebrating PI Day! Next The Lucky Green String Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated