Pod Insights The Agile Daily Standup - AgileDad How to Give Feedback to High Performers on Your Team About this episode How to Give Feedback to High Performers on Your Team No one is perfect and that applies to high performers on your team too. They may be doing excellent work or exceeding your expectations, but that doesn’t make them flawless or leave them with no room for improvement or areas of growth. How to connect with AgileDad: - [website] https://www.agiledad.com/ - [instagram] https://www.instagram.com/agile_coach/ - [facebook] https://www.facebook.com/RealAgileDad/ - [Linkedin] https://www.linkedin.com/in/leehenson/
Transcript 0:15 Speaker 00 Have you ever found yourself trying to give feedback to high performers on your team? And not exactly knowing what to say? Or feeling like what you say might just be considered completely empty? I know for certain I've been in that situation before. And it's not because I don't appreciate what the high performers are doing. It's just sometimes we don't know the best way to give really good feedback to really good people. We have to start with an understanding that no one is perfect. And it also applies to the high performers on your team. They may be doing excellent work or exceeding your expectations, but it doesn't always make them flawless or leave them with no room for improvement. Especially, you know, they should always have an area where they could have some growth.
0:57 Speaker 00 Whether it's personal growth, professional growth, they should always have something. And not giving constructive feedback conveys that you don't care about them. You don't recognize them and don't appreciate the value they're bringing to the team. You're not doing enough. All you do is pass on those occasional remarks. So when I talk about occasional remarks, the thing that I'm talking about is like, when I went to the grocery store and the cashier says, "How are you doing today?" Or "How's your day so far?" If I say, "Girlfriend, pull up a chair. I've got a story to tell you." It would just be awkward and weird because the person who asked really didn't care how I was doing. They were just trying to say it in passing or say it to start a conversation. Or say it to help them pass their time.
1:42 Speaker 00 When in actuality, the sincerity of the gesture just wasn't there. It's the same as telling someone it's a high performer, "Oh, that was great," or "You rock." While you might even think that you're being sincere or that you mean what you say. When you try to use those simple phrases to tell someone how great they are, sometimes it could have a negative effect.
2:04 Speaker 00 Occasionally, it doesn't even inspire or motivate them or challenge them to do better. You know, rather, lack of clarity of development on development and growth areas can make them repeat behaviors that prevent them from reaching their highest and best potential. True stuff. Your high performers are highly valuable to the team, any organization. On occasion, they're up to 400 times, 400% more productive than an average performer. Losing them robs the organization of excellence while also incurring additional costs, time, and effort to hire a replacement. We don't ever want to wind up in that place where you have to hire someone or replace a high performer. Trust me, it's a nightmare. I've been there.
2:46 Speaker 00 Spending a significant amount of time with people on the team who aren't doing well, or those who need guidance to excel, that's not wrong. In fact, I'd argue it's right. It's just problematic when you do it at the cost of avoiding spending any time with the high performers. Oh, they're on cruise control. I hear people say those kinds of things all the time, and that could be detrimental. So I have a couple of quotes here. I have one from Marcus Buckingham. It says, "Talent is the multiplier. The more energy and attention you invest in it, the greater the yield. The time you spend with your best is quite simply your most productive time." I think that's true. I find that when you give constructive feedback to high performers, it helps them stay motivated,
3:29 Speaker 00 invested, and there are things you could do to help make sure that you are doing the right thing and that you're approaching them the correct way. So let's give you a short list. Right at the top, I'd say manage your ego. Now, when I say ego, I'm not trying to say in a negative way they're being egotistical. When I say manage your ego, I should also say maybe understand their ego. Every single person who is high performing got there because they are good at something, and they know they're good at it. So it's not so much...
4:03 Speaker 00 You accusing them of doing something negative. It's helping them govern the inner voice in their head and you governing the inner voice in your head. Don't ask yourself things like,
4:14 Speaker 00 I'm not going to say anything because what if it puts them off or what if they don't agree or what if they take it the wrong way? If you keep going down that path, it limits your communication and limits your ability to inspect and adapt. And it closes off the feedback loop, which is probably the worst part. So when you want to give good feedback, instead of saying something like, oh, you always come late to meetings and that's unacceptable. Try saying, I noticed in the last two meetings that you came in 10 to 15 minutes after the meeting started.
4:41 Speaker 00 How can you come to meetings on time and help set a good example for others? This way, you're not tearing someone down. You're just helping build everyone else up. Or instead of saying, you have great ideas to share, but you also have to let others speak up in discussions. Not letting others speak can be construed as rude. Say this instead, hearing diverse viewpoints help us all make better decisions. How can you help me encourage more participation from others in the discussions? I love that. Absolutely love that. And it's a different approach, right? How about this? Here's another quote. This one's from Kelly Patterson. It says, "Respect is like air. As long as it's present, nobody even thinks about it. But if you take it away, it's all that people think about.
5:25 Speaker 00 The instant people perceive disrespect in a conversation, the interaction is no longer about the original purpose. It's now about defending our dignity." How true is that, right? People take air for granted, but the second you take it away, people will fight with their life to get air, right?
5:44 Speaker 00 And that is exactly where high performing people sit. We need to make sure that we talk about actions and impact. High performance are the ones who most often do the impactful work. And that makes them super curious about how their actions contribute towards the goals or how their actions take away from goals. So it's important that we give honest feedback. I'm not saying it's not tricky because it is.
6:10 Speaker 00 When you get this type of feedback, it can easily result in people feeling heard or demoralized. And you're only aiming for candor. You're aiming for radical candor. Feedback that's smaller, more targeted, less personal, less judgmental and equally impactful. But it's sometimes it's not easy. I'll say that right now. It's not easy. So another thing that you could do to help.
6:31 Speaker 00 Get it all organized. I don't want to say compartmentalized, but organized is to chart out the plan for growth, right? High performers don't just like to stay busy. They want to know that what they're doing is making an impact. So they derive a sense of accomplishment from solving tough problems and seeking to push the boundaries of their own limits that they can be the best at what they do. So don't just assign work or don't just assign work to high performers for the sake of getting them to do work. Oftentimes, I refer to this as, hey, you've done such a fantastic job. You know, we really appreciate all that you put into this. So we're going to reward you with more work. That that that doesn't work, right?
7:14 Speaker 00 We need to remember part of charting it. Part of charting out a path is to make sure that we're beginning and ending with responsibility. We should always try to make conversation a two way street with our high performers. I've been in situations where we let the high performers say everything and everyone where everyone else in the team feels squelched. Or I've been in situations where we say everything trying to inspire and uplift the high performer, but don't give them a chance to comment or give feedback. If you're trying to do this constructive, you need to make sure it's a two way street. You shouldn't do all the talking and they shouldn't do all the talking. You need to make sure that if you recognize that you're making any assumptions or that you have any bias, that you're controlling your bias and that you're not just walking a mile in their
7:56 Speaker 00 shoes, but you're walking a mile in their shoes and remembering to take your own shoes off first. You need to become an effective listener. You need to make sure that you understand how to create a climate of trust and collaboration. Strong listening skills are the foundation for every solid relationship. Last but not least, I want to talk about follow up and follow through. There's a famous quote, I don't remember who said it, but it was, we judge ourselves by our intentions, but we judge others by their behaviors. That's why following through our commitments is such a critical component of making trust and establishing trust. When you make false promises, inconsistent actions, and unpredictable behavior, that all leads to a series of distrust.
8:41 Speaker 00 So don't make promises you can't keep. If you have discussions and you promise something, make sure that you follow through. Keep yourself in check, keep a working list of all the commitments that you have. Take time to make a timeline and focus your attention on your progress towards meeting your commitments and then schedule regular sync-ups, especially with high performers, leadership and others, to review what's going on to keep everybody on the same page. If you can do those things, it's going to help you increase and improve your communication skills and it's going to give the high performing members of your team a reason to love working with you. That's going to do it. I hope you enjoyed this episode. If you have a topic you want to discuss, learnmoreatagiledad.com. We'd love to hear from you. As always, we encourage you to stay healthy, stay well and stay agile, my friends. Until next time, do take care.
Previous 5 SuperPowers Every Facilitator Needs Next The Mindset of Highly Attractive People Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated