Pod Insights The Agile Daily Standup - AgileDad Agile Is Dead! Who Cares? About this episode Agile Is Dead! Who Cares? Many people despise Agile and claim it’s dead for good, while others still defend it. But now, with Agile Alliance joining the Project Management Institute (PMI), the future is anything but certain. How to connect with AgileDad: - [website] https://www.agiledad.com/ - [instagram] https://www.instagram.com/agile_coach/ - [facebook] https://www.facebook.com/RealAgileDad/ - [Linkedin] https://www.linkedin.com/in/leehenson/
Transcript 0:15 Speaker 00 Agile is Dead, Episode 9683.
0:22 Speaker 00 I thought that would just be a fun way to start. How many times am I going to bring you to Agile is Dead? So what? There's so many people who are still up in arms, even now, about the whole Agile Alliance joining PMI and what's going on. There's so many people out there who despise Agile. They want to say, "Ooh, Agile is dead, it's gone. We don't want anything to do with it anymore." There's so many organizations who tried SAFE and other scaling techniques and felt like they were too rigid or too heavy, too much overhead. And it's just caused them to put themselves in this rut, this endless rut of, "What do I do now?"
1:04 Speaker 00 And there is no, I've heard people say Agile 2.0, 3.0, there's just more. But I think this move from Agile Alliance was really, really interesting because while many perceived it as a last resort, I perceived it as something smart and a benefit for them to take. So here's the whole crux of it. People gradually lost interest in Agile conferences. And I think the cause behind that, the root cause, was the whole pandemic, right? COVID. People didn't want to meet in person. People were trying to find new ways to do things. And that was the advent of online conferences, where you'd have people from all over the world attend without having to get on a plane, and it was cheaper.
1:48 Speaker 00 And yeah, there's just, there's a lot of things that happen. But the Agile Conference, Agile 2023, 2024, that was the primary revenue stream for Agile Alliance. They didn't have classes that they offered or specific certifications. So they had no choice at some point but to find other distribution channels. PMI, on the other hand, is undoubtedly a strong distribution channel. Yet, many people still question whether or not this is the right move. So I want to give you some takeaway from a few different people, and I'm going to give you some quotes. And these are exact quotes from people who are involved at the core, right? So let's start with Mike Cohen. So Mike Cohen, everyone knows, full transparency, he's a dear friend of mine.
2:32 Speaker 00 He's also the co-founder of the Agile Alliance.
2:36 Speaker 00 So he doesn't perceive this merger as evil, per se, but he did go as far as to say it made him sad. Here's what he said. He said, quote, "As a co-founder of the Agile Alliance, this is not what we envisioned when we started that organization. I see the logic here. As Agile is a way of managing projects, and PMI wants to be all about all the best ways to manage projects. From its founding, the Agile Alliance depended on its big conferences for revenue. Since COVID, ding ding, that's declined. I actually like the PMI and don't see it as evil, but it still saddens me."
3:16 Speaker 00 And Mike is such a good guy. He's just a good person. And I can tell you in no way did he mean ill will or harm to anyone involved in these transactions. I can tell you another dear friend of mine, Bob Hartman, Agile Bob, he said that this is exciting and he sits as a board member on the new PMI Agile Alliance. And he is so excited and ecstatic. He says, "This is going to bring nothing but positive change to the world of project management. There's so many things that are going to happen in the near future that's going to revolutionize the way that we build products and projects." And I tend to lean and agree with him. I think that no one here has ill will or bad feelings.
4:01 Speaker 00 I feel like this is being made or construed into something bigger than what it really is because people sit on absolute opposing sides of the spectrum. That's what it boils down to. At the end of the day, it's not about doing Agile right or applying PMI Agile or or applying straight, you know, Agile this way or that way, right? It should be about creating value and impact for our customers and our business about being profitable. That's what we should care about. At the end of the day, are we building products and services to have a huge impact on customers? That people are actually interested in buying. That's what it's all about. Step back and ask yourselves, has the agile idea failed us?
4:44 Speaker 00 Or have we in turn misinterpreted or misapplied it? And this is a conversation I've been having a lot at agile leadership summits. I found that a lot of organizations who are leaning away from agile. Make it easy to blame agile and claim it's dead because they can't find. They don't want to see their own problems and solve their own problems. It's harder to look in the mirror and consider yourself a problem or consider something your organization's doing as a problem. It's easier to just point finger at agile and say, well, it's agile's fault. Agile's death. And I think that when people start discussing this. You are distracting from what matters. And that's getting the work done. The stuff that provides impact creates value.
5:28 Speaker 00 You, you need to get back in there and you need to get things done. I think for so long agile's just been this misunderstood sticky note buzzword. It's the magic wand to maximize delivery. I had one organization who remain unnamed. They called me into the organization and do some coaching. And they were so excited to have me personally go in and do the coaching. And one of the first things they said was, uh, you know, we are so excited to have you here. We know that you're going to revolutionize the way we do things and we're so happy about that. They said, we also want to warn you that XYZ company has a rich tradition of doing things a certain way. So we don't want to change what we're doing. We just want you to come in and agilify it. Can you make it a little more agile?
6:14 Speaker 00 Also, if you have somebody at scrum dust handy, handy, can you sprinkle some scrum dust on it and make it scrummy? Kind of like pixie dust. They really did say scrum dust. That scared the bejeebers out of me, right? I think that people need to get the reality of what's happening in the agile world. And I have said these four principles. I've said these four things more times than I care to count. If I had a half a cent for every time I said this, I'd be a kajillionaire. Here we go. Number one, agile is not a one size fits all processor framework, period. Just because you're doing the agile doesn't mean you're going to get agile results. You need to apply to things that make sense to your organization.
6:58 Speaker 00 And you need to make sure you're doing it in a way that's going to yield the greatest impact to your consumers internally and externally. Agile is not about a tool. That's number two. Mastering Jira or any other tool, DevOps, doesn't matter which one you're doing. It doesn't automatically make you agile. You can be doing exactly as the tool says. I hear people all the time say, we're doing the Jira agile, but it's just not working. I'm like, oh, I love Jira, but not this way, right? I think that people take, they invest so much in a tool that they want the tool to drive their process. Instead of letting the framework of what they do drive which tool they select, which is really interesting. Okay, here I, here goes the hardest one for me to swallow. Here we go. Number three.
7:41 Speaker 00 Certifications do not guarantee your business will become agile, period. I'm a certified Scrum trainer. I issue certifications and I'm saying this. Having a certified Scrum master, a certified Scrum product owner, that's great. As long as they got the training from the right place. Outside of that, it's a vanity metric. It's something you can feel good about, but it really doesn't mean anything unless your organization has engaged with the right trainer. Now, this is the part where I can sound a little self-serving, but I've helped organizations actually achieve true business agility. And as part of that journey, I've certified thousands and thousands, over 10,000 Scrum masters. Product owners, yeah, about four or 5,000 more.
8:24 Speaker 00 What I can tell you is these organizations are successful, not because the product owner got that certification, because the product owner got that certification from me. And I want to go on record and say, If you have a really good trainer, a really strong company that can help your organization with a transition and can teach people how to hit the ground running instead of just what the great book of Agile says, you're going to be in a much better place. But I think too many organizations lean in on the great big book of Agile and not on anything else, right? And then number four, and this is one that I've explained in multiple leadership summits, Agile does not work miracles. I tell people all the time, Agile is not going
9:07 Speaker 00 to help your team walk on water. You're not going to be able to raise the dead, whether it's a dead project or whatever. It's just going to help you gain better vision and know what you're doing. And it's going to give you a little bit more of a crystal ball than what you have before. It's going to make you more predictable. It's going to make it easier for you to figure out what you can actually do.
9:25 Speaker 00 And I can tell you, people, when I say these things, they get hurt, they get upset, they get frustrated. I've lost more gigs by telling people Agile is not one size fits all. There's no checklist you can have that's going to cover everything. Now, you can put together a playbook of things that you feel are in the best interest of organizations and measure how you're doing against a playbook, but you should never have a checkbox as, okay, that we did number one, let's do number two, you know. I mean, even I have the Agile 12-step program, but notice I said it was a program. And the first thing I tell you about, it's not all one size, it's not one size fits all, and it's not all or nothing, right? I said that right out of the gate. And I think that's important. If you are doing those things
10:10 Speaker 00 that I listed above incorrectly, you are actually hurting yourself by saying, and you're hurting Agile by saying you're doing Agile, because you're not. Here's what matters the most. I'm going to rattle off some things here. These are the things that, in my opinion, matter more than anything else you're doing. Learning of a process.
10:28 Speaker 00 If you're prioritizing continual learning over adapting a rigid process, you're going to be better off. Don't feel like you have to do every single step and save to be successful. You need to learn as you go and prioritize continual learning. Empowerment instead of control. Empowering teams to make decisions instead of enabling them, enforcing them to make change and not micromanaging them is the key to success there. Set a clear direction and not a strict path. Let everyone know we're moving this way, but it doesn't have to be between these guardrails. Make sure the people have a clear vision, but the flexibility to move as they need to, to go in that direction. You need to learn to embrace discomfort. Anytime you're uncomfortable, it means you're growing, right?
11:13 Speaker 00 Face uncertainty and change with a heads up. Take risks gradually. Embrace the unknown instead of searching for all the answers upfront. Don't try to use the "I need to know everything before I get started" approach. I remember someone very close to me said, "One day I want to get married." I said, "Okay." I said, "When do you want to get married?" He says, "Well, when I'm completely out of debt, I've finished my schooling, and I have at least this much money put away and saved." I'm like, "So you're going to retire? So you're going to retire from this life single? Because you're never going to get all that way, right? You're never going to be exactly where you need to be." Adapt your plans. Ditch plans when they become outdated or irrelevant. Don't stick with a plan just because it's a plan. It doesn't make any sense. And focus on current issues.
11:56 Speaker 00 Solving media problems while being aware of potential future challenges without letting the future challenges step in and block you. Be humble. Humility is so overlooked. You've got to be humble enough to admit that you were part of the problem and that you can step back and perform a health check at any point in a working model. I recently put together a couple of Scrum Master and Product Owner lists that you can look at just to kind of do an assessment and see where you are. And you can perform that health check that they're talking about on a working model. You can reflect on areas where you're ignorant and don't know anything about it and figure it out. You can learn and adapt and adjust and pivot. I think that if you can follow through.
12:37 Speaker 00 And really focus on understanding your target audience. Be humble and the world will teach you nice lessons. Be arrogant and you'll miss your chance to evolve. You'll miss your chance to become something bigger. Agile cannot survive when command and control reigns in an organization. Agile actually has a chance to succeed in curiosity, courage, and growth. Dominate your mindset. You have a growth mindset instead of a fixed mindset. Those are the things that are going to help you be successful. So I think when you start down this path of Agile's dead, we're all doomed. The doom and gloom campaign is over. We're done with that. It's time for us to move to the new campaign. And the new campaign is, I'm going to call it, I'm going to go back in time and call it the Jody Watley campaign. What have you done for me lately?
13:22 Speaker 00 If we can figure out what Agile has done for us and what we can do to support Agile, it's going to make it work in our organizations. I can tell you that firsthand. That's going to do it. I hope you enjoyed this episode. If you have a topic you want to discuss, learn more at agiledad.com. I'd love to hear from you. And as always, I encourage you to stay healthy, stay well, and stay agile, my friends. Until next time, do take care.
Previous Because People Are AMAZING! Next The Customer is Mostly Wrong? - Could It Be True? Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated