Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Who Was The Ultimate Tudor Traitor? About this episode The Tudor court was dangerous and high stakes at the best of times, where survival could often mean betraying others.
Enter: Jane Boleyn, thrust into the Tudor limelight when her sister-in-law, Anne Boleyn, marries Henry VIII.
Did she really contribute to the axe falling on Anne Boleyn's neck? Was she a spy for Thomas Cromwell? Was all of this just what it took to survive as a woman in this world?
Joining Anthony and Maddy today is the fantastic Philippa Gregory, historian and author of Boleyn Traitor https://www.philippagregory.com/books/boleyn-traitor#.
This episode was edited by Tom Delargy, and produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer is Charlotte Long.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers. Now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries. And I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Ant and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:53 Speaker 00 Adultery, incest, treason, insanity. The Tudor Court had it all.
1:01 Speaker 00 And in the eye of the storm was the wicked Lady Rochford, Jane Berlin. The woman, whose alleged testimony condemned her husband to death on the charge of incest with his own sister, Queen Anne Berlin. The deposition, which may have been the killing blow, delivered the siblings to the chopping block on Tower Hill. In a court notorious for chewing up and spitting out women, Jane Berlin kept her head longer than most. But her strategy for survival has marred her legacy. Was her testimony really the nail in the coffin for Anne and George? Was she really a conniving, jealous traitor driven to insanity? Or was she a skillful survivor in a system built for her destruction?
1:46 Speaker 00 From the heart of the Tudor Court, this is After Dark.
1:54 Speaker 01 It is a cold February morning in 1542, and inside the Tower of London, a woman waits to die. That woman is Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford, who once moved through the heart of Henry VIII’s court, but is now condemned, her mind frayed after months trapped inside these stone walls. The wife of George Boleyn, brother to the fallen former queen Anne, she outlived them both, only to stand on the brink of the scaffold herself beside another doomed young queen. The Tudor court promised splendor and status, but for so many of its women, it meant betrayal and ruin. Catherine of Aragon cast mercilessly aside,
2:39 Speaker 01 and Boleyn demonised and beheaded, Catherine Howard, here about to fall. Queens, wives, ladies-in-waiting, all pawns in a game where favour could vanish overnight. Jane’s crime is treason. Her reputation forever stained as wicked. Yet her story is more complicated. But as the winter light spreads across Tower Green, her time has come to walk towards the block, another casualty of Henry’s perilous court. This is After Dark, and this is the story of the Boleyn Traitor.
3:47 Speaker 01 Hello, my name is Anthony.
3:48 Speaker 00 And I’m Maddie.
3:49 Speaker 01 Now Tudor history is something we've enjoyed covering on a lot of previous After Dark episodes. We have covered the final days of Amber Lynn. We've talked about Tudor sweating, sickness, the plague, of course. But today we have something altogether more special than any of those. We are very, very excited to be joined by the incredible historian and author, Philippa Gregory. Philippa, welcome to After Dark.
4:15 Speaker 02 Thank you so much. Lovely to be here.
4:16 Speaker 01 Now, this is an exciting time because we have a brand new book called The Berlin Traitor coming out on the 7th of October 2025. We were talking about this before we came on air. You are heading into a really busy time. You're already in a really busy time. Just give us an insight as to what it feels like for you as an author before the book hits the shelves. You know, you've been doing this a long time, you've had such huge successes, but I would imagine it still feels like a very, a very raw time.
4:44 Speaker 02 Well, it's a very interesting time because there's a terrific appetite for this book. There's a lot of interest in it already, but there aren't very many readers. So it is a bit sort of on the top of a diving board, like, how's it going to go? And publication day is not the day that people get their first copies, because obviously reviewers get them a bit before. But usually it's after publication that you start to get the reviews. And there is this really big sense of, how's it going to go? Is it as I think it is? Are people going to read it as I intended it? Are people going to go completely nuts about it, which sometimes happen? Is it going to be as well received? I hope. It's a sort of a Christmas Eve with a little bit of
5:29 Speaker 02 Halloween throning.
5:31 Speaker 01 You're naming all the best times of the year. So this sounds like a good time to be in.
5:35 Speaker 00 Now, Philippa, I'm sure it will be a huge success, but this is far from your first foray into the Tudor world. What is it about? That particular period, those particular collections of people that interest you? And why do you think people want to keep returning to that?
5:49 Speaker 02 Well, I think politically, it is one of the most interesting times in all of English history, that it is the time that what has been a sort of rule of the lords of quite dispersed country, in which, for instance, people in Cornwall don't even speak the same language as people in other parts of England, and someone in Yorkshire couldn't understand someone who lived in Southampton, say. It's quite a dispersed country. It's been in a hundred years of war with France, so it's quite a poor country. It's had this massive War of the Roses, so it's a country accustomed to internal enmity. And out of all of that, the Tudors start to pull together the power on themselves
6:34 Speaker 02 and on, interestingly, London and the South East, but very, very much on this one family and of this one family, on this one person, Henry VIII. And that's really the start of tyranny. And it's an extraordinary thing to be in our time now and look at in a period of history when obviously a lot of countries are embracing the idea of a strong male leader and see there's England doing it in the 15th century with disastrous consequences for the Parliament, for the Lords, and especially for the women of the court.
7:11 Speaker 00 This is why I love having people on After Dark, guests who are both historians and fiction writers, because the way, Philippa, that you speak about that period, the way that you weave together that story, it's just so evocative and it makes me excited. As someone who works predominantly on the 18th century, it makes me feel so excited about the Tudor period, actually. And I think I'm always fascinated by it, and we will, I know we'll talk about this as the episode goes on, but the space that you occupy, where you straddle the world of history and the world of fiction, and the way that you meld those two together is just so exciting to me as a historian. I absolutely love that, so I'm really excited for this conversation.
7:47 Speaker 02 Thank you.
7:48 Speaker 01 One of the things, you know, you're talking about some of the figures there, Henry VIII, and we're hearing about this power coalescing around Henry and some figures and some histories that we might be a little bit more familiar with. But one of the people that I wasn't very familiar with takes centre stage in this new book and has a really interesting history of her own. And her tenacity is quite interesting and her approach to this world, because, you know, you're saying the world is being reshaped to a certain extent, and therefore those interacting with that world have to change the ways in which they're interacting. Enter Jane. Tell us a little bit about Jane Parker, as she initially is.
8:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, she's the daughter of Lord Morley. So she's sort of upper aristocrat. He's not a power broker at court, he's a scholar. He's very much distant from the court, he turns out when he's ordered to. But his great love is scholarship and living in the country. And he makes a good marriage for his daughter Jane to a neighbour, someone whose lands are adjacent. And they are the Bolins, they're, you know, rising gentry, not quite yet nobility. The father, Berlin, is married into the House of Howard, so they've got a noble connection. They're not middle class by any means, they're above that. But in the Tudor world, they're not grand families. And Jane goes to court and is the maid of honour to Catherine
9:08 Speaker 02 of Aragon. And so is a career courtier at court as her young husband, she marries him after she's been at court for a while, as her young husband is a career courtier at the court of the King Henry VIII. And then, of course, the jackpot happens for the Bolins and Anne Boleyn pulls off this extraordinary coup, which is again both personal and political in that she persuades Henry to abandon his wife Catherine of Aragon and marry her. Cue, you know, so many other changes, the Reformation, everything else you can think about, but Jane, in that sense, suddenly jumps up to being sister-in-law to the Queen
9:50 Speaker 02 of England, from no preparation whatsoever, suddenly, bang, they're there, and suddenly they are the ruling elite, just as Henry is starting to concentrate power on themselves, and by her own incredible political skills and her personal skills, concentrates Henry's authority on her. So she's advising Henry, she advises him against Cardinal Wolsey, the traditional advisor of the King of England, and she built her own power base in court. And we start the novel pretty well while Anne is hoping to confirm that power base with the birth of a son and heir, and thus guaranteeing the Tudor dynasty, the Tudor-Bowlin
10:30 Speaker 02 dynasty, and their power permanently. And Henry is still in love with her, and that still looks like it's going to happen. And Jane's career then falls dramatically with the Bowlins. I argue, unlike your introduction, that she does nothing to help the fall of her sister-in-law and her husband. I believe there are witnesses to Anne's behaviour, but I don't believe Jane is one of them. We've got one document that says that she will try and speak to the King for George, her husband, so she may very well have been trying to save him. And then, what's the million-dollar giveaway for me, is that when the Bowlins
11:10 Speaker 02 are killed, George and Anne are executed, a father disappears, sister disappears, you don't hear a peep from any Bowlin for, for years. Jane Bowlin gets promoted, she becomes Jane Seymour's lady-in-waiting, an act of parliament is passed in order to give her a better dower as a widow than she was entitled to, though she's the widow of a traitor, and should in theory get nothing. And you have to say, or I have to say, nobody has said very much before, but it would be wise to say, how has this happened? This is the widow of a traitor, and moreover, a traitor accused of incestuous sex with his sister,
11:50 Speaker 02 the Queen of England. This is the sort of thing people die for, and yet Jane rises up to be Jane Seymour's lady-in-waiting, and from there, continues to be lady-in-waiting to the subsequent queens until she makes her final fatal mistake.
12:06 Speaker 00 She's such a fascinating character, Philippa, not least because it's so hard to access what was going on in her mind. You talk about this extraordinary climb through the ranks that she's starting, yes, from a privileged position within this world, but she, because of the association with the Belins, ends up in stratospheres that she wouldn't otherwise have found her way into. And I just wonder, as a novelist, how you approach someone who is so hard to define and around whom there is so much ambiguity in terms of her motives, in terms of the actual behaviour that she did, what she did or didn't do to Anne and George. So what's your starting point for a character like Jane?
12:45 Speaker 02 I think the starting point is the history and the way I like to write historical fiction, my starting point is always a history. So first of all, I try and figure out what she's doing. You can never know with a historical character, prior to the age of diaries, you can never know what they're thinking, and even then, they're probably lying. So, you know, you have to start off with what are they actually doing? So I trace her career. You know, in my research, I trace her early career and then her marriage and then this inexplicable rise. And then I start to speculate as a historian, how could this be explained? How is the logical explanation for this? So previous historians have been very satisfied
13:28 Speaker 02 with a psychological and condemnatory and a stereotype view of her. So Victorian historians in particular, who are the great historians of the Tudor period, so you come across them all the time, but what they tend to say is that she's a bad woman. Her brother was having an incestuous relationship with his wife, or at any rate, she didn't keep him home. Whatever he's doing, it's not right. So she's a bad woman on account of that. And then subsequently, she's involved in another adultery case. So she's a sinful woman in the point of view of the Victorians. And that's the solution to the question, what is Jane like? She's a bad woman. End of story.
14:09 Speaker 02 Then you come ahead to the years where people start looking for a psychological explanation and you start, you're past the years, the past the sixties of, as it were, women's lib. So people are prepared to look into what they imagine as being her inner thoughts and fears. And they go like, she's involved in two adulteries. She's certainly a in the room witness for one of them. She's a sexual voyeur, that explains what she's doing. So now we haven't got that she's bad anymore. We've got that she's obsessively addicted to sex, so much so that her particular kink is sex done by queens of England. Very, very particular. Very specific. Very particular and very high risk. Yeah. Extremely high risk. So that doesn't make much sense.
14:53 Speaker 02 And then you go forward into our age, which is even more psychological in its search for explanations. And our age comes up with the fact that at her death, she is diagnosed as being insane. And so there you are, she's just crazy. I think it takes a woman of some common sense and also a woman who doesn't believe in the stereotypes of women, in this instance, me, to go like, obviously, she's not. None of these are true. She's not sin, sinful, that's not an explanation for anything. Obviously, she's not a very, very, very particular voyeur. If she was addicted to sexual voyeurism with her money and the class she's in, she could satisfy it every single night without getting involved in the adultery of the queens of England.
15:38 Speaker 02 That's mad. The idea that she is in fact mad, I think, completely ignores the fact that at the time she, I think, pretends to be mad, or at the time she is diagnosed as mad, there is no death penalty on people who are recognized as mad. So it's a completely rational way of saving her own life. Strategy. And it would have worked very, very well, except she failed to allow for the incredible vindictiveness of Henry VIII, who changed the law so that he could execute a mad woman, indeed her.
16:12 Speaker 01 I want to zone in on one particular point in this history, and we'll do this with different points as we go through this, but I want to talk about what has been termed the first betrayal slightly. And you alluded to this in terms of what we mentioned in the introduction about this potential betrayal of her husband, George, and how you don't really see that in the archive, and it doesn't really present itself in the novel either. Can you talk about what that betrayal was supposed to have been, what we have received that, and say how you circumnavigate that in this novel?
16:45 Speaker 02 Well, the betrayal is supposed to be that, I mean, again, you go back to the Victorian historians.
16:51 Speaker 01 I thought as much, yeah.
16:52 Speaker 02 It matters very much to them that Anne, mother of Elizabeth I, their top favourite historical character, is not, in fact, an adulterous, bad woman, as you would be if you were an adulterous woman to a Victorian historian. So there's a real desire by the Victorian historians to exonerate Anne and to suggest that this is a show trial. So therefore, everybody who gave witnesses of George and Anne's intimacy, which was put together by mostly Thomas Cromwell, to make it into a believable charge of Anne's adultery with many men, including her brother, all of that, you've got to find some way of blaming
17:33 Speaker 02 it on others and show that it's exactly a show trial, it's not true. We now think as modern historians that it probably was a show trial, that it is unlikely that Anne Berlin had sex with this many people. And the evidence for that is pretty good, that the dates and the places which are cited are simply not credible.
17:53 Speaker 01 They don't match up, right?
17:54 Speaker 02 She's not even there for a lot of them. There's a very good reason for her having sex with somebody she could trust, in that Henry VIII is reported as being impotent even then. So certainly, George is executed probably because he says in court that the king is impotent, one way or another. But there's a whole sense of like, this is not a proper trial, this is not proper evidence. Who is responsible for the accusation? And it's very, very good for the Victorian historians to say, it's his wife, horrible Jane.
18:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, another woman.
18:27 Speaker 02 Another woman, probably jealous.
18:29 Speaker 01 Hmm, yeah, yeah, yeah.
18:31 Speaker 02 You know, you've got this really great story of female rivalry and female malice, and this powerless woman who gains the greatest power by betraying her husband and her sister-in-law.
18:55 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sunny Graham. Years later, Sunny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sunny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays, and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
19:35 Speaker 03 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors, and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets, The History of Sex, Scandal and Society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts. Brought to you by the
20:20 Speaker 03 award-winning network, History Hit.
20:33 Speaker 00 It's a very deeply Victorian narrative, isn't it, of these women being pitted against each other. There's just not room in that version of the history being told for more than one woman to exist and to have any kind of complexity. Philippa, you mentioned Thomas Cromwell when you were speaking then, and I just wonder if you can say a little bit more about his possible relationship with Jane, because you have a bit of a theory on this, don't you?
20:55 Speaker 02 Well, yes, Thomas Cromwell, I think, is the only man who had the power and ability to change the law so that she got her full dowry, indeed more than her full dowry. So she ends up with Blickling Hall in Norfolk, which is now post 17th century rebuild, but even at the time was an enormous palace. So she's a very wealthy woman in her own right. She doesn't need to work anymore at the Queen's Court. Thomas Cromwell, I think, is the only person who could have got that for her from the Parliament. And Thomas Cromwell is probably the only person who would have placed her at the head of the Queen's Ladies for three subsequent queens. And we really see, I think, why he does that when we see
21:39 Speaker 02 that Anne of Cleves comes to England and Henry VIII turns against her and wants a divorce. Then there is witness statements about the incapacity of the two of them, Anne and Henry, to conceive a child. He is recorded as being impotent and she is recorded as being a completely innocent virgin. And the witnesses who provide this unlikely account are led by Jane. So I think Thomas Cromwell puts her in place in the Queen's Rooms and she does exactly what he needs at that point, which is produce incontrovertible evidence that Anne of Cleves has said that in the morning, Henry VIII kisses her and says, "Good day sweetheart",
22:21 Speaker 02 and she says, "Good day". And she says, in Jane's account to her ladies, "She didn't know there was anything more than that to bedding a king". So you go like, this is a woman who's been sent by her family to England to get a son from the King of England. That's her only job. That's the only thing she has to do. And they have sent her and she doesn't know anything about sexual intercourse at all. This is not a Victorian girl. This is a girl in the medieval world who will have been brought up seeing animals on the farm all the time, who will inevitably have heard bawdy jokes and bawdy stories, who knows the laws about impotence, who knows what happens in the church courts about impotent and barren marriages. She knows absolutely.
23:06 Speaker 02 And also, she's not speaking English at this time. She is not going to say to her English ladies in waiting, in the morning, the King says to me, good morrow sweetheart. She doesn't have those words. But those are the words she's reported as saying by Jane Berlin. So I think Jane is there in place, and Thomas Cromwell has put her in place. But again, this is fiction. Or if you like, the Wilder Shores of speculation. I don't have any document that shows that Jane is ever paid by Thomas Cromwell, except all the money she gets could only have come to her, I think, by his goodwill.
23:42 Speaker 01 It is, however, I know you're saying speculation. It is, however, informed speculation. And I think that's
23:46 Speaker 02 Yes, it's very grounded in the history of the
23:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that's one of the gems of your fiction work in that you work with the mind of a historian because you are a historian. And so that speculative point is what we all do as historians when we're sitting around chatting. You just channel it into a fiction and an outlet that is still ground in the facts, in the historical facts. So I think that's what really draws people into your work specifically, Philippa. But I want to talk a little bit about, you mentioned afterwards that there's the three successive queens that she's still there for. Give us an idea of what that looks like for Jane at that time. What is that experience like for her? And you've hinted at it already, but let's get to the kind of heart of it. Why do you think that's such an unusual position for her to find herself in?
24:33 Speaker 02 Well, it's a not uncommon position for a woman, widowed as she is, to become, as it were, a career courtier. And again, this is quite new history, that most historians up until now have not been very interested in the ladies in waiting. And so you miss out the women career courtiers. We all know that Thomas Howard is always there doing stuff. We always know that Thomas Stanley is there always doing stuff. We know that the royal dukes are always around the court and that they get different jobs to do. Often warfare, often diplomacy, sometimes politics. But there hasn't been a lot of study of the women's side of things and what the women are doing in the Queen's Court, which is, which runs parallel.
25:17 Speaker 02 But it is quite separate, but it has its own hierarchy, it has its own pensions, has its own pay, it has its own working conditions and traditions. And we see that really clearly when we have a queen on the throne. Because then, as it were, the Queen's Court becomes much more important as the intimate court of the queen. And the men's court becomes the external court of the queen. But nonetheless, there were substantial Queen's Courts. To every one of Henry's queens and they all had career diplomats and almost certainly spies. And ladies in waiting and supporters and cheerers and best friends attached. Jane, as a widow, is wealthy enough to step back from all of that and retire to her estates.
26:02 Speaker 02 But, you know, she's not very old, she's only in her thirties. I think she was a career courtier from a child. I think she would be bored to death.
26:10 Speaker 01 It's the world she knew.
26:10 Speaker 02 In the country, you know, like also, this isn't Bickling Hall, Norfolk, with the communications that it is now. You'd go there, you'd disappear off the end of the world. Nobody would ever remember you again. So she's been at the heart of everything that matters ever since she was a child of twelve. Since she isn't yet scarred and since she isn't yet really conscious of the danger that she's in. Since she's got, I think, in Cromwell, a very, very astute patron, spymaster, who is asking her questions. And she has this terrific sense that we all know of being absolutely in on the secrets. And in her case, these are the secrets of a nation. You know, there's very few people.
26:52 Speaker 02 That you see who have been in power, who step away from it, it doesn't happen very often. Most of the time, people want to stay in, if they can get back, they do. And she has this extraordinary opportunity, after the collapse of her husband and sister-in-law, to step right back into the court of a very inexperienced queen. So Jane Berlin knows much better than Jane Seymour, how Jane Seymour should behave. Yeah. And she knows a ton better than Anne of Cleves, who's a foreign princess anyway.
27:22 Speaker 00 Yes, and who is clueless on some level, and then also acting potentially more clueless than she really is. And in terms of Jane's return to court, though, after everything that happens with Anne and George, is there a world in which she's not welcome because of those associations and because of the downfall of that family? And is it therefore Cromwell who facilitates her place at this court? Or is she in and of herself a popular figure? Why is she allowed to stay for so long?
27:49 Speaker 02 You don't get to be laid in waiting to the Queen of England because people like you. It's a paid post, it's an incredibly desirable post. You get it by bribing the court officials, or by being so important yourself that you get the post. So it's got to be Cromwell, the only other person who might have got it for her, might have been Thomas Howard, but she's not a direct relation to him, and we don't see her serving him in any way at all through the next stages. The next time she serves Thomas Howard, it's at the time of the reign of Anne of Cleves. But you couldn't have foreseen that then, because it's Jane Seymour, and she gets pregnant within the first year of marriage. So, you know, in a way, you might go, job done. All we need, from Thomas Cromwell's
28:32 Speaker 02 point of view, he probably goes, what I need is a really, really, really reliable pair of eyes and a reporter at Jane Seymour's court. Both Janes knew each other, Jane Seymour knew Jane Berlin. But I don't think she was tainted, in a sense, by the accusations. Against her husband and her sister-in-law, because I think everybody will have been absolutely terrified by that. It's not just them who are killed. Remember, there are six, six men are charged, five other men are killed. And there's other men who are charged and released, and there's other men who aren't charged, but whose names are on, in a sense, on the books. So I think there was, it was like a shadow going across the court. I think everybody goes like, let's keep our heads down.
29:15 Speaker 02 Let's see how it pans out. Let's hope to God Jane Seymour gets a baby and that we end up, as we have been always before with a king and a queen, who may or may not like each other at the time, but nobody gets killed.
29:28 Speaker 00 And everyone's fulfilling their function.
29:30 Speaker 02 Yeah.
29:30 Speaker 00 And roles, yeah.
29:31 Speaker 02 And, you know, a- as in the present day, something happens and you all go like, gosh, that's absolutely terrible. That's never happened before. And you're very quick to go like, it probably will never happen again. We'll just stay quiet and hope that it passes on. And in the case of Henry and I would say all Tarrant's, it just gets worse.
29:50 Speaker 00 Yes.
29:51 Speaker 01 What we have then, and you know, you're talking about this kind of game of stakes and game of politics that Jane is very much part of, one way or the other, even if it's not Cromwell, but I, I think it's pretty persuasive that, that, that this is why she's in place. But almost inevitable in the Tudor court, if you've managed to survive for X amount of time, is a downfall. And Jane experiences a downfall too. Let's touch on that and talk to us about how that comes about, Philippa.
30:20 Speaker 02 Well, like everything in history, there's a lot of reasons for anything that ever happens. I think the fact that Cromwell loses his hold over Henry and is executed actually on Catherine of Howard's wedding day, which is just typical bad taste of Henry. I mean, the other thing that identifies Tarrant's is they always have the most awful manners. So there we go. But she loses then, I think, her spymaster, but I think she also, she loses her patron. And I think she loses a key advisor. So now she is playing a very dangerous game. She hasn't got anyone to report to. She hasn't got anyone to advise her and she hasn't got anyone to help her if she gets into a jam.
31:03 Speaker 02 So she's now very much on her own and she is looking after a queen who is very, very young. We're not sure Catherine Howard's actual age, but she's a teenager, she's a young teen. And she is now Queen of England with no training and no education and no background for this role. And she behaves understandably like a child in a sweet shop. She's terribly greedy for jewels and things like that. And she falls in love, I believe, sincerely and totally with a young man who isn't steady or reliable or very safe, but is hugely attractive, Thomas Culpepper, an adventurer. And she begs Jane to help them
31:46 Speaker 02 meet. And here, accounts differ. They all end up charged with adultery or helping the adultery. And they all blame each other. Culpepper and Catherine mostly blame Jane. And Jane doesn't say actually as much as they do, but she says that they demanded it and that she exceeded to their demands. What she's actually doing, given that she's as clever as I believe she is, I think she may have thought that there's only one way that Catherine Howard is going to get pregnant, and that's if she has sex with somebody other than Henry VIII, who is now been impotent and proclaimed his impotence with three preceding queens. You know, he's not father material.
32:30 Speaker 01 Yeah.
32:31 Speaker 02 There's no doubt in anybody's mind that this is not very hopeful. During the marriage to Catherine Howard, although we, when we read about it, we normal read about this sort of December, May blooming of Henry, he has a complete six weeks, eight weeks, when he just closes the door in Hampton Court and won't see anybody and just stays in his room and eats. He's, you know, he's prone to these period of deep depression and ill health. So they think he's not going to live. So I think Jane quite sensibly calculates that there's a very good chance that if she can get Catherine Howard pregnant by another man, or allow Catherine Howard to sleep with the man that she's longing to sleep with. Catherine might get pregnant, in which case Henry will marry her, in which case she'll
33:16 Speaker 02 be queen, in which case if he dies soon, which everybody thinks he's going to, Catherine will become Dowager Queen, with a very good chance of being on the Regency Council of her son. She's a Howard, it's Jane's house, she's in touch with Catherine's uncle, the Duke of Norfolk. If it had worked, it would have been an extraordinary power play, and you would have seen Jane, the power behind the throne of the Queen Dowager, possibly advising on a second marriage for the Queen Dowager, she could have married Thomas Culpepper then, and her son would have been King of England. It's not a stupid thing to do. In the circumstances she's in, it's not the best thing to do. The best thing to do would
33:58 Speaker 02 probably be to keep her head down and try and keep the lid on Catherine Howard. But this is a very impulsive teen in love for the first time, who no one has ever said no to in probably all her life. I think you couldn't have kept the lid on Catherine Howard. You couldn't keep the lid on Thomas Culpepper, who is an adventurer. And so what she does is she does the best she can with it, and constructs this really, really compelling possible future, and hopes it's going to happen. And of course, what does happen is the reverse, in that they are caught, and Catherine loses her head in the interrogation, she's not with Jane, Jane can't advise her, and Catherine ends up thinking she's throwing
34:42 Speaker 02 everybody off the scent, but in effect, giving them enough evidence to pick up Culpepper and his friends, and the previous men in her life, who were probably in any case abusers. But the Tudor mind doesn't go there. And actually, neither do the Victorian mind. So we have Jane as a reputation of being lascivious, immoral, lighthearted, and very stupid, whereas in fact, her story is much more complicated and interesting than that.
35:10 Speaker 00 So Philip, Jane has this incredible propensity for plotting and survival and all of that, but we do know that her downfall comes to the extent where she is potentially forced to feign madness in order to survive. And that, even then, that doesn't work for her. So what happens? What is the end of her story, without giving too much of the novel away?
35:28 Speaker 02 Well, it's history, so you can Google it.
35:31 Speaker 00 It is available on Wikipedia.
35:35 Speaker 02 I think she comes up with a strategic plan, even in the Tower of London, even when in my novel she is in the room where her husband waited for his execution, even though she can see Tower Green where her sister-in-law was executed. So she knows the stakes are incredibly high. And in my version of events, she pretends to be mad and Henry VIII sends his private physician to see her. And in my version of the events, the private physician reports her as insane, but knows that she's pretending. And that puts her under the protection of the law, which says that people who are mad in the Tudor law cannot be executed. The
36:18 Speaker 02 assumption is, is that God has already punished them for whatever they've done. There's no point beheading them. They have lost their minds. So normally, you'd go into the care of your family if you were noble. And if you were poor, you would have the incredible mercy of being trapped on the streets or, or in prison for life. But either way, she's going to survive. And in the history, we know she is released to Admiral Russell and his wife and their beautiful house on the strand. And she stays there over Christmas and she's examined quite frequently. And then Henry, the king, deliberately and mindfully changes the law on madness. So mad people can be executed. And the first person to
36:59 Speaker 02 be executed under this new law, and in my view, the only one he wanted is Jane herself.
37:05 Speaker 00 Classic Henry VIII behaviour, that, isn't it?
37:07 Speaker 01 It's so often personal with him when he changes those laws. So it makes sense.
37:11 Speaker 02 But it's also classic Tarrant behaviour, that Tarrants use the law for their personal vindictiveness. And you see it in Henry, and we see it all around the world now. And it's one of the real kind of warning signs that you've gone beyond having a bit of a narcissist running the country. You've stepped into Tarrant territory.
37:30 Speaker 01 I wonder who you're talking about, Philip. Who could you possibly be referencing? We're surrounded by it at the moment. That, that's so interesting. And I think it says something about, yeah, the vindictiveness and the insecurity of the, of the Henry VIII.
37:45 Speaker 01 As well as saying something about the potential strategizing. Again, this is the word that keeps coming to me when we're talking about Jane is strategizing and how easily women are so overlooked in terms of their strategy making in this time period, anything up to the 19th, 20th century, really. So you are building this more complex world where we can see women as power brokers and as participants in power. And I think that's really, really valuable as well.
38:24 Speaker 03 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets, The History of Sex, Scandal and Society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts. Brought to you
39:08 Speaker 03 by the award-winning network, History Hit.
39:23 Speaker 00 The way that you're describing Jane as well, Philip, I'm amazed by how savvy and skillful she actually is, especially towards the end when she's lost Thomas Cromwell as a spymaster. And you touched on it earlier, talking about, you know, there's this sort of, and I suppose it probably does come from those Victorian historians, and I think we're still dealing with it today and struggling to unpick it, this idea that the Tudor court is predominantly run by men, that it's men doing the scheming, the plotting, and that the women's court and those ladies in waiting were so close to any queen in this period. Are just there to provide a bit of decoration, to you know, a little bit of gossip. Maybe they might know some secrets about who fancies who, who's sleeping with who. But beyond that, that they have no real power or influence.
40:07 Speaker 00 And what you're explaining here with Jane is that actually she's a key player throughout this history for all three of these queens, that she's so central to what's happening, both good and bad, and that she is playing a game in terms of the wider court and where she sees herself and the direction that she wants that court to go in. Actually, she is influencing royal history and royal politics, but also that she's a survivor and that she's out for herself as much as anyone else. And that's, there's something so powerful in that. I'm really compelled by this idea that she has more power than I maybe imagined, which is, I think, a sort of, you know, a kind of internalized misogyny, I suppose, that we're all, like I say, still dealing with this Victorian idea that these women held no power and were of no particular interest.
40:52 Speaker 02 I think it's true. And if you think of, you know, medieval women are normally identified in stereotypes. So you have the virgin, who becomes the virgin bride, and then you have the wife, who hopefully is fertile, or you have the eve, the adulteress, the woman who doesn't understand that her husband's honour is her honour and that she should defend that, and that's the most important thing. And then you have sort of the widow and the hag. What you don't have is any stereotype of a clever woman who plans her own life and is her own agent.
41:28 Speaker 00 Autonomy does not exist.
41:30 Speaker 02 There are hags and there are, you know, sluts, but there's no stereotype of a scholar. There's no stereotype of an artist. There's no stereotype of a female genius, you know. All of these stereotypes are.
41:44 Speaker 00 Only muses.
41:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, they're not misogynist in the sense that they are anti-women, so I'm not complaining. But they are misogynist in the sense that women are just absent. Yes. And, you know, one of the things that really strikes me about history, why I wrote my book, Normal Women, 900 Years of Making History, is a history of women in England, that women are just absent from the record and you don't notice it because they're not there. Similarly, you know, in Tudor history, we don't notice, because the books are very often called Six Wives of Henry VIII, we don't notice that it's six stereotypes of Henry VIII. We don't observe the fact that these are not described to us as persuasive
42:29 Speaker 02 real women, trying the best in their own lives for themselves, for their families, for their husband, for their children, if they have children.
42:35 Speaker 00 And they're only understood in terms of the king as well, the six wives of Henry VIII.
42:39 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly. And that's why memorably, you hardly hear about any of Henry's mistresses, because basically, historians have gone, we've got six wives, that's enough. But anyway, like, that's too many, too many already. So Jane is one of these forgotten women, because there are in a sense, too many women in the Henry court for historians to grapple with. And the other thing is that her story is so incomprehensible, if you don't go, here's a woman with agency, trying to survive, trying to prosper, and trying every now and then to pull off a real coup.
43:12 Speaker 00 Yes, if you remove that element of her personality and who she was, some of her behaviour and the places we find her in are sort of inexplicable, really, aren't they?
43:22 Speaker 02 They're inexplicable, and, and we do fall back on the fact, it's got to be something irrational, like lust or just madness. Because why else is she doing this?
43:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, that we're, we're filling in those gaps, but actually, maybe the filling in is far more obvious than we have thought to think before. By the way, if you haven't read Philippa's book, Normal Women, please do. And, and in addition, listen to the podcast, because I think what the podcast does, which it accompanies the book, it brings those histories right into the modern day. And, and you're speaking to some incredible women on there about the ways in which adjacently, these histories are informing everyday lives, and how people are relating to those lives today. But I want to talk to you about something else before we let you go. You're a very busy person, so we have to let you go at some point. But I want to talk to you about a little book called The Other Bolin Girl. You may have heard of it, it might crop up before you every now and again, you know,
44:15 Speaker 01 I like to ask obscure questions. But when you're approaching a new novel, and, you know, it's, it's time to sit Down at the computer for the first day or however you write at a laptop, whatever it is. How on earth do you choose what is coming next? Because it's hard enough for the rest of us, but we don't have the scrutiny and the expectation. Sorry to tell you all of this. Well, the book's written now, but you know, people have expectations and they have, they have desires of what you might be able to bring them. And so how does that sit on your shoulders on day one?
44:47 Speaker 02 It's lovely that I don't, I mean, I'm very sorry readers, but I don't think about them.
44:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:52 Speaker 02 At all. Because if I thought about them, I would make, make sure I didn't think about them because the last thing you can do when you're starting a novel is think about the readers. I think it would be chokingly discouraging. Also, I'm not interested in anything, you know, I am, by the time I sit down to write it, I've done something like a year of research on this character. I am just desperate to start telling her story and to be inside her head. I want the experience of writing. I'm not thinking about the experience of reading. That's another year away. I'm actually very obsessive at the time. So I'm in my study, the door's shut.
45:32 Speaker 02 The dog's on my, under the, under the desk ideally. And in this case, Jane Berlin and I are starting the story of her extraordinary adventure that nobody has ever told before. And like, nothing's going to stop me there, you know, I am in love with my work. I just want to be with it all day.
45:53 Speaker 01 And then does that wrangle a little bit when you have to then start sharing that a little bit when you're like, oh, now I have to hand this over and there's editors and then eventually there's, you know, it starts to go to print and then you have to book tour it. And does it feel like a different experience, a different product then?
46:11 Speaker 02 It's a different job altogether.
46:13 Speaker 01 It is, isn't it?
46:13 Speaker 02 It's a completely different job than, and it's not my favorite, it's not my favorite job. I mean, I do it. And I am always, always, always glad to see the book go out and it does have that excitement about it. But, you know, I do a series of lecture tours. I'm going to be doing it for this book. It's a very different thing to talk to you about the book or to stand up on stage and talk to an audience about the book. From the nun-like solitude of my study in the country, where it's just me and Jane, and every now and then I'll stop and say, "Why did you do that?" And then I go like, "I know why you did it, and nobody else knows why you did it." And the thrill of that is unlike real life.
46:58 Speaker 02 That's why it works as a novel, that people in their real lives go to it, and it catches them up and it takes them somewhere else. And the power of it is that sometimes in that story, you can say something about real life that you can't say another way. And that's why it's important, as well as tremendously enjoyable to me.
47:21 Speaker 00 Philippa, I can't wait to read The Blood Traitor. When is it out and where can people buy it?
47:26 Speaker 02 It's out on October the 7th, and you can get it anywhere you get your books.
47:30 Speaker 00 Fantastic. Thank you so much for joining us. I have to say, as someone who writes at home in her pyjamas with her dogs under the desk, I feel a little bit like I'm going to be emulating Philippa next time I sit down to write. Yes, I feel thoroughly legitimised. If you've enjoyed this episode of After Dark, you can leave us a five-star review wherever you get your podcasts. It helps other people to discover the show. If you have a suggestion for a topic or a guest that you would like to see on, then you can let us know at [email protected] . See you next time.
48:48 Speaker 00 The.
Previous The Railway Murder That Shook Victorian Britain Next The Dark Truth About Madam Tussauds Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated