Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal The Victorian Sex Scandal of Fanny & Stella About this episode The Victorians are seen as the ultimate guardians of rigid gender boundaries.
When Fanny Park and Stella Boulton transgressed those imagined lines, they triggered a scandal that reached the length and breadth of Britain.
To tell this story Anthony is joined byHRH Aphrodite https://www.instagram.com/hrhaphroditei/?hl=en, historian, artist and drag queen.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube: www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Edited by Hannah Feodorov and Anna Brant. Produced by Stuart Beckwith.
For tickets to see Anthony and Maddy talking about her new book, Hoax, click here: https://www.conwayhall.org.uk/whats-on/event/hoax/
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 10,509 words · 4 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers, now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries, and I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Anton and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:52 Speaker 01 It's April 1870 and gaslight flickers along London's West End. The Strand Theatre doors swing open and the audience spills into the night. Silk hems lifted from the damp pavement, kid gloves buttoned tight, laughter drifting into the fog. Among all these people walk two figures, curls pinned beneath bonnets, skirts swaying.
1:20 Speaker 01 They've walked these streets before, but tonight, plainclothes officers are watching them. Within hours, both men will be in custody, and Victorian London will be gripped by one of the century's most sensational scandals.
1:40 Speaker 01 In Victorian London, newspapers feasted on scandal like nothing else. And on a spring evening in 1870, two young men attended the Strand Theatre in full drag. By morning, London would be gripped by one of the century's most sensational scandals. In an empire built on rigid masculinity, how dangerous was a man in a silk dress? From the heart of the West End, this is After Dark.
2:35 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to After Dark. I'm Anthony and today's episode takes place in London in 1870. I mean, I'm saying I'm Anthony. Nobody is here to see me today, but I'm just going to try and ignore the splendor that's sitting beside me for a moment, because we are going to talk about two young people called Fanny and Stella. Now, when we were talking about doing this episode, there was only one person that I could think of to come in and take us through this history. And that, of course, is, I shall no longer delay the introduction, it is the one and only HRH Aphrodite. Cue applause, cue applause, cue applause. That way in just a studio with just two of us, but there is applause
3:15 Speaker 01 happening everywhere in the world. And I first encountered Aphrodite at the Queen's House, fittingly enough, in Greenwich. And Aphrodite was doing a tour of the paintings, right? Like, not just the paintings, but-
3:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was, it was how to look sexy historically, was the official line of the tour.
3:36 Speaker 01 And it did, it excelled in its, in its, in its purpose. And I just thought this was, I was writing Queer Georgians at the time, or had I finished? But it was somewhere around there, or maybe Queer Georgians was just about to come out. And I was thinking of different ways in which not only queer people, but queer people can present the past. And this was a mixed audience. There were so many people there and they were really glued to this history. And I was like, we need a little bit of this on After Dark. So I'm so pleased that you've been able to, to come along and to, to help us with this particular history. But we were chatting a little bit before, before we, we started recording. And some people will be like, well, this is not what a historian looks like. And to those people, we say quieten down for a moment.
4:18 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's, it's interesting. There's a lot of politics about the presentation of history, isn't there?
4:25 Speaker 01 Yeah. But talk, talk to me a little bit about that then. How, how did you, Aphrodite, come to this, to be doing? There's loads you could do. You could be lip syncing, which I know you do as well, but like, you could be lip syncing seven days a week if you want to be. And you do lip sync, but, but this is your lane.
4:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's, do you know what? It's funny, because it is not the avenue that I expected to be working in. I think me and you come from very similar backgrounds, which was little, little queer boys who were very theatrical. And there is, there was a big problem that I had growing up when I was doing community theatre, which was, we would do a lot of these, like, I was in Treasure Island, for example, and the costumes were, were really crap, because they're expensive, you know, it's like, it's an incredibly arduous thing to invest in making the past look somewhat like it did.
5:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:21 Speaker 02 And it's something that I noticed in history sites quite a lot. So when I was a teenager, I lived on the island of Jersey, which is in the Channel Islands, and there's a lot of really interesting historical locations that, that would have costumed interpreters. And the best thing about it is, actually, so, one of the castles in Jersey was where Charles II stayed when he was on the run from the parliamentarians. And the person who used to do Charles II in Jersey was a performer who, I don't, I don't know them, but they are assigned female at birth. So it's like drag kinging.
6:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:01 Speaker 02 As Charles II.
6:04 Speaker 01 That's so interesting. So that's, so actually, even at a time before, even these conversations had started, in the public domain at least, but that's, that's a good distinction also to bear in mind. There were people out there, drag kinging up history straight away. And I mean, look back at some of the things that you see, you see men in drag playing Elizabeth I back in the sixties and seventies. So this is, you're a part of a legacy. It's not like you're the first.
6:29 Speaker 02 No, definitely not. There's, there's a great guy called Douglas Bing, who was a music hall star in the sort of twenties and thirties. And so I actually did my dissertation on this, was about impersonation drag.
6:44 Speaker 01 Right.
6:44 Speaker 02 And what kind of, because arguably Shakespeare's doing it, right? So like, when he's writing Henry VIII, and Berlin is a character in Henry VIII. But the material culture around celebrity impersonation is not.
6:58 Speaker 02 What we have now, we benefit from access to public figures all the time, right? And so what's interesting about this is like, there's always been an interest in drag, particularly in history contexts, as its own kind of costuming gender type thing. Like Elizabeth I, to us, Elizabeth I looks very feminine. But if you compare the Armada portrait, for example, which is in the Queen's house, to what she was brought up wearing, it's actually very butch. She's playing with gender quite a lot. And we will see, I think, in this episode a lot, there's that gender and clothing are synonymous
7:42 Speaker 02 more than gender and sex.
7:44 Speaker 01 Oh, absolutely. I mean, this is one of the points, I so agree with that. This is one of the points that came up for me again and again in Queer Georgians, where people don't necessarily understand. And actually, maybe we can help them through that distinction between gender and sex, because you hear this in so many, in so many circles so often of historic or even present day gender, there are, you will often hear, there are two genders. That's what, and I'm like, if you're saying that, and if you truly believe that, okay, let's, let's give them the benefit of the doubt and say that they truly believe that. Then you, what it actually means is you don't understand what gender is in the broadest context, let alone in the historic context.
8:21 Speaker 02 And it's, it is something to be performed, right? And that is something that a lot of people do. You know, Elizabeth I performs gender.
8:30 Speaker 01 And she says, I have the heart and stomach of a king.
8:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, the body of a weak and feeble woman, but the heart and stomach of a king and of a King of England.
8:36 Speaker 01 And she, and she is, and King of England at that is, is right. So you look at all the quotes coming out. But, but this, this is why performance of gender is not new. It is blending those boundaries, bringing everything in. We have this idea then of, of the, the, the third sex, as they refer to in the 18th century. But of course, they are actually referring to gender. They don't mean someone we would now understand as intersex. They mean somebody who's playing with those boundaries of gender. And I think that brings us on to Fanny and Stella, because that playfulness and that blurring is happening here. So I, and this is why I wanted you to have this conversation, because I think you're so uniquely placed, because you perform, you are an actor, you're a historian, you're
9:21 Speaker 01 a drag artist, you're an activist, you have. All of the things that they had in many ways.
9:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
9:29 Speaker 01 Your, your life in some ways, thankfully, without the, the legal ramifications nowadays, although there are other ramifications.
9:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
9:36 Speaker 01 You know.
9:37 Speaker 02 I will say, watch this space.
9:38 Speaker 01 Right, yeah, see, you, you just, you, you don't know, do you? What's coming around the corner?
9:42 Speaker 02 No.
9:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, and so what we want to talk about with Fanny and Stella to begin with, just to allow people into the world a little bit is, we'll get into the who they are in a minute, but as far as you see it through the research you've done on them and through conversations that we're, we're going to have today, what is their gender performance in, in the context of 1870? And, and let's talk about the, you know, a lot of people shy away from this conversation, but I don't think we should, being who we are on this platform. Pronouns, how do we refer to them? What's the best way to talk about them? The most respectful way to talk about them and to really highlight this history in a, in a positive way?
10:17 Speaker 02 Sure. And well, I think context is very important. And what is central to this story is drag as a theatrical device.
10:30 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:31 Speaker 02 Right, that is a contentious thing that comes up in court.
10:35 Speaker 01 Hmm.
10:35 Speaker 02 And, and it's important, I think, to just get a lay of the land of like, okay, if you are someone in the mid 1850s and you were going to have a gander around London to find crosses, where are you going to go? And so the circus is a good one. Uh, so circuses are pretty unregulated entertainment at this time. And, and there's a great sort of interesting business plan, which is claim women are doing things and it's just teenage boys being acrobats, for example, on the back of horses.
11:14 Speaker 01 And so what? It's kind of saying, women don't do this, but look, we have them.
11:19 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:19 Speaker 01 Actually, they're not even, so there's just layers of gender play there.
11:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, and circus and, and sideshow and freak show, I think freak has, freak is a term that will come up when talking about this history because the Victorians don't understand freakish. And the way that we would call it freakishness, to be made a freak is more to be the centre of attention. And there's not that negative connotation with it, right? So sexes will employ, you know, bearded women, for example. That those people are not always people assigned male at birth presenting as women. You know, there are plenty of medical conditions that cause facial hair to sprout.
12:01 Speaker 02 And so there is this kind of interesting blurring the lines of gender to begin with, which is something that is interesting.
12:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:09 Speaker 02 I think that's also something that you need to understand is that like Britain is at the height of its empire at this point, right? It's taken a dip after losing America and we had to take some time and lick our wounds and fight Napoleon and all that.
12:25 Speaker 01 All the other things.
12:26 Speaker 02 And then Vicky comes along and there is this prompting of like no for queen and country. And so London at this time, I believe I'm correct in saying is the biggest city in Europe.
12:40 Speaker 01 Yes.
12:40 Speaker 02 And it's welcoming thousands, if not millions of people from across the world. It's the biggest city that and and sort of migration of people that the world has seen arguably since ancient Rome. And so you're going to get entertainment that people want to have a look at. And so if you're a bit middle class and the circus is all right, but you don't really want to be seen in those settings. Then what are the other options? You can go to the theatre.
13:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
13:10 Speaker 02 Theatre on the West End has had female actresses since the reign of Charles the Second. They kind of kill off the the drag queen that the Elizabethans would have understood it as. But they invent the drag king, which is very convenient because particularly for the more highbrow arts like opera. If you have a young man in a story that needs to be de-sexualized in order to showcase his youth. Then you just cast a young woman and put her in breeches and so they got called breeches roles.
13:42 Speaker 01 And we still see that today. I mean, think of Peter Pan's. All across the country.
13:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a really good one. I know over lockdown, I watched a recorded version of Cinderella. I think it's like Puccini or something.
13:54 Speaker 01 Okay, yeah, sure.
13:54 Speaker 02 I'm not that good on opera. And the prince was a woman.
13:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:58 Speaker 02 Forty, like forty year old woman who was very good sort of, sort of tenor.
14:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
14:03 Speaker 02 Voice, but was, was in drag.
14:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
14:06 Speaker 02 And so that's like highbrow. If you want to go a bit more lowbrow, there's pantomime. Pantomimes start as like vignettes that accompany variety theatre, basically, and they're fairy tales because everyone knows them. So you can play with the sort of expectations of what a fairy story is. And that invites a lot of crossdressing, typically of older female characters. And some people make lots of good money doing this. Dan Lino is a really good example. If you Google a picture of Dan Lino, he will almost certainly be in female attire, playing some sort of grand dame, might be the stepmother from Cinderella.
14:50 Speaker 02 The famous one, and this is also important to point out, is him as Widow Twanky.
14:57 Speaker 02 And that is a Chinese story.
14:59 Speaker 01 Right.
15:00 Speaker 02 That he leans into.
15:02 Speaker 01 This is interesting, right? Because now we're talking about this idea. You talked about London being one of those, one of the foremost cities in the world where everyone is crossing through here. There's, there's something for everyone to see, everyone to experience, different communities, different parts of the world, coalescing in this one city. And now we're bringing in this idea on top of gender, this idea of race into it as well. And I think, you know, you spoke about empire before. Empire is trying in so many different ways to control, especially at this particular moment in time, in the eighteen seventies, to control ideas around race and gender. And we're, we're going to see that in terms of gender here. But what you're pointing to there is this kind of cross section between the gender
15:44 Speaker 01 ideas, playfulness, and then the kind of more insidious ideas that are happening around race and the crossover.
15:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, and that's where you get minstrelsy, right? So no discussion of Victorian crossdressing is kind of complete without acknowledging minstrelsy, which like, I think we struggle to imagine today just how pervasive minstrelsy was in culture, because it still is pervasive. You know, like Jingle Bells, the famous song that is actually not about Christmas, apparently it's about Thanksgiving, is a minstrel song. It was normalized. It was completely normalized.
16:22 Speaker 01 They weren't even questioning the appearance of people in blackface, or of people in drag to a certain extent, depending on the context of where they're seeing it, which kind of brings me to Fanny and Stella a little bit. And you talked there about, and this is what reminded me to make this link, you talked about how there were livelihoods to be made in this world of entertainment. And for Fanny and Stella and other people like them, there is money to be made in donning geish and to putting yourself on stage.
17:06 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
17:49 Speaker 03 Land of Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt and avoid the poisoner's cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
18:43 Speaker 01 Let's start with Stella Ernest Bolton first. What do we know about Stella?
18:48 Speaker 02 We always start with Stella. So Stella, so we do need to have a conversation as well about how we're going to refer to them.
18:55 Speaker 01 Go, you tell me what your findings are on this.
18:58 Speaker 02 I'm in drag.
18:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:59 Speaker 02 I feel very comfortable referring to them as their drag names.
19:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:04 Speaker 02 Because number one, they're not consistent. They do change names quite a lot.
19:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:09 Speaker 02 Stella is the one that she's using when she's arrested. It's the name that her friends and acquaintances will... In modern parlance, we would say Kiki with her with. And I like Stella more than I like Ernest, to be honest.
19:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's just a nicer name.
19:26 Speaker 02 I love the name Ernest, but Stella is beautiful.
19:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, and Stella was beautiful.
19:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, she's the hot one.
19:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:33 Speaker 02 So Stella's a bit weird, right? So in this context, we have, you know, you've got minstrelsy, you've got people like Dan Leener doing pantomime. Stella Boulton is born in 1847. Her dad is a wine stockbroker.
19:49 Speaker 01 So there's a bit of money.
19:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, but not loads.
19:51 Speaker 01 No, no, we're middle classing it here.
19:53 Speaker 02 Yes. So one thing to keep in mind is that the stockbroking that we think of Greed is Good, Iron Rand, all that 1980s malarkey is somewhat there, but it's a lot more sort of difficult to make it big. You're a trader, you're an importer.
20:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
20:13 Speaker 02 And that's where her dad is for wine.
20:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:15 Speaker 02 And he has married a lovely lady called Mary Ann, who we will have to come back to at some point. But Mary Ann Bolton is, she's had, I think it's either two or three sons before Ernest, who have both, or all three have passed away as children. And I do think that is, A, something that gets overlooked when talking about history, about the loss of children and how that will impact relationships with children that manage to survive. And I think Stella's relationship with her mother is foundational on that she didn't really seem to care how he behaved. She was just happy he was alive.
20:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, nice.
20:57 Speaker 02 And he's, he's a little cross dresser as a child.
21:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:03 Speaker 02 And it's also-
21:04 Speaker 01 Even as a child?
21:04 Speaker 02 Yes.
21:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:06 Speaker 02 According to her.
21:07 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yeah.
21:07 Speaker 02 And so also something to flag as well, there's a lot of different layers to this, is that this story is about a crime and is a courtroom drama, right? It's a sex scandal, quite literally, not sex in the sort of erotic sense, but in a biological sense. And we are going to encounter layers upon layers of scrutiny to these texts because at the end of the day, I know you're not supposed to lie on the stand, but you will frame information in a way to make it seem more innocent than-
21:43 Speaker 01 Right. Yeah, of course, there's, there's an agenda, but and equally, I think it's a really good reminder that most of what we know about Fanny and Stella is coming through the prism of, of aggressive documents, essentially.
21:54 Speaker 02 A trial transcript that survives in its entirety. And you've done work on Oscar Wilde's- There's not a complete trial transcript of the wives.
22:02 Speaker 01 No, no, they're not. There's a lot there, but they're not complete. Yeah, it's, this is, this, I believe this is more complete.
22:10 Speaker 02 Yeah.
22:10 Speaker 01 And it's, it's how we get introduced to them, as I say, and so we've touched on, there's Stella.
22:15 Speaker 02 Stella, yeah.
22:16 Speaker 01 Let's go to Fanny, who, by the way, and I just think this is so funny. I think it's so catty as well. Amongst her friends, as far as I'm aware, Fanny was often referred to as the handsome one.
22:29 Speaker 02 Yeah.
22:30 Speaker 01 I'm like, all right, shade.
22:32 Speaker 02 Do you know what? There's a lot of photographs of them.
22:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, there is, isn't there? There's quite a few.
22:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, they, they loved getting their pictures taken, which, same.
22:39 Speaker 01 Fair enough.
22:40 Speaker 02 But she certainly, listen, some of us are born with facial structures that look quite androgynous.
22:49 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
22:49 Speaker 02 And it is important to mention that at the time of the trial, they are 23.
22:54 Speaker 01 Young.
22:54 Speaker 02 Fanny is 23, Stella is 22. They're both born in 1847, just at separate ends. And like, they are not fully grown adults.
23:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, they are still, you know, even at the time, they're considered young.
23:10 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, yeah. These are young people. Yeah.
23:11 Speaker 02 And I, I think Fanny was quite a handsome boy, but.
23:16 Speaker 01 For some reason, I know, I agree with you, but I was looking going, there's nothing wrong with poor Fanny. She's absolutely fine, bless her. But it's, it's also, I think it's something got to do with ideas of desire around people in drag. And often desire coming from same-sex attractive men as well, going, which one am I going to pick here? As if they're available for you. So, so we have this image of Fanny then, but, but tell us about her background. So we talked about Stella's upbringing a little bit. What about Fanny?
23:45 Speaker 02 Fanny is, is, is the rich one out of the two of them.
23:49 Speaker 01 Is she, yeah.
23:50 Speaker 02 So her, so she's one of 12.
23:53 Speaker 01 Ah.
23:54 Speaker 02 Yeah.
23:54 Speaker 01 Were they Irish?
23:55 Speaker 02 Um, no.
23:57 Speaker 01 I can say that because I am Irish. It's fine. Yeah.
23:58 Speaker 02 I, I mean, it's, it would, it would be a fair assumption to make. I'm not gonna lie. You know, my, I think my nan was one of 13.
24:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think mine too.
24:05 Speaker 02 So, no, they are respectable, upper middle class. Her dad is a judge.
24:13 Speaker 01 Oh.
24:14 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:15 Speaker 01 Okay.
24:16 Speaker 02 And she is the third son. Okay. So this is kind of important. The eldest one dies.
24:22 Speaker 01 Right.
24:23 Speaker 02 In, uh, he's, I think he's in the military and he dies.
24:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:27 Speaker 02 The second one.
24:30 Speaker 02 Is is doing some stuff on the side with an Italian boyfriend.
24:35 Speaker 01 Oh.
24:36 Speaker 02 And a few years prior to the trial gets brought to court as a victim of blackmail. Because the Italian boyfriend is threatening to out him as.
24:45 Speaker 01 Oh, I see.
24:47 Speaker 02 A sodomite.
24:48 Speaker 01 But this is the family business.
24:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, and then it gets thrown out of court. And then two years later, what happens?
24:54 Speaker 01 Good old Fanny.
24:55 Speaker 02 No.
24:55 Speaker 01 Oh, no, what?
24:57 Speaker 02 Harry, that's the brother's name, Harry.
24:59 Speaker 01 Oh, I see.
24:59 Speaker 02 Starts trying to get it on with a police officer.
25:02 Speaker 01 A get caught again.
25:04 Speaker 02 Yeah.
25:04 Speaker 01 Like, so goes, so is up against, is up in court again.
25:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, and you can abscond. So.
25:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:13 Speaker 02 Absconding as well is a very important thing at this point in time. And maybe we should cover the legislation.
25:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:18 Speaker 02 That is in place.
25:19 Speaker 01 We'll come to that.
25:20 Speaker 02 You can run away.
25:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
25:22 Speaker 02 In theory, it's not that bad of a crime.
25:24 Speaker 01 They won't follow you.
25:25 Speaker 02 No.
25:26 Speaker 01 If you make their jobs a little bit easier, the likelihood is unless you're like particularly profiled, these wouldn't have been profiled enough. They're not going to pursue you too far.
25:34 Speaker 02 No, and I do wonder if that was on the family advice.
25:37 Speaker 01 Well, they will have known the law quite well if they're.
25:39 Speaker 02 Well, his dad is a judge.
25:40 Speaker 01 Exactly. They know what they're doing here.
25:42 Speaker 02 And they live in Maribor, you know, like Maribor in like the eighteen forties through to the eighteen sixties. That's a very fashionable corner of London to be.
25:51 Speaker 01 Still is.
25:51 Speaker 02 And it still is. And so Fanny is raised in a house. She doesn't go to school, but she's educated by her sisters. Because her mum dies.
26:00 Speaker 01 Okay.
26:01 Speaker 02 Her mum dies when Fanny is three.
26:03 Speaker 01 Oh.
26:03 Speaker 02 And he's got, or she, they have got, so even I made mistakes.
26:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, but it's not even a mistake because here's the thing, they do code switch themselves all the time. They use different pronouns all the time.
26:14 Speaker 02 Yeah.
26:15 Speaker 01 And I just think like, we're just following what they were doing. Like, that's, she uses she sometimes, uses he sometimes.
26:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
26:21 Speaker 01 Will do the same because that's, that's the most respectful thing to do.
26:25 Speaker 02 Yeah. And so she, I like she, she is raised primarily around women, around a lot of women that she's related to. Fanny, there's not as much clear cut. Stuff about Stella is, it's in the name, she's the star.
26:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:43 Speaker 02 Of the story. But Fanny likes acting and I think also something needs to be sort of discussed around just how boring life in the Victorian times could be.
26:56 Speaker 01 Depending on what you're doing, yeah.
26:58 Speaker 02 Domestic entertainment is a huge part of it. Like, you know, you're having, you've got, there's no TV, there's no radio. Depending on the family, there's an aversion to modern technology. But there is home theatricals, which involve a lot of dressing up and being silly for your family's entertainment. And I think Fanny comes to cross dressing in that regard. She's got loads of older sisters.
27:26 Speaker 01 Sisters are there.
27:27 Speaker 02 Sisters are there.
27:28 Speaker 01 Throwing on an L skirt again.
27:30 Speaker 02 I'm quite lucky because I've got two older sisters. They didn't do that.
27:34 Speaker 01 Oh, they didn't?
27:35 Speaker 02 No, I think I wanted them to.
27:37 Speaker 01 It's like, you're making up for it now?
27:39 Speaker 02 No, exactly. I'm overcompensating. But yeah, so it's really interesting, right? So Stella's from a boy family. She has a, she has a brother.
27:47 Speaker 01 A boy family.
27:48 Speaker 02 A boy family.
27:49 Speaker 01 That's what we call them now.
27:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, the TikTok lingo, you know? It's coming for us all. But yeah, Stella's from a family of boys and Fanny is from a family of girls.
28:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:01 Speaker 02 And that will shape a lot, I think, about how they behave.
28:05 Speaker 01 And how they go into society.
28:07 Speaker 02 Definitely.
28:08 Speaker 01 Right, I want to skip forward a little bit. We'll come back on all of this because we'll talk about the legislation that you mentioned and we'll talk about all of that. But, okay, I want to come skip forward a little bit and come to the main event of, of the, the arrest and the build up to the arrest. And then we can backpedal a little bit and find out some of the context. Fanny and Stella are known in the area around the West End that is known for its entertainment culture. They are part of that scene. They are part of that, that group of people. The Strand is known for its light comedy. There's burlesque happening there, it's popular culture. And the police are there and thereabouts. I mean, I used to work in Strand for years and. A bar there. So I know that's not much has changed, to be perfectly honest.
28:51 Speaker 01 But here's a report from the Liverpool Daily Echo and it says, well, yes. William Chamberlain Constable said, I have seen the two dressed as women, the two being Fanny and Stella, dressed as women about the neighbourhood of Brunswick Square and at the Hobart Casino, always in female attire, talking to gentlemen for the last year, suspecting them, I watched them. Interesting. So it is the 28th of April, 1870. The pair have gone to the Strand Theatre, dressed as women, as is their custom to do. Inside, men in dresses are part of that entertainment. That's kind of what I'm getting at here.
29:33 Speaker 01 And there is something that happens that night that is different than every other night, and it changes the course of their lives.
29:43 Speaker 02 Yes. It's a Thursday night, which I think gives a lot of context. Cause they're wasted.
29:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
29:50 Speaker 02 From the sounds of it, they're very drunk and they drink a lot.
29:53 Speaker 01 And why would you not be, by the way?
29:55 Speaker 02 Yeah. And I think this is something that like, I feel very protective of, which is that they are not,
30:04 Speaker 02 they're not like your picture perfect.
30:07 Speaker 01 No.
30:07 Speaker 02 Victims.
30:08 Speaker 01 Why should they be?
30:09 Speaker 02 And they are, they are very much reminiscent, I think, of queer culture from a much older time than like people my generation, I'm 25, people my generation will be, I'm sorry, will be familiar with, which is, you know, there is a lot more of a culture around drinking, about being intoxicated in public. And that's not a bad thing.
30:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
30:32 Speaker 02 Cause they're living through quite interesting times in history.
30:36 Speaker 01 There's, there's a lot going on for them.
30:38 Speaker 02 And they've.
30:39 Speaker 01 Are they at work this night or are they there?
30:41 Speaker 02 I mean. No.
30:42 Speaker 01 I, I should highlight this, I suppose. There is an implication. And I'd be interested to know your opinion on this, but there is an implication in some of the research that Fanny and Stella were also sex workers and soliciting.
30:52 Speaker 02 Yes.
30:52 Speaker 01 What, do we, do we think there's enough there to say that?
30:55 Speaker 02 Kinda.
30:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, I, I, I think so. My instinct is it's probably the case.
30:59 Speaker 02 They're actors, right? And so one thing that you will see is that like Stella and Fanny are maybe not characters that they've played on stage, but they're archetypes.
31:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:11 Speaker 02 And Stella is a young loose woman who was like.
31:17 Speaker 02 The terror of Victorian Britain, you know, because she was loose lipped, she swore a lot. She, um, she smoked cigarettes, which was not a done thing at the time. Um, and Fanny was, um, more genteel, a bit more of a matronly mother.
31:38 Speaker 01 Kind of. That's probably what I would do if I was going to bed. Just like, just give me a bonnet and put me to bed.
31:43 Speaker 02 Well, she pretends to be a widow sometimes.
31:46 Speaker 01 Does she? That's iconic.
31:47 Speaker 02 Which is iconic because at the start of the decade, what happens? Albert dies.
31:51 Speaker 01 Sure, sure, sure.
31:53 Speaker 02 And so we are living in a Britain that has, uh, the widow of Windsor at the head of it. And I, it's, it's not trendy to be a widow, but I will say it will give you a lot of societal freedom.
32:05 Speaker 01 Yes, absolutely, yeah.
32:07 Speaker 02 Being a young lady like Stella is not at liberty to partake in, right? And she can be left alone in the company of men, for example. Stella is a young lady and always needs an attendant nearby to make sure that everything is above board.
32:21 Speaker 01 Yes.
32:21 Speaker 02 And it sounds like they're on a date, to be honest. They're there with two gents.
32:26 Speaker 01 And the Strand Theatre.
32:27 Speaker 02 In a private box.
32:28 Speaker 01 Yes. And we do know what happens in private boxes in these types of venues. And, and actually I've worked in theatre bars, I said already, and it still happens in boxes to this day.
32:36 Speaker 02 Oh, yes.
32:37 Speaker 01 But, uh, you would be shocked to know what some of the stuff that happens in those boxes. Anyway, uh, we're not here to judge, but we will. Um, so we, we, what is it that, so nothing is unusual about this. They're there, they're with, possibly on a date, they're in company, they've done this before. Why then is this the night that, that this happens, do we think?
33:01 Speaker 02 They're being very loud.
33:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:03 Speaker 02 That's one thing. People are getting annoyed because they keep making rude jokes and, and shouting over the actors, which fears. I've been to the theatre with drag queens before. That's what happens.
33:15 Speaker 01 That, that stacks up.
33:16 Speaker 02 That, yes. And, um, they keep making like kissing noises at the people, which I've, I've read elsewhere is kind of like this ASMR, if you would like me to, is like.
33:31 Speaker 01 Oh.
33:32 Speaker 02 Which was a calling.
33:33 Speaker 01 I hope we got that on YouTube, just to say.
33:36 Speaker 02 Don't AI me, please.
33:40 Speaker 02 Is is a calling card for sex workers to procure Johns. And so they're being very loud and very noisy. You will have also heard from.
33:49 Speaker 01 I'm so sorry, I'm gonna stop you there. I'm gonna stop you there and say, what other history podcast or YouTube channel are you getting?
33:56 Speaker 02 Come on.
33:56 Speaker 01 A drag queen doing 19th century sex call noises? Just to put it out there, if there's any awards going, there's only one place that you're gonna find this. I'm so sorry.
34:05 Speaker 02 You are watching History Hit.
34:10 Speaker 02 So you will have heard at the very beginning of that sentence that I've watched them for over a year.
34:16 Speaker 01 Yes, yes.
34:17 Speaker 02 They're under police surveillance.
34:18 Speaker 01 Isn't that odd a little bit?
34:20 Speaker 02 Kinda.
34:20 Speaker 01 For a year. I mean, I know there's, there's always been raids, there's always been surveillance, but that's a long time a year.
34:25 Speaker 02 Stella has a bit of a reputation. She's, she's run into the law quite a few times.
34:30 Speaker 01 As we see.
34:30 Speaker 02 And one of, so she's ran to the law twice at this point. And it's because they are, well, certainly Stella is just so effeminate.
34:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
34:39 Speaker 02 And one of the men that they're with that night, Hugh Mundell, is a bit of a hanger on for Stella. Stella is taken, I should also note. And one of the reasons why the police may have been following in their sort of footsteps is because she is going around calling herself Lady Arthur Clinton.
34:56 Speaker 01 Brilliant. Of course she is.
34:57 Speaker 02 And Lady Arthur Clinton is the wife of Arthur Clinton, who is the third son of the Duke of Newcastle.
35:07 Speaker 01 Right, okay, so she's picked, she's picked the aristocracy to marry into.
35:12 Speaker 02 Yeah. And I think we look and we don't judge.
35:16 Speaker 01 We look.
35:17 Speaker 02 You don't have a photograph of Arthur Clinton in front of you, do you? You don't have all that.
35:21 Speaker 01 Is there a Google?
35:22 Speaker 02 Yeah.
35:22 Speaker 01 Okay.
35:23 Speaker 02 He's ugly.
35:24 Speaker 01 Okay.
35:24 Speaker 02 I'm sorry.
35:25 Speaker 01 I'm allowed, I'm gonna allow it.
35:26 Speaker 02 He was a nice, I'm sure he was a very lovely man.
35:28 Speaker 01 I'll Google it later.
35:29 Speaker 02 And but he was MP.
35:31 Speaker 01 Yes.
35:31 Speaker 02 So his brother was the MP for Newark in Nottinghamshire. And in the 1860, I think it's the 1865 election, he, he becomes the MP for Newark. And his dad works in the government. It's very important to keep a tab on sex work at this time. You know, there is legislation in place that is, allows the police to stop and search anyone they believe is a sex worker, a prostitute in the parlance of the day, and investigate them and, you know, perform medical examinations on them without their consent. And I think that's really interesting because that's what happens to Stella and Fanny.
36:15 Speaker 01 Sure.
36:15 Speaker 02 So I think personally, and the family are very silent in this case, particularly the Duke's family are like a silent partner in this. And I wouldn't be shocked if they were being followed in a kind of Christine Keeler-esque to draw parallels between about like, what do these people know?
36:37 Speaker 01 Yes, yes.
36:38 Speaker 02 And what are they privy to?
36:39 Speaker 01 Yes.
36:40 Speaker 02 And so they are arrested. Hugh Mundell, who is with them, testifies again and again.
36:47 Speaker 01 What are they arrested for though? Making noise? No. I mean, I do know the answer, but yeah.
36:51 Speaker 02 So this is where the story requires me to read legal jargon and I am sorry for it. But so when they are brought to the magistrate's court at Bow Street.
37:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
37:03 Speaker 02 They are, they are told that they are breaking several laws and they are charged with the following the next day. That they did each and one another feloniously commit the abominable crime of boogery.
37:23 Speaker 01 Okay.
37:24 Speaker 02 Further, that they did unlawfully conspire together and with diverse other persons feloniously to commit the said crimes. Further, that they did unlawfully conspire together and with diverse other persons to induce and incite other persons feloniously with them to commit the said crime. And further.
37:46 Speaker 01 No, good, okay.
37:46 Speaker 02 That they being men did unlawfully conspire together and with diverse others to distinguish themselves as women and to frequent places of public resort so disguised and to thereby openly and scandalously outrage public decency and corrupt public morals.
38:04 Speaker 01 Okay. Now, they've been charged the following day. So this is the 29th. They've been charged for this. Okay, I have a few, a few things to kind of unpack with this. First of all, there's not many laws at this time as they stand. They've been slightly changed since the 18th century, but. The burden of proof for sodomy, which is really kind of surprising that Fanny and Stella are even brought up on this, is penetration. You need to be able to prove penetration. And that's a hard thing to prove.
38:30 Speaker 02 Hello.
38:31 Speaker 01 Unless one of, unless one of the participants, and we see this in the 18th century, goes, yeah, he did, because I was the, as they would have said, the pathic or the bottom. And I can attest, I can testify that that's what happened. We don't have that here.
38:48 Speaker 02 No.
38:48 Speaker 01 So what they're saying is, which is odd i- in terms of sodomy laws, is that they're quite girly. They must take it up the charts.
38:57 Speaker 02 And that's the interesting thing about this case.
39:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:00 Speaker 02 It's a legal precedent in a lot of things, but one of the big things is crossdressing.
39:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:04 Speaker 02 Because as I've described earlier, there's a whole industry of people. Dan Lino was straight.
39:09 Speaker 01 Mm hmm. Yes, yes.
39:11 Speaker 02 It is the first time that there is a correlation in the public imagination of being a crossdresser and being a queer.
39:16 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:17 Speaker 02 And I use that word queer because sodomy in this time is more akin to sexual assault, right?
39:25 Speaker 01 It's, it's, it can, it can, yes, the law equates to all of those things. So the sodomy law includes buggery.
39:34 Speaker 02 Yes.
39:34 Speaker 01 Bestiality.
39:35 Speaker 02 Yes.
39:35 Speaker 01 And abuse of rape, basically. Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
39:39 Speaker 02 And so it's, it's new legislation. That's the interesting thing. In 1861, there's this bill that collects up all of the refuse offenses against the person.
39:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:51 Speaker 02 And that is basically any conceivable way that you can damage someone else.
39:55 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:56 Speaker 02 And so there's, it's, it's under the things of like procuring someone to get an abortion, a pregnancy termination. It's, it's a bill, in my perspective, I was looking through the legislation last night because it's still on the government website. It's a bill targeting poor people.
40:13 Speaker 01 Ah, yeah, sure. It, it, it also feeds into the, what used to be the Vagrancy Act.
40:17 Speaker 02 Yeah.
40:18 Speaker 01 It also comes in, and I, you, you mentioned it there, this idea of gross indecency as well, and the fact that they overlap both of them. Right. So we have, Fanny and Stella have now been arrested.
40:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
40:28 Speaker 01 They have been charged. I would imagine, we know that it's going to be, they're going to be charged under conspiracy laws, under sodomy laws, under all kinds of different moral institutional changes.
40:43 Speaker 02 Yeah.
40:45 Speaker 01 What is the evidence here? And how do they go about trying to prove this? Because there's still a burden to be met here that they have to prove it. So what do these two people have to undergo? Because I can imagine it might be quite bleak in order for Victoria, because it's going to be Victoria versus in order for Victoria to feel satisfied that they did this.
41:09 Speaker 02 They immediately after getting charged are brought back across the street to the prison that they were brought to on Thursday night, Friday morning. One thing to also note as well is that when they first appear in court, they're still in drag.
41:22 Speaker 01 Because it's so quick, such a quick turnaround.
41:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, the night before. And apparently there is a crowd outside. It's a bit weird because it happened after the evening news would have been published and late enough that it wouldn't have hit the morning press. So people know about it. And what is really horrible about what's next? And just like the biggest trigger warning for like medical sexual assault. If that's something that makes you uncomfortable, maybe skip forward about three minutes. They are ordered to undress for the second time in front of a room full of policemen. And quite conveniently, Scotland Yard has procured a doctor. And he has to look for signs of sodomy. And so he
42:08 Speaker 01 Does whatever he has to do.
42:09 Speaker 02 He does what he has to do and makes quite extensive inspection of their genitalia. And there's not actually really good up to date medical texts at this time in Britain about the impact of sodomy. We know that Stella had an anal fistula when she was a child.
42:30 Speaker 01 And this is discovered during?
42:31 Speaker 02 During the inspection. It's noted as being something that's a bit weird. But it is also, Fanny is probably got syphilis. And that makes itself known in sort of scarring tissue around her anus. But it's kind of funny, it's not funny at the same time. He pays a great deal of attention to their genitals and says that they have elongated. Penises, willies, we're gonna be adults. They have big willies and they have, Bolton has really big balls.
43:05 Speaker 01 So bizarre, isn't it?
43:07 Speaker 02 Kinda.
43:08 Speaker 01 Like, what?
43:09 Speaker 02 But it's because it's seen as a sign of like, oh, you've been active in using it.
43:14 Speaker 01 It's exactly, and it's like, it's almost like an engorged appendage that you're so destitute in this demoralised thing that, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
43:24 Speaker 02 And these as well, right, so it's also important to note that the police can get away with this in a way that they couldn't do with someone like Oscar Wilde, who we will have to keep coming back to because he is arguably one of the closest sort of contemporaries of this, even though it happens 25 years later, is that these people are middle class and they don't have good legal representation, at least not initially.
43:46 Speaker 01 Not yet.
43:47 Speaker 02 Their lawyer changes over the course of the trial, but at this point in time, they've got a friend who is wealthy, she's a cross dresser, and she's got a friend who is Jewish, who is a lawyer.
44:15 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
45:09 Speaker 01 So we now have had the idea that they've been arrested, they've been charged, they've been processed, they've been inspected. There will now need to be some kind of administrative process that starts prior to the trial. There will be some hearings that take place. Tell us a little bit about, and these can get very detailed and it's basically admin, a lot of paperwork, so we won't linger too long on this. But the hearings that come before the trial, tell us a little bit about what transpires or what do we learn?
45:39 Speaker 02 Superintendent James Thompson.
45:41 Speaker 01 Another James.
45:41 Speaker 02 Is another one, yeah, is the head of the case and he goes above and beyond. So Fanny and Stella have a flat that has been watched by plainclothes policemen for about a fortnight before they're arrested and they raid the flat basically and steal loads of letters and photographs and the photographs are important, which we'll get to later, steal loads of photographs and all of their drag. And over the course of the hearings, they are basically finding people who have links with the case and also building a prosecution to arrest more people.
46:19 Speaker 01 Right.
46:20 Speaker 02 Including Arthur Clinton.
46:21 Speaker 01 Right.
46:22 Speaker 02 And what is really damning is that Arthur Clinton dies during the trial. Maybe.
46:29 Speaker 01 Oh, ah, you talked about absconding earlier.
46:32 Speaker 02 Yes.
46:33 Speaker 01 And he's the type of person.
46:35 Speaker 02 And he's a nobleman.
46:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, I was gonna say.
46:36 Speaker 02 He's not gonna inherit anything. He's the third son. He's basically a lord for the formality of it.
46:41 Speaker 01 So he can abscond.
46:42 Speaker 02 And maybe he does. I like to think he does personally. I, but his family says he's died of scarlet fever and on his deathbed says, I've got the quote here actually, he basically is like, the only thing I'm guilty of is going a bit too far with my theatrical life.
47:01 Speaker 01 Right. We're all guilty of that.
47:03 Speaker 02 Hello. But we've, he's an MP that is now an actor. That's how him and Stella have met. And there is some evidence to suggest, because Stella has the calling cards that say Lady Arthur Clinton, that they are continuing the kind of drama, narrative drama that they have performed onstage, offstage.
47:20 Speaker 01 Hmm, sure.
47:20 Speaker 02 So they raid this flat and they bring out all of these letters and anyone who's got a letter addressed to them is, is interwoven into the scandal, including people from Scotland.
47:31 Speaker 01 Wow, so this stretches the whole breadth of the country.
47:34 Speaker 02 It's a big one. It's a very big doozy and it's stoking interest. But the prosecution realised that they're in over their heads and they get swapped out. And so, not the prosecution, sorry.
47:48 Speaker 01 The defence.
47:49 Speaker 02 The defence realised that they're in over their heads and they get swapped out. And they get an actually very good lawyer.
47:55 Speaker 01 This was a good thing in many ways, wasn't it? That this change over happened, yeah.
47:59 Speaker 02 He's a really good lawyer. He's got a portrait of him, so you know he must be pretty. And he was a sir, I think. He was a lord. And that gives them enough time. They have about a year.
48:10 Speaker 01 Until the actual trial.
48:11 Speaker 02 Until the actual trial. And the trial is already falling apart before it even goes to trial. So they wanna do it in, I believe it's the Old Bailey.
48:21 Speaker 01 Yes.
48:21 Speaker 02 And actually, they can't. And so it gets tried in the Houses of Parliament.
48:28 Speaker 01 Yes, it does. Yes, this is true. They wanted it to be at the Old Bailey. Yes, yes, yes. You've just reminded me. So, okay, fast forward then, May 1871. Here's the trial. This is the pinnacle of what we have come here to see. We're gonna get an outcome. The defence, as you said, have changed. But they're pretty confident in their stance now. The prosecution are working for the state. They have all these documents. They've got letters from people implicating people up and down the country, all the way up into Scotland, also members of the nobility, some of whom have died slash absconded, whatever that might be. We're in the trial. What happens?
49:04 Speaker 02 So, May 9th, it begins, it's Tuesday, ends on the 15th, which is, I believe, a Monday. So it's about a week.
49:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
49:11 Speaker 02 And over the course of the trial, it is becoming very obvious that the prosecution not only have secured no witnesses to sodomy, which is what they're being charged for, the worst that they can accuse them of is being cross-dressers.
49:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
49:24 Speaker 02 And having dear, affectionate language, lovey language in their letters. And... That is not a crime.
49:34 Speaker 01 No.
49:35 Speaker 02 And it is also what they play on, which is that they're not gay. They're eccentric.
49:42 Speaker 01 Theatrical. And I think we may all have used that defence.
49:46 Speaker 02 Oh, God, yeah. Suck me, age 12.
49:49 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yes.
49:51 Speaker 02 But it's, it is suitable grounds, right? Because crossdressing in the culture imagination is not, is not imagined as being a gay thing.
50:01 Speaker 01 And neither is effeminacy a crime.
50:03 Speaker 02 No.
50:03 Speaker 01 Right? Which, which is essentially what's brought us here.
50:06 Speaker 02 Yeah.
50:07 Speaker 01 You are too effeminate.
50:08 Speaker 02 And, and the masculine ideal has not sort of altered too much at this time that, like, when they show up to court, they're wearing very tight fitting suits and they've grown mustaches.
50:20 Speaker 01 Right, right, right.
50:21 Speaker 02 So they're very dandyish and because they didn't have facial hair previously, because, you know, they didn't want to go out.
50:27 Speaker 01 They're doing funny and sell it?
50:27 Speaker 02 Yeah. They were seen as more untrustworthy, not having facial hair.
50:31 Speaker 01 I see. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. That makes sense in the context of this time.
50:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, because it is, it's seen as kind of, you know, a bit gender ambiguous and that.
50:39 Speaker 01 A stamp of approval to be able to, in terms of Victorian masculinity, to be able to perform that code
50:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, definitely, definitely.
50:47 Speaker 01 of masculinity. So what we have essentially, although it lasts almost a week, is a case that falls, if you were the prosecution, it's embarrassing, actually.
50:56 Speaker 02 It's actually incredibly humiliating because they've broken the law.
50:59 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yes, yes.
51:01 Speaker 02 That police, Mr. James, Superintendent James, is going into a jurisdiction that does not fall under English common law.
51:08 Speaker 01 Hmm.
51:09 Speaker 02 It's in Scots law that is tried by the Scots Parliament and he has blackmailed people into giving him information. And that is seen as a bit like over egg in the pudding.
51:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:19 Speaker 02 A bit. They're a bit like, yeah.
51:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. Even for the Victorians.
51:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a bit too much. And they.
51:27 Speaker 02 They have friends in high places who come quite literally in the public gallery to cheer them on and people boo when like stuff is alleged that is like categorically not true and cheer when it goes well for them. So it is, it's a performance for them. Yeah. And it really does always tie back to this theatrical sort of performance at the heart of their drag, right?
51:55 Speaker 01 And actually, what's great about that is despite this being not life and death, because people are not killed at this point in time for same sex activity and they're found not guilty. Anyway, spoiler, but they are to a certain extent in their element in a perverse sort of way because of the theatrical element of it. I suppose now would be a good time. We're gonna wrap this one up, but now would be a really good time to kind of point out that this trial directly or indirectly, whatever way you want to look at it, impacts what's coming with Wild in the 1890s because what we see is the La Boucher Amendment Act coming afterwards. And this is where it changes from this idea
52:36 Speaker 01 of having to prove sodomy to ideas of gross indecency.
52:41 Speaker 02 Yes.
52:41 Speaker 01 And this is how Wild is tried and then jailed because you wouldn't have been able to prove penetration with Wild either.
52:50 Speaker 02 No. Well, the interesting thing is, right? So the defence get a team of six, well, five medical professionals and a member of parliament because the Crown has a vested interest in the prosecution, right? And they perform another medical inspection and they see no sign of sexual sort of action to their genitals at all. And what the, so what Fanny and Stella do prove actually, and what's really exciting about this trial is that they've got friends, they went to drag balls, they knew gay men from a variety of social backgrounds, which being a minority sexuality, even today, I know you can attest this as well, brings you into
53:33 Speaker 02 Quite interesting places with like, I used to work at a gay bar that Chris Bryant used to go into, do you know the MP?
53:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
53:41 Speaker 02 He used to come in sometimes.
53:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
53:42 Speaker 02 And like, you do get access to these people by this identity factor.
53:46 Speaker 01 That's so true.
53:47 Speaker 02 And what Bolton Park showcase is not necessarily gay sex. That's what the trial is for. And it's, it's, they're bad people to do that with because one of them's pretending to be a widow. And the other one, the other one is in actually quite a committed, happy marriage.
54:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, so true.
54:04 Speaker 02 So they have a maid, for example, who's a witness.
54:08 Speaker 01 This is, and I say this in Queer Georgia, this is what it comes down to often with queer or same-sex attracted or gender non-conforming histories. They always go for, for the sex part of it, as if there's not other, and sex is really important.
54:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
54:21 Speaker 01 There's, it's not, they, they don't concentrate on that potential household unit that we're, you're discovering there, or the fact that, you know, they have this community around them of joy and camaraderie and, and that they, they're crossing these, these class boundaries. But one thing, I don't want to let you go, Fanny, I was gonna say, I don't want to let you go.
54:42 Speaker 02 Fanny?
54:43 Speaker 01 Both of them, why did I go there?
54:45 Speaker 02 I know, Stella, surely.
54:47 Speaker 01 It's because you've got a first sound and she's funny, okay. So before I let you go.
54:51 Speaker 02 Yeah.
54:51 Speaker 01 I want to know what happens to them. We know this, or some people do, that this trial happens and it's so big and theatrical and devastating on another side.
55:00 Speaker 02 Yeah.
55:01 Speaker 01 But what happens in the rest of their lives? Do we even know? Because often people disappear from the archive at this point.
55:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, my favorite thing about like the culmination of the trial is like they're found not guilty.
55:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
55:10 Speaker 02 I guess how long the, the jury take to come to that conclusion?
55:13 Speaker 01 Okay, I really don't know, but I'm gonna guess, I'm gonna say they find them not guilty within 30 minutes.
55:18 Speaker 02 It's a bit 53.
55:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
55:21 Speaker 02 But yeah, they find them not guilty and a cheer of bravo goes up in the public gallery and Stella faints.
55:29 Speaker 01 Oh, Stella.
55:29 Speaker 02 Which is quite sweet. And then immediately, so they are found guilty, they're just not found guilty of this crime.
55:36 Speaker 01 Of that particular, yeah.
55:37 Speaker 02 They are bound over by the law. So they promise to keep the peace and not disturb the public by cross-dressing for, I think it's about two years they're bound over for, they're not allowed to appear in public.
55:51 Speaker 02 Stella immediately is like, well, the newspapers are writing about me. I'm going on tour. And she goes, she goes on this gorgeous tour of the north.
55:59 Speaker 01 It's like she'd just been on Drag Race.
56:00 Speaker 02 Yes. Well, it's, it's, in my mind, it's kind of like the Victorian Chicago, right? Like at the very end.
56:09 Speaker 02 So she goes on tour doing her domestic comedies again with quite a hot actor. And we know that because she puts an advertising call out for an actor.
56:20 Speaker 01 Hot actor.
56:20 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, if you read between the Victorian lines, it's like, yeah, I want a hot piece of meat to accompany me on stage and make me look great.
56:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
56:27 Speaker 02 Whereas Fanny's brother, Harry, gets discovered during the course of the trial, as you'll remember, for opportunity of a police officer.
56:35 Speaker 01 Yes.
56:35 Speaker 02 And he-
56:36 Speaker 01 God, that family has a lot on the plate.
56:38 Speaker 02 Has a lot on the plate. And they, they arrest him and he goes to jail. But Fanny's dad dies. He gives character witness stuff during the trial.
56:49 Speaker 01 He's the judge, right?
56:49 Speaker 02 He is the judge and he dies about six weeks after the verdict comes out.
56:53 Speaker 01 Okay.
56:53 Speaker 02 And so Harry and Fanny high tail it to New York.
56:58 Speaker 02 And Fanny dies in 1881. So she's, she's 32, 33, probably as a result of late stage untreated syphilis.
57:07 Speaker 01 Because you had said that was discovered during the intrusive inspection, yeah?
57:11 Speaker 02 Which I think adds another element to this story, right, is like sickness. And that is something that has always appealed to people about this is, you know, in more modern parlance, we connect it with like HIV and AIDS. But like syphilis kind of was that for a very long stretch of history.
57:26 Speaker 01 And for not just people in what we would now understand as queer community across society.
57:29 Speaker 02 It was endemic, right? And so she has a, she has a minor theatrical career in America and she actually ironically plays Broadway. The theatre that she performed at is one of the few that is, is still standing on Broadway. Which is, I think, a really nice end for Fanny, even though she does die quite young. Stella lives for a lot longer and Stella sees, they get fanfiction written about them at the time that they were living. So Stella would have- Known that, yeah.
58:00 Speaker 01 Been aware that that was there.
58:00 Speaker 02 She'd been out to America at that point. She kind of packed in the acting after a while. She changes her name, so she's not allowed to go by Stella Boulton. She has to go by Ernest Bolton. And then a few years after the trial, she changes it to Ernest Bane.
58:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
58:15 Speaker 02 I think in a bid to kind of distance herself from the scandal.
58:18 Speaker 01 From the notoriety, sure.
58:19 Speaker 02 Yeah. And then she sees the installment of the Criminal Amendment Act in 1885. And she would have known about Oscar Wilde, because she dies in 1904.
58:30 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. I mean, she outlives Wilde.
58:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, she dies of a brain tumour, which is quite a horrible end to go. The particular type of brain tumour that she has. But she sees the long term implications of what she did. And the archive just kind of goes quiet because she doesn't get in trouble again.
58:48 Speaker 01 Does she not?
58:48 Speaker 02 No. But I don't think she learnt her lesson. I reckon she just learned to keep her head down.
58:52 Speaker 01 Listen, Aphrodite, that was, I knew you'd be perfect for this. I knew this would be the perfect way to introduce you to the After Dark audience with this particular history. Because it is so, it is so joyful. Yes, it's hard. Yes, there's awful things that happened to these two people. But at the same time, I always try and say this when I'm talking about queer Georgians, that we really need to remember the lives that they did lead, as opposed to the lives that were taken from them or the lives that were highlighted in court documents. And I think with this, we do get an idea that there was this community around Fanny and Stella that they were part of, that they were loved in and that they were celebrated in and that they were able to live that life. If you have enjoyed this episode, you probably want to find out a little bit more about H R H Aphrodite. Where can they find you?
59:38 Speaker 02 Anywhere. Now, so if you would like to follow my adventures in history, you can look me up on Instagram at H R H Aphrodite, with a P H, not an F. It's a very different Aphrodite. I at the end, H R H Aphrodite I. On Instagram, if you would like to shoot me an email, it is [email protected] .
59:59 Speaker 01 She wants to be booked and blessed, guys. You've done this already. You've worked with the National Archives. You've worked with the National Maritime Museum. She's experienced.
1:00:07 Speaker 02 If you want.
1:00:08 Speaker 01 I feel like I'm her agent now.
1:00:10 Speaker 02 Please be. If you want a historical drag queen to come along and spice up your heritage location, I will do it. So please get in touch. And also, I am the producer of a history drag cabaret.
1:00:23 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yes.
1:00:24 Speaker 02 That I always love to talk about.
1:00:26 Speaker 01 Go on.
1:00:27 Speaker 02 So if you would like to see drag queens, kings and things talking about history and historical subjects, then please come on down to Horrible Histories. We host them at The Divine in Dalston. Please don't sue us, Scholastic. Thank you so much. Come on down and learn about queer history from, you know, the dozens. I'm not the only drag queen doing this. I also do want to vouch and say that this is a whole shelf of performers, including my drag king husband Hunter Gatherer, caster Hex is great. She makes all her own clothes, Elizabeth the Thirsty, Medusa Has Been. You know, there is, this is a very, it may seem niche. This is a big world. So yeah, come on down and talk about queer history with queer people
1:01:12 Speaker 02 in fancy dress. It's quite fun.
1:01:14 Speaker 01 We love it. We love to see it. So that's where you can find Aphrodite and the queer ensemble of drag. If you would like to see myself and Maddie, we are going to be hosting a live book event for her new book, Hoax, which comes out on the 7th of May. And you can find tickets on Maddie's socials. If you have an idea for an episode on After Dark, it's [email protected] . If you've enjoyed this episode, please leave us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts, because what does it do? It helps other people to discover us. And we're on YouTube. Go to YouTube now and you'll find us at After Dark History Hit. And you can watch us as well as listen to us. Thanks very much. I'm going to have enough. Goodbye.
Previous Henry VIII's Descent into Darkness Next The Murder that Shook Mary Queen of Scots Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated