Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal The Dark Truth about the Haitian Revolution About this episode The Haitian Revolution is the only successful, permanent slave revolt in history, resulting in the creation of an independent state.
Haiti is also the first modern nation of the world to permanently abolish slavery.
So what happened the August night of 1791 when the enslaved people of what was known as Saint-Domingue, rose up and started burning plantations?
It's a history that involves American and French Revolutions, with the British and Spanish also waging in on the fighting.
Joining Anthony and Maddy is Marlene Daut, Professor of French and African Diaspora Studies at Yale University and author of several books on Haiti, including Awakening the Ashes: An Intellectual History of the Haitian Revolution.
This episode was edited by Hannah Feodorov. Produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer was Freddy Chick.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 10,282 words · 5 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers. Now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries. And I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Anton and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:51 Speaker 02 Blood donation is now more inclusive. More LGBTQ+ individuals are able to donate blood with the American Red Cross due to FDA guidelines that eliminate eligibility questions based on sexual orientation. The Red Cross celebrates this historic change and welcomes those who may be newly eligible to donate blood. There's a place for everyone in the mission of the Red Cross, including you. The Red Cross is committed to achieving a blood donation process that treats all potential donors with equality and respect, while maintaining the safety of the blood supply. Join us and help save lives. To learn more and make your appointment to donate blood, visit redcrossblood.org/lgbtq. That's redcrossblood.org/lgbtq.
1:42 Speaker 00 It's a prophetically stormy night in Saint-Denis, 1791. Rain lashes the clearing as dozens gather in the dark, breath held, nerves tight as wire. A drumbeat rises, slow at first, then urgent, echoing the tension rippling through the enslaved masses of the island. Beneath the trees, Hookman's voice cuts through the storm, and Cecile Fateman's invocation seems to crack open the night itself.
2:15 Speaker 00 For generations, uprisings have flared and died here, but not this time. Tonight, vows are sworn, spirits called, and fear gives way to something sharper. At Boisquemont, the breaking point has finally come, and revolution is about to ignite.
2:40 Speaker 00 On the island the French called Saint-Domingue, half a million enslaved people laboured under a regime so brutal it was never meant to be survived. But beneath the plantation, something was stirring. Whispers of revolt, where previous generations had fallen short, spread through the enslaved population. In 1791, under the shadow of a vodou ceremony, leaders like Bookman and Fateman lit the spark that would become an inferno. What followed was the only successful slave revolution in history, one that carved the world's first black republic from fire and blood, defeating the might of Napoleon's army in the process.
3:25 Speaker 00 From the heart of revolutionary Haiti, this is After Dark.
3:59 Speaker 01 Hello there, my name's Anthony.
4:01 Speaker 00 And I'm Maddie.
4:02 Speaker 01 And today, we are learning about a history we have long wanted to do on After Dark. The Haitian Revolution of 1791 to 1804 was the final and most decisive in a long line of revolts by the enslaved in the French colony of Saint-Domingue, culminating in the elimination of slavery in the colony and the founding of the Republic of Haiti. It's a violent and bloody history that arguably deserves... More attention than it has previously had. And luckily, we have scholars working in the field who are giving it the attention it deserves. So to help us unpack and understand these dramatic events is Marlene Doutt, Professor of French and African Diaspora Studies at Yale University, and author of several books, including Awakening the Ashes: An Intellectual History of the Haitian Revolution.
4:47 Speaker 01 Marlene, welcome to After Dark.
4:51 Speaker 03 Thank you so much for having me.
4:53 Speaker 01 We're very, very excited, as I said, about this episode. Because one of the reasons we were excited, Marlene, is because we know a lot of people will be coming to this episode with actually very little information to hand about this particular revolution. If you name, you know, the Glorious Revolution of 1688, they might have an idea of that. Obviously, the American Revolution, they'll know something about that, the French Revolution, certainly. But here's another revolution that links in many ways to all of these events, but that people don't have the same kind of firsthand account of for themselves. So before we get into the nitty gritty, can you give us a historical context, I suppose, of the world that created this revolution? So what was happening beforehand in this area?
5:34 Speaker 03 Yes, absolutely. Haiti is certainly a vital part of the age of revolutions. And as you mentioned, it's often leapt out, even though of all those revolutions, it sort of has the most momentous and longitudinal consequences. But of course, it didn't start out that way. So the island of Saint-Domingue, which was a French colony, sits on the western third of the island of Hispaniola in the Caribbean. And the Spanish had come with Columbus in 1492 and colonized the island, forcibly transporting Africans from the continent to work as slaves. But when the French took over the western third, the part that becomes Haiti in 1697, they really transformed the society from kind of a middling slave society,
6:18 Speaker 03 a colony that is, you know, not necessarily that robust or important to Spain at that point. And they transform it into a true plantation society, a true slave society. From 1697 to 1791, when the Haitian Revolution Breaks out, the French forcibly transport nearly 900,000 captive Africans just to that side of the island, which is no bigger than the US state of Massachusetts. And despite the vast amount of torture and death of enslaved Africans on that island, at the moment the revolution breaks out, there are still about 450,000 of them. And there are only about 30,000 white French colonists.
7:03 Speaker 03 So there's a deeply unequal society in terms of who's doing the labor, who's in charge, but also just the numbers. And this really, this disparity will contribute to not just the outbreak of revolution, but to its eventual success.
7:19 Speaker 00 Marlene, you very eloquently hinted at it here, but give us a little more of a sense of what life would have been like for the enslaved peoples who were living in this part of the colony pre-revolution. And of course, the circumstances that then lead to the revolt itself.
7:35 Speaker 03 Yes, so French Saint-Domingue is considered one of the most torturous slave societies in all of the Atlantic world, including North America, what becomes the United States, South America, and all the rest of the Caribbean. It has a reputation of being a torturous society. And one of the reasons for that is the high death rate. So even though I mentioned nearly 900,000 captive Africans just transported by the French, that doesn't count the other flags that transported Africans to the island. If you think about it, there's only half that amount there at the moment of the revolution. And that includes those who are born there for over 100 years. And so when the French crown sent a naturalist, a French naturalist,
8:18 Speaker 03 to the island in the 1770s to figure out why the death rate was so high, he came back with a report. He is not an anti-slavery activist. He is completely racist. And he comes back with a report saying, "The white French colonists are torturing these individuals." That he says, he gives an astonishing statistic. He says, "An African transported to this island will not..." Not live longer than two or three years. He says, an African born on this island will not live above fifteen or sixteen years old. And for his efforts, when he gets back to France with this report, he's fined, arrested, and his book is pulled out of circulation.
9:02 Speaker 03 And again, this is a book commissioned by the French Crown. So this vast inequality, but also the torturous conditions of death. When the Haitian revolutionaries say liberty or death, they mean it because they know that the alternative is remaining enslaved and almost certain death anyway.
9:22 Speaker 01 We've talked, Marlene, about this French presence and the idea of French intellectualism either being coming over and suppressing the enslaved population, or even when it's tried to be challenged, such as the case that you just described there, that it's immediately shot down. But we also know that there's this idea, and I use idea in a really deliberate sense, of ideas of liberty and égalité and fraternité coming out of the French Revolution. So how does the French Revolution influence these French lands overseas? Is there a thought cross pollination there? Or is this something that's totally separate?
10:04 Speaker 03 Well, it's sort of separate and then becomes linked later. And sometimes that linking is only in people's imaginations. And sometimes it depends on the context, who is being influenced. So I did mention two parts of the society, the white French colonists and enslaved Africans. But there's also another large group of people, free people of color. The French had instituted what became later known as the Code Noir in 1685 to regulate their slave colonies. And one of the more interesting provisions of this code said that enslaved African women could be liberated by white men who owned them, were enslaving them,
10:47 Speaker 03 if that white man married the woman and converted her to Catholicism. And then any children produced from that union would follow the Condition of the now free mother. So this led to a large sector of society being free people of color. In some estimates, it's thirty to forty five thousand, so even more than the white French colonists. And these are individuals, because they come from, you know, white French columnist fathers initially. They also own plantations and enslave people. And many of them go to be educated in France. And some of them are there at the moment that the storming of the Bastille happens, when the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen happens,
11:28 Speaker 03 when the French king calls together the estates general and asks for grievances. And they have a lot of grievances because back in Saint-Domingue, they experience a lot of color prejudice, which puzzles them. Because their defense at that point is, but we are plantation owners like you. We are, all we are is people of color, but we're related to white men like you. And do you have this prejudice because we had African mothers or grandmothers? And the white French colonists' response to that was absolutely. Because the white French colonists very much understand that if you say that free people of color can have equal rights, that the white French colonists are not superior to them racially, and these ideas are already in circulation,
12:11 Speaker 03 then how do you explain enslaving only people who are African or of African descent? So their sort of justification falls away and they know that. But when these free people of color go to France, there's some prejudices they experience, but as long as they have a lot of money, they, it seems to not matter as much and they're able to go to the colleges and they're able to circulate in society. And so they certainly seize on the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen to say, what about us? To which the white French colonists say, not you.
12:46 Speaker 00 So we have this very tense society then, Marlene, that's very nuanced, very complicated in terms of the intellectual ideas of race, its definition, the status that everyone occupies within that society, but also in terms of practice, in terms of legal procedure, in terms of what that looks like on the ground. You've spoken about the torture and the violence and the incredibly short life expectancy as well of the people who are enslaved. And I suppose the big arena backdrop of this, as Anthony's mentioned, is the French Revolution and eventually war with Britain that is fought in across both the French and the British Empire. What happens in Haiti in particular, in Saint-Domingue, to spark revolution? Take
13:27 Speaker 00 us to the night the revolution starts. What is that moment when events start to unfold?
13:36 Speaker 03 So in August 1791, in the middle of the month, there are these kind of clandestine meetings. And the most famous one happens at a spot called Mont-Rouge, which is in the northern part of the colony, which will become important because that's the part where you're going to see the most rebellion and revolution as the revolution unfolds. And most of the leaders were going to come out of that region. And so a crowd of enslaved individuals, many of them drivers or what we might call overseers, so enslaved people but who also are kind of in positions of power on various plantations, they watch out and over other enslaved people. And they are sometimes trusted, sometimes feared,
14:18 Speaker 03 but they come together nonetheless, and they decide to hatch a plan for rebellion. And Toussaint Vertu, who's the most famous of the Haitian revolutionary generals, is kind of in a backseat position here. This meeting is led by a man named Boukmandari, there's a man named Biassou, another named Jean-François. And within about a week of this meeting, full-scale revolution breaks out. The freedom fighters, as I like to call them, because the French, of course, called them brigands and insurrectionists and terrorists and all these words, they began burning down plantations. in the northern plain to bring the plantation economy to a standstill.
15:01 Speaker 03 And it turns out that sugarcane burns very fervently and spreads very quickly. And so by the end of seventeen ninety one, there are thousands of plantations that have been destroyed. And nearly every African in the northern plain is in open rebellion, either through using violence to achieve liberty or not working, have completely deserted the plantations where they had been enslaved.
15:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's interesting. There's this kind of multi-pronged approach that not only is there, you know, very understandable violence against the enslavers themselves, but also an attack on the economy, on everything that this island is built on as well. So we have these, you mentioned there's sort of an area in which this is concentrated. Are there pockets of rebellion happening across Saint-Domingue simultaneously? And you hinted that there are leaders within this movement very early on. How coherent is this to begin with? Or is this something where, you know, people on one plantation are hearing about something happening elsewhere? And then they are rising up. What exactly is the plan here?
16:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, one of the astonishing things is, you know, how well organized they are, given the fact that there are such great distances between the plantations in the northern plain. So you of course have Cap-Français, which is the principal port city in the north, which is sort of like the capital of the entire Caribbean, just because of the number of ships coming and going. And remember, Saint-Domingue is principally a sugar and coffee colony, but there's also cacao, indigo, cotton in lesser numbers. But it's their main staple, sugar and coffee. And so the coffee plantations tended to be in the hills. And so those will be set on fire a little bit later.
16:49 Speaker 03 But the revolution, we can actually track it as it spreads. So starting in Montrouge, there are parts to the north and to the south of that. The only place that the French are able to sort of Protect for the moment is Cap Francs, and you can see why they would want to put all of their their efforts behind that. The Freedom Fighters are eventually going to take that city, but not until a couple of years later. Principally, in those early days, the revolution is going to spread southward and westward. We're going to eventually see the city of Port-au-Prince, which is the official capital of the colony and becomes the capital of independent Haiti.
17:29 Speaker 03 We're going to see that fire happen, and we're going to just see a whole-scale, basically end of the plantation economy, which causes the French to want to do anything possible to get it back going, including later, as we will see, abolishing slavery, because it has de facto already been abolished.
17:51 Speaker 01 Let's zoom in a little bit then, Marlene, just to give people a sense of how these events were unfolding on the ground and how the people there were experiencing this. And I want to take you to the night of the 21st of August. We're going back to the the start of the significant unrest, I suppose. So it's the 21st of August, 1791. And over the over a 10-day period thereafter, things really change on the ground. Can you talk us through that particular episode?
18:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, so the enslaved begin to burn down plantations. Many of those leaders started with the plantations where they had been enslaved. And we start to see reports from French soldiers, the French do have a military presence on the island, but it is not significant in the numbers they need. So they have to go and recruit. And so some free men of color, this includes, and of course, lots of white French colonists, including some who had fought in the American Revolution at the Battle of Savannah in October 1779, and others who had fought in various other Caribbean theatres of the American Revolution. Because one of the less well-known things about the American Revolution is that it
19:01 Speaker 03 also involved contests over various islands as the French tried to fight the British on behalf of what would become the United States. And so on. In those 10 days, the French are in disbelief, but they also believe, because this has sort of happened before, just not on the same scale, that they can crush those brigands. And so the language that they're using in their reports is, they say things, the white French colonists, like, "Spread terror everywhere you go." And in fact, even though this is a time when most people believe that, you know, black enslaved Africans are the ones engaged in the majority of the violence, when you look
19:44 Speaker 03 at the reports of the French, they are actually the ones perpetrating most of the violence. The enslaved Africans are burning things, but they aren't kind of shooting at people because they mostly don't have guns until later. It's the white French colonists who will say, "I met 12 of them on the road from this city to this city, and I massacred them all." "I met 400 of them," the Marquis de Rouvray writes home and says, "I killed every last one of them." And several of these officers will, in fact, receive commendations for the number of "rebels" they killed in these early days.
20:22 Speaker 00 So we're seeing that inequality still in terms of numbers, that, you know, you spoke about the large population of enslaved people on the island compared to the white overseers, the white plantation owners, but actually, in terms of how people are armed, the weaponry they have access to, the tactics they might have access to, the way that they can organize and communicate and move across the land is still very much weighted in favor of the white colonists themselves. We have those initial 10 days when everything really starts to come into play. And this is a revolution that isn't overnight, is it? This continues into at least 1792. Let's get to that point when the French are also fighting the British now. So what pressure?
21:09 Speaker 00 Is revolutionary France under in its colonies when it's facing rebellion like this alongside an enemy like the British Empire as well? Does that affect what's happening in Saint-Domingue?
21:20 Speaker 03 It certainly does because the French are dealing with massive chaos. So they've got this chaos that is happening in their most lucrative colony. And they also have to now ward off the British and the Spanish with whom they are at war. And of course, in the 18th century, the French are constantly at war with Britain and Spain, especially with Great Britain. And every time they strike a treaty, that treaty is temporary until one of those powers sort of breaks the treaty and declares war on the other one. And so the French have declared a republic in fall 1792. In January 1793, they have executed their king, which does not make the other world powers that have monarchies very happy.
22:03 Speaker 03 And so by spring 1792, the colony of Saint-Domingue, it's like a world war because they're at war with the Spanish who still occupy the eastern side of the island, who have now invaded. And in fact, some of those freedom fighters who had been leaders in the early days join with the Spanish because they wrongly believed that the Spanish are going to offer them liberty. And then when the British invade, they mostly are in the south near Port-au-Prince. And a lot of the free people of color, especially those who had fought at the Battle of Savannah, join with the British because they believe that Great Britain will respect their rights as free people of color. And so now you have all of this sort of war. They've got to fight the enslaved Africans.
22:48 Speaker 03 They're still also have to fight free people of color who are not allied with either the enslaved Africans or any of the other invading forces, and certainly not with the French. They also have a rebellion going on from the white French colonists who are very upset about the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen because they know it opens the door to to think about rights for free people of color, which they don't want. And so actually, white French colonists during this time period try to create their own independence movement, citing the example of the American colonists from the United States. So France is essentially in big trouble in 1792 and has to take drastic action.
23:28 Speaker 01 I think one of the most tantalizing things about this particular revolution, Marlene, is the fact that we have leaders that are emerging and that have stood the test of time in terms of the historiography. They come down to us even now. Obviously, you mentioned earlier Toussaint Louverture, and there are others as well. Can you give us a taste of who these leaders are in a little bit more detail, maybe pick one or two of them, to sort of give us a sense of why they are leading this and what they have available to them and how they're viewed by the population there?
24:04 Speaker 03 Yes, absolutely. So Boukman Dadi is early on killed by the French colonists. They put a bounty on his head, and a white French colonist literally delivers his head to one of the assemblies to collect the prize. So this leaves a little bit of an opening, no pun intended, because Louverture in French, of course, means the opening. And Toussaint does walk through, following this, and become one of the principal leaders. But he really is one among many at this point. He's not the sort of huge, singular leader he will become later during the revolution. And he has been free. He had free status for decades before the revolution began. He had, by many accounts, learned to read, learned to write,
24:49 Speaker 03 had some education in military and classical antiquity history. He was familiar with certain precepts of the Enlightenment. And so when he starts to give speeches, he's very much utilizing words that come both from his background of being the son of two Africans forcibly transported to the island. He's talking about collective action. He's talking about coming together. And he's able to marry that, however, with this language that would appeal to the free people of color who had been in France. Equal rights, brotherhood, let us all come together, work together. A Haitian proverb says, you know, it's basically the equivalent of many hands lighten the load. It's about the idea of kumbit, which in Haitian
25:31 Speaker 03 caole is collective work for a kind of greater good. And so when you read his speeches, you can see, oh, this is why. He's able to rally the free people of color and the Africans in open rebellion together, even though their causes had initially been separate, is he's speaking to both groups simultaneously. And alongside him, we have Jean-Jacques Desailly, who will become the founder of Independent Haiti, following Toussaint Le Vert's untimely demise. We also have another man eventually named Henri Christophe, who becomes the king of Haiti. And he is from the island of Grenada and he fought in the American Revolution at the Battle of Savannah.
26:14 Speaker 03 And he brings tactical skills that he learned from the blunder that battle was, the French and American patriots lose. And he brings those tactical skills and what he learned from that loss into the revolution. So when you see who becomes leaders, it isn't really accidental. They have qualities that united them together. They were each of them, other than Toussaint, they're mostly born in the colony or in another colony in the Americas. And they bring a wealth of knowledge of other places in the world and other military struggles or actual book knowledge like Toussaint Le Vert.
26:54 Speaker 00 It's fascinating, isn't it, that they're able to transcend all of these different boundaries that are set in place in the colonial world and to speak these different languages, quite literally that enable them to speak to different groups of people and to bring people together.
27:21 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sunny Graham. Years later, Sunny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sunny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
28:01 Speaker 02 Blood donation is now more inclusive. More LGBTQ plus individuals are able to donate blood with the American Red Cross due to FDA guidelines that eliminate eligibility questions based on sexual orientation. The Red Cross celebrates this historic change and welcomes those who may be newly eligible to donate blood. There's a place for everyone in the mission of the Red Cross, including you. The Red Cross is committed to achieving a blood donation process that treats all potential donors with equality and respect while maintaining the safety of the blood supply. Join us and help save lives. To learn more and make your appointment to donate blood, visit redcrossblood.org/lgbtq. That's redcrossblood.org/lgbtq.
28:44 Speaker 04 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets: The History of Sex, Scandal, and Society twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts.
29:28 Speaker 04 Brought to you by the award-winning network, History Hit.
29:43 Speaker 00 Marlene, tell me about some of the women who emerge in the revolution, because it's not just men, is it?
29:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, we could, starting with that, you know, 1791 gathering in August, there is a woman named Cecile Fatima, and she is what's considered a vodou priestess, I guess, in the parlance of today. And she is one of the leaders of this moment when they're trying to convince people that... They should engage in revolt and rebellion. But there's also plenty of other women from everyday women who are providing supplies to soldiers. There are also women fighting in combat, and we know that because the French are killing the freedom fighters indiscriminately when they capture them. And they will say, you know, that they they killed a woman, a woman freedom fighter.
30:32 Speaker 03 So it's sort of like the gender equality of death, right? If you're a freedom fighter, it sort of erases any idea that you would be then treated differently once you're captured. And so we have some of the wives. Those are the women we tend to know most about of the military generals. So one of these women is a woman named Marie-Jeanne La Martinière, and she's married to a black general. And she fights in men's clothing, so she's engaged in armed combat. We also have another wife of the general named Suzanne Belair. She was married to Toussaint Vierter's nephew, Charles Belair, who was also a general. And she helps him, aids him to evade French troops.
31:17 Speaker 03 And when they are caught, they are both executed together. So the story of women in the revolution is sadly also mirrors the sort of destruction against the male population. They did not get any special treatment. In fact, a free woman of color named Marie Bunnell, who had previously been an enslaver, she found herself jailed at one point and had to escape the colony clandestine clandestinely in order to to continue to live. And she initially went to New Orleans and then eventually to Philadelphia. And so this is a time when women do participate, and we have a lot of documentation of it. But we also see them come into the frame mostly as they are punished, because that's what the record sort of leaves us.
32:02 Speaker 00 I'm really fascinated by this, just thinking about women in the French Revolution across the pond in this moment and how, you know, fraternity and egalitarian doesn't necessarily extend to women. And there's a lot of debate, you know, amongst the amongst the French in terms of what women's role will be in this new revolutionary France. And, you know, whilst there are women working as spies and and, you know, potentially trying to create some kind of National Guard in Paris, they don't necessarily get to share the platform with the men in the same way. And I'm interested, Marlene, in how From the communities that are revolting here in Saint-Domingue, what is the view of gender and of women's roles? Is it encouraged and expected that women will revolt alongside the men?
32:44 Speaker 00 You know, the women that you've mentioned there, are they unusual to find themselves in these circumstances because they are married to revolutionary leaders or, you know, partners of, or are moved to fight in a way that isn't ordinary? Or is there more equality? Is that a simplistic way of viewing it to say that there's more equality in this moment in this community?
33:06 Speaker 03 It's a very interesting question because when you read the letters of the male revolutionaries, they don't seem to be sort of like, oh, we need to protect all the women and make, like, the women are there alongside them. And so when they describe them, they don't seem to find it remarkable that women would be aiding them in all of these various ways, or that they would be in combat. And one of the reasons perhaps is because those who had been born on the continent of Africa, who were from societies that had female warriors. And then the other thing is all the tortures that the women themselves experienced in French Saint-Domingue. I think it was simply understandable that even if they didn't engage in armed combat,
33:50 Speaker 03 that they would want to help the male freedom fighters. And so that's what you see a lot of in terms of how they are writing about the women. And it is very interesting then that once emancipation is going to come to the island, the commissioners from France, who formally abolished slavery in 1793, are going to specify precisely because they know Olympe de Gouges, the Declaration of the Rights of Women in France, are going to specify male and female slaves. So even though in French, the male form takes precedent and is supposed to encompass both genders in this context of a law like this, they say nègres et négresses.
34:35 Speaker 03 They make that distinction, and which is because they were definitely influenced by some of the rhetoric and discourses also coming out of France. So you kind of see it on both sides. The other thing I would mention is that Saint-Domingue was a kind of society that upsets our ideas about gender roles, maybe in other ways as well, because women, for example, tended to keep their last names and hyphenate when they would get married. And this was often because they were the partner bringing the most wealth to the relationship. And so when you go into French civil archives, and this is pre-revolution, you see marriage
35:16 Speaker 03 contracts that specify that the property is the woman's and that it's her inheritors, including her children, but if she doesn't have any, her side of the family that kept the money. And that seems to be very different from what was happening in metropolitan France. And this is because of the way that wealth was sort of spread and understood in this colony, which is not operating according to French aristocratic sort of ideals and laws. It seems to have its own special customs and ways of doing things.
35:47 Speaker 01 I want to pick up on one of the names you mentioned when we were talking about these women, Marlene, which is Cécile Fatima. And I want to use her as a gateway and to talk a little bit about the role of Vodou and how that is placing itself within Haitian society and how, if at all, it influences or starts to shape the revolution.
36:07 Speaker 03 Yes, so it's what is called Boukman's Prayer is typically how the role of Vodou, although they didn't call it that in the era, is explained. So at some of these gatherings, the one that happens in the middle of the month, but also some of the ones that happen later, leading up to August 21st, 22nd, and 23rd, which is where we see the revolution really break out. The freedom fighters are kind of taking this oath that later comes to be called Boukman's Prayer. In Haitian Creole, they're saying, you know, the god of the white man calls them to commit crimes, but our god, who's the true god, wants good works from us and wants us to be free. And so Cécile Fatima, in various accounts, she sacrifices an animal.
36:51 Speaker 03 The freedom fighters kind of seal a, they use the blood, you know, to kind of create a brothership and say that we're, you know... We're brothers in arms now, blood brothers in arms. And so she's sort of reputed in Haitian history for her role in bringing together the freedom fighters around the idea of religion, around the idea of one true God, which is Bon Jé, which is not necessarily different from the Christian God, but is different from the God of the colonists. Because we learn fascinating things about the religious worldview of the freedom fighters. Because they have watched the French colonists and priests, Catholic priests on the island, wield the idea of God to keep them in chains.
37:36 Speaker 03 And so when you see how the freedom fighters talk about God, that is a false God, that is not a real God that the white French colonists are praying to. Because there is only one God, Bon Jé, which in Haitian Khayel, roughly translates to Bon Dieu, the good Lord, right? And there's only one of that individual. And the freedom fighters, they pray to and they rely on and gain strength from Bon Jé, not from the false God that the French colonists appear to worship in their eyes.
38:07 Speaker 00 This is a completely new element of the story to me, actually. And I'm really interested in Smalina. And do we have a sense of how this religion that is specific to the freedom fighters and the community that they're drawing on? Do we know how this develops and when it first sort of appears on the island? Is it unique to Saint-Domingue?
38:27 Speaker 03 It's definitely not unique to Saint-Domingue. It's a syncretic religion. It draws on West African religious concepts. A lot of the lois or spirits in contemporary Haitian vodou, we see that they have corollaries with various spirits and religious icons in West Africa, particularly in the Daume and Nigeria and Benin regions, and to some extent in what is now the Congo. And so we can actually see the religious influences. But it's syncretic because we also see the influence of Catholicism. Because of course, the New World Africans, as they came to be called, Were influenced by Christianity, both on the continent,
39:12 Speaker 03 as they were forced to make the long journey, many of them from interior places to the coast and were sort of captured or kept at way stations. Probably the most famous one people know is El Nino Castle or Gory Island off the coast of Senegal. And so there, they had some religious quote unquote instruction. I want to make sure I put that in scare quotes because of course, there's a certain missionizing involved that a lot of these slave traders are saying, you know, first of all, they'll be more docile if we convert them to Christianity and we'll, you know, uproot their paganism and all of these kinds of things. And, you know, it's reasonable to expect that some of the captive Africans and enslaved Africans, as time wore on, began to believe
39:55 Speaker 03 in certain parts of the Christianity that they had been exposed to in terms of reading the Bible and different figures. Because the ones that they sort of pull into what becomes known as Haitian vodou are figures like Mary, people who are seeming self-sacrificing, but also are wise, and various saints like Saint Patrick, for example, that are ones that they kind of use to blend together. And importantly, we do not see in Haitian vodou a Satan figure, a devil figure. And one of the reasons for this may be that from the Haitian revolutionary perspective, the devils were the white French colonists
40:40 Speaker 03 because they actually say that in later writings. So they didn't need to invent some person in the underworld. They were like, you know, that Shakespeare phrase from The Tempest, "Hell is empty and all the devils are here." That sort of seems to be a part of also what they took from Christianity.
41:07 Speaker 02 Blood donation is now more inclusive. More LGBTQ plus individuals are able to donate blood with the American Red Cross due to FDA guidelines that eliminate eligibility questions based on sexual orientation. The Red Cross celebrates this historic change and welcomes those who may be newly eligible to donate blood. There's a place for everyone in the mission of the Red Cross, including you. The Red Cross is committed to achieving a blood donation process that treats all potential donors with equality and respect while maintaining the safety of the blood supply. Join us and help save lives. To learn more and make your appointment to donate blood, visit redcrossblood.org/lgbtq. That's redcrossblood.org/lgbtq.
41:50 Speaker 04 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets, The History of Sex Scandal in Society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts.
42:34 Speaker 04 Brought to you by the award-winning network, History Hit.
42:49 Speaker 01 It's, it's actually quite tantalizing. Well, first of all, I want to say as an Irishman, I'm very pleased that St. Patrick was useful. That, that, that seems, I'm at least proud of that. That said, I think we have a lot to do as Irish people in terms of facing up to our own historic role in the transatlantic slave trade, especially as overseers. And it's not very well known here. We tend to conflate the Irish situation and the situation of enslaved black people. And I think there's so much more nuance there to to be explored in terms of the Americas. But one of the one of the other things that I I'm intrigued about in terms of this idea of this kind of Christian false god. And then the logic that comes with that of going, look what these people are doing.
43:31 Speaker 01 This couldn't be a godly thing. And I and I that that to me is very tantalizing. I've got goosebumps. You were describing it because it just seems so visceral in terms of its reaction to what they're experiencing on the ground. And so true, actually, in so many more sense than than this kind of prescribed Christianity that's being enforced upon these people. I I want to ask you, Marlene, in terms of the end of this, or the kind of, I suppose, end is a is a difficult word, right? Because when do these things end? But the quietening down of this revolution, how does it start to come under control? Under whose control does it come? And how do we see this start to change into something that looks different than what was there before?
44:14 Speaker 03 Yes, so the year seventeen ninety three is going to be a big year. So I mentioned the French have executed their king, they've already instituted a republic, they've sent commissioners to the island to calm things down. They've sent troops to calm things down. But when the commissioners get there, they have a revelation like, oh, my goodness. What we've been told back in France is like not one tenth of actually what's going on here. And they take an astonishing step to abolish slavery formally. Now, again, remember, nobody's working anyway. And this is very clear from newspaper reports, right? So they they take this step and they institute what is supposed to be a plantation economy worked by free hands.
44:56 Speaker 03 And one of the things that they do in these laws is to say, we need those freedom fighters who were the leaders on our side. And so they start to give them important military posts. Toussaint Vercher has since left the Spanish side, joined with the French, he becomes a general. Jean Jacques Desailly, who is one of Toussaint's greatest lieutenants, he also becomes a general. Henri Christophe, he becomes a general. And so now the French are sort of Saying, we want everyone to get back to work on the plantation. We've abolished whipping, we've abolished slavery. We can't sell or buy anybody or transport anybody across the seas. You can't do any of these things, but we do need people to work. And they get to Saint-Louis Verture on their side.
45:37 Speaker 03 And he likes being in power to the extent that he will eventually create a constitution for French Saint-Domingue. And it will name him governor general for life with the ability to choose his successor. Now, this is eighteen oh one. The problem, so from seventeen ninety-three to eighteen oh one, this colony is free and French. Think about that, right? It is being run by free black men like Toussaint Le Verture and his lieutenants. And now in eighteen oh one, Napoleon Bonaparte has risen to power in France. And at first, it seems when you read his letters, he doesn't quite know what to make of Toussaint Le Verture. He's thinking, this might be okay.
46:20 Speaker 03 But once Le Verture sends him the constitution as a kind of fait à conquis, it's been ratified, it's been signed. Toussaint defends himself and says, I was just seeking Bonaparte's approval. But Bonaparte gets it and his, the language Bonaparte used in his diary to explain this moment is, he had drawn his sword out of his sheath. He considered it a declaration of war, a usurpation of his authority as first consul of France. And he sends a massive military expedition, whose primary goal is to crush and defeat Le Verture and arrest him. And sadly, that's what happens.
46:57 Speaker 00 First of all, the absolute audacity of white colonists to say, you know what, guys? We're going to abolish slavery when there's been a revolution and the enslaved have risen up and freed themselves. You know, it's, it's, it seems like bureaucratic nonsense at that point. And Napoleon, I mean, Napoleon complicating things again is just, you know, entirely predictable, isn't it? So when we get to this point where Napoleon's force arrives in Saint-Domingue, what is the feeling among the revolutionaries? The ordinary men and women who have fought for their freedom, who have got themselves out of the plantations, they've burned the fields, they've fought for what they now have. What's their feeling towards their leaders? In terms of have they sold out?
47:42 Speaker 00 Are they still representing their best interests? Is the fact that they're now going to have to fight Napoleon something that they are prepared for? Or is this viewed as a catastrophic miscalculation in terms of the revolutionary leaders themselves?
47:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's a great question because there are definitely some of the freedom fighters who had been very instrumental during the pre 1793 days, who want nothing to do with the French. They do not agree with this idea that what we need to really be focused on is getting the plantation economy back going so that we can benefit France. And also because these black generals are being paid handsomely. In fact, Toussaint Verchur, Dessarine and Christophe Alum, that's not even to mention the other black generals, own between them more than 40 plantations, or leases, I should say, or have control of more than 40 plantations from which they derive profits. Right, so you can see that the people who are working
48:44 Speaker 03 might start to think, hmm, like, what's going on here? We're supposed to be quote unquote free. And so when the Leclerc expedition comes, some of them are not necessarily predisposed to align with the black generals who rightly figure out that France did not send 30,000 troops with Bonaparte's brother in law, a man named General Charles Leclerc, in peace. Right, because when Leclerc comes to the island in 1802, he says, I come in peace. And the black French generals are thinking, well, then why would you need 30,000 French troops? That it was the largest expedition to ever set sail from France at the time. And it's astonishing when you think of all the wars they fought in the early modern period,
49:27 Speaker 03 but also in the 18th century alone, and that they would send this massive expedition. And so the black freedom fighters, led by these generals, have a recruitment problem. Now they need Toussaint Verchur again to rally everyone to his side to convince them. And there are a few things that happen. That are going to initially help him out. One is that only Christophe has command over Cap-France. He's a brigadier general and he gets into this skirmish with Leclerc, who's trying to land his troops there. And Christophe threatens him. He says, if you are going to try to land these troops anyway, when we don't have permission from Toussaint, who is on the eastern side of the island, what is today the Dominican Republic.
50:11 Speaker 03 He says, if you do this anyway, I will burn this city to the ground. And even on those ashes, I will fight you. And Leclerc doesn't believe him. He tries to land the troops anyway and Christophe has the city burned. He tells women and children to evacuate. He has the city burned. And this stance against the French actually does win him some of those friends back from the mountains, who took, in one writer's words, "one look at armed white Frenchmen and they had run for the hills to get their machetes." They were thinking, absolutely not. We're not engaged in any treaties with these, you know, people who've made false promises to us. And Desailly follows suit. And for a time, the black French generals are leading black troops against the French,
50:56 Speaker 03 who it becomes pretty quickly clear that they are trying to reinstate slavery. And one of the reasons that the black freedom fighters know this is because at the Treaty of Amiens, the island of Martinique had been returned to French rule. And now the French have a problem. Because although the commissioners abolished slavery on Saint-Domingue in 1793, the French National Convention had followed that up by abolishing slavery in February 1794 in all French overseas territories. But Martinique was not included because the French had lost the island to the British. And so when the French get the island back, they have to decide, is slavery abolished there? Or can it be maintained?
51:38 Speaker 03 And they passed the law of May 1802, saying it could be maintained. And now the freedom fighters know for certain that the French are not on their side. But in the intervening months, you know, sort of complicated things are happening. Ali Christophe is going to be convinced briefly to join with the French, Dessalines as well, and Toussaint Le Riche feels defeated, and he's going to lay down his arms. He knows that he doesn't have everyone on his side. There were some freedom fighters in the south who had allied with one of the rivals that Toussaint Le Riche had sort of had banished from the island earlier. So there's a lot of factions still at play. And he retires to his plantation, but this isn't good enough for the French.
52:21 Speaker 03 And in June eighteen O two, they trick Toussaint Le Riche into a meeting, and they have him summarily arrested and deported to France.
52:28 Speaker 01 Isn't that so interesting and actually quite horrifying to a certain extent? Because what we're getting is this idea about the abolition of slavery, right? And that comes with all its narrativization that's happened in the intervening two hundred, three hundred years in terms of this kind of the Wilbur force of it all, the white savior-ness of it all. And actually, one of the most chilling things, I think you said during this, Marlene, was that, yes, okay, the slavery was being abolished in French territories. And then Martinique comes back in and they're like, wait, could we still potentially get away with that? And I think that's a really troubling insight into the mindset of people who may even previously have advocated for abolition.
53:12 Speaker 01 It says something far more dangerous and long lasting. And on that note, the long lasting element of this, I'd love to know what you think the legacy of the Haitian Revolution is today. What are we seeing that draws parallels? How do we live with the results of this? How do you see it live cheek by jowl with us today?
53:32 Speaker 03 You know, the legacy of the Haitian Revolution, the true legacy, is in being the first modern nation in the world to permanently abolish slavery. Because, yes, there's the Wilbur force of it all, but on the French side, there's the French Revolution of it all, saying, oh, but the French National Convention abolished slavery in seventeen ninety four. And Napoleon Bonaparte not only maintained it in Martinique in May eighteen O two, he reinstated Slavery in all the other French overseas territories with the law of July eighteen oh two, which makes France the only country in the world ever to reinstate slavery after previously abolishing it. Right? And yet, this is not the narrative of how abolition is told.
54:16 Speaker 03 In fact, in textbooks, you will often read even in the United States, oh, Great Britain was the first nation to abolish the slave trade, not slavery, in eighteen oh seven. But that's actually not true. The Haitian revolutionaries abolished slavery and the slave trade in January eighteen oh four with their Declaration of Independence, followed up in eighteen oh five with the first constitution for Haiti. And so I truly think that the legacy of, you know, insisting that slavery is unacceptable anywhere, at any time, and for any reason. The other thing I would say is that it makes sense that the freedom fighters of Saint-Domingue,
55:00 Speaker 03 you know, would want to see and make laws about slavery being permanently abolished and the slave trade as well. But one of the other things they do that doesn't get recognition is that they declare in eighteen oh seven, slavery and the slave trade a crime against humanity. And again, this is not how we are taught, that story of how those words come into our lexicon. I've seen attributions to the Nuremberg Charter, seen attributions to the International Criminal Court of Justice, to the Loi de la Bureaucratie, right? Anything not to recognize the deep struggle of the Haitian people and the better world that they left us by insisting that the abolition of slavery, that freedom and equality were human rights and that slavery itself was a crime against humanity.
55:44 Speaker 00 Marlene, I know the answer to this is going to be racism, of course, but why do you think the Haitian Revolution has fallen out of our history textbooks? I know in recent years, there is more interest in it broadly speaking outside of academia, and there is a lot of work being done on it now. And I think, isn't there even a dramatization that's coming soon, hopefully? So it is growing in terms of its popular appeal, people's understanding of this moment. But why is it that it doesn't sit alongside the narrative of will be forced of the French abolishing slavery in the seventeen nineties? What is it about? Because this is, I mean, from the way that you speak about this is such a...
56:26 Speaker 00 An exciting history that has so many different elements to it that changes on the ground very, very quickly. It has this spiritual and religious dimension as well, which I was completely unaware of and I find completely fascinating. And as Anthony says, it's something that really reflects the visceral horror of what's happening on the ground and people's need, their absolute desperation to rationalize it, to build a defense against it. So we have all these elements. It's a moving, exciting story with fascinating individuals that come out of it. Why don't we know more about it?
57:02 Speaker 03 Honestly, I wish I had a more sophisticated answer than racism and white supremacy, right? Because if it is in fact the freedom fighters of Saint-Domingue, then who give us true equality, who give us the true meaning of liberty that we all hold dear today, that we say we hold dear today, right? Then what does that mean in like just the US context alone? What does that mean about Thomas Jefferson? What does that mean about the Declaration of Independence, the US Declaration of Independence? What does that mean about the US Constitution? Because what that means is that the excuses that have been made ever since I was a little girl in elementary school, that they were men of their time, Jefferson and, you know,
57:45 Speaker 03 Adams and all of the crowd of people who are going to be signing the Declaration of Independence, that they're men of their time and they just did as other men did, but they didn't do as other men did, right? Because already we see just in Saint-Domingue, the freedom fighters striking out for freedom in the same era. It's striking when you look at the dates, right? Right as the United States is trying to finally ratify its constitution, it's taking a very, very long time, right? That they are from the same era. And yet, when Haitians achieve their independence, they don't follow in the steed of the American Revolution, they don't follow in the steed of the French Revolution, because they don't use euphemisms in their
58:27 Speaker 03 constitution. The word slavery does not appear in the US Constitution. And in fact, in the documents reinstating slavery in France, they do- Everything they can to avoid using that exact word. They say, we want to put back into place the laws that existed before seventeen eighty nine, which is to say before the French Revolution, right? And this has allowed certain levels of denial, even at the textbook level. Did they really reinstate slavery? Right, this is the question that French would ask. But obviously they did, because then in eighteen forty eight, they re abolished it after the French Revolution of eighteen forty eight. Right, and so, you know, as one journalist said, you know, you're taught in French school that France is the only nation to abolish slavery twice.
59:12 Speaker 03 And again, I could say, or you could, or you could phrase it a different way, right? They're only nation to reinstate slavery after previously abolishing it. And I think that the narrative is scary to those who think that national unity cannot bear contradictions, which of course we know that it can actually. That's what brings nations together is recognizing the messiness of the history and coming together for reconciliation so that we don't forget. Because one of the Haitian national mottos is never forget, right? Because forgetting leads to repetition. And I think that the case of contemporary Haiti also weakens the
59:57 Speaker 03 ability of other nations to want to have a respect for Haiti's revolution, despite all that it's given the world, because they'll say, look at Haiti now, as if two hundred years of punishment, you know, didn't follow the Haitian Revolution.
1:00:11 Speaker 01 It's an unsettling thought when you think about eighteen forty eight, you're talking about the re abolition of of French slavery. That is not that long ago. It is so easy for us to, you know, when seventeen appears in front of a date, you're kind of going, gosh, that seems long ago. But eighteen forty eight, you know, Dickens is writing, people that we know very well is alive at this time. And it's, it becomes unsettling when you think about this. And you talked about reversals, Marlene, and it becomes unsettling when you hear rhetoric from some of the most powerful people in the world talking about make Ever great again in terms of where exactly do you want to pinpoint that greatness to? How far are we going back? Because you're talking about you're talking about going back.
1:00:55 Speaker 01 That's what that's what you're suggesting in that. And it's it's an interesting and by interesting, I mean absolutely horrifying prospect. If you were to drill down into into the the semantics of that. However, I think that the hopeful thing that you're saying, Marlene, is that or that I'm taking from this at least is in what we have overlooked, there is such rich material to take us forward. And and that is something that we need to celebrate and to highlight. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why we have wanted to do this episode for the last two years. And and what an amazing, amazing leader we had in Marlene through this history. Thank you so much for for guiding us.
1:01:34 Speaker 00 Thank you so much. I honestly think that was my favorite episode that we've ever done. I I could do 10 more episodes with you on this. I I would love to do a mini series.
1:01:45 Speaker 01 If you've enjoyed this episode, please leave your comments in wherever you listen to your podcasts. You'll be able to take part in a conversation there about the wider impact of the Haitian Revolution and share maybe resources that you found yourselves on the Haitian Revolution. Because there is now some incredible history books and different things on TV and all the rest of it out there. And thank you so much for listening. Leave us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts. It helps other people to discover us too. And until next time, happy listening.
1:02:22 Speaker 02 Blood donation is now more inclusive. More LGBTQ plus individuals are able to donate blood with the American Red Cross due to FDA guidelines that eliminate eligibility questions based on sexual orientation. The Red Cross celebrates this historic change and welcomes those who may be newly eligible to donate blood. There's a place for everyone in the mission of the Red Cross, including you. The Red Cross is committed to achieving a blood donation process that treats all potential donors with equality and respect while maintaining the safety of the blood supply. Join us and help save lives. To learn more and Make your appointment to donate blood. Visit redcrossblood.org/lgbtq. That's redcrossblood.org/lgbtq.
Previous The French Revolution's Reign of Terror Next Who Was the Man In The Iron Mask? Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated