Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Henry VIII's Murderous Reign About this episode Henry VIII was a monarch everyone was excited for, and turned into someone who weaponised his powers for murder.
What happened in his life that caused the death toll to suddenly rise?
In this episode, Anthony and Maddy are joined by historian and author, Gareth Russell https://www.garethrussell.co.uk/, to unpack the warning signs that led to beheadings, burnings and savagery in the Tudor court.
Find out more about Gareth's work: https://www.garethrussell.co.uk/
This podcast was edited by Tim Arstall and produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer was Freddy Chick.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 10,449 words · 4 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers, now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries, and I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Antony and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:52 Speaker 01 He spent his reign carving his will into the bodies of his realm. Be it the Reformation martyrs who burned, the scholars who were slaughtered, or the queens he beheaded. Even Thomas Cromwell was fed to the killing machine that he created for Henry. So was Henry VIII a serial killer, or just a product of a brutal time?
1:19 Speaker 01 Tyburn, central London, 1536. A May wind rolls through the crowd as the Carthusian monk kneels, hands bound, lips moving in a prayer no longer recognised in this land. The rope is coarse, the silence absolute, until the herald shouts the king's will. Henry has torn England from Rome, the pope and some whisper from God himself. The monks who once floated above politics in a hush of incense now dangle over the abyss. The cart jerks, the body falls, the blades wait. Conscience is treason, and treason has choreography. Hang, cut, quarter, display.
2:03 Speaker 01 Around Tyburn Tree, mothers clutch children, councillors take note, and every soul rehearses obedience. If the holiest men can suffer this fate, who is safe? Wives, ministers, martyrs? The scaffold is busy. This is Henry VIII's England, where killing passed as governance, and not even silence could grant you survival.
2:57 Speaker 00 Hello, I'm Maddie. And I'm Anthony. Now, Tudor history is something, I think it's fair to say we've covered a lot on After Dark. We've done a lot of this. Yeah, we did a recent episode with Philippa Gregory on Jane Berlin, which was very good. You may have heard of her, Gareth. I haven't even introduced the guest yet, and I'm already talking to him. Already breaking the fourth wall. Yes. So, today, we're going to be talking about the poster boy for how messed up the Tudors could be. I think it's fair to say it's Henry VIII himself. Oh, I thought you meant Gareth. I'm doing it again, I'm sorry, go. Do you know what? We're joined by Gareth. Yeah, sorry. We're very excited. Gareth, welcome to After Dark.
3:30 Speaker 02 Thank you. What a well-maintained mystery, Anthony. I really appreciate it.
3:32 Speaker 00 He's showing my professionalism here.
3:35 Speaker 02 What a grand reveal.
3:38 Speaker 00 It's after lunch, guys. It is. We've had our sandwiches. It's chaos already. Like, hey, Gareth's here, everyone.
3:45 Speaker 00 Okay, Gareth, tell me this. You spend a lot of time in the Tudor world.
3:48 Speaker 02 Yep.
3:49 Speaker 00 What is it that people love about the Tudors? Why do we keep coming back and back to them?
3:53 Speaker 02 I think part of it is it's a self-feeding machine, to be honest, because I think once you become familiar with the names, you then can start to have a much more in-depth reaction to it. So, people, the Six Wives are the most famous in this group, but they sort of become avatars for what you see in your life. Know enough about them that you can start to construct a morality play. So for instance, people will often pick a team between Catherine of Aragon and Anne Boleyn or Anne Boleyn and Jane Seymour. And when you ask them who their Catherine is, who their Anne is, you might be hearing about two very, very different people. So I think the familiarity sustains the industry in itself. It's sort of that self generating thing.
4:36 Speaker 02 The other thing is that it is a little bit like the Titanic disaster. It becomes a grand and dramatic example of all of life's big themes with the dull bits cut out. So there's no such thing as a marriage going a little bit south in the Tudor court.
4:53 Speaker 00 Don't do it by halves.
4:54 Speaker 02 No, no, there's no kind of like, you know, I wish you well.
4:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, this is an amicable breakup goodbye.
4:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, when they go low, we go lower. That's, that's, that's the thing.
5:02 Speaker 00 Right to the chopping block.
5:04 Speaker 02 There's something in that, you know, sometimes I feed into this when they go low, we go lower thing. I'm like, go on, let me see what that looks like. Yeah, I mean, sometimes.
5:12 Speaker 00 That's Anthony's playbook.
5:14 Speaker 02 Well, it's. Sorry, Michelle. Anne Boleyn did it. You're like, you're the Duke of Suffolk made one bad comment about her and she was like, totally hear what you're saying, hon. I'm just intrigued. Yeah. About you marrying your son's fiance right after your wife's death. Sorry, did I say too much?
5:26 Speaker 00 Whoops.
5:28 Speaker 02 So I'm just going to thrive over here. Yeah.
5:29 Speaker 00 They're all messy bitches, is what you're saying.
5:31 Speaker 02 So I mean, if you could do a reality TV show, their confessionals straight to camera would have been absolute gold.
5:36 Speaker 00 Why has nobody done that?
5:38 Speaker 02 I want to do the Real Housewives of Hampton Court.
5:40 Speaker 00 Oh my God, somebody commissioned that immediately.
5:42 Speaker 02 Yeah. And I wanted, you know, if you ever watch those shows like Real Housewives of Reality TV, it's usually like, let's play a game that bonds us as sisters. Pick up the crossbow and fire at whichever one around this table has the ugliest child. That's always something like.
5:56 Speaker 00 He's thought a lot about this.
5:58 Speaker 02 I want it to be Anne Boleyn being like, I would love us to play a bonding game, ladies. Let's drink whoever's child achieved the most. Catherine, Jane, nothing? Cool. Just a drink for me.
6:09 Speaker 00 None for you.
6:09 Speaker 02 So I think, I mean, even the fact that you can joke about it, the fact that there's humour there means these are familiar enough tropes and people that you can, you can buy into it.
6:16 Speaker 00 These are characters we've all spent time.
6:18 Speaker 02 Correct. And I think it is something that even that joke there about reality TV, there's a modernity to it. But the other thing is that it matters. It is, I think, the moment, at least now, where we feel the modern age to begin. It moves into something recognizably modern, but still strange enough that it's an intellectual vacation to go there. So it has a lot of the ingredients.
6:43 Speaker 01 Oh, intellectual vacation.
6:44 Speaker 02 Just came to me and I'm enjoying it.
6:45 Speaker 01 Just make that, that's pretty good. There's something very entitle in that, I think, because yes, it's asking questions. It's, you know, it's asking us to explore some of those things, but there's also escapism in the Tudors.
6:56 Speaker 02 Yeah.
6:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:57 Speaker 01 We overlook that too easily, I think.
6:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, I suppose as well, the historic tropes that we have is this idea that the medieval world is just bloody and it's people being bludgeoned to death and hacked to death and all of this. And then the Tudor court, yes, it has its brutality, but it has those machinations, that plotting. It has this cerebral element to it, which of course exists in the medieval world too, and any medieval historian will tell you that. But our perception is that that begins in the Tudor period.
7:22 Speaker 02 I completely agree. And actually, now that I'm thinking about it, I think absolute monarchy, or in this case quasi absolute, is cleaner for us to invest in. So once you start to get into the 17th century, you start to get much more complex ideologies rather than factions. And by the time, you'll know this, once you get into the 18th century, it is really complex.
7:43 Speaker 00 And that's not the same monarchical shorthand, right? In terms of if you're explaining to any kind of public audience, that's not the same. Oh, George the Third, people might know, oh, this is the man, King of Lost America, but there's not the same. If somebody, if you say Amblin or Henry VIII, people are like, yep, I know exactly what that rule looked like, who his.
8:00 Speaker 02 What is a wig? What is a Tory?
8:01 Speaker 01 What's wearing?
8:02 Speaker 02 Correct. And I think even if you talk about periods in the 18th century that are really famous, like the French Revolution, and you're having to say, actually, a royalist and a monarch are starting quite the same thing. And then there's a Jacob and a Girard. Like, it's all very complex. And it's much more interne signing. And I think with the Tudors. It is morally complex but politically simple. And that's what I think allows that investment.
8:23 Speaker 01 You should consider talking about the Tudors more.
8:25 Speaker 00 They're quite good at this.
8:27 Speaker 01 One of the things that I am intrigued by, we're kind of touching on it, so let's go straight to it. Is this idea of the world into which a man like Henry VIII can become king. What is that world Gareth? What does it look like? Why is this all set up to favour him on the throne?
8:44 Speaker 02 I think there is a sense of fatigued relief that the Wars of the Roses, or whatever term they were using then, is over. And there is that kind of cross-community feeling with Henry and his siblings, that they are the children of both the last sprig on the Lancasterian family tree in Henry VII, and also the brightest bloom of the York family tree. And people ultimately do want peace. They want this to work. And, you know, in many ways, that kerfuffle between Edward V and Richard III has swept the board. There isn't a lot of choice left for the York, because there's not really that sense of let's keep this going for honour's sake. So in that sense, he is a child of peace and people are happy about that.
9:30 Speaker 00 Oh, the irony.
9:31 Speaker 02 Oh, the irony. But that actually cuts to it, I think, because one of the big defences of Henry that I think is an inappropriate, or at least in my view, an unsustainable defence, is that at least the country didn't slide into civil war. Which is true.
9:45 Speaker 00 It's a low bar.
9:46 Speaker 02 It's, it's really low. It's like, you know, after, like, imagine White Star Line after the Titanic advertising every voyage being like, it didn't say.
9:55 Speaker 01 Chances are this one will be okay. Law of averages.
9:58 Speaker 00 Statistically, you're fine.
9:59 Speaker 02 The bar is that low. And also, if you go to the people of the North in the 1530s, or Caoiseach Gonnall in the south of Ireland, also in the 1530s, and ask them to tell the difference between a civil war and what he's done to them, I mean, it, it's not really going to be that different. In fact, they probably suffered more than they would have under the civil war, because the civil war tended to target the upper classes in terms of its body count. I think that cuts to why there is such relief when he comes to the throne in 1509, because it's the first since. Fourteen twenty two that has been completely uncontested. That's a long time. Almost certainly, there is no one alive who can remember Henry the fifth becoming Henry the sixth smoothly. So it is the last time the English monarchy has worked as it is intended to work.
10:43 Speaker 02 So Henry the eighth almost seems to be bringing back those halcyon days of Henry the fifth and Edward the third and the glory days of the monarchy passing. As it should. As it should, whether that was accurate or not is by the by. That's how it is perceived. And then from Henry the sixth onward, it's been sort of past the parcel almost when it happens. And so Henry the eighth comes to the throne on a wave of adulation and relief and also money. So Henry the seventh is a very astute businessman and probably overly astute. But he also, he is clever in using a lot of the financial advisers of Richard the third and Edward the fourth to create fiscal and financial continuity.
11:26 Speaker 02 So the monarchy is solvent, which is pretty much every Tudor monarch and all of the Sturts will discover is no small task to achieve. So he's rich, he's young, he's good looking, he's of uncontested legitimacy. So he arrives ostensibly as Prince Charming. But what I think, I mean, everyone has their view on this. I think that creates another chimera. I think that's another mistake because I think we sort of treat Henry the eighth a bit like the French Revolution. The years of like the years of dark, everything's going really well and then it isn't. And it's the fall from the horse in fifteen thirty six. I do not believe that is correct.
12:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, we have these kind of slightly mythological beats in his story.
12:09 Speaker 02 Yes.
12:09 Speaker 00 Yeah. Taking this idea that he's this kind of charismatic Prince Charming at the beginning. And whether or not he has other traits within him at that moment that already exist. How do we go? This is no small question. From this hopeful new monarch that everyone is excited for, that is bringing this idea of the sort of golden days that have passed and all this, and bringing all these potentials to the throne. How do we go from that? Does someone who is weaponising the tools of the state for his own purposes, that's a pretty remarkable transformation. And if we don't have those traditional beats like the fall from the horse, in your view, what does that look like, that narrative arc, I suppose?
12:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a great way to put it. It's an arc.
12:55 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:56 Speaker 02 I don't think there is a Rubicon or a Berlin Wall, or however you want to phrase it. I don't think there's a point where the light becomes dark and the sun sets. I think we're watching, I don't think the sun's ever that bright, to be honest, under him. I think you only have to look at some of the warning signs really early on. So, the first in 1510, within a year of becoming king, is the execution of two of his father's most unpopular advisers, Ebsen and Dudley. And they were not fuzzy and cuddly men, and they had been knee-deep in Henry VII's increasingly unjust taxation policies. But they had been following orders from Henry VII. And Henry the Eighth throws them to the wolves to bolster his popularity. I mean, what they had done were his father's orders. And he sort of
13:40 Speaker 02 absolves the dynasty by sacrificing these two men. So the propensity towards legally questionable savagery is there from the get-go. The other thing that I think is a wound he carries is that he is played like a fiddle in the first five years by his father-in-law, King Ferdinand, and by the Habsburg Emperor Maximilian, who are more intelligent asleep than he is awake. And they kind of trick him into very expensive wars in the continent. He gets involved, he thinks it's going to be the second coming of Henry V. And what they do is they make him bring the English army in, use it as a distraction, get what they want out of France, and then leave him to face the cost and ruin alone. And it's
14:21 Speaker 02 really not until this brilliant Oxford graduate, Father Thomas Wolsey, rises through the ranks in one of those wars and becomes his chief minister, that we see a Wall being built around Henry and one where he becomes a lot more careful about who he trusts. But also, I think he doesn't take the right lessons from having been played by his father in law and Emperor Maximilian. I I think he always wants to prove that he actually was cleverer than them. And you see, the the the wrong lesson is taken from it. We should be starting to see us stripping away those mythological beats that you mentioned, one of which is his first marriage. And this idea that it was a blissful romance and he was so in love with Catherine of Aragon.
15:02 Speaker 02 And people will tell this story of him dressing as Sir Loyal Heart and, you know, jousting in her honor. He was one of a cast of seven. They all had names like that and they all picked ladies to joust for this. There's not actually a huge amount of evidence that he's ever besotted with Catherine of Aragon. It's that she's the perfect queen for this period. She's very elegant. She's internationally connected. She manages to weather pretty competently the storm that comes when her father humiliates her husband. But to be honest, I think he's from the get go prickly about his reputation, reactive, impulsive. And also, I don't think he is anywhere near as bright as I think he's I think he's an averagely intelligent person.
15:45 Speaker 01 I totally agree. So we're going to come to the wives and we're going to come to some of the ways in which Henry's leanings or limits, actually, based on what you're saying, influence, attack, shape the histories of these women. But before we get there, let's talk about the Reformation specifically.
16:03 Speaker 02 Yes.
16:04 Speaker 01 Give us some background about what the what is the Reformation on the ground in England at this time? How is that taking place? And then who are some of the casualties beyond the wives? We'll come to them separately, but wider societally, religious institutions, et cetera. Who are the casualties under Henry at this time of of that Reformation?
16:21 Speaker 02 Well, to Molly's earlier point, I actually think if I'm looking for the moment, the fall from the horse for me is actually the Reformation.
16:27 Speaker 00 That's interesting.
16:28 Speaker 02 I think all of those ingredients that we've talked about are there. And I think at his core, he cannot handle disobedience or embarrassment. And after fifteen thirty one, fifteen thirty two, really, he embarks upon a policy that is guaranteed to generate a substantial, indeed unprecedented, amount of disobedience and pushback.
16:47 Speaker 00 Hmm.
16:48 Speaker 02 And that's when you start to see the body count really beginning to rise. And it's before the the fall. I mean, it's really the Carthusian monks who start to pay the the most brutal price early on. One of the most exciting books, I think, that has come out recently is James Clark's History of the Dissolution. And so it's a tome, it's a chunky book. But one of the things that he exposes in this is almost more blood chilling than the official narrative, which is that there was never a plan to shut all the monasteries down in one go. It was an engine that no one was driving and it just gathered.
17:20 Speaker 00 That's more worrying.
17:21 Speaker 02 Absolutely terrifying. And that, yes, there were people around him like Thomas Cromwell, who rises to sort of replace the defunct Woolsey, but who were keen on the dissolution of the monasteries, to put it mildly. You have a second wife, Anne Boleyn, who turns very strongly against them. But that almost corroborates further the theory that it just becomes, again, a self fulfilling machine. So the the Reformation initially starts with being presented not as a revolution, but as a restoration. The suggestion that the Vatican had usurped the authority that the so called donation of Constantine, the first Christian emperor that had given the Vatican supremacy over the other parts of the church and over kings was a forgery, which in fairness it probably was.
18:02 Speaker 02 And that, in fact, if you went back to the to the early days of Christianity, the alliance between throne and altar, church and monarchy, monarchs had played a huge role in it. Constantine had gone to the Council of Nicaea, Justinian had been involved in Chalcedonian Christianity. So the the argument put forward is actually incredibly conservative, or at least reactionary, which is that.
18:22 Speaker 00 And very, very clever.
18:23 Speaker 02 Very, very clever, which is actually, we're not Protestants, we are restoring. And that's a theme that runs through Christianity, restoring the gospel of Jesus Christ. And that is something that they present themselves as doing. But once the legislation goes through and the Pope is sort of demoted to simply being a bishop, the bishop of Rome, and the king is in nominal control of the Church within England, Wales and Ireland. Then it becomes open to what is the Church of England. And initially, it does seem to be that the plan is for it to be Catholic. And the first victims are, to use sort of modern parlance, on the right of the Catholic Church in England.
19:03 Speaker 02 It's the Carthusian monks who cannot in good conscience accept that Henry has the right to usurp the headship of the Church. And the other two victims of that are the former Lord Chancellor, Thomas More, and Cardinal John Fisher, who had been very close to Henry's grandmother and to his wife. And interestingly, if you look at Thomas More's personal, private writing, he has no problem accepting the king's marriage to Anne Boleyn. He excuses himself from the coronation, probably on the grounds of the Archbishop's schism with the Vatican. But he does refer to her as being really anointed queen, and he prays for the safe birth of her children. So it's less about the demotion of Catherine of Aragon and more for the truly devout, that they cannot accept the break with Rome.
19:47 Speaker 02 Initially, though, there is not, if you look at 1533, 1534, there is no uprising in the Pope's favour. The behaviour of the faithful is, oh, well, we'll get on with it. And actually relinquishing the Vatican is not a totally unpopular move. It's when it starts again to mutate and change. And this is what you will see going through revolutions and progressive causes throughout history. There are points at which people will go, actually, this is as far as I ever wanted to go. It's going too far. And you start to see that with the attack on the monasteries. And there are certain elements that are much more popular with the people. So that the two that really seem to be points of no return are Veneration of the Virgin Mary and Prayers for the Dead.
20:30 Speaker 02 And but just below that, Transubstantiation and the monasteries. And if you go to places like Fountains, you'll see just what an enormous social and cultural Unit they were. It's one of those things that is so omnipresent, the monasteries, that you don't notice how much they're there until they're not. Yes. So when that starts to change, then you begin to see massive fracture lines and the the executions that he's ordered in fifteen thirty four and fifteen thirty five. Are I can understand why Catholics regard them as martyrdoms. They are points of religious principle. More in Fisher are beheaded. The the Carthusian monks are publicly torn limb from limb by being hanged, drawn and quartered.
21:07 Speaker 02 So those are notorious and tragic, but they are contained. It's really after fifteen thirty six when you start to see a geographical bent coming to this. And the north in particular of England saying this is too far for us and we're not going to support the ripping apart of the monasteries. That you begin to see massive, massive pushback against his policies with the pilgrimage of grace uprising. And that's where you be the the numbers begin to to really rapidly rise. And I do think you see by his own standards, what Henry does is morally appalling. Because he lies through his teeth. You know, he he summons the leaders to court and says, I really want to hear everything that you're. But let's talk about this. His third wife, Jane Seymour, is wheeled out as sort of the charming first lady to trick them.
21:50 Speaker 02 Whether she knew or not, we'll never know. But certainly the charm offensive was put on at Christmas fifteen thirty six. The rebels dispersed, thinking they're being heard. And then Henry sends a flimsy pretext, his men north to brutalize it. And it's that and the Kildare Rebellion that you see in South. Eastern Ireland at the same time that you see Henry send out genuinely unprecedented orders, which is kill the women and children as well. You read the letters he sends to the Duke of Norfolk and Suffolk and the letters he exchanges with Lord Gray, I think, Lord Gray, and he becomes the Lord Deputy in Ireland. And they're bone chilling. I mean, there it is unprecedented, the lengths he goes to when those far those big rebellions, one in Ireland and one in the north. That rise up against him. And of course, there are there are multiple motivations in them.
22:34 Speaker 02 But ultimately, at their core, they are religious in motivation.
22:38 Speaker 00 What is the reaction to the those at court around Henry, his advisors, the people who he's giving orders to, who are then going carrying out these atrocities? Well, how do they view him as a monarch in this moment? Are they reading those letters thinking, excuse me, what? Or are they just thinking that's the king? We're going to do what he says. This is all fine. This is, we have religion and morals on our side. This is, this is okay. What's the situation there?
23:04 Speaker 02 That's a great question. I suppose the answer is unknowable, but it does tap into something broader about how does he hold on to the throne? So the scale of Lord Kildare's rebellion in Ireland and the pilgrimage of grace in the north of England are massive, particularly in the case of the pilgrimage of grace. It's the largest rebellion against the Tudors by quite a distance. And ordinarily, it should have been enough to push the monarch's office through.
23:43 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way. Same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
24:23 Speaker 03 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets, The History of Sex, Scandal and Society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts.
25:07 Speaker 03 Brought to you by the award-winning network, History Hit.
25:22 Speaker 00 Can I just say, this is so interesting to me that we don't discuss this when we talk about the Tudors. We're so focused on the romances and the court and all of that, that this doesn't register.
25:32 Speaker 01 It's really hitting home with me as well, as not as a Tudor specialist, but going, actually, this is why I should be interested in this more than I'm led to believe, yeah.
25:42 Speaker 02 Well, that's interesting that this is sort of anecdotal, but I remember about 20 years ago, was it? There was a two-part mini-series that came out with Ray Winstone as Henry the Eighth.
25:50 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
25:50 Speaker 02 And it had Helen Bonham Carter as Amblin and Emily Blunt as Catherine Hard. It's very good. They're excellent.
25:55 Speaker 00 Great casting.
25:55 Speaker 02 I know. That was her first big role, Emily Blunt, but they had Sean Bean as Robert Ask. And I think it was episode two, yeah, Amblin was episode one. So episode two, it was the first one recently that showed the Pilgrimage of Grace. And one of the reviews said, I've read many Tudor books and they've just made up a rebellion. That's how little it got reported on.
26:18 Speaker 00 Wow.
26:19 Speaker 02 And so the Pilgrimage of Grace and the Kildare Rebellion in Ireland, they are huge. They're really, really big. And I would say the Kildare Rebellion deserves, I mean, its own book because it's the first of Ireland's sectarian tensions. It's the first time you see that taking precedent with the Pilgrimage of Grace in the North. The reason why he is not nudged off his throne, or at least clipped in the way, say, Henry III or Henry VI had been by rebellions, is the aristocracy don't break rank. Or if they do, it's individually. So it's Kildare kind of acting on his own. The Earl of Warman doesn't get involved. It's some of the minor lords in the North. It's not the Duke of Northern Ireland.
26:57 Speaker 00 And it usually doesn't end well for them.
26:58 Speaker 02 Correct. So had the aristocracy broken rank, this could be a very, very different story. So then you go into hypotheticals or maybe just sort of whimsical wonderings, what is it? And we're back to, I think, this is so speculative on my part, but I'm sure listeners and viewers will allow me it.
27:15 Speaker 00 We're always doing this on this podcast, it's fine.
27:17 Speaker 02 I think the most unquantifiable thing in history is charisma. And you cannot explain it. I mean, remember Jack Scarsberg, who wrote a brilliant academic biography of Henry the Eighth? He said, you'll never really understand Anne Boleyn, except to understand that she obviously had charisma seeping out of her fingertips.
27:33 Speaker 00 She had ritz.
27:33 Speaker 02 But yeah, that's it. She had, you have, some people have it. Henry the Eighth, I do think must have had it, or whether it's Stockholm syndrome, whatever it is, there is something in these people at court that they don't break rank. And they are aware that he's not, th- this myth that generates itself, that he was incredibly popular. I mean, when I wrote a book on his fifth wife, I had a, I loved doing this, the politics, the start of the fifteen forties and the late fifteen thirties. Because of what you said, which is that we don't hear about it. It's really messy and it's fascinating. But a lot of the reports that the Privy Council were receiving were saying some things like, if the king knew men's thoughts about him, his heart would quake.
28:14 Speaker 02 So the informants coming into court are saying there are jokes about the royal family. So the Prince of Wales, the future Edward the Sixth. They're saying, oh, he'll grow up to be just like his father because he murdered his mother by being born. So like the first murder, that, there are all these quite dark jokes. And English politicians or privy councillors, I should say, who are abroad, when Henry the Eighth dies, are, one's in a pub in Italy. And you don't expect in deepest Catholic Italy, Anne Boleyn to have become a folk heroine, but they're coming up to him and saying he slaughtered poor Queen Anne. He, he's become notorious throughout Europe. So the world beyond the palace walls, I think, sees him in one way. And the world within sees him in a very different way. And it's this sort of bone chilling obsequiousness that they all have.
28:58 Speaker 02 And again, there's, you see this even in, you know, some regimes throughout history where it's sort of, I mean, I'm being really pseudo flippant here, but it's a bit like an abusive relationship where he gives them enough. I mean, they're falling over themselves to, to, to, to win his approval and he can turn like that. There's almost something pathetic about the way they live for his smiles and his charm, and then they live in terror.
29:25 Speaker 00 I think an abuser is a really, is a really good way of putting it. And I think something you said earlier, Gareth, about he's kind of middling intelligence.
29:32 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:32 Speaker 00 Actually, and I, I think that's fascinating because I'm always interested in the people that we come into contact in the past, you know, as historians, we spend so much time with in the archives, whether it's a monarch or a lowly farmer or whoever it is, and actually being able to access. Who they were and what they would have been like to be in the room with. And I think Henry's one of those people where, because he's so contradictory and because we have such contradictory views of him as this monster, but also this charismatic, handsome young man who wooed all of these women and everyone was falling over themselves to, to get his approval. That really interests me, this idea that he is charismatic, but not very clever.
30:11 Speaker 02 Yeah.
30:12 Speaker 00 And that that actually is a sort of a winning combination for a lot of dictators in history, actually, a lot of men who are abusers, actually, that that's, that's the combo.
30:23 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, I mean, he, that regime, the, the, the kind of government that he creates, you, you talked earlier about the weaponization of the apparatus of the state. It is important that we, you know, I think that there can be a bit of presentist navel gazing where we try to make everything applicable. And, you know, he, he is and he isn't a tyrant. And the reason why I would say he isn't is that he really doesn't actually go over the boundaries of parliament, which is one of the big litmus tests of it. Parliament, for their own reasons, I think, tend to be more obedient than they probably should have been. And when you have kings who don't have charisma, like James the first.
31:00 Speaker 01 Yes, literally, he was going to mine.
31:02 Speaker 00 Poor James.
31:03 Speaker 02 Poor James, he was like, and he makes this, I mean, I did a book on him recently and I remember.
31:08 Speaker 00 Excellent book.
31:09 Speaker 02 Thank you very, thank you very much.
31:10 Speaker 00 Do, do go and buy this. Yeah, yeah, great cover, great title, fantastic.
31:15 Speaker 02 Thank you very much. But I swear at one point was like, I kind of am getting on the divine right of kings side here because essentially his complaint was, I am the first king in God knows how long he's had a family, so I have to pay for them. I'm spending just about as much as Elizabeth the first did in herself. You not once asked these kind of difficult questions to Elizabeth and certainly not to Henry the eighth. And they were more difficult with Elizabeth because she was a woman and they could press on the marriage point. You didn't really have to press that with Henry the eighth, but with Henry, they don't ask difficult questions about, well, how have you blown through all the money from your father and then all the money from the dissolution of the monasteries and you still, you're still coming just for more. So there must have been a charisma there.
31:56 Speaker 02 But he also, to the middling intelligence point, he's not stupid, but he's not, he's certainly not as intelligent as his son or his youngest daughter. And I don't think he was as, as intelligent as his elder daughter either. I think the children were all more intelligent than he was. If you read Sertio Septum Sacramentorum, his defense of the seven sacraments. It's fine, it's, but it's sort of just regurgitating everyone else's views. It's not.
32:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's quite transcriptive. Yeah.
32:21 Speaker 02 It is. It's, it's a really, it's like, don't make it look like you copied my homework.
32:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
32:27 Speaker 00 Changed a few words.
32:28 Speaker 02 Yeah. And, and you know, and the Pope is grateful because it's useful, not because it's brilliant. I think with Henry, he's also for a long time masked by the people around him. So he, his first two wives were both charismatic and both very intelligent. And he clearly resents that. And they are, you know, he, he doesn't, you know, his sixth wife is extremely intelligent. But the next four are not on the same level when it comes to outshining him, which I think Catherine and Anne had done on more than one occasion.
33:04 Speaker 00 Do you think there's a deliberate choice by him?
33:06 Speaker 02 I do. Or as deliberate as the impulse to fall in love can be. There is a good piece of evidence and so that it's not too speculative, but there is a good piece of evidence from an argument he had with his third wife, Jane Seymour, when he said that his second wife had lost her head because she disputed too much over the affairs of the realm. So in that moment, he not only accidentally admitted that he knew Anne Boleyn was innocent, but that essentially she had been too clever and that he had taken matters into his own hands and she talked back. So I do think there, there's a good.
33:37 Speaker 00 And what a chilling thing for Jane to read and be like, oh, I'll be quiet then.
33:40 Speaker 02 Absolutely. Do you know what? I mean, keep quiet and hope for better days.
33:43 Speaker 01 You've spoken about a lot that has got me thinking about the Tudors in a way I haven't necessarily thought about them since probably my undergrad days, because actually you forget the nuances once, especially once you enter into public history realms and you're talking about the Tudors, it can become very.
33:56 Speaker 00 Because the same story is rehearsed all the time.
33:58 Speaker 01 But actually, you know, I remember talking about some of these things at undergrad and being, this is why I loved Tudor history at that time, actually, because the nuances and the complexities are, they're all there. But you're talking about, you know, this idea of.
34:12 Speaker 01 Bone chilling. And I love that as the way you phrased it because I think it's very easy to say tyrant or evil or whatever it is, but actually to internalize that a little bit more and to then think about it in terms of the other wives that are following the first two and know what the stakes are. But what is striking me even more is that Henry comes at a point which James, six and first, doesn't benefit from this. Henry's coming at a point where there is this transition. You talked about we're coming into almost a sense of modernity or something we recognize. But there's also something of the medieval king about him here too, right? You know, we're talking about fields of blood. We're talking about power through coercion. We're talking about physical violence. And these are threads that although are not as
34:57 Speaker 01 present in Henry's reign, he still seems to use as threats or as things to, I can take your head off because they did. And that's not weird because this is the legacy that we come from. Whereas I think by the time we get to James, he doesn't have access to that medieval threat anymore. So I'm just wondering, we moralize around Henry a lot, don't we? Where we go tyrant, all of these kinds of things. Do you think it's because there's anything in this idea of him sitting between these two periods and straddling them?
35:31 Speaker 00 Is he the last medieval king?
35:32 Speaker 01 Yeah. Is he the last medieval and the first modern? You know what I mean? Does that allow him a, grace is probably the wrong word, but but an elasticity that later kings are definitely not afforded?
35:42 Speaker 02 I hadn't thought of it that way. And I think you're right. So I think the history of the modern world is the push and pull to some extent. It is the story of the push and pull between government by the many and government by the one.
35:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:54 Speaker 02 And also the curse, the benefit, the debate over strong man government that runs through the modern period as much as ideology does. And so Henry, in many ways, is the avatar of the strong man. And a narrative was created around Bluff King Hal, which presented him as a great example of strong man government. And it fed into that myth, which is actually to make the omelette, you have to break a few eggs. There will have to be bodies in the wake in order for the greater good. And what is never asked Is or seldom asked, I should say, is, but were those eggs the ones he needed to break?
36:29 Speaker 01 Hmm.
36:30 Speaker 02 So once you move away from him being the last of the first or the avatar and just go into that period with him, all of a sudden, what it becomes is a fascinating, sticky, unnecessary mess. And all of the things that he did achieve, i.e. no civil war and preventing foreign invasion, or at least in the case of the Scottish invasion defeating foreign invasion in fifteen thirteen. All of those things that he achieved certainly could have been achieved with a much lower body count. So at that point, you step away from him as the strong man, or if you're still inclined to see him that way, it asks really interesting questions about the strong man
37:10 Speaker 02 in government, which is that is strength necessarily justified by savagery? Or in order for someone to win, must somebody else lose? That's the question that I actually think Henry in a strange way does answer, which is this is how you don't do it.
37:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a tricky old mire, isn't it? He's a complex man. And of course he is because it's one of the reasons again why he endures. If he was, if it was very black and white, he wouldn't endure.
37:34 Speaker 02 Correct.
37:34 Speaker 01 But because of this complexity, he's there.
37:36 Speaker 00 Something that you said earlier about him, especially early on, feeling threatened or undermined or unmanned in some way, whether that's by the intelligent women in his life, or whatever it is. I'm thinking about some of his other, the other casualties of his reign, I suppose, and particularly Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard, who are two wives that he obviously has killed, but also Cromwell as well, who's his, you know, very close advisor and sometime good friend. How should we read those? Are they people who ultimately humiliate him or threaten him in a way that makes him feel small and therefore it's reactionary to have them killed? Is it that he sees their behaviours as betrayals?
38:15 Speaker 00 And therefore, that's how he legitimizes it in his own mind. In terms of Henry's own psychology, if we can ever access such a thing, what do you think is going on with those, those, those three in particular, who are, you know, they stand out as particularly brutal and, and tragic moments in the story?
38:32 Speaker 02 So that's interesting. I think I would actually start with a fourth that I think is a good introduction to those because this person wasn't, these people weren't as close to him. But there's an element, there's a, there's a whiff of what Henry will do. And it goes back to what we're talking about with the Kildare Rebellion. So I'm dashing Silken Thomas Fitzgerald, so called, because he's the best dressed man in Ireland. We grow up with him, by the way. He's one of the ones we know of.
38:54 Speaker 00 Nice, nice.
38:55 Speaker 02 So Silken Thom, Silken Thomas leads the Kildare Rebellion. And I think if memory serves, each five uncles, I, I might have the numbers wrong one way or the other. I think two back the government and three back him, or three back the government and two back him. Anyway, Kildare is given the same deal the Pilgrimage of Gracelyars are, which is all is forgiven, come to London and explain yourself. And he brings the uncles.
39:19 Speaker 00 Right.
39:19 Speaker 02 And Henry then kind of ritually humiliates them because he has them all condemned to death for treason. But despite the fact that Silken Thomas is the Earl of Kildare and Assen Earl should be beheaded, he is tied on a hurdle along with the cousins and dragged through the streets like a common criminal.
39:36 Speaker 00 Oh, Henry's a petty bitch.
39:37 Speaker 02 Petty bitch and hanged alongside all of the uncles, the guilty and the innocent, the loyalists and the rebels. And it is partly to decimate the House of Fitzgerald, which has been one of the great houses in Ireland. But I think the inclusion, that the figures there are, yes, the humiliation of Silken Thomas, but the really interesting one are the uncles who backed Henry. And they are still knocked over as collateral damage. And I think you can see that with people like Henry.
40:04 Speaker 00 That tells you so much about who Henry is.
40:06 Speaker 02 That's why I always try and tell people, look at, look at Silken Thomas, not just because it is a great horrible overlooked example. And you can see this, it runs through everything. So when you go to the giant fall of a second wife in 1536, how can Henry throw his best, one of his best friends, Henry Norris, to the wolves with her? How can he throw Thomas Cromwell, who has been a friend, who has been a close advisor? And why is it that when it comes to Catherine Howard, he is easier on Thomas Culpepper, who looks like he wanted to sleep with her after the marriage, but is more brutal to Frances Durham, who had slept with her before the marriage? There is all of this culture of him humiliating and degrading and destroying before or after, so it isn't done to him.
40:51 Speaker 02 There's something there. And psychology and every, we're all a messy bitch, but.
40:56 Speaker 00 Talk for yourself.
40:59 Speaker 02 But I think, I always, I mean, I know the goldwater standard is an important thing. And in my books, I try not, because I can't, I'm also not trained in psychology. But part of the joy of doing things like this is that you can, you can, and you understand the viewer and listener's intelligence and allowing it to just be a thrown out theory. I know this word is tossed around far too much today, but there is something of a narcissistic rage attack there. I don't want it anymore. Yeah. So I am going to destroy it. And I think there's something.
41:26 Speaker 00 No one else has allowed it.
41:27 Speaker 02 Correct.
41:28 Speaker 00 It was my toy, it's going away.
41:29 Speaker 02 That's it. And I think when I, you know, Henry Norris, for instance, refuses to do what Henry wants him to do, which is admit that Anne had come on to him and that they had slept together and basically provide the evidence they need to condemn Anne. So he says, well, you'll die with her then. So there's, you know, that's again, the test of loyalty. And I think there's something, I don't know if this is the right phrase I have in my head, but something like an implicit truth, which I think a lot of narcissists have or manipulative people have, which is, I know Anne Boleyn deserves to die because she's disappointed me, but I know that you won't accept that reason. So I'll give you a reason why she deserves to die.
42:06 Speaker 01 And it doesn't really matter.
42:07 Speaker 02 Doesn't matter.
42:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
42:08 Speaker 02 Because the truth, the implicit truth will get there, which is that she'll be dead. That runs through his reign. And when I worked on the biography of Catherine Howard, one of the things that I came away with so forcefully as an impression was there is no truth in the suggestion that Henry was bounced into making that decision. Henry pushed for her death, even when the House of Lords were questioning in January 1542. We don't know what Queen Catherine has done. Justifies the death penalty. Henry says that he wants to torture her to death with his own sword. Henry is the one who authorises torture in Francis Derrin to be used after he's condemned to get more information out of him. There is a kind of gatling gun of
42:53 Speaker 02 depraved humiliating tactics being fired against everyone. And the other one that I would say where you see this that doesn't end up with a body count, but is equally revealing of the the mental inspiration behind it is his fourth wife, Anne of Cleves. So if anyone has ever read the detail Henry goes into to justify the annulment of the marriage.
43:15 Speaker 00 It's so humiliating.
43:16 Speaker 02 Her vagina's slack, she stinks, her breasts are droopy, her breasts, he really is, it's vile. And it is so unnecessary. And even by the standards of the day, by the way. Correct. It's vile and unnecessary in the standards of the day. People are embarrassed.
43:30 Speaker 00 Yeah. And it's like, Henry, look to yourself.
43:32 Speaker 02 Yeah. And also, he hasn't read out in front of the ecclesiastical tribunal consisted of 239 men who had to sit and listen to that, per Anne of Cleves. I mean, that is just humiliation on another level. And he does this. There is a humiliation kink, I think, that he has, that pushes a lot of his stuff forward. So when you're looking at those executions that you brought up, I think it is Henry smash. I think that's kind of that that's what he wants to do and he will do it.
44:14 Speaker 03 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors. And even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history, kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr Kate Lister. Listen to But Twix the Sheets, The History of Sex, Scandal and Society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts.
44:58 Speaker 03 Brought to you by the award-winning network, History Hit.
45:13 Speaker 01 We recently did an episode on the, what was it? I think it was like the most evil kings of medieval Europe or something like that. Henry doesn't quite qualify for that because of the time period. Nonetheless, we spent time talking about three different figures and it was, you know, it was pretty gruesome stuff. Listening to you now, I think Henry is even worse than than some people who had a much bigger body count, like Vlad the Impaler or something. But the kind of psychological approach, again, I know we're speculating around that somewhat such as the want of the podcast. Yeah, again, to come back to the, I think is so apt, this bone chilling thing. And it's so easily overlooked with Henry because again, you've said this before Gareth
45:55 Speaker 01 about this avatar-like appearance that a lot of these tutors take on where they almost become those, you know, those fashion dolls you can cut out of things and stick the clothes on. They start to become that, the wives especially, but him too. And it's a bit like the king who beheaded his wives. And actually, it's so much worse than that. That's bad enough.
46:13 Speaker 02 Yes.
46:13 Speaker 01 But it's so much worse than that when you kind of get down into it. We grow up and we are told and we're left with this impression of his daughter, his oldest daughter, Mary, as Bloody Mary, and we've spoken about this before. And we know that his body count is much higher than hers.
46:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
46:28 Speaker 01 But in terms of destruction, both of life and of institution and of moral and societal, you know, ways of being, how bad do you think, is bad the right word? How destructive do you think Henry is compared to the kings that went before and came after?
46:47 Speaker 02 Substantially. I think let's, let's acknowledge his incompetence as well, which doesn't ever, there's this idea that he was a brilliant king apart from the wife murdering, oops, which is just not the case. So I, you know, when people, they'll talk, they'll try to justify. You know, ambulances, Catherine should have learned from Anne, which is interesting. Let's have a look beyond the palace walls at what he did. I love the story of his wives. I'm not one of those people who tries to say, let's not look at it. I think it's one of the history's most brilliant stories, but it's not the whole story here. So let's have a look at the economy with rampant inflation and the coin is being debased time and time again.
47:31 Speaker 02 The monarchy is hemorrhaging money. He leaves massive debts to his children. He's wildly extravagant. You have the letters from Thomas Cromwell saying, sir, we don't need 55 palaces. The upheaval is insane. He pushes and pushes Scotland into becoming an enemy, which it hadn't been at the start of his reign. He leaves England diplomatically isolated because he doesn't find relationships to replace the ones with Catholic Europe that he's lost. There is no stability in foreign policy whatsoever. He messes up the Crown of Ireland Act. He forces through the surrender and regrant policy with the Gaelic nobility in Ireland that arguably is the first scattering of the seeds that you and I were harvesting when we were born in the 20th century. So you have all of that. You then have this myth that he founded the navy and it all went super well.
48:16 Speaker 02 It's underfunded. That's the reason the Mary Rose is sitting in a museum. Because like everything he did, rather than invest in proper, long-term solutions, the Mary Rose had too much stacked on top of it to make it look impressive and then it capsized.
48:32 Speaker 00 That's Henry all over though, right?
48:34 Speaker 02 It's the perfect metaphor. It's exactly it. And then poor Catherine Parr sitting next to him being like, this is going to be a rough couple of weeks. And also the sort of pseudoactive union with Wales is handled badly as well. I don't see a competent king. I see someone who in many ways was saved by the sophisticated bureaucracy, the structure in the counties and the gentry and the love of stability. I mean, let's be very clear. There is one, a couple of threads that run through the English national character. And one is an innate small c conservatism. And what I mean by that is, you know, even I would say people on the left in Britain are small c conservative. And what I mean by that is you have to really push them. Before they will willingly cause havoc or they will overturn stability.
49:20 Speaker 02 And that's why, you know, I sort of more critical of Charles the first than I was when I started my career. Cause I think you have to push the English to be mad, mad. The English in particular are an excellent passive aggressive nation. You could argue you're seeing that now. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And I think that he is saved by the fact that his people don't really want to rebel. They're pushed to, and there's a massive one in fifteen thirty six and fifteen thirty seven. But the south stays pretty loyal. And all of this around him, I think, endures despite his best efforts. He's not a disaster to himself in the way that say Richard the second is or Charles the first. But he is unnecessarily aggressive. He rips the monasteries out and doesn't replace them with anything either. I mean, there's a lot of Henry smash, not Henry build.
50:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, there's no plan. It's just a smash.
50:07 Speaker 02 That's in a nutshell, there is no plan. And so he's not really a strong man.
50:12 Speaker 00 And that's the scariest thing about him.
50:14 Speaker 02 That's the most, I mean, I remember working underground at the start of the first world war. And when I realised that both the Kaiser and the Tsar thought the war was a terrible idea. And I was like, oh my God, there was no one in charge of this. Like, we got there and at least three of the heads of state involved knew it was a bad idea. And to me, that is Henry the eighth in a nutshell, which is there was no plan. It was all impulsive and reactive and prickly and thin skinned. So I don't know where you would put him on the evil meter. But I certainly would not be putting him on the great meter. I don't think he deserves to be in the top twenty of the country's best monarchs by a considerable margin.
50:53 Speaker 00 Gareth, this has been an absolute delight. I feel like we could talk for several more hours just about Henry the eighth. If people are living under a rock and don't know where to find your work, where can they do so, please?
51:03 Speaker 02 Well, my website's GarethRussell.co.uk and I'm also pretty active on the Holy Gram. So underscore Gareth Russell.
51:12 Speaker 00 You are very active on that. You do some great things.
51:14 Speaker 02 I know, but I wasn't. I was so bad.
51:16 Speaker 00 Did you get told by an agent you need to pick a place?
51:20 Speaker 02 Do you, I think the best comment I got from someone I worked with was, I'm sorry, do you have a camera on your phone?
51:26 Speaker 00 You're like, time, time to change my ways.
51:28 Speaker 02 Like, I promise that I will use it.
51:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, I, you know, I think it's a useful thing to let listeners and viewers on YouTube, whatever, know that as part of being a historian now is being well enough versed in social media, like to whatever.
51:44 Speaker 00 Every single time I do anything, I forget to, I forget to take any pictures.
51:48 Speaker 02 I'm starting to get better at it.
51:50 Speaker 00 Are you?
51:50 Speaker 02 But I'm starting to do a little like come with me, like do the weird.
51:52 Speaker 00 Yeah.
51:54 Speaker 02 Because also it's nice to be able to see what we do or like the country also, some of the places I get to go.
51:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:58 Speaker 02 Are really lovely and it'll be so nice to let people see that. But also, I mean, I love what you did the other day about reacting to like off the cuff about costume dramas.
52:07 Speaker 01 But here, that can be really controversial.
52:09 Speaker 00 Oh.
52:10 Speaker 02 Yes, like, yeah, people care about.
52:11 Speaker 01 I'm like, wow.
52:12 Speaker 00 Did you not see when he said which Brontes would enjoy Taylor Swift and which would not?
52:17 Speaker 01 Oh. But these are two of my biggest recent videos. Nothing about real history.
52:21 Speaker 02 Come on, Taylor Swift and the Brontes. You, you mess with two religions there.
52:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, but I said the Brontes.
52:27 Speaker 00 And there's a big Venn diagram crossover there, right? Like, come on.
52:30 Speaker 02 Yeah.
52:31 Speaker 01 I said they wouldn't be into that.
52:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
52:32 Speaker 01 And that, but listen, look, we live for the controversy.
52:36 Speaker 02 I'm stunned.
52:37 Speaker 01 I like to just stir it and walk away. I'm just like, guys, have a nice time.
52:42 Speaker 02 I was listening to, you're on your own, kid, on the way over.
52:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly, exactly. I commented on your video being like, you're so wrong, I can't even. And I still to this day get notifications of like the 1,020th person that's liked your comment. And I'm like, you're just wrong.
52:55 Speaker 01 That video is up to like 300,000 views or something.
52:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's wild.
52:57 Speaker 02 By the way, it's never the ones that you think.
52:58 Speaker 01 Never.
52:59 Speaker 02 Never.
52:59 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:00 Speaker 01 We should finish this episode.
53:00 Speaker 02 Sorry, we're sorry.
53:01 Speaker 00 Final, final, final question.
53:02 Speaker 01 Oh, go, sorry.
53:03 Speaker 00 Which Taylor Swift album would be most applicable to Henry? It's got to be Torture Poets, like the female rage.
53:11 Speaker 01 Torture.
53:11 Speaker 00 Because it's the best one, you don't understand.
53:13 Speaker 02 I like to think.
53:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
53:15 Speaker 02 Oh, God, um.
53:17 Speaker 00 I feel like Anne would sing Reputation.
53:19 Speaker 02 Anne might sing Smallest Man Who Ever Lived, right in his face.
53:22 Speaker 00 Perfect.
53:23 Speaker 02 She was like Catherine.
53:24 Speaker 00 And he'd be like, Henry Smash.
53:25 Speaker 02 Henry Smash. And she was like, please, Henry, I don't want you to be intimidated, but I've actually memorized words of more than four songs.
53:32 Speaker 00 There's some big words.
53:33 Speaker 02 There's some really big words here, guys.
53:34 Speaker 01 Can I just say?
53:35 Speaker 00 Here's a dictionary.
53:36 Speaker 01 Just add all those conversations together. I can hear our YouTube producer in there right now going, "Yes, this is the content. Taylor Swift, Henry VIII, the Tudors."
53:45 Speaker 00 We are hitting all the content points.
53:47 Speaker 01 Just put that at the start of the episode and then they'll stay watching.
53:49 Speaker 00 I think you better wrap up before we go completely off the rails.
53:51 Speaker 01 That is one of, there are conversations that we have on this podcast over the years now, a couple of years, that I, that stick with me. This is going to be one of those conversations. I don't just mean the, the Taylor Swift and, and, you know, social media conversation.
54:04 Speaker 02 Oh, at least one of my sisters will watch the show solely to cut that reference.
54:07 Speaker 01 Well, yes, there you go.
54:08 Speaker 00 Finally, Gareth is interesting.
54:10 Speaker 02 Thank you, Gareth. Once in a decade.
54:13 Speaker 01 It's just, I think the nuance that we can bring to someone like Henry VIII is you forget that it's there. We're told it's there, we learn it underground, but actually this has been a brilliant reminder, Gareth. So thank you for bringing this back into After Dark. Let us know what you thought of the episode in the comments on YouTube or give us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts. We're across so many platforms at this stage that you can't move but for finding us. Thank you for joining us and join us again next time on After Dark.
55:42 Speaker 00 The.
Previous The Perfume Poisoner Who Killed 500 Men Next Day in the Life of a Tudor Executioner Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated