Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Dark Side of Prehistoric Britain About this episode Across prehistoric Britain people raised vast stone circles, buried their dead in monumental tombs, and left offerings in rivers and bogs. Archaeologists have uncovered skeletons bearing signs of violence, carefully arranged human bones, and bodies that may have been killed in ritual…
Out guest today is fan favourite Ronald Hutton. Ronald is a returning guest, having been on numerous episodes of After Dark including the the Execution of Charles I and the Dark Side of the Celts.
Edited by Hannah Feodorov. Produced by Tomos Delargy. Senior Producer is Freddy Chick.
For tickets to see Anthony and Maddy talking about her new book, Hoax, click here: https://www.conwayhall.org.uk/whats-on/event/hoax/
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers, now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries, and I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Ant and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:56 Speaker 01 Before castles, before kings, before the Romans, prehistoric Britain was a land of tribes, ritual and survival. Across open plains and dense forests, people raised massive stone circles, ceremonially buried their dead in great Neolithic tombs and preserved them forever in the dark bogs. Were these sacred acts of devotion or something darker? Archaeologists have uncovered evidence of human bones with butchery marks. But what do these discoveries really mean? Did prehistoric Britain's practise human sacrifice or even cannibalism? In this episode, we travel back thousands of years to uncover the beliefs and the bloodshed
1:40 Speaker 01 behind prehistoric Britain's most haunting mysteries.
2:11 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to After Dark. Now, you may have noticed recently that I am currently flying solo because Maddie is mining for gold in South America, but we are going to have plenty of adventures together between now and the time when she gets back. And in this episode, we have a real treat for you. I'm so excited for this, and I know you will be too, because we are exploring the dark side of prehistoric Britain. And who better, of course, to help us than Professor Ronald Hutton? He is a returning guest, one of our fan favourites. I don't need to tell you that. You are the fans and he is one of your favourites. He is a professor at the University of Bristol and specialises in early modern Britain, British folklore, pre-Christian religion and modern paganism.
2:55 Speaker 01 Ronald Hutton, welcome back to After Dark.
2:57 Speaker 02 It's a delight to be back.
2:59 Speaker 01 They are going to be so excited. I can hear them squealing with delight right now. Now, tell me this, one of the things I first was introduced to your work when I was doing my, well, either undergrad or postgraduate, and it was around the Civil War particularly is what I would have been reading your work in my first experiences of it. But we are here today talking about something slightly different, and that is prehistoric Britain. And I'm really intrigued to know how and what makes that link for you. And if you see any parallels between the two times?
3:36 Speaker 02 I don't see any particular parallels between Tudor and Stuart history and prehistoric times. The link is me because I'm simply greedy.
3:48 Speaker 02 I was the kind of thirteen, fourteen year old who would relentlessly trek round historic and prehistoric monuments together and say if I were in South Wales for a summer holiday, I'd look at the stone circles and the dolmens and I'd look at the castles that had all been ruined in the civil war, pretty well equally. And frankly, being in a university like Bristol that could let me do what the heck I liked, I didn't see any reason not to do the lot.
4:22 Speaker 01 It's so true, because actually historians so often go, this is my lane, I am sticking to it. And, and you know, in terms of the civil war, there's plenty there that will keep you occupied. But it's, there's something very, I think adventurous and commendable about going, I am going to be greedy and I am going to invest all this time and my expertise in these seemingly disparate time periods.
4:44 Speaker 02 What is adventurous to one observer is reckless to another. And I'm perfectly happy to own up to both qualities. I never calculate anything when I research and write it. I just follow my heart, go full steam ahead. And then when everything's done, reckon with the consequences.
5:05 Speaker 01 But I think that's why, that's so interesting. And I love to hear historians say that because I identify with that myself. But it's so refreshing to hear a historian say they follow their heart, because that I think is why you resonate with our audiences so much, because they see that, they feel that, they hear that in the way that you explain these histories. So thank you for being so adventurous or reckless, whichever way you might want to view it. Let's talk then about this particular history and prehistoric Britain. It's a very broad term, prehistoric Britain. Give us a time period in which we are situating ourselves for this discussion.
5:43 Speaker 02 For this discussion, I'd imagine we're situating ourselves back around thirteen, fourteen thousand years. That's when humans trekked back to what's going to be Britain at the end of the last ice age. Now, we've been visiting what was going to be Britain for tens of thousands of years before. But it's really from around thirteen, fourteen thousand years ago, that we have enough evidence to work out at least what might possibly have been going on.
6:14 Speaker 01 Talk to me about that evidence then, because when we come to your other area of specialism, the civil war, we have tracts of written material, we have material culture, there is even clothing left from that time, and very relatively good nick, but our documentary evidence looks different from this time, doesn't it?
6:35 Speaker 02 We have really, strictly speaking, no documentary evidence from anywhere in British prehistory, or indeed in anybody's prehistory, which is what makes it prehistoric. The moment you get written evidence, even if it's just inscriptions carved on stone, you get history.
6:53 Speaker 01 So what do we use then? What is, what are, what are the tools available to us as historians to start piecing these histories together?
7:04 Speaker 02 The tools available for prehistory are essentially material objects, but material objects are enormous in their abundance and their complexity for most periods, and you can tell an awful lot from them. So with the bones of people and of the animals they kept and/or ate, their artefacts which they make for every branch of life, we can now tell their ethnicity, their appearance, their diseases and physical mishaps and triumphs, their technology, their living conditions,
7:47 Speaker 02 their patterns of migration and trade. We can tell everything in fact, except what's going on in their heads. We are usually completely at sea, as sea as the Victorians were, about their social arrangements, their gender relations, their political structures, and above all, their religious beliefs.
8:10 Speaker 01 And that's very articulated, I suppose, in, say, for instance, Stonehenge, where we have this continuous conversation, don't we? And it's one of the things that we hear again and again on this podcast going, well, it could be this. There's potentially an archer. There's potentially some religious connotations here. Do you think the potential in this prehistory is what keeps people coming back, coming back and keeping them intrigued in what they don't know as opposed to what they do?
8:40 Speaker 02 The great frustration of prehistory is how little we can probably ever know about aspects of it. In many ways, the aspects in which most people are most interested, like what people thought. But the great release of that is that, given quite an abundance of evidence, we can leave everybody to make up their own minds. Stonehenge is popular, partly because it's the people's temple. You don't have any kind of organised clergy there in charge of proceedings and giving their particular stamp of religion to what
9:21 Speaker 02 was, since it has no central practical purpose, clearly a ritual monument, a temple, if you like. And if people want to see painted savages committing dreadful human sacrifices and performing war dances with stone tomahawks, they can. If they want to see wise priestesses presiding over a matriarchal and peaceful and ecologically friendly society, they can. If they want to see white-robed elderly men gazing at the heavens and learning their secrets, they can.
10:11 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
10:54 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series, Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hits. There are new episodes every week.
11:47 Speaker 01 It is that freedom, I suppose, in prehistory that's quite interesting to a lot of people. But it's a freedom that comes into one part of a pre-Christian polytheistic belief that we call paganism.
12:04 Speaker 01 And for some people, they probably have an idea of what that encapsulates. But tell us in this period, what exactly paganism, as far as we can tell, means?
12:16 Speaker 02 Well, the term pagan is coined by Christians to define religious believers whom they are not and who are not followers of the Jewish religion. It's a very handy umbrella term, therefore, these days, for followers of the pre-Christian, the traditional, the rooted religions of Europe and the Near East. And indeed, of those today who practise religions which are inspired by those. But actually, in its linguistic root, it works quite well. Because since the 1990s, the consensus over what the word originally means, it's a Latian,
13:01 Speaker 02 a Roman term, is it's the religion of the Pargus, which is the unit of local government. In other words, the old religion, the rooted religion, the traditional religion. And that's precisely what it is.
13:14 Speaker 01 And we have various ideas of what that looked like. And one of the ways that we fill some of those gaps in knowledge is by the things that we find in the ground, right? And me, as an Irish person, I have been to the National Museum in Ireland many times. And in a specially designed, curved, encapsulued little space, we have bog bodies. And they are, you know, you can see the hair on these people's heads. You can, you can see a type of skin that's still covering the bones. Often, they're, they're, they're kind of, you know, just the torso or the upper half of the body. It gives this idea of...
13:56 Speaker 01 Of a brutal existence, it also lends itself, although not always in terms of accuracy to this idea of sacrifice that's happening in some of these, as you really nicely explained there, Ronald, these pagan rituals that feed into the belief systems. But how prevalent was human sacrifice or ritual killing at this time? Can we even know?
14:23 Speaker 02 I don't think we can ever know how prevalent human sacrifice was in prehistoric Europe, unless we get much better sorts of evidence than we've got hitherto. There are basically two different types of source, and they're both equally dodgy. The written sources are by enemies of the peoples accused of human sacrifice. They are mostly Greek and Roman, and because the Romans conquered absolutely everybody else concerned, it's the Roman voice we hear. We do not really have any single example in ancient Europe
15:03 Speaker 02 or the ancient Near East of a culture that practiced human sacrifice actually telling us about it. The nearest thing is from Tunisia, where the ancient Carthaginians left cemeteries of infant remains that seem from inscriptions to be offered up to the deities. But I don't think there's a single inscription there that actually says, I have killed this child for the deities. We surmise that. So there's still a doubt even there. And when you look at the material evidence, as one will be saying again and again when looking at this kind of issue,
15:46 Speaker 02 what to one person's eye is a human sacrifice, to another person's eye is an executed criminal, guilty or innocent, or a mugging victim?
16:00 Speaker 02 What to one person's eye is a severed head which is a trophy brought back from a battlefield or removed from somebody after they've been sacrificed, is to somebody else's eye the skull of an admired ancestral warrior being brought back so it can help protect the tribe?
16:19 Speaker 01 That's fascinating because there has always been this, I suppose, pop culture idea that when you see these bog bodies, and I'd love to read the museum inscriptions now, having heard you speak on that, Ronald, because the idea is so closely linked to sacrifice, just by default, almost. And it's interesting the ways in which we need to tell ourselves or want to tell ourselves certain things about that material that we are discovering in the grounds. I have an example here, the Lindoman. I don't know if you could maybe tell us a little bit about that particular discovery?
16:58 Speaker 02 Lindoman and I have a long relationship. He was the most heavily studied prehistoric human body until his time, which is the 1980s. He was found in a peat bog south of Manchester called Lindomoss in 1984. And he was the first really well-preserved British bog body found in recent enough times to be scientifically studied. He was taken to London, where a top clinical pathologist said that he had been killed three times over. His throat
17:39 Speaker 02 had been cut across the jugular vein, his neck had been broken by strangulation by a grot, and his skull had been smashed with a heavy blow. Now, this is overkill by anybody's reckoning. And so this looks like a heavily ritualized death. And because the Romans had said that the Druids, the priests of ancient Britain and neighboring areas, committed human sacrifice regularly, this was taken as proof positive that the Romans were correct.
18:13 Speaker 02 So where's the problem? Well, there are two. The first is that before the body went to the pathologist in London, it was studied in Manchester by an equally good anatomist from Liverpool University, who said this guy was beaten to death. His head was broken by a blow. Another broke his neck and a third broke one of his ribs. The cut across the jugular vein seems to have been made after the body was in the bog, probably by somebody digging for peat long after. And the garrote around the neck showed no trauma from strangulation.
18:53 Speaker 02 It was almost certainly a necklace which had sunk into the tissues as they swelled in the bog. So that completely contradicts the view of the other expert. But this contrary view was buried for many years. And the other problem is the dating, that the carbon dating shows a one-third probability that it's post-Roman, so it's not ancient at all. And a two-thirds probability that it's from the Roman period. If it is pre-Roman, that it's not by more than a few years. The dates cluster in the Roman period, when there aren't supposed to be any Druids or human sacrifice. So there's something really wrong here.
19:36 Speaker 02 So either you can say, well, this just proves that the Druids lingered in secret in the Roman period, carrying on murdering people on the sly. Or you can say, well, that's one slightly far-fetched but possible interpretation. But there are loads of others. You know, this could be a criminal who'd been sentenced to death and executed in Roman Britain and chucked into a bog. He isn't the only guy in the bog. There's remains of at least one, probably two more bodies that are both absolutely from the Roman period. So we're looking at a dumping ground for bodies that have met violent deaths.
20:18 Speaker 02 Could be the victims of a mugging gap that would waylay and Kill travelers, could be the local dump for the execution site, or it could be a site of human sacrifice. But if this is Roman, then the other explanations than human sacrifice on the surface carry a lot more traction. So you see how far we've come now from the idea that this is the conclusive proof that the Iron Age pre-Roman druids committed human sacrifice. The British Museum, to its credit, has altered its label on the exhibit because the BM is where the body ended up and is still on display.
20:59 Speaker 01 I think that is utterly compelling because I think most of our listeners will be thinking, if a body is found, and this now seems silly after what you've just said, Ron, but this is what I came in with to a certain extent. So I might as well say it because other people will be thinking it too. If a body is found in a bog, then there has to be something ancient and prehistoric about it. That's just the default in my mind. But of course, the bog, I walk my dogs on a bog when I'm in Ireland almost every day today. I mean, you know, you could fall into a bog at any time or be pushed into a bog at any time. Or it's interesting, the associations we've made with prehistory and this, the oneness with the ground and the earth.
21:44 Speaker 01 Because those things meld in our minds, they come together as part of one story. But this idea of something far more visceral and human and potentially far after we have believed that it was the case. I mean, what I also find interesting is the idea that we can tell that he was probably a male in his mid twenties and we can get some gleams of actual interest from it. But it's this unknowing is utterly, utterly compelling. And it's why I think people are drawn to these histories. Now, when we're talking about prehistoric Britain, we've established that, okay, there may have been human sacrifice, there may not. One of the things I would imagine we're finding, and again, correct me if I'm wrong,
22:26 Speaker 01 is some form of weaponry or vestiges of weaponry. Do we conclude that this is a violent time? Or do we conclude that these are hunting tools, you know, survival tools? What do we, what do we feel about some of that material that we're finding?
22:42 Speaker 02 You can draw some pretty certain conclusions about the purpose of weaponry from the weaponry. For example, once swords get invented, which in Britain is in the Bronze Age, they are useless for carpentry, tree felling or hunting. They're purely war weapons. You can use a spear on red deer or rival warriors with equal facility, but a sword is a weapon of war. Likewise, a mace is not going to be too much use as a hammer. You need a different style of head for that. So that is for braining people.
23:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
23:24 Speaker 02 So there are custom-made war weapons. And overall, in British prehistory, the conclusion reached is in many ways rather comforting one, which is that then as now, human beings not infrequently wage wars or at least get involved in fights. But they wax and wane. In other words, there are periods that are more peaceful than others and some that seem very peaceful in between warlike periods. So we haven't had some kind of even like fall from grace from a time in which we all loved each other and put flowers in each other's hair
24:06 Speaker 02 and learned how to domesticate animals and grow crops to a time we're all killing each other like maddened canines.
24:15 Speaker 01 It's gone from this, it's become this brutalist thing. Whereas, you know, actually it's not that delineated at all, which it makes far more sense. When we're talking, we're talking now about human sacrifice, we've talked about violence, we've talked about the ways in which people are dying brutally and all of these kind of things. There is also this idea that prehistoric civilizations are obsessed with cultures of death, or that they, you know, they live more cheek by jowl with it. I'm imagining, from what you've said so far about the other areas that we've discussed, is that this probably is less definitive than we have otherwise imagined.
24:57 Speaker 01 But talk to me about those cultures of death and those practices of death. I remember seeing in some kind of, you know, one of those outside museum situations where they'd try and replicate Bronze Age dwellings and all that kind of thing, a hole in the side of a cliff, basically, that was just, and a body was bundled up and shoved in there. And it was very much presented as in like, well, the houses are over there and the burial sites are over here and we're living cheek by jowl. Do we think that was the case, or what can we glean from that?
25:29 Speaker 02 There are world cultures which you can say have a more close and constant relationship with death than others. Ancient Egypt is a good example, where the elite spend a lot of their lives preparing for death. And famously, the way in which bodies are prepared is a very long, expensive and intricate process. But archaeologically, it's very hard to judge whether a society is more preoccupied with the dead and the idea of dying than others. Supposing we scrap all the written record from 21st century Britain, or indeed any
26:11 Speaker 02 modern Britain, we have vast cemeteries across the landscape, which are studded with written memorials to people. When you compare that with a lot of prehistory, you find that only a small percentage, maybe even 5% to 10% of the population, seems to get buried at all. Uh. The rest have just disappeared. Uh. Either there was no conservation of their bodies, or they were laid out to be picked clean, or else uh they were cremated and their ashes thrown into water, or their bones
26:50 Speaker 02 thrown into water. But no memorials, no funeral monuments, uh and actually precious little sign of human bone, except fragments of it around living spaces, which suggests there's no special kind of status attributed to the dead.
27:09 Speaker 01 Is there a a an idea of collective burial then? Is is uh are people buried as individuals in individual spaces, or is this is it is it less formalized?
27:20 Speaker 02 Throughout prehistory, there are particular styles of treatment of the dead that keep waxing and waning. It's like a carousel. They go out of fashion and then come back. Uh. Cremation versus inhumation, which is the burial of whole bodies or unburned bodies is a classic case. Uh. Another case is collective versus individual burial. There are prehistoric societies that like interring their people together. There are prehistoric societies that don't. If you take a good example from just one period, which is the early Neolithic, and just one type of monument, which is what we call a longbar or a dolman, uh that's
28:05 Speaker 02 a bigger than mounds, which uh often in most areas has a stone or a timber chamber as an end with bones of the dead. But that I've just, which I've just said, is really just true of uh the chalklands of Wessex, you know, Wiltshire, Hampshire, Dorset, and the Cotswold area, where you find very large numbers of human bones quite often in chambers in these long mounds we call longbarrows. In Sussex, you have longbarrows that look exactly the same on the grounds, but they have little Or no human bone in them.
28:46 Speaker 02 Instead, the mound is very carefully constructed of soils from different districts. So it's the mound itself, not the dead, that is the object of reverence. And when you cross beyond Swansea into West Wales, the long mounds vanish completely. And what you're left with is the big stone chambers, which get a bit bigger. And you get some human bones there, not very many, only with other types of deposit like flints and pots, and not very much of any. So it looks as if the reverence is to the big stones themselves. Alistair Whittle and Vicky Cummings gave the marvelous label of stones that float to the sky
29:30 Speaker 02 for these enormous capstones that seem to have been the object of reverence. So what is basically derived from the same kind of architectural style can have three utterly different applications in areas which today would be half a day's drive apart at exactly the same time, which is between three and four thousand years before the Christian or common era.
30:02 Speaker 01 So we're talking about death in prehistoric Britain. And probably what's coming to mind for a lot of listeners will be the idea of Stonehenge. Or maybe not, maybe we've been misled. Tell us, Ronald, how this does, or if it does, or might it link up to ideas of death? Or is this something else entirely when we're talking about Stonehenge specifically?
30:28 Speaker 02 When we're talking about Stonehenge, there's stuff we do and don't know. What we don't know is what the ceremonies were there and what the religion was and what the associations were. It's the largest cemetery that we possess in England from the early third century before the the common or Christian era, with a lot of cremations in particular being interred there.
30:59 Speaker 02 But is this because the dead are the focus of what goes on there? Or is it for the same reason that you get churchyards around churches? But people like their honoured dead to lie close to what is dedicated essentially to something else? Uh, which is a religious monument that isn't directly concerned with honouring humans at all? We know that Stonehenge was really important at midwinter. Because uh, it was aligned on the setting sun at midwinter. Uh, it's, it's the product of careless, megalomaniac carpenters. They're carpenters because uniquely, and it doesn't really work.
31:44 Speaker 02 Attempted to shape enormous stones as if they were wood. Plaining them smooth, curving them slightly. And above all, fastening together the tops with mortise and tenon joints like doorways. Now, th- these are not stoneworkers' techniques, they're woodworkers. And they're careless because the pièce résistance at Stonehenge was the greatest of those freestanding three stone settings like doorways, which are Stonehenge's logo image. This was called the Great Trilithon. And the setting sun at midwinter went down so that with wonderful precision, it would have thrown a laser-like beam of red light
32:26 Speaker 02 through the narrow gap between the two uprights of the trilithon. But it isn't there now and hasn't been there for a very long time. Because it was sloppily built. What they needed to do was have two enormous upright stones that each went six feet into the earth and was fully anchored. They got one of those, it's still standing. But they either couldn't find or couldn't be bothered to find another upright of equal length. And they got a much shorter stone that had a a bit jutting out like a shoe from the bottom. And you can almost hear the arguments around the drawing board in a four and a half thousand years ago. They convinced themselves.
33:09 Speaker 02 That if they put this upright in the earth and the projecting bit sticking beneath the turf would stabilise it. And if they jammed a heavy enough lintel stone on top, fastened the rock solid upright by a mortise and tenon joint, then it would keep the rockier stone stable. They were wrong. The shorter stone toppled, it seems not too long after it was built. It might even be while Stonehenge was still being built, which is why we have no absolute proof that the outer circle of stones was ever finished, was ever erected in its holes. You may notice there's a big gap on the southwestern side today. And the
33:53 Speaker 02 lintel toppled over into the centre, the falling upright broke in two and also knocked the altar stone over, which is where the beam of light coming through had hit in a stunning visual display. And the broken stones are still there. They were never cleared away, which means the people who built Stonehenge abandoned it when the Great Trilithum came down. So it's a disaster.
34:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
34:19 Speaker 02 Because of sloppy construction.
34:23 Speaker 01 Some things never change.
34:24 Speaker 02 So this is quite a story and it's fact, we can state it for truth. But when you actually ask what that red beam of light was supposed to mean, is it the birth blood of the great goddess pouring from between her legs, the uprights? Is it a male sun fertilising a female earth? Or is it something else completely different? You know, does that red beam signify the pouring of sacrificial blood, for example, of lifeblood? We've got to make it up for ourselves.
35:17 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt, and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
36:12 Speaker 01 With the possibility that you're describing in the ways in which we interpret these monuments, fragments of bones, some of the elements of tools that you've been describing, Ronald, I wonder how or what you would say to people when it comes to trying to differentiate mythology from prehistoric fact, if such a thing exists. How do we separate out our desire for a good story, or should we even bother, separate out our desire for a good story from what we know we have and we can say about these prehistoric, particularly in the terms of prehistoric British cultures?
36:58 Speaker 02 At the present state of British prehistoric archaeology, we have an immense array of fact in that we're getting better and better with our dating, we're getting better and better with our DNA analysis, we're getting better and better with our knowledge of what bones can tell us about people's health and longevity and so on. And we can say more and more about their living conditions in every aspect.
37:31 Speaker 02 Beyond that, we have to make it up. So everybody can have their personal mythology, their personal fiction about prehistory on an enormous range of reactions from the kind of Lord of the Flies view of human nature, that scratch a human being and you'll find a savage, to the benevolent view of human nature, that the more humans are allowed to be themselves, the better things get, and the many points between. And both of those extreme positions are equally valid when applied to prehistory. And so is everything on the spectrum in the middle.
38:11 Speaker 02 So in theory, we could have as many different interpretations of a prehistoric monument and the people who built it, as there are people who care to make the interpretations. Indeed, theoretically, rather more if people change their minds.
38:28 Speaker 01 Let's, to finish up this conversation then, I'd like to talk about some of the people that we may need to either blame or credit, whichever way you'd like to look at it, if you're frustrated by the not knowing, or if you're inspired by it. In terms of the ways that the Victorians have shaped our idea of prehistory, is that something that has helped maintain interest over generations? Or, I mean, it's relatively recent in terms of, you know, the prehistory we're talking about here, but are they responsible for a lot of the layering that we have talked about today?
39:08 Speaker 02 Basically, our view of anything in the West was Victorian until the 1960s. And that's because the Victorians achieved so much. They founded the science of archaeology. They handed us, with a lot of help from the continent, our basic division of prehistory, Old Stone Age, New Stone Age, et cetera.
39:36 Speaker 02 And they handed us our basic excavation techniques and a lot of our most important finds. But there was a disposition under the Victorians to take a very dark view of prehistory for two reasons. The first is it was the greatest ever age of progress and of optimism in progress. The Industrial Revolution, the enormous expansion of European power, Western power and influence. And therefore, aided by the discovery of the Great Age of the World and the doctrine of evolution, the Darwin doctrine of evolution, you have this view of life as a perpetual ascent
40:18 Speaker 02 from the primitive to the complex, from the barbaric to the civilized, that begins with a protoplasmic atomic globule wriggling in the pre-Cambrian slime and ascends through ever more admirable and complex and intelligent life forms until you reach Queen Victoria. And the other thing is the expansion of European power, particularly French and British, over the tropical world. Subduing and, in the views of the conquerors, civilizing and christianizing huge numbers of indigenous peoples in Asia and in Africa,
41:02 Speaker 02 while the Canadians and the former American colonies were doing the same in the Americas. And therefore, people with indigenous lifestyles and older religions were being conquered and subdued and civilized by the British. And so the obvious British role model became the Romans. Who after all brought cities, marching in step, reinforced concrete, currency, a uniform and complex currency to most of Europe. And they provided the template for Victorian imperialism.
41:44 Speaker 02 And therefore, the indigenous peoples became acquainted with the prehistoric northern European peoples, including the ancient British, whom the Romans were conquering. If you want a snapshot, you just need to go to the Houses of Parliament, where when they were redecorated under Victoria, there was a gallery called The Progress of Britain, with a series of before and after shots. And the first before and after was, on one side, a British druid committing a human sacrifice, and on the other side, a Victorian army officer rescuing an Indian woman for being burned on her husband's pyre in the Rite of Sati.
42:26 Speaker 02 In other words, we were like that 2,000 years ago, but now we're better and can stop the rest of the world being like that. And it kind of makes us cringe now, but you can see where they're coming from.
42:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. One of the things I'm aware of here, and I suppose what we try to do on After Dark a lot is send people out into the world to see these histories, experience these histories, read about these histories, whatever it might be. And if we were here talking about 17th century, we could do that very readily, and there are houses you could go to, there are whatever else. And obviously, we have monuments, but what would you say to listeners or viewers on YouTube who are thinking, how do I encounter prehistoric Britain in everyday life? Where are the places to go? What are the things to watch out for? What traces does it leave where you don't necessarily have to step inside a museum?
43:24 Speaker 02 If you want to encounter prehistoric Britain at the present day, then there are three things that you can do. It actually depends how far you want to immerse yourself, of course. If you want a day in prehistoric Britain, it's one thing. If you want to develop a relationship with it, it's another. If you want a day out, then you simply pick a charismatic looking prehistoric site and go and spend time there. Go down a flint mine at Grimes Graves, look at an old Stone Age meat processing plant at Boxgrove in Sussex. But if you want to immerse
44:04 Speaker 02 yourself, then there are three means and they're all accessible, no matter where you happen to live. Number one is go out on the ground, see the physical remains of prehistoric activity. Number two is do go to the local museum and ask questions there. And the third thing is to read, not just read well-written, user-friendly books by archaeologists, but fictional works, novels, compare and contrast Bernard Cornwell and Ken Follett on Stonehenge.
44:43 Speaker 01 I think one of the things that, this is where my, my, my hidden desire to be an archaeologist starts to, starts to manifest itself, because often I, when I'm on a train or something and I'm going past, you know, I'm bored and I'm looking out the window and, and you start to see, if you're slightly elevated and you might be looking down on some of the fields below and you start to see some of those patterns in the fields of, you know, it reminds, it makes you feel like you're on time team for just a moment and you're like, ah, I think I've spotted something kind of prehistoric there. So I do like this idea of going out and encountering these things in the land. And, and local historians, I would also say, are a really useful tool in knowing the, the patterns of the landscape in, in people's
45:25 Speaker 01 general area. So it's, it's good to be able to tune in to some of that as well. Ronald, thank you so much for coming on to talk to us on After Dark. About prehistoric Britain, because it is, it is a world that is, you know, the subtitle of this is myths, misdeeds and the paranormal. We look at that darker side of history. But within darkness, sometimes darkness manifests itself in, in a lack of knowledge, or as you've been describing today, the gift of possibility, that within that darkness, we can find multiple meanings. And, and those meanings are different for different people. But therein lies the richness of this prehistoric exploration. If you've enjoyed this episode, please do leave us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts. Are you also watching us
46:08 Speaker 01 on YouTube? It's important that you get all your After Dark fix wherever you can. So we're on YouTube now. Find us at After Dark History Hit and watch the episodes you've been listening to on your podcast platform. Until next time, happy listening.
Previous Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand Next Speaking with the Dead: Ancient Necromancy Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated