Pod Insights a16z Podcast Zach Perret (Plaid) & Simon Khalaf (Marqeta): New Applications in Fintech About this episode In this conversation from 16z's Connect Fintech event, a16z General Partner Angela Strange, Plaid CEO and cofounder Zach Perret, and Marqeta CEO Simon Khalaf discuss how AI will shape the future of banking, the battle between payment rails in the U. S., and how there's still opportunity to transform the basic credit card into a fully digital product.
“In the Vault” is a new audio podcast series by the a16z Fintech team, where we sit down with the most influential figures in financial services to explore key trends impacting the industry and the pressing innovations that will shape our future.
0:00 - Intro
1:56 - GenAI's potential impact on credit modeling and fraud
4:46 - Implications of payment products becoming digital products
7:09 - Why brands will embed finance
8:33 - The card vs. pay-by-bank debate
11:01 - New infrastructure to combat fraud
12:24 - Reassessing traditional "top-of-wallet" tactics, historic business models
17:27 - Potential implications of the Visa/Mastercard antitrust suit
20:04 - Regulation around open banking and sponsor banks
24:12 - Outro
Full transcript: https://a16z.com/podcast/in-the-vault-new-applications-in-fintech-with-plaid-and-marqeta/
Resources:
Find "In The Vault" on a16z.com: https://a16z.com/podcasts/in-the-vault/
Find more about a16z's vision for the future of fintech: https://a16z.com/banking-on-AI/
Find Angela Strange on X: https://x.com/astrange
Find Zach Perret on X: https://x.com/zachperret
Find Simon Khalaf on X: https://x.com/Simonkhalaf
Find a16z on X: https://x.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z/
Subscribe to the a16z Fintech newsletter:
https://info.a16z.com/newsletters-fintech.html
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 0 That's why I hope in the next two years the word FinTech will this will disappear and it will be embedded finance because they've got distributions, they've got the consumer, right?
0:14 Speaker 2 So let's start with generative AI.
0:16 Speaker 1 No
0:16 Speaker 2 joke.
0:17 Speaker 1 You promised us you were starting with a joke.
0:18 Speaker 2 I have I have many jokes, none of them were uh quite acceptable for the audience. I I do have one. Okay, okay, go for it.
0:25 Speaker 0 So uh we were doing an introductory call with Zach, and my wife passed by and she's like, he's talking to Fabio. Uh uh and now like the only thing I can think of when I see Zach is Fabio.
0:39 Speaker 1 So to try to distract from this, the only joke I could come up with is that if you cover the six and the Z in the A16Z logo, it says AI. Okay, that's all I have.
0:50 Speaker 2 That was actually pretty good. We've been telling a lot of our portfolio companies to buy the.ai domain. So if we're eating our own medicine, we should do that. Okay, let's uh let's dive into AI. As Alex mentioned yesterday, one of the unique things of this platform shift is there's a top-down mandate in every company to figure out AI, experiment with AI. So there's a lot of experiments going on. But I thought a good place to start would be fast forward five, ten years. Like what area, what is an area of financial services that you think could be dramatically transformed with generative AI and how. Zach, I'll start with you given you've got the best AI joke.
1:25 Speaker 1 Uh okay. Fair enough. Um so I think it's it's it's somewhat hard to tell where exactly things are gonna go. I think there's some very obvious candidates over the next call it five-ish years, through to five-ish years, somewhat regulation dependent, um, that will be massively transformed through AI. Um the two that come to mind for me, uh first is credit modeling. Um that one should have massive change, but uh currently is very regulatorily constrained in the US. Um our our European team is doing a bunch of work on it because there are you know there's no FCRA um uh in most of Europe. And uh so I I think that one will have a major shift. The second is fraud detection. Um this is something that is much more real time and can happen much more in real time. Um people ask us what we're doing in AI, and the answer is like nothing interesting. Um we're doing the same things that all of your companies are doing.
2:13 Speaker 1 We're making our engineers more efficient, we're working on support, uh uh uniquely to Plowd, we're working on making transaction data cleaner with AI, um, uh which I think some of you might appreciate. But um uh the most interesting thing that we're doing by far is working on our identity verification uh fraud detection uh tooling. Um as most of you know, the industry standard more or less to uh verify a user is uh you know, uh when when they're doing identity verification, um is to send in a photo of your ID uh to do some basic like uh data entry, maybe some document uh scanning, um, and then to do a selfie liveness check. And every single one of those things can now be manufactured with AI. Um the selfie liveness check being the scariest. Um so you know, I I think it's like you know a matter of matter of months, and frankly, it's already happening when we're gonna start seeing things like AI generated uh like sorta generated uh liveness checks.
3:03 Speaker 1 And the question is like can we detect them? Or has this like major pillar of of uh of fraud reduction uh throughout financial services just been completely destroyed? And like now we have to shift to like pass keys being the best in class thing, and even that's like not uh has different utilities.
3:19 Speaker 2 Yeah. No, and you probably read fraud last year. We have some fraud companies in the room, I think they're hoping to hoping to solve this hit ten billion dollars in losses just for consumers. It's spawning interesting companies like AI or not. And so I think you know, uh many of the generative AI is gonna help us, but turns out fraudsters have it too, and that's gonna be uh a super challenging vector. Simon, what do you think?
3:41 Speaker 0 Um I'll get I'll get to Gen AI. I think before getting to Gen AI, I just want to be celebrate the moment that a payment vehicle became a digital product. Because there's so much opportunity here because if you think about a payment card, it's the most adopted techno technological product ever invented. More distribution than Google and Facebook combined, more distribution than clean water. And it's still a piece of plastic for many. But when you if you think of this payment product as a digital product, it is the most addictive product ever invented. Give you a stat. So right now the most addictive product, well, according to the Senate and the Congress, right, is uh TikTok. And if you look at its usage, adjust it for the US population reach, adult population, is 2.1 times a day.
4:31 Speaker 0 But a payment card is used 2.2 times a day. So you've got the digital product that the most addictive product, that's no longer a payment product. It's an engagement product that every brand is gonna need. So if you think about it this way, that's the exciting part. Now that we made it a digital product, it could displace the Facebook feed. It could displace the Google search bar, it could displace my Yahoo. Uh if you think it is the open face of the internet. And that's when you introduce Gen AI. Now, okay, let's talk about what can we do with it. Like all digital brands, and as m Mark mentioned, we're still so early in the e-commerce cycle. Is how do you change consumer behavior? Not how do you intercept it.
5:17 Speaker 0 Changing consumer behavior is actually requires visuals and requires bribery, which is called rewards. So if you think about it, the card can be generated instantaneously at the right time, right purchase for the right consumer, right merchants with the right look, and then the reward does not have to be the dumb 3% cash back. It can be sometimes you can give 40% back and sometimes nothing. But it's generated by the machine with the goal to increase the propensity of the purchase. So if you look at those things, you have increased the GDP and you built phenomenally more opportunity for gross merchandising values. And I think that's what's what excites us about Gen AI.
6:01 Speaker 1 I really wonder how much the industry would change if we started calling rewards and interchange fees bribes. Um
6:09 Speaker 2 Market is new branding. Um maybe actually so pushing on that, one of my favorite things is that every company is gonna be a fintech company. And there's an argument now that oh, okay, that's that's pass by. But I think talking to you, you say there's tons of brands that still need to be a card. So yeah, maybe talk forward how it's gonna happen. I think
6:27 Speaker 0 I'm gonna steal the uh one of the block posts from Alex. It's like the future of payment is red. Look at Target. I mean, uh they make more money from financial services than retail. You look at Macy's, they make 47% of their operating margin from the Macy's card. And that's not a very successful program. And this goes on and on and on. I agree that uh not all fintech, not all companies want to become a bank. That's why I hope in the next two years the word fintech will this will disappear and it will be embedded finance because they've got distributions, they've got the consumer, right? We can bring the technology to them, right? Because fintech demonstrated the art of possible. They're gorgeous products. You look at Cash App as an example.
7:13 Speaker 0 It's the only financial services product that's been in the top 25 on the app store the last three years, right? It's a great product, and list goes on and on, right? They built great products. Now, if you add distribution to that, right, that's when you get the magic. And I think we're gonna get there.
7:33 Speaker 1 Every company is a fintech company. They will be a fintech company. It's a matter of time. They just have to figure out if they if they know it or not.
7:39 Speaker 2 Yeah. Um so maybe maybe changing years a little bit so we could talk about generative AI for a while. Uh there's been some interesting news in the in the payment rails space in the last few days. Um but I'm gonna start with the card versus pay-by-bank debate. And I know Zach, you talked to a lot of merchants. I think your line was, you know, some love them, some are totally confused.
7:59 Speaker 0 Uh
7:59 Speaker 2 how do you see that paying out? Because on the on the good side, right? Merchants in theory could have zero interchange if they convince consumers to move over, but there's obviously a lot of challenges there.
8:08 Speaker 1 Yeah, so I mean I think I think there's um a couple of massive trends happening in the industry, which are surprised to no one. We talked about uh the digitization of money. Um obviously that's still ongoing. Um that not only includes cash, but it also includes check. Um then there's the like kind of uh uh sophistication addition uh of of uh of payments mechanisms. So um if you look at a very basic ACH transaction, uh which Renee does a ton of them, uh clearly. Um I didn't realize the volume was that high. Um uh but but uh very basic ACH transaction versus a better informed ACH transaction, be that an easier way for a consumer to set up the ACH, uh, which Plot does, um, or a more informed transaction to understand, you know, is this ACH gonna fail? Um so putting kind of risk models and and and better information around it. Um and we're still very much in the kind of like transitionary phase of going from uh kind of not digital to digital for the first time and then kind of digital 1.0 to like fully fintech uh enabled.
8:58 Speaker 1 Um and that's gonna happen massively over the next few years. Um so uh the easiest way to think about it is like the way that you pay your cell phone bill. Um uh oftentimes people are typing in uh account routing numbers the way that you pay your power power bill, uh oftentimes you're typing in account and routing numbers. Um and those kinds of uh very basic uh ACS transactions are sometimes they're even paid in checks by by many people. Um those will become much better informed. Um a lot of people like to talk about uh the concept of paying with your bank account uh in a like retail transaction. Um no one's gonna walk into a Starbucks and say, I would like to pay for my $3 coffee with my bank account. Um that's basically never gonna happen. Um or or any small merchant for that matter. Frankly, in my opinion, like very few in person transactions are ever gonna happen uh uh with it with an ACH payment. But there are some really big payments that are digital that that should occur.
9:46 Speaker 1 So let's say I'm buying a car. Um it's very unlikely that any car dealership's gonna let you put a car on your credit card. It's very unlikely that your credit card is even gonna accept a car because the the price is so high. Um but figuring out how to make Make digital car purchases uh something they can scale. Um well that's that that's definitely gonna happen. We're in this interesting inflection year where pay by bank um is getting a lot of tailwind, uh kind of a lot of uh kind of in initial conversation traction um due to um basically Fed now and RTP, so these faster payment mechanisms uh due to everything that's happening in Europe and kind of the continued push uh on on things like PICs uh and UPI in internationally. So every large merchant is saying, hey, should I have a pay by bank strategy? Um I think the answer is yes, but um uh yes, but not for that transaction that uh doesn't make any sense for pay by bank.
10:31 Speaker 1 Um I do think the next 12 months will show uh kind of a a bigger shift in the market, but again, I think it's gonna be mostly concentrated to those those parts of the market where pay by bank just makes sense. Um and it's it's currently sort of digital 1.0 or not digital at all. Yeah.
10:45 Speaker 2 And then maybe one follow up there, and then I'm gonna ask Simon a different version of that question. Right? Like if you think of the card networks, obviously, they built a lot of surrounding infrastructure like around fraud, chargebacks, all of these sort of extra infrastructure that needs to happen to make that work. And I know Plaid, you've been doing a lot more around fraud, a lot more on different things. Like what else do you think needs to be built to really help this other rail take off? Um
11:09 Speaker 1 I mean, I think the answer is uh a ton of different things need to exist. Uh so um the networks have had many years of uh you know exclusive access to the financial institutions, uh, really deep partnerships, gigantic amounts of cash, um, and they've been able to build uh like obviously incredible businesses uh on the back of that. Um I think when you look at a pay by bank uh rail or even just ACH generally, um uh a lot of people like to say that it's it's old, it's decrepit, it's running on on kind of servers that were built in the 90s, and all of that is absolutely true, but it works. Like it works really, really well, it works really consistently. Um if there were going to be massive fraud problems, most of those massive problems already would have occurred. Now, when we're taking it to new places, yes, there will be new fraud vectors. Um but the reality is when you look out across the the fintech ecosystem, um, there's a ton of companies that are building really great products to help kind of accelerate this transition or or that could pivot and accelerate this transition.
12:01 Speaker 1 So my take is um as an industry, fintech will largely come together. There'll be a lot more partnerships. I like to say that fraud is the one area where no one really competes. Um maybe competing for overall spend, but the reality is everyone's collaborating to try to reduce fraud in the ecosystem. Um so I I think that there's a lot of pieces out there that'll come together over the coming years. Yep.
12:20 Speaker 2 Awesome. Then one of the other major themes in financial services is you know, how do you get somebody to adopt your card? But then specifically, how do you get to be top of wallet as that card? And I think as Simon mentioned right now, the big innovation in card is we've moved from the physical card to now it's at least in my Apple wallet to the point where I forget my regular wallet most of the time. But I think the dynamics of how do you be top of wallet, how does that control is getting significantly disrupted. So you want to talk a little bit more about how you're thinking about that, Simon? Sure. Yeah. I mean,
12:50 Speaker 0 we're having uh insane amount of dialogues with brands that are st that stopped thinking about how do I get to top of wallet because it is uh so archaic compared to the dynamic nature of content. If you look at advertising, which is by the way, a lot more complicated than payments, but everybody in payments think payment is very complicated. It's okay. Yeah. So no one talks about my ad being the first one that's shown. Right? You bid on it, right? And that's what's gonna happen to a payment vehicle. It is gonna be a just in time selection. I'm not saying it's you're gonna have infinite amount of cards. You can, because digitally you can.
13:37 Speaker 0 Uh so but there is gonna be one wallet or card that looks like a wallet, right? That will generate multiple virtual cards that are branded by the experience. And that I think will take that conversation away. Now that's gonna put a lot of power in the hands of the wallet owners, like uh the ones that are in embedded in the in the device, like Apple and Google, because they can build that technology that will select uh a payment card and basically do a runaround what the merchant has done. But it's okay because the merchant will get the signal, and that becomes an engagement signal. I'll give you an example. So let's say that you put your buy now pay later card on file.
14:26 Speaker 0 Excellent. So payment one goes. Payment two, three, and four, right? Is an opportunity for the consumer to come back and do something and for the brand to inject a point of sale ad. So all of a sudden, what you were paying a dollar to Google on a click, you get for free. So that's I think is gonna be the win-win. Uh, which is a brand gets an engagement signal, and then everybody makes money.
14:55 Speaker 1 You one of the most interesting things to me in the card landscape is that um cards are not a fundamentally digital product. They were built for an analog world. The form factor to a consumer is still really hard. We talk about cards, though most of us don't have most of our cards in our wallet. I certainly don't. Um I have many more cards digitally than I than I do in my wallet. Um, but when I talk about cards, like we're talking about a 16 digit pan, uh uh, we're talking about uh a CVV code, uh, we're talking about uh an expiration date, and like all of that you have to store in your head, or maybe one of your browsers remembers it. So I still think we're like like even just at the beginning of this interesting journey of taking a card from being something that's truly not digitally native and making it digitally native, and I think things like this. Absolutely. Um I mean,
15:36 Speaker 0 honestly, that's what the reason I'm here. Uh uh I I uh not here in this uh uh uh venue. Thank you for having me. But in uh in in FinTech, yes. So I look at the digital card, uh, sorry, a payment vehicle as a car was in 1913, right? There's not a lot of roads, but you know it's gonna be big. I look at it and it's Yahoo and it's 1996, in which the competition is the New York Times. The news that's fit to print decided by an editor. Like if you look at it, Yahoo, we have a few colleagues from Yahoo here. We had a billion users visiting the homepage, a billion users. And I could put anything in front of them, they'll click. I mean, I can get Kate Middleton to do anything you want, right? And 330 million people would believe it, right?
16:24 Speaker 0 When you look at uh a payment card becoming a digital product, that's the opportunity. Like an ad was a billboard 20 years ago. An ad was a piece of coupon that you clip 20 years ago, right? And now the machinery that Google, Facebook, and all the attack industry built to optimize on a click, right? If you do that for a payment vehicle, who cares about the 220 basis points? I'm gonna increase your sales by 30%. Uh so uh regarding the payment rails, I I agree with Zach, it's a yes but, but the but is bigger than the yes. Because if you look at uh all the folks that are honestly complaining about the interchange. Okay, let's talk about it. These are the same people who are paying Google and Facebook a dollar per click and the 10% conversion to sell a $50 item.
17:14 Speaker 0 So I I didn't fail basic arithmetic. So that is actually 20% tax on everything you sell. So the folks that are paying 20% are complaining about 120 basis points. I'm like, come on. That when you buy advertising, you talk in percentages, not in basis points. So you're an order of magnitude off in terms of trying what you're trying to optimize. So I think that's when if you take a look outside the fintech industry and get out of the BIPS conversation, you see a lot more optimization above the in the top of the funnel.
17:49 Speaker 2 No, it's a smart way to think about it and sort of your advertising cost and your interchange cost. It's sort of all related energy.
17:54 Speaker 0 It's called a cost of goods sold.
17:56 Speaker 2 Which is which is a good segue, actually. So a couple days ago, um MasterCard and Visa came to a settlements. And all of the headlines were around how interchange is gonna go down by four BIPs, it could save the industry 30 billion dollars. Probably the more interesting angle though, is how it's going to allow merchants to steer customers towards different payment cards by discriminating. So, you know, we're very early days here, but would love to hear what do you think the impact might be
18:26 Speaker 1 of this really. I am completely unqualified to answer that question. Um,
18:30 Speaker 0 speculation. Yeah. Uh I mean, the I'm a soccer fan, and there's the World Cup every four years. It's like you enjoy like all these great uh games, and then the Germans win. So I mean, this is the same thing. It's like it's been like a nice debate, and then at the end the VSA and MasterCard win. So uh but uh uh so I think that's what I read into the settlement. And congratulations. I mean, they've done a fabulous job. So I think the innovation is not gonna be on the merchant side. Uh because why? The innovation is gonna be in the wallet size. Because if you look at what Apple Pay has done, it is a personal individual checkout that works in every country in every merchant in every location.
19:15 Speaker 0 That is the universal checkout. That's your point of sale terminal that's yours. That's what I think innovation is gonna be, which is it will select the best cart at the best time to do to do the most important value delivery to the consumer and gives the merchant an opportunity to communicate in near real time to that consumer. And I think that will be auctioned. It would be like an advertise like an advertising exchange, and merchants will compete for to deliver an offer to the consumer in the wallet. I and a point of sale. I'll give you an example. Sorry, I don't want to take that. I went to Whole Foods, and I tried to see what percentage of the people coming are paid shoppers versus individual shoppers.
20:02 Speaker 0 How many are holding an Instacard badge or the door dash? It was actually 17% over the period of two hours. That was zero two years ago. Now what the what is point of sale advertising when when you have a paid chopper? It's gone. That's why you have to move it to either to the checkout, the digital checkout, or to the wallet. And I think it's gonna move to the wallet.
20:27 Speaker 1 So I said it was on qualified. I actually think you're underselling the merchants massively though. Um the the level that the merchants are active in trying to build differentiated payments products, point of sale, uh like point of sale financing products, like loans, so and so forth. Not the small ones. We talk about small business, but the reality is the big ones, they're gonna do way more.
20:45 Speaker 2 Um important regulatory topics. Open banking. So the US is uh infamously behind the rest of the world in open banking. I think you very cleverly pretty much created it without having actual you know regulation behind you. Now 1033 is coming into effect. Maybe I'm sure everybody's familiar, but maybe just a quick explanation on 1033 and what, if any change do you think that's gonna have in the US?
21:14 Speaker 1 Well, did does anyone know what 1033 is like the raise of hands people know? Okay, great. I'm gonna explain 2010 33 then, because only only half people know. Um so uh in in in Europe there have been these rules uh that that basically force banks to have APIs to allow consumers to collect their transaction data uh to set up a basic payment, so on and so forth, uh kind of a basic bank links payment. Um and those rules have been around for eight-ish years at this point. Um in the US, there's a provision of Dodd Frank called Section 1033 of uh of Dodd Frank, um, which effectively says uh consumers own their financial data and banks can't stop them from getting their financial data. And it's like you know, two two sentences, like very short statement. Um and the CFPB has had regulatory authority to go write rules on this thing forever. This is basically the the last piece of Dodd frank that hasn't had rules written on it, uh basically the last thing uh that the regulators got involved in.
22:01 Speaker 1 And in doing so, actually uh the US allowed, uh probably not intentionally, but allowed a really wonderful fintech market to build and grow and flourish. Um the CFP's always been aware of their latent authority, they just haven't actually written the rules. Um so what's happened is um uh the CPB's told the banks, sometimes directly, sometimes indirectly, over the last few months, extremely directly. Um, hey, you're gonna have to have APIs, hey, this is what's gonna happen. Um and we strongly recommend that you figure out a way to work with FinTech. Um, but also the CPB didn't actively jump in. They wanted to see what would emerge and and what would happen. And I think that that's actually an amazing outcome because you saw in Europe the the really quick regulation led to a lot of whiplash in the market. There was a short boom of fintech, then a lot of pullback in fintech, and like it it may well come back over time. Um in the US now they're more or less cementing the ecosystem in a way that is um, yes, safer for consumers long term, uh, but also allows the regulators to have the right level of input.
22:53 Speaker 1 Um so I think the next the next year when this rule goes into effect is gonna be fascinating. I'm certain it's gonna be sued by like I don't know, a gajillion different companies, uh the banks, the big banks want to sue it, the small banks want to sue it, like a bunch of fintechs want to, it's all all over. So who knows when it's gonna actually go like finally into effect and and what it's actually gonna look like. Um but the fact that uh like it's it's being stated very clearly that consumers own and have access to their financial data. Um they are the owners of uh of their financial lives, not the banks. Um that is actually a big step forward, and I think people people under sell it. Um this year is gonna be a really fascinating year to watch FinTech because we're gonna see kind of a lot of the like there are certain banks that still block access to consumers' data. Those banks are gonna have to give access. And there are certain FinTech apps that don't give access to a consumer's transaction data, that don't give access to a consumer's account and routing number.
23:44 Speaker 1 The regulators are like taking a very clear view on that that that those fintech companies have to have to give that data. Um it's gonna be a big inflection year, and um, I don't know. It's it's been a really fun process so far. Hard, but fun.
23:56 Speaker 2 Awesome. Um, one last one last question. I'd be remiss if we didn't talk about sponsor banks as we talk about other things that have really powered the rise of financial services. I remember when I started ACC, there was maybe five sponsor banks, now there's over a hundred. In the recent last year, a large percentage of them are under some form of regulatory constraints. You just put out an op-ed talking about just the importance of this business model for smaller banks and maybe what needs to happen to enable them to do it better. Do you want to talk from a tech perspective?
24:25 Speaker 0 I'll be quick. I mean, uh the beauty about this industry is that there's a trillion dollar everywhere you look. I mean, uh, which is interesting. Uh but we're not gonna do it with just uh with just uh a 50 banks. We want a participatory economy. Uh we'd love to have every bank participate. And and uh the burden is on us to make it simpler for them to participate. And there's gonna be a lot of education we have to do with the regulator. I don't blame them. I mean, in in Silicon Valley, we did so many three letters acronym, they don't even understand what we're talking about, right? So we have to go educate them why this is very good for our economy, why the regional banks need to participate in this, because it's a regional banks that fund the small business, it's a regional banks that fund the farmer, it's the regional banks that that actually fund the SMBs that employ 50% of the US population.
25:15 Speaker 0 So having all of them participate, and we're working on it, we're investing in it to allow all these banks to participate in our platform in the part in a participatory economy. And I this is where I see the future. Every bank participates in this. And we're just the front end, the content, the user experience, and the aggregator uh of these banks.
25:36 Speaker 2 Fantastic. All right. Well, from uh AI 6D, I would like to thank Fabio and our our new advertising company in Marketo for uh for joining us here on stage. Uh fantastic. Thank you.
Previous The Science and Supply of GLP-1s Next How Discord Became a Developer Platform Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated