Pod Insights a16z Podcast The Truth about 1000 True Fans + Pricing Our Attention About this episode The idea of "1000 true fans" argued that to be a successful creator, you don’t need millions of customers or clients, as long as you also have a direct relationship with those fans. But how is media changing today as a result, and what nuances do people often miss about the concept? And why are we apparently surrendering our attention (whether to TV, books, or whatever) for only $3 an hour?!
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Sonal? Hi, everyone. Welcome to the A6 and Z Podcast. I'm Sonal. Today's episode was recorded at our most recent annual innovation summit in our pop-up podcast booth with me and Kevin Kelly, founding executive editor of Wired Magazine and author of several books. In this quick, literally hallway-style chat, I asked him about two of his big ideas: the notion of 1,000 true fans, which sometimes people misinterpret or miss the nuances of, and two, the idea of being able to sell our own attention versus our attention being sold for very little. And we try to connect the dots between these and other ideas, including some new, never-been-heard-before ones in between. The second idea was also covered in his most recent book, The Inevitable, which we did a podcast on with Chris Dixon. And his conversation with Mark at this summit is also available in
0:44 Sonal? this feed as well. Welcome, Kevin.
0:47 Speaker 01 It's a real delight to be here. Thanks for having me.
0:50 Sonal? I think of you as one of the original thinkers of the future. We were just coming off of summit. One of the big themes was about the future of business models after advertising. This is a talk Connie gave last year, and then today she went further on that, like what happens when things become a super app. We had Kevin Chu from Forte talking about business models for crypto economics and gaming. And then we had Jonah Peretti and Chris Dixon talking about the evolution of the web and how so much of the promise of the web, in some ways, came about, but in other ways, didn't because of the sort of albatross around our neck of advertising as a business model. So one idea I remember you talking about in your book that just blew me out of the water. It was so interesting. Like, it was a Kevin Kelly signature idea, is this idea that you can actually, in the
1:34 Sonal? future, we may be able to, quote, "reverse our attention economy." You should actually explain this idea.
1:41 Speaker 01 Sure, sure. So, the idea is, in some ways, disinterfering attention. So, advertising model is, let's say I am a company, I'm selling a widget, and I want people to know about the widget. I want attention to the widget. So, the normal way is, I will hire advertising agencies, I will make ads that will go out and people will see the ad. So, I'm paying an advertising company, and they're going to make an ad that will then take that attention from the consumer.
2:17 Sonal? Right.
2:18 Speaker 01 But you could actually short-circuit that, rather than having a two-step. What if I paid...
2:26 Speaker 01 The audience directly for their attention.
2:28 Sonal? Exactly.
2:29 Speaker 01 And so, let's say I send a call out and saying, I will pay you 25 cents to watch this ad. So you're getting paid for your attention, to give your attention to an ad. And it's not just ad, it could even be something like email. And so you could set up something saying, I'll charge 25 cents to read your email. So you have to pay me for my attention. And so if it's true that attention is the only scarcity that we have in this world of abundance, how come you and I are giving our attention away for free?
3:09 Sonal? I completely agree, which is why I'm so glad we're finally talking about this. So a couple of quick things. On the example you just gave about email, that's a great example that's commonly cited for a way that we can fight the spam problem. Especially when you think about combining with crypto and blockchain economies, where you can actually do micro-payments in a scalable way. Because right now, it's actually very cost prohibitive to charge someone 25 cents to read their email. And then, if someone is a spammer, it's pretty unlikely that they're gonna do a spray and pray method to try to get your attention, or even a spearfisher, whoever. All the bad economic models of the web get broken, to your point, with this perfect example of email, because the bad actors are not incented to pay for the attention. But I wanna really dig a little deeper,
3:53 Sonal? because your idea is a lot more nuanced. And I really wanna pause the profound implications of what you're saying.
3:59 Speaker 01 So you're putting the power back into the consumer. The power of the attention is with us who have it. We're surrendering it. We're giving away for free when we should really be charging. We wanna have a technology that reverses that, so the power is back with us. And there's a second aspect to that.
4:16 Sonal? Oh, good. This is what I wanna hear.
4:17 Speaker 01 Which is that in media and publications, in that world, the publication, the magazine, the newspaper, whatever that portal is, they don't really have choice about what advertisements they run.
4:34 Speaker 01 That is something that's decided by the advertiser. But what if anybody could run an ad and you would get the benefits of that ad? If people clicked on it, if people watched it. So what you have is you have an outsourced crowd decentralized version of an ad network. Where anybody is making an ad and anywhere anybody can run the ad. And you have the money flowing through the system, again, using crypto to kind of keep or blockchain to keep track of things.
5:08 Sonal? Yep.
5:08 Speaker 01 But what that would mean is that you would have, you would have very, very creative people making ads that worked. And the sponsors have to pay up when people actually watch them. And so what I'm trying to do is to imagine a decentralized advertising system that put power back into the audience.
5:32 Sonal? Yeah.
5:32 Speaker 01 But it would require something like crypto or blockchain.
5:36 Sonal? Yep.
5:36 Speaker 01 To maintain the integrity and to have that financing.
5:40 Sonal? Right, the providence, economics, the alignment of incentives, all the things, all the features.
5:44 Speaker 01 Sending the credit money through as it followed these different things. So that's a possibility that we haven't really thought about before.
5:51 Sonal? I love it, but lest people think this is so far off, because you brought me, you proposed this idea in your book, The Inevitable, which is about the future. And who knows if that's five years, 10 years, 20 years, 100 years. Lest people think that's so far off, let me give a concrete example today.
6:04 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
6:04 Sonal? So TikTok, basically what people are already doing in a de, not necessarily decentralized, but certainly a bottom up manner. Their centralized platform is TikTok.
6:14 Speaker 01 Right.
6:14 Sonal? They are essentially making ads. And these are short viral clips where they are promoting some idea, a product. Because if you think about an ad, it's simply an ad for anything, whether it's a product, an idea, whatever. They're short, they go viral. And the reason they go viral is unlike on YouTube, where the algorithm is very optimized for people who are mature creators, have an established track record, et cetera. Because it's all purely AI-based. It's not basing things on specified intent, but learned intent. It can let anybody, any creator, have a clip go viral, even if they don't have a huge following. And that's hugely powerful. So it's really fascinating is what you're basically describing is kind of already happening with TikTok. And now we just need to put the economic of getting those creators paid. Because the other thing that I think is super interesting about this
6:57 Sonal? is that when you have new models, business models, it then in turn, this is something you and I both care about, changes a creator economy that feeds it. Not only unlocking creators who maybe didn't come out before in the current model, but more importantly, you don't even have to get that big of a scale in order to be successful. It actually ties to your original true idea of 1,000 true fans. But that part of your idea that people don't talk about as much, they don't get past the 1,000 true fans, is that not only do you get the 1,000 true fans, but you get the nodes next to them. So I'd love for you to explain that. And then maybe we can connect the dots between this attention economy back to 1,000 true fans.
7:35 Speaker 01 Just to summarize the 1,000 true fans theory very, very quickly, which is that in the world in which you have direct contact with your audience, and when you're not going through the intermediate of a publisher, the studio, a record label, but you actually have your true, you have your fans that you're getting the money directly from.
7:57 Sonal? Yep.
7:57 Speaker 01 That if you could get a certain amount of money from them directly every year, that the number that you would need to make a living is in the neighborhood of thousands. So 1,000 true fans, if you could get $100 each from one of your, for each of your fans for a year, then that's $100,000. So, and that's what I would call a true fan. Someone who's going to buy whatever you make. You know, the hardcover, the softcover, the singles, the box set. They're going to travel 200 miles to see you. That's your true fan. But that's just your true fans. And your true fans become basically marketers for this other concentric circle around them, which is kind of the casual fan. And so it's your true fans who actually are doing
8:41 Speaker 01 the hard work of publicizing.
8:44 Sonal? Evangelizing even.
8:45 Speaker 01 Promoting you to this other larger, even larger one. So you get the income not just of your true fans, but you get the larger income of that.
8:53 Sonal? That concentric circle that's right next to it.
8:56 Speaker 01 Casual fans around you. And the other aspect of 1,000 true fans is that in a world of a billion, now that we are global and we have a global system. Even if there's only one in a million people who are interested in your idea, you still have a thousand potential people.
9:11 Sonal? Yes.
9:11 Speaker 01 You just have to find them.
9:12 Sonal? Yeah.
9:12 Speaker 01 So there's almost any idea you could come up with, anything that you can imagine, can probably find a thousand people on the planet.
9:21 Sonal? Yep.
9:21 Speaker 01 To be true fans of it. And so that process of finding your true fans is really the process that we want to use. And we want to have tools that enable us to do that easier and easier.
9:32 Sonal? Yeah. You wrote about 1,000 true fans in what year was it again?
9:36 Speaker 01 Gee, it was right before, it was before Kickstarter. It was probably like, I don't know, 2007 or something.
9:41 Sonal? It was very prescient as always, so it was very early. Then Chris Anderson, our mutual friend, wrote The Long Tail around, either before or after that, I'm forgetting when he wrote that, 2006 is I think when that book was.
9:52 Speaker 01 I think he wrote before.
9:53 Sonal? Right. And that, and the idea of The Long Tail is that the internet lets you find these niche communities. So that goes to the discovery aspect and you can actually create communities around niches. Then you wrote 1,000 true fans. And now today, we're talking about this idea of monetizing and reversing the attention economy. What I'm hearing you say when we connect all those dots is that we now finally have a business model for those 1,000 true fans to monetize because what readers are essentially doing, if you imagine a world where the reader is at the center of a future media web, where there's a million publications like this and whatever, forum, podcast, newsletter, blog post, doesn't matter, you know, decks, whatever. We now have a way and add crypto in for an economic internet that empowers creators
10:36 Sonal? of all kinds to now empower readers to monetize their attention and essentially curate their custom personalized, perfectly curated, dream holy grail paper of their choice, but that be printed on demand by selling their attention.
10:52 Speaker 01 I even had another idea that I think was patentable. Patents don't give you much, so I decided to publish it instead of patenting it. And it was called, I'll Pay You to Read My Book.
11:02 Sonal? Tell me more about this. I've never heard this.
11:04 Speaker 01 So the problem with books these days is I don't care about selling books. I want people to read my books. And it's so, attention is so, so scarce that I said, oh, look, I'll pay you to read my book and I'm gonna make money doing it.
11:19 Sonal? How?
11:20 Speaker 01 Here. So it's an ebook. And what it is, is I'll sell the book. For, let's say, $4. And then I will pay you $5 if you finish reading the book. And we can tell, Amazon can tell, whether you've read the whole book or not.
11:36 Sonal? Right, they have, they already have that data.
11:37 Speaker 01 Right. And so, most people probably won't finish it. And so, I think the total amount that I would make would exceed the amount that I have to pay out. So, there'd probably be fewer people who are gonna finish it.
11:48 Sonal? Interesting.
11:49 Speaker 01 And so, I could, I could adjust those numbers. But I would sell it for very little and I would pay you if you actually finish reading it. So, the idea is, I'm paying for your attention.
11:57 Sonal? Yes, you are. The completeness of the attention. Because what I love is that you're not saying it's an either or, a binary yes/no.
12:03 Speaker 01 Right, right.
12:03 Sonal? It's actually a degree. What I love about this is, A, it very much, it very much fits into a world we're entering now, where there is no discrete beginning and end. Like Doug Rushkoff and I talked about narrative collapse, you know? Like, in one of the op-eds I did for me at Wired. In this world of Game of Thrones, binge-watching, the everlasting story, gaming economies, gaming narratives. And we just talked today about how gaming is bigger than music and entertainment, film combined. Huge economies, and those narratives are endless narratives.
12:33 Speaker 01 Right.
12:34 Sonal? So, what I love about what you're saying is essentially it's a way to optimize for the few rare completers, while also making money off the people who are dipping in and out and not gonna complete the thing. So, it puts it on a degree and kind of a continuum. But the second thing that I love about it is that if you, this is a crazy counterintuitive part of this, if your idea and your book is so damn good that people are gonna read the entire thing, you're actually gonna pay them a lot more. Because you're paying them a dollar extra to make this happen. And so, tell me about that, the flip side of it. Does it actually make creators not wanna? Because one thing that Connie's talked about in China is that there's actually apps that let people, readers weigh in on books as they're being created. And that then in turn changes a narrative or how many chapters. This reminds me of the Charles Dickens and day of like, paying by word.
13:19 Speaker 01 So the reality is that very few people make real money from books. I don't make a living from books. I make my living from giving talks about the book.
13:28 Sonal? So the book is like a vehicle for the container for the idea.
13:30 Speaker 01 That's true for more and more people. The actual book itself is just a part of this network. And so you can still lose money on a book, and many authors do, and still make overall. It's particularly important when you are talking about ideas. Maybe this doesn't work if you're just writing novels.
13:47 Sonal? Yes.
13:48 Speaker 01 But if you're trying to get ideas out.
13:49 Sonal? This is what we both care about more than anything.
13:51 Speaker 01 Then, again, the battle for attention is so great that I am willing to pay you for your attention. By the way, one thing I also about attention is I did these calculations of the total amount of attention that are given to different media. And I found out that on average, we surrender our attention for about $3 an hour.
14:13 Sonal? Wow, that's so cheap.
14:15 Speaker 01 That's so true. So I looked at the total amount of time that you spend reading a book and how much you can charge, how much you pay for the book, for a movie, for whatever it is. And it comes out to very, very low pay that we are accepting for our attention.
14:31 Sonal? It's insane.
14:32 Speaker 01 That we value our attention at. And so, you know, and when TV, TV is, if you take all the amount of hours that people watch TV and the total amount of revenue of TV, that's what it come out to be.
14:44 Sonal? Yeah.
14:44 Speaker 01 It's like, we're giving up our attention for such small wages. So we really want to be charging more.
14:50 Sonal? Well, what I love about this is it puts, again, people at the center. And what I love about what you're saying is this is a way to be optimistic about the future, that readers and creators can be empowered by putting better models in place that align incentives, that remove adverse selection and bad alignment of incentives, that we can actually embrace a better future.
15:11 Speaker 01 Right, right.
15:11 Sonal? So thank you for joining this episode of the A66 Podcast.
15:14 Speaker 01 And if we were really doing things, we would be paying you, listener, right now.
15:18 Sonal? The listener.
15:19 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:19 Sonal? That's fantastic, listeners. We need to be paying you. Thank you so much for listening. Kevin, thank you so much for joining the A66 Podcast live from the Andreessen Horowitz Annual Innovation Summit. The future is inevitable.
15:29 Speaker 01 Good, good.
Previous Writers Writing, Readers Reading, Creators Creating Next All about the Coronavirus Page updated September 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated