Pod Insights a16z Podcast The China Threat: Silicon Valley and the Great Uncoupling About this episode Representatives Mike Gallagher (R-WI) and Jake Auchincloss (D-MA) discuss why the United States must strengthen its technological advantage in areas like AI, develop next-generation manufacturing capabilities domestically, and rethink how Silicon Valley does business with China. Gallagher is Chair of the House Select Committee on the CCP, on which Auchincloss also serves.
To learn more about the American Dynamism Summit, visit our website at a16z.com/ad-summit.
Visit the full playlist: https://bit.ly/3IqWn1W
Transcript 0:09 Speaker 2 The China threat, and this is an audience that would know it well, is a very broad topic, uh, spanning from an app that might be on some people's phones in the room called TikTok to Taiwan. Um what is the scope of the issue as you see it, and what should we be most concerned about? Big question. We'll start with you, Congressman Gallagher.
0:26 Speaker 0 Uh well, first of all, thank you for having me. Thanks uh uh uh to all of uh uh you for being part of this. I see a lot of friendly face I can't really see, but I think I see some friendly faces in the audience. Lots of
0:36 Speaker 2 friendly faces.
0:36 Speaker 0 And some enemies too. I see a lot of enemies, which is good. It means I'm doing something right. Um I think to take your second question first, the risk in simplest terms from China is war, right? And we tend to discount the possibility that Xi Jinping could do something as stupid as try to take Taiwan by force because it does look irrational from a Western perspective. But if the collapse of deterrence in Ukraine has taught us anything, it's that particularly when you're dealing with autocratic systems who just don't have robust feedback loops, they could do something that looks irrational from our perspective, that we think is deterred or deterrable, and yet from their perspective of preserving the regime makes sense. And so my concern is that despite what's happening in Ukraine, despite the fact that the system is blinking red across the world, despite the erosion of the conventional balance of power, particularly in the Indo-Pacific, we are still, we still have not fielded the deterrence by denial posture that makes absolutely no sense.
1:36 Speaker 0 And if you look at what just happened in Jordan, right? This is something that should have been obvious to anybody that watched the Iranian attack on the Saudi oil facility a few years ago, the Ocaque oil facility. The Army can't do its one JRock, it's one joint function, which is defense for our expeditionary bases against missiles and drones like this. We're on the wrong side of the cost curve. Look at all the SM6s we've expended in the Red Sea right now. We haven't moved to maximum production rates of long-range precision fire. So beyond all the talk about decoupling and ideological warfare and TikTok, if we don't get the hard power side of the equation right, we may stumble into war on someone else's terms, and it's going to be horrific. It will look the current, it will make the current crises in the Middle East and Ukraine look like child's play in comparison.
2:25 Speaker 0 Other than that, I'm an optimist.
2:28 Speaker 2 Congressman Aukenklas, I'd love to hear your take on it.
2:30 Speaker 1 Yeah, I appreciate the chance to be here, and it's good to be here with the chairman of the of the China Select Committee. Uh I think America is gonna outcompete China. I think we're gonna win this contest if we want to. And those are the four words that I spend a lot of time thinking about. If we want to. Because the competition between America and China is a competition of worldviews. China views individuals as pawns of the state. The United States was founded upon the timeless ideal that individuals have inherent worth and value. And those are mutually inconsistent ways of approaching governance, of approaching economics, of approaching diplomacy and and uh great power competition, and we must win. And we can if we want to. And the reason I am concerned about if we want to, is that we are seeing increasing uh antibodies against the free and open society upon which the United States is premised.
3:25 Speaker 1 We're seeing on the on the right, this blood and soil nationalism, obviously articulated by Donald Trump, that is fundamentally about closing America off. And we see on the hard left uh a rejection of Western society and what it represents from the enlightenment onwards. And both of those are wrong. There is much for us to be proud of in uh what Western society has produced, and much of it has been crystallized in the US form of government, and we should fight for it. Uh, but we should also fight for it, not as a blood and soil idea, but as the American creed that uh every individual, regardless of the circumstances of their birth, should be free to pursue their aspirations in life.
4:06 Speaker 2 Yeah. So one thing from the outside looking in, it seems like there is bipartisan support, uh, agreement around how important this issue is. I'm sure there's some sparring internally. It would be great to understand where you two are in alignment where where there's consensus on the committee, and then what are the the major points of disagreement?
4:24 Speaker 1 Yeah. We're laughing because this morning uh there's a little bit of fisticuffs on the committee. I heard. Uh I'll let the chairman
4:33 Speaker 0 start
4:34 Speaker 1 though.
4:35 Speaker 0 Uh well, I do think it gets to like maybe something like we are trying to do our committee's work amidst what is a very fractious uh political environment, right? And I I'm I have yet to meet sort of like the person who's enthusiastic about this Trump v. Biden rematch. And so there is like a big black hole that is the 2024 election sucking everything into its wake. And that is a challenge. It's a challenge to get anything done in Congress uh on a good day. I do think, and the last year of our committee's work uh proves this, that there is broad agreement that uh on the nature of the threat, uh, that we must do something about it, that we're not attacking it with a sense of urgency. When it comes to um, I think the sort of military aspect of the competition, I actually think there's more agreement than disagreement.
5:22 Speaker 0 Um the ideological uh aspect of the competition, there's disagreement within the Republican Party on to what what priority do you give ideological uh warfare? I give it a high priority, largely because Xi Jinping uh seems to think it's important. Having studied the collapse of the Soviet Union, he concluded that the main problem was insufficient commitment to ideology, and part of the reason we won the old Cold War is because Reagan was quite good at ideological warfare. Uh but on the economic side, I actually don't think it's like it's a clear Republicans have an approach, Democrats have an approach. There's weird bedfellows. Uh and I think Jake and I would agree on the fact, and he's actually one of the the loudest voices in his party for a pro, correct me if I'm wrong, a pro-trade agenda.
6:09 Speaker 0 And though we had somewhat of a disagreement about whether to revoke permanent normal trade relations with China, I think yes, Jake thinks no. I think we agree on the idea that as we adopt a more competitive economic relationship with China economically. Um, we need to be enhancing intensifying our economic and technological partnerships with the rest of the world and assume some intelligent risks. And I do think the absence of a trade agenda uh is a huge grand strategic gap for both parties right now, if that makes sense. Just one, I think the primary point of disagreement sometimes is on the relative prioritization of climate change in the relationship with China, uh, as well as the prospect uh of engagement with the CCP at the highest levels, what that might yield.
6:54 Speaker 0 I'm more skeptical of that than some of my my diplom my democratic uh friends.
6:59 Speaker 1 I agree that it's not always Democrat versus Republican where there's disagreements, and I think the the sort of uh productive dissent that I try to add into the committee uh is we spend a lot of time focusing on uh competition with China that can be zero sum. It's about export controls, it is about restrictions on licensing, it is about tariffs, obviously, it is about uh uh playing keep away with intellectual property. And there is a place for that, and it's important. But ultimately, I think in the Sino-American competition, 90% of the questions that matter are about America, not about China. China's got 1.4 billion people, they are a highly motivated, well-educated workforce. They're gonna create a bunch of impressive stuff. And the questions that I find most impactful for our future are about are we investing in basic research and development?
7:49 Speaker 1 Are we in are we trying to attract uh high-skilled and frankly low-skilled immigration to the US economy, which keeps us dynamic? Do we have rule of law and contract enforcement? Are we investing in quality infrastructure, like the boring stuff that we should be focused on before Washington gets distracted by like quantum strategy? And my contention is we're here in Washington, we're not doing a good enough job on the boring stuff. We should take care of that. We should be asking ourselves hey, in the latest PISA tests program for international student assessment, American 15-year-olds went backwards on math scores. That is what should be animating us, because if American 15-year-olds can't do math, we're not out of competing anybody. I don't care what our what our semiconductor strategy is.
8:36 Speaker 2 Yeah. Yeah. Well, speaking of semiconductor strategy, I mean, that is one thing that is top of mind for this audience, for our founders, chip production, you know, it it is it is something that if it is catastrophically disrupted. Um, I would love to hear how you're thinking about worst-case scenario, you know, how how you even think about how to respond if something like that were to come to pass in Taiwan.
8:53 Speaker 0 Specifically with Taiwan. Well, I guess one of the reasons, though it's not the only reason uh that Taiwan is important, because if there was even a blockade scenario that played out, it would be profoundly disruptive to the global economy. I mean, you're talking trillions of dollars lost in even the low-end modeling for something like this. And then if they were somehow able to take Taiwan, which admittedly is a very hard problem, just from a pure like invading an island and doing an amphibious assault is a hard problem. Jake's a Marine, I'm a Marine. This is something that we are uh we are we are raised to understand. Zach Shore uh is a Marine, I think, although he was mostly drinking the entire time with me. We were roommates in Carlsbad. Luckily, Facebook had just started, so none of it's online.
9:38 Speaker 0 So just sneaked under the radar. Yeah. Good bless. It's it's mutually assured destruction, bro. So you
9:44 Speaker 1 launch your missiles.
9:45 Speaker 0 I'm watching mine. Um so uh and I also think maybe the conceptual mistake we made with the CHIPS Act, uh, and I know there's disagreement about the CHIPS Act, is that um we need By onshoring onshoring production of semiconductors to America, it would somehow enhance deterrence. But I wonder if the opposite could be true, right? The more we onshore, the less relevant Taiwan is, and therefore the more attractive of a target is, or just as a question of investment, would it have been better to fund a SHIPS Act in order to make an invasion uh impossible, if not highly unlikely, because even if they don't establish a lodgement in an invasion, it's gonna massively muck up the entire global economy. But the economic reason is not the only reason Taiwan is important.
10:33 Speaker 0 If Taiwan falls, it will make our ability to fulfill our treaty commitments with Japan and the Philippines impossible. Las Vegas rules do not apply. What happens there will not stay there. And though we've had a brutal, and this is the third reason debate about the nature and role of democracy promotion in American foreign policy. There's something different in my mind about fending an existing vibrant democracy from an authoritarian threat that if America doesn't stand for that, I'm just not sure what we stand for. So we should also stand for Ukraine. Agree. Yeah. Let's do it. Tell your speaker. I will stand right now for you.
11:13 Speaker 2 So one thing that's that's also on the agenda for this week, and I know we're jumping around a lot, but you all cover such breadth on the committee, um, is you're holding the CCC cyber threat um to the homeland and national security um uh hearing tomorrow. Most citizens, when they think about cyber threats until recently, they didn't think about attacks on critical infrastructure, things that could take out the power grid by nation states. What you've learned about these threats, what how do you assure the American people that things are going to be all right? Or or is it actually a uh a bad scenario that we should be very concerned about as citizens?
11:45 Speaker 1 Uh it's a it's a legitimate threat, and we need to harden our targets, electoral systems, public water supplies, um utilities. They've made big strides in the last five years, and it's been a bipartisan issue under uh uh CISA and Homeland Security to make themselves harder targets, a source of good jobs for young people as well. Massachusetts has created a lot of good cybersecurity certificates around this area. But actually the the sort of digital threat I'm by far the most concerned about is is TikTok. We are ceding the ideological ground to our adversary to inculcate the next generation of Americans into a worldview that uh is really I think antithetical to a lot of what we stand for. And and the chairman has been articulate about this and in the free press, which I read your essay on that. Oh wow, thank you.
12:30 Speaker 1 Uh we have I think read all your stuff too. I think we've got to force the sale. I just don't think we would never have allowed CBS, ABC, NBC to be owned by the Soviet Union in the 1960s. And that is, I think, if anything, understating the degree of influence that we are seeding right now. And that's not a speech issue. You can post whatever you want. It's a question of reach. Just because we honor and respect the First Amendment does not mean that we have to allow our biggest adversary to control in a black box an algorithm that influences hundreds of millions of people. That is not free speech. That is the control over reach. Yeah. And
13:06 Speaker 0 go ahead. I just want to foot stomp that and say, yes, there's a concern with TikTok that it can track your location and uh your your browser history. That's a huge problem for Zach in particular. Uh but that's not the primary threat. And Jake, I think said it well. I mean, to to allow a company uh that is owned by ByteDance, which is beholden to the Chinese Communist Party to be the dominant news platform for the next generation of Americans, I think I think borders on national suicide. And by the way, if you are invested in ByteDance, I would assume you want TikTok to go public in America. Uh that's not gonna happen under the current ownership structure. So it is in your interest for there to be a complete separation where none of the plumbing is connected and an American company controls uh TikTok US and doing does doing things and there's control of the algorithm.
13:54 Speaker 0 So, and just one final note on cyber, I do think having chaired the Cyberspace Celarium Commission, beyond all the fancy things we can do, like giving CISA the ability to do threat hunting on.gov networks, I think it all just comes down to human beings, right? Our biggest threats are human threats, a contractor doing something they shouldn't do, and our successes will be a function of our ability to get the best in the brightest in cyber to work with DoD and the federal government.
14:20 Speaker 2 Yeah. Now speaking of TikTok, I mean, many are concerned about the way that the tech community engaged with China in previous decades, how it engages now. What are your thoughts about the right way that technologists that companies should be engaging with China on a host of issues?
14:34 Speaker 0 Listen, I I don't think anyone expects, you know, Andreessen or some tech company to be the State Department. But I mean, if if social justice or ESG is a big deal for you and your employees, I just would ask you to recognize that there's no worse ESG actor and no greater offender of social justice issues than the Chinese Communist Party. They suck on the E, the S, and they really suck on the G. Uh the G stands for anything, it's to stand for genocide. So speak up. Uh we're
15:06 Speaker 1 asking American companies to act like American companies.
15:12 Speaker 0 I mean, listen, Jake Jake mentioned an issue that I I think you'd think there's no agreement on immigration and listen, immigration politics, speaking of things that suck, they really suck. Uh but I wonder if our framework is actually the same, right? Like make it difficult, if not impossible, for people to come here illegally. But when it comes to legal immigration, modernize the system where it could scale up or down depending on the needs of our economy, and then when it comes to high high skilled immigration, and you want all these smart people, like we should actively be on a recruiting mission around the world to scoop up the best and the bright. Oh, I'm gonna.
15:45 Speaker 1 Guys, don't applaud that from him because I'm gonna throw a red flag on that plate because we do have a Republican uh talking about immigration reform when things are so well. Yeah, Speaker Johnson, I mean, we'll get Speaker Johnson and Mitch McConnell saying the quiet part are loud here, which is that they'd rather campaign on immigration than govern on it. And you know, that's not you, Mike saying that, but at a certain point, the Republican Party is gonna own the fact that for 20 years they've been telling the American people that immigration is broken. We have in good faith a bill to start fixing it, and the speaker has said it's dead on arrival.
16:19 Speaker 0 Do we have the bill? I'm actually not this isn't like a rebuttal. I don't. I people keep asking me about the deal. I just don't know what the deal is. I haven't seen it. I was on Fox News on
16:27 Speaker 1 Saturday, and as far as Fox News is concerned, it is anathema. Yeah. And it's because it
16:34 Speaker 0 says we can't vote on it. You've
16:35 Speaker 1 got Senator McConnell killing it, you've got Speaker Johnson killing it. Damn you, Lochlin Murdoch. We agree we have we have overlap on the policy, but on the politics, I I just I do feel like one side is serious about it and the other side has not been as serious about it. Yeah, well,
16:48 Speaker 2 moving to a more hopeful note. Um, you know, 10 years ago, 10 years ago, um, you know, when I first moved to Silicon Valley, no one was talking about China. I would actually say even five years ago, no one was talking about China. I would love to hear from your perspective. You know, we we have a number of great founders where that is the focal point of their business now. It is top of mind for engineers and for founders in Silicon Valley. How have you experienced that shift with Silicon Valley? And do you think it's making real progress in in the eyes of what you're what you're building towards as well.
17:17 Speaker 1 I might actually put that question back on you. I mean, you're the one running the American dynamism portfolio, and and I I would imagine that the spectrum of China has galvanized some of the entrepreneurs that you work with to want to work with the United States government, which is not a particularly fun customer to have to deal with, but they've said if we're serious about being in the 21st century what we became in the 20s century, the the guarantor of the Pax Americana and the shining light, uh, we have to do housing, we have to do military, we we gotta do utilities, we gotta do energy, all the stuff that I think in the first uh boom out of Silicon Valley was really overlooked. Uh so I think that's inspiring, and I would just encourage everyone here to uh to keep pushing the US government to be a better customer.
18:02 Speaker 1 And I say this all the time to the Department of Defense. We do not need the Department of Defense to be a venture capitalist, we don't need it to be an equities investor. We need the Department of Defense to be a good, reliable, expeditious customer. And until they get that right, I don't think we're gonna fully realize the possibilities of your portfolio. Oh
18:24 Speaker 0 yeah, I'll just I'll just quickly here I'm actually cautiously optimistic here, and it's not just because we now have I've always wanted to do like a time-lapse photo of the like the banner of sponsors at the Reagan National Defense Forum. And I actually think it tells like a good story about new and interesting companies who want to work with DOD.
18:42 Speaker 2 Or at
18:42 Speaker 0 least want to hang out with me for two days at Reagan. Um we've had outspoken voices, obviously, who I think are great, like Dr. Carpet Palantir, like Palmer Lucky, uh who's busy here, is he wearing shoes? Uh not this year, it
18:55 Speaker 2 was here last year.
18:56 Speaker 0 Andrew. Um but I think there's more people that want to get in that game and want to try and break down the barriers to working with DOD. And it is ultimately, however, to Jake's point, gonna take DoD actually making big bets on a few companies that are non-primes, because we just keep admiring the valley of death problem. And that that's the sort of the less hopeful side of the equation. If you go to Reagan, almost every year the secretary comes, it doesn't matter if it was Mattis or now Austin, it kind of gives the same speech about we're gonna cross the valley of death and this and that, and that's where we just need to appropriate money to DOD, right? We're talking about a supplemental right now. What are we supplementing? We haven't actually passed the DOD appropriation, and then we have to force DOD to make big bets on things.
19:41 Speaker 0 And then we in Congress have to make sure that if some of those bets don't work out, which they all won't, that we won't just rake them over the coals. We need to celebrate original mistakes while vilifying and demonizing making the same mistakes over and over again.
19:56 Speaker 2 So this is a question. This is a question that's gonna allow our our audience to dream. But if there were a President Aachenklas or a President Gallagher, how would that administration address the relationship with China and technology differently? Would it be different? What would you tack do tactically?
20:12 Speaker 0 Well, Jake and I are here today to announce.
20:20 Speaker 0 I would love to be president of an obscure liberal arts university. Actually, the politics of that would be
20:27 Speaker 1 brutal.
20:29 Speaker 0 Yeah, well,
20:29 Speaker 1 you want to tackle that first? If I if I were president, how would I tackle the US-China technological relationship? Yeah,
20:35 Speaker 2 is there something tactical you would do on day one?
20:38 Speaker 1 So, and this is I think a a uh a point of I think uh of genuine maybe intellectual disagreement here. Jake Sullivan has talked about a a uh a small garden with a high fence and this idea that there are some things that we're gonna protect with all measures available. Um I would be I would be a little bit tougher on how we describe that garden than I think uh the current approach is because I worry that it becomes really an excuse for uh for lobbying, frankly, where every industry comes and tells us how strategic they are and ultimately it actually makes our economy more sclerotic and less dynamic. I would I'm I'm persuaded that cutting-edge semiconductors belong in that garden. I have not been persuaded of basically anything else.
21:25 Speaker 1 I believe in markets that have global access, particularly for high RD, high fixed cost industries that are so important for our future, utilities, biotech, uh semiconductors, etc. And so I I really I want to see the maintenance and expansion of the US operating system as a global commercial entity.
21:45 Speaker 0 So I would, and I actually do think this is, and I Jake's uh dissent uh on some of our our uh econ recommendations was was productive. I think it made the final product better, and I respect his position. I would cut off the flow of US capital, both passive and active, public and private, to a greater number of sectors. I think a sector-specific set of guardrails is actually much easier to implement than the multi-list whack-a-mole we currently play right now, which is a total shambles. And so we have trilli billions, probably hundreds of billions of dollars, American dollars that are flowing into Chinese technology and military companies that are building things like aircraft carriers, artillery shells, fighter jets, things that are designed to kill Americans in a future conflict, and I think that's perverse. I think we should close the loopholes for licensing exemptions.
22:31 Speaker 0 Like right now, uh Huawei is off the mat. It's coming back with SMIC semiconductors in part because they still have access to US technology, right? We're funding our own destruction. To me, uh it's crazy. I would tighten up our Cipheus loopholes so that people can't buy land, for example, near military bases or critical infrastructure. But, and maybe this is where we agree on the positive side. I've long argued for we need a uh a gold standard free trade agreement with the UK post-Brexit that could have a docking provision that other countries could join. When it comes to AUKUS, I give the Biden administration a ton of credit for AUKUS, but in some ways the most important part of AUKUS is not the pillar one nuclear sub thing, which we could screw that up. We should not screw that up. That's a big deal. We need to build more subs. 2.5 Virginians a year. Let's do that.
23:16 Speaker 0 Uh pillar two on the technology side, we still have all these outdated barriers to cooperation with the Aussies and the Brits, our closest allies. Who doesn't love the Aussies and the Brits? Because of ITAR regulation, we can't share our best technology and people. That's a huge own goal. I would be for a digital trade agreement. Like we have IPEF, which is our only trade thing in Indopaycom is not a real thing. And it's less of a real thing now that they've neutered IPEF, and it was neutered to start with. So I think again, to get to the basic balance, I would adopt a more restrictive framework with respect to China and our bilateral relationship, but in return and simultaneously, I would deepen our engagement with other countries and assume some intelligent risk in the rest of the world. Yeah.
23:58 Speaker 2 So I want to end with a personal question from my 88-year-old aunt in Chicago. Uh I sent her a couple months ago, I sent her a video of Palmer Lucky, and she called me, very upset, said, Katie, I didn't know that I needed to be worried about China too. And I think that's something that a lot of Americans feel. The world feels like it's on fire. It feels like another thing that they have to worry about. The work you're doing, what can you tell my 88-year-old aunt and other Americans that would assuage their fears and make them feel like we're on the right course on the China threat.
24:27 Speaker 0 Well, don't be sending your grandma Palmer like that.
24:29 Speaker 2 I really shouldn't have done. I regret it, I sure. 88-year-old aunt, but yeah, I shouldn't have done it. I should have done that. Mr.
24:34 Speaker 0 Palmer since his grandmother. I'll give you a hopeful uh story that happened this week uh in my district. And I think it gets to sort of the generational, she's part of the greatest generation. The boomers screwed it up, they continue to screw it up. There should be no boomers allowed to run for president ever. Uh Although Biden's not a boomer. He's so old, he's not a boomer. Silent. He's a member of the greatest generation. Or the silent generation. Silent generation. He's older than the People's Republic of China, if you can believe it. Uh true. Fact check me. Fact check. Uh okay, so I we had a we had an event in my district like six years ago. I was a new member of Congress. We dedicated this fitness trail that uh an army general would pass away unexpectedly, his widow raised the money. It's beautiful thing. This girl came up to me, she was in eighth grade at the time, raised by her grandparents, Shauna, Wisconsin, rural area, and she's like, you know what?
25:25 Speaker 0 This event has so inspired me, and General Cohn's example inspired me. Like, I want to go to a service academy one day. Well, on Wednesday this week, I'm gonna get a little choked up. Uh I'm not. Uh uh sh I got to tell this young lady that she got an appointment to the United States Naval Academy. Just like incredible young American, like man. It's awesome. So there's still humans like that in America,
25:46 Speaker 1 Patriots. Yeah, uh, he stole my answer. I would tell her to join me on my phone calls, telling young people they got appointed to the service academies. You read those resumes, you look at their achievements, and then you talk to them about why they want to why they want to serve and it is restorative for your sense of optimism. Um tell her to come knock doors with me in in my district, and you find talking to the average American, there's a deep reservoir of common sense and decency that in aggregate gives me great hope that uh America is a land of possibilities and don't bet against us. Yeah. Congressman Aachenklas, Gallagher,
26:20 Speaker 2 this is a lot of fun. I'll say
Previous What is American Dynamism? Next From Silicon Valley to the Pentagon: The Future of Defense Innovation Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated