Pod Insights a16z Podcast Of Emojis and Innovation About this episode with @fredbenenson @jenny8lee and @smc90
A whole new set of emojis are about to hit people's phone within a month, but that's not the only reason we're re-running this popular (and defining!) episode of the a16z Podcast from 2015. It's an evergreen classic, that is really about how innovation works -- from the politics and economics of creativity, to the design and governance of social communication systems, and much more...
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Sonal? Hi, everyone. Welcome to the A6 and Z podcast. I'm Sonal. This week, we're resurfacing one of our favorite episodes of all time, all about emojis. It's timely, not just because a whole new set of emojis are about to hit many people's phones soon, but because the episode, which was actually first recorded in 2015, is really an evergreen and broader conversation about how innovation comes about, because we cover the tension between open standards versus closed and proprietary systems, the economics of creativity, the governance and politics of design, and much more. We began with a brief tour of different emoji and how they came about, where emoji fit in the taxonomy of visual and social communication, and why that matters, especially when it comes to machines reading emotions.
0:43 Sonal? And finally, we talk about the ambiguities and difficulties to translating emoji when it's not really meant to be a language. Our guests are Fred Benenson, who was the second employee at Kickstarter and VP of their data. He also famously Kickstartered a project to translate Moby Dick entirely into emoji. And Jenny Aitli, former New York Times reporter, who was a member and is now vice chair of the Unicode Emoji Subcommittee. She first led the effort to get the dumpling emoji, which is where we briefly start this conversation.
1:14 Speaker 01 I wasn't a really big emoji user. In fact, the first time I ever heard of emoji was when Fred started his Kickstarter called Emoji Dick. And I was like, what the fuck are emojis? This is before they showed up on our iPhones, like perky little yellow faces. I was like, what? It's like, sounds something very bizarre.
1:31 Sonal? I just started. I didn't even actually, just to be blunt, I had a very hard time using emoji because I didn't quite understand how to even frankly use them. I don't understand when people send it to me, if it's not the obvious heart, you know, et cetera. But as I've been using it more, I've found myself sort of expressing myself now in kind of quirky ways. And I don't know if people really get it or not, but I'm getting a kick out of it.
1:50 Speaker 01 That's the fun of the ambiguity.
1:53 Speaker 02 I have a friend who showed me an exchange between a friend of his, who was dating a guy, and he would only send her emoji. And she was like, I just can't, I can't handle this. And he showed me the screenshots of their exchange, and it was hilarious.
2:05 Speaker 01 You're helping translate?
2:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, and so like, I was like, oh.
2:08 Sonal? You're like the sort of De Burgeurac of like emojis.
2:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, I was like, this is what this feeds.
2:11 Speaker 01 I can definitely see it being like, sort of a irreconcilable difference between people and relationships.
2:17 Speaker 02 Significant.
2:17 Speaker 01 Fast forward many, many years, emoji have showed up on our iPhone. And I'm texting with my friend Ying Lu, who's best known as the designer of the Twitter Fail Well. So we're texting back and forth about like dumplings. And so I send her a picture of the dumplings I'm making. And then she texts me back, knife and fork, knife and fork, yum, yum, yum, yum, yum. And she goes, wait, Apple doesn't have a dumpling emoji. I was like, how could that be? I was like, because there's so many obscure Japanese food emojis. And some emoji are from Japan. Like you have, you know, everything ranging from ramen to curry rice to tempura, to like the, you know, the rice thingies on a stick. To even, there's even the like triangle rice ball that looks like it had a bikini wax.
2:54 Speaker 02 Right. There's also the, the fish cake, which is the white one with the, with the purple swirl.
2:59 Speaker 01 Totally, right? And I was like, how could there not be dumplings? Right? Because it's such a universal food, right? Because there's like pierogies in Poland and momos and, you know, kiosa and empanadas. Like, it's just like a food from around the world. I mean, technically, samosa is a dumpling. Yeah, samosa, ravioli. And I was like, okay, emoji are universal. And then dumplings are universal. How could there not be a dumpling emoji? And just in my mind, I was just like, clearly, whatever system in place has failed. How do you solve a problem like the dumpling emoji? Yeah, and I found out that emoji are regulated by the Unicode Consortium, which is a nonprofit organization based in Mountain View, California.
3:41 Speaker 01 It now has 12 full voting members that pay $18,000 a year to, to vote on issues, including like emoji and other kind of like technical numbers. Are all those members in Mountain View or from around the world? So of those 12, nine are US multinational tech companies. Oracle, IBM, Google, Yahoo, Adobe, Facebook, Microsoft, and Symantec. Then of the other three full voting members, one is the German software company SAP, another is the Chinese telecom company Huawei, and the last is the government of Oman. That's a really interesting crew. It's an interesting crew. And they have these quarterly meetings. And then I just show up and they're, you know, very welcoming. You know, they're like, you know, thank you for coming. What brings you here? Tell us about yourself. It felt like showing up at church.
4:26 Speaker 01 Like a new church, you're a new member, they all knew each other very well. They're very excited that there's like someone, you know, young and like diverse that is like just like randomly showing up. And so I, in that process, learned how you get emoji passed and how they're regulated. And so in January of 2016, we submitted a full proposal for dumplings, takeout box, chopsticks and fortune cookies and got those all passed. So those will be in Unicode 10, which means that that's announced in June of 2017. And so they'll actually hit your phones several months after that. I was like, wow, billions of keyboards will be impacted by this.
5:01 Sonal? That's amazing. Were there other proposals submitted at the time?
5:04 Speaker 02 Oh, they're constant proposals. There's this whole process that people like Jenny, some of them make it through.
5:10 Speaker 01 It's a lot of work.
5:11 Sonal? It does introduce some good useful bars, actually, for making sure quality gets through.
5:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, and to their credit, the Unicode Consortium has an amazing list of emoji criteria where they say, okay, here's what we're looking for for emoji. It's got to have like, you know, kind of a unique meaning in that it's not covered by other stuff, but it also should have like, you know, some ambiguity. So it's not just like literally one thing, it could be used in other contexts.
5:33 Speaker 01 Also, there's one of the more interesting rules, which is no celebrities, deities or logos.
5:39 Speaker 02 Whoa, the Easter Island head is kind of a violation of that one, but that's got its own story. A couple of years ago, with a big update, the Easter Island head showed up in like the back of the travel section of emoji. And I was like, what is that doing there? Who's traveling to Easter Island so often that they need to use the Easter Island head emoji? And it kind of just stuck in my mind. And then I started using it in this kind of like slightly culturally insensitive way to like reference some supernatural phenomenon that I didn't understand, right? Like if I was in a conversation with somebody and I was just like completely flummoxed, I'd just like send that one.
6:09 Sonal? Yeah, it's like your version of Bermuda Triangle.
6:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, I was just like, who knows? Stone face. Other people use it for like stoned, right? Like, there's lots of combinations in there. The reason why it's in there is that there's a statue in downtown Tokyo, I think it's a Shibuya station, that is called Moyai, which is a name of just like, it's a proper noun of that statue, which was made by an artist that was like a reference to originally Easter Island head. So it turns out Japanese teenagers use this waypoint to meet each other. And so that's how it ended up in Japanese cell phones, and that's why it ended up in emoji. The artists used this inspiration of Easter Island. The interesting twist is that when you look at it on the iPhone, it doesn't look anything like the statue in Tokyo. At some point, Apple was like, we're not going to make it.
6:54 Speaker 02 Like this Tokyo one, we're gonna do the original one. Android, on the other hand, their moai emoji looks like the Tokyo Station one.
7:03 Sonal? So fascinating. I read a study, I actually included in our newsletter months ago, of someone comparing how emojis look on different platforms and how it actually changes meaning.
7:11 Speaker 01 Totally.
7:12 Sonal? Because you can actually think you're sending one thing and you get something else.
7:15 Speaker 02 That's gonna happen in any system that has standardization. Like, you're gonna try really hard to make sure people hew to the specification. But, you know, people do their own implementations and things change. In fact, the whole reason why emoji are in Unicode was because you would send your friend an emoji and then their cellphone would actually just render the incorrect one. It could be so much worse, and the fact that there is a standard means that, like, you only get these, like, weird edge cases.
7:41 Speaker 01 There's still some interesting vestiges of, like, the different telcos between Apple and Google. One was Dokomo and the other one was Softail.
7:48 Speaker 02 Softail.
7:49 Speaker 01 Softail. So they're basically, depending on who their partner was locally, they kind of inherited those generations of emojis. For example, on Apple, women with bunny ears is like two women dancing in kind of like a let's-party kind of way with their bunny ears, whereas on Android, it's just the headshot of a woman with bunny ears.
8:07 Speaker 02 And it's referencing this slightly misogynist part of Japanese culture of bunny woman, which is itself a reference to the Playboy bunny. And so, like, they were cocktail waitresses working in nightclubs. That made its way into the Japanese set, and then so when it came over to America, like, I think Apple must have been like, let's make this a little more fun.
8:23 Speaker 01 One of the easiest things, actually, to get emoji pass is showing that a vendor uses it. Another argument is for completion. This is actually why chopsticks got passed fairly easily, because we had, like, knife and fork.
8:35 Sonal? Oh, so you need completion of a set.
8:36 Speaker 01 You need completion. So.
8:38 Sonal? Is that so you can tell a whole story, like, stringing together a bunch of?
8:40 Speaker 01 No, I just think that it's like, they're engineers.
8:42 Sonal? Right. You can't have A, B, C, D, and skip the D.
8:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. They're actually, one of the weird issues is that they're red, yellow, green, purple, blue hearts, but not orange. So one of the big lobbying efforts has been to fill in the orange.
8:55 Sonal? So the case of the Apple bunny ears and the Japanese bunny woman, that was a case where there was an intentional translation to sort of obscure the cultural reference.
9:03 Speaker 01 It's more that. Often try them map technically the same emoji, but it's like rendered and sort of interpreted differently. They like emoji that can have multiple meanings. You can also just have like emoji that have one meaning, but it really has to be a really good one with going to be one meaning. So for us, the Chinese takeout box, for example, one of the arguments that we made, we made is that it's, it's one, it's an iconic shape. It also symbolizes both an entire cuisine, which is Chinese food, and also a means of eating, which is delivery and takeout.
9:30 Speaker 02 Right.
9:30 Speaker 01 Right. And so, so in that one symbol, you get a lot of sort of secondary meaning. And with fortune cookies, like it's technically a cookie, but it also means like mysterious in the future and the unknown.
9:41 Sonal? So like our primary secondary meaning, one of the criteria for an emoji to get passed is that it has to have a certain element of ambiguity to it.
9:48 Speaker 02 I love this. I've been thinking about this so much. When I did emoji deck, it was more of an experiment around crowdsourcing and emoji itself. Like I wasn't like so much interested in making a formal case that emoji could be a language because it was still so early. Could it get there maybe one day? Yeah, but Unicod makes a really good point. They're like emoji is not a language. It shouldn't be a language. The value is that it's ambiguous. And I've really come around to that thinking in this idea that the charm of sending an emoji is that it can be interpreted in a couple of different ways. And, and that's actually why we value it. And, and I'll go further and say that a lot of people ask me why emoji have become so popular. And I think it's tied to the fact that we now are just inundated with text. We live in a text culture, right? We, we communicate via text.
10:33 Speaker 02 Our careers are run over email. We read constantly. Everything we do is mediated through almost literal words. And so emoji represents this kind of reaction to that. And the popularity of emoji, I think, is largely due to the fact that we need some other way of expressing ourselves over text.
10:51 Sonal? If the pipes are so mechanical, like phones and machine. You no longer have the nonverbal aspect. So this is actually replacing sort of this, this human element of the glimmer in your eye or like the cheeky, the blush on your cheek. There's an emoji that does that.
11:05 Speaker 02 You think about the amount of signal you get from somebody's voice on an analog telephone. And when you strip that out and all you're communicating is like LOL, you don't actually know how sincere that laugh is or that chuckle or whatever that person's trying to convey. And so emoji gives us a much bigger palette to convey this kind of like extra like limbic meaning that we want to have in our, in our communications, but we, we can't because we're just, we're texting all the time.
11:29 Sonal? So to break down the taxonomy of figural representation, not using literal text, let's talk about where emoji fits. We have emoticons, which are like a colon and a, and a parenthesis, and that gives you a smiley face or like a semicolon and a parenthesis, and that gives you a wink.
11:42 Speaker 01 Right, using punctuation.
11:43 Sonal? Using punctuation is emoticon.
11:45 Speaker 01 Often ASCII-ish.
11:46 Sonal? Right.
11:46 Speaker 02 And it goes way back.
11:47 Sonal? There's the art as well.
11:48 Speaker 02 Some of the earliest references to emoticons go back to the 19th century as well.
11:52 Sonal? Oh, my God.
11:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, people were using colons and dashes and parentheses to express like a wink. It goes way back. It's important to add in hieroglyphs and iconography. Other humans have had this idea before, right? Like the, the medium and the technology is kind of like incidental.
12:07 Sonal? I'm so glad you brought that up because it's so important to not get caught up in technology time. Well, technically, technology includes like sticks and, and stones. So that does go back in time. But in the context of this machine web that we live in, then we have emoticons as part of the taxonomy, and then we have emoji. But how would you guys define emoji?
12:25 Speaker 01 It's Japanese, drawing language.
12:27 Sonal? Emoji.
12:28 Speaker 01 I don't know how to pronounce in Japanese, but the Chinese. The emo is not for emoticon or emotion or anything. It's just totally coincidence.
12:34 Sonal? Wow.
12:35 Speaker 02 It's hard not to just hew to the Unicode standard and say it's the, it's the set of icons defined in Unicode that represent objects and nouns and actions and.
12:49 Speaker 01 The way that I explain it to people is an emoji is a character, an emoji is something you can put in the subject line of an email because it literally is text. So, so in the same way that Unicode has kind of defined a standard to unify all the graphical representation of different languages throughout the world and even non languages. So like, you know, the wingdings and all that kind of stuff. Emoji actually slipped into that entire system. So there is literally what they would call a code point assigned to each emoji. Or sorry, not every single one, because now they're like compound emoji, but there are code points assigned to. Emoji, which basically says, you know, when you, when a computer sees this code point, they render it in a certain way.
13:30 Speaker 02 But that, it's important to kind of wrap your head around what's actually happening inside the computer, because the emoji is being sent as text. If your computer supports UTF eight, UTF 16, that's just like a standard way for your computer to handle text, whether it's your phone or your laptop. Then it's being told, render this emoji. But it's actually up to your computer's operating system, whether it's OSX or iOS or Android or whatever, to go fish out a little image and put it on your screen. And so that image is actually controlled by the hardware manufacturer or the software manufacturer. You know, when it's actually rendered on your screen, the, the operating system's choosing which image to show you. And those images are actually stored, you know, in the same way that other images are stored on your computer as little PNG files. And so Apple, you know, puts those on your computer and your computer chooses to render
14:15 Speaker 02 those, which is why you may get slightly different.
14:18 Sonal? Interpretation.
14:19 Speaker 01 Right. I'm glad to watch this a little bit. This is actually really interesting, because recently Facebook just introduced their own emoji and that like basically hijack Apple emoji. So you can turn that on or off, but essentially they, they will replace, they'll swap out all the ones on the Apple.
14:33 Speaker 02 And Twitter's had their own set for a while. And so.
14:35 Sonal? Why is that?
14:35 Speaker 02 So there are interesting copyright considerations here. My guess is a lot of those companies are doing it because A, they can afford to make their own set.
14:42 Sonal? Yeah.
14:42 Speaker 02 B, they want to avoid the legal liability of using Apple set.
14:46 Sonal? Right.
14:47 Speaker 02 And C, like, they think they might kind of have some like moment of like, hey, did you see Twitter's new emoji? Right? And so they're, you know, these large companies are kind of.
14:56 Speaker 01 Innovating on emoji.
14:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, like re-innovating and re-illustrating their emoji. And I think, you know, I think Microsoft actually just evolved to a new set or was it Android? I think it might've been Google Android. They, they just upgraded to make it seem a little bit more normal, like they had gone from like.
15:11 Speaker 01 I suppose not the terrible blue and white.
15:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
15:13 Speaker 01 Or there's like the blobby ones or.
15:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, the Android, I think Google had blobby ones for a while. Now they're doing somewhat normal ones.
15:19 Speaker 01 Scariest emoji ever, the Microsoft emoji are like blue and gray and they look like monsters that hide underneath your bed.
15:27 Sonal? Why? Why are they blue and gray?
15:29 Speaker 02 I think it's just an attempt to be like, like different from like. Yellow skin tone.
15:33 Speaker 01 Part of the original emoji is you wanted things that were skin tone neutral. So Apple and Google chose yellow, but Microsoft for some reason chose gray.
15:44 Sonal? Oh, gray, because I was gonna say for Hindu, like, blue is actually not a bad thing to have your skin blue. It's like a god.
15:48 Speaker 01 The other thing is if you have your own set of emoji, you can actually start adding to that set without going through.
15:54 Sonal? The Unicode.
15:55 Speaker 01 Unicode. So like a very good example is the gay family emoji originally where they're not. It's not actually one emoji. You know, the ones like man, man, kid, kid. That is actually a compound emoji of four characters glued together using something called a quote zero with joiner, which is basically like an invisible glue. So if you are sending that emoji to someone else who doesn't have the ability to render that, it actually unravels itself into like a multiple character. Now, what you're seeing is a lot of vendors making compound emojis. So like actually one of the places where this is being debated for use is the need for a professional female emoji. Right. Because one of the big problems right now on the existing set of women as represented by emoji is like,
16:39 Speaker 01 there are only like really four roles for women to play compared to men. You know, men, you can be a sleuth, or you can be, you know, a policeman. You can be sort of a medical worker. There's all kinds of things you can be. You can even be Santa Claus. But as a woman, the four things you can be as a role are basically bride, princess, dancer, ploy by a bunny.
16:59 Sonal? Oh, my god. It just goes to show you how the polit-- I mean, of course, this is the politics of human life play out in these systems. I mean, the perfect example I was thinking of is a rifle emoji. And the case of, I believe, Apple, Google, and Facebook. Charlie Warzel at BuzzFeed wrote a really detailed article investigating this and about how they sort of help suppress, as part of the Unicode consortium, the rifle emoji.
17:19 Speaker 02 Right. Emoji already has a gun in it, right? And it's like, okay, so how many more versions of that do we need? And you're right, it's absolutely a political topic. I mean, that issue manifests itself in so many other places in emoji. The country flag stuff is super interesting.
17:33 Sonal? Yeah.
17:33 Speaker 02 Because that uses kind of what Jenny's talking about with these compound emojis. Unicode didn't actually want to decide which flags were and weren't in emojis.
17:41 Sonal? Right. Then political issues.
17:44 Speaker 02 What they did was they built this kind of like meta country system so that you would actually be pairing these country letter emojis together. So CNN would go together and then it would be up to your phone to decide if you showed the Chinese flag. They pushed that decision making, that like political decision making of which flags to support off to the handset manufacturers. So
18:04 Speaker 01 Microsoft actually does something weird there.
18:06 Sonal? What do they do?
18:06 Speaker 01 They they just show the they they don't show a flag. They show a flag plus the two letters.
18:11 Speaker 02 Right, right.
18:12 Speaker 01 Microsoft doesn't render it normally.
18:13 Speaker 02 To the point about politics being kind of embedded in emoji, it's not just because these are icons that, you know, represent the parts of our lives that we feel passionate about. It's because there's a finite palette. It's not like language where you can only, you know, you can kind of combine, say whatever you want.
18:29 Sonal? It's combinatorial. You can take multiple combinations and turn into whatever you want.
18:32 Speaker 02 You get way more degrees of freedom to kind of express yourself. There's a finite number of food items that are ever to go in there. And when you think about the vast like multitudes of humanity, whether it's, you know, people's relationship status or structural orientation or skin color, it's like, like emoji is never going to be able to express that. And so like, how do you contain this thing that's like growing and kind of has to grow as more and more people use it, but also by definition has to be a finite list of icons?
18:58 Sonal? Well, how do they handle the skin tone issue? Because one of the things that I noticed is that you an Apple, because I use an Android, so I didn't notice this, you can press down on a thumbs up, for example, and then you can pick among 15 different shades to like pick a skin coat shade that's closest to you.
19:13 Speaker 01 Five and yellow. Yeah, it's it's based on the fits.
19:15 Speaker 02 Fitzpatrick skin tone.
19:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's actually used. It's the same skin tone system that dermatologists use to categorize.
19:22 Sonal? This reminds me a little bit of being a kid when like you had Crayola box. I remember that the only shade you had, there was like a nude shade or like a skin tone.
19:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, nude was always Caucasian.
19:30 Sonal? So I'd use sepia. I remember using sepia to represent my skin color.
19:33 Speaker 02 There's a great history about this in, uh, this is gonna sound weird for me to say, but like women's pantyhose like had this issue where nude was always considered Caucasian.
19:41 Sonal? Right.
19:42 Speaker 02 And people were like, this is ridiculous. It was one of the earliest blind spots of emoji I remember.
19:47 Sonal? Right. Well, I mean, if you have like only white men designing them. Do you remember when Slack, there was this guy who wrote a post about Justin Brown hand?
19:53 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:54 Sonal? And I remember it was so meaningful because it's such a minor, seemingly arbitrary thing. But then it is true. Like, the first time I saw that I could find my skin color in a system and to be able to use it was kind of amazing.
20:07 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:07 Sonal? And empowering. And I think there's something significant about that.
20:10 Speaker 02 I would totally agree. I don't share your experience as that be as a person on the other side. And so it's funny for me because I don't.
20:19 Sonal? He's a white male.
20:20 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:20 Sonal? And for those of you listening, I'm a white guy.
20:25 Speaker 02 I don't share that like sense of identification with the bright white skin like.
20:31 Sonal? Right.
20:31 Speaker 02 Fleishman index.
20:32 Sonal? That's not necessarily me.
20:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm like, it's, it's, it feels odd to opt into that.
20:37 Sonal? Yes.
20:37 Speaker 02 Which speaks to my privilege as a white male where I just like.
20:40 Sonal? Not just that. I mean, if you're not exposed to it, you're not exposed to it. The bottom line is if you're any person of color, you're always aware of your color.
20:44 Speaker 02 Right. And so.
20:45 Sonal? Especially if you're in a context where everyone else is not the same color as you.
20:47 Speaker 02 And so when I texted my friends who are not white and, and I'm like, should I be choosing that one? And I just choose to choose the yellow skin tone. That's just like the, I feel way more comfortable with that.
20:56 Speaker 01 So my, so my solution is I often send four. It's like, it'll be like yellow, light, dark, and then like the beige one. So it's like a Benetton ad and emoji where.
21:05 Sonal? Benetton emoji. That's fabulous.
21:07 Speaker 02 So now the kind of evolution is that we have yellow for like all of the human face characters. And then you can choose skin tones for some of them. But it doesn't get at like more nuanced issues about like cultural and racial identity having to do with facial structure or hairstyle.
21:21 Sonal? Oh, right. Like as a features, like, that's a great point, actually, because one of the pet peeves I have is when I used to go to foreign countries and look at billboards, it always glorified that Aquile nose, the face structure, whereas there's a totally different type of face structure in different areas.
21:33 Speaker 02 Emoji probably won't ever have that amount of like customization. And Unicode gets this. And they'll, they actually say like, we're adding like 60 emoji a year. This is unsustainable. We feel like the future is inline images. And that kind of breaks my heart as like kind of a, you know, nerd standardization guy who like, who really appreciates all the hard work that went into Unicode and, and the idea that it is a standard. Because if you're just sending inline images forever, then like, you know, you have no idea what's going to be on the other side if they can render the image.
22:06 Speaker 01 Yeah. So stickers. I mean, so Kim emoji, for example.
22:08 Speaker 02 Right.
22:09 Speaker 01 Kim Kardashian's quote emoji. They're not actually emoji. Those are just stickers. They're images that you can text back and forth. But, you know, again. Standards, can you put it in the subject line of an email? And those, you can't.
22:20 Sonal? You can't, so therefore they don't qualify.
22:22 Speaker 01 They're not technically emoji.
22:24 Sonal? Right, so then going back to our hierarchy, we went from emoticon to emoji and now stickers.
22:28 Speaker 01 Stickers. Stickers are basically inline images. I mean, stickers are just images that you can pick from a palette.
22:33 Speaker 02 And I think you can, you know, in certain apps, you can like apply a sticker to an image that it like sits on top of it. But you're then in this kind of like proprietary ecosystem of that's okay. But like, you think about the stuff that really works and the stuff that really changes the future of the web and communication. It's all standardized, right?
22:51 Sonal? You're saying this as a standardization person because my friend Connie, who wrote a wonderful post on the topic of stickers, argues that emoji are very limited for what you need to do because she feels that you have so much more expression and the ability to convey so much more with stickers than you do with emoji.
23:07 Speaker 01 Emoji doesn't preclude the use of stickers. There is some subset of images that are universal enough that should be hardwired into the operating systems and are basically can be cross-platform that an iOS device can talk to, you know, Microsoft Windows and can talk to like an Android device, can talk to your Mac laptop. Like the fact that at least you're not going to get little square boxes as long as your operating systems are fairly up to date.
23:34 Sonal? Well, that goes and then your point about the why standardization is important because you're now giving up that you're in this proprietary ecosystem like WeChat or Line and you only have their sticker set and you can't always transfer all these stickers across.
23:45 Speaker 02 And then also if you think about the accessibility issues around stickers, right? Like people using screen readers, they're not going to be able to interpret an image. And like emoji actually have names. And so in theory, there's much better accessibility for emoji for somebody who's visually impaired, so.
23:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, like for example, last year Oxford English Dictionary chose
24:05 Speaker 02 Face with tears of joy.
24:07 Speaker 01 Which I always thought looked very sad. I only, it's, you know, the thing with the eyes and it's like bawling, but that's actually face of tears of joy. And that is how, you know that because, you know, all these emoji.
24:18 Sonal? They say the label. Oxford put that in their dictionary.
24:21 Speaker 01 So the word of the year was an emoji.
24:23 Speaker 02 Part of the reason they chose that was that it ended up as number one on my friend's site called emoji tracker dot com.
24:29 Sonal? Oh, right, that's right. The emoji tracker, which tracks all the use of emoji on Twitter.
24:32 Speaker 02 And for a while, it was just like, it was like the heart emoji or something, or just the smiling face emoji. So I think it's really interesting when the top emoji shuffle because, you know, whenever you start texting with somebody who hasn't used emoji before, they're like choosing like the safest ones.
24:46 Sonal? Going back to this idea of some of the companies owning their own emoji and some of the proprietary open tension between standardization, freedom of expression. What do you make of this notion that part of what we're doing here is essentially also creating a more machine readable web in terms of emotional reading? Because essentially, you're now adding a whole new layer where you can codify people's emotions, sentiment in ways beyond just a black and white like, don't like.
25:11 Speaker 02 I've been thinking about this so much, actually, and not in the context of emoji, but actually Facebook reactions.
25:16 Sonal? Yeah, me too. I used to assign and edit up ads on this topic because I was very obsessed with it.
25:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think it's a really interesting topic because if you look at traditional sentiment analysis in the data world, it's kind of a joke. You have to have training data. You have to know good cases.
25:29 Sonal? Right. And just to interject for a moment, as someone who's been tested a million of those systems and can never find one that actually works for my needs, they're so binary. You don't get anything useful. You're not getting insight.
25:40 Speaker 02 One of the reasons there is that words have these degrees of freedom. They can be sarcastically, and you would never know it based on the semantics. And so, traditional sentiment analysis is really broken because you're using these kind of stale, rigid semantic definitions. What's really interesting about Facebook reactions is, you know, you think you're saying, "I love this thing," or "I'm sad about this," or "I'm angry about this." What you're actually doing, in conjunction with that, is giving Facebook really great labeled data for sentiment analysis.
26:12 Sonal? That's right. Machine readable data. That is a holy grail of emotional sentiment understanding. When I was at Wired, I assigned a piece to a sociologist, Evan Solinger, because I wanted to coin this phrase, the mood graph. Because we have an interest graph, social graph, you know, all kinds of other graphs that link all these nodes and ideas. And now to have like a mood graph, to essentially be able to put your pulse on someone's mood, something very finite, yet constantly changing. It's just a fascinating thing to be able to codify this.
26:42 Speaker 01 The sentiment stuff generally correlates very strongly with human face and body. So I think this is also why people agitate so much for emoji that look like themselves. Like the redheads and people with beards and people, you know, who are, who have like, who are bald.
26:56 Sonal? Or anyone who has curly hair. People with curly hair relate to other people with curly hair.
27:00 Speaker 01 And so I think people really love seeing themselves represented in emoji, which is why Bitmoji, which is highly, highly, highly customized stickers in sort of emoji spirit.
27:10 Sonal? Oh, my cousins and I use Bitmoji on WhatsApp all the time. I think there's something really symbolically important about Bitmoji because you are putting yourself in it and conveying in this sticker form. The fact that Snapchat bought it, I think is really telling.
27:23 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, for a hundred million dollars.
27:24 Sonal? Right. Especially given that they are changing this culture of how you express yourself through your facial expressions with face swapping and filters. Connie and I made the argument that it's sort of like selfies, as selfies as a form of stickers. So what we're talking about, the machine readable, is a little distinct than this, but it's sort of an interesting idea all the same.
27:40 Speaker 02 I also think it ties into this slightly dubious notion of the uncanny valley, where if you want to try to represent yourself and you want to have like configurability around that, it needs to be kind of cartoonish for it to be believable. I think what we're seeing with Snapchat filters and I don't know if you guys have played with snow yet. That's like, it's like take Snapchat filters and just multiply them by a thousand. It's like, it's like, I mean, just like amazing amounts of diversity around the amount of stuff you can put on your face. It's, it is this weird convergence on identity and emoji that's kind of happening.
28:11 Sonal? I, I agree. And in fact, this is going to be a little, sound like a little out of left field for a moment, but the whole notion around the Chewbacca mask lady, when, you know, that was the most popular Facebook Live video ever. It got like unprecedented views and it was simply a woman who was trying on her Chewbacca mask in the car. And she's laughing and giggling about it and then she puts her mask on and then she takes it off and she laughs so uninhibitedly. It's insane. And I make the argument that what was so empowering, because it was totally took off for obvious reasons, is not the fact that she was laughing so uninhibitedly, it's a fact that it took putting on and then taking off the mask for her to do that, which is a lot, not unlike what happens with communication through these filters and being able to now express yourself through these cartoon Like ways in a real way.
28:54 Speaker 02 It it takes me back to like theater and like Shakespeare in like seventh and the eighth grade. I remember having these like really intense discussions about like what it is to put on a mask and what a mask represents.
29:03 Sonal? It's a very Cambellian idea, right? The Joseph Campbell like mask and the myth and the man.
29:07 Speaker 02 Yeah.
29:07 Sonal? You're right. There's a theater. I mean, that's why people say improv is so interesting for any career field. But I think that there is an interesting moment now coming together with selfies, stickers, emoji, bit mojis all together where we do have this new emotional web coming together.
29:20 Speaker 02 Right. And and using emoji, uh, the first time I thought about this, could be kind of like putting on a mask over your, you know, self to, yeah, over your words to convey to yourself this like this extra, this this kind of additional layer, this emphasis of your emotion that you otherwise might not get.
29:37 Sonal? Okay. So going back to you writing an entire book in emoji, and yet you're saying that you've kind of evolved during thinking that, you know, that emoji is not necessarily a language, but clearly it is a visual language and it's it is a tool for communication. It's not complete. So how did you translate that? I mean, what were some of the trade offs and decisions you made? And by the way, for the audience, that book was like 2009 or that was like many years ago. What emoji space were you working off? Did you make them up? Like, what'd you do?
30:01 Speaker 02 So I'd gotten a text from my college roommate whose wife is Japanese. He sent me an emoji and I was like, what is that? They told me you could download like a basically a Japanese app and it would like awaken your iPhone to the emoji keyboard.
30:14 Sonal? Come alive to emoji.
30:16 Speaker 02 In the like, like you have to hack the iPhone to get the special keyboard of like Japanese icons. And I was like, oh, my God, I want this so bad. I was like, this is amazing. I should write a book in emoji. Um, and I was like, oh, that's a lot of work. I don't know if I can write a whole book in emoji. And then I was like, well, maybe I can translate a book in emoji. I was like, okay, what books would work? And I was like, well, it has to be in the public domain because I worked a lot in like the copyright reform space. Nobody's gonna just like let me translate their book into emoji without a lot of effort. For a moment, I thought about the Bible and I was like, that's too obvious. What's like, what's like totally even more inappropriate?
30:49 Sonal? So Moby Dick came to mind.
30:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, it came to mind as like this, this like impossible book to translate, to put into these symbolic characters. As soon as I thought, I was like, no, I can't do that. That's crazy. And I was like, that's like too hard.
30:59 Sonal? Honestly, it's a little bit like, I just came back from seeing Hamilton. And so it's a little bit like the idea of putting a rap to like the founding fathers. That's what I find so fascinating.
31:05 Speaker 02 I would say Hamilton was probably.
31:06 Sonal? It's a mashup of mediums and time and culture.
31:09 Speaker 02 And and and it's, it's like one of those things where you tell it to somebody and they're like, you can't do that. That's crazy. And then you're like, well, the fact that you just said that made me want to do it. And so.
31:17 Sonal? Well, not only that, there are not one, but two. Whale emoji.
31:21 Speaker 01 Were there at that time?
31:22 Speaker 02 No, there was only the
31:23 Speaker 01 The only cute one?
31:24 Speaker 02 The cute one, the kind of eight bit style one.
31:26 Sonal? It was a whale emoji.
31:27 Speaker 01 Ahab is battling the cute whale. Yeah.
31:30 Sonal? There's a second one.
31:31 Speaker 02 The second, I think it's called sperm whale, didn't come up until later. So I was like, okay, wow, that would be really interesting to do all of Moby Dick, because it's also like really long. I mean, it's 10,000 sentences. And, okay, well, if I don't want to do this, maybe hire somebody to do this. And I was like experimenting with Mechanical Turk at the same time. I think it was like one of the original Amazon web services. It was like, it would later become, you know, part of that AWS umbrella.
31:54 Sonal? Yeah, I remember people using it for research and stuff.
31:56 Speaker 02 Right, it's still used for research, it's still valuable for that. But, you know, a couple other people had done like an experiment here or there, like using it like off-label. I had made a task on Mechanical Turk just to ask Turk workers, if you could ask anyone, like, to do anything on Mechanical Turk, what would you have them do? And they came up with this long list of stuff, and I don't think translate a book into emoji was one of them. But there's some creativity out there. I was like, okay, I'm gonna, I'm gonna try this thing, or I'm gonna hire people to translate Moby Dick into emoji, some portion of it, and see if this works. So I did the first chapter, and the results came back, and they were hilarious. They were so good.
32:30 Sonal? They were good.
32:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, they were great.
32:31 Sonal? First of all, what did they, what do you mean you did the first chapter? Like, did they break it down word by word?
32:35 Speaker 02 So.
32:36 Sonal? How do you capture that in emoji? Is it like a sentence?
32:38 Speaker 02 So I decided I was gonna do it as, on a per-sentence basis. And that actually turned out to be one of the challenging parts of the project, was like splicing sentences is actually like, kind of like a classically hard and all natural language processing problem.
32:49 Sonal? Right.
32:50 Speaker 02 And so I kind of like figured out a hack to like chop it up, and I wrote a lot of regular expressions to basically get the whole book into sentences.
32:56 Sonal? But you decided basically that sentence was a unit of analysis, not a phrase, not a word, a sentence.
32:59 Speaker 02 In the task, and you say, pick any of these emoji. And then I actually wrote my own little emoji picker, because these things didn't exist at the time. I had gotten the emoji from a friend. He had reverse engineered the iPhone SDK and basically hacked out the PNG files from the software kit to basically have the raw emoji in image form. And so I took that and just made like a little JavaScript, like HTML thing, and, you know, dumped that into Mechanical Turk, and it like came back, and I was like, hey, this works. And so I think the, the, the sentence that's kind of like on the cover of the book, if you go to the website, it's like.
33:32 Sonal? The website being Emoji Dick.
33:33 Speaker 02 Emoji Dick dot com. Call me Ishmael is the first sentence of Moby Dick. And the, the emoji that the Turk worker chose was like.
33:43 Speaker 02 Telephone, man with face, sailboat, whale emoji.
33:46 Sonal? That's amazing.
33:47 Speaker 02 It was just like, the rest of it was just like indecipherable emoji nonsense. And some of the people were just like, all right, give me my five cents. I'm going to click some random emoji. And other people just like clicked every single emoji. So the plan became have people translate the same sentence multiple times. So you get three different emoji translations for one sentence. And then have another set of tasks where people vote on the best, most appropriate translation. And so like of the three, which one got the meaning across the best?
34:15 Sonal? Yeah.
34:16 Speaker 02 And I was like, oh, I was just like getting really excited about this. And I started doing the math on how much it was going to cost. And I was like, oh, it's going to be thousands and thousands of dollars. That summer, I met the Kickstarter guys, I started talking with Andy Baio. He was like, you should put on Kickstarter. So that night I went home and put it on Kickstarter, launched it the next day and ended up working for them.
34:32 Sonal? And by the way, how much did the campaign, how much money did the campaign make?
34:34 Speaker 02 I, my goal was like 3,500 and ended up raising 3,700. So I worked on it for, you know, nights and weekends for another like eight or nine months. And then, you know, I published it on Lulu.com. You can still buy it, it gets printed on demand and you know.
34:46 Sonal? Do people still buy it?
34:47 Speaker 02 I've sold like thousands of dollars of Emoji Dick. And, and I'd say hundreds of copies and I've probably like five or 600 copies of it have sold since then, which you know, it's not a lot.
34:59 Sonal? This podcast is going to sell a bunch.
35:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, well.
35:01 Sonal? You better share some of the proceeds with me.
35:02 Speaker 02 Okay, so there are two copies. One, there, there's a black and white copy, which is like the easy to print one. And that's like 20 or 30 dollars. And then there's the full color one, which like is obviously preferable because emoji is so colorful. But when you're printing on demand, 800 pages of color laser hardbound copy, it's actually really expensive. So that thing costs like 180 dollars.
35:24 Sonal? Right, because you're not printing in bulk.
35:25 Speaker 02 Exactly.
35:26 Sonal? Because you actually save money when you're printing bulk.
35:27 Speaker 02 So I have to sell that one for that much and like people still buy it. In 2013, the Library of Congress contacted me and they, you know, they said, uh, we would like to acquire Emoji Dick as our first emoji book. I was like, are you sure? They're like, yeah, yeah, we're sure. And I was telling a friend and David Gallagher, I think you, you must know from the Times. And he's like, you know. Everyone submits their stuff to the Library of Congress. It's not that big of a deal. And I was like, no, man, they asked for it. Like, they're acquiring it.
35:52 Sonal? I think it's a big deal because it's a curatorial point of view.
35:55 Speaker 02 Totally.
35:55 Sonal? They're saying we're, this is a cultural moment. It's not just a book that was published.
35:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
35:59 Sonal? And we need to figure out how to acquire it.
36:01 Speaker 02 I was like, all right, I'll spare a copy. I signed it, I sent it to them. And then they sent me this little, like, you know, certificate in digital form. And what's hilarious, and this is my favorite part, is that it's somehow listed as a translation of Moby Dick. So when you look up Emoji Dick, it says all these libraries have it because it's really just saying that, like, they have a translation. They have the original Moby Dick. Now it's got a life of its own and people still discover it.
36:22 Sonal? I mean, you actually even curated an art show.
36:24 Speaker 02 Yeah.
36:25 Sonal? Did you base on this?
36:25 Speaker 02 Friends of mine put together a kind of emoji survey art show. And there was some really great stuff in there. Emoji tracker was there. There was a programming language built out of emoji. There's a lot of other good stuff.
36:37 Speaker 01 Emojis can have their URL. I mean, that's another thing. They're literally tech, so you can have like emoji at, well, I don't know, at Gmail. But you can have emoji in your email address.
36:44 Speaker 02 Yeah.
36:45 Sonal? Oh, you can.
36:45 Speaker 02 Oh, you can also buy emoji domains.
36:47 Sonal? So you have an emoji book, you have emoji art shows.
36:50 Speaker 01 Emoji hackathon.
36:51 Sonal? Emoji hackathon.
36:52 Speaker 01 So our big news this week is that in November in San Francisco, we are going to throw the first ever Emoji Con.
36:59 Sonal? What?
36:59 Speaker 01 Which is basically.
37:00 Sonal? Is that Comic Con?
37:01 Speaker 01 It's like Comic Con, but emojis.
37:02 Speaker 02 I really hope people will show up dressed in emoji costumes.
37:06 Sonal? I was about to say, I'm gonna show up as, oh, you're gonna, you guys are gonna, Ying's gonna show up as a dumpling emoji, for sure.
37:09 Speaker 01 Or like, you know, poop emoji, or like the ghost emoji. So it has many different elements to it. So one is definitely sort of this whole emoji learn aspect where it's like panels and talks. Then there's a sort of emoji film festival. And then there's an emoji hackathon. And then there's an emoji art show. And then, of course, the opening party emoji where, you know, our goal is to only have food that is also emoji.
37:29 Sonal? So why a conference? I mean, of course, I see the cultural significance, but to bring people together around this first, this idea of a first ever Emoji Con? Like, what's the significance of that?
37:38 Speaker 01 I thought it already existed. And to me, the fact that it didn't.
37:41 Sonal? I kind of did too, to be honest. When you just said that, I was like, what?
37:43 Speaker 01 Yeah. And then I was like, the fact it didn't exist, and I kind of have this issue where of like, I think something needs to be.
37:48 Sonal? You will make it exist, goddammit.
37:50 Speaker 01 Right? So we did that with dumpling emoji, we did it with Emoji Con. And so we actually have some really cool sponsors. We're gonna have a lot of kind of. Emoji activists kind of out there.
37:58 Sonal? Emoji activists.
37:59 Speaker 01 And also, you know, from our perspective, you know, there are a lot of policy decisions around emoji. And obviously, the world really cares about emoji, whether or not it's a rifle emoji or the condom emoji or like professional women emoji. Part of the goal of Emoji Con is to open up that discussion. So it is not just held at the Unicode level.
38:15 Sonal? Right.
38:15 Speaker 01 So to hear.
38:15 Sonal? So are Unicode members going to be attending this conference?
38:17 Speaker 01 Members of Unicode Emoji Subcommittee, including like, you know, the co-chairs. And we timed it in November between the Unicode Conference itself and the Unicode Technical Committee meeting. And also, like, it's right around election day.
38:31 Sonal? Well, you guys, thank you for joining the A6 and Z podcast.
38:34 Speaker 02 Thanks for having us. This is so much fun.
38:35 Sonal? This is so much fun.
38:35 Speaker 01 So much fun.
38:36 Sonal? We could keep going.
38:37 Speaker 01 Hours and hours on emoji.
38:38 Sonal? Yeah, I wish we could.
Previous CRISPR 2.0 and the Future of Gene Therapies Next How to Build an Open Source Business Page updated September 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated