Pod Insights a16z Podcast Marketplace Tactics: Metrics, Growth vs. Focus, Business Strategy | Field Notes by Connie Chan About this episode Field Notes, a new video podcast series by a16z, explores the business models and behaviors that are changing consumer technology.
In this episode, host Connie Chan talks to Deb Liu, the CEO of Ancestry and the former VP of App Commerce at Meta. The conversation covers all things marketplaces: What metrics to focus on, how to balance growth and focus, and how to turn user behavior into business strategy.
Transcript 0:10 Speaker 1 Hi, and welcome to Field Nets. I'm Connie Chan, and this is a new video podcast series from Andreas and Horowitz, where we talk about the business models and behaviors changing in consumer technology. Today I'm with my guest Deb Lou. Deb is the CEO of Ancestry and the former VP of Commerce at Meta. We'll be talking all about marketplaces. What metrics to focus on, how to balance growth and focus, and how to turn user behavior into business strategy. Deb is also a career coach on the side. So we'll also
0:38 Speaker 0 be diving into her best career tips.
0:40 Speaker 1 So Deb, let's start with Ancestry, where you are currently the CEO of Ancestry.
0:50 Speaker 1 And we know a lot of people right now, even today are doing interviews on Zoom. What tips do you have for people and thinking, especially executives? Like tell me about joining a company as CEO without having ever stepped into the building.
1:04 Speaker 0 Well, first, I think it was, you know, really intimidating. Like you're picking a CEO for a company they had just bought for 4.7 billion dollars. Blackstone did the entire interview process in Zoom. And it was such an honor to meet so many people and to be able to connect with them multiple times. But at the same time, you really don't know what someone's like unless you really meet them. The other part that was really funny was that I um I actually they they set me up with the executives. So this is when I was deciding whether they're joined. And instead of telling them who I was, they set up the meetings blind, where on the other side they just said, you're meeting the CEO, and then I show up on Zoom. And I didn't know the first couple, I didn't realize they had not told me who told them who I was. And they look at me and I said, Are you okay?
1:49 Speaker 0 And they said, uh, and I said, Do you want to Google me? And each of them said yes. And then I realized what they had done, and it was so interesting because I met them all one day. And it was very interesting because to walk in blind and actually to see your new manager or your new boss, um, and have no information about her. It was just uh really
2:08 Speaker 1 for them too. What a what an interesting introduction into your role as CEO. But I I love that you are CEO of such a large company. Um, and I wanted to talk a little bit about Ancestry specifically, because I think a lot of people don't realize Ancestry's done a lot of pioneering work with AI, and AI is all the rage right now. But you mean even recently deploying handwriting recognition to try and search the US census, like what other ways is Ancestry using AI and what are you excited about with regards to AI?
2:40 Speaker 0 Well, AI is gonna revolutionize our entire industry. I mean, we did 1940 census. It took us nine months and hundreds of people hand keying and indexing the records. So think about that. I mean, there's like a million pages of records. And so what they did was they just dropped the pages and it's just images, right? And so, you know, 1940, nine months, and we spent, you know, a ton of money and a ton of time making it happen. And so for 1950, we wanted to be absolutely prepared. So we built an AI model. We actually created pages, we tested it, we tried all these different things, and then it took nine days to digitize the entire census. On the other side, I think AI will really transform storytelling too. You know, because someone's life story is now available on Ancestry. We can actually build stories about people's lives based on just the records people have saved on there.
3:26 Speaker 0 And so I just think that that's gonna help people really bring the stories of their families to life and you know, not just connecting over records and birth marriage death, but also the life that they actually led.
3:38 Speaker 1 You guys have a massive data set on people's heritages, like their their grandparents, their great grandparents, their great great grandparents. Like, how are you thinking about the data opportunity inside Ancestry?
3:51 Speaker 0 Well, first we have 40 billion records, 75% of which is completely exclusive to ancestry. And so these are records like draft cards, you know, birth certificates, but also we digitize a lot of land records and local records as well. And so this past year, we had a record year, so five billion pieces of content, you know, digitized. And then this coming year, for 2023, we're gonna triple that because of the AI work that we're doing, which is bringing on 15 billion more records.
4:18 Speaker 1 Like when I think about AI, I often wonder like, okay, fast forward five years from now, paint a picture of like what could be possible. Is there anything you can share on a couple of years from now, five years, 10 years from now? Like, what will we be able to know about our past through a company like Ancestry?
4:38 Speaker 0 Well, part of it is really, you know, the storytelling, you know, how, why, not just the what, which we have, we have we have a lot of those records, but the why. Can we find letters? Can we find, can we digitize people's records, that the letters that they have, photos that they have? Can we actually record the oral history of our family so that and then transcribe them so that we can
4:58 Speaker 1 help
4:58 Speaker 0 bring that storytelling to life? Can we automatically create you know books around the story of your family without you having to do you know hundreds and hundreds of hours of writing? These are the most powerful things that I think we could bring to life. And I hope that that will come to pass
5:14 Speaker 1 soon. So storytelling actually has been part of an arc in your career because you spent a lot of time also figuring out how to bridge relationships at Facebook, where you spent a good chunk of your career you were leading platform, payments, games, and marketplaces. Um, what are some of the parallels that you saw between either the missions of the two companies or the type of work you were doing?
5:36 Speaker 0 Well, part of the work that I did at Facebook all those years was really about connection. You know, the the theme for Facebook Marketplace when we started it was connecting people through commerce. And you know, it's not really just about like transactions, it's about actually changing people's lives through how you connect them. And so the same thing in Ancestry is really connecting people to their own family story. And you know, social media and Facebook is about storytelling. It's just you're telling it in the present. And Ancestry is telling the story in the past. And so those things will come together because today becomes the past very, very soon. And so that's why this job attracted me is because a lot of the work that I did at Facebook was about connecting people in the present with transactions, with you know, connecting with your community, connecting through commerce.
6:21 Speaker 0 And now, you know, it's another way of connecting. And I, you know, that's the theme of my career, which has been technology can really bring us closer together if we do it right.
6:31 Speaker 1 And and you've you've uh you've definitely spent your time at companies working on projects that are bringing people together. And I want to get a little bit more tactical because I know a lot of our listeners are founders or people who are building products, and you've built a lot of those things at Meta almost from you know from the ground up. So, what are some types of advice that you give? Let's start with marketplaces, right? Like, what are some types of advice that you will give to marketplace founders? Um, whether they are doing cold start or maybe they're trying to figure out how to scale it, or they're hitting issues where supply is greater than demand or vice versa.
7:07 Speaker 0 You know, I think the biggest thing about building a marketplace is what is your right to win? Like what is the category and what is the narrow thing that you have an advantage in that no one else has, whether it's an interest, whether it's sellers or buyers, whether it's a niche or brand. Knowing who you are and what it is that makes you special is the first and most important step to building a marketplace.
7:28 Speaker 1 Does that mean though, if there's already a marketplace that addresses those buyers and sellers, that there's not a room, there's no room for a new
7:36 Speaker 0 No, you can have a totally different take on it. I mean, look at eBay. I worked at eBay for many years, and you know, what eBay did really well was all of the categories. But what they did poorly was any individual category. And you've seen entire categories get moved off of eBay because they couldn't do really well by you know rental properties. They couldn't do really well by you know, like um collectibles, they couldn't do really well by you know handmade sellers. So you can see these these marketplaces saying, hey, if we just focus on these buyers and sellers, we could do this better. And we don't have all the categories, but we have the ones that really matter to our customers.
8:12 Speaker 1 But then those marketplaces where they pick something off, eventually the goal is to recreate the large, you know, the large big player that covers a lot of categories, right? Everything that picks off something from Craigslist, the ultimate goal is to build back Craigslist.
8:26 Speaker 0 But if you think about it, like for example, Airbnb grew out of Craigslist, for example, local rentals, but they haven't been in every category, right? They ended up, you know, and you know, so focus is incredibly important. And the same thing is true for, you know, if you look at Etsy, like they're just not gonna be and used cars and parts and things that are really strong. And so really kind of knowing who you're gonna be and what you're gonna be, and having a vision for what is the thing that I want to win first, and then look at the concentric circles.
8:53 Speaker 1 Yeah.
8:54 Speaker 0 Some of those concentric circles will never overlap. You know, Etsy will probably never sell car parts. How do
8:58 Speaker 1 you figure out though, like what is the next concentric circle to tackle, right? Because Etsy started with handmade things. Now now there's a bunch of stuff on there that's not handmade, actually. Um, lots of cross-border stuff. People say a lot of the Chinese cross-border Amazon sellers are now all on that. Whether that's true or not, I'm not sure. But the point being, like, how do you figure out if you are building a marketplace? What is the next category to go after and when to do it?
9:25 Speaker 0 Yeah. So first, you know, what is the most similar category to what you're doing? So Amazon did books because there's ISBN, there's like, you know, there's all it was very structured, very easy to look up, categories were already there. But the next thing they did was CDs because music published by large publishers had a very similar category, characterization. You know, one of the most recent things they've been trying to do for a long time is soft goods, right? Basically, you know, clothing, which is very, very hard when you have a very structured system. Right.
9:56 Speaker 0 I think the thing about Etsy is, you know, what they did was they attracted. A type of buyer. And now they're trying to figure out what categories needs that type of buyer. I am an Etsy buyer. I actually buy these bears made and these apaca fur bears, my daughter collects on there. And you know, a lot of them are made in Peru and imported into America. And they're handmade, but they're made by artisans who actually, but it's not the sellers. So it's not the sellers are actually just third parties. And my daughter collects them and they're beautiful. But as a buyer of handmade goods, this is a category that's like a an extension of something that I would buy. Because I've bought a number of other handmade things. And so the question has to become you know, how true do you stay to your core? And then in which next concentric circle are you willing to go? And what in really meeting your buyers where they are, you know, what are the things that they're looking for?
10:46 Speaker 0 But I do think they have to be really careful because it becomes, you know, something where it feels like it's the inauthenticity of like a manufactured good. You know, it these bears are still handmade, they're still, but they're just not made by the seller. That's one thing. Yeah. But then if they're manufactured in mass production, they're gonna feel really inauthentic to me as a buyer. And so I think they're walking a really fine line of growth as well as authenticity and authenticity.
11:11 Speaker 1 And so as you studied all these large existing marketplaces and and you've built some of them or worked out some of them yourself. What are some of the big things you think they did right that people don't think about or are aware of, or some missteps that you think might have caused them to go off track?
11:28 Speaker 0 Well, I think what eBay did that was really special was having people trust each other online to send money in the mail. That just seemed so crazy at the time. But I remember I was an early eBay seller, and people would just mail me money orders. It's like mailing cash in the mail to another person. People would send me checks, which had all their information on it. And it just, you know, but it was that trust system that they built. The reputation system was something where you can send something to someone else, like money to someone else, and they're gonna mail you a thing in the mail. That just seems so crazy. And yet their reputation system was able to build that connection between people. I think PayPal augmented that so you didn't feel like you had to research trust that there was a layer, but and so it actually accelerated the growth. I think what changed though for eBay was that um the reputation system actually became a two double-edged sword.
12:16 Speaker 0 Part of it was that every employee of eBay knew that you didn't want to buy from somebody that had a 4.8 star or less. Because the in order to give someone a negative feedback as a seller, you basically had to buy your burn your buyer account. You would you had to be willing to never come back because the seller was gonna do something called retaliatory negative feedback, which was give you negative feedback as a buyer. And so the system was set up to protect sellers and to hurt buyers in some negative way, which wasn't known to the company for a long time. And part of that really hurt the reputation because now somebody who's a 4.6 seller, which you would think is very good in the world, suddenly became like a really negative experience. And yet people didn't know how to complain. They would complain quietly to PayPal, they would get their money back, and but then they would never actually publish a negative um a star because they were afraid to burn their account.
13:04 Speaker 0 And so you're creating incentives on both sides and how you think about this incentives. And so I wrote an article really thinking about ratings and reviews in detail. A lot of sites, you know, it's it's a mutual mutual agreement. So some sites do it, Airbnb, for example, where you both give each other feedback, but then they reveal it at the same time. And so that way you can't get, you know, you don't see the feedback before you. There's no
13:26 Speaker 1 retaliation. No retaliation.
13:28 Speaker 0 They do it that way. Another way is eBay just doesn't allow buyers to get negative feedback from sellers because buyers completed their part of the transaction by paying, yeah, and making the purchase. And so they changed their policy at some point. But the point is really thinking hard about the reputation and trust system can make or break you over time.
13:47 Speaker 1 What about a marketplace like Amazon? How do you think uh what are some things that you think that they've done particularly well?
13:54 Speaker 0 Well, what they did wonderfully was, you know, when they didn't have the inventory, they supplement. They were they were actually a first party seller, and then they tested auctions and it didn't work, and then suddenly they said, you know what, we're gonna have this buy box and a third-party marketplace and just see what happens. And suddenly it's open up a whole new avenue to bring a long tail of product that they could never have had and warehoused in their in our own inventory.
14:16 Speaker 1 Yeah.
14:16 Speaker 0 And so it really brought selection to the fore. And it allowed people to compete for the buy box. And so you're competing on quality of service, plus you're competing on price. And so they use both dimensions to actually see you basically get no sales if you're not in the buy box. And so what they did was they gamify two sellers. And so I think each marketplace really needs to think about what are you incenting? Are you incenting good behavior or just trying to prevent bad behavior? And those things matter a lot over time.
14:43 Speaker 1 Yeah. And how early should founders be thinking about this, or is this like core to how the whole product is set up from day one?
14:50 Speaker 0 It should be absolutely core to how the product is set up. So one of the biggest challenges you see in marketplaces is you know, it's people can there's there's seller fraud, there's buyer fraud, and there's collusion fraud. And every marketplace needs to think about all of those things at the same time. If you don't build that in from the start, you could really lose the thread, and it could cost you a lot of money.
15:11 Speaker 1 Yeah, that makes sense. What advice do you give for people who are in the growth stage where they actually have a great product, there's good liquidity, but they're not kind of hitting the growth targets that they're looking for. Maybe that's category expansion. But how do you counsel marketplaces on growth?
15:27 Speaker 0 Well, you know, I think sometimes it's easy to let's just open new categories, right? But really, the question is are you actually deepening your relationship every single day with your buyers? And to really looking hard at the retention curves, the J curves and seeing if you are you retaining them and is your product getting better every day. One of the things we did for Facebook Marketplace was we at first, our first metric wasn't transactions because we couldn't measure them. It was how often people were coming. It was weekly to monthly actives because as a classified marketplace, you know, you look at classified marketplaces and it's about frequency. Basically, people don't buy anything unless they come, and they don't come if they don't run a top of marketing. And so really it was good, right? Can we get them there? And then once we got them there, is can we get them to message people? And then once we message people, can we get sellers to mark this as sold?
16:15 Speaker 0 And so it was really a single set. But then over time, we we actually saw traffic going up. So people came back more often. If they made a transaction satisfactorily, they would come back more often over time. And so then you get the J curves. And I think a lot of marketplaces are just like, let's just look at raw tonnage of transactions. But you know what? Yeah,
16:33 Speaker 1 most marketplaces, the metrics people focus on, it's all numbers, it's all dollars, it's not it's not number of users or frequency of visits or any of that.
16:42 Speaker 0 But if you actually search um leaky bucket in eBay, there was uh an article written about this where you know, at some point it became a leaky bucket, and then you burn through entire countries of buyers. Yeah,
16:53 Speaker 1 and that becomes
16:54 Speaker 0 a huge problem. And I think they're trying to fix that now. But I think one of the big issues that the marketplaces have is you can always bring more people through the door with enough dollars. The question is, can you deepen your relationship with them? What is your actual 30-day, 90-day, 180-day retention?
17:09 Speaker 1 Those buyers, what are some things that you did at Facebook Marketplace to get them to spend more time or check it more frequently, have better attention, anything you can share there?
17:19 Speaker 0 Well, in a marketplace where the goods are completely dynamic. So, for example, you're unlikely to go to Airbnb if you're not traveling, right? You just don't go and browse and see what's available. But in a browse marketplace, it's really important to bring people in. So we gave people reasons to every time you you actually loaded the marketplace tab, the top of the tab was completely different, had different items on it. So it never felt static. You were constantly rethinking, so we would then we added this thing called top picks.
17:46 Speaker 1 Like even if there was nothing new, you would shuffle it. You would just reshuffle it.
17:50 Speaker 0 So you constantly definitely because it felt like you want people to have that feeling of there's something new here every day. And so really knowing what you occupy and where you are matters a lot to actually how you build the experience.
18:03 Speaker 1 And in that browse browse scenario, because a lot of marketplaces tend to be a little bit more browsing. How do you figure out how to balance the, you know, there's sellers that they've already purchased from before? Um, or maybe there's a restaurant they always order on Doordash. How do you surface that versus showing the new, the net new restaurants that they haven't tried?
18:24 Speaker 0 Well, I think the best thing is really understand people's behaviors. There's a group of people who only buy one thing, right? You know, when I get a DoorDash, I go to because I have this favorite Mexican restaurant that was across the street from PayPal, I still go to, and we order when we order there, we order like 10 burritos and eat it for like you know several days. And so they can show someone like me that, but when I'm in a different location, they should suggest every single thing that's possible out there. When we travel, I want to discover new things. I love Vietnamese food. I you say, you know, my kids are like, let's find the local Vietnamese food and let's go have on me, you know. And so, you know, showing me a selection of things that I've looked for before when I'm in a different place. And so really thinking hard about what is the job to be done for this person at this moment and when they come, and how can I actually take all the data I have on their previous visits and bring it all together?
19:13 Speaker 1 I really love that idea of focusing not just on the dollars, the top line dollars, the GMV that's going through the take rights. I mean, that all matters, but to your point, if the buyers aren't browsing, you have fewer and fewer chances to get them to convert to a transaction. So even just figuring out everyday traffic is a really important metric that marketplaces should take into account.
19:36 Speaker 0 It's traffic, but conversion on traffic. But the other thing you said was it's not just traffic versus GMV, it's are you thinking about GMV? Are you thinking about transactions? And so there was a time, and this was back when Flipkart was was growing like crazy. They really really chased GMV. And so they sold a ton of mobile phones because it was a high GMV item. Amazon, like how many transactions? Like I'd rather you buy a You know, $2 kind of tube of toothpaste here, then $200, right? Because it's all about frequency of use because now you're really dependent on it. You see And that drives things like Prime that unlock a bunch of other
20:12 Speaker 1 stuff.
20:13 Speaker 0 So the whole point is there their approach was really different. If you're chasing GMV, you want to sell high GMV, you know, growth categories. If you're chasing transactions, which is people come back by a $2 tube of toothpaste, then you really, your behavior, what you present to people is really different.
20:28 Speaker 1 This is amazing feedback, I think, for a lot of founders to focus on just general traffic and retention, not just not just GMV. Very, very important. I also want to talk about a different aspect of what I think makes you so amazing of a role model for for a lot of folks in tech, which is that you're also an author. You are also really big on mentorship. You also are the creator of not just a book, but also a newsletter that a lot of readers are reading and consuming on learning how to be, especially females, um, how to be a successful female in tech.
21:00 Speaker 0 Talk a little bit about how you moonlight as a career
21:03 Speaker 1 coach and you've mentored hundreds of people. What kind of career advice do you give those lucky mentees of yours? Um, and what's something tactical that you can share with our audience?
21:14 Speaker 0 Well, you know, recently I wrote this article. It's like tell them what you want. And I know it sounds really crazy, but so many people call me and I do these kind of 15 minute coaching sessions. It's usually strangers, they text me, I call them, and and someone's like, well, I want to get promoted, but I don't know how. I'm like, well, what happened when you told your manager you want to get promoted? And it's like silence. They said, well, how do you get promoted if you don't tell somebody? And I realize that sometimes we get in our own way, like we know what we're supposed to do. And my job is not to tell people what to do, but to unlock in them what they need to know to get, you know, because a lot of these people know they should have done that before calling me. And I'm like, why don't you call me back after you talk to your manager? But the point is, I think sometimes we just assume that things are supposed to work a certain way because it's comfortable for us.
21:59 Speaker 0 But but I'm, you know, I tell people if you don't hear no enough, you're probably not asking enough.
22:04 Speaker 1 How often should we be hearing no?
22:07 Speaker 0 Well, you know, like think about I read a lot of stories about founders. They're like, I went to 30 VCs and you know, you but you just need two people. What are two people that say yes? Right. And the whole point is if if you if hearing no is something that you're allergic to, you're never gonna be able to raise money. You know, how do you get your first partner? You're gonna be the underdog for a long time. And if you don't, you know, allow yourself to hear no a lot, and the answer might be not now. Thank you. I know this isn't right for you now. Let's talk in six months, you know. But I think sometimes we get in our own heads and we worry so much about what other people think about us. But if you instead, if you treat as a numbers game, I remember talking to one founder and she just had a list and she's like, here's all the people who turned me down, but here's the one who said yes. And I said, How did you deal with that much rejection?
22:53 Speaker 0 And she said, I realized that my goal was not to get everyone to say yes, but to get the right one to say yes.
22:58 Speaker 1 Thanks for watching Field Notes, my new video podcast series featuring leaders and consumer tech. For more career advice, emerging trends, and marketplace tactics, check out part two of my conversation with Deb dropping later this week. And be sure to subscribe to the A60Z channel so you don't miss an episode.
Previous Building Hardware and Taking on the Phone Giants with Carl Pei Next Marketing web3: Audience, Community, More Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated