Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Virtual Reality v Augmented Reality, and What's Next About this episode Virtual reality (VR) -- and augmented reality (AR) -- seem to be everywhere these days, showing up in demos and offerings from the world's biggest gadget makers to the Hollywood, gaming, and media crowds. But what's the difference between VR and AR? Is one better suited for work vs. play? What happens when you are building experiences -- and an entirely new visual grammar -- from scratch ... will we actually need standards next? a16z's Chris Dixon and Wired Entertainment's Peter Rubin discuss all this and more on this episode of the a16z Podcast.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Hi, it's Chris Dixon. This is the A16Z Podcast. Uh I'm here with Peter Rubin from Wired Magazine, who um has spent a lot of time studying uh virtual reality and augmented reality. So we're gonna talk about that today. One of my favorite topics. So Peter, thanks for being here. Um what what let's just like the the broad landscape, like what's going on now? So there's obviously Oculus, uh, Microsoft's HoloLens, Magic Leap, like what's your impression of what's happening?
0:23 Speaker 0 Well, right now it seems like last year and continuing into this year, it's what's interesting about it is there have always been kind of these tertiary players in the market and like smaller companies, but what's happening now is the Titans are kind of by proxy drawing these lines in the sand. So Facebook kind of sided with VR for Oculus. Um Microsoft made its bet with augmented reality, and we can talk more about that difference. Um and then Google went from kind of one mode of AR thinking with Google Glass to not necessarily scrapping that, but they're they're rethinking what they're doing there internally, and instead, you know, last year there was that half a billion dollars that went to Magic Leap, which is uh kind of an AR startup based in South Florida. So we don't know what Amazon is doing. We know that Apple is uh filing some patents and hiring VR engineers, so there's certainly a lot of motion in the space.
1:13 Speaker 0 Sony. Sony's got Project Morpheus for kind of the the console specific play. Yeah. Aaron Powell So
1:18 Speaker 1 how do you think about VR versus AR? Like what are the different first of all, like which do you think will happen sooner? Um, how optimistic are you about each what are the different use cases? Aaron Powell
1:28 Speaker 0 I was uh you know it's interesting. I think people saw a usable case of AR first, popularly speaking, when Nintendo 3DS came out. That was kind of a really low-fi version. Um it gave people a sense of what was possible. It's
1:43 Speaker 1 not like like the the games that came with it with the cards, like I saw though, those were really cool. But there were there wasn't a ton of follow-up as far as I remember. Trevor Burrus, Jr. And and I think
1:51 Speaker 0 this is the case with a lot of what Nintendo does. Developers don't necessarily take advantage of the
1:56 Speaker 1 functionality.
1:58 Speaker 0 Right. So they had these cool cards that came with the 3DS that that when you looked through uh the the 3DS had kind of this front-facing camera and it would bring characters
2:07 Speaker 1 to life out of the state. It was the 3D effect too is surprisingly good.
2:10 Speaker 0 Yeah, it was really, really well done. And so I think that AR was almost in the ether just a little bit earlier, and certainly, you know, uh Oculus caught fire and and you know the story well in 2012. So we've had a couple of years now to get used to it. But after, you know, I've spent a lot of time, you know, with a bunch of different companies talking about this and thinking about this. And VR is going to be well is first to market already. I mean, with the Samsung Gear VR that came out in December, we have a consumer product for sale. That is a big that's a big leap leap to make. Um and then certainly I think that more of the technical problems have been solved for virtual reality rather than augmented reality. Um
2:52 Speaker 1 and just to specifically, I think the uh to me, at least the big bottleneck with AR is to do it well for most applications, you're gonna need very good machine vision.
3:01 Speaker 0 Right. Right. Because
3:02 Speaker 1 you're gonna you don't want if if you have the real world there, you want to have the virtual overlay interact with the real world. And to do that, you have to understand the real world. And and to do that, my understanding from the technologists is that to do that in a very low latency kind of real-time way is far beyond the current capabilities. Right. Like if you've tried Crescent Bay, like it's working, right? Yeah,
3:22 Speaker 0 it's it's definitely working. And and certainly, you know, I haven't I haven't used Magic Leap. I've used uh uh a number of different kind of not quite consumer-ready AR technologies, but what I understand from people who have experienced Magic Leap and what they're working on there is it's gonna take half a billion dollars to make this real to realize this. And so while they have kind of these prototype experiences, there's so much more to do, and there's so many more problems to be solved. And I think you're absolutely right. It's it's kind of exponentially more complex to layer artifice over the world that you actually see whereas with with VR, you have kind of the luxury of being able to pre-render everything that a person might see, at least in a CGI scenario in a gaming scenario or something like that.
4:08 Speaker 1 And especially with and that whole info the other thing too, I think is the tool chain kind of like the Unity and Unreal and all the different things you do to build VR, but has already been built up pretty it's those are pretty powerful tools for the gaming world. And also just all the talent and everything else. It's just sort of like as soon as they get excited, it's you can shift it over pretty quickly.
4:25 Speaker 0 Oh yeah, that's that's very true. And certainly since you know it was last March that the Facebook acquisition happened, but since then the the kind of quantum quantum leap that happened at Oculus is all of a sudden with that backing, they'd had multiple rounds of funding, as you well know, but after they had this vote of confidence uh from someone who clearly isn't going anywhere, all of a sudden the talent started coming. Like they had this very Spartan mentality, like we need 300 people who are the absolute best at what they do, and they just keep poaching and keep poaching and keep adding new people. And just today, you know, we're we're recording this on a Monday, and at Sundance this morning they announced that Oculus Story Studio, which is this um this venture to develop CGI filmmaking, and they got um they got Edward Sachi and they got Sashka Unseld from Pixar. Um so they're getting pretty incredible talent even outside the gaming space.
5:13 Speaker 0 Gaming was where they started, and so they were able to lay a lot of groundwork and certainly with Unreal and Unity streamlining that process. The question now is for me at least, what's gonna happen in the realm of of live action video, because there's so many problems that need to be solved there.
5:29 Speaker 1 I also think that I'd be curious if you think it's right. I my sort of framework for it is VR will be more about play, because it's a fully, you know, it's a fully invented world, whether I I I personally think it'll be less I think games will be big, but I think it'll be a lot of like what's happening with the Hollywood stuff, kind of quote experiences. But but they're completely new worlds, right? Whereas once you've introduced like once I'm looking at AR, I'm looking at my office, like generally that is you know, is is more for a work context, right? You're overlaying information, you're you know, Googling, magically Googling everything you see, right? I think so. That's kind of my broader.
6:00 Speaker 0 No, I think that's true. And and certainly after um after the wired story about HoloLens came out last week, I saw a couple tweets of yours, and and I think you nailed it there. That um I think I think I
6:11 Speaker 1 was debating with startup, like a fictional Twitter character. I think that was you and Startup L. Jackson, right? There were worse people to think I have to reflect on my life when I have spending my afternoon with an imaginary person, but anyways. Worst people, worse people to debate
6:26 Speaker 0 with. But I think you're right. I think the enterprise applications for AR are the the kind of driving thing right now, and certainly um even players that aren't Google and are uh aren't Magic Leap and aren't um and aren't Microsoft recognize this, you know. There are companies that their entire kind of uh raison debt is is working on this instructional overlay. And certainly that's what uh our writer Jesse Hempel saw when she got hands-on with the HoloLens uh, you know, up at Microsoft. And you're right. Um I think absolutely that there is this there's a recreational bent to VR. Not which isn't to say we're not gonna have productivity suites in there, and you're not gonna be able to tell a conference and you're not gonna be able to have kind of in uh you're gonna have a virtual desktop display when when resolution catches up to this, and and we'll be able to kind of overhaul what we think of as workspace.
7:19 Speaker 0 But for the most part, I think that that is a very easy uh uh divergence point of the two technologies. Aaron Powell
7:26 Speaker 1 So do we know does Microsoft it's they're gonna pursue some kind of gaming thing with the HoloLens? It's it's part of their Xbox group, right?
7:33 Speaker 0 It's it's hard to say because you know, since Nadela came in and took over from Ballmer, I think it's possible that the original roadmap has changed. And in 2012, I think there was a a kind of internal roadmap that leaked, and part of that was you saw people wearing these AR glasses, and they they meant it to be part of the Xbox Entertainment group. I think that's changed. We'd heard
7:57 Speaker 1 about it because when we invested in Oculus, whatever it was a year and a half ago, we did, you know, we were sort of analyzing the competitors and had heard a bunch of rumors about that, but had heard it was a gaming and it was very good, by the way. Um like the best out there.
8:09 Speaker 0 Yeah.
8:10 Speaker 1 Outside of Oculus.
8:11 Speaker 0 I think I think that's true. I mean, as different as as the two are. But I think that uh, you know, I think that it may have started that way, but I would imagine that with what they're doing with every device stuff and and what they're trying to do with Windows 10, I would imagine that HoloLens is gonna be a
8:25 Speaker 1 more integral part of that than it was originally intended to be.
8:27 Speaker 0 So I would I would be surprised if they weren't trying to leverage their enterprise world. Aaron Powell
8:33 Speaker 1 And then Google, do you do we have any sense beyond like the the cardboard stuff and you know, is is there like gonna be a serious effort, Magic Leap?
8:40 Speaker 0 As far uh well, I mean, so cardboard is cardboard is the kind of lowest of the low end of the of the VR solutions. Um but with Magic Leap, the way they talk about it, not the way Google talks about it, but the way uh Magic Leap talks about it is they see it as this magical intersection of the two. And I think that we're probably and actually we're gonna move to this point where one device is gonna be able to handle both, whether that's fully contained VR or Switch, you know, on some continuum to to an AR overlay. But I think that the way I I think that the two are different. I mean, cardboard came out of that 20% time thing and they handed it out to developers at I.O. and they were like, see what you can do. And so Street View is cool, um, and people are doing some interesting things for such a uh for such a kind of low processor solution.
9:26 Speaker 0 But I think that what Google sees in Magic Leap is something that's uh a lot more transformative than that. Aaron Powell
9:33 Speaker 1 So what do you think? So what's your prediction for the next couple years in terms of you know Oculus comes out, like will it be a gaming device? Will you know
9:43 Speaker 0 it's gonna be it's gonna be an entertainment device, right? I think we both know that. And I think that while it it they position themselves as gaming first, I think they're they're gonna come out of the gate with a lot of uh non-gaming entertainment things, just like the Samsung Gear VR had, you know, they they commissioned a lot of 362. Degree video, they commissioned a lot of uh other experiences, and and certainly there are companies now that are that are cracking streaming VR experiences. So I think that we're looking at kind of a media viewer and a streaming viewer and a gaming device. So, you know, there are all the the developer community working in Oculus, even outside the kind of triple A houses that have their seeker projects, the development community has been so fanatical and the pipeline is so robust that there are already so many games that you can play just for a dev kit.
10:31 Speaker 0 I mean Elite Dangerous. Have
10:32 Speaker 1 you played uh like Blaze Rush, for example? I haven't played Blazer Up. So I've been I was playing all weekend, I have one at home. And uh uh it what's really surprised me is and Lucky's Tale, have you seen Lucky Sales? Oh yeah, yeah, Lucky Sale's
10:42 Speaker 0 phenomenal. So
10:43 Speaker 1 Blaze Rush and Lucky Tail, I think are the two best games so far on the Oculus. And what's surprising is they're both third person.
10:48 Speaker 0 Yeah,
10:48 Speaker 1 um, and they're not the flashiest first person kind of now and like Elite Dangerous is cool. I I um I guess the qu I mean, so I want to hesitate here because uh until you have incredibly good, you know, like the top triple A game designers build stuff. I don't want to overgeneralize. Um have you seen a Crescent Bay demo? Yeah,
11:07 Speaker 0 yeah.
11:07 Speaker 1 Like the part where you're like in the street with a robot. Show down that epic with the slow motion bullets. Like that's when you when you see that, you're like, okay, that's those are the gears. I think that's the Gears of War Team. Once you see like the pros make stuff, you're like, okay, maybe I have to reconsider. Right. Because I be prior to seeing that, I was like first person's not gonna work as well. Then I saw that, I'm like, okay, maybe now that I see the pros do it. But think about Blaze Rush, though, it's a very boring game. No offense to the Blaze Rush guys if it's not Oculus. Like I played it on the screen. It's just like a cars, it's like you're watching cars from a third person go around track. First person, it is amazing. Like I literally played it for six hours this weekend. Like the the missiles, like things are blowing up anybody that we have the stereo headphones, and like the missiles like flying past your head, and like guys are like blowing up, and it's just like and and it that's only one player. If you get two players, like it's really engaging, and it there's no like nausea or anything else or like weirdness.
11:53 Speaker 0 Well, the game design question, I think that if if it's gonna be first person, it either has to be slowed drastically to what kind of fast switch games are, or you have to give the person a stable, you have to give the player a stable environment like a car chassis, right? That changes everything because all of a sudden you have this fairly pretty good, yeah. Yeah. And
12:09 Speaker 1 or space, like Elite Danger.
12:11 Speaker 0 Exactly, because you're surrounded by something that's not going to be.
12:14 Speaker 1 No, it's like a kind of a racing one. It's good.
12:16 Speaker 0 I think that we're gonna see uh for first person, it's gonna be a lot of uh exploration games. I think you know, Jonathan Blow, who made Braid has been working on this game, the witness for a long time, and it's this kind of very it's a throwback to mist and puzzle games like that, but he's it it was not originally meant for VR, but he's working on it to play in the rift. And I think that first person you're gonna need to slow things down. That's what made that epic demo and crescent bass so compelling is they slowed it way down. It was bullet time. You could kind of move through it at your at your leisure. And what John Carmack has said um in some tweets recently is he thinks it might be best if you just take control over yaw uh kind of uh left to right swivel away from the player. Um not left to right swivel, left to right strafing. Um actual movement uh on the code. Maybe more like
13:00 Speaker 1 you're on Rails, kind of like old, you know, like Dragon's layer games or whatever where you sort of like have a few key decision points.
13:06 Speaker 0 Yep. And I and what some other people are doing is rather than letting you uh, you know, if you're using an uh an X back, an Xbox controller, you can think of as a PlayStation one if that's your preferred console, is if you're using that that right thumbstick to swivel on the neck of the player. Some designers are using the shoulder buttons instead to click this and you'll instantaneously swivel 90 degrees. And what that does is it takes the world doesn't spin around you. And as much as as used to as you can be for first of uh to first person experiences, having the entire 360 degree sphere that you're living in move around you is uh it's a profoundly disorienting thing. And so while I think you're right, I think we're gonna have great first person experiences, they need to be in the hands of people who have done some really, really deep thinking about what works and what doesn't.
13:53 Speaker 1 Yeah. Um and we mentioned Lucky's Tale, which I think is amazing. And like that's one where I don't think it's publicly available right now. Uh I'm not sure. It's sort of a Nintendo S, like Mario World-esque.
14:04 Speaker 0 There may be a demo available on Samsung.
14:07 Speaker 1 The thing about that is like you bring, and I've done this, you bring non-gamers over and they try it, and like it has the it has the kind of wonder of like the original Nintendo or something. Oh, yeah, that's like everyone loves it. It's not a game hardcore gamer experience. That
14:19 Speaker 0 was my first that was my first reaction to it as well. I saw it, I guess it was last year at E3, they brought it, and uh I was like, yeah, third person, we'll see. And I put it on and it takes you back. It is it is as kind of cartoonishly brilliant as those early Nintendo games the first time you played Mario. The difference is they've done some such good thinking about camera control and and how to root a to ground a person in this game world without moving them around. You can control what you see, but it's done at such kind of gentle speeds that you're never gonna get uncomfortable in that.
14:52 Speaker 1 Nintendo should be all over this. Like that they I don't know. I mean, they need they need something, they need a hook. And this when you see Lucky's Tale, like this is how uh you know, imagine like Super Smash Brothers and how awesome it would be. Oh
15:03 Speaker 0 my god. Yeah, I mean, look, Nintendo made their play with NFC, you know, the the the nearfield stuff with um with amoebos, which are which were kind of popular among dedicated gamers, but we've seen for well over a decade now, they take three or four years to move on a technology that's already changing the landscape. So, you know, if that's the direction they go, and and Miyamoto has certainly cautioned us against thinking that they're doing this. Um I think they want to see how it plays out. They're so cautious about that stuff and they're so reserved that it wouldn't surprise me if they go that way. AR didn't really pan out for them. Um but yeah, they've got they've got the IP to really make that worthwhile. Yeah,
15:43 Speaker 1 the the what's so exciting to me now, like actually Paul Bettner, who's um Lucky Tale uh this came from him. He said uh it's like he says it's like the beginning of film when you know the Lumera brothers, like the trains coming at them and everyone thinks it's actually coming at them, or or he he the example he gave is before they had the notion of an establishing shot in film, you know, establishing shot is like when you show the building outside and then you show before that they would if you watch like the old like Charlie Chaplin movies, it's have like 10 minutes of just people going in and out of Grand Central State. Like they didn't understand how the they didn't understand like the neuroscience, so to speak, right of how the brain interprets film and creates a reality, right? Um and I think we're at that that's what Paul this is I'm quoting Paul here, but um we're at that that period now with VR, right? So people are just figuring out what and it's gonna be really, really interesting. Do you know Chris Milk?
16:28 Speaker 0 Oh yeah, I was just about to bring him up because the
16:30 Speaker 1 stuff he's working on is fascinating and uh doing music videos and other Did you try the Beck thing?
16:36 Speaker 0 I tried the Beck thing, and actually, you know, it's funny that you say uh the the Lumier Brothers just one of the one of the experiences that he has at Sundance right now is this kind of abstract take on the uh the the train coming the train pulling into the station. It
16:49 Speaker 1 was the one that freaked out all the
16:50 Speaker 0 French audiences in in like 1890s uh when they first saw it. But we're at the dawn of this new visual grammar, right? Filmmakers are trying to figure this out because no one's had to we've been viewing movies through a frame for so long that that we have no idea how to approach these, and then be even beyond that, beyond the logic of like establishing shots and and like you said, how people's brains interpret signals. If you're in a in a sphere of reality and you can look anywhere, and action is going to unfold quite possibly in a different zone of that screen. What's going to cue you to be looking at the thing that's narratively most important to the to the movie experience? And you know, there's some I've seen some really interesting um kind of papers and and thinking from some groups who are trying to, at least for for rendered movies for CGI stuff, trying to create almost like a new code where zones will be highlighted and little kind of very subtle changes.
17:44 Speaker 1 Control the attention. Yeah,
17:45 Speaker 0 to control the attention. Just because we um, you know, when you're sitting in an IMAX theater, there's pretty one there's one thing you're gonna be looking at, and even if you're looking at the upper left corner of the screen, something needs to happen at the lower right, you're gonna know about it. This is very different. Something can happen behind you. And I think that you know, Oculus's move to pursue directional audio was a really smart one to make it an integrated part of their consumer solution. Because we got so used to putting on headphones, just stereo headphones or maybe even surround sound to play games in VR, but you're gonna need something that's uh a half-turn past that. You're gonna need something that's truly calibrated to a to it to that environment.
18:25 Speaker 1 Have you seen like have you seen how Chris Milk does his recordings? No,
18:28 Speaker 0 huh? No,
18:29 Speaker 1 he actually has a um plastic human head with ears all around it because so it turns out like the reason that you that you know a sound is behind you is your brain is trained to to know that when it hits like the shape of your ear will alter the sound. And so your brain knows if it if the sound sounds a certain way, it's to the right of you. If it sounds a different way, it's behind you because of the shape of your ear. So the only way to properly record 3D sound is to have basically a head with a bunch of ears on it. And then as you turn, this is and as you turn, then the the sound turns appropriately. That's the way you trick your brain. So that's
19:04 Speaker 0 fascinating. So I have a question for you, actually. You know, I've been thinking a lot about this, and you know, there are a lot of players entering this space, and I think that Oculus is is happy about this, and there's room for everyone, but we have this spectrum that's emerged now, right? You have kind of low end devices like Google cardboard or any clamshell device that lets you basically plug a smartphone in if it doesn't have any onboard processing. And then you have kind of Samsung Gear VR, which is a little bit between the two. It has a little bit of onboard work that's being done, and then you have kind of full standalone uh peripheral that works with a with a dedicated computer. We're gonna I would imagine we're gonna need standards at some point. Yeah, right. We're gonna need um something that is kind of certified VR. You know, I was uh last week I was at this event in uh in Miami, and I ended up meeting the guy who started the meant to be seen forums, which was this uh message board for 3D and later VR, which is where Palmer and CarMac first
19:59 Speaker 1 connected.
20:00 Speaker 0 So he and I were talking and he he kind of made me see the light about this. He said, you know, what is gonna stop someone from claiming uh that a product is VR just because you can put on goggles. Yeah. Right. Because there's still a lot of consumer products out there that are basically just hanging a screen in front of your eyes and aren't delivering that transport of experience. So
20:20 Speaker 1 I think it's a great so I think one to me, one of the big open questions is how good does a VR have to be to for people to embrace it, right? So I think if you talk to like Brendan at Oculus, he's got a very, very high bar, arguably too high. Like he doesn't think like to me, Crescent Bay, you know, is clearly a you know uh it's ready to go ready to go. And he, you know, he's still like wants to, you know, he still wants to make it better. Um he's got a very, very high bar. Other people I talked to, I think Chris Milk is one, think we're all old people who grew up on in the era of what he calls rectangle fetishism and back when people stare at rectangles on the wall. And those people fetishists so the rectangle fetishists believe that um you know you've been so trained not to see this, but when the tw like the six year old you put a Samsung thing on a six-year-old and they don't, you know, they're off to the races it's like all you know, it's like they they don't need much better.
21:07 Speaker 1 And of course they'll watch their movies in a virtual movie theater with their Samsung on. So there's sort of like what you might call like the VR maximalist view of like Brendan and the minimalist. And I don't know the answer. I mean, I think I tend to my instinct is is more on the Brendan side. I think you need to make it really, really good, uh, especially people are gonna use it for six hours or something. Um, and like the DK too, I love it, but there's a screen door effect. Oh, yeah. There's uh the field of view, you know, the refresh rate, there's issues, right? Um so I tend to think that, and therefore, you know, uh as you can't really impose standards to say everyone has to make something just as awesome as Oculus who's spending billions of dollars, right? So if you're a maximalist, it's hard to imagine standards emerging anytime soon because it's gonna be you know a constant horse race. It'd be like it'd be like back in the PC era in the 90s saying everyone has to have a top-tier Pentium, like just not realistic, right?
21:56 Speaker 1 So I don't I it's that's a big question to me. Is like what will you like how much of this is just that we grew up in the non-VR era and expect the standards to be very high? How much is you know the other thing is interesting is right, like you people talk about simulator sickness, and I think up until two years ago, everyone thought that had to do uh people we talked to when we invested in Oculus, they also had to do with the latency, right? The latency in between your head, it's it's motion to photon, your head moves and then your eye gets updated, right? And then it turns out basically like Oculus is now solved that. Like it's it's it's low enough, it's whatever it is, 10 milliseconds doesn't matter. Um yet you still and you generally don't get sick, but like you still get like if a zombie jumps out from the right side of your, you know, you know, from from behind you, you get scared, and potentially if enough of that happens, you get sick.
22:41 Speaker 1 So I think we've moved beyond the point where the sickness comes from technical issues. It now comes from the fact that you your body feels like you're in a different world.
22:50 Speaker 0 Oh, yeah. And
22:50 Speaker 1 people can do things to you in that world that have a strong emotional impact on you, right? So we sort of move beyond to my mind the technical into the sort of the the like you talked about standards. I think there's gonna be more like standards like you can't have zombies just jump out on people. That's almost like that's like a that's like you know, the whatever the federal department that regulates VRs is you know what I mean. It's
23:10 Speaker 0 the may cause seizures of VR.
23:13 Speaker 1 To me, there's two so to answer your question, there's sort of two levels, right? There's the technical level of what do you need minimally to convince people and not have simulator sickness, and then there's what is the con what are the rules of the content in that world? Because your body, it's a different fit feeling than what seeing something on the screen.
23:27 Speaker 0 Yeah, game design best practices is gonna be a huge part of this. And I think one of the best things to come out of Epic's kind of close partnership with Oculus throughout their entire development process is they're really up there at at the front lines figuring out what works and what doesn't. They they created you know the vast majority of those early demos through DK1, DK2, um, and like you said, they did that kind of PS Resistance on uh on uh Crescent Bay. And um so they and you know, every triple A studio has them and is working with it, but there are going to be, I think, maybe categories. Um and we see this now. If you put on your Samsung and you go to the store, you see uh most people will be comfortable, uncomfortable for some, uncomfortable for many, and it's this very squishy scale.
24:13 Speaker 0 Um, but that's based on how dynamic is the action, how much does your perspective move around the world? Um and I think that that actually maybe is a clue to how we're gonna see this evolve. Is there maybe there's just gonna be uh a scale of probably not one to ten, but I would imagine it's on a G through NC17 type of hierarchy, right? Where only the most battle-hardened, you know, uh call of duty heads will be able to handle something. And you know, I'm I'm a big believer in the idea that those experiences should be available to those who want them, should a studio be willing to invest in that.
24:49 Speaker 1 Turn it off. Yeah, turn it off faster, more violent. Think about like the kids playing like this. And
24:54 Speaker 0 yeah, you think
24:55 Speaker 1 about those
24:55 Speaker 0 kinds of things. Yeah, think about the kind of the sniper montages you see of kids running around a Call of Duty map, no scoping everyone and doing a 360 turn in between. And it's dizzying to watch in YouTube. Imagine playing that, and that's how they're gonna want to do it. But like
25:09 Speaker 1 turn it up, make it tomorrow
25:11 Speaker 0 up. It's terrifying.
25:14 Speaker 1 It's gonna be awesome. Um so on the on the uh developer side. So we have you know, if you go on the the Reddit forums or an Oculus Share, there's tons of kind of indie excitement. Um I think Oculus has a few partnerships. But you know, what what are you seeing in terms of like the you know, is why I guess the question I have is why isn't you know EA and Activision, all these guys, you know, going heavy into it, or do you think they will at some point? I think they are
25:37 Speaker 0 I think they have. I think that um, you know, I think that there's some value maybe in for a studio at least in waiting for those specs to get a little more firmly entrenched. I don't know if Crescent.
25:49 Speaker 1 Yeah, I think it's to the risk, the market risk.
25:52 Speaker 0 I think uh I think a lot of people like a lot of prospective employees were swayed by the acquisition last year. Um I think that you know it was
26:02 Speaker 1 interesting, you know, like you say that because you know, we live in a different world where startups are able like the game world's different than the than the than the venture capital startup world, and it's funny because we uh we like for example Michael Abrish, we try I actually flew up to Seattle a couple weeks before um the Facebook acquisition because we were trying to recruit him for so long. Um and then once Facebook happened, I think it was the day after, literally. He and so the in the game world you're right, like they don't believe in kind of startup equity as much. And like Facebook coming in with like cold to hard cash.
26:31 Speaker 0 That's real to them.
26:32 Speaker 1 Made a big big difference in the developer world.
26:34 Speaker 0 But but also I mean that the way the way the gaming ecosystem has changed is there's this huge middle ground that used to exist and and no longer does, right? So you have all these really small, vibrant indie games, and then on the uh other end of the spectrum you have
26:49 Speaker 1 shaped, it's the very indie and the very big very
26:51 Speaker 0 indie and very big. So what I don't think we're gonna see in the early years are very big. We're not gonna see destiny done for VR. We're not gonna see EA buy in at a hundred million dollar level. I think what we are gonna see quite possibly is obviously the proliferation of indie games that are made for it just because that's what's happening now. But I think that we may see a slight return of this idea of the double-A game, these things that used to exist. You know, there were a lot of games that maybe they were 10 bucks cheaper than the big games you would buy, but they were a full-fledged, really polished game experience, and I think that you can spend 10 million dollars on something, 20 million dollars on something without the risk of going all in on the next Assassin's Creed being VR. You know, you don't have to be able to do that. People under
27:33 Speaker 1 I think people underestimate the size of the, for example, the Steam PC gaming community. Oh my god, it's massive, and those are the obvious early adopters for VR.
27:42 Speaker 0 And the games that are so huge on Steam are games that are just a uh a grain of sand to the console gamer, things like Kentucky Root Zero and you know, even the telltale game stuff. It's just uh there's a really solid foundation for smaller games. And that's what those are gonna be uniquely well suited, I think, to VR in general.
28:04 Speaker 1 So uh Sundance just happened. Yeah. I think did you write anything?
28:08 Speaker 0 We've I'm editing stuff. I have a couple of letters. You guys had
28:10 Speaker 1 some articles about I thought about um about this, and apparently VR was was uh one of the hot topics there. Yeah.
28:16 Speaker 0 Well, it's all taking place for the most part within the New Frontiers program, which is kind of the more experimental thing. So there are I think there may be seven uh things that were built for VR, any th everything from cardboard to Samsung to to the DK too. Um and then obviously, as we mentioned, the Oculus Story Studio announcement came out and Chris Milk's announcement um that he's working with Annapurna pictures, um to this company Verse, which is basically a distribution platform that he's making for VR filmmakers, and then he's got other prongs of that as well. And a Perna is also working with Vice and Vice News put together this really cool VR experience of being at the uh the millions march, the the police brutality marches in NYC this past fall. They they brought a setup there, and you know, this is so dependent on people solving the live action capture.
29:07 Speaker 0 And there are there are a lot of ways that it can go wrong. I mean, it's
29:11 Speaker 1 these very there's a lot of companies like John is one, right? These cool 3D cameras.
29:15 Speaker 0 Next VR is another.
29:23 Speaker 0 Some people are just making their own array of reds, uh kind of around a poll. Framestore is is exploring some really cool things they're doing with video. Um and so there are a lot of people in the space, but I think the way it's looking right now is a lot of that is just gonna stay proprietary. I don't think we're gonna find a um uh an all-in-one solution.
29:42 Speaker 1 You think do you think we'll see like a big um investment from Hollywood?
29:47 Speaker 0 Oh yeah, I think we already I think we already are. I mean, I think that every time a big developer tries it, they're blown away. I mean, uh from Alfonso Quarone to Cronenberg, um and like I said, that now that Pixar people are are working. Working on CGI movies with them, we're already seeing that. They've had people, you know, Oculus has had um I'm gonna forget his name while I'm on the spot, but they had a Hollywood liaison for about a year now, and those fruits are certainly paying off. What we what we we saw very early was studios getting in to VR for ancillary marketing purposes. You had the Interstellar thing, you had the Game of Thrones thing, you had um you had the Pacific Rim thing. And I think that the the potential of those was was borne out really quickly. I think now they're they're starting to crack those narrative questions that lead to an actual film experience.
30:34 Speaker 1 All right, awesome. Well, thanks a lot for being here.
30:36 Speaker 0 Thanks for having me in, Chris.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated