Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast: The Macro and Micro of Parenting About this episode We tend to talk about tech and parenting through devices and artifacts -- screen time, to code or not to code -- but actually, there's a bigger, macro picture at play there: game theory, economic incentives, culture, and more. So in this back-to-scho...
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Hanne Tidnam? Hi and welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Hannah and today's episode is a hallway style conversation in honor of back to school season on the economics of parenting, but not in quite the way you'd think. So much of the discussion around parenting and tech today is about the use of specific products or devices. So in this conversation, we wanted to broaden the context and instead explore what it means to use economics as a framework for understanding the nature of parenting. For example, using game theory to think about parenting in terms of our interactions, our choices, incentives, but also the way broader economic environments change parenting styles in different cultures. And last but not least, how tech might be impacting all of that. The first voice you'll hear is Kevin Zolman,
0:43 Hanne Tidnam? professor at CMU, a game theorist and philosopher and co-author of the recent book, The Game Theorist's Guide to Parenting. And the second voice is Fabrizio Zilibati, a macroeconomist at Yale, working on a book called Love, Money, and Parenting.
0:56 Speaker 01 One of the real central struggles for parents, I think, is making this balance between, you know, what makes life easy today, what gets your kid to stop crying or to stop fighting with you or whatever, and what makes a good kid in the long run. You know, you can give them an extra cookie now and they'll stop bugging you for it, but also you're not teaching them good eating habits. We try to find ways of planning and designing their interactions with their kids so that they can get their kids to do things that are both in the long-term interest of the of the child, but also make life easy on the parents.
1:31 Hanne Tidnam? And that's where game theory comes in.
1:33 Speaker 01 And that's exactly where game theory comes in. Yeah, we describe game theory as the science of strategic interaction. And the idea here is that anytime you've got two different people whose interests aren't exactly the same, you know, you have a child who wants another cookie for dessert and a parent who wants their kid to finish their vegetables. And so one of the focuses of game theory has been on how can you create strategic interactions, games, between two different individuals so that both individuals can come out in a way that's good for both of them?
2:04 Hanne Tidnam? Can you give us an example of the ways in which that that tends to play out in sort of real, concrete, daily parenting dilemmas?
2:11 Speaker 01 You're driving on vacation, the kids are harassing one another in the backseat, and dad turns around and says, if you guys don't behave, we're canceling the vacation. Right.
2:20 Hanne Tidnam? Which is you're never supposed to do because then inevitably it happens.
2:24 Speaker 01 It happens.
2:25 Hanne Tidnam? What do you do then?
2:26 Speaker 01 Yeah. Exactly. Every parent knows you're not supposed to do it, but they all, but everyone finds themselves doing it nonetheless. In game theory terms, this is called a non-credible threat. And the reason that it's a non-credible threat is because the kids, if they're sophisticated enough, and most kids are, will realize that mom or dad doesn't want to cancel the vacation any more than the kid does.
2:49 Hanne Tidnam? Right. You're in the car, it's packed, you're on your way, there's no way.
2:53 Speaker 01 Exactly. And by not designing the interaction in the right way, you end up putting yourselves in a no-win situation. The kids have called your bluff, you don't want to cancel the vacation, but you also don't want to establish a reputation with your kids that your threats mean nothing. And so, one of the things that game theory teaches, you want to design punishments or rewards for your kids that are possible for you to follow through on and that you want to follow through on. So instead of going to the amusement park in the morning, maybe you'll go to a museum. That's a threat that's credible because the kids know you'll want to go to the museum.
3:27 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
3:28 Speaker 01 But that you would be happy to follow through on if the time come.
3:31 Hanne Tidnam? Fabrizio, as a macroeconomist, your work kind of telescopes out and looks at parenting from that macro level. In your work, you talk about, just to set a little context, the three major parenting styles. Authoritarian, where parents really strongly determine what's allowed and isn't, and don't give kids much opportunity for feedback, or backtalk really. Permissive parenting, which is really the opposite, where parents give kids lots of freedom and choice, and even sometimes kind of allow them to be the leaders. And then authoritative, which is a kind of positive middle ground and the way that we're, I think, being told now to parent, where parents are in charge but allow kids some agency as well. So how do those different styles play out in different situations and different contexts?
4:14 Speaker 02 We think that parents have some common goals in different parts of the world, but that the environment and the constraints they are subject to are different, especially the changes in economic inequality.
4:30 Hanne Tidnam? Yes.
4:30 Speaker 02 And we look at variation across nations over time. So comparing the seventies with the nineties or the turn of the century, comparing Sweden with the United States or China. So on the one hand, we think that most parents want their children to be happy. This altruistic concern. At the same time, you know, happiness is a concept that refers to the present and to the future. So you can have a very happy child and a less happy adult, depending also on some choices that are made during childhood or when a youngster.
5:10 Speaker 02 So we postulate that parents somehow think the good for their children, but with a stronger emphasis on their future. Children also care about their own future, but somehow they are a bit more present oriented. And that's the part we call paternalism. That's the reason why parents try to influence the choice or the views of the world of children.
5:35 Hanne Tidnam? Interesting. So you're describing the interaction of parenting basically as this combination of paternalism and altruism, but really having to do with whether you're thinking about the now or the future. I mean, but aren't those different ways of seeing things? Basically, kids really thinking about the now and parents thinking about their kids' future and what's best for the future. Isn't that kind of just the definition of parenting?
5:56 Speaker 02 There is an element of common interest between parents and children, you know, the drive to success. And then there is an element of dissonance, of the diversity of views, where parents care more for their children when they will be adults. Whether it's more the economic part of it or other way of enjoying life when we think about parents and children, if we think that parents and children value them differently. So if both parents and children think that, you know, being a great painter is a good thing, this type of conflict does not arise.
6:33 Hanne Tidnam? It's really about whether they're aligned with their children or have a different point of view.
6:38 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
6:38 Hanne Tidnam? So where do these two ways of interacting meet then? This sort of large picture of parents and children being aligned or not about the future and the now? And the more micro daily strategic interactions that Kevin described?
6:53 Speaker 02 Game theory typically stipulates that payoffs are essentially given. Cultural economics have tried to put a new level of elaboration on that. So the idea that one of the investment an agent can make is in changing somehow the payoff of the other. We reason that way when we try to persuade children. The children are fighting on the back of the car. Another way some parents act is to try to convince day by day children that fighting in the back of the car is not worthy and it has some negative moral aspect.
7:34 Speaker 02 If you go back one century or more, my grandparents, my grand grandparents' generation, most of the interaction between parents and children was regulated by restrictions. So parents were telling children what they could do and what they could not do. We think they were doing it on the ground, again, on this altruism and paternalism.
7:53 Hanne Tidnam? Right, the same driving factors, but it was coming out another way.
7:58 Speaker 02 One of the changes that we have seen in the way in which parents strategically influence the way children behave is driven by this change in the system of incentive and also in how much control and monitor parents can exercise. We think that this is one of the reasons why a certain way of authoritarian parenting style has declined. Corporal punishment, we see decline everywhere in the world. One of the reasons we think is that its effectiveness is lower in the new environment, in the new economic environment.
8:33 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, interesting. It's not because our cultures have changed, but because it's actually less effective in what we want the outcome to be?
8:40 Speaker 02 Yes, there is a two ways interaction between culture and economics. Once a certain set of behaviors become more or less acceptable, then they become also ingrained.
8:51 Hanne Tidnam? Kevin, do you see these parenting styles also in sort of how you think about your game theorist lens of looking at parenting interactions? Or I guess a bigger way to ask that question is, what do you see the role of culture playing in these particular dilemmas and conflicts that parents and children have?
9:07 Speaker 01 I think culture plays a huge role. I think that, you know, the fact that children are in a lot of respects much more independent of their parents these days than than they were in the, you know, much, much distant past.
9:20 Hanne Tidnam? Do you think so? I feel like they're actually less independent. They don't roam around town on their bikes the way we did when we were kids. They've all got phones. We know where they are all the time.
9:29 Speaker 01 Well, they're they're more independent in the following way, let me say, which is that there's a lot of interactions that kids have where the parents aren't present. You know, a century or two centuries ago, kids weren't going to school. They weren't leaving the house. They weren't interacting over at friends' houses as much. One of the fundamental problems that modern parents face is the fact that in some respects, kids know more about what's going on in the kids' lives than the parents do. So, you know, you your child is doing poorly in school and comes home and says, I'm working as hard as I can, you know, but I just can't manage to do well. Well, here are parents face a real struggle. Because on the one hand, if if the child is deceiving them, is really not working that
10:12 Speaker 01 hard, the parent would like to do various things to encourage the child to work harder. On the other hand, if the kid really is working as hard as they can, and this is just the best they can do, it's counterproductive for the parent to criticize them for getting a C or a B or whatever.
10:27 Hanne Tidnam? Well, and I'm really glad you bring this up because I wanted to ask, where does truth and fiction fit into these models? You know, are we are we assuming that we have a basic understanding of the facts? And are we actually assuming that children are rational players here in these strategic interactions?
10:42 Speaker 01 I definitely think kids are rational. But one of my favorite stories, I've got it secondhand, but was of an economist's son who ran into the store and came out holding two candy bars and said, Dad, can I have two candy bars? And Dad says, no, no, no, you can only have one. And the kid gets this giant smile on his face because of course he only wanted one, but he knew that if he asked for two, the compromise would be at one.
11:06 Hanne Tidnam? Right, right.
11:07 Speaker 01 Kids are sophisticated strategic reasoners in figuring out how to get what they would like to from their parents.
11:14 Hanne Tidnam? And that truth and lies fits into that then because they're using it ultimately to get what they want.
11:21 Speaker 01 Absolutely. I mean, every parent has to go through the struggle of teaching their kid why lying is wrong. Because kids will figure out at some point that they can get what they want by deceiving their parents.
11:32 Hanne Tidnam? That it's useful, that lies are useful.
11:34 Speaker 01 Kids have access to all sorts of information that parents can't observe directly themselves, right? All parents here is the fight between the siblings in the next room. They don't know who started it because they weren't there. In situations where the parents are worried that their children might be facing an incentive to deceive them, how can parents sort of design the social interaction to minimize the consequence of that deception? Or the incentive to do it?
12:01 Speaker 02 If in the end, parents and children had exactly the same view of the world, there would be no game. So we go to the root of what makes parents and children see things differently. The interesting thing is that love that creates a common interest.
12:15 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, that is really interesting to think of the emotion of love as actually serving as a kind of common ground that aligns these interests and these different goals.
12:24 Speaker 02 Education is also a powerful instrument for parents in exercising some control through influence and moral persuasion on children. So if parents want to try to change the payoff in the game, so they try to change the way children behave by making them think differently in the game, well, more educated parents may have access to higher sophistication. But that's not to say that less. Educated parents are irrational. They may just have more limited set of instruments at disposal. Which comes to the point also why education is negatively correlated with punishment, with corporal punishment.
13:07 Speaker 02 And one of the answers is that, well, the set of strategy that more educated parents can play is more sophisticated. And that leaves somehow parents who have less time and lower education with a more simple way of intervening.
13:24 Hanne Tidnam? I thought it was really interesting that you said that we know less of what kids are experiencing than we once did. Because I think in a lot of ways, it feels like we actually know far more, right? With the technological tools and the way kids use technology, the way parents use technology, GPS data and texting and being always in touch and the way that schools, you know, send home information, there's ways in which we know a lot more. So how do you see that impacting different parenting styles?
13:52 Speaker 02 Children make many more choices than they used to be. And the same access to technology you mentioned per se, if unmonitored, opens up a variety of potential action contacts that parents may or may not approve. So parents work very hard in trying to grow their children responsible and make their choices. If I think about the wrong type of thing I could have done when I was myself a child, there were somehow obvious type of things my parents could check. But if my daughter, which is now 18, when she was younger, she would have engaged in some type of activities.
14:36 Speaker 02 Well, then it wouldn't have been so easy for me to figure out unless I engaged myself in a very extensive type of monitoring. On the one hand, this perception of risk as something completely intolerable. But this together with the fact that technologically you can do more control, there are instruments for doing that. Society has created. This cluster in which, you know, making the right encounter, going to the right school, giving the right answer in that particular interview, everything tends to be so important
15:15 Speaker 02 that parents feel that they have some sort of duty to be there and to intervene and to protect their children, although in the end they come back fired, essentially.
15:28 Speaker 01 I think that they're the same issues, they're just in slightly new clothing. I mean, parents could always keep track to greater and lesser degrees. Technology opens up a new avenue for them that wasn't there before. You know, you can keep the Facebook password or follow your kids on Twitter or something like that. But if kids want to hide their behavior from their parents, they still can. And so I think that the question of how to use technology is, in a certain sense, it just is the same questions all over again, just with new options available.
15:58 Hanne Tidnam? We talk a lot about in the media about helicopter parenting. I would think that Fabrizio, in terms of how much of a role technology is playing in sort of different socioeconomic frameworks and countries must have an effect on parenting styles, or has it not?
16:16 Speaker 02 Well, if I think of technological change as a driver of economic inequality, then we find a large effect. If I look at the effect of technology on inequality in different countries, that has resulted in some countries, very large increasing of skill premium, educational premium, et cetera, in others, less so. In Sweden, the proportion of parents that we classify as permissive has remained pretty much constant over time, and is about 75% of the respondents. Whereas in the United States, that percentage is
16:54 Speaker 02 as low as 18%. And if I go to those we classify as authoritative parents, again, in Sweden, it has been low and it has not changed much over time. It's around 7%. In the United States, it is as high as 45%, and it has Increased significantly over time, where this authoritative element, I think, captures part also of this phenomenon of helicopter parents.
17:22 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, you do think it's authoritative, that helicopter parenting?
17:26 Speaker 02 Well, if I had to capture the element of this continuous presence of parents in the life of their children, I would say it's a mixture of authoritative and authoritarian. Where authoritarian, since we sort of capture by the value of obedience is probably more of a traditional way of being authoritarian parents.
17:51 Hanne Tidnam? I see. To me, it seems that the element of control that is implied, it would make it more authoritarian, that style.
17:59 Speaker 02 It depends also on how these are defined, and here we define as authoritarian parents that value, among the most important value, obedience.
18:11 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
18:11 Speaker 02 Now, it's not necessarily the case that an overprotective parents requires blind obedience in the way in which, you know, the traditional farming families, fathers typically require children to obey to them.
18:29 Hanne Tidnam? You can be overprotective and still be offering your child lots of choices.
18:32 Speaker 02 That's right. I would say that they are not the old style authoritative parents. They are rather, you know, very engaged parents, but also obsessed with their children not making mistakes and providing an excess support that in the end was more into the control part.
18:48 Speaker 01 Helicopter parenting is one of these things which it's always a little tricky, I think, because I've never met anybody that claims to be a helicopter parent.
18:57 Hanne Tidnam? Nobody wants to be, right?
18:58 Speaker 01 Nobody ever wants to admit that it's them, and so you're sort of criticizing a straw person.
19:03 Hanne Tidnam? I don't know. I mean, I feel like I'm aware of those tendencies in myself. I think it's Peter Gray, who talks about how we're not exposing our kids enough to fear and risk and that they need these things to sort of inoculate themselves against, to learn that it's okay and how to deal with it. And so I constantly am aware of this battle, right? Where I'm like, well, I want, I don't want to say be careful, but please be careful. You know, and it's like the helicopter urge of following your kid around when they're, you know, on a skateboard, on a cement skate ramp, or whatever it is. But so it's, I think we all have those tendencies in different degrees. You're not universally a helicopter parent?
19:42 Speaker 01 No, I definitely agree with you. And we talk about this because it's, there's, this is one of those cases where there's this really sort of bizarre connection that you would never think of unless you thought about it from an economic standpoint. There's this connection between this concept that economists have long worried about called moral hazard and helicopter parenting, or exposing your kids to risk.
20:03 Hanne Tidnam? What does that mean?
20:04 Speaker 01 The idea of moral hazard is familiar from bank bailouts. If a bank knows that it's going to get bailed out, if things really go south for them, that encourages them to engage in higher risk activities because they know that there's a certain sort of safety net.
20:20 Hanne Tidnam? Well, and it's not that risky, really.
20:22 Speaker 01 It's not that risky. Right. What looks like risk is not risk because in the end, if things go badly, the risk will be borne, the downside of the risk will be borne by the government or by the public, rather than the banks themselves. And so if the existence of insurance or the availability of a bailout is there, it actually encourages more dangerous behavior by the bank because it knows that in the really catastrophic events, it doesn't have to deal with the consequences. And the same thing is, is exactly the same tension that you feel, that if you're always there, warning your kids about danger, protecting them from, from bad things, if you're always there to sort of provide them with a safety net.
21:07 Speaker 01 The kids themselves might start engaging in higher risk activities precisely because they know that mom or dad is always there to bail them out.
21:15 Hanne Tidnam? Absolutely. My youngest is a major accident magnet. And I'm sure that it's because, weirdly, I'm there to catch him. So he never learns, like, don't jump off the top of the slide.
21:27 Speaker 01 Exactly. But of course, the exactly the other side is felt by governments and parents alike because you don't want to let your kid risk his life, you know? And so if you see him doing something that's really dangerous, it's not as though, you know, I would want to wag my finger at you and say, ah, ah, ah, moral hazard.
21:45 Hanne Tidnam? Right. Yeah.
21:47 Speaker 01 Kids need to learn how to internalize, you know, what risk is. And if they don't ever experience the downsides, the failures, the, the, the bad things that can come about from taking risks.
22:00 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
22:00 Speaker 01 Their perception of risk is going to be skewed. And when they become adults, they'll engage in risky behavior. And then you as parents are no longer there to protect them. And it could be really catastrophic.
22:11 Hanne Tidnam? But so how do we actually avoid creating that kind of moral hazard while still, you know, like reasonably making sure our kids are safe? It's sort of hard to know where to toe that line.
22:20 Speaker 01 It's important to kind of think about, you know, sort of two ways that parents can be over-involved in, in, in their children and two ways that they create moral hazard for their kids. One is by, is by being over-involved in terms of protecting their kids from bad things and, and steering their kids towards what the parents see as good things. But I also think that there's a way that parents can, can be over-protective with their kids, and that is involving themselves too much in the kid's decision-making process. So I can still, as a parent, say, let my kid define for him or herself the life that, that, that child would want, but be very involved in asking the kid questions and telling and suggesting things that they might do.
23:05 Speaker 01 And I think that that can be dangerous, too.
23:06 Hanne Tidnam? Even just helping the decision-making.
23:09 Speaker 01 Even just helping the decision-making because one of the real skills that, that children need to learn in order to be functioning adults in our society is how to evaluate the options that are in front of them, how to figure out what options they really do have, and how to decide which options to pursue. And if the parents are sort of too involved in that process, kids don't learn how to make decisions on their own. And so it can feel like for a parent that you're very hands off. You know, I'm not telling my kid what decision to make. I'm just helping them make their decisions.
23:39 Hanne Tidnam? You can actually become a crutch, essentially.
23:42 Speaker 01 Exactly. You also want to raise children into adults that will become adults that are self sufficient, at least insofar as they can make decisions on their own, rather than with the help of their parents.
23:55 Hanne Tidnam? That's kind of a self fulfilling. I mean, it's nice to feel needed. So there's an incentive for parents to keep doing that beyond just the child's best interests. It's because it actually feels good to the parent, right? To be needed in that way.
24:07 Speaker 02 From a more macro perspective, when you ask parents in different parts of the world, what values are, in their opinion, most important? Well, again, in Sweden, you have as many as 80% of them that regard independence as one of the cardinal value. If you take the United States, that percentage is just about 50%.
24:30 Hanne Tidnam? Wow.
24:30 Speaker 02 I think if I may say, this is one of the virtues of the permissive parenting style. By letting children learn from their own mistake and take their decision their instinct would drive them to, people develop the capacity to make decisions. In some of these countries, like Scandinavian countries, people develop an extremely good capacity to cooperate, to work in team. Because on the one hand, there is less competitive pressure. And at the same time, people somehow become more adult and independent driven earlier on.
25:07 Hanne Tidnam? Well, and I liked that you said this is possibly one of the benefits of the permissive style. Because we tend to think right now that authoritative is probably the best blend. And too permissive is not good. But actually, here's one, you know, large cultural side effect or benefit of having this more permissive style is this value of independence that comes out. How is parenting style tied to education systems? The organization of the school systems, especially within different countries?
25:34 Speaker 02 In a very competitive and segregated system like the United States or the United Kingdom.
25:41 Speaker 02 The success in school opens a door of success in the labor market. In other systems like in Sweden, there is much less of an emphasis on grades, admission to high league school, and the system is altogether more homogeneous. And so this makes somehow the system of incentive provided by the school very different. China has this very dramatic examination called Gaokao at the end of high school, and everything in the school system gets geared towards preparation.
26:20 Hanne Tidnam? Drives towards that.
26:22 Speaker 02 So this, of course, generates a system of incentive in parents, which is very particular, also in children, of course, in trying to prepare and succeed. Because, you know, getting a top spot and ending up in Beijing, in Peking University or in Shingguo University is very different from going to a small provincial university.
26:44 Hanne Tidnam? I'm going to actually ask a kind of pessimistic question now, which is ultimately, how much does this really matter? Don't some people argue that parenting styles don't have as much impact as we think? What's the real relationship between cause and effect here? And I guess, how do we know?
26:59 Speaker 02 I do think that parenting styles matter. Evidence suggests that parents that interact with their children in a certain way tend to lead, for instance, to better results in school. If you take the PISA study and look at the questionnaire about how much time people spend reading books, talking politics with their children, well, you see a significant effect. I think we have a sufficient number of empirical observations that suggest that parenting styles.
27:33 Speaker 02 I also think that the way parents interact with their children is a very important predictor of how future society is shaped. I want to make clear that the alternative is to believe that the genetic factors are the most important element of the play.
27:53 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
27:54 Speaker 02 The transmission of value, I think, is important. I do not believe that successful people have good genes and less lucky people, as I call them, have worse genes.
28:06 Hanne Tidnam? Right, and also because it makes us a better parent to believe that we have some impact.
28:12 Speaker 02 Well, it gives us also a mission to fulfill. Otherwise, well, we have fulfilled it in the first day by bringing out genes and then we can relax. I think there are so many topics of favor of parents to behave that way.
28:26 Hanne Tidnam? And how about you, Kevin? Do you think that we really can improve our outcomes in a systemic way by thinking about game theory in terms of these interactions? Or is it sort of one by one? Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.
28:39 Speaker 01 Well, so here's the thing. I don't, I don't really necessarily know that the extent to which a good or bad parent is going to improve or not improve how their child performs long term at their life. But what I am very confident about, and I think probably no parent would disagree, is that the way that parents interact with their children is going to affect the day to day interactions between the parent and the child, which is going to affect the parent and the child's relationship at the very least for the rest of their life. If you have positive interactions with your kids that are mutually rewarding for both of you, it's going to make the experience of being a parent better for you, and it's going to make the experience of being a kid better for your child. And so even if at
29:21 Speaker 01 the end of the day, it doesn't or does or doesn't affect the adult that your child becomes, there's still reason to focus on how to figure out how to have positive mutually rewarding interactions with your kids. And in the end, that seems like good enough reason to me.
29:37 Hanne Tidnam? To Fabrizio's kind of earliest definition of the difference between parent and child, even if it's really about just the child's and the parents now, not the future, it's worth figuring out. Thank you both so much for joining us on the A16Z podcast.
29:53 Speaker 01 Thank you very much for having me.
29:54 Speaker 02 Thank you very much.
Previous a16z Podcast: Cash, Growth, and CEO ❤️ CFO Next The Future of Money: Banking on Fintech Page updated September 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated