Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | The Future of Money and Monetization About this episode Technology companies are running hard at almost every part of the traditional banking business -- from raising funds to moving money from one person to another. And as you would expect, that has meant change, both in terms of the banking services that are available to all of us, and the pricing of those services.
It begs the question of what role banks play going forward, and whether tech companies are partners or competitors (or some combination) to the players in the traditional banking business? And finally, if banking gets unbundled by tech –- if there is a choice of services -- what fees, and at what price will consumers be willing to pay? a16z’s Alex Rampell leads a discussion with TransferWise Executive Founder Kristo Käärmann and Tilt founder and CEO James Beshara on the future of money and monetization. The discussion occurred as part of the firm’s U. K. Tech Summit.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 3 Welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Michael Copeland. Technology companies are running hard at almost every part of the traditional banking business. From raising funds to moving money from one person to another. And as you would expect, that has meant change. Both in terms of the banking services that are available to all of us and the pricing of those services. It begs the question of what role banks play going forward. And whether tech companies are partners or competitors, or some combination. To the players in the traditional banking business. And finally, if banking gets unbundled by tech. If there is a choice of services, what fees and at what price will consumers be willing to pay?
0:45 Speaker 3 A16Z's Alex Rampel leads a discussion with transfer-wise executive founder Christo Carmen and TILT founder and CEO James Bashara on the future of money and monetization. This discussion occurred as part of the firm's UK Tech Summit. Alex and Christo start things off.
1:03 Speaker 1 So one thing, just given that the topic is the future of money, how do you think about regulation? Because one thing that I find very interesting is that how did Airbnb and Uber and Lyft get started? They didn't get started by embracing local laws. They almost flouted them. Because if you can imagine Airbnb, if they were starting tomorrow and they said, okay, we're going to go to every local town and city and say, can we do this? They'd get a lot of no's. The challenge is if you go into the realm of money and you say, you know what, KYC, know your customer laws, AML, anti-money laundering laws, those are stupid and antiquated, we're not going to follow those, you go to jail. So the consequences are much much higher than providing a temporary rental or a temporary car service. So how do you think about regulation? Because when you're touching money, um things get a little bit more complicated. But if you follow every law that was established in the 1500s, it's a little bit hard to get business done too.
1:54 Speaker 2 And especially as the laws are uh usually written for the fax machines, not for the not for the smartphones. So people have told me that I was stupid because I chose the other way. Um I spent about nine months before showing the product to anyone, uh going through the FCA or then FSA regulation process and and licensing. So we took the way, unlike Uber or or Airbnb to be uh a fully licensed money service in the UK before we even uh before we even got started, and now we have a big team not just doing everything that the banks do uh for adhering to AML and KYC rules, but we have another team who gets us licenses in every single country that we we operate.
2:43 Speaker 2 So recently uh we got licensed in Japan, we're in Hong Kong, we're licensed in Australia, uh in the US, etc. etc.
2:53 Speaker 0 Yeah, I think with us, um, you know, in contrast to Airbnb or Uber, you know, you we actually can work within the system. I don't think, you know, in many cities and many markets, Airbnb or Uber just would not be able to work. There was no system to work within. Um so they really had their only option was to go outside the system. When it comes to money and and money transmission or processing, um and man, there are a lot of there's a lot to the system, and there's a lot of paperwork. Um, but I think we also similarly chose the the approach of just get really good at paperwork and work within the system.
3:33 Speaker 2 Yeah. And uh just to just to add to that regulation question a little bit. So I honestly believe that you know regulation is not bad if you if you look into this. You know, we're dealing with money, so there should be consumer protection. Um and we all want to catch the bad guys. So in the kind of the essence, I think regulation makes sense. And you know, I don't feel uh feel bad about some particular regulations or that kind of the way that they're written, uh, but the the idea is good.
4:02 Speaker 1 Yeah. And how about customer acquisitions? So I mentioned this uh incumbents, I mean, if anything, you're fighting the incumbents in a very, very meaningful way, a transfer-wise. Um because and it's hard for the income, it's not a technological innovation per se. I mean, it there is, there's a lot to what you do that's technological, but if you're charging a fraction of what they're charging, they can't just roll out what you're doing because it would cannibalize their own fee structure. So, I mean, how do you think about, I mean, I've I've noticed a lot of marketing campaigns for you in my limited time here in the UK. Um, how do you think about acquiring customers and keeping customers? So for us,
4:36 Speaker 2 for us, the the customer acquisition problem is really explaining the problem. Um we were talking earlier earlier about um pricing models in different parts of finance, and what I believe is uh it's not that the banks are banks are bad. Um banks have a very hard time across the board, across different product lines, but it's uh it's just this pricing model that has evolved where we decide not to show the real price of a service, and then we hide it either into the interchange or into the exchange rate, and then the consumer doesn't really have a choice, uh and they don't know how much they get charged uh by making payments for making payments or or moving money around, and that's what we believe is wrong.
5:22 Speaker 2 And when you when you ask the customer acquisition question, we find that once people understand that, once they understand how they pay for the service, and once they realize that they have a choice, you know, it becomes very easy. So these kind of uh quirky uh stunts that we do, these are really just a nice way how to explain what the problem
5:45 Speaker 0 is. Yeah. Yeah, I think when it when it comes to money, one of the biggest benefits of being so of having such a high barrier to entry and all the paperwork that that we just referenced, one of the biggest benefits is as a young developer, none of my friends as developers were doing anything with money because it it's just really hard to do from you know from your bedroom, uh, you know, working on something nights and weekends. And so when you take on and when you bite the bullet and and get really good at that paperwork, and you introduce an app which and when I say it's the easiest way to collect money from a group, so for your uh a Christmas dinner, a Christmas party for a group gift, for um you know renting an Airbnb with eight friends to fundraising from uh for a community cause with with a hundred and fifty people, it really is the easiest way to do it.
6:37 Speaker 0 Um and we just launched in the UK three months ago, so you can download the app and and see what I mean. The the UI UX, it's garners a really strong word of mouth, a really really strong word of mouth. We're the fastest growing app on college campuses in the US. Um I think it's because uh dealing with money, there's just there are not many great well-designed apps when it comes to money and payments. Um it becomes a big benefit for the user acquisition channel.
7:05 Speaker 1 Yeah. So one of the things that's that's uh nice about this particular panel is that nobody here is I mean, neither one of you is trying to be the next bank and kill the current banks. Um so in many cases or in all cases, it means that you know we need to work with banks. I mean, I found this with a firm where it was very hard to even open a bank account when they asked us what our business was, and we said we're gonna loan money, and like nobody would even take a deposit from us. Um, a multi-million dollar deposit of our first venture capital check. Um, so what what would you like to see banks do differently? Um, if anything, because obviously, you know, you compete with banks a little bit at transfer wise, but also like people have deposits at their bank account that they use to then transfer money using you. So there's a lot of stuff where you you have to participate within the financial system as well.
7:52 Speaker 1 What would you like banks to do differently or change?
7:55 Speaker 2 That is a very good very good question. Yesterday I was uh in Finland at a huge tech conference, 15,000 people, and um I didn't even get so people realize that banking needs to evolve. Um like you were you were explaining with the slides how you know different verticals are are being uh challenged by you know different lenders and payment companies and so on. The question was how quickly is it going to happen? So is it something that's gonna happen in the next five years, or do we have 15 years, or do we have 20 years to go? Um and I don't know the answer, but what I see from say Uber, you know, things seem to happen faster than we than we think. Um and then the the next question is you know what should the what should the banks do?
8:43 Speaker 2 And I think uh the smartest banks, and we work with banks all over the world in every country where we are, we have banking partners and the infrastructure, so it's about 52 bankers that we uh that we pay fees to, and you know, in total that's multiple millions a year. And uh we find that some banks accept and acknowledge that the world is going to change, and they uh they get on with it by looking at what their role is going to be in that that changed world. Um going that far, and uh don't want to kind of blow blow my own horn, but there are a couple of small banks who have decided that it's better for them to recommend transfer-wise to their customers than offer them the international payment product of their their own, the Swift payment, that they can't really support to every single country around the world because they don't know how the Japanese payment system works and they can't guarantee when the money's gonna hit the accounts and what the fees are gonna be uh taken on the other side.
9:49 Speaker 2 So we do see that there are banks who think very hard about what their role is going to be and how they need to evolve to uh to catch up with what you were just. Describing.
10:01 Speaker 0 Yeah, the uh to the banks out there in the audience, um I would second what Chris is saying. Recommend tilt to every one of your customers. Uh that'd be great. Um but uh I think uh more more poignantly, I'll tell you a story. Um a company in the US that has a massive asset. Um it's not their focus, but they have this massive asset of this infrastructure. Their focus is selling books, uh, their focus is e-commerce, um, the company's Amazon, and in 2005 started to uh make use of this inventory, this asset that they had in infrastructure. And that became AWS, and now it's something that we along with a gazillion other sites use as an infrastructure, and I think that banks could use that story internally in recognition of you know, we have no interest of doing anything in banking from the licenses that banks already have to the safety security that they provide.
10:59 Speaker 0 Um, I think the opportunity that a bank can provide for the world, the first two to really take me up on it. James at Tilt is my email, is to be the AWS of uh money, be that infrastructure that allows for sites uh and services like Tilt or Transfer Wise to be built upon that way. We were talking about it last you know, behind the stage that you know, trying to solve the the UI UX of an application is really hard. Trying to solve the payments back end is really really hard. And uh and banks that have tried to get into kind of the the UI UX, I don't think they'll be able to compete with 50 really dedicated designers, developers that are just focusing on the user experience, um the user interface, and those 50 people will not be able to compete with banks that have um security safety uh at their core.
11:54 Speaker 0 So I'd say that would be a really big opportunity for them.
11:58 Speaker 1 Yeah, it's interesting. The opportunity it's almost saying an API for banking. Um part of the problem, like at least in the US, there's been one new bank charter granted in the last five and a half years, and it was an Amish bank. Um exaggeration. So they actually had a drive-thru for a horse and buggy, um, which is which is kind of funny because that's Wells Fargo's mascot. But um one of the other things that we were talking about backstage was just where credit cards go. So obviously, credit cards are very important for you because that's how people crowdfund campaigns. If people didn't have credit cards, that would be more problematic. Um, but also credit card fees are very high. So I was mentioning Target, big retailer in the US has about a 1.5% net margin, so net income over revenue.
12:43 Speaker 1 If interchange went away, they would double their profit. So it's not a surprise that they're always suing my my former employer of Visa because they want those fees to go down. But credit cards have become so pervasive. There are billions of them around the planet right now. Visa MasterCard have become an international duopoly. Um, but it's like how do you see like where should fees be? And the reason why I mentioned this is what we're talking about backstage, is that uh if fees go down, then that means that rewards cards go away. Um and in many cases that just means a giant transfer of wealth from a bank to a merchant without going to a consumer. It's one of these issues of concentrated benefit and diffuse harm. So do you are you experimenting with other payment models or methods? If it
13:28 Speaker 0 goes to the merchant, then it will go to the consumer. Um and uh and and it might not be a complete hundred percent pass through, but I'd say that uh the transfer of wealth will make it its way to the consumer. It just always does. So if the mer if target is able to save, then um then I'd I have a feeling that it will make its way to the consumer. But um I I you know, but this has been kind of something, especially in Silicon Valley. So people have been ringing that bell that you know, so there's room for um you know, huge huge room for disruption for credit card processing because that interchange does I mean that is a uh a huge pain point. And it's it's something that I I can tell you as a potential customer of this um mythical product that banks could provide because everyone that has a credit card also has a bank account.
14:20 Speaker 0 Um, you know, we would buy it, we would we'd jump in you know head first because of credit cards, uh they really kind of work against uh the merchant in a lot of ways.
14:31 Speaker 2 So I should moderate here because I know that you are of the opposite opinion. Because I I agree with James totally, but you're you don't you don't think that it will go on to the I think it's
14:41 Speaker 1 tricky. No, I mean it's the the problem is that imagine that this water bottle here costs one pound and interchange goes down by one percent. Will I even notice or care about 99 pence versus one pound? And I think that's been the problem historically. Like so, Australia has interchange at 49 and a half basis points by law, and now I mean, and this is not me supporting visa, it's more of it's very peculiar that you have an industry where when prices go down, consumers can be worse off. And in Australia, now there are no more rewards cards. Um people have to pay an annual fee to get a credit card in many cases, versus 15 years ago where credit cards were free and they got 1% cash back. So it did, I mean, Australia is a case study of how it did become a transfer of wealth. But it's also kind of interesting thinking about as an investor now, you know, what is there a room for another payment player?
15:28 Speaker 1 There's a consortium of merchants in the US called MCX, and they're trying to wean people off of credit cards, and obviously if nobody used your credit card and you paid 0%, that would be great for you. Um what the MCX merchants have found is that to wean people off a credit card, they have to bribe them with rewards and all sorts of other things, and those rewards cost 5% or 10%. Because if I want to change your behavior and get you to drop Visa or drop MasterCard, I can do it. But I'd have to say I'm gonna give you 10% if you go switch your payment instrument. But wait a minute, I'm only paying 2% right now in fees. So that's that's kind of part of the question is like how do you I mean there is a massive opportunity here because the incumbents haven't innovated in a long time when it comes to core payments, but the distribution is just so broad.
16:13 Speaker 2 So unfortunately, I don't know what the answer is, but we founders kind of often use this uh this method of imagining the future. So you imagine the future of you can't really imagine the future of payments costing even 49 basis points. It doesn't just doesn't make sense. You know exactly how if you know how payments, card payments work, you know, electrons go from the terminal or one web browser through the gateway to the issuing bank, money gets deducted, electrons go back, and it's done. Doesn't cost 45 49 basis points, definitely doesn't. So you can't imagine the future where card payments are gonna uh cost as much as they do. The question is, how do we gonna get there? And uh that's probably the excitement of being a VC of seeing so many different people trying in different angles, and then taking it back to which one's gonna go through.
17:03 Speaker 2 I personally raise my hand, I don't know. I know it's gonna get there, but I don't know.
17:08 Speaker 1 I raised the same hand, so
17:10 Speaker 0 yeah. The uh I would I'd offer the uh kind of the analogy of so think about uh Facebook and making a you know status update or Twitter and posting a tweet, it's free. And so it's you have this wealth of communication that is happening because um because it is free. When you get to uh making a payment online, any type of payment, there's a tax. So on Tilt where there might be a three dollar payment or someone's pitching in five dollars uh for you know a cause they care about or or something that's happening on the campus, and there's a tax to that. And so I don't know what the amount is. I don't know what uh what potential would be unlocked by removing that tax, but I do know that if Facebook taxed you 25 cents every time that you wrote a uh Facebook post or uploaded a photo on Instagram and they charge you 25 cents, there'd be a lot less information that would be distributed around the world through Facebook, Twitter, you know, WhatsApp charging you 25%.
18:11 Speaker 0 It's inconceivable.
18:12 Speaker 3 Yeah,
18:13 Speaker 0 and I think that that's happening right now when it comes to payments and the transfer of wealth, um, and we don't know the real cost of it. The closest uh thing that I can get to is I know in and in some estimations peer-to-peer payments in the US is 1.2 trillion dollars a year. The amount that happens electronically digitally is only about five billion. So that shows you the delta that is happening digitally uh versus what is happening uh through cash and checks where there isn't a tax. Um it's a very US thing, by the way. That and that could be a very US thing. What I'd love to ask why do you feel it's a US thing?
18:50 Speaker 2 I've never I've never written a check in my life. Yeah.
18:53 Speaker 0 You use a bank app, right? Here,
18:55 Speaker 1 right? Well, this is one of the peculiar things, which is every I've seen dozens and dozens of payment companies, and we'll help you send money to your kids' school or we'll help you do something. Checks are free in the US, and all the newfound business models need to make money. So they end up charging more than this classic infrastructure, which is totally antiquated. Like you should never be writing paper checks, but it's actually cheaper in the US in almost every case to write a paper check than to make an electronic payment, which is crazy. So
19:24 Speaker 2 what do you guys think about um just a question about advertising or kind of advertising driven banking? Because you you brought the Facebook example. Facebook can't charge 25 cents for a post. They show us adverts. They advertise. Well, this is what do you think that do you think the banks are gonna be like uh taking peace from advertising in the future?
19:46 Speaker 0 So this is that you know, this is right in line with uh Alex's side of things with trial pay. Um love to hear his answer. I think that there is definitely room for a new model when you have eyes on your product, and and when You uh when you can provide for retailers out there next year is a big focus for us to add in businesses tapping into the millennial consumer group that we have on on uh on tilt to where you can start we have the Atlanta Hawks tilting merchandise, uh with uh jet blue tilting uh deals for their customers on Twitter, um things like that. And I think that that definitely when you're providing content for people to consume, it opens up a new uh a new avenue to monetize beyond beyond transaction fees. But
20:31 Speaker 1 actually, we're we're out of time here, but I'll I'll add my my two cents. That was exactly what I did for nine years at TrialPay. Um I mean I I still find it we we didn't quite hit it just because we had the innovation but we didn't have the distribution, which is why we sold the Visa. But um, if you're buying something, it anything that you can show to a consumer when they're buying something, this is why Amazon doesn't sell books anymore. They do. They sell books and they sell 20 million other SKUs because the point of purchase is incredibly valuable. It's when you go to Tesco why an end cap is so valuable. So I definitely think that advertising will play a different role, but it's not banner ads, it's not click ads, it's actually uh things of genuine value and benefit to consumers, and it's something that all of the card networks are really focused on right now as well. Because if interchange goes to zero, how do they make money? And how do they provide rewards to consumers?
21:17 Speaker 1 Let's have merchants fund it. Well, thank you very much, both of you. And thank you, everybody, for your time.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated