Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast: The End (and Beginning) of Programming About this episode There are over 20 million programmers out there -- and double that, if you count everyone else coding in other ways -- but where are the next 100 million developers? How do we get to a billion developers? The answer, observes a16z general partner Pet...
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 The content here is for informational purposes only, should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any A16Z fund. For more details, please see A16Z.com/disclosures.
0:19 Sonal? Hi, everyone. Welcome to the A6 and Z Podcast. Today's episode is all about the end and new beginning of programming, featuring guests Chris Wanstrath, co-founder and former CEO of GitHub, and A6 and Z general partner Peter Levine, who's on the board of and led our investment in GitHub. The conversation was recorded previously at our annual A6 and Z Summit event. Only this Q and A turns the tables, with Chris asking Peter all the questions around his thesis about the end of programming with a glimpse ahead of what comes next.
0:48 Speaker 02 Hi, everyone. Hello. Thank you for joining us today. I'm Chris, by the way. This is Peter. If you're confused about who was who, I'm the GitHub person. This is the Andreessen person. But we've actually known each other since 2012. We've been working together for a long time. We're 10 years old. And we first decided to raise investment in 2012 after we were around four years old, because we wanted to branch out from our own personal networks of software developers, from programmers. We wanted to get into the world of business. We wanted to really expand GitHub to anyone who was interested in building software. And Andreessen has been a huge part of that. But Peter, in particular, has been there since 2012, since the very first meeting that we had. So I say that not to say that Peter is this great guy,
1:32 Speaker 02 because he is, but to tell you that he has interviewed me so many times that I'm very excited to interview him for once. So this is a big moment for me. I come from this world of really product-oriented, consumer-focused, software developers, building things for other software developers. And Peter has helped, as a software developer himself, me and the company really expand what we're thinking in terms of customers and in terms of our approach to business. So this was an opportunity for us, I feel, to talk about some of the things we agree on in terms of the next 10 years, and some of the things we don't agree on. I don't think either of us knows the truth of what's going to happen in 10 years from now, but I think it's somewhere in the middle.
2:13 Speaker 03 I have to ask one question. You know, we're here to talk about the beginning and end of programming. How many programmers are out there in the world?
2:22 Speaker 02 We think there are 20 million people employed that are writing code. But the idea of what a programmer is, someone who writes software in their free time, or even professionally, that's not counted in a programmer. It's way more than 20 million, it's way more than 40 million. It's growing every day. And I think what that means isn't that the reporters are wrong, or Gartner is wrong, or Red Monk is wrong. I respect those firms a lot. I think really what that means is the term and the sort of definition is evolving and changing. We also see our customers, people that used to use Jira, people that are in the marketing team that want to update just some copy on a website. They're increasingly moving to something like GitHub. And they're also giving us feature requests specifically for these teams of people that are not the core, you know, sort of code collaborate ship developer pipeline.
3:06 Speaker 02 So I think the answer to your question is 20 million full-time, 40-hour-plus developers. But don't be fooled by that number. There are way more people who have their fingers in development than the numbers than GitHub can even tell, and it's growing. So the more you can open that up, I think, the better it is for everyone. So anyway, what I want to talk about, though, is not 20 million or 40 million developers. We talk at GitHub a lot about the next 100 million developers. But what do we need to do to ensure that people in the future can become developers? For me, it's a lot more of how do we lower the barrier to entry? How do we get more people on board? How do we make development this thing that a billion people want to use? I think for Peter, he sees it almost, I don't want to put words in his mouth,
3:50 Speaker 02 sees a different route to the next billion developers. And I think you see it more from data than simplifying tools, making tools easier, lowering the barrier to entry.
3:59 Speaker 03 So originally, I was thinking about this talk as titling it "The End of Software Development", but then "The End" may be a little much. So it's really how do we go from 20 or 30 million developers to a billion developers? So in order to get to a billion developers, I want to change the definition of what a developer and what a programmer is, right? And when we think about sort of data as the input into a system, we often think about right now like, you know, facial recognition is easier done, better done by a computer than done by a human right now. And I started to think about how data as an input to a system
4:40 Speaker 03 could actually change the world of programming such that everyone becomes a programmer. The reason why I think that programming ends as we currently know it is the declarative languages that we've used since the beginning of time, beginning of compute time, has all been based on if then else. If this, do that, do this, right? And it gets very complicated, but it's all if then else. And basically, as a programmer, you have to know what you're asking for. You tell the computer what you want it to do. As opposed to the reverse is, I want to look at data and I want to instruct the outcome as opposed to a priori knowing what the input might be. So let me give you an example.
5:23 Speaker 03 A football coach becomes a programmer. And if one had to program a football game and said, quarterback throws the ball to the receiver, if this, then that, and these guys go do this, it's an indeterminate problem. There's too many moving pieces, like the program would be very, very complex to just run one play, okay? Just like if you were doing facial recognition or voice recognition, it's very complicated to do if then else on facial recognition. So imagine now, when we have all the tools to go and do this, imagine that through repetitive looking at football plays, the system actually learns. And it learns what the right movements are and all of that.
6:08 Speaker 03 And then what does the coach do? The coach comes in and optimizes that model to say, you know what, the system got it a little wrong here. The quarterback should move 10 yards back, whatever. And the coach, in conjunction with the system, Actually is a programmer. Because the coach actually informs the data and they become a, in my new definition of the world, a programmer. And you can take this now across any field, whether you're a lawyer, an accountant, a salesperson, and we can watch the best behaviors. We can watch the best behaviors and best human interactions. Let's say I'm trying to fix a transmission. Well, I can wear goggles and I can record it and I have the best expert going and fixing a transmission.
6:51 Speaker 03 And that person would then go back to that data. And of course, we need the right tools. So what are the tools for us to go manipulate this data? It won't be a spreadsheet. It will be some visual interface where I, as an auto mechanic, can go in and modify the output of what the system is doing. And in effect, we create a set of expert rules based on what the human does. And then imagine that we go roll out those rules to everyone else who has to go fix transmissions or become a salesperson or a lawyer or an accountant or football coaches. And in my mind, by using data and having folks optimize the data, they actually become the next generation of programmers. They're not trained as programmers.
7:35 Speaker 03 They won't even know what a program really is. They're all manipulating data in the context by which they are familiar with their own expertise. So that's what I think happens.
7:46 Speaker 02 Well, so I guess my question there is, my father is not a computer guy, but very much a car guy.
7:51 Speaker 03 My father too.
7:52 Speaker 02 He loves cars. He works on them. And if I can give him all the information at his fingertips to fix the car, I think it makes his journey much better. But if I were to give him all the information available to fix the diagnostic program that was running on his car, you know, let's say he has all the data available to him. Is he able to actually make those changes? So one side of it is, yes, I have all this data available to me. The other side of it, I think, is, do I have the tools to make these changes? Yes, I can understand, but can I actually affect the world? Is there a second sort of industry or a second tier of, you know, data becomes the most important thing that says, yes, now everyone has access to what's going on, but how do we actually affect that? Or do you see those things being intertwined?
8:35 Speaker 03 I mean, I think it's very intertwined. You know, your father, I've actually met your father. He brought ice cream to a party once.
8:41 Speaker 02 He did. He did bring Peter Ice Cream one time, yes. Well, if you're ever from Cincinnati, please go to Grater's Ice Cream. It's the world's best ice cream. It's worth bringing to California.
8:48 Speaker 03 So, I mean... Imagine your dad is fixing some part of the car and that has been done by someone else. And imagine if somebody else has optimized, effectively has created the exact, precise user manual for how to fix a particular part of the car. Imagine if your dad now was wearing goggles and it looked at what he was doing and the system was helping him to do a better job in fixing certain parts of the car. You take the experts, who are the programmers in their field, and they then push that knowledge off to everyone else. So maybe your dad's an expert in certain parts of this and he can participate in it. It's the open source of data, right? Everyone's manipulating this to get better solutions.
9:31 Speaker 02 So then for the current open source developers, people that today spend their time fixing bugs, sort of trying to make this piece of software better, not because they're making money off of it, because they want to become a developer who has this name. What does this do for them? Does this make them become data scientists, the current crop of open source developers? Or do they now partner more with data scientists in the future?
9:55 Speaker 03 You know, I think that data science will become the new academic approach in computer science. There'll be less coding and more about data science. New algorithms for data science, new approaches to understand the world around us. So, you know, we can call this software 2.0, which is moving from code to data. And I think many people will need to literally upgrade their skill sets to know much more about data than they will about code, in my opinion.
10:24 Speaker 02 Don't people just suck at interpreting data? So like, I think about fake news. I think about like the lies that we all see going through the internet. And I think about programming. Like, if we're trying to get a billion developers, don't we feel like people in general, including myself, are bad at data but OK at like telling people and machines what we want?
10:42 Speaker 03 So let me parse the question in a couple of ways. When we know what we're looking for, we're actually very good at that. I can write a query and say, "Look for, you know, all numbers, you know, greater than 10." When you know what you're looking for, we're actually very good at that. What we're not good at is looking for things that we don't know that we're not looking for, right? And so I think what's going to happen, and we're already starting to see this, is systems in the future will actually help us see data in ways that we... Can't see it right now, so let me give you an example, a real example. There's a company that collects data off of traffic signals and to see how many red and green lights that occur
11:26 Speaker 03 in a traffic environment and the flow of traffic. That's the input, so that, I would argue, we could code that. But the system actually uncovered the fact that there's a correlation between the lights not working and the maintenance schedule for the light itself. That was something that the human, in your sense, right? Terrible at finding things that we don't know that we're not looking for. Because you don't know? But a computer, through looking at data and looking at patterns, actually helped to determine in that situation a new thing that the human wasn't looking for to begin with. And that's where I would argue that code breaks down. Code will say the number of times that, you know, the current code,
12:09 Speaker 03 if light goes on, counter goes up by one, right? But if you're not looking at a maintenance schedule there or whatever, how would you ever know to look at a maintenance schedule?
12:17 Speaker 02 Right.
12:18 Speaker 03 So that's an example of kind of taking correlated data and using that through a machine that I believe will start to really, you know, move us again from this notion of intent, you know, find something, to this notion of using data to find correlations that actually we may not have been looking for. I mean, to some people, the fake news is real news.
12:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's right.
12:41 Speaker 03 So that's a little more arbitrary. But certainly, you know, the input of data, I believe, is going to be a super big deal.
12:47 Speaker 02 So then I guess part of that is, one of the things that we first talked about ever when we met was that you worked on X11, the X-Windows system.
12:53 Speaker 03 Yes.
12:54 Speaker 02 The Unix windowing system, X-Windows. So I've used that for a long time. It came out of the 80s. One of the big first, in my opinion, successful free software projects that brought sort of this idea of open source and free software to consumers. And it wasn't the best, but it was there, and it was an option, and it was great. So I think that is all to say that... There was once a period of time where everyone, everyone believed that code's intrinsic data was in being kept private. And there was, there was value in code. And like, if I had this piece of code and you didn't, I had something that was worth something. And maybe you were in a position where, while the industry felt that way, you know, some of the hippies that, you're not wearing sandals today, but some of the hippies you either went to class with, or you were...
13:38 Speaker 03 I mean, I wore shirts, t-shirt, no shoes.
13:40 Speaker 02 People in the 80s where you were hanging out, they were really into free software. Before a lot of us, I think, realized that there's something real there. It's not just about hippies, it's about, there's a practical value. Do you feel like data's in a similar spot? It's our valuable asset, there's intrinsic value into keeping data secret.
13:55 Speaker 03 Right.
13:55 Speaker 02 We once felt that about code. I don't know if I think that data being open is going to be something that works, but I think that a lot of people once felt that about code.
14:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:04 Speaker 02 Do you think that we're gonna want to make data more open?
14:06 Speaker 03 Yes, I think we do. You know, there's this phrase out there, "Data's the new oil," right? And I have this vision that we all become our own oil well. And we are going to dispense data. And there are now ways where people can get paid for producing data, right? So instead of contributing my data to some centralized place, I can actually monetize that data, my data, to the extent that I want to, or I can contribute it. Examples might be, if I have a camera on the front of my car and I'm going through streets and I'm recording visual information, I can choose to maybe offer that to some service that's gonna make maps better. But maybe I get paid for that.
14:49 Speaker 03 Or if I have, let's say, our talk here, if somebody finds it valuable, maybe we get paid for it, right? And so, I think there will be a lot of cases where data becomes the purview of each individual, and we will choose how we wanna go dispense it. And I think in certain cases, our data and what we produce will become... Valuable to consumers and there'll be a market for data. And rather than all our data going to centralized companies that are, you know, hidden inside of organizations, we all will have control over our data. And I think to have a market and to have economics around that data is really interesting. So I think that's kind of the way it takes shape in terms of what happens to data and how people own it and control it.
15:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, that definitely resonates with me. I've seen a lot of history repeats itself, but the time scale is always what is the most different to me. You know, free software really started in the 80s. GitHub came out in 2007. And for me, GitHub was very much influenced by the open source movement. But I think for a lot of people, open source didn't become part of their vocabulary until maybe later, 30 years after free software. So with data, do you see a similar timeline?
16:01 Speaker 03 I mean, in some ways, it's already happening. There are companies out there who look at Salesforce productivity, looking at the most productive salespeople in an organization, learn what they do, modify that, and then go give that information to, so where everyone gets assisted by this new technology. A lot of that stuff is starting to happen. We may not think about it as the data economy or this change in programming, but it is starting to happen as we have these new models where we can process massive amounts of information and to where the outcomes really become, I'd say, digital assistance to humans to actually make them better.
16:44 Speaker 03 Whether it's the football player, the auto mechanic, the accountant, the lawyer, or the salesperson, each of those can be better based on observing the experts in that field. And I would argue it's starting to happen. And sure, it'll take a long time and all that, but I definitely see it.
17:00 Speaker 02 So my final question is hopefully relevant to people here. It seems like this is starting to happen. Like, your blog post, I think from a year ago, on edge computing.
17:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
17:09 Speaker 02 You felt it was starting to happen. So, maybe to you, a lot of what's occurring in this conversation feels obvious, but to others, it's very new. What should I think about if I'm like a CIO or any executive at a company and I'm hearing this? Is there anything I should do differently in the next year? Is there anything I should think about? Or is it just like, trust my team because this is happening?
17:27 Speaker 03 You know, in all of these, sort of my end of things that I've been thinking about, whether it was the end of cloud computing last year, or the end of programming, you know.
17:35 Speaker 02 Peter's trying to kill everything.
17:37 Speaker 03 Anyway, yeah. But it starts a new thing. And what has been interesting is when you start out with these, like, when I start to talk about this stuff, literally, everyone looks at me, because I've been through this now, like I'm crazy. Like, "Are you nuts? Programming is gonna be around forever?" and that. And as I start to think about it in my own mind and put some concrete examples and bring things together, it actually starts to make sense even to me. I mean, I thought about this, I couldn't really describe it. Now, you know, kind of over time, you get better at sort of thinking about the examples and that. So what I would leave for all of you is, what does it mean in your organization to utilize data? I mean, I gave the Salesforce example, that's a very real example.
18:21 Speaker 03 So where else can we model the experts in your environment? Where can we take those, you know, kind of that data? And then how do we provide, you know, what framework and what rules would you go and look at as CIOs on where you might optimize things based on people doing expert work in your environment? And I will bet you, if you start just thinking about this, because I did, I went through this exact exercise, you will realize that every function within your company has the opportunity to be data-driven, has the opportunity to be iterative and cognitive based on the work that we're all doing to try to optimize things. And once you start thinking about this, then it becomes reality.
19:06 Speaker 03 And so, I'll leave you with that, and next year, we can revisit this. I guarantee you, it will start to proliferate through the industry in the same way that some of the other things are.
19:17 Speaker 02 Awesome. Well, thank you so much.
19:18 Speaker 03 Thank you.
19:18 Speaker 02 Thank you, Peter. Thanks, everyone.
Previous In Conversation: Netflix' Ted Sarandos and Marc Andreessen Next An Intro to Crypto: Decentralization, the Big Picture Page updated September 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated