Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Mental Models for Understanding Crypto Tokens About this episode This episode of the a16z Podcast goes deep on various trends in cryptocurrencies -- from mental models for understanding tokens and what may give them long-term value; to the role of stablecoins in the ecosystem; to scaling, on-chain and off-chain protocols, forks, and more.
The discussion features general partner Chris Dixon in conversation with Nick Tomaino, the founder of early-stage crypto venture fund 1confirmation, editor of The Control, and former business development at Coinbase. (He is also an investor in Basecoin, Cosmos, Ethereum, and MakerDAO.) You can also check out past episodes in this series, covering everything from investing in cryptocurrencies and protocols to accelerating research and practical applications to why crypto tokens matter -- as well as a video covering the building blocks of all things crypto -- at a16z.com/crypto.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 The content here is for informational purposes only, should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any A16Z fund. For more details, please see A16Z.com/disclosures.
0:19 Hanne Tidnam? Hi, everyone, and welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Hannah, and today's episode continues our series on all things crypto with Chris Dixon in conversation with Nick Tomano, founder of early-stage crypto fund One Confirmation and formerly BD at Coinbase. In this conversation, they start off with a framework for understanding tokens, to what gives them long-term value, what's the role of stable coins in the ecosystem, as well as scaling issues, on-chain versus off-chain protocols, forks, and other trends in crypto. You can also check out more details about this episode, as well as past episodes in this series, and a video covering the building blocks of crypto on our site at A16Z.com/crypto.
1:00 Chris Dixon? So, people may have heard of tokens, on coins. Token sometimes means, like specifically ERC20, which means tokens built on Ethereum. Some people use the term more broadly, there's a little bit of confusion around the nomenclature. But broadly, tokens, coins, there are different categories of tokens, I guess, and maybe you can, so you have a kind of a framework here, you can help walk us through that.
1:18 Speaker 03 There's a lot of different mental models people have, and this is just mine, but how I think about it is simply kind of two types. So, the first is what I call a usage token, and some people call it a medium of exchange token, some people call that a utility token, but it's basically a token where ownership is required to use some digital service. And you can think of any blockchain as a digital service where you have kind of buyers and sellers. Bitcoin's the most widely-known usage token where ownership is required to use this digital service, and in the case of Bitcoin, that digital service is a ledger that can be used by anyone to store and transfer value, right?
1:55 Chris Dixon? The original usage token, by the way, were IP addresses and domain names, right? I mean, like the sort of scarce network resources of the internet, which... You needed an IP address to access the internet and you needed domain names to set up a website.
2:06 Speaker 03 Yep, that's right. And so if you look right now at CoinMarketCap.com, the top 25 tokens by market value, I think 24 of the 25 are usage tokens. One of the interesting things is, right now, a lot of the ICOs that we're seeing are kind of masquerading as usage tokens, right? But how I think about whether a usage token can have long-term value is really, is the digital service that's being provided, it will demand for that increase in the future? And are there kind of scarce, unique resources underlying that digital service?
2:40 Chris Dixon? Yeah, will there eventually be what I would call consumptive demand, not speculative demand, right? Meaning, demand to actually use the service as opposed to simply to buy it and hoping it'll go up in price, right? In the same way that, you know, at the beginning of the internet, domain names, people bought them for speculative use cases. Eventually, you know, someone just bought pizza.com for $10 million, they bought it to use it, namely to sell pizzas, right?
3:00 Speaker 03 Yep.
3:00 Chris Dixon? And so, or whatever their model is, affiliate marketing for pizzas or something. But eventually, the reason domain names eventually, or IP addresses, you need them to, you know, if you want to have servers on the internet or something like this. So eventually, the consumptive demand replaced the speculative demand.
3:13 Speaker 03 Exactly.
3:13 Chris Dixon? And I think what you were saying about ICOs is a lot of sort of masquerading is that there are obviously people taking advantage of the, you know, just the money flowing in and sort of taking what is probably just a normal company that's not a protocol and sort of calling it a protocol and making up a kind of use case as to how it's a usage token, but it just is an excuse to raise money.
3:31 Speaker 03 Exactly.
3:32 Chris Dixon? All right, so that's usage tokens. And then what's the other kind?
3:34 Speaker 03 So the other is what I call a work token. So it's basically a token where ownership gives the token holders the right to contribute some type of work to a decentralized organization. And so, an example of this is something like the reputation token, which is native to Augur, where you don't have to own rep to use the prediction market, that's the design, this isn't a live product yet, but ownership gives you the right to do work in this decentralized organization.
4:00 Chris Dixon? Why would you want to pay to do work?
4:03 Speaker 03 Well, you'd want to own a token, a stake that gives you the right to do work in the future. So basically, if you think that millions of dollars will be flowing through the Augur network in, you know, a couple of years, and you want a piece of that, right?
4:18 Chris Dixon? So it'd be kind of like, if Facebook were a crypto protocol, a work token might be the ability to vote on how the newsfeed algorithm works.
4:26 Speaker 03 Yep, yeah.
4:26 Chris Dixon? And you can see how... You know, at some point, if Facebook is helping to determine who wins an election, like having some say in that algorithm could be valuable. If these crypto networks become very important, having some voice in it would seem to be valuable.
4:41 Speaker 03 Exactly, exactly. And I think it could manifest itself in many ways, right? So I think the most interesting work token will be when Ethereum switches from proof of work to proof of stake. And by the way, these aren't mutually exclusive, so you can have tokens that are both usage and work tokens, and I think many tokens in the future will likely be that.
5:00 Chris Dixon? And Ether will be when it switches to proof of stake.
5:02 Speaker 03 Exactly, exactly. You'll need Ether to, you know, to pay gas, to run smart contracts, and then you'll also, ownership will be required to do work in the network, and in that case, that work is validating transactions. And so when Ether switches, you know, people will want to own Ether, they may want to own Ether to earn the mining fees, if you will.
5:24 Chris Dixon? Yeah, I mean, that's the other reason you want to own work tokens, not just to vote on it, but in the case of like the proof of stake in Ethereum, you get paid for it.
5:29 Speaker 03 Exactly. ZeroX is another kind of example of, you know, what they call a work token, where the work is just governance. So in some cases, you may just value, you think this is going to be important and you want to play an important role in it, but in other cases, like in the case of Augur and Ether, it'll actually give you the right to earn fees in the network. And so I think, to me, I'm really excited about like completely new organizational structures, which Bitcoin is kind of the first, but you know, on the work side, you can only participate if you, you know, have sophisticated hardware and a lot of computing power, right? So I think when we see proof of stake, we're going to start to see kind of more inclusive ways to create decentralized organizations that lots of people can participate in.
6:11 Chris Dixon? There's another kind of tokens people talk about, which I would call like traditional asset security tokenization. You know, I guess my view on that is, and that is taking something that's, you know, a piece of real estate or something that has traditionally had value and creating a digital token that represents, you know, lets you trade that or something, right? My own view is that's far less interesting and that's not even part of the crypto movement in a way. To me, it's not really a cryptocurrency concept, and it just may just be a kind of regulatory workaround or something.
6:42 Speaker 03 I agree with that. I would say, I think, you know, it could be really meaningful in the sense that we could see a lot of traditional assets tokenize, but from a technology perspective, I don't think it's that exciting. But I do know that, you know, everyone around the world is seeing all this money that's poured into ICOs this year and thinking, maybe we should tap into this kind of global liquidity pool and tokenize our real estate project or our security or things like that. And I do think it's likely that we do see particularly jurisdictions that want to be favorable to it, put regulation in place and attract kind of investors and entrepreneurs
7:27 Speaker 03 that are thinking about this.
7:28 Chris Dixon? Do you think that the kind of tokenization has gone too far? I mean, the flip side would be, hey, maybe every project should have, you know, should have a token. And this is just kind of like a new business model and a new way to kind of, you know, align incentives around a new network or something?
7:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think it's gone too far. My sense was that the ICOs had slowed down quite a bit, but there were still 400 million in token sales in November alone. And so I think there's, in this boom, there's certainly people that shouldn't be doing tokens that are. So how that will play out over time, I'm not sure. But I would caution, you know, anyone who's looking at investing in tokens to think a lot about whether the token can have long-term value or not. Or is this just an interesting project, but, but there's not a strong reason for the token to kind of persist over time and have significant value?
8:21 Chris Dixon? Yeah. Everything we're discussing is highly speculative. One thing we should say here is that we do not recommend that people listening buy any of these tokens. And if you do buy them and like, you do a lot of research and put a very, very small amount of money into them because it's super risky. And I think a lot of people, including me, think it's very likely we're in a boom part of a cycle. And while I think we're very, very excited about the long-term technological prospects of what's going on in cryptocurrency, you know, I think it's very likely that the prices have gotten ahead of the actual progress.
8:55 Speaker 03 Certainly, this year has been all about the token boom, right? There's been over $4 billion in token sales. What I'm really spending a lot of time thinking about is like, what are the actual products that people are going to use over the next year or so? Because I think a lot of these big projects that have raised a ton of money aren't likely going to ship anything for many years in some cases. But I think there are kind of a few different categories of products that we're going to see actually start to drive real usage kind of in the next year. And we're already seeing that to some extent. So one example is like decentralized exchange.
9:30 Chris Dixon? Just for the listeners, what is a decentralized exchange?
9:32 Speaker 03 So, very simply, in a centralized world, which exists now in digital assets, you're trusting a third party like Coinbase that allows you to trade, right? So you're storing your value on kind of a centralized service and then trading and then withdrawing. Decentralized exchange basically facilitates trustless exchange of assets. So if you control your private keys, you can trade, basically. And it's a more secure way and you don't have to, you know, give a third party your funds, which is susceptible to hacking and things like that.
10:11 Chris Dixon? So what are some examples there?
10:13 Speaker 03 So, one kind of project that I think is quite interesting that's seeing traction is ZeroX. So ZeroX did a token sale earlier this year, and they're already seeing some projects kind of built on top of what they call relayers. Radar Relay is a good example of that.
10:29 Chris Dixon? And the architecture there is you use Ethereum as the settlement layer, but then you have sort of off-chain relays or order books that do the high throughput
10:39 Speaker 03 That's right.
10:39 Chris Dixon? transactions, which is an emerging architecture we're seeing more and more of, which is sort of use Ethereum is less performant, but you can trust it and you can send money through smart contracts and things like this. And so use it for what it's good for and then do everything else off-chain.
10:52 Speaker 03 That's exactly right.
10:52 Chris Dixon? And 0X is sort of one of the more interesting examples of that architecture.
10:56 Speaker 03 Yep. And so an alternative to kind of the 0X approach is something like Ether Delta, which does everything on-chain. So they do order book on-chain. And every time you change an order, for example, if you're using MetaMask, you have to pay gas and click a button. And it's a kind of a poor user experience, right?
11:12 Chris Dixon? Well, and expensive potentially. The design protocols that use both on and off-chain is very tricky, right? Because you have to make sure that the off-chain stuff is also happening in a trustworthy way.
11:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:23 Chris Dixon? Like on-chain, you get trustworthiness for free just based on the nature of the blockchain architecture.
11:27 Speaker 03 Yep.
11:27 Chris Dixon? But off-chain, you have to guarantee that as well, right?
11:29 Speaker 03 Exactly.
11:29 Chris Dixon? So you don't have like a rogue order book or something like this, right?
11:32 Speaker 03 Yep, yep.
11:32 Chris Dixon? And so that becomes a very tricky design problem, right?
11:34 Speaker 03 Yep. To be clear, it's still early and I think there's still, even in 0X, a lot to be figured out. By the way, I am a personal investor in many of these projects being discussed. But I think what's interesting about 0X is they're solving a real problem and they're seeing a real ecosystem kind of emerge on top.
11:49 Chris Dixon? That's kind of characteristic of the projects that we'll be seeing work to get usage in the near term. They tend to be more crypto-focused because that's where the users are today of these crypto products, right?
11:59 Speaker 03 That's exactly right.
11:59 Chris Dixon? As opposed to, you know, I think you and I both believe that someday people will have social networks and ride-sharing and all sorts of things using crypto protocols, but that might be farther away.
12:08 Speaker 03 Yep.
12:09 Chris Dixon? Just given the way this is evolving.
12:11 Speaker 03 That's right, yeah. I think one mistake I see, you see a great entrepreneur on paper that's solving some, you know, real-world problem with blockchain technology and it sounds really good, but...
12:23 Speaker 03 Can they really execute? Is the technology stack really there at a point to solve an end-user application? I'm most excited about projects that are solving problems for the existing crypto community rather than the broader landscape.
12:37 Chris Dixon? What's missing? Why can't you solve problems in the broader landscape today? Is it just the Ethereum scaling issues? Is it other services, like for example, identity services? Is it just that we're missing kind of core components?
12:47 Speaker 03 There's a lot of core components that are still missing. Take something like Augur, which is a decentralized prediction market, which is kind of an end-user application. In order for something like Augur to become interesting to a mainstream, even if mainstream users wanted to use this type of product, I think there's a lot of things missing. So one is a decentralized stablecoin, right?
13:09 Chris Dixon? So what is a stablecoin?
13:10 Speaker 03 So a stablecoin is a coin that has the volatility characteristics similar to that of a dollar, combined with the decentralization characteristics similar to that of a Bitcoin or Ethereum. So taking kind of the best of the stability characteristics of fiat currencies and the decentralized characteristics of cryptocurrencies. The volatility of Bitcoin and Ether are such that they're moving 5% or 10% in a given day, and no one that's actually using it as a medium of exchange for something or placing bets would actually want to use that, right? So a decentralized stablecoin, in my view, is like a core piece of middleware that's missing in the ecosystem. I think another is identity. A lot of these services really rely, at the application layer, rely on identity, and
13:52 Speaker 03 there hasn't been an identity-based protocol that's really emerged and gained a lot of traction yet.
13:57 Chris Dixon? So that's like, if you build a decentralized ride-sharing service, how are you going to keep track of the rider and driver ratings, as an example?
14:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:05 Chris Dixon? And how are you going to avoid cyber attacks and all these other kinds of things?
14:08 Speaker 03 Exactly. One of the things I'm excited about in terms of kind of new projects is like continuous token mechanisms. So how do you drive usage of the product and give new users, for some action, new tokens? And something like identity, I think, is a piece that's really needed, in most cases, to do that in a way that can't be gamed by cyber attack.
14:27 Chris Dixon? So let's talk a little bit about stablecoins. So we're investors in a stablecoin, basecoin. First of all, I think there's two categories of stablecoins. There's things that where they try to peg the digital asset to a physical asset, right? And some of these are controversial.
14:42 Speaker 03 Yep, Tether being the most well-known.
14:44 Chris Dixon? And then there are what you might call kind of like crypto-native, the ones like Maker Die and Basecoin, where there's no tying it to something. Instead, there's this kind of game theoretic mechanism that's been developed. So maybe we can talk a little bit about how these, the Maker Die and Basecoin work.
15:01 Speaker 03 The actual mechanisms that they're using to create a stablecoin are quite complex. At a high level, this idea of creating what some people call an algorithmic central bank, right? A central bank where you kind of peg some asset and based on market supply and demand, the supply of the token adjusts. And so in the case of Bitcoin, for example, Bitcoin has a very clear-cut money supply, which is that 21 million Bitcoin will ever be created in the year 2140, and the rate at which new Bitcoin or mine decreases by half every four years. In the case of something like Basecoin, they're pegging, you know, the coin to some asset.
15:46 Speaker 03 You could say one Basecoin equals $1, and then based on the free-floating price, the supply of the coin adjusts, right? So if the price goes up, more coins get printed. If the supply goes down, then a new type of token in their ecosystem called a bond gets printed and folks buy the bond with Basecoin. So that's kind of...
16:09 Chris Dixon? Essentially, as you said, you can think of it as kind of a second reserve of currency that acts like a banker or something and buys and sells or, you know?
16:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
16:18 Chris Dixon? It tries to, it tries to adjust the price to a target. And like with a lot of these economic things, it works to the extent people will believe it works, because for the banking mechanism to work, there has to be real value there. Whether there's value there partly depends on whether people believe there's value there.
16:29 Speaker 03 Right.
16:30 Chris Dixon? And so it has this kind of reflexivity property. Until these things are running at scale for years, I guess we won't really know if they work, but it seems like a really important problem and... One that's worth working on?
16:40 Speaker 03 One kind of fair question. Some would argue, well, Bitcoin volatility has decreased every year, and at some point, it will get to a point where it's actually a good medium of exchange, which we'll see. Other economists would argue, well, it's a fixed supply, and so by definition, there will be more volatility fundamentally than a coin where stability is the actual goal. So we'll see.
17:05 Chris Dixon? Yep. Okay. So let's talk about forks. So forks were a big topic this year. Forking is this very powerful mechanism, and it's really kind of a new concept where if you don't like how a project's being run, you can copy the project, and not just the code, but all the data from the code. There was a Bitcoin fork with Bitcoin Cash. There was a threatened fork with SegWit2X that was called off. There was famously Ethereum forked, creating Ethereum Classic and Ethereum. The equivalent would be like, I don't like how Facebook is running their algorithm, creating Facebook 2, and it not only has all the code of Facebook, but it also has all the photos and everything else. Like, it's just the whole thing. It's just Facebook 2. And one of the important things about it is it keeps the people governing the network in check, right? If they start to extract
17:48 Chris Dixon? rent or do other things that are bad, the community can just fork them. In fact, that happened with, like, Monero came out of a fork, right? So Monero is a very popular privacy coin that the community felt like the creators had taken too much of the initial token distribution to fork them, and now Monero is far more popular and successful. But it also creates this really weird situation where you have these kind of alternative timeline history things, and you have these weird coins, and like, there's, for example, Bitcoin Gold, right? What's the story of Bitcoin Gold?
18:15 Speaker 03 I actually don't know the exact story, other than it popped up a couple of weeks ago, and it now has a total market value of over $6 billion.
18:24 Chris Dixon? And Bitcoin Cash had like a real community momentum behind it.
18:27 Speaker 03 Yep.
18:28 Chris Dixon? It was a set of Bitcoin core community members who were unhappy with the governance and decided to create a new fork. Bitcoin Cash has like a, what is it, a $26 billion market cap now, which is more than the... Entire crypto space a year ago.
18:43 Speaker 03 Yep.
18:44 Chris Dixon? But that at least has sort of this community and kind of use cases and Reddit forums and a whole bunch of other things, right? Whereas you have these other things which are just like mystery forks or something.
18:52 Speaker 03 You know, we hear so much about the ICO boom, but in terms of kind of like total value created this year, there's actually been way more value created by forks than ICOs.
19:03 Chris Dixon? Yeah, you're right. Like the total ICO raise, what is it? It's a couple billion. It's like four billion, four billion. Whereas Bitcoin Gold, which is a fork that none of us even know where it came from or whether it's real, is worth seven billion.
19:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:18 Chris Dixon? It's a lot of crazy stuff, yeah.
19:20 Speaker 03 Yeah. My view, though, is that like the developer team and community behind the project is the most important aspect of these projects. So when you have a fork, you basically have two different communities that have some disagreement about how the future should look, right? And in the case of Bitcoin versus Bitcoin Cash or B Cash, you know, it's about the block size.
19:41 Chris Dixon? Well, yeah, the block size, which is symbolic of a broader debate around being kind of digital gold or digital Visa.
19:48 Speaker 03 Yep, exactly. So, but an idea and a belief is one thing, but having like a team and a community that can execute on that belief is another thing.
19:57 Chris Dixon? So what are some of the other things you're excited about in the crypto world?
20:00 Speaker 03 So I think, you know, this idea of solving scalability problems, right, is very important and I think is going to manifest itself in many different kind of directions. What I call kind of middleware piece that's really needed for something really being used by millions of people is, you know, the Ethereum blockchain or whatever blockchain you're using has to be able to process hundreds or thousands of transactions per second, right? And right now Ethereum can process roughly 15, Bitcoin roughly seven. And so there's a lot that needs to be done there. And so there's some interesting kind of approaches.
20:36 Chris Dixon? Bitcoin, it's only going to get worse now that the Bitcoin scaling debate seems to be over. So the price of transactions will go up and the transactions per second, I think, will go down, right? But the hope with Bitcoin is that the so-called layer two solutions work. The Ethereum development team, on the other hand, has a different approach, which is they're actually willing to make pretty dramatic changes to the core, including sharding, which adds parallelism. Instead of having 30,000 miners all running the same code, they can run different code.
21:04 Speaker 03 That's right.
21:05 Chris Dixon? It feels like there's a lot of interesting directions through which people are trying to improve the scaling, especially on the Ethereum side.
21:10 Speaker 03 For sure. And then the other thing that I would add is what I call horizontal kind of solution. So something like Cosmos, which is trying to create some framework for new coins to be created and even port over existing ledgers. They're working on a cool project right now called Ethermint, which is basically taking the Ether ledger, porting that on top of the Cosmos, what they call Tendermint, consensus mechanism, and their own peer-to-peer layer. And so if a developer is building something on Ethereum, but they want 1,000 transactions per second or something like that, they could just port it over.
21:48 Chris Dixon? Port it over and have the code work, and also have the transaction history ported as well.
21:53 Speaker 03 Both. But the transaction history from that point forward is different.
21:59 Chris Dixon? I think of Cosmos as, I guess, people calling it pair chains like Polkadot.
22:02 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:02 Chris Dixon? And there's a set of proposals for doing this, which is for interchain interoperability or something like this.
22:07 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:08 Chris Dixon? And you think of that as another vector through which
22:11 Speaker 03 Scaling can be achieved.
22:13 Chris Dixon? It kind of goes back to the original sidechain idea.
22:16 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:16 Chris Dixon? Which was back from Crypto V1 or Crypto Wave 1.
22:20 Speaker 03 Exactly.
22:20 Chris Dixon? Which was this idea that you'd have these sidechains off Bitcoin, which you could basically burn coins on Bitcoin, take them over to the sidechain, do other things, try out new software and do other experiments, and then bring them back.
22:30 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:31 Chris Dixon? So this is kind of like V2 version of sidechains or something.
22:34 Speaker 03 Exactly. And then there's new chains that are just fundamentally more scalable.
22:41 Chris Dixon? Like Definity as an example.
22:42 Speaker 03 And the exciting thing as an investor and someone interested in the space is that there's a lot of different projects all happening at once. Where if you look back on Bitcoin, a couple of years ago, it was really just sidechains, and then Lightning came along. But it feels like there's a lot of stuff. Kind of all happening at once on top of Ethereum.
23:02 Chris Dixon? I feel like the good news is the token model provided an economic model through which new projects could get funded and have sort of maybe a long-term business model as well to have the token appreciate and have the sponsoring entity hold some portion of those coins. The flip side of it has almost worked too well, which is now the incentive being to go join the, you know, work on Ethereum, which in the old days would be like working on Linux. The incentive is to create, you know, your own operating system, your own blockchain. Sometimes I worry that like this new incentive of having a token almost works too well and is creating kind of splintered development efforts.
23:36 Speaker 03 It's certainly possible. And yeah, some people are kind of hoping to see more like coin distribution for contributions and things like that, which.
23:46 Chris Dixon? Like Fred Arson has this idea, right? This idea that you would have kind of through token inflation, you would have essentially like, you know, bounties paid out for people that contribute helpful new code to a project.
23:57 Speaker 03 But I think right now, what is kind of interesting to me is that we are seeing all these different ideas being attempted, right? In my mind, in kind of crypto, the idea maze is kind of just accelerated like 100x, right? We're seeing all of these different ideas happen at once. I think the best kind of entrepreneurs are paying attention to what's going on in all of them and seeing what's working, what's not, and taking kind of different pieces. And that was like Ethereum being the best example of that to date, right? Where Vitalik studied the ecosystem very carefully, knew exactly how Bitcoin worked, what worked, what didn't, knew how like the initial proof of stake systems like Peercoin
24:39 Speaker 03 worked, knew what was wrong with them and kind of crafted together a lot of different pieces from like historical context and then built something.
24:46 Chris Dixon? Yeah, I've been involved as an investor in the space, like we invested in Coinbase in 2013 and I've spent all a lot of 2014 and 15, 16 and 17, meeting with crypto companies. I probably see five, what I would call like highly qualified teams a week now, whereas I might've seen five highly qualified teams like in the year of 2014. It's just dramatic, right? To me, it feels like the way the iPhone felt in 2014. 2009 through 11, where just like every smart person who knew how to program and design and do other things said, I'm going to build an iPhone app.
25:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
25:17 Chris Dixon? Right. And of course, 99% of those didn't work, but the ones that did worked spectacularly well. The other interesting thing is now it's transitioned, it's not just these people that have sort of grown up in crypto. At least what I'm seeing is lots of teams leaving GAFA companies, Google, Facebook, et cetera, and getting into this and really good teams. People with with real, you know, strong engineering and product backgrounds. And I think for me, at least, it's the vast majority of it centered around the Ethereum ecosystem. Who knows which of these projects will work, but there's a lot of stuff going on.
25:50 Speaker 03 Yep, yep, agreed.
25:51 Chris Dixon? So what would be your predictions for the craziness to come over the next year or two?
25:56 Speaker 03 I think that we're going to see proof of stake really, you know, a lot of people are still skeptical on proof of stake and don't think it could be pulled off. But I think proof of stake is going to be a really important kind of catalyst for the broader adoption and interest in blockchains.
26:13 Chris Dixon? What specifically makes you think that proof of stake will spur broader interest?
26:17 Speaker 03 I think it solves a number of problems. The one problem that a lot of people point to is kind of the electricity cost, right? So, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars are being spent external to the network of Bitcoin just to secure the network.
26:33 Chris Dixon? This is Bitcoin mining, which, you know, you see all these articles about it. It's now passed, I think it's like the country of Ecuador or something, in electricity usage, which is, which, you know, is excessive.
26:42 Speaker 03 Yep.
26:43 Chris Dixon? That's just too much.
26:44 Speaker 03 But more broadly than that, I think mining miners controlling a network has proven to be pretty problematic. And so I think kind of aligning stakeholders and miners and putting them, you know, as one will be important in terms of, you know, progress in making changes to protocols and just kind of.
27:08 Speaker 03 Making blockchains more cohesive, if you will.
27:10 Chris Dixon? It also, from a technical point of view, I think allows for a lot more wider space of design of blockchain consensus mechanism designs that allow for scaling and other kinds of things, right? Things like Definity, you can't do, as far as I understand it, without proof of state.
27:24 Speaker 03 That's right.
27:25 Chris Dixon? And that has like all these nice features, like a couple second transaction finality time, which is a much shorter time than on existing popular blockchains. So your job is to invest in new protocols. What are some of the characteristics you look for for differentiating between attractive investment opportunities and unattractive ones?
27:43 Speaker 03 So I have four characteristics that I evaluate every project based on. The first is team, the second is product, the third is community, and the fourth is token mechanics. So for me, someone with kind of deep historical context on crypto is important. Someone that has, you know, deep technical understanding of consensus mechanisms and crypto economics and things like that is very important.
28:09 Chris Dixon? So let me push back on that a little bit. One thing I'm seeing is because the kind of movement is growing, by definition, you have new people entering who don't have the same history in it, but do have, in some cases, very strong technical backgrounds in relevant fields like distributed systems and cryptography. One thing I debate is that if someone is very strong in those areas, but maybe hasn't, like you and I have, like, kind of lived through all the different events of the last four years. I mean, if you look at the internet as an analogy, like, a lot of the early teams that were working on it were kind of like hardcore internet believers, but then eventually, like, this sort of different, this new vintage kind of came in that was sort of more classic computer science and built a lot of the important things.
28:50 Speaker 03 Yep. No, it's a good point. I struggle with this. I think I'm just personally more biased towards kind of the deep crypto person as opposed to the new kind of entrant. I think there will be a time in the ecosystem when the new entrant builds some really important stuff. I think my view is that we're still in the infrastructure middleware buildout, and so I think it's more likely that the deep kind of crypto person.
29:15 Chris Dixon? Okay, fair enough. What about, and then so second was product?
29:18 Speaker 03 So how I think about product is like, I'm a native crypto person myself. Like, I was one of the early users of Coinbase, that's how I got involved, and I spend a lot of time in reddits and slacks and different forums, just paying attention to new products being developed. One takeaway from Coinbase, I would say, is that you need a great team, but you also need fantastic product timing, right? There's a lot of great teams and you really need both. And so I spend time thinking about like, what are the right products right now?
29:48 Chris Dixon? Specifically, my experience with investing is the risk is often being too early, as opposed to too late. Like, you know, when you're deeply into a field, like, it's sometimes easy to go and kind of try to jump ahead of where the reality is right now. And then third is community.
30:03 Speaker 03 In almost all cases, having a strong community is important to being successful. And so I take Ethereum as the best example, where Ethereum has great technology, but even more so, I would say Vitalik has done an incredible job kind of building a really healthy, vibrant developer community in kind of leading in a way that's inclusive and open and things like that.
30:27 Chris Dixon? I'd also say it's very technology focused. So if you just look at like our Ethereum versus some of the other coins, it's focused on the technology and the applications, not on just the price.
30:37 Speaker 03 And they made a concerted effort early to do that.
30:40 Chris Dixon? In fact, they push price discussions over to ETH Trader.
30:44 Speaker 03 ETH Trader, exactly.
30:45 Chris Dixon? Which is a very interesting way. And the community could be, what? It could be GitHub, Twitter, Slack, groups, Reddit.
30:52 Speaker 03 Yep.
30:53 Chris Dixon? They tend to be on sort of multiple networks.
30:55 Speaker 03 Yep. I often look even like at a founder's Reddit activity. So is this a founder that's kind of been deep in the community? And is very engaged and things like that?
31:06 Chris Dixon? And then the fourth is token mechanics.
31:08 Speaker 03 Yep. Does the token make sense? And do you have conviction that, you know, it's a token that could have long-term value? So that's one piece of it. And then the second is, and I think maybe this is a little bit of a different perspective than some, but I actually think kind of the way that the token is priced and launched initially is pretty important to the long-term success of the project. So in token mechanics, it's one, do you think this token could have long-term value? And two, is it being launched in a way that is perceived fair? And that can attract a lot of people from all over the world over time?
31:42 Chris Dixon? And so the mistakes people make are sort of unfair, you know, investors granted deep discounts. I've been hearing a lot more talk about things like airdrops or other kinds of... Token sale mechanics that ensure broader distribution.
31:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
31:57 Chris Dixon? I feel like there's more and more thinking around that.
31:59 Speaker 03 Yep, and I hope that continues, right? Like for airdrops, I think oh, me say go is a good example of, you know, they gave everyone that owns Ether some ratio of their own token. I'm hopeful that more teams will be thinking about when they create a token, not optimizing for like the short-term cash grab, but more optimizing for product usage. And so thinking about how to create a token distribution where users do an action and get tokens.
32:26 Chris Dixon? There's been so much attention on ICOs that, by the way, you don't need an ICO. Bitcoin never had an ICO. Ethereum had a very, relatively speaking, small one, 18 million.
32:34 Speaker 03 Yep.
32:34 Chris Dixon? And I don't think that was a key part of the network's success. It's really kind of a secondary part of this. It's really about building networks and communities.
32:41 Speaker 03 Exactly, yep. And I actually think if you focus too much on the ICO or the, you know, the token sale, it can actually really hurt your community. And I think we've already seen that in a few cases.
32:52 Chris Dixon? One thing I'm surprised is on your list is governance. Do you think about that?
32:55 Speaker 03 My view is that in the early days of like a project, governance is less important. So I think governance, once a project reaches a certain scale, is very important, but I don't view like traditional startup governance as that broken. Something like Ethereum, which from a decision-making perspective is pretty centralized right now. That's actually been a good thing for Ethereum, and it's allowed them to move fast and break things, right? Once it gets to a certain level, I think, you know, they'll recognize that shifting governance is important. But I think it's really hard to have like a really decentralized or empowering governance structure early on and really build something.
33:35 Chris Dixon? There's some basic things like vesting as an example, like a bunch of projects had no vesting for the key team members. And I think that then those people took their tokens and left, which in startup world, like vesting is just a fundamental concept.
33:48 Speaker 03 Okay, so you're talking less about governance from a decision-making perspective from the protocol, but more how the team that's building is governed.
33:57 Chris Dixon? Yes, well, I think all of the above. Like, it can be on-chain or off-chain governance, right? So you can imagine both, and people have experimented with both. But there can be governance in the sense of like, how do you control the protocol? How do you upgrade the protocol? Do that on-chain or off-chain, right? And if, to the sense it's off-chain, like, that means the human layer. And those organizations, how are they formed? Are they for-profits? Are they nonprofits? Do they, you know, do they have vesting? There's this whole thing, right?
34:19 Speaker 03 Yep.
34:20 Chris Dixon? Like, is it run well?
34:22 Speaker 03 Yeah. Certainly important. And on the governance of the teams, I think there's certainly been a kind of learning curve this year. And at the beginning of the year, I think there was a lot of abuse of ICOs and, you know, founding teams getting liquidity right upon funding and things like that. And I think from that perspective, there's been kind of big changes already, and I think there will continue to be.
34:48 Chris Dixon? Great.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated October 9, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated