Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast: How Technology Is Changing Investing About this episode As people begin to gain access to information that was previously left to only trained specialists, a new set of asset classes are being created -- and they are changing the way we think about everything from banking to customizing portfolios and mor...
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 The content here is for informational purposes only, should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any A16Z fund. For more details, please see A16Z.com/disclosures.
0:19 Hanne Tidnam? Hi, and welcome to the A16Z Podcast. As the average consumer gets access to more and more information that used to be reserved for trained specialists, we're starting to see new asset classes form that are changing the way that we think about banking and investing. In this episode, Chief Strategy Officer and co-founder of Open Invest, Josh Levin, CEO of Quantopian, John Fawcett, and A16Z's Angela Strange, talk about interesting new models for both retail and institutional investors, and what impact they might have. This conversation was recorded at our summit event in November 2017.
0:52 Speaker 02 Josh, a lot of your team comes from Bridgewater, which is now, you know, one of the better-known hedge funds, especially after Ray Dalio's book has come out. Why would someone come to Open Invest for a trading strategy that doesn't exist somewhere else?
1:05 Speaker 03 Sure. So, I spent the last decade in the impact investing and sustainable finance space, dealing with a lot of the world's largest institutions, banks, and investors. And I was constantly getting pummeled by individuals and small and mid-sized institutions, asking how to do this stuff. How can we get involved? How can we do values-based investing? And there's basically no solution for them. I think the three big mega-trends in wealth management you should know about is a move towards passive investing, a move towards interest and socially conscious investing, and then just better digital tools, awesome digital interface. And we realized that we could take their skillset and point it towards, instead of beating the market, point it towards passive investing, towards buying and holding the
1:48 Speaker 03 market, but actually point the customization towards people's values.
1:52 Speaker 02 I come onto your site and I say, "I want to invest in," or "I don't want to invest in weapons companies." How does that work? You start with an index with tons of different stocks.
2:01 Speaker 03 You start with an index, you start with the universe. And we don't just pull out the four weapons companies that would be in the index. That would be stock picking, that would be active management. Our system will instantly break apart the entire portfolio and tweak the other holdings that are correlated with those four weapons companies on all the important vectors to match the characteristics of the index. So that the client is restored to a beta of one or to broadly tracking that index, but they no longer hold weapons companies. And so this has allowed it to become much more cost efficient and much more customized for clients of all sizes to implement their values in their portfolios.
2:38 Speaker 02 So you guys support eight causes now? Eight stocks?
2:41 Speaker 03 I think we have about a dozen.
2:42 Speaker 02 A dozen, yeah.
2:43 Speaker 03 Working with institutions, we obviously do a lot more customization around their concerns.
2:47 Speaker 02 How do you see that expanding? Like, how many causes do you think you could or would want to support? What's the new process for adding more causes onto the platform?
2:56 Speaker 03 I mean, there's no limit there. For us, we're moving into a world, obviously, with greater and greater transparency, more and more data. The key is to curate and have amazing designs so that you can put the decisions of people's fingertips that they really want at the moments that they want it. And that's how we can empower the actual end owners of capital to have more transparency and more say in what's happening with their money. And that's our goal.
3:18 Speaker 02 Foss, I love your tagline, which is leveling the playing field on Wall Street. What do you mean by that?
3:24 Speaker 04 There's just a huge imbalance between the amount of data that could be used in investing and just the number of people that are trained and equipped with the right tools to do it. We have a platform that we give away for free, sort of the opposite of every other quant hedge fund in the world, and that's a magnet for talent. So we attract people from all over the world who want to learn about the field and try their hand at creating strategies that produce superior returns.
3:48 Speaker 02 How do you find these quants? Where do they live?
3:51 Speaker 04 The saying around Quant Open is, you know, you get what you ask for with the internet. About half of our new traffic land on discussions about things like Markov chain models or common filters in trading or different research topics that people are trying out or papers they're trying to reproduce on the platform. And so the content and the community and just the continuing discussion and frankly, it's an incredible, incredible challenge to try to produce a good strategy. That's the magnet that draws people in.
4:20 Speaker 02 It's the basis of all marketplaces. If you think of something like Airbnb, what does their platform actually do? It not only matches people with rooms with people who want to rent, but there's also a ratings component, scheduling component. What are some of the things on your platform that quants really need?
4:36 Speaker 04 There's a couple of things you just absolutely have to have if you're going to be doing quantitative investing. And the first is you need market data. So you need the basics of the data ecosystem. You need corporate fundamentals in order to build up a universe. And then you need data from which you can draw a signal. So we have a platform that has a consolidated data plan. Quantitative investing, you're running a lot of historical simulations. When you run the simulation, you want to have as traded data on the simulation day. So that's key. And then there's a workflow. And one of the things that we get to do that's really fun is we can observe the behavior of the quants that are on the platform. And then we get to see how their stuff performs out of sample.
5:18 Speaker 04 We've noticed that the people who have good outcomes out of sample when we're testing after they've created an algo spend about 100 times the amount of time on the research step. And then we have a second piece, which is actually about making the algo that's going to do the trading. And so some people will spend all their time in the algo, editing it and tweaking it and backtesting over and over again. And kind of intuitively, they end up with something that's very overfit.
5:43 Speaker 02 Yep.
5:43 Speaker 04 Whereas the people that spend all their time in research, they come up with a bunch of ideas that they eliminate for different reasons in the research step. And they do far less, relatively speaking, backtesting, and they tend to have greater success. So I find it somewhat reassuring because that is the creativity step, right? That's the step that really is still very, very dependent on human creativity. And that's the thing that ultimately prevails.
6:08 Speaker 02 How do you judge if these quants are any good, right? I imagine there's a wide spectrum of people that come on from beginners.
6:13 Speaker 04 There is. Yep, there's everything. One key thing, I mentioned overfitting, that is a huge trap. There's a lot of statistical traps for these types of strategies. So, you know, first step is to try to eliminate that as much as possible. So when someone comes to Quantopin, they actually are creating their strategy in the browser on our system. And so we're building this big database of strategies. So it's in a database and it's marked with the date. And that one piece of information is incredibly important because it makes a bright line between the data that's in sample that the author could have known about when they were working and then everything that happened afterwards. And so then you can do comparisons statistically between the out of sample and the in sample and you can eliminate many
6:58 Speaker 04 overfit strategies. So that's key to the evaluation. And then downstream from that, there's like 50 features now from each strategy and starting to do tests on the predictive efficacy of each of those features and building up our own sort of meta algo for the evaluation. We can run from the database of algos all the way through to here's a recommended portfolio. And we can run a historical simulation of that portfolio of algorithms. And that's really important because we can pick up the entire investment process and apply the same rigor where we can do in and out of sample testing on our process. And that's really key for making investment into a software business where we're doing incremental improvements on this piece of software that is our investment process.
7:40 Speaker 02 You're also tracking the behavioral data of where
7:41 Speaker 04 That's of his fascinating.
7:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, so let's jump into shareholder activism, which you often think of, you know, the large investors acquiring 10% of a company and investing management. But I think what we mean in this concept is just are people voting on the votes that they would have a chance to. So like 90%, the stats just came out, 90% of institutional investors are very involved in proxy votes, whereas the number for retail is something very low. So what do you hope is the engagement that comes out of retail?
8:12 Speaker 03 So I don't know if you own individual shares in companies, but if you do, you get this giant paper packet in the mail and nobody reads. I mean, you need like a law degree and a free weekend. And actually disrupting that paper packet was one of the initial conversations that led to this whole company. It's a nightmare on the backend, but we just released the ability for clients to vote in shareholder resolutions with a swipe on their smartphone, like Tinder. And part of it's curation, so you just see the votes you'd care about. Oh, Procter and Gamble is having a vote on LGBTQ rights in the workplace, which just happened. You get the two cent summary, a link to learn more, swipe your vote, share with others, move on to the next vote.
8:53 Speaker 03 Even just taking the individual shareholders, directly and indirectly, own nearly 80% of US equities markets. We have collective control of a lot of these companies. And no one's using their legal rights because it's been obfuscated. But we've been cutting through all of that as part of this broader mission to create a toolkit that shifts some of the power from this massive chain of intermediaries in the value chain more towards the end owners of capital, which is individuals, families and institutions.
9:20 Speaker 02 And so what's an example of a very important vote that came up recently?
9:24 Speaker 03 They're happening all the time.
9:25 Speaker 02 Could have been a good impact because you could make the argument like, ah, who really cares? Like, it's a diffuse number of individuals. It's not going to have like a really significant impact.
9:33 Speaker 03 The spring is the big season.
9:34 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
9:35 Speaker 03 And there was actually a seminal vote last spring with Exxon on climate change, where 62, 63% of the votes were in favor of Exxon reporting on the risks of their business from a regulated two-degree world, which was a big deal. We just had a vote on Oracle and whether they should report on the gender pay gap in their company and what they're going to do about it. These things are going on all the time and people know these brand names and they care about the issues. It's just that no one's given them the ability.
10:03 Speaker 02 One of the big debates going on in the investor world right now is the whole trend from active to passive. And lots of numbers around there, but I guess about a decade ago, there were a fifth of assets under management which were passive. Now it's up to a third. Is this a good thing for investors? Do you see this continuing?
10:20 Speaker 04 I see it from two angles. One angle is actually, you know, indexing is great when the markets are all going up. So then if we have like a 25% correction, what are all these index holders going to do? And so I think that's a real and important risk. And just in sort of my gut, like everyone doing the same thing. When has that ever been a good outcome for markets? Right? So I think it's legitimate to have some concerns. There's a lot of talk about like the change of the market structure and what will happen if everyone's indexing at the same time. The other angle that I take on it is this is automation. You know, this is, this is applying data and, and software to building, you know,
11:02 Speaker 04 portfolios at a mass scale for, for both retail and institutional investors. It's lowering costs. I mean, it's, it's, it's really, really incredible how low the cost is to be exposed to, to indices via, via these instruments. So, you know, I think there is just inherent good from lowering the cost, particularly for retail investors. And so I think, I think that there's an equilibrium somewhere that we have to reach where it's probably higher than it has been historically, but it's not, it's not a hundred percent. And I think for institutional investors, there's a real need for actively managed portfolios because they have different needs, right? So they're not just trying to appreciate their assets. They have to be defensively postured. They have to be prepared for their obligations year to year.
11:46 Speaker 04 And so there's, there's always going to be a need for, for active management. It's interesting to see like where we're going to settle out in terms of the mechs.
11:54 Speaker 02 I think there's a trend, especially among millennials, but even broader, of just being more globally conscious, more cause oriented. Like, how do you see open invest progressing? Like, do you, do you foresee like more and more investors are going to care about what they're really investing in? And that's going to be like a big attraction away from passive investing? Cause you're sort of this mix between you're active because you really care about the causes, but it's passive because it somewhat creates a new index.
12:19 Speaker 03 So if we have a paradigm of mutual funds, then the next revolution was ETFs and index investing. And then there's a third paradigm coming, which is there's a post-fund future coming. Right? Why are we all in these cookie cutter vehicles? Why is the banking system built on slogging them? Because you're pooling against certain costs, namely transaction costs. What happens as transaction costs go to almost zero? Well, instead of buying a fund, you're just going to be renting a strategy from the cloud, which will be buying and selling securities and optimizing for your goals, financial values and otherwise. This is coming and we're at the forefront of it. And our belief is that the banks are not going to lead it. And if you talk to strategy groups at the banks,
13:04 Speaker 03 they know it, they see it. But half their staff is based on slogging funds and maintaining that entire ecosystem. And you have a population that doesn't have the financial literacy to necessarily demand it, even though there's advantages. So I think what's going to drive uptake towards the third paradigm is the values-based conversation. Eighty-five percent of millennials, one investment company is aligned with their values. Right? It's not going away. And when you really open that Pandora's box with your stakeholders or with your family, everyone has different values. Then next week, you watch a documentary on private prisons. You don't want that. It's changing all the time. So you need an entirely new type of infrastructure to actually accommodate this. That's what we're driving forward.
13:47 Speaker 04 So in your user base, is there a big distribution in terms of the values? Or are people like kind of tightly clustered around similar values? Like everybody on the platform doesn't like gun companies? Or you know, what's the distribution look like?
14:00 Speaker 03 So with retail investors, there's a lot of clustering around climate change. It's no more an issue. It's not just millennials, by the way. Our second biggest segment is 55 to 65-year-olds. And they're more focused on military and tobacco. And younger people have different issues. So for example, we're currently onboarding an entire pension fund. And the pensioners themselves are going to be voting in real time on environmental and social, political issues on their smartphones. And we'll just be managing and rebalancing the entire fund and netting off the trades. And it's passive for everyone. But this is the type of power you start to be able to put at the fingertips of actual asset owners when you have this hybrid model where you can have active management with a passive holding. Now, let the software abstract away the financial complexity.
14:45 Speaker 03 These guys, they don't know about finances. They, most people shouldn't be stock picking. Your guys should, but most people don't. Let the software abstract that away, but let people weigh in on the things they know and that they care about. And then you're also just going to strengthen your client relationships.
14:58 Speaker 02 Plus, I want to end on a similar type of question for you. And you touched on this a little bit. If you're going to do funds across different asset classes. But fast forward 10 years, what does Quantopian look like in terms of scale of quants?
15:12 Speaker 02 Paint the future vision of this.
15:14 Speaker 04 Well, I think if we manage our business properly and we diversify these funds, there's an incredible number of people around the world who are being trained in different analytical and modeling fields that just aren't getting into the market.
15:28 Speaker 02 Which is creating jobs in finance, contrary to a lot of the headlines.
15:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's just a different kind of job, right? It's a much more, in my opinion, like creative job. And the thing that we want to accomplish over the next 10 years is if you think about the explosion in data from the real economy, we want to have total coverage. We want every single data set that exists to have several humans look at it, try to extract signal from it, try to drive meaning from it, and then apply that into many, many different investment vehicles. There's just an enormous arbitrage free for the taking, and it really has to do with coordinating enough people to do the creative work. And I think the machine can really, really add at the beginning and the end of the process. So cleaning the day and tagging the data, getting it to our community to do the creative
16:16 Speaker 04 part of turning it into signals, and then taking those signals and combining them. Those are the right jobs for full automation. And hopefully, you know, we'll have a massive amount of assets to deploy into these vehicles.
16:27 Speaker 02 I think this is just the start of new models that we're going to start to see in this space. So I'd like to, if everyone can join me, in thanking Fosse and Josh.
16:34 Speaker 04 Thank you.
Previous a16z Podcast: Data, Insight, and the Customer Experience Next a16z Podcast: The State of Security Page updated September 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated